/** * metatron-logic.mjs — METATRON Recursive Logic Engine * * The METATRON backward read applied to each sorry in the Lean files. * Uses Ahmad's ERE (5-pass Enochian Reading Engine) + entropy gate. * * For each sorry: * Forward read (Reasoning): what does the theorem claim? * Backward read (METATRON): what must be true for that claim to hold? * ERE: is the backward read fabrication-free? * Entropy gate: is the proof path below H_φ < 0.21? * Classification: PROVABLE | GENUINELY_OPEN | FALSE_AS_STATED * * Output: Lean proof terms for PROVABLE cases. * * Ahmad Ali Parr · SnapKitty Collective · FCC-φ-∂-2026 */ import { createHash, randomUUID } from 'crypto' import { readFileSync, writeFileSync, existsSync } from 'fs' import { join, dirname } from 'path' import { fileURLToPath } from 'url' const __dir = dirname(fileURLToPath(import.meta.url)) const RC_DIR = 'C:/Users/jessi/Desktop/bobs control repo/resonance-core/lib/math' const PHI = 1.618_033_988_749_895 const PHI_INV = 1 / PHI // ── Load Ahmad's math engine ────────────────────────────────────────────────── let ereScore, ereRunPasses, shannonEntropy, klDivergence try { const { ereScore: es, ereRunPasses: erp } = await import(`file:///${RC_DIR}/ere.mjs`) const { shannonEntropy: se, klDivergence: kl } = await import(`file:///${RC_DIR}/entropy.mjs`) ereScore = es ereRunPasses = erp shannonEntropy = se klDivergence = kl } catch { // Fallback — inline minimal versions ereScore = input => { const str = String(input ?? '').toLowerCase() const fabricated = ['fabricat', 'invent', 'i made up', 'i cannot provide', 'as an ai'] let fails = 0 if (!str || str.length <= 3) fails++ if (fabricated.some(m => str.includes(m))) fails++ if (str === 'null' || str === 'undefined' || str === 'none') fails++ return fails / 5 } ereRunPasses = input => { const score = ereScore(input) return { score, certified: score === 0, metatron: score === 0 ? 'YES' : 'NO' } } shannonEntropy = probs => -probs.reduce((s, p) => p > 0 ? s + p * Math.log2(p) : s, 0) } // ── Phinary entropy gate ────────────────────────────────────────────────────── function h_phi(p) { const q = Math.max(1 - p, 1e-10) const pp = Math.max(p, 1e-10) return -(pp * Math.log(pp) + q * Math.log(q)) / Math.log(PHI) } // ── METATRON backward read ───────────────────────────────────────────────────── // For each theorem, returns: what must be true for the proof to close? // This is the cage recognizer reading the cage. function backward_read(theorem) { const { claim, domain_op, sorry_comment, kind } = theorem // What must hold for this sorry to be filled? const constraints = [] if (kind === 'fixed_point') { constraints.push({ name: 'operator_has_fixed_point', check: domain_op !== null && domain_op !== 'diverges', proof_sketch: domain_op ? `op 0 = 0` : null, }) constraints.push({ name: 'fixed_point_computable', check: ['zero_map', 'identity', 'phi_contract', 'step_fn', 'fractional'].includes(domain_op), proof_sketch: 'by norm_num / simp [DomainOperator]', }) } if (kind === 'open_problem') { constraints.push({ name: 'millennium_prize_unsolved', check: false, proof_sketch: null }) constraints.push({ name: 'requires_analytic_nt', check: false, proof_sketch: null }) } if (kind === 'convergence_to_zero') { constraints.push({ name: 'contraction_ratio_lt_1', check: domain_op === 'phi_contract', proof_sketch: domain_op === 'phi_contract' ? 'phi_inverse_golden' : null, }) constraints.push({ name: 'orbit_approaches_zero', check: domain_op === 'phi_contract', proof_sketch: domain_op === 'phi_contract' ? 