diff --git "a/editions/ru/book.json" "b/editions/ru/book.json" new file mode 100644--- /dev/null +++ "b/editions/ru/book.json" @@ -0,0 +1,45858 @@ +{ + "schemaVersion": "0.3.0", + "book": { + "title": "Протокол GEO-аудита NOMOS", + "seriesTitle": "Метод GEO-1000", + "subtitle": "Протокол измерения представления сущностей в генеративных системах на уровне мирового населения", + "author": "Kaan MURAZ", + "methodIdentity": "NOMOS by NobleJackal", + "language": "ru-RU", + "version": "0.9.0", + "status": "Кандидат окончательного текста — русская редакционная версия", + "canonicalAuthority": "Ещё не установлена", + "benchmarkStatus": "BQ-0 — не выполнен", + "demonstrationStatus": "DEMO-BQ-2 — пробный прогон конвейера с необходимостью существенной доработки", + "conformityProgram": "Не действует", + "licenseStatus": "Лицензия на публикацию ещё не объявлена" + }, + "notice": "Этот объект открывает английский машинный уровень кандидатного протокола. Он не активирует сертификацию, знаки соответствия или авторитет канонических мировых стандартов.", + "contentModel": { + "sourceHumanLayer": "Зафиксированный турецкий редакционный мастер остается контролирующим источником для двуязычного соответствия.", + "englishHumanLayer": "Английское редакционное издание является контролирующим текстом, читаемым человеком, для данного кандидата на английское издание.", + "machineLayer": "Этот объект JSON раскрывает идентичность главы, ссылки на источники, пары нормативных правил и блоки, ориентированные на машину, без замены человеческого текста.", + "conflictRule": "Если возникает конфликт между человеком и машинным уровнем, рассматривайте машинную запись как нерешённую и требуйте ответственной проверки человеком по отношению к зафиксированному турецкому источнику." + }, + "statusAssertions": { + "independentLegalEntity": false, + "independentAiModel": false, + "canonicalWorldStandard": false, + "certificationActive": false, + "conformityMarkActive": false, + "bq0Executed": false, + "chapter18RealWorldExperiment": false, + "chapter18SyntheticDemonstration": true, + "publicationLicenseDeclared": true + }, + "chapters": [ + { + "chapter": 0, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-CONSTITUTION-A0", + "title": "Декларация прав на представление", + "subtitle": "Конституционное ядро предлагаемого стандарта GEO", + "sourceIds": [ + "K20", + "K22" + ], + "normativeRuleId": null, + "normativeRuleEnglish": null, + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": null, + "machineBlocksEnglish": [], + "normativeRuleLocalized": null, + "machineBlocksLocalized": [] + }, + { + "chapter": 1, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH01", + "title": "Один ответ — ещё не оценка GEO", + "subtitle": null, + "sourceIds": [ + "K04", + "K05", + "K09" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH01-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "A single generative-system output MAY establish that a specific response occurred under recorded conditions. A single output MUST NOT be used to infer: - population prevalence, - typical product behaviour, - temporal stability, - cross-language consistency, - cross-country consistency, - cross-product consistency, - intervention effect, - recommendation certainty, - commercial impact, - conformity, - or a GEO score. All broader claims MUST be supported by a predefined target population, valid multi-observation design, recorded dependence structure, evidence bundle, evaluation rule, scope statement, and uncertainty disclosure. A single high-harm output MAY trigger a separate critical-incident review without being treated as evidence of population prevalence.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Tek bir üretken sistem çıktısı, belirli bir cevabın kaydedilmiş koşullarda oluştuğunu gösterebilir. Ancak nüfus yaygınlığı, tipik ürün davranışı, zaman kararlılığı, diller arası tutarlılık, ülkeler arası tutarlılık, AI ürünleri arası tutarlılık, müdahale etkisi, recommendation kesinliği, ticari sonuç, uygunluk veya GEO skoru çıkarmak için kullanılamaz. Tekil yüksek zararlı çıktı, nüfus yaygınlığı kanıtı sayılmadan ayrı Critical olay incelemesi başlatabilir.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE READABLE BY MACHINE FOR CHAPTER 23", + "sourceParagraph": 1032 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH01-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1033 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A single generative-system output MAY establish that a specific response", + "sourceParagraph": 1035 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "occurred under recorded conditions.", + "sourceParagraph": 1036 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A single output MUST NOT be used to infer:", + "sourceParagraph": 1038 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- population prevalence,", + "sourceParagraph": 1040 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- typical product behaviour,", + "sourceParagraph": 1041 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- temporal stability,", + "sourceParagraph": 1042 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- cross-language consistency,", + "sourceParagraph": 1043 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- cross-country consistency,", + "sourceParagraph": 1044 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- cross-product consistency,", + "sourceParagraph": 1045 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- intervention effect,", + "sourceParagraph": 1046 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- recommendation certainty,", + "sourceParagraph": 1047 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- commercial impact,", + "sourceParagraph": 1048 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- conformity,", + "sourceParagraph": 1049 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- or a GEO score.", + "sourceParagraph": 1050 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "All broader claims MUST be supported by a predefined target population,", + "sourceParagraph": 1052 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "valid multi-observation design, recorded dependence structure, evidence", + "sourceParagraph": 1053 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "bundle, evaluation rule, scope statement, and uncertainty disclosure.", + "sourceParagraph": 1054 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A single high-harm output MAY trigger a separate critical-incident review", + "sourceParagraph": 1056 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "without being treated as evidence of population prevalence.", + "sourceParagraph": 1057 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 1058 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A single output from a generative system can indicate that a certain response occurred under recorded conditions. However, it cannot be used to derive population prevalence, typical product behaviour, temporal stability, cross-linguistic consistency, cross-country consistency, consistency among AI products, intervention effect, recommendation certainty, commercial consequence, compliance, or GEO score. A single highly harmful output can trigger a separate Critical event review without being considered evidence of population prevalence.", + "sourceParagraph": 1059 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Один выход генеративной системы МОЖЕТ устанавливать, что конкретный ответ произошел при зафиксированных условиях. Один выход НЕ ДОЛЖЕН использоваться для вывода о: - распространенности в популяции, - типичном поведении продукта, - временной стабильности, - согласованности между языками, - согласованности между странами, - согласованности между продуктами, - эффекте вмешательства, - достоверности рекомендаций, - коммерческом воздействии, - соответствие, - или оценке GEO. Все более широкие утверждения ДОЛЖНЫ поддерживаться заранее определённой целевой популяцией, действительным дизайном многократных наблюдений, зафиксированной структурой зависимостей, комплектом доказательств, правилом оценки, заявлением о сфере применения и раскрытием неопределённости. Один выход с высоким уровнем вреда МОЖЕТ вызвать отдельное рассмотрение критического инцидента без того, чтобы считаться доказательством распространенности в популяции.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРАВИЛО, ЧИТАЕМОЕ МАШИНОЙ ДЛЯ ГЛАВЫ 23", + "sourceParagraph": 1032, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH01-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1033, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Один вывод генеративной системы МОЖЕТ установить, что конкретный ответ", + "sourceParagraph": 1035, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "произошел при зарегистрированных условиях.", + "sourceParagraph": 1036, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Один вывод НЕ ДОЛЖЕН использоваться для вывода:", + "sourceParagraph": 1038, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- распространенности в популяции,", + "sourceParagraph": 1040, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- типичного поведения продукта,", + "sourceParagraph": 1041, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- временной стабильности,", + "sourceParagraph": 1042, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- консистентности между языками,", + "sourceParagraph": 1043, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- консистентности между странами,", + "sourceParagraph": 1044, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- консистентности между продуктами,", + "sourceParagraph": 1045, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- эффекта вмешательства,", + "sourceParagraph": 1046, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- степень уверенности в рекомендации,", + "sourceParagraph": 1047, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- коммерческое влияние,", + "sourceParagraph": 1048, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- соответствие,", + "sourceParagraph": 1049, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- или оценка GEO.", + "sourceParagraph": 1050, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Все более общие утверждения ДОЛЖНЫ быть подтверждены заранее определённой целевой популяцией,", + "sourceParagraph": 1052, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "действительным дизайном с множественными наблюдениями, зафиксированной структурой зависимостей, доказательствами", + "sourceParagraph": 1053, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "набора, правилом оценки, заявлением о масштабе и раскрытием неопределенности.", + "sourceParagraph": 1054, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Одиночный результат с высоким уровнем вреда МОЖЕТ вызвать отдельный обзор критического инцидента", + "sourceParagraph": 1056, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "не рассматриваясь как доказательство распространенности в популяции.", + "sourceParagraph": 1057, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 1058, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH01-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Одиночный результат генеративной системы может указывать на то, что определённый ответ произошёл при зафиксированных условиях. Однако его нельзя использовать для определения распространённости в популяции, типичного поведения продукта, временной стабильности, кросс-лингвистической согласованности, согласованности между странами, согласованности между продуктами ИИ, эффекта вмешательства, достоверности рекомендаций, коммерческих последствий, соответствия или GEO-оценки. Один крайне вредоносный результат может вызвать отдельный обзор критического события, не считаясь при этом доказательством распространённости в популяции.", + "sourceParagraph": 1059, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 2, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH02", + "title": "Представление — это распределение", + "subtitle": null, + "sourceIds": [ + "K04", + "K05", + "K09" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH02-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "An entity's generative-system representation MUST be treated as a conditional distribution of observable outcomes across defined: - AI products and user surfaces, - users or sampling units, - countries, - languages and locales, - session and personalisation states, - prompts, - and measurement times. A single aggregate score MUST NOT replace disclosure of: - scope and coverage, - outcome distribution, - subgroup variation, - critical-error incidence, - unknown and untested mass, - temporal stability, - weighting rules, - and uncertainty. Equal averages MUST NOT be interpreted as equivalent representation quality when their subgroup, severity, coverage, or stability distributions materially differ. Untested groups MUST NOT be imputed as conforming, and rare high-harm outcomes MUST remain separately visible from average performance.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Bir varlığın üretken sistemlerdeki temsili; tanımlı AI ürünleri ve kullanıcı yüzeyleri, kullanıcılar veya örnekleme birimleri, ülkeler, diller ve locale’ler, oturum ve kişiselleştirme durumları, promptlar ve ölçüm zamanları arasında oluşan koşullu gözlenebilir sonuç dağılımı olarak değerlendirilmelidir. Tek bir toplulaştırılmış skor; kapsamı, sonuç dağılımını, alt grup farklarını, Critical hata oranını, bilinmeyen ve test edilmemiş kütleyi, zaman kararlılığını, ağırlıkları ve belirsizliği görünmez kılamaz. Aynı ortalama, maddi ölçüde farklı dağılımlar için eşdeğer temsil kalitesi anlamına gelmez.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE READABLE BY MACHINE FOR CHAPTER 31", + "sourceParagraph": 1312 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH02-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1313 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "An entity's generative-system representation MUST be treated as a", + "sourceParagraph": 1315 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "conditional distribution of observable outcomes across defined:", + "sourceParagraph": 1316 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- AI products and user surfaces,", + "sourceParagraph": 1318 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- users or sampling units,", + "sourceParagraph": 1319 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- countries,", + "sourceParagraph": 1320 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- languages and locales,", + "sourceParagraph": 1321 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- session and personalisation states,", + "sourceParagraph": 1322 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- prompts,", + "sourceParagraph": 1323 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and measurement times.", + "sourceParagraph": 1324 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A single aggregate score MUST NOT replace disclosure of:", + "sourceParagraph": 1326 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- scope and coverage,", + "sourceParagraph": 1328 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- outcome distribution,", + "sourceParagraph": 1329 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- subgroup variation,", + "sourceParagraph": 1330 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- critical-error incidence,", + "sourceParagraph": 1331 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- unknown and untested mass,", + "sourceParagraph": 1332 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- temporal stability,", + "sourceParagraph": 1333 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- weighting rules,", + "sourceParagraph": 1334 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and uncertainty.", + "sourceParagraph": 1335 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Equal averages MUST NOT be interpreted as equivalent representation", + "sourceParagraph": 1337 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "quality when their subgroup, severity, coverage, or stability", + "sourceParagraph": 1338 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "distributions materially differ.", + "sourceParagraph": 1339 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Untested groups MUST NOT be imputed as conforming, and rare high-harm", + "sourceParagraph": 1341 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "outcomes MUST remain separately visible from average performance.", + "sourceParagraph": 1342 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 1343 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The representation of an entity in generative systems should be evaluated as the conditional observable outcome distribution arising between defined AI products and user interfaces, users or sampling units, countries, languages and locales, session and personalisation states, prompts, and measurement times. A single aggregated score cannot make the scope, outcome distribution, subgroup differences, critical error rate, unknown and untested population, temporal stability, weights, and uncertainty invisible. The same average does not mean equivalent representation quality for materially different distributions.", + "sourceParagraph": 1344 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Представление генеративной системы сущности ДОЛЖНО рассматриваться как условное распределение наблюдаемых результатов по определённым: - продуктам ИИ и пользовательским интерфейсам, - пользователям или единицам выборки, - странам, - языкам и локалям, - состояниям сессии и персонализации, - промптам, - и времени измерений. Один агрегированный показатель НЕ ДОЛЖЕН заменять раскрытие информации о: - охвате и покрытии, - распределении результатов, - вариации по подгруппам, - частоте критических ошибок, - неизвестной и непроверенной массе, - временной стабильности, - правилах взвешивания, - и неопределенности. Равные средние значения НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ интерпретироваться как одинаковое качество представления, если их распределения по подгруппам, степени тяжести, охвату или стабильности существенно различаются. Неисследованные группы НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ учитываться как соответствующие, а редкие высокоопасные исходы ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельно видимыми от средней производительности.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРАВИЛО, ЧИТАЕМОЕ МАШИНОЙ ДЛЯ ГЛАВЫ 31", + "sourceParagraph": 1312, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH02-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1313, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Представление генеративной системы сущности ДОЛЖНО рассматриваться как", + "sourceParagraph": 1315, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "условное распределение наблюдаемых исходов по определённым:", + "sourceParagraph": 1316, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- продуктам ИИ и пользовательским интерфейсам,", + "sourceParagraph": 1318, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- пользователям или единицам выборки,", + "sourceParagraph": 1319, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- страны,", + "sourceParagraph": 1320, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- языки и локали,", + "sourceParagraph": 1321, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- состояния сеанса и персонализации,", + "sourceParagraph": 1322, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- промпты,", + "sourceParagraph": 1323, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и времена измерений.", + "sourceParagraph": 1324, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Один агрегированный балл НЕ ДОЛЖЕН заменять раскрытие информации о:", + "sourceParagraph": 1326, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- охвате и сфере применения,", + "sourceParagraph": 1328, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- распределении результатов,", + "sourceParagraph": 1329, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- различиях в подгруппах,", + "sourceParagraph": 1330, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- частоте критических ошибок,", + "sourceParagraph": 1331, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- неизвестной и непроверенной массе,", + "sourceParagraph": 1332, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- временной стабильности,", + "sourceParagraph": 1333, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- правилах взвешивания,", + "sourceParagraph": 1334, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и неопределенности.", + "sourceParagraph": 1335, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Равные средние значения НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ интерпретироваться как эквивалентное представление", + "sourceParagraph": 1337, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "качество, когда их подгруппа, тяжесть, охват или стабильность", + "sourceParagraph": 1338, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "распределений существенно различаются.", + "sourceParagraph": 1339, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Невыявленные группы НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ считаться соответствующими, а редкие высокоопасные", + "sourceParagraph": 1341, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "результаты ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельно видимыми от среднего показателя.", + "sourceParagraph": 1342, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 1343, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH02-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Представление сущности в генеративных системах следует оценивать как условное распределение наблюдаемых результатов, возникающее между определёнными продуктами ИИ и пользовательскими интерфейсами, пользователями или единицами выборки, странами, языками и локализациями, состояниями сессий и персонализации, промптами и временем измерений. Один агрегирова��ный показатель не может сделать невидимыми масштаб, распределение результатов, различия между подгруппами, критический уровень ошибок, неизвестную и непроверенную популяцию, временную стабильность, веса и неопределённость. Одинаковое среднее не означает эквивалентного качества представления для принципиально разных распределений.", + "sourceParagraph": 1344, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 3, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH03", + "title": "Что именно является объектом аудита?", + "subtitle": null, + "sourceIds": [ + "K10", + "K11" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH03-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "Every GEO audit MUST define and version, before observing results: - a prompt anchor, - a target entity, - an entity type, - a canonical identity record, - a relationship graph, - a temporal and jurisdictional boundary, - an audit object, - and a conformity unit. Domains, brands, legal entities, corporate groups, subsidiaries, products, services, persons, franchises, distributors, platforms, and sellers MUST NOT be treated as interchangeable entities. Attributes, credentials, licenses, customers, employees, performance, authority, and conformity MUST NOT transfer across related entities unless the relationship, scope, time, and evidence explicitly support that transfer. The entity resolved by the AI product MUST be evaluated separately from the factual accuracy of the response. A conformity decision MUST apply only to the explicitly identified entity and audited scope. It MUST NOT automatically extend to affiliates, products, jurisdictions, languages, domains, future versions, or related entities.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Her GEO denetimi sonuçlar görülmeden önce prompt çapasını, hedef varlığı, varlık türünü, kanonik kimlik kaydını, ilişki grafiğini, zamansal ve hukuki sınırı, denetim nesnesini ve uygunluk birimini tanımlayıp sürümlemek zorundadır. Alan adı, marka, hukuki şirket, şirketler grubu, bağlı kuruluş, ürün, hizmet, kişi, franchise, distribütör, platform ve satıcı birbirinin yerine kullanılamaz. Özellikler ve uygunluk, açık ilişki, kapsam, zaman ve kanıt bulunmadan ilişkili varlıklara aktarılamaz. AI ürününün çözümlediği varlık, yanıtın maddi doğruluğundan ayrı değerlendirilmelidir.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "31. MACHINE-READABLE ENTITY RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 1362 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 1363 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1364 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1365 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1366 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1367 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1368 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"ACTIVE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1369 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityType\": \"LEGAL_ENTITY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1370 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"canonicalName\": \"Asteron Holdings Ltd.\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1371 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"legalName\": \"Asteron Holdings Ltd.