{ "random_baseline": 0.1789, "n_questions": 14850, "subjects": [ "biology", "english", "geography", "history_of_kazakhstan", "human_society_rights", "kazakh_and_literature", "world_history" ], "models": { "KazBERT": { "model_id": "Eraly-ml/KazBERT", "pll_overall": 0.2228, "pll_by_subject": { "biology": 0.2246, "english": 0.198, "geography": 0.2293, "history_of_kazakhstan": 0.2267, "human_society_rights": 0.2511, "kazakh_and_literature": 0.2267, "world_history": 0.2248 }, "emb_overall": 0.2126, "emb_by_subject": { "biology": 0.2122, "english": 0.1793, "geography": 0.2119, "history_of_kazakhstan": 0.2101, "human_society_rights": 0.3094, "kazakh_and_literature": 0.2223, "world_history": 0.2256 }, "vocab_size": 32000, "seconds": 801.8 }, "mBERT": { "model_id": "google-bert/bert-base-multilingual-cased", "pll_overall": 0.2205, "pll_by_subject": { "biology": 0.2318, "english": 0.2663, "geography": 0.209, "history_of_kazakhstan": 0.2064, "human_society_rights": 0.2601, "kazakh_and_literature": 0.2063, "world_history": 0.2248 }, "vocab_size": 119547, "emb_overall": 0.2332, "emb_by_subject": { "biology": 0.222, "english": 0.2112, "geography": 0.2392, "history_of_kazakhstan": 0.2264, "human_society_rights": 0.296, "kazakh_and_literature": 0.2436, "world_history": 0.2451 }, "seconds": 2631.3 }, "XLM-R base": { "model_id": "FacebookAI/xlm-roberta-base", "pll_overall": 0.2188, "pll_by_subject": { "biology": 0.2161, "english": 0.2599, "geography": 0.2084, "history_of_kazakhstan": 0.1856, "human_society_rights": 0.2511, "kazakh_and_literature": 0.2248, "world_history": 0.2223 }, "vocab_size": 250002, "emb_overall": 0.2087, "emb_by_subject": { "biology": 0.224, "english": 0.203, "geography": 0.2078, "history_of_kazakhstan": 0.1663, "human_society_rights": 0.1883, "kazakh_and_literature": 0.2317, "world_history": 0.2296 }, "seconds": 2867.7 }, "kaz-roberta": { "model_id": "kz-transformers/kaz-roberta-conversational", "pll_overall": 0.2273, "pll_by_subject": { "biology": 0.1927, "english": 0.2117, "geography": 0.2276, "history_of_kazakhstan": 0.2433, "human_society_rights": 0.2915, "kazakh_and_literature": 0.2321, "world_history": 0.2264 }, "emb_overall": 0.2424, "emb_by_subject": { "biology": 0.2057, "english": 0.208, "geography": 0.2544, "history_of_kazakhstan": 0.2696, "human_society_rights": 0.3229, "kazakh_and_literature": 0.2457, "world_history": 0.2337 }, "vocab_size": 52000, "seconds": 680.2 }, "KazakhBERTmulti": { "model_id": "amandyk/KazakhBERTmulti", "pll_overall": 0.207, "pll_by_subject": { "biology": 0.1882, "english": 0.2212, "geography": 0.2165, "history_of_kazakhstan": 0.1758, "human_society_rights": 0.1928, "kazakh_and_literature": 0.2255, "world_history": 0.2068 }, "emb_overall": 0.2247, "emb_by_subject": { "biology": 0.2057, "english": 0.2076, "geography": 0.2357, "history_of_kazakhstan": 0.2215, "human_society_rights": 0.3453, "kazakh_and_literature": 0.2321, "world_history": 0.2223 }, "vocab_size": 100000, "seconds": 1173.4 } } }