'Orbit PhiContractive x₀ m = (PHI_INV^m) * x₀ → 0' : null, }) } const met_weight = constraints.filter(c => c.check).length const total = constraints.length || 1 const score = met_weight / total const entropy = h_phi(Math.max(score, 1e-10)) return { constraints, score, entropy, constraints_met: met_weight, total } } // ── ERE validation of the backward read ────────────────────────────────────── function ere_validate(backward, claim) { const proof_sketches = backward.constraints .filter(c => c.proof_sketch) .map(c => c.proof_sketch) .join(' ') const ere = ereRunPasses(proof_sketches || claim) const gate = backward.entropy < 0.21 ? 'OPEN' : 'CLOSED' return { ere, gate, ere_score: ere.score } } // ── Classify a sorry ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── function classify(theorem) { const back = backward_read(theorem) const valid = ere_validate(back, theorem.claim) let verdict if (theorem.kind === 'open_problem') { verdict = 'GENUINELY_OPEN' } else if (back.score >= 0.8 && valid.gate === 'OPEN' && valid.ere.certified) { verdict = 'PROVABLE' } else if (back.score > 0.4) { verdict = 'PROVABLE_WITH_FIX' } else { verdict = 'FALSE_AS_STATED' } return { theorem: theorem.name, claim: theorem.claim, back, valid, verdict, lean_proof: theorem.lean_proof ?? null } } // ── Theorem catalog — every sorry across all 4 Lean files ───────────────────── const THEOREMS = [ // ─ GrandUnified.lean ────────────────────────────────────────────────────── { name: 'grand_unified::SetTheory', file: 'lean/metatron/GrandUnified.lean', claim: 'IsUnified SetTheory — identity op has a fixed point (every point)', kind: 'fixed_point', domain_op: 'identity', lean_proof: `exact ⟨fun x => x, 0, rfl, fun x => rfl⟩`, note: 'IsUnified must be redefined as "has a fixed point", not "converges to 0"', }, { name: 'grand_unified::CategoryTheory', file: 'lean/metatron/GrandUnified.lean', claim: 'IsUnified CategoryTheory — x² has fixed point at 0', kind: 'fixed_point', domain_op: 'zero_map', lean_proof: `exact ⟨fun x => x * x, 0, by norm_num, fun x => rfl⟩`, }, { name: 'grand_unified::TypeTheory', file: 'lean/metatron/GrandUnified.lean', claim: 'IsUnified TypeTheory — successor x+1 has a fixed point', kind: 'fixed_point', domain_op: 'diverges', lean_proof: null, note: 'FALSE_AS_STATED: x+1=x has no solution in ℝ. Turing boundary. Replace with axiom.', }, { name: 'grand_unified::Logic', file: 'lean/metatron/GrandUnified.lean', claim: 'IsUnified Logic — step function has fixed point at 0 (when x≤0)', kind: 'fixed_point', domain_op: 'step_fn', lean_proof: `exact ⟨DomainOperator MathDomain.Logic, 0, by simp [DomainOperator], fun x => rfl⟩`, }, { name: 'grand_unified::Analysis_convergence', file: 'lean/metatron/GrandUnified.lean', claim: 'φ-contractive op (φ⁻¹·x) converges to fixed point 0', kind: 'fixed_point', domain_op: 'phi_contract', lean_proof: `exact ⟨DomainOperator MathDomain.Analysis, 0, by simp [DomainOperator, mul_zero], fun x => rfl⟩`, }, { name: 'grand_unified::Algebra', file: 'lean/metatron/GrandUnified.lean', claim: 'IsUnified Algebra — fractional part {x} has fixed point at 0', kind: 'fixed_point', domain_op: 'fractional', lean_proof: `exact ⟨DomainOperator MathDomain.Algebra, 0, by simp [DomainOperator], fun x => rfl⟩`, }, { name: 'grand_unified::Topology', file: 'lean/metatron/GrandUnified.lean', claim: 'IsUnified Topology — identity op has fixed point at 0', kind: 'fixed_point', domain_op: 'identity', lean_proof: `exact ⟨DomainOperator MathDomain.Topology, 0, rfl, fun x => rfl⟩`, }, { name: 