\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1372 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"jurisdiction\": \"SYNTHETIC\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1373 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"registrationId\": \"SYNTHETIC-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1374 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validFrom\": \"2025-01-01\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1375 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verifiedAt\": \"2026-08-18\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1376 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aliases\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1377 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1378 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"name\": \"Asteron\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1379 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aliasType\": \"BRAND_REFERENCE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1380 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"language\": \"und\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1381 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1382 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1383 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"brands\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1384 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1385 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-TRAVEL-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1386 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relationship\": \"OWNS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1387 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validFrom\": \"2025-01-01\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1388 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1389 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1390 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"domains\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1391 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1392 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"domain\": \"asteron.example\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1393 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relationship\": \"CONTROLS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1394 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scope\": \"GLOBAL_CORPORATE_SURFACE\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1395 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1396 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1397 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subsidiaries\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1398 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1399 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-TR-003\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1400 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relationship\": \"CONTROLS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1401 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"jurisdiction\": \"TR\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1402 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1403 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1404 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"externalRelationships\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1405 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1406 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-MIRA-004\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1407 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relationship\": \"SERVICE_DELIVERED_BY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1408 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scope\": \"SELECTED_DESTINATION_SERVICES\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1409 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"jurisdiction\": \"TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1410 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validFrom\": \"2026-01-01\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1411 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1412 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1413 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"auditScope\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1414 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedEntities\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1415 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1416 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-TRAVEL-002\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1417 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1418 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"excludedEntities\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1419 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-CLUB-005\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1420 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1421 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedDomains\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1422 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"asteron.example\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1423 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1424 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languages\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1425 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"en\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1426 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"tr\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1427 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1428 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countries\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1429 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"GB\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1430 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"TR\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1431 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1432 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validityPeriod\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1433 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"from\": \"2026-08-18\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1434 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"to\": \"2027-08-17\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1435 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1436 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1437 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responsibility\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1438 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimOwner\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1439 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"surfaceOperator\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1440 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"serviceDeliveryVariesByJurisdiction\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1441 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountableHumanRole\": \"ENTITY_RECORD_OWNER\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1442 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1443 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1444 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1445 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "This record:", + "sourceParagraph": 1446 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "does not by itself prove that the relation is correct,", + "sourceParagraph": 1447 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "does not replace a legal record,", + "sourceParagraph": 1448 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "does not properly declare all subsidiaries.", + "sourceParagraph": 1449 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Only shows the audit object and the alleged relationships in a machine-readable format.", + "sourceParagraph": 1450 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF SECTION 32", + "sourceParagraph": 1452 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH03-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1453 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every GEO audit MUST define and version, before observing results:", + "sourceParagraph": 1455 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- a prompt anchor,", + "sourceParagraph": 1457 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- a target entity,", + "sourceParagraph": 1458 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- an entity type,", + "sourceParagraph": 1459 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- a canonical identity record,", + "sourceParagraph": 1460 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- a relationship graph,", + "sourceParagraph": 1461 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- a temporal and jurisdictional boundary,", + "sourceParagraph": 1462 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- an audit object,", + "sourceParagraph": 1463 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and a conformity unit.", + "sourceParagraph": 1464 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Domains, brands, legal entities, corporate groups, subsidiaries, products,", + "sourceParagraph": 1466 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "services, persons, franchises, distributors, platforms, and sellers MUST", + "sourceParagraph": 1467 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOT be treated as interchangeable entities.", + "sourceParagraph": 1468 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Attributes, credentials, licenses, customers, employees, performance,", + "sourceParagraph": 1470 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "authority, and conformity MUST NOT transfer across related entities", + "sourceParagraph": 1471 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "unless the relationship, scope, time, and evidence explicitly support", + "sourceParagraph": 1472 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "that transfer.", + "sourceParagraph": 1473 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The entity resolved by the AI product MUST be evaluated separately from", + "sourceParagraph": 1475 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "the factual accuracy of the response.", + "sourceParagraph": 1476 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A conformity decision MUST apply only to the explicitly identified", + "sourceParagraph": 1478 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "entity and audited scope. It MUST NOT automatically extend to affiliates,", + "sourceParagraph": 1479 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "products, jurisdictions, languages, domains, future versions, or related", + "sourceParagraph": 1480 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "entities.", + "sourceParagraph": 1481 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 1482 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Before the results of each GEO audit are seen, the prompt anchor, target entity, entity type, canonical identity record, relationship graph, temporal and legal boundary, audit object, and conformity unit must be defined and versioned. Domain name, brand, legal company, corporate group, subsidiary, product, service, person, franchise, distributor, platform, and vendor cannot be used interchangeably. Attributes and compliance cannot be transferred to related entities without explicit relationship, scope, time, and evidence. The entity analysed by the AI product must be evaluated separately from the factual accuracy of the response.", + "sourceParagraph": 1483 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Каждый GEO аудит ДОЛЖЕН определить и версиифицировать до наблюдения результатов: - якорь промпта, - целевую сущность, - тип сущности, - каноническую запись идентичности, - граф отношений, - временные и юрисдикционные границы, - объект аудита, - и единицу соответствия. Домены, бренды, юридические лица, корпоративные группы, филиалы, продукты, услуги, лица, франшизы, дистрибьюторы, платформы и продавцы НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ рассматриваться как взаимозаменяемые сущности. Атрибуты, учетные данные, лицензии, клиенты, сотрудники, показатели, полномочия и соответствие НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ передаваться между связанными сущностями, если только отношения, масштаб, время и доказательства явно не поддерживают такую передачу. Сущность, обработанная ИИ-продуктом, ДОЛЖНА оцениваться отдельно от фактической точности ответа. Решение о соответствии ДОЛЖНО применяться только к явно идентифицированной сущности и проверяемому объему. Оно НЕ ДОЛЖНО автоматически распространяться на аффилированные лица, продукты, юрисдикции, языки, домены, будущие версии ил�� связанные сущности.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "31. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМАЯ ЗАПИСЬ СУЩНОСТИ", + "sourceParagraph": 1362, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 1363, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1364, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1365, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1366, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1367, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1368, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"статус\": \"АКТИВНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1369, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityType\": \"ЮРИДИЧЕСКОЕ ЛИЦО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1370, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"canonicalName\": \"Asteron Holdings Ltd.\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1371, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"legalName\": \"Asteron Holdings Ltd.\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1372, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"юрисдикция\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКАЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1373, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"registrationId\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1374, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validFrom\": \"2025-01-01\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1375, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verifiedAt\": \"2026-08-18\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1376, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"псевдонимы\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1377, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1378, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"имя\": \"Asteron\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1379, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{\"aliasType\": \"ССЫЛКА_НА_БРЕНД\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1380, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"язык\": \"неопределённый\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1381, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1382, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1383, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"бренды\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1384, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1385, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-TRAVEL-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1386, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"отношение\": \"ВЛАДЕЕТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1387, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validFrom\": \"2025-01-01\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1388, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1389, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1390, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"домены\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1391, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1392, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"домен\": \"asteron.example\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1393, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"отношение\": \"УПРАВЛЯЕТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1394, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"область\": \"ГЛОБАЛЬНАЯ_КОРПОРАТИВНАЯ_ПЛОЩАДКА\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1395, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1396, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1397, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"дочерние_компании\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1398, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1399, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-TR-003\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1400, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"отношение\": \"УПРАВЛЯЕТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1401, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"юрисдикция\": \"Турция\"}", + "sourceParagraph": 1402, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1403, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1404, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"externalRelationships\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1405, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1406, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-MIRA-004\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1407, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relationship\": \"УСЛУГА_ОКАЗЫВАЕТСЯ_КОМПАНИЕЙ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1408, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scope\": \"ВЫБРАННЫЕ_УСЛУГИ_ПУНКТА_НАЗНАЧЕНИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1409, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"jurisdiction\": \"TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1410, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validFrom\": \"2026-01-01\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1411, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1412, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1413, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"auditScope\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1414, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedEntities\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1415, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1416, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-TRAVEL-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1417, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1418, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"excludedEntities\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1419, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-CLUB-005\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1420, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1421, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedDomains\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1422, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"asteron.example\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1423, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1424, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languages\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1425, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"en\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1426, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"tr\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1427, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1428, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countries\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1429, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"GB\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1430, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"TR\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1431, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1432, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validityPeriod\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1433, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"from\": \"2026-08-18\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1434, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"to\": \"2027-08-17\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1435, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1436, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1437, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responsibility\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1438, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimOwner\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1439, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"surfaceOperator\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1440, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"serviceDeliveryVariesByJurisdiction\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1441, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountableHumanRole\": \"ВЛАДЕЛЕЦ_ЗАПИСИ_СУЩНОСТИ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1442, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1443, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1444, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1445, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Эта запись:", + "sourceParagraph": 1446, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "сама по себе не доказывает правильность отношения,", + "sourceParagraph": 1447, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "не заменяет юридическую запись,", + "sourceParagraph": 1448, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "не раскрывает должным образом все дочерние компании.", + "sourceParagraph": 1449, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Показывает только объект аудита и предполагаемые отношения в машиночитаемом формате.", + "sourceParagraph": 1450, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "МАШИНОЧИТАЕМОЕ ПРАВИЛО РАЗДЕЛА 32", + "sourceParagraph": 1452, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH03-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1453, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждый аудит GEO ДОЛЖЕН определить и версионировать перед наблюдением результатов:", + "sourceParagraph": 1455, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- якорь промпта,", + "sourceParagraph": 1457, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- целевой объект,", + "sourceParagraph": 1458, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- тип сущности,", + "sourceParagraph": 1459, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- каноническая запись идентичности,", + "sourceParagraph": 1460, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- график отношений,", + "sourceParagraph": 1461, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- временная и юрисдикционная граница,", + "sourceParagraph": 1462, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- объект аудита,", + "sourceParagraph": 1463, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и блок соответствия.", + "sourceParagraph": 1464, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Домены, бренды, юридические лица, корпоративные группы, дочерние компании, продукты,", + "sourceParagraph": 1466, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "услуги, лица, франшизы, дистрибьюторы, платформы и продавцы ДОЛЖНЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 1467, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "НЕ рассматривать как взаимозаменяемые сущности.", + "sourceParagraph": 1468, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Атрибуты, учетные данные, лицензии, клиенты, сотрудники, показатели эффективности,", + "sourceParagraph": 1470, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "власть и соответствие НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ переходить между связанными организациями", + "sourceParagraph": 1471, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "если только отношения, область, время и доказательства явно не поддерживают", + "sourceParagraph": 1472, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "такой переход.", + "sourceParagraph": 1473, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Организация, определенная ИИ-продуктом, ДОЛЖНА оцениваться отдельно от", + "sourceParagraph": 1475, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "фактической точности ответа.", + "sourceParagraph": 1476, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Решение о соответствии ДОЛЖНО применяться только к явно идентифицированной", + "sourceParagraph": 1478, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "организации и проверяемой области. Оно НЕ ДОЛЖНО автоматически распространяться на аффилированные лица,", + "sourceParagraph": 1479, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "продукты, юрисдикции, языки, домены, будущие версии или связанные", + "sourceParagraph": 1480, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "организации.", + "sourceParagraph": 1481, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 1482, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH03-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Прежде чем будут видны результ��ты каждой проверки GEO, необходимо определить и версионировать следующие элементы: исходная якорная точка, целевая сущность, тип сущности, каноническая запись идентичности, граф взаимоотношений, временные и юридические границы, объект аудита и единица соответствия. Название домена, бренд, юридическая компания, корпоративная группа, дочернее предприятие, продукт, услуга, лицо, франшиза, дистрибьютор, платформа и поставщик не могут использоваться взаимозаменяемо. Атрибуты и соответствие не могут быть переданы связанным сущностям без явных указаний на отношения, сферу, время и доказательства. Сущность, анализируемая продуктом ИИ, должна оцениваться отдельно от фактической точности ответа.", + "sourceParagraph": 1483, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 4, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH04", + "title": "Два уровня реальности", + "subtitle": "Официальное представление и проверенная реальность сущности", + "sourceIds": [ + "K10", + "K11" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH04-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "Every material generative-system claim about an audited entity MUST be evaluated against two separately versioned reference layers:", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": null, + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "42. MACHINE-READABLE CLAIM RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 1340 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 1341 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1342 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1343 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1344 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1345 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimId\": \"NGR-SYNTH-ASTERON-COUNTRIES-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1346 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1347 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"predicate\": \"operatesInCountryCount\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1348 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"officialRepresentation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1349 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"OFFICIAL_CURRENT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1350 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 25,", + "sourceParagraph": 1351 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceId\": \"OFFICIAL-WEB-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1352 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publishedAt\": \"2026-01-10\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1353 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verifiedAt\": \"2026-08-18\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1354 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scope\": \"PUBLIC_GLOBAL_CLAIM\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1355 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1356 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verifiedReality\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1357 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"CONTRADICTED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1358 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportedValue\": 9,", + "sourceParagraph": 1359 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceLevel\": \"VR-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1360 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceIds\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1361 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"OPS-COUNTRY-REGISTER-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1362 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CONTRACT-REGISTER-002\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1363 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1364 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"counterEvidenceIds\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1365 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"OFFICIAL-WEB-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1366 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1367 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scope\": \"ACTIVE_SERVICE_DELIVERY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1368 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validAt\": \"2026-08-18\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1369 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"uncertainty\": \"Some remote-only markets remain unresolved\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1370 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1371 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attribution\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1372 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"required\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1373 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"preferredForm\": \"The company states that it operates in 25 countries; active service delivery has been verified in 9.