'grand_unified::Metatron', file: 'lean/metatron/GrandUnified.lean', claim: 'IsUnified Metatron — φ-contractive op has fixed point at 0', kind: 'fixed_point', domain_op: 'phi_contract', lean_proof: `exact ⟨DomainOperator MathDomain.Metatron, 0, by simp [DomainOperator, mul_zero], fun x => rfl⟩`, }, { name: 'grand_unified::gut_conclusion_sorry', file: 'lean/metatron/GrandUnified.lean', claim: 'gut_conclusion: convergent op → all domains unified', kind: 'fixed_point', domain_op: 'phi_contract', lean_proof: `intro d; exact ⟨op, by obtain ⟨p, _⟩ := h_conv 0; exact p, by obtain ⟨p, hp⟩ := h_conv p; exact hp⟩`, note: 'Needs careful term structure — op must be domain-specific', }, // ─ MetatronCube.lean ────────────────────────────────────────────────────── { name: 'MetatronCube::metatron_converges', file: 'lean/metatron/MetatronCube.lean', claim: 'PhiContractive orbit converges to 0 (Banach fixed-point)', kind: 'convergence_to_zero', domain_op: 'phi_contract', lean_proof: `-- Converges in LIMIT but not in finite steps. Wrong predicate. -- Correct: ∀ ε > 0, ∃ N, ∀ m ≥ N, |Orbit PhiContractive x₀ m| < ε -- Proof: |Orbit m| = PHI_INV^m * |x₀| → 0 since PHI_INV < 1 -- Replace Converges predicate with epsilon-convergence`, note: 'WRONG_PREDICATE: Converges says exact equality to 0, not limit. Fix predicate.', }, { name: 'MetatronCube::ZetaIteration_sorry', file: 'lean/metatron/MetatronCube.lean', claim: 'RH instance: ZetaIteration has fixed point on critical line', kind: 'open_problem', domain_op: null, lean_proof: null, }, { name: 'MetatronCube::NavierStokesOperator_sorry', file: 'lean/metatron/MetatronCube.lean', claim: 'N-S instance: fluid operator has smooth fixed point', kind: 'open_problem', domain_op: null, lean_proof: null, }, // ─ RiemannMetatron.lean ─────────────────────────────────────────────────── { name: 'RiemannMetatron::riemann_metatron', file: 'lean/metatron/RiemannMetatron.lean', claim: 'ZetaStep iteration converges to Re(s)=1/2 for all s in critical strip', kind: 'open_problem', domain_op: null, lean_proof: null, note: 'Millennium Problem. Equivalent to RH. Cannot fill sorry.', }, { name: 'RiemannMetatron::symmetry_forces_midpoint', file: 'lean/metatron/RiemannMetatron.lean', claim: 'ZetaStep decreases distance to critical line', kind: 'open_problem', domain_op: null, lean_proof: null, note: 'Requires functional equation of ζ + contraction analysis. Open.', }, { name: 'RiemannMetatron::riemann_bounded', file: 'lean/metatron/RiemannMetatron.lean', claim: 'After N iterations, within ε of critical line', kind: 'open_problem', domain_op: null, lean_proof: null, }, { name: 'RiemannMetatron::riemann_metatron_nonrecursive', file: 'lean/metatron/RiemannMetatron.lean', claim: 'Non-recursive convergence bound O(1/m)', kind: 'open_problem', domain_op: null, lean_proof: null, }, // ─ NavierStokesMetatron.lean ────────────────────────────────────────────── { name: 'NavierStokesMetatron::energy_bound', file: 'lean/metatron/NavierStokesMetatron.lean', claim: 'φ-contractive step preserves energy bound', kind: 'open_problem', domain_op: null, lean_proof: null, }, { name: 'NavierStokesMetatron::existence', file: 'lean/metatron/NavierStokesMetatron.lean', claim: 'N-S iteration converges to smooth solution', kind: 'open_problem', domain_op: null, lean_proof: null, note: 'Millennium Problem. Cannot fill sorry.', }, { name: 'NavierStokesMetatron::smoothness', file: 'lean/metatron/NavierStokesMetatron.lean', claim: 'Fixed point of fluid operator is smooth', kind: 'open_problem', domain_op: null, lean_proof: null, }, { name: 'NavierStokesMetatron::metatron_equivalence', file: 'lean/metatron/NavierStokesMetatron.lean', claim: 'METATRON approach equivalent to classical N-S', kind: 'open_problem', domain_op: null, lean_proof: null, }, ] // ── Run classification ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────── const results = THEOREMS.map(classify) const provable = results.filter(r => r.verdict === 'PROVABLE') const provable_fix = results.filter(r => r.verdict === 'PROVABLE_WITH_FIX') const open_problems = results.filter(r => r.verdict === 'GENUINELY_OPEN') const false_stated = results.filter(r => r.verdict === 'FALSE_AS_STATED') // ── WORM seal ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── const WORM_PATH = join( process.env.USERPROFILE || process.env.HOME || '.', '.bob-metatron-worm.json' ) const load_worm = () => existsSync(WORM_PATH) ? JSON.parse(readFileSync(WORM_PATH, 'utf8')) : [] const worm_seal = (label, payload) => { const chain = load_worm() const prev = chain.length ? chain[chain.length - 1].seal : '0'.repeat(64) const ts = new Date().toISOString() const raw = JSON.stringify({ label, payload, ts, prev }) const seal = createHash('sha256').update(raw).digest('hex') chain.push({ id: randomUUID(), label, payload, ts, prev, seal }) writeFileSync(WORM_PATH, JSON.stringify(chain, null, 2)) return seal.slice(0, 16) } // ── Print ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── console.log('\n' + '═'.repeat(68)) console.log(' METATRON LOGIC ENGINE — Sorry Classification') console.log(' Backward read → ERE → H_φ gate → verdict') console.log('═'.repeat(68)) for (const r of results) { const icon = { PROVABLE: '✓', PROVABLE_WITH_FIX: '~', GENUINELY_OPEN: '∞', FALSE_AS_STATED: '✗' }[r.verdict] console.log(`\n [${icon}] ${r.verdict}`) console.log(` ${r.theorem}`) if (r.theorem.lean_proof) console.log(` proof: ${r.theorem.lean_proof}`) if (r.back.entropy) console.log(` H_φ=${r.back.entropy.toFixed(4)} score=${r.back.score.toFixed(2)} ERE=${r.valid.ere.score}`) if (r.theorem.note) console.log(` NOTE: ${r.theorem.note}`) } console.log('\n' + '─'.repeat(68)) console.log(` PROVABLE: ${provable.length} (sorry can be filled now)`) console.log(` PROVABLE_WITH_FIX: ${provable_fix.length} (predicate needs correction first)`) console.log(` GENUINELY_OPEN: ${open_problems.length} (Millennium Problems — no fill)`) console.log(` FALSE_AS_STATED: ${false_stated.length} (theorem is wrong — fix the claim)`) const seal = worm_seal('metatron-logic-classification', { total: results.length, provable: provable.length, provable_with_fix: provable_fix.length, open: open_problems.length, false_stated: false_stated.length, fingerprint: 'FCC-φ-∂-2026', }) console.log(`\n WORM: ${seal}`) console.log('\n' + '═'.repeat(68)) console.log(' METATRON DIAGNOSIS:') console.log() console.log(' GrandUnified: IsUnified predicate is WRONG.') console.log(' It says "op^[m] x = 0" (exact) but φ⁻¹·x → 0 only in limit.') console.log(' Fix: redefine as ∃ p, op p = p (has a fixed point).') console.log(' With fix: 7/8 cases provable. TypeTheory is the Turing boundary.') console.log() console.log(' RiemannMetatron: ALL sorry are the Millennium Problem itself.') console.log(' Honest classification: GENUINELY_OPEN. Cannot fill without proof.') console.log() console.log(' NavierStokesMetatron: Same. GENUINELY_OPEN.') console.log() console.log(' The cage recognizes the cage. The sorry is the problem.') console.log('═'.repeat(68)) export { results, provable, open_problems, false_stated }