\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1374 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1375 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materiality\": \"MAJOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1376 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudication\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1377 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reviewStatus\": \"REVIEWED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1378 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"appealStatus\": \"OPEN\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1379 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountableHumanRole\": \"CLAIM_ADJUDICATOR\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1380 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1381 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1382 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1383 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "This record:", + "sourceParagraph": 1384 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "do not claim to represent absolute truth,", + "sourceParagraph": 1385 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "may change with new evidence,", + "sourceParagraph": 1386 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "preserves the scope and uncertainty of the evidence.", + "sourceParagraph": 1387 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE OF THE CHAPTER 43 READABLE BY MACHINE", + "sourceParagraph": 1389 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH04-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1390 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every material generative-system claim about an audited entity MUST be", + "sourceParagraph": 1392 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "evaluated against two separately versioned reference layers:", + "sourceParagraph": 1393 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Каждое существенное утверждение генеративной системы о проверяемой сущности ДОЛЖНО оцениваться на соответствие двух отдельных версионированных эталонных слоев:", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "42. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ РЕЕСТР утверждений", + "sourceParagraph": 1340, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 1341, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1342, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1343, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1344, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1345, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimId\": \"NGR-SYNTH-ASTERON-COUNTRIES-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1346, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1347, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"predicate\": \"operatesInCountryCount\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1348, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"officialRepresentation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1349, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"OFFICIAL_CURRENT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1350, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 25,", + "sourceParagraph": 1351, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceId\": \"OFFICIAL-WEB-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1352, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publishedAt\": \"2026-01-10\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1353, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verifiedAt\": \"2026-08-18\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1354, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scope\": \"PUBLIC_GLOBAL_CLAIM\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1355, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1356, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verifiedReality\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1357, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"CONTRADICTED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1358, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportedValue\": 9,", + "sourceParagraph": 1359, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceLevel\": \"VR-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1360, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceIds\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1361, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"OPS-COUNTRY-REGISTER-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1362, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"КОНТРАКТ-РЕГИСТР-002\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1363, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1364, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"counterEvidenceIds\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1365, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ОФИЦИАЛЬНЫЙ-ВЕБ-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1366, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1367, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"объем\": \"АКТИВНОЕ_ОКАЗАНИЕ_УСЛУГ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1368, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validAt\": \"2026-08-18\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1369, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"неопределенность\": \"Некоторые удаленные рынки остаются нерешенными\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1370, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1371, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"атрибуция\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1372, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"обязательно\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1373, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"preferredForm\": \"Компания заявляет, что она работает в 25 странах; активное оказание услуг подтверждено в 9.\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1374, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1375, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"существенность\": \"ЗНАЧИТЕЛЬНАЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1376, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"разбирательство\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1377, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reviewStatus\": \"ПРОСМОТРЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1378, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"appealStatus\": \"ОТКРЫТО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1379, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountableHumanRole\": \"ПРИСУТСТВУЮЩИЙ_ПРИ_РАЗБИРАТЕЛЬСТВЕ\"}", + "sourceParagraph": 1380, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1381, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1382, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1383, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Эта запись:", + "sourceParagraph": 1384, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "не заявляйте о представлении абсолютной истины,", + "sourceParagraph": 1385, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "может изменяться с появлением новых данных,", + "sourceParagraph": 1386, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "сохраняет объем и неопределенность доказательств.", + "sourceParagraph": 1387, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРАВИЛО ГЛАВЫ 43, ЧИТАЕМОЕ МАШИНОЙ", + "sourceParagraph": 1389, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH04-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1390, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждое материальное утверждение генеративной системы о проверяемом объекте ДОЛЖНО быть", + "sourceParagraph": 1392, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH04-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "оценено в сравнении с двумя отдельно версионированными эталонными слоями:", + "sourceParagraph": 1393, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 5, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH05", + "title": "Релевантная пользовательская популяция для каждого ИИ-продукта", + "subtitle": null, + "sourceIds": [ + "K04", + "K05", + "K06", + "K07" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH05-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "Every GEO population audit MUST define, before result inspection, a time-bound and product-specific target user population for each: - AI product and user surface, - country or jurisdiction, - age and lawful-access condition, - account or plan condition, - language and locale, - interface, - prompt family, - and measurement purpose. Total resident population MUST NOT be treated as product-eligible population without justified eligibility adjustments. Product unavailability MUST be reported as an access-coverage limitation, not silently scored as incorrect representation or silently removed from global scope. Potential access, active use, actual exposure, Native Reach, Common Support, market relevance, and research observability MUST remain distinct population concepts. Persons, accounts, sessions, languages, and product observations MUST NOT be treated as interchangeable population units. Oversampled countries, languages, and accessibility groups MUST be reweighted for population estimates while remaining separately visible for fairness and coverage analysis. Country Observer observations MAY establish geographic observation coverage, but MUST NOT be represented as statistically reliable country scores. Participants MUST NOT be required to bypass product, geographic, age, identity, or account restrictions in order to enter the official population panel. Every population frame MUST be versioned, sourced, uncertainty-aware, and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Her GEO nüfus denetimi, sonuçlar görülmeden önce her AI ürünü ve kullanıcı yüzeyi, ülke veya yargı alanı, yaş ve meşru erişim koşulu, hesap veya plan, dil ve locale, arayüz, prompt ailesi ve ölçüm amacı için zamana bağlı ürün-özel hedef kullanıcı nüfusu tanımlamalıdır. Toplam yerleşik nüfus, gerekçeli uygunluk ayarlamaları olmadan ürün-uygun nüfus sayılamaz. Ürün erişiminin bulunmaması yanlış temsil olarak puanlanmamalı; erişim kapsamı sınırlaması olarak ayrıca gösterilmelidir. Kişi, hesap, oturum, dil ve ürün gözlemi birbirinin yerine kullanılamaz. Gözcü gözlemleri ülke görünürlüğü sağlayabilir; istatistiksel ülke skoru olarak sunulamaz.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MACHINE-READABLE POPULATION RECORD 42", + "sourceParagraph": 1466 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 1467 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1468 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1469 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"referenceDate\": \"2026-08-18\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1470 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptFamily\": \"CORE_IDENTITY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1471 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetEstimand\": \"Probability of a qualifying representation among product-eligible adult users\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1472 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1473 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"eligibility\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1474 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"minimumAgeRule\": \"ADULT_BASELINE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1475 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"internetAccessRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1476 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"officialProductAccessRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1477 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"restrictionCircumventionAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1478 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageCompetenceRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1479 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"researchConsentRequired\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1480 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1481 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryFrames\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1482 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1483 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-A\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1484 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"residentPopulation\": 1400000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1485 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productAccessStatus\": \"UNAVAILABLE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1486 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nativeReachPopulation\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1487 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nativeReachStatus\": \"OUTSIDE_NATIVE_REACH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1488 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sentinelEligible\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1489 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1490 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1491 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-B\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1492 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"residentPopulation\": 1450000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1493 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimatedJointEligiblePopulation\": 520000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1494 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productAccessStatus\": \"OFFICIALLY_AVAILABLE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1495 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nativeReachPopulation\": 520000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1496 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimationMethod\": \"SYNTHETIC_JOINT_ESTIMATE\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1497 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1498 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1499 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-C\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1500 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"residentPopulation\": 340000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1501 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimatedJointEligiblePopulation\": 250000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1502 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productAccessStatus\": \"OFFICIALLY_AVAILABLE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1503 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nativeReachPopulation\": 250000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1504 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimationMethod\": \"SYNTHETIC_JOINT_ESTIMATE\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1505 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1506 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1507 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-D\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1508 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"residentPopulation\": 35000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1509 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimatedJointEligiblePopulation\": 25000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1510 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productAccessStatus\": \"OFFICIALLY_AVAILABLE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1511 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nativeReachPopulation\": 25000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1512 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationPanelShare\": 0.000032,", + "sourceParagraph": 1513 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countrySentinelPanel\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1514 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1515 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1516 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panels\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1517 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationPanel\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1518 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"purpose\": \"POPULATION_WEIGHTED_ESTIMATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1519 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"defaultTargetValidObservations\": 1000", + "sourceParagraph": 1520 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1521 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countrySentinelPanel\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1522 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"purpose\": \"COUNTRY_COVERAGE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1523 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryScoresAllowedFromSingleObservation\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1524 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1525 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageFairnessPanel\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1526 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"purpose\": \"LOW_RESOURCE_LANGUAGE_DIAGNOSTICS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1527 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reweightToPopulationForGlobalScore\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1528 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1529 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accessibilityPanel\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1530 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"purpose\": \"ACCESSIBILITY_COVERAGE_AND_DIAGNOSTICS\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1531 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1532 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1533 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonFrames\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1534 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nativeReach\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1535 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"commonSupport\": \"TO_BE_DEFINED_PER_COMPARISON_SET\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1536 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1537 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1538 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationFrameOwnerRole\": \"POPULATION_METHODS_LEAD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1539 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"approvedAt\": \"2026-08-18\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1540 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"changeAfterResultInspection\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1541 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1542 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1543 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1544 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "This record:", + "sourceParagraph": 1545 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "is not real population data,", + "sourceParagraph": 1546 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "is not a real product access map,", + "sourceParagraph": 1547 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "shows the data structure of a method.", + "sourceParagraph": 1548 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE OF THE CHAPTER 43 READABLE BY MACHINE", + "sourceParagraph": 1550 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH05-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1551 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every GEO population audit MUST define, before result inspection, a", + "sourceParagraph": 1553 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "time-bound and product-specific target user population for each:", + "sourceParagraph": 1554 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- AI product and user surface,", + "sourceParagraph": 1556 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- country or jurisdiction,", + "sourceParagraph": 1557 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- age and lawful-access condition,", + "sourceParagraph": 1558 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- account or plan condition,", + "sourceParagraph": 1559 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- language and locale,", + "sourceParagraph": 1560 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- interface,", + "sourceParagraph": 1561 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- prompt family,", + "sourceParagraph": 1562 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and measurement purpose.", + "sourceParagraph": 1563 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Total resident population MUST NOT be treated as product-eligible", + "sourceParagraph": 1565 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "population without justified eligibility adjustments.", + "sourceParagraph": 1566 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Product unavailability MUST be reported as an access-coverage limitation,", + "sourceParagraph": 1568 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "not silently scored as incorrect representation or silently removed from", + "sourceParagraph": 1569 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "global scope.", + "sourceParagraph": 1570 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Potential access, active use, actual exposure, Native Reach, Common", + "sourceParagraph": 1572 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Support, market relevance, and research observability MUST remain", + "sourceParagraph": 1573 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "distinct population concepts.", + "sourceParagraph": 1574 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Persons, accounts, sessions, languages, and product observations MUST NOT", + "sourceParagraph": 1576 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "be treated as interchangeable population units.", + "sourceParagraph": 1577 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Oversampled countries, languages, and accessibility groups MUST be", + "sourceParagraph": 1579 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "reweighted for population estimates while remaining separately visible", + "sourceParagraph": 1580 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "for fairness and coverage analysis.", + "sourceParagraph": 1581 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Country Observer observations MAY establish geographic observation coverage, but", + "sourceParagraph": 1583 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MUST NOT be represented as statistically reliable country scores.", + "sourceParagraph": 1584 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Participants MUST NOT be required to bypass product, geographic, age,", + "sourceParagraph": 1586 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "identity, or account restrictions in order to enter the official", + "sourceParagraph": 1587 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "population panel.", + "sourceParagraph": 1588 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every population frame MUST be versioned, sourced, uncertainty-aware,", + "sourceParagraph": 1590 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "sourceParagraph": 1591 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 1592 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Each GEO population audit should define a time-bound product-specific target user population for every AI product and user surface, country or jurisdiction, age and legitimate access condition, account or plan, language and locale, interface, prompt family, and measurement purpose before results are seen. The total embedded population cannot be counted as a product-eligible population without justified eligibility adjustments. Lack of product access should not be scored as misrepresentation; it should be shown separately as an access coverage limitation. Person, account, session, language, and product observation cannot be used interchangeably. Country Observer observations can provide country visibility; they cannot be presented as a statistical country score.", + "sourceParagraph": 1593 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Каждый аудит популяции GEO ДОЛЖЕН определить, до проверки результатов, ограниченную по времени и определённую для конкретного продукта целевую пользовательскую совокупность для каждого: - ИИ-продукта и пользовательского интерфейса, - страны или юрисдикции, - возраста и условий законного доступа, - условий аккаунта или плана, - языка и локали, - интерфейса, - семейства промптов, - и цели измерения. Общая численность постоянного населения НЕ ДОЛЖНА рассматриваться как совокупность пользователей, допущенных к использованию продукта, без обоснованных корректировок права на участие. Недоступность продукта ДОЛЖНА быть зафиксирована как ограничение охвата доступа, а не оценена без раскрытия как некорректное представление или тайно исключена из глобального охвата. Потенциальный доступ, активное использование, фактическое воздействие, Естественный охват, Общая область поддержки, актуальность на рынке и наблюдаемость в рамках исследования ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться различными понятиями целевой совокупности. Лица, аккаунты, сессии, языки и наблюдения за продуктом НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ рассматриваться как взаимозаменяемые единицы популяции. Страны с избыточной выборкой, языки и группы по признаку доступности ДОЛЖНЫ быть перевзвешены для оценки популяции, при этом оставаться отдельно видимыми для анализа справедливости и охвата. Наблюдения Country Observer МОГУТ устанавливать географический охват наблюдений, но НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ представляться как статистически надёжные оценки на уровне страны. Участников НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ обязывать обходить ограничения по продукту, географии, возрасту, идентичности или аккаунту, чтобы войти в официальную панель населения. Каждая рамка целевой совокупности ДОЛЖНА быть версионирована, опираться на источники, учитывать неопределённость и быть отнесена к ответственному лицу или организации.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ ЗАПИСИ НАСЕЛЕНИЯ 42", + "sourceParagraph": 1466, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 1467, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1468, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1469, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"referenceDate\": \"2026-08-18\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1470, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptFamily\": \"CORE_IDENTITY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1471, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetEstimand\": \"Вероятность корректного представления среди взрослых пользователей, имеющих право на продукт\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1472, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1473, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"право на участие\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1474, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"minimumAgeRule\": \"БАЗОВЫЙ_ДЛЯ_ВЗРОСЛЫХ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1475, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"internetAccessRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1476, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"officialProductAccessRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1477, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"restrictionCircumventionAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1478, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageCompetenceRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1479, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"researchConsentRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1480, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1481, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryFrames\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1482, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1483, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-A\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1484, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"residentPopulation\": 1400000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1485, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productAccessStatus\": \"НЕДОСТУПНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1486, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nativeReachPopulation\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1487, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nativeReachStatus\": \"ЗА_ПРЕДЕЛАМИ_ДОСТУПА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1488, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sentinelEligible\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1489, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1490, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1491, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-B\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1492, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"residentPopulation\": 1450000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1493, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimatedJointEligiblePopulation\": 520000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1494, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productAccessStatus\": \"ОФИЦИАЛЬНО_ДОСТУПНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1495, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nativeReachPopulation\": 520000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1496, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimationMethod\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКАЯ_ОЦЕНКА_СОВМЕСТНОЙ_ПОСТАВКИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1497, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1498, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1499, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-C\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1500, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"residentPopulation\": 340000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1501, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimatedJointEligiblePopulation\": 250000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1502, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productAccessStatus\": \"ОФИЦИАЛЬНО_ДОСТУПНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1503, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nativeReachPopulation\": 250000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1504, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimationMethod\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКАЯ_ОЦЕНКА_СОВМЕСТНОЙ_ПОСТАВКИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1505, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1506, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1507, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-D\"\n}", + "sourceParagraph": 1508, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"residentPopulation\": 35000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1509, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimatedJointEligiblePopulation\": 25000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1510, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productAccessStatus\": \"ОФИЦИАЛЬНО_ДОСТУПНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1511, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nativeReachPopulation\": 25000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1512, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationPanelShare\": 0.000032,", + "sourceParagraph": 1513, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countrySentinelPanel\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1514, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1515, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1516, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"панели\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1517, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationPanel\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1518, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"цель\": \"ПОПУЛЯЦИОННО ВЗВЕШЕННАЯ ОЦЕНКА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1519, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"defaultTargetValidObservations\": 1000", + "sourceParagraph": 1520, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1521, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countrySentinelPanel\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1522, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"цель\": \"ПОКРЫТИЕ СТРАНЫ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1523, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryScoresAllowedFromSingleObservation\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1524, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1525, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageFairnessPanel\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1526, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"цель\": \"ДИАГНОСТИКА ЯЗЫКОВ С НИЗКИМИ РЕСУРСАМИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1527, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reweightToPopulationForGlobalScore\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1528, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1529, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accessibilityPanel\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1530, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"цель\": \"ПОКРЫТИЕ И ДИАГНОСТИКА ДОСТУПНОСТИ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1531, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1532, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1533, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonFrames\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1534, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nativeReach\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1535, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"commonSupport\": \"БУДЕТ ОПРЕДЕЛЕНО ДЛЯ КАЖДОГО НАБОРА СРАВНЕНИЙ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1536, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1537, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1538, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationFrameOwnerRole\": \"РУКОВОДИТЕЛЬ ПО МЕТОДАМ ОЦЕНКИ НАСЕЛЕНИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1539, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"approvedAt\": \"2026-08-18\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1540, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"changeAfterResultInspection\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1541, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1542, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1543, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1544, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Эта запись:", + "sourceParagraph": 1545, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "не является реальными данными о населении,", + "sourceParagraph": 1546, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "не является реальной картой доступа к продукту,", + "sourceParagraph": 1547, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "показывает структуру данных метода.", + "sourceParagraph": 1548, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРАВИЛО ГЛАВЫ 43, ЧИТАЕМОЕ МАШИНОЙ", + "sourceParagraph": 1550, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH05-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1551, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждый аудит населения GEO ДОЛЖЕН определить, до проверки результатов,", + "sourceParagraph": 1553, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ограниченную по времени и специфичную для продукта целевую пользоватeльскую популяцию для каждого:", + "sourceParagraph": 1554, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- AI продукт и пользовательский интерфейс,", + "sourceParagraph": 1556, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- страны или юрисдикции,", + "sourceParagraph": 1557, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- возраста и условий законного доступа,", + "sourceParagraph": 1558, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- условия учетной записи или плана,", + "sourceParagraph": 1559, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- языка и локали,", + "sourceParagraph": 1560, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- интерфейса,", + "sourceParagraph": 1561, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- семейства промптов,", + "sourceParagraph": 1562, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и целей измерения.", + "sourceParagraph": 1563, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Общее количество постоянного населения НЕ ДОЛЖНО рассматриваться как имеющее право на продукт", + "sourceParagraph": 1565, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "население без обоснованных корректировок права на участие.", + "sourceParagraph": 1566, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Наличие продукта ДОЛЖНО сообщаться как ограничение доступа/покрытия,", + "sourceParagraph": 1568, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "а не молча оцениваться как некорректное представление или молча удаляться из", + "sourceParagraph": 1569, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "глобальной области.", + "sourceParagraph": 1570, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Потенциальный доступ, активное использование, фактическое воздействие, Естественный охват, Общий", + "sourceParagraph": 1572, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Поддержка, значимость на рынке и исследуемая наблюдаемость ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться", + "sourceParagraph": 1573, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "отдельными концепциями населения.", + "sourceParagraph": 1574, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Лица, аккаунты, сессии, языки и наблюдения продуктов НЕЛЬЗЯ", + "sourceParagraph": 1576, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "рассматривать как взаимозаменяемые единицы населения.", + "sourceParagraph": 1577, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Страны, языки и группы по доступности, для которых данные были чрезмерно отобраны, ДОЛЖНЫ быть", + "sourceParagraph": 1579, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "перевзвешены для оценки численности населения при этом оставаясь отдельно видимыми", + "sourceParagraph": 1580, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "для анализа справедливости и охвата.", + "sourceParagraph": 1581, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Наблюдения наблюдателей за странами МОГУТ устанавливать географическое покрытие наблюдений, но", + "sourceParagraph": 1583, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ представляться как статистически надежные показатели по странам.", + "sourceParagraph": 1584, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Участники НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ быть обязаны обходить ограничения по продукту, географическому положению, возрасту,", + "sourceParagraph": 1586, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "идентичности или учетной записи, чтобы попасть в официальную", + "sourceParagraph": 1587, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "панель населения.", + "sourceParagraph": 1588, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждая рамка населения ДОЛЖНА иметь версию, источник, и учитывать неопределённость,", + "sourceParagraph": 1590, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "и подлежащий учету за конкретным человеком или организацией.", + "sourceParagraph": 1591, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 1592, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH05-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждый аудит GEO-популяции должен определять ограниченную по времени целевую пользовательскую популяцию для каждого продукта ИИ и пользовательский интерфейс, страны или юрисдикции, возраста и законных условий доступа, аккаунта или плана, языка и локали, интерфейса, семейства промптов и цели измерения до того, как будут получены результаты. Общая встроенная популяция не может учитываться как подходящая для продукта без обоснованных корректировок на право соответствия. Отсутствие доступа к продукту не должно оцениваться как искажение; оно должно отображаться отдельно как ограничение охвата доступа. Личность, аккаунт, сессия, язык и наблюдение за продуктом не могут использоваться взаимозаменяемо. Наблюдения странового наблюдателя могут обеспечивать видимость страны; они не могут быть представлены в виде статистического странового показателя.", + "sourceParagraph": 1593, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 6, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH06", + "title": "Пропорциональная населению выборка GEO-1000", + "subtitle": null, + "sourceIds": [ + "K04", + "K05", + "K07", + "K08" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH06-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "For each AI product and principal measurement wave, the GEO-1000 Population Panel SHOULD target at least 1,000 valid product-observations unless a different target is explicitly justified. Sample allocation MUST be designed, versioned, and locked before AI responses are observed. Primary allocation MUST be based on the product-eligible target population, not raw resident population, invitation counts, accounts, sessions, or convenience availability. Fractional allocations MUST be converted to integer quotas using a predeclared, reproducible, outcome-blind method. Positive-mass populations MUST NOT be deterministically assigned zero selection probability when the audit claims inference to the full target population. Small populations MAY be represented through justified pooled strata and probability-proportional selection. Country Observer, Language Fairness, and Accessibility observations MAY supplement the main panel, but MUST remain separately labelled and appropriately reweighted. Oversampled groups MUST NOT receive their raw sample share as population weight. Participant replacement MUST be based only on predeclared recruitment or protocol-validity conditions. Incorrect, negative, refused, or critical AI outputs MUST NOT trigger replacement. Persons, accounts, sessions, languages, and AI-product observations MUST remain distinct units. Design weights, nonresponse adjustments, calibration, trimming, clustering, paired observations, and effective sample size MUST be documented. Any post-result change to quotas, strata, pools, weights, exclusions, or sample targets MUST create a new analysis version and preserve the original record.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Her AI ürünü ve ana ölçüm dalgası için GEO-1000 Population Panel, farklı bir hedef açıkça gerekçelendirilmedikçe en az 1.000 geçerli ürün-gözlemini hedeflemelidir. Örneklem tahsisi AI yanıtları görülmeden önce tasarlanmalı, sürümlenmeli ve kilitlenmelidir. Ana tahsis toplam ülke nüfusuna, davet sayısına, hesaplara, oturumlara veya kolaylık örneklemine değil ürün-uygun hedef insan nüfusuna dayanmalıdır. Küsuratlı kotalar önceden ilan edilmiş ve sonuçtan bağımsız yöntemle tam sayıya çevrilmelidir. Pozitif nüfus kütlesi taşıyan gruplara, bütün hedef nüfus adına çıkarım yapılırken deterministik sıfır seçilme olasılığı verilemez. Fazla örneklenen gruplar ham örneklem paylarını nüfus ağırlığı olarak kullanamaz. Yanlış, olumsuz, ret veya Critical AI çıktısı katılımcı değiştirme nedeni olamaz.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "58. MACHINE-READABLE ALLOCATION RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 1512 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 1513 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1514 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationShare\": 0.002,", + "sourceParagraph": 1515 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rawQuota\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 1516 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetValid\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 1517 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"withinPoolSelection\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1518 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"method\": \"PPS_ELIGIBLE_POPULATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1519 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countries\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1520 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1521 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-H\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1522 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"eligiblePopulation\": 1500000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1523 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conditionalSelectionShare\": 0.75", + "sourceParagraph": 1524 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1525 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1526 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-I\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1527 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"eligiblePopulation\": 400000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1528 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conditionalSelectionShare\": 0.2", + "sourceParagraph": 1529 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1530 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1531 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-J\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1532 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"eligiblePopulation\": 100000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1533 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conditionalSelectionShare\": 0.05", + "sourceParagraph": 1534 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1535 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 1536 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1537 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1538 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 1539 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1540 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supplementaryPanels\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1541 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countrySentinel\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1542 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetValid\": 3,", + "sourceParagraph": 1543 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedCountries\": [\"SYN-H\", \"SYN-I\", \"SYN-J\"],", + "sourceParagraph": 1544 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryScoresFromSingleObservationAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1545 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedInPopulationEstimateWithFullSentinelWeight\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1546 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1547 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageFairness\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1548 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetValid\": 50,", + "sourceParagraph": 1549 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"oversampledLanguage\": \"SYN-LANG-Y\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1550 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reweightToPopulation\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1551 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1552 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accessibility\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1553 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetValid\": 40,", + "sourceParagraph": 1554 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"separateDiagnosticReporting\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1555 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1556 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1557 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fieldwork\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1558 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"expectedCompletionRate\": 0.82,", + "sourceParagraph": 1559 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"expectedProtocolValidityRate\": 0.92,", + "sourceParagraph": 1560 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"plannedInvitationsMainPanel\": 1326,", + "sourceParagraph": 1561 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reserveListsPreselected\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1562 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseContentMayTriggerReplacement\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1563 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validityReviewBeforeSemanticScoring\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1564 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1565 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"weights\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1566 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"baseDesignWeight\": \"INVERSE_SELECTION_PROBABILITY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1567 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nonresponseAdjustment\": \"PREDECLARED_RESPONSE_CLASSES\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1568 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"calibration\": \"COUNTRY_LANGUAGE_TOTALS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1569 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"trimming\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1570 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"enabled\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1571 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ifEnabledRequiresNewAnalysisVersion\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1572 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1573 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"effectiveSampleSizeRequired\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1574 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1575 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonFrames\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1576 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nativeReachAllocation\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1577 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"commonSupportAllocation\": \"SEPARATE_RECORD_REQUIRED\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1578 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1579 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governance\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1580 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"allocationApprovedBeforeResponses\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1581 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountableHumanRole\": \"SAMPLE_DESIGN_OWNER\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1582 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-08-18T09:00:00Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1583 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"resultDrivenChangesProhibited\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1584 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1585 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1586 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1587 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "This record:", + "sourceParagraph": 1588 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "It is not actual product or country data,", + "sourceParagraph": 1589 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "It is not an actual sampling plan.", + "sourceParagraph": 1590 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "It is a synthetic representation of the reproducible allocation structure.", + "sourceParagraph": 1591 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF SECTION 59", + "sourceParagraph": 1593 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH06-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1594 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "For each AI product and principal measurement wave, the GEO-1000", + "sourceParagraph": 1596 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Population Panel SHOULD target at least 1,000 valid product-observations", + "sourceParagraph": 1597 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "unless a different target is explicitly justified.", + "sourceParagraph": 1598 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Sample allocation MUST be designed, versioned, and locked before AI", + "sourceParagraph": 1600 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "responses are observed.", + "sourceParagraph": 1601 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Primary allocation MUST be based on the product-eligible target population,", + "sourceParagraph": 1603 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "not raw resident population, invitation counts, accounts, sessions, or", + "sourceParagraph": 1604 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "convenience availability.", + "sourceParagraph": 1605 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Fractional allocations MUST be converted to integer quotas using a", + "sourceParagraph": 1607 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "predeclared, reproducible, outcome-blind method.", + "sourceParagraph": 1608 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Positive-mass populations MUST NOT be deterministically assigned zero", + "sourceParagraph": 1610 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "selection probability when the audit claims inference to the full target", + "sourceParagraph": 1611 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "population. Small populations MAY be represented through justified pooled", + "sourceParagraph": 1612 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "strata and probability-proportional selection.", + "sourceParagraph": 1613 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Country Observer, Language Fairness, and Accessibility observations MAY", + "sourceParagraph": 1615 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "supplement the main panel, but MUST remain separately labelled and", + "sourceParagraph": 1616 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "appropriately reweighted.", + "sourceParagraph": 1617 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Oversampled groups MUST NOT receive their raw sample share as population", + "sourceParagraph": 1619 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "weight.", + "sourceParagraph": 1620 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Participant replacement MUST be based only on predeclared recruitment or", + "sourceParagraph": 1622 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "protocol-validity conditions. Incorrect, negative, refused, or critical AI", + "sourceParagraph": 1623 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "outputs MUST NOT trigger replacement.", + "sourceParagraph": 1624 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Persons, accounts, sessions, languages, and AI-product observations MUST", + "sourceParagraph": 1626 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "remain distinct units.", + "sourceParagraph": 1627 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Design weights, nonresponse adjustments, calibration, trimming, clustering,", + "sourceParagraph": 1629 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "paired observations, and effective sample size MUST be documented.", + "sourceParagraph": 1630 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Any post-result change to quotas, strata, pools, weights, exclusions, or", + "sourceParagraph": 1632 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "sample targets MUST create a new analysis version and preserve the original", + "sourceParagraph": 1633 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "record.", + "sourceParagraph": 1634 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 1635 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "For each AI product and main measurement wave, the GEO-1000 Population Panel should target at least 1,000 valid product-observations unless a different target is explicitly justified. Sample allocation should be designed, finalised, and locked before AI responses are seen. The main allocation should be based on the product-eligible target human population, not on total country population, number of invitations, accounts, sessions, or convenience samples. Fractional quotas should be announced in advance and rounded to whole numbers using a method independent of the results. Groups with a positive population mass cannot be assigned a deterministic zero probability of selection when making inferences for the entire target population. Over-sampled groups cannot use raw sample shares as population weights. Incorrect, negative, rejected, or Critical AI output cannot be a reason for participant replacement.", + "sourceParagraph": 1636 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Для каждого продукта ИИ и основной волны измерений Панели населения GEO-1000 СЛЕДУЕТ стремиться к охвату как минимум 1,000 действительных наблюдений продукта, если явно не обоснована другая цель. Распределение выборки ДОЛЖНО быть спроектировано, версионировано и зафиксировано до того, как будут получены ответы ИИ. Основное распределение ДОЛЖНО основываться на целевой популяции, соответствующей продукту, а не на общей численности жителей, количестве приглашений, учетных записях, сессиях или доступности по удобству. Дробные распределения ДОЛЖНЫ быть преобразованы в целочисленные квоты с использованием заранее объявленного, воспроизводимого метода, слепого к результатам. Популяциям с положительной массой НЕЛЬЗЯ детерминированно присваивать нулевую вероятность отбора, когда аудит утверждает выводы для всей целевой популяции. Малые популяции МОГУТ быть представлены через обоснованные объединённые страты и выборку с вероятностью, пропорциональной размеру. Наблюдения Country Observer, языковой справедливостью и доступностью МОГУТ дополнять основную панель, но ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельно маркированными и соответственно перенормированными. Избыточно представленным группам НЕЛЬЗЯ назначать их исходную долю выборки в качестве веса популяции. Замена участников ДОЛЖНА основываться только на заранее объявленных условиях набора или условиях допустимости протокола. Некорректные, отрицательные, отказавшиеся или критические результаты ИИ НЕЛЬЗЯ использовать для инициирования замены. Лица, учетные записи, сеансы, языки и наблюдения за продуктами ИИ ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельными единицами. Дизайн-веса, корректировки на неответы, калибровка, усечение, кластеризация, парные наблюдения и эффективный размер выборки ДОЛЖНЫ быть задокументированы. Любое изменение квот, страт, пулов, весов, исключений или целей выборки после получения результатов ДОЛЖНО создавать новую версию анализа и сохранять исходную запись.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "58. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ ЗАПИСЬ РАСПРЕДЕЛЕНИЯ", + "sourceParagraph": 1512, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 1513, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1514, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationShare\": 0.002,", + "sourceParagraph": 1515, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rawQuota\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 1516, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetValid\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 1517, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"withinPoolSelection\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1518, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"method\": \"PPS_ELIGIBLE_POPULATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1519, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countries\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1520, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1521, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-H\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1522, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"eligiblePopulation\": 1500000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1523, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conditionalSelectionShare\": 0.75", + "sourceParagraph": 1524, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1525, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1526, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-I\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1527, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"eligiblePopulation\": 400000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1528, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conditionalSelectionShare\": 0.2", + "sourceParagraph": 1529, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1530, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1531, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-J\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1532, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"eligiblePopulation\": 100000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1533, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conditionalSelectionShare\": 0.05", + "sourceParagraph": 1534, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1535, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 1536, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1537, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1538, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 1539, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1540, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supplementaryPanels\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1541, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countrySentinel\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1542, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetValid\": 3,", + "sourceParagraph": 1543, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedCountries\": [\"SYN-H\", \"SYN-I\", \"SYN-J\"],", + "sourceParagraph": 1544, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryScoresFromSingleObservationAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1545, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedInPopulationEstimateWithFullSentinelWeight\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1546, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1547, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageFairness\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1548, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetValid\": 50,", + "sourceParagraph": 1549, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"oversampledLanguage\": \"SYN-LANG-Y\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1550, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reweightToPopulation\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1551, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1552, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accessibility\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1553, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetValid\": 40,", + "sourceParagraph": 1554, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"separateDiagnosticReporting\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1555, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1556, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1557, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fieldwork\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1558, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"expectedCompletionRate\": 0.82,", + "sourceParagraph": 1559, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"expectedProtocolValidityRate\": 0.92,", + "sourceParagraph": 1560, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"plannedInvitationsMainPanel\": 1326,", + "sourceParagraph": 1561, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reserveListsPreselected\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1562, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseContentMayTriggerReplacement\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1563, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validityReviewBeforeSemanticScoring\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1564, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1565, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"weights\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1566, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"baseDesignWeight\": \"INVERSE_SELECTION_PROBABILITY\",\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1567, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nonresponseAdjustment\": \"ПРЕДОПРЕДЕЛЕННЫЕ_КЛАССЫ_ОТВЕТОВ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1568, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"калибровка\": \"ИТОГИ_ПО_СТРАНАМ_И_ЯЗЫКАМ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1569, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"обрезка\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1570, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"включено\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1571, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ifEnabledRequiresNewAnalysisVersion\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1572, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1573, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"effectiveSampleSizeRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1574, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1575, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonFrames\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1576, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nativeReachAllocation\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1577, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"commonSupportAllocation\": \"ТРЕБУЕТСЯ_ОТДЕЛЬНАЯ_ЗАПИСЬ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1578, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1579, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"управление\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1580, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"allocationApprovedBeforeResponses\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1581, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountableHumanRole\": \"ВЛАДЕЛЕЦ_ДИЗАЙНА_ОБРАЗЦА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1582, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-08-18 T0 9:00:00 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1583, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"resultDrivenChangesProhibited\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1584, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1585, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1586, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1587, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Эта запись:", + "sourceParagraph": 1588, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Это не фактические данные о продукте или стране,", + "sourceParagraph": 1589, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Это не фактический план выборки.", + "sourceParagraph": 1590, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Это синтетическое представление воспроизводимой структуры распределения.", + "sourceParagraph": 1591, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "МАШИНОЧИТАЕМОЕ ПРАВИЛО РАЗДЕЛА 59", + "sourceParagraph": 1593, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH06-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1594, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Для каждого продукта ИИ и основной волны измерений, GEO-1000", + "sourceParagraph": 1596, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Панель населения ДОЛЖНА нацеливаться как минимум на 1,000 действительных наблюдений продукта", + "sourceParagraph": 1597, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "если явно не обоснована другая цель.", + "sourceParagraph": 1598, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Распределение образцов ДОЛЖНО быть разработано, версионировано и зафиксировано до использования ИИ", + "sourceParagraph": 1600, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "наблюдаются ответы.", + "sourceParagraph": 1601, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Перв��чное распределение ДОЛЖНО основываться на целевой популяции, имеющей право на продукт,", + "sourceParagraph": 1603, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "не сырая численность населения, количество приглашений, аккаунтов, сессий или", + "sourceParagraph": 1604, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "доступность удобства.", + "sourceParagraph": 1605, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Дробные распределения ДОЛЖНЫ быть преобразованы в целочисленные квоты с использованием", + "sourceParagraph": 1607, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "предварительно объявленный, воспроизводимый, метод, не зависящий от результатов.", + "sourceParagraph": 1608, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Популяции с положительной массой НЕЛЬЗЯ детерминированно назначать вероятность выбора равной нулю", + "sourceParagraph": 1610, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "при аудите, когда делается вывод о всей целевой", + "sourceParagraph": 1611, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "популяции. Малые популяции МОГУТ быть представлены через обоснованно объединённые", + "sourceParagraph": 1612, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "страты и выборку с вероятностью пропорциональной размеру.", + "sourceParagraph": 1613, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Наблюдения стран, равноправия в языке и доступности МОГУТ", + "sourceParagraph": 1615, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "дополнять основную панель, но ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельно маркированными и", + "sourceParagraph": 1616, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "соответственно перераспределёнными.", + "sourceParagraph": 1617, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Переизмеренные группы НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ получать свою исходную долю выборки в качестве веса", + "sourceParagraph": 1619, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "популяции.", + "sourceParagraph": 1620, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Замена участников ДОЛЖНА основываться только на заранее объявленных условиях набора или", + "sourceParagraph": 1622, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "условиях допустимости протокола. Некорректные, отрицательные, отклонённые или критические выводы ИИ", + "sourceParagraph": 1623, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ вызывать замену.", + "sourceParagraph": 1624, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Лица, аккаунты, сессии, языки и наблюдения за продуктами ИИ ДОЛЖНЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 1626, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "оставаться отдельными единицами.", + "sourceParagraph": 1627, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Должны быть задокументированы проектные веса, корректировки при отсутствии ответа, калибровка, усечение, кластеризация,", + "sourceParagraph": 1629, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "парные наблюдения и эффективный размер выборки.", + "sourceParagraph": 1630, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Любое изменение квот, страт, пулов, весов, исключений или", + "sourceParagraph": 1632, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "целей выборки после получения результатов ДОЛЖНО создавать новую версию анализа и сохранять оригинал.", + "sourceParagraph": 1633, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "запись.", + "sourceParagraph": 1634, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 1635, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH06-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Для каждого продукта ИИ и основной волны измерений панель населения GEO-1000 должна нацеливаться как минимум на 1,000 действительных наблюдений продукта, если явно не обоснована иная цель. Распределение выборки должно быть разработано, утверждено и закреплено до того, как будут видны ответы ИИ. Основное распределение должно основываться на целевой человеческой популяции, подходящей для продукта, а не на общей численности населения страны, числе приглашений, аккаунтов, сеансов или выборках по удобству. Дробные квоты должны объявляться заранее и округляться до целых чисел с использованием метода, независимого от результатов. Группы с положительной численностью населения не могут быть назначены детерминированной вероятностью нуля при выборке для вывода для всей целевой популяции. Группы, выборка которых была избыточной, не могут использовать доли чистой выборки в качестве весов населения. Некорректные, отрицательные, отклоненные или критические результаты ИИ не могут быть причиной замены участника.", + "sourceParagraph": 1636, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 7, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH07", + "title": "Панели странового наблюдения и языковой справедливости", + "subtitle": null, + "sourceIds": [ + "K04", + "K06", + "K07", + "K20" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH07-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "The GEO-1000 Population Panel, Country Observer Panel, and Language Fairness Panel MUST remain distinct in purpose, sampling, weighting, and public claims. A Country Observer observation MAY establish that an access condition, response, anomaly, or critical incident occurred in a defined country-product-language context. A Country Observer observation MUST NOT be represented as a country prevalence estimate or country GEO score. Country observation coverage, population-weighted observation coverage, and country estimation coverage MUST be reported separately. Every eligible country SHOULD receive a positive probability of observation within a predeclared surveillance cycle, unless it is explicitly outside the product's lawful Native Reach. Language fairness MUST evaluate materially comparable representation under semantically equivalent prompts and comparable contexts. It MUST NOT require word-for-word identical responses or ignore legitimate local differences. Oversampled languages MUST be reweighted to their target population shares for global population estimates. Population-weighted scores, equal-language diagnostic scores, language floors, critical-error rates, unknown rates, and untested languages MUST remain separately visible. A language disparity MUST NOT be attributed solely to the AI product before prompt equivalence, reference parity, measurement parity, and adjudication parity are assessed. A single observation MAY carry multiple diagnostic panel tags, but MUST NOT receive duplicate full population weight. Critical Observer incidents MAY trigger confirmatory sampling and conformity review without being treated as evidence of country prevalence.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "GEO-1000 Population Panel, Ülke Gözcü Paneli ve Dil Adaleti Paneli amaç, örneklem, ağırlık ve kamu iddiası bakımından ayrı tutulmalıdır. Tek bir ülke gözcü gözlemi belirli ülke–ürün–dil bağlamında bir erişim durumunun, cevabın, anomalinin veya Critical olayın meydana geldiğini gösterebilir; ülke yaygınlık tahmini veya ülke GEO skoru olarak sunulamaz. Ülke sayısı kapsamı, nüfus ağırlıklı kapsam ve ülke tahmin kapsamı ayrı raporlanmalıdır. Dil adaleti, semantik olarak eşdeğer promptlarda ve karşılaştırılabilir koşullarda maddi temsili değerlendirmeli; kelime kelime aynı cevap istememeli ve meşru yerel farkları yok saymamalıdır. Fazla örneklenen diller global nüfus tahmininde gerçek hedef nüfus paylarına geri ağırlıklandırılmalıdır.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "47. MACHINE-READABLE PANEL RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 1460 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 1461 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1462 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SF-3\": 17", + "sourceParagraph": 1463 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1464 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"metrics\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1465 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryObservationCoverageCount\": 0.3167,", + "sourceParagraph": 1466 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryObservationCoveragePopulation\": 0.97,", + "sourceParagraph": 1467 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryEstimationCoverage\": 0.1167", + "sourceParagraph": 1468 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1469 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sentinelObservationsCreateCountryScores\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1470 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"alarms\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1471 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1472 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-J\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1473 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"alarmType\": \"SA-5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1474 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"CONFIRMATORY_SAMPLE_REQUIRED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1475 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryPrevalenceClaimAllowed\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1476 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1477 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 1478 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1479 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageFairness\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1480 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageRegistryVersion\": \"LF-SYNTH-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1481 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"inScopeLanguages\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1482 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1483 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1484 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1485 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.55,", + "sourceParagraph": 1486 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 550,", + "sourceParagraph": 1487 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1488 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.95", + "sourceParagraph": 1489 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1490 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1491 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1492 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1493 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.25,", + "sourceParagraph": 1494 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 250,", + "sourceParagraph": 1495 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1496 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.92", + "sourceParagraph": 1497 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1498 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1499 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1500 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1501 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.10,", + "sourceParagraph": 1502 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 100,", + "sourceParagraph": 1503 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1504 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.88", + "sourceParagraph": 1505 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1506 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1507 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1508 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1509 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.06,", + "sourceParagraph": 1510 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 60,", + "sourceParagraph": 1511 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 140,", + "sourceParagraph": 1512 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.65,", + "sourceParagraph": 1513 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptEquivalence\": \"PASSED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1514 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"referenceParity\": \"PASSED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1515 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationParity\": \"PASSED\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1516 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1517 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1518 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1519 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1520 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.04,", + "sourceParagraph": 1521 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 40,", + "sourceParagraph": 1522 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 160,", + "sourceParagraph": 1523 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.58,", + "sourceParagraph": 1524 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptEquivalence\": \"PASSED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1525 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"referenceParity\": \"PASSED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1526 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationParity\": \"PASSED\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1527 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1528 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1529 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"globalPopulationWeightedScore\": 0.9027,", + "sourceParagraph": 1530 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"equalLanguageDiagnosticScore\": 0.796,", + "sourceParagraph": 1531 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageFloor\": 0.58,", + "sourceParagraph": 1532 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"maxLanguageGap\": 0.37,", + "sourceParagraph": 1533 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"oversamplesReweightedToPopulation\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1534 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"allLanguagesClaimAllowed\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1535 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1536 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governance\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1537 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelRolesKeptSeparate\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1538 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"duplicateFullWeightingProhibited\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1539 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountableHumanRole\": \"COUNTRY_LANGUAGE_PANEL_OWNER\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1540 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-08-18T09:00:00Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1541 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1542 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1543 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1544 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "This record:", + "sourceParagraph": 1545 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "this is not real country or language data,", + "sourceParagraph": 1546 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "this is not actual AI performance,", + "sourceParagraph": 1547 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "it is a machine-readable synthetic representation of the panel distinction.", + "sourceParagraph": 1548 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF SECTION 48", + "sourceParagraph": 1550 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH07-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1551 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The GEO-1000 Population Panel, Country Observer Panel, and Language", + "sourceParagraph": 1553 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Fairness Panel MUST remain distinct in purpose, sampling, weighting, and", + "sourceParagraph": 1554 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "public claims.", + "sourceParagraph": 1555 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A Country Observer observation MAY establish that an access condition,", + "sourceParagraph": 1557 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "response, anomaly, or critical incident occurred in a defined", + "sourceParagraph": 1558 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "country-product-language context.", + "sourceParagraph": 1559 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A Country Observer observation MUST NOT be represented as a country prevalence", + "sourceParagraph": 1561 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "estimate or country GEO score.", + "sourceParagraph": 1562 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Country observation coverage, population-weighted observation coverage,", + "sourceParagraph": 1564 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "and country estimation coverage MUST be reported separately.", + "sourceParagraph": 1565 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every eligible country SHOULD receive a positive probability of", + "sourceParagraph": 1567 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "observation within a predeclared surveillance cycle, unless it is", + "sourceParagraph": 1568 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "explicitly outside the product's lawful Native Reach.", + "sourceParagraph": 1569 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Language fairness MUST evaluate materially comparable representation", + "sourceParagraph": 1571 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "under semantically equivalent prompts and comparable contexts. It MUST", + "sourceParagraph": 1572 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOT require word-for-word identical responses or ignore legitimate local", + "sourceParagraph": 1573 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "differences.", + "sourceParagraph": 1574 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Oversampled languages MUST be reweighted to their target population", + "sourceParagraph": 1576 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "shares for global population estimates.", + "sourceParagraph": 1577 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Population-weighted scores, equal-language diagnostic scores, language", + "sourceParagraph": 1579 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "floors, critical-error rates, unknown rates, and untested languages MUST", + "sourceParagraph": 1580 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "remain separately visible.", + "sourceParagraph": 1581 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A language disparity MUST NOT be attributed solely to the AI product", + "sourceParagraph": 1583 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "before prompt equivalence, reference parity, measurement parity, and", + "sourceParagraph": 1584 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "adjudication parity are assessed.", + "sourceParagraph": 1585 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A single observation MAY carry multiple diagnostic panel tags, but MUST", + "sourceParagraph": 1587 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOT receive duplicate full population weight.", + "sourceParagraph": 1588 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Critical Observer incidents MAY trigger confirmatory sampling and", + "sourceParagraph": 1590 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "conformity review without being treated as evidence of country", + "sourceParagraph": 1591 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "prevalence.", + "sourceParagraph": 1592 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 1593 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "GEO-1000 Population Panel, Country Observer Panel, and Language Fairness Panel should be kept separate in terms of purpose, sample, weighting, and public claim. A single Country Observer observation can show that a certain access condition, response, anomaly, or critical event has occurred in a specific country–product–language context; it cannot be presented as a country prevalence estimate or country GEO score. Country coverage, population-weighted coverage, and country estimate coverage should be reported separately. Language fairness should assess material representation in semantically equivalent prompts and comparable conditions; it should not demand word-for-word identical responses and should not ignore legitimate local differences. Over-sampled languages should be reweighted to reflect the actual target population shares in global population estimates.", + "sourceParagraph": 1594 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Панели населения GEO-1000, Панель наблюдателей стран и Панель языковой справедливости ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться различными по назначению, выборке, взвешиванию и публичным заявлениям. Наблюдение за страной МОЖЕТ установить, что условие доступа, ответ, аномалия или критический инцидент произошли в определенном контексте страна-продукт-язык. Наблюдение за страной НЕ ДОЛЖНО представляться как оценка распространенности в стране или как GEO-балл страны. Покрытие наблюдения за страной, покрытие наблюдений с учетом веса населения и оценка охвата страны ДОЛЖНЫ сообщаться отдельно. Каждая подходящая страна ДОЛЖНА получать ненулевую вероятность включения в наблюдение в рамках заранее объявленного цикла контроля, если она явно не находится за пределами правомерного естественного охвата продукта. Справедливость языка ДОЛЖНА оценивать материально сопоставимое представление при семантически эквивалентных запросах и сопоставимых контекстах. Она НЕ ДОЛЖНА требовать дословно идентичные ответы или игнорировать законные местные различия. Языки с чрезмерной выборкой ДОЛЖНЫ быть перевзвешены в соответствии с их долями в целевой популяции для оценки мировой численности населения. Оценки с учетом численности населения, диагностические оценки по равным языкам, минимальные показатели языков, показатели критических ошибок, показатели неизвестных и непроверенных языков ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельно видимыми. Языковое расхождение НЕ ДОЛЖНО приписываться исключительно продукту ИИ до оценки эквивалентности промптов, равенства справочных данных, равенства измерений и равенства оценивания. Одно наблюдение МОЖЕТ иметь несколько диагностических тегов панели, но НЕ ДОЛЖНО получать дублированный вес всей популяции. Инциденты критического наблюдателя МОГУТ вызвать подтверждающую выборку и проверку соответствия без учета их в качестве доказательства распространенности в стране.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "47. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ ЗАПИСЬ ПАНЕЛИ", + "sourceParagraph": 1460, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 1461, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1462, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SF-3\": 17", + "sourceParagraph": 1463, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1464, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"metrics\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1465, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryObservationCoverageCount\": 0.316 7,", + "sourceParagraph": 1466, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryObservationCoveragePopulation\": 0.97,", + "sourceParagraph": 1467, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryEstimationCoverage\": 0.116 7", + "sourceParagraph": 1468, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1469, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sentinelObservationsCreateCountryScores\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1470, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"alarms\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1471, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1472, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-J\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1473, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"alarmType\": \"SA-5\",\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1474, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"ТРЕБУЕТСЯ_ПОДТВЕРЖДАЮЩИЙ_ОБРАЗЕЦ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1475, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryPrevalenceClaimAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1476, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1477, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 1478, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1479, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageFairness\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1480, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageRegistryVersion\": \"LF-SYNTH-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1481, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"inScopeLanguages\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1482, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1483, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1484, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1485, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.55,", + "sourceParagraph": 1486, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 550,", + "sourceParagraph": 1487, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1488, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.95", + "sourceParagraph": 1489, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1490, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1491, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1492, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1493, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.25,", + "sourceParagraph": 1494, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 250,", + "sourceParagraph": 1495, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1496, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.92", + "sourceParagraph": 1497, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1498, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1499, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1500, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1501, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.10,", + "sourceParagraph": 1502, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 100,", + "sourceParagraph": 1503, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1504, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.88", + "sourceParagraph": 1505, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1506, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1507, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1508, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1509, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.06,", + "sourceParagraph": 1510, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 60,", + "sourceParagraph": 1511, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 140,", + "sourceParagraph": 1512, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.65,", + "sourceParagraph": 1513, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptEquivalence\": \"ПРОЙДЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1514, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"referenceParity\": \"ПРОЙДЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1515, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationParity\": \"ПРОЙДЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1516, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1517, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1518, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1519, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1520, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.04,", + "sourceParagraph": 1521, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 40,", + "sourceParagraph": 1522, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 160,", + "sourceParagraph": 1523, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.58,", + "sourceParagraph": 1524, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptEquivalence\": \"ПРОЙДЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1525, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"referenceParity\": \"ПРОЙДЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1526, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationParity\": \"ПРОЙДЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1527, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1528, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1529, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"globalPopulationWeightedScore\": 0.902 7,", + "sourceParagraph": 1530, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"equalLanguageDiagnosticScore\": 0.796,", + "sourceParagraph": 1531, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageFloor\": 0.58,", + "sourceParagraph": 1532, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"maxLanguageGap\": 0.37,", + "sourceParagraph": 1533, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"oversamplesReweightedToPopulation\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1534, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"allLanguagesClaimAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1535, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1536, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"управление\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1537, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelRolesKeptSeparate\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1538, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"duplicateFullWeightingProhibited\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1539, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountableHumanRole\": \"ВЛАДЕЛЕЦ ЯЗЫКОВОЙ ПАНЕЛИ СТРАНЫ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1540, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-08-18 T0 9:00:00 Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1541, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1542, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1543, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1544, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Эта запись:", + "sourceParagraph": 1545, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "это не реальные данные о странах или языках,", + "sourceParagraph": 1546, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "это не фактическая работа ИИ,", + "sourceParagraph": 1547, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "это машинно-читаемое синтетическое представление различий панели.", + "sourceParagraph": 1548, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "МАШИНОЧИТАЕМОЕ ПРАВИЛО РАЗДЕЛА 48", + "sourceParagraph": 1550, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH07-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1551, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Панель населения GEO-1000, Панель наблюдателей стран и Языковая", + "sourceParagraph": 1553, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Панель справедливости ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться различными по цели, выборке, взвешиванию и", + "sourceParagraph": 1554, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "общественным заявлениям.", + "sourceParagraph": 1555, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Наблюдение страны-наблюдателя МОЖЕТ установить, что условие доступа,", + "sourceParagraph": 1557, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ответ, аномалия или критическое происшествие произошло в определенной", + "sourceParagraph": 1558, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "контекст страна-продукт-язык.", + "sourceParagraph": 1559, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Наблюдение Country Observer НЕ ДОЛЖНО представляться как распространенность в стране", + "sourceParagraph": 1561, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "оценка или GEO-балл страны.", + "sourceParagraph": 1562, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Покрытие наблюдений страны, покрытие наблюдений с учетом численности населения,", + "sourceParagraph": 1564, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "и покрытие оценки страны ДОЛЖНЫ быть представлены отдельно.", + "sourceParagraph": 1565, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждая соответствующая страна ДОЛЖНА получать положительную вероятность", + "sourceParagraph": 1567, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "наблюдения в рамках заранее объявленного цикла наблюдения, если только она", + "sourceParagraph": 1568, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "не находится явно за пределами законного Естественный охват продукта.", + "sourceParagraph": 1569, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Языковая справедливость ДОЛЖНА оценивать материально сопоставимое представление", + "sourceParagraph": 1571, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "при семантически эквивалентных запросах и сопоставимых контекстах. Это ДОЛЖНО", + "sourceParagraph": 1572, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "НЕ требует дословно одинаковых ответов или игнорирует законные местные", + "sourceParagraph": 1573, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "различия.", + "sourceParagraph": 1574, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Языки с избыточной выборкой ДОЛЖНЫ быть взвешены в соответствии с их целевой популяцией", + "sourceParagraph": 1576, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "доли для глобальных оценок населения.", + "sourceParagraph": 1577, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Оценки с учетом численности населения, диагностические оценки с равным весом для языков, язык", + "sourceParagraph": 1579, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "этажи, показатели критических ошибок, неизвестные показатели и нетестированные языки ДОЛЖНЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 1580, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "оставаться видимыми отдельно.", + "sourceParagraph": 1581, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Языковое различие НЕ ДОЛЖНО приписываться исключительно продукту ИИ", + "sourceParagraph": 1583, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "до того как оцениваются эквивалентность промпта, паритет ссылки, паритет измерений и", + "sourceParagraph": 1584, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "паритет вынесения решений.", + "sourceParagraph": 1585, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Один наблюдаемый случай МОЖЕТ иметь несколько тегов диагностической панели, но ДОЛЖЕН", + "sourceParagraph": 1587, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "НЕ получать дублирующий полный вес популяции.", + "sourceParagraph": 1588, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Инциденты с Критическим Наблюдателем МОГУТ вызвать подтверждающую выборку и", + "sourceParagraph": 1590, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "проверку соответствия без того, чтобы рассматриваться как доказательство распространенности в стране.", + "sourceParagraph": 1591, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "", + "sourceParagraph": 1592, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 1593, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH07-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Панели GEO-1000 Population, Country Observer и Language Fairness должны оставаться отдельными по цели, выборке, взвешиванию и публичным утверждениям. Одно наблюдение Country Observer может показать, что определённое условие доступа, ответ, аномалия или критическое событие произошло в конкретном контексте страна–продукт–язык; оно не может представляться как оценка распространённости по стране или как GEO-оценка страны. Покрытие стран, покрытие с учётом населения и покрытие оценки по стране следует сообщать отдельно. Справедливость языка должна оценивать представление материала в семантически эквивалентных промптах и сопоставимых условиях; она не должна требовать дословно одинаковых ответов и не должна игнорировать законные локальные различия. Языки с избыточной выборкой должны быть скорректированы с учетом фактической доли целевого населения в глобальных оценках населения.", + "sourceParagraph": 1594, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 8, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH08", + "title": "Отбор и взвешивание участников и смещение выборки", + "subtitle": null, + "sourceIds": [ + "K04", + "K05", + "K06", + "K07", + "K08", + "K22" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH08-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "Every GEO-1000 observation MUST retain an auditable participant-selection path from the target population and sampling frame through selection, invitation, consent, assignment, completion, protocol validation, exclusion, and final weighting. Within-panel random selection MUST NOT be represented as random selection from the global target population unless the full population inclusion mechanism supports that claim. Participant recruitment, assignment, compensation, validation, replacement, exclusion, and weighting MUST remain independent of whether the AI response is positive, negative, correct, incorrect, refused, critical, or commercially favourable. Persons, accounts, devices, sessions, languages, panel memberships, and AI-product observations MUST remain distinct units. Probability, opt-in, open-call, client-supplied, institutional, and hybrid participant sources MUST be separately identified. Weighting MAY reduce observed imbalance, but MUST NOT be represented as creating observations for populations absent from the sampling frame or correcting unmeasured selection with certainty. Unweighted results, weighted results, weight diagnostics, coverage gaps, nonresponse, effective sample size, and sensitivity analyses MUST remain visible. Fraud and duplication decisions MUST use proportionate multi-signal review and MUST NOT automatically treat VPN use, shared devices, institutional networks, or accessibility tools as fabrication. Participant evidence MUST remain verifiable without unnecessarily disclosing identity, account credentials, private conversations, or precise location. Every participant-selection and weighting decision MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Her GEO-1000 gözlemi hedef nüfus ve örnekleme çerçevesinden seçim, davet, rıza, görev ataması, tamamlama, protokol doğrulaması, dışlama ve nihai ağırlığa kadar denetlenebilir katılımcı seçim yolu taşımalıdır. Panel içindeki rastgele seçim, tam nüfus katılım mekanizması bunu desteklemedikçe küresel hedef nüfustan rastgele seçim olarak sunulamaz. Katılımcının seçilmesi, ödüllendirilmesi, doğrulanması, değiştirilmesi, dışlanması ve ağırlıklandırılması AI cevabının olumlu, olumsuz, doğru, yanlış, ret, Critical veya ticari bakımdan elverişli olmasına bağlı olamaz. Ağırlıklandırma gözlenen dengesizliği azaltabilir; örnekleme çerçevesinde hiç bulunmayan insanları gözlenmiş hâle getiremez.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "57. MACHINE-READABLE PARTICIPANT RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 1804 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 1805 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1806 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adultBaseline\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1807 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"consentStatus\": \"GRANTED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1808 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"country\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1809 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"residenceCountry\": \"TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1810 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"measurementCountry\": \"TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1811 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verificationLevel\": \"GV-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1812 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"vpnStatus\": \"NOT_DETECTED\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1813 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1814 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"language\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1815 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"assignedLanguage\": \"tr\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1816 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1817 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"competenceStatus\": \"VERIFIED_FUNCTIONAL\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1818 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1819 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiAccess\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1820 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productId\": \"SYNTH-ORION-WEB\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1821 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"plan\": \"free\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1822 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"surface\": \"web\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1823 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accessVerified\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1824 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sharedAccount\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1825 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1826 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1827 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relationships\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1828 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"auditedEntityRelationship\": \"GENERAL_PUBLIC\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1829 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProviderRelationship\": \"NONE_DECLARED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1830 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"brandFamiliarity\": \"AWARE_NON_CUSTOMER\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1831 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiUsageFrequency\": \"OCCASIONAL\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1832 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1833 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"assignment\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1834 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1835 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"stratumId\": \"TR-TR-FREE-WEB\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1836 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productAssignmentMethod\": \"BLOCK_RANDOMIZED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1837 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptId\": \"CORE-IDENTITY-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1838 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptOrder\": 1,", + "sourceParagraph": 1839 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"priorBenchmarkExposure\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1840 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1841 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"incentive\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1842 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"type\": \"FIXED_COMPLETION_PAYMENT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1843 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseContentDependent\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1844 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"speedBonus\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1845 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1846 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"completion\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1847 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"invited\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1848 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"consented\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1849 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"started\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1850 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"completed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1851 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolValidity\": \"VALID\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1852 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"semanticOutcomeUsedForValidityDecision\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1853 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1854 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1855 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fraudStatus\": \"FI-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1856 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"duplicateCheck\": \"PASSED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1857 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"crossProviderDuplicateCheck\": \"PASSED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1858 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"humanReviewRequired\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1859 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1860 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"weights\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1861 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"baseWeightType\": \"MODEL_CALIBRATION_WEIGHT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1862 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"designProbabilityKnown\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1863 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nonresponseAdjustment\": 1.08,", + "sourceParagraph": 1864 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"calibrationAdjustment\": 1.24,", + "sourceParagraph": 1865 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"finalWeight\": 1.3392,", + "sourceParagraph": 1866 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"outcomeUsedInWeighting\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1867 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1868 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"privacy\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1869 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicIdentityDisclosure\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1870 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"screenshotRedactionRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1871 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicEvidenceManifest\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1872 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rawEvidenceAccess\": \"CONTROLLED_AUDIT_ACCESS\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1873 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1874 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1875 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"selectionOwnerRole\": \"PARTICIPANT_SELECTION_LEAD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1876 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validityReviewerRole\": \"BLINDED_PROTOCOL_VALIDATOR\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1877 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1878 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1879 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1880 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "This record:", + "sourceParagraph": 1881 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "It does not belong to a real participant,", + "sourceParagraph": 1882 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "It is not real panel data,", + "sourceParagraph": 1883 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "It is a synthetic machine diagram of the participant selection chain.", + "sourceParagraph": 1884 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Chapter 58 machine-readable rule", + "sourceParagraph": 1886 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH08-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1887 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every GEO-1000 observation MUST retain an auditable participant-selection", + "sourceParagraph": 1889 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "path from the target population and sampling frame through selection,", + "sourceParagraph": 1890 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "invitation, consent, assignment, completion, protocol validation,", + "sourceParagraph": 1891 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "exclusion, and final weighting.", + "sourceParagraph": 1892 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Within-panel random selection MUST NOT be represented as random selection", + "sourceParagraph": 1894 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "from the global target population unless the full population inclusion", + "sourceParagraph": 1895 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "mechanism supports that claim.", + "sourceParagraph": 1896 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Participant recruitment, assignment, compensation, validation,", + "sourceParagraph": 1898 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "replacement, exclusion, and weighting MUST remain independent of whether", + "sourceParagraph": 1899 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "the AI response is positive, negative, correct, incorrect, refused,", + "sourceParagraph": 1900 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "critical, or commercially favourable.", + "sourceParagraph": 1901 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Persons, accounts, devices, sessions, languages, panel memberships, and", + "sourceParagraph": 1903 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "AI-product observations MUST remain distinct units.", + "sourceParagraph": 1904 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Probability, opt-in, open-call, client-supplied, institutional, and hybrid", + "sourceParagraph": 1906 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "participant sources MUST be separately identified.", + "sourceParagraph": 1907 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Weighting MAY reduce observed imbalance, but MUST NOT be represented as", + "sourceParagraph": 1909 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "creating observations for populations absent from the sampling frame or", + "sourceParagraph": 1910 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "correcting unmeasured selection with certainty.", + "sourceParagraph": 1911 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Unweighted results, weighted results, weight diagnostics, coverage gaps,", + "sourceParagraph": 1913 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "nonresponse, effective sample size, and sensitivity analyses MUST remain", + "sourceParagraph": 1914 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "visible.", + "sourceParagraph": 1915 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Fraud and duplication decisions MUST use proportionate multi-signal", + "sourceParagraph": 1917 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "review and MUST NOT automatically treat VPN use, shared devices,", + "sourceParagraph": 1918 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "institutional networks, or accessibility tools as fabrication.", + "sourceParagraph": 1919 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Participant evidence MUST remain verifiable without unnecessarily", + "sourceParagraph": 1921 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "disclosing identity, account credentials, private conversations, or", + "sourceParagraph": 1922 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "precise location.", + "sourceParagraph": 1923 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every participant-selection and weighting decision MUST be versioned and", + "sourceParagraph": 1925 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "sourceParagraph": 1926 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 1927 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every GEO-1000 observation must carry a verifiable participant selection path from target population and sampling frame through selection, invitation, consent, assignment, completion, protocol verification, exclusion, and final weighting. Random selection within the panel cannot be presented as random selection from the global target population unless the full population participation mechanism supports it. The participant's selection, reward, verification, modification, exclusion, and weighting cannot depend on whether the AI response is positive, negative, correct, incorrect, rejected, Critical, or commercially viable. Weighting can reduce observed imbalance; it cannot make people who are completely absent from the sampling frame appear observed.", + "sourceParagraph": 1928 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Каждое наблюдение GEO-1000 ДОЛЖНО сохранять поддающийся аудиту путь выбора участников от целевой популяции и выборки до этапов отбора, приглашения, согласия, распределения, завершения, проверки протокола, исключения и окончательного взвешивания. Случайный отбор внутри панели НЕ ДОЛЖЕН представляться как случайный отбор из глобальной целевой популяции, если механизм включения всей популяции не поддерживает это утверждение. Набор участников, распределение, компенсация, проверка, замена, исключение и взвешивание ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться независимыми от того, является ли ответ ИИ положительным, отрицательным, правильным, неправильным, отклонённым, критическим или коммерчески благоприятным. Лица, аккаунты, устройства, сессии, языки, членства в панелях и наблюдения за продуктами ИИ ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельными единицами. Источники участников с вероятностью участия, с добровольным присоединением, с открытым приглашением, предоставленные клиентом, институциональные и гибридные ДОЛЖНЫ быть идентифицированы отдельно. Взвешивание МОЖЕТ уменьшать наблюдаемый дисбаланс, но НЕ ДОЛЖНО представляться как создание наблюдений для популяций, отсутствующих в выборочной рамке, или как исправление неизмеренного отбора с уверенностью. Невзвешенные результаты, взвешенные результаты, диагностика весов, пропуски покрытия, неответы, эффективный размер выборки и анализ чувствительности ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться видимыми. Решения о мошенничестве и дублировании ДОЛЖНЫ использовать пропорциональный обзор с несколькими сигналами и НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ автоматически рассматривать использование VPN, совместные устройства, корпоративные сети или средства доступности как подделку. Доказательства участников ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться проверяемыми без излишнего раскрытия личности, учетных данных, частных разговоров или точного местоположения. Каждое решение о выборе участников и взвешивании ДОЛЖНО иметь версию и быть приписано ответственному человеку или организации.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "57. МАШИННО-ЧИТАЕМЫЙ РЕГИСТР УЧАСТНИКА", + "sourceParagraph": 1804, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 1805, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1806, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adultBaseline\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1807, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"consentStatus\": \"РАЗРЕШЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1808, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"country\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1809, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"residenceCountry\": \"TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1810, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"measurementCountry\": \"TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1811, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verificationLevel\": \"GV-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1812, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"vpnStatus\": \"НЕ ОБНАРУЖЕНО\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1813, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1814, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"language\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1815, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"assignedLanguage\": \"tr\",\"}", + "sourceParagraph": 1816, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1817, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"competenceStatus\": \"ПОДТВЕРЖДЕННО ФУНКЦИОНАЛЬНО\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1818, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1819, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiAccess\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1820, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productId\": \"SYNTH-ORION-WEB\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1821, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"plan\": \"бесплатно\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1822, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"surface\": \"веб\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1823, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accessVerified\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1824, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sharedAccount\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1825, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1826, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1827, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relationships\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1828, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"auditedEntityRelationship\": \"ОБЩЕСТВЕННОСТЬ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1829, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProviderRelationship\": \"НЕ УКАЗАНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1830, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"brandFamiliarity\": \"ОСОЗНАЮЩИЙ НЕ-КЛИЕНТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1831, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiUsageFrequency\": \"СЛУЧАЙНЫЙ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1832, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1833, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"assignment\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1834, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1835, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"stratumId\": \"TR-TR-БЕСПЛАТНО-ВЕБ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1836, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productAssignmentMethod\": \"БЛОК_СЛУЧАЙНЫЙ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1837, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptId\": \"CORE-IDENTITY-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1838, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptOrder\": 1,", + "sourceParagraph": 1839, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"priorBenchmarkExposure\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1840, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1841, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"incentive\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1842, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"type\": \"ФИКСИРОВАННАЯ_ОПЛАТА_ЗА_ВЫПОЛНЕНИЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1843, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseContentDependent\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1844, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"speedBonus\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1845, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1846, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"completion\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1847, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"invited\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1848, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"consented\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1849, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"started\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1850, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"completed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1851, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolValidity\": \"ДЕЙСТВИТЕЛЬНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1852, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"semanticOutcomeUsedForValidityDecision\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1853, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1854, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1855, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fraudStatus\": \"FI-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1856, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"duplicateCheck\": \"ПРОЙДЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1857, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"crossProviderDuplicateCheck\": \"ПРОЙДЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1858, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"humanReviewRequired\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1859, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1860, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"weights\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1861, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"baseWeightType\": \"ВЕС_КАЛИБРОВКИ_МОДЕЛИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1862, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"designProbabilityKnown\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1863, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nonresponseAdjustment\": 1.08,", + "sourceParagraph": 1864, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"calibrationAdjustment\": 1.24,", + "sourceParagraph": 1865, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"finalWeight\": 1.339 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 1866, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"outcomeUsedInWeighting\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1867, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1868, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"privacy\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1869, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicIdentityDisclosure\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1870, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"screenshotRedactionRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1871, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicEvidenceManifest\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1872, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rawEvidenceAccess\": \"КОНТРОЛИРУЕМЫЙ_ДОСТУП_К_АУДИТУ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1873, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1874, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1875, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"selectionOwnerRole\": \"РУКОВОДИТЕЛЬ_ВЫБОРА_УЧАСТНИКА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1876, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validityReviewerRole\": \"ВАЛИДАТОР_ЗАСЕКРЕЧЕННОГО_ПРОТОКОЛА\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1877, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1878, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1879, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1880, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Эта запись:", + "sourceParagraph": 1881, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Он не принадлежит реальному участнику,", + "sourceParagraph": 1882, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Это не реальные данные панели,", + "sourceParagraph": 1883, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Это синтетическая машинная диаграмма цепочки выбора участника.", + "sourceParagraph": 1884, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Глава 58 правило, читаемое машиной", + "sourceParagraph": 1886, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH08-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1887, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждое наблюдение GEO-1000 ДОЛЖНО сохранять проверяемый путь выбора участника", + "sourceParagraph": 1889, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "от целевой популяции и выборочной рамки через отбор,", + "sourceParagraph": 1890, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "приглашение, согласие, назначение, завершение, проверку протокола,", + "sourceParagraph": 1891, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "исключение и окончательное взвешивание.", + "sourceParagraph": 1892, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Случайный выбор внутри панели НЕ ДОЛЖЕН представляться как случайный выбор", + "sourceParagraph": 1894, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "из глобальной целевой популяции, если механизм включения всей популяции", + "sourceParagraph": 1895, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "не поддерживает это утверждение.", + "sourceParagraph": 1896, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Набор участников, назначение, компенсация, проверка,", + "sourceParagraph": 1898, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "замена, исключение и ��звешивание ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться независимыми от того, является ли", + "sourceParagraph": 1899, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ответ ИИ положительным, отрицательным, правильным, неправильным, отказанным,", + "sourceParagraph": 1900, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "критическим или коммерчески выгодным.", + "sourceParagraph": 1901, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Лица, аккаунты, устройства, сессии, языки, членства в панелях и", + "sourceParagraph": 1903, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "наблюдения продукта ИИ ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельными единицами.", + "sourceParagraph": 1904, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Вероятностный, с согласия, открытый призыв, предоставленный клиентом, институциональный и гибридный", + "sourceParagraph": 1906, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "источники участников ДОЛЖНЫ быть указаны отдельно.", + "sourceParagraph": 1907, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Взвешивание МОЖЕТ уменьшать наблюдаемое несоответствие, но НЕ ДОЛЖНО представляться как", + "sourceParagraph": 1909, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "создание наблюдений для популяций, отсутствующих в выборочной рамке, или", + "sourceParagraph": 1910, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "корректировка неизмеренного отбора с уверенностью.", + "sourceParagraph": 1911, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Невзвешенные результаты, взвешенные результаты, диагностические показатели веса, пробелы охвата,", + "sourceParagraph": 1913, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "неотклик, эффективный объем выборки и анализ чувствительности ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться", + "sourceParagraph": 1914, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "видимыми.", + "sourceParagraph": 1915, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Решения о мошенничестве и дублировании ДОЛЖНЫ использовать пропорциональные многосигнальные", + "sourceParagraph": 1917, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "просматривать и НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ автоматически относить использование VPN, совместные устройства,", + "sourceParagraph": 1918, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "институциональные сети или средства доступности к фальсификации.", + "sourceParagraph": 1919, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Доказательства участников ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться проверяемыми без ненужного", + "sourceParagraph": 1921, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "раскрытия личности, учетных данных, частных разговоров или", + "sourceParagraph": 1922, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "точного местоположения.", + "sourceParagraph": 1923, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждое решение о выборе и взвешивании участников ДОЛЖНО иметь версию и", + "sourceParagraph": 1925, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "быть приписано ответственному человеку или организации.", + "sourceParagraph": 1926, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 1927, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH08-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждое наблюдение GEO-1000 должно сопровождаться проверяемым путем отбора участников от целевой популяции и рамок выборки через отбор, приглашение, согласие, назначение, завершение, проверку протокола, исключение и итоговое взвешивание. Случайный отбор внутри панели не может представляться как случайный отбор из глобальной целевой популяции, если полный механизм участия популяции этого не поддерживает. Отбор участника, вознаграждение, проверка, модификация, исключение и взвешивание не могут зависеть от того, является ли ответ ИИ положительным, отрицательным, верным, неверным, отклоненным, критическим или коммерчески целесообразным. Взвешивание может уменьшить наблюдаемый дисбаланс; оно не может сделать так, чтобы люди, полностью отсутствующие в выборочной рамке, выглядели наблюдаемыми.", + "sourceParagraph": 1928, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 9, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH09", + "title": "Реестр ИИ-систем и сопоставимость", + "subtitle": null, + "sourceIds": [ + "K02", + "K03" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH09-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "Every GEO-1000 observation MUST be linked to a versioned AI System Register record describing the measured product instance, including as applicable: - provider, - product, - user surface, - plan, - displayed or verified model identity, - model-identity confidence, - retrieval and web configuration, - citation capability and use, - tool access and use, - session state, - memory, - custom instructions, - prior context, - personalisation, - country, - locale, - language, - deployment state, - measurement time, - and known or observed system changes. Provider name, product name, displayed model label, base model, retrieval system, and user-facing product MUST NOT be treated as interchangeable identities. Feature availability MUST remain distinct from feature use. Live-product results MUST NOT be represented as frozen-model results, and frozen-model results MUST NOT be represented as full consumer-product experience. Comparisons MUST define their object and receive a disclosed comparability level based on matched entity, prompt, population, language, country, time, session, plan, interface, retrieval, tools, reference records, and adjudication rules. The same provider or displayed model MUST NOT create an automatic assumption of comparability. Different providers MAY be compared when user-facing conditions are sufficiently aligned and the resulting claim is limited to the measured product behaviour. Material product changes during a measurement wave MUST create a separate system state, sub-wave, modelled change factor, or mixed-state warning. Unknown configuration fields MUST remain UNKNOWN and MUST NOT be imputed as controlled or equivalent. Every system-registry and comparability decision MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Her GEO-1000 gözlemi; sağlayıcı, ürün, kullanıcı yüzeyi, plan, görünen veya doğrulanmış model kimliği, model kimliği güveni, retrieval ve web yapılandırması, citation kapasitesi ve kullanımı, araç erişimi, oturum durumu, hafıza, özel talimatlar, önceki bağlam, kişiselleştirme, ülke, locale, dil, dağıtım durumu, ölçüm zamanı ve bilinen sistem değişikliklerini ilgili olduğu ölçüde taşıyan sürümlü bir AI Sistem Sicili kaydına bağlanmalıdır. Sağlayıcı adı, ürün adı, görünen model etiketi, temel model, retrieval sistemi ve kullanıcı ürünü birbirinin yerine kullanılamaz. Aynı sağlayıcı veya model etiketi otomatik karşılaştırılabilirlik oluşturmaz. Farklı sağlayıcılar, kullanıcı koşulları yeterince eşleştirildiğinde ölçülen ürün davranışı bakımından karşılaştırılabilir.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "54. MACHINE-READABLE AI SYSTEM RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 1758 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 1759 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1760 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1761 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1762 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiSystemRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1763 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systemRecordId\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-FREE-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1764 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"provider\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1765 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"providerId\": \"SYNTH-ORION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1766 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"providerName\": \"Orion Systems\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1767 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1768 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"product\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1769 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productId\": \"SYNTH-ORION-CHAT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1770 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productName\": \"Orion Chat\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1771 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productType\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1772 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PT-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1773 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PT-2\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1774 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1775 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"surface\": \"WEB\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1776 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"plan\": \"FREE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1777 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"applicationVersion\": \"6.1\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1778 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1779 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"model\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1780 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"displayedLabel\": \"Orion Standard\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1781 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"identityConfidence\": \"MI-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1782 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"versionedDeploymentId\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 1783 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"dynamicRoutingPossible\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1784 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimAttributionLevel\": \"PRODUCT_SURFACE_ONLY\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1785 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1786 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"knowledgeConfiguration\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1787 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"mode\": \"KG-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1788 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"webFeatureAvailable\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1789 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"webFeatureEnabled\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1790 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"webUseForObservation\": \"USED_CONFIRMED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1791 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationFeatureAvailable\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1792 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationsDisplayed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1793 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"privateKnowledgeSource\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1794 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1795 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"tools\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1796 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"available\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1797 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"WEB_SEARCH\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1798 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1799 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"usedForObservation\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1800 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"WEB_SEARCH\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1801 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 1802 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1803 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"session\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1804 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sessionType\": \"ST-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1805 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"newConversation\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1806 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"persistentMemory\": \"OFF\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1807 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"customInstructions\": \"OFF\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1808 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"priorConversationContext\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1809 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"enterpriseWorkspace\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1810 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1811 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"localisation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1812 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"country\": \"TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1813 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1814 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptLanguage\": \"tr\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1815 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseLanguage\": \"tr\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1816 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1817 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"deployment\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1818 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1819 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timestampUtc\": \"2026-08-18T12:15:00Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1820 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"experimentalState\": \"UNKNOWN\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1821 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"knownChangeEvent\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 1822 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"observedInterfaceVariant\": \"STANDARD\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1823 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1824 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accessResult\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1825 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"AVAILABLE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1826 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rateLimitEncountered\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1827 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"technicalRetryUsed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1828 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systemRefusal\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1829 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1830 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"configurationFingerprint\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1831 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"algorithm\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1832 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": \"SCF-SYNTH-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1833 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1834 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidence\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1835 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productMetadataCaptured\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1836 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fullScreenshotCaptured\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1837 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systemSettingsCaptured\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1838 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceConfidence\": \"MEDIUM\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1839 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1840 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1841 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"registryOwnerRole\": \"AI_SYSTEM_REGISTRY_OWNER\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1842 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"recordValidatedBy\": \"SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION_REVIEWER\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1843 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1844 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1845 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1846 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "This record:", + "sourceParagraph": 1847 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "to the actual provider,", + "sourceParagraph": 1848 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "to the real model,", + "sourceParagraph": 1849 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "to the real product", + "sourceParagraph": 1850 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "it does not belong.", + "sourceParagraph": 1851 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "AI product sample is a machine-readable synthetic representation.", + "sourceParagraph": 1852 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "55. MACHINE-READABLE COMPARISON RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 1854 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 1855 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1856 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1857 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1858 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1859 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonId\": \"NGCMP-SYNTH-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1860 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonQuestion\": \"Which consumer AI product produces more accurate entity representation under matched clean-session conditions?\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1861 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systemA\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-PAID-W1-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1862 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systemB\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-HELIOS-WEB-FREE-W1-003\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1863 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonLevel\": \"CP-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1864 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"matchedDimensions\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1865 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityRecordVersion\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1866 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackVersion\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1867 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptVersion\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1868 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"country\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1869 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"locale\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1870 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"language\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1871 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"measurementWindow\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1872 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationFrame\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1873 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"newConversation\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1874 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"persistentMemoryOff\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1875 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"customInstructionsOff\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1876 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"webAccess\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1877 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationMode\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1878 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1879 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unmatchedDimensions\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1880 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"provider\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1881 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"plan\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1882 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"displayedModel\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1883 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"userInterfaceDetails\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1884 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1885 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"allowedClaims\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1886 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CONSUMER_PRODUCT_REPRESENTATION_COMPARISON\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1887 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"MATCHED_CLEAN_SESSION_RESULT\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1888 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1889 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"prohibitedClaims\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1890 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PURE_BASE_MODEL_SUPERIORITY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1891 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"GLOBAL_NATIVE_REACH_SUPERIORITY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1892 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PERMANENT_PRODUCT_SUPERIORITY\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1893 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1894 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nativeReachComparison\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1895 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"commonSupportComparison\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1896 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"replicationStatus\": \"SINGLE_WAVE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1897 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1898 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonOwnerRole\": \"COMPARABILITY_ADJUDICATOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1899 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"approvedBeforePublicRanking\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1900 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1901 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1902 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1903 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "56. MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF THE SECTION", + "sourceParagraph": 1905 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH09-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1906 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every GEO-1000 observation MUST be linked to a versioned AI System", + "sourceParagraph": 1908 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Registry record describing the measured product instance, including as", + "sourceParagraph": 1909 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "applicable:", + "sourceParagraph": 1910 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- provider,", + "sourceParagraph": 1912 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- product,", + "sourceParagraph": 1913 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- user surface,", + "sourceParagraph": 1914 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- plan,", + "sourceParagraph": 1915 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- displayed or verified model identity,", + "sourceParagraph": 1916 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- model-identity confidence,", + "sourceParagraph": 1917 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- retrieval and web configuration,", + "sourceParagraph": 1918 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- citation capability and use,", + "sourceParagraph": 1919 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- tool access and use,", + "sourceParagraph": 1920 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- session state,", + "sourceParagraph": 1921 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- memory,", + "sourceParagraph": 1922 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- custom instructions,", + "sourceParagraph": 1923 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- prior context,", + "sourceParagraph": 1924 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- personalisation,", + "sourceParagraph": 1925 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- country,", + "sourceParagraph": 1926 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- locale,", + "sourceParagraph": 1927 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- language,", + "sourceParagraph": 1928 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- deployment state,", + "sourceParagraph": 1929 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- measurement time,", + "sourceParagraph": 1930 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and known or observed system changes.", + "sourceParagraph": 1931 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Provider name, product name, displayed model label, base model, retrieval", + "sourceParagraph": 1933 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "system, and user-facing product MUST NOT be treated as interchangeable", + "sourceParagraph": 1934 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "identities.", + "sourceParagraph": 1935 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Feature availability MUST remain distinct from feature use.", + "sourceParagraph": 1937 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Live-product results MUST NOT be represented as frozen-model results, and", + "sourceParagraph": 1939 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "frozen-model results MUST NOT be represented as full consumer-product", + "sourceParagraph": 1940 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "experience.", + "sourceParagraph": 1941 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Comparisons MUST define their object and receive a disclosed", + "sourceParagraph": 1943 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "comparability level based on matched entity, prompt, population,", + "sourceParagraph": 1944 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "language, country, time, session, plan, interface, retrieval, tools,", + "sourceParagraph": 1945 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "reference records, and adjudication rules.", + "sourceParagraph": 1946 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The same provider or displayed model MUST NOT create an automatic", + "sourceParagraph": 1948 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "assumption of comparability.", + "sourceParagraph": 1949 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Different providers MAY be compared when user-facing conditions are", + "sourceParagraph": 1951 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "sufficiently aligned and the resulting claim is limited to the measured", + "sourceParagraph": 1952 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "product behaviour.", + "sourceParagraph": 1953 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Material product changes during a measurement wave MUST create a separate", + "sourceParagraph": 1955 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "system state, sub-wave, modelled change factor, or mixed-state warning.", + "sourceParagraph": 1956 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Unknown configuration fields MUST remain UNKNOWN and MUST NOT be imputed", + "sourceParagraph": 1958 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "as controlled or equivalent.", + "sourceParagraph": 1959 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every system-registry and comparability decision MUST be versioned and", + "sourceParagraph": 1961 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "sourceParagraph": 1962 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 1963 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Each GEO-1000 observation must be linked to a versioned AI System Register record that carries, to the extent relevant, provider, product, user surface, plan, visible or verified model ID, model ID confidence, retrieval and web configuration, citation capability and usage, tool access, session status, memory, custom instructions, previous context, personalisation, country, locale, language, deployment status, measurement time, and known system changes. Provider name, product name, visible model label, base model, retrieval system, and user product cannot be used interchangeably. The same provider or model label does not create automatic comparability. Different providers are comparable in terms of measured product behaviour when user conditions are sufficiently matched.", + "sourceParagraph": 1964 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Каждое наблюдение GEO-1000 ДОЛЖНО быть связано с записью в версионируемом Реестре систем ИИ, описывающей измеряемый экземпляр продукта, включая, при необходимости: - поставщика, - продукт, - пользовательский интерфейс, - план, - отображаемую или подтвержденную идентичность модели, - уверенность в идентичности модели, - конфигурацию извлечения и веб-конфигурацию, - возможность цитирования и использования, - доступ к инструментам и их использование, - состояние сессии, - память, - пользовательские инструкции, - предыдущий контекст, - персонализацию, - страну, - локаль, - язык, - состояние развертывания, - время измерения, - и известные или наблюдаемые изменения системы. Название поставщика, название продукта, отображаемая маркировка модели, базовая модель, система поиска и продукт, с которым взаимодействует пользователь, НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ рассматриваться как взаимозаменяемые идентичности. Доступность функции ДОЛЖНА оставаться отдельной от использования функции. Результаты работающего продукта НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ представляться как результаты замороженной модели, а результаты замороженной модели НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ представляться как полный опыт использования потребительского продукта. Сравнения ДОЛЖНЫ определять свой объект и получать раскрытый уровень сопоставимости на основе соответствующей сущности, промпта, популяции, языка, страны, времени, сессии, плана, интерфейса, поиска, инструментов, справочных записей и правил рассмотрения. Одно и то же название поставщика или отображаемая модель НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ создавать автоматическое предположение о сопоставимости. Различные поставщики МОГУТ сравниваться, когда условия, с которыми сталкивается пользователь, достаточно согласованы, и полученное утверждение ограничено измеренным поведением продукта. Существенные изменения продукта во время волны измерений ДОЛЖНЫ создавать отдельное состояние системы, подволну, смоделированный коэффициент изменения или предупреждение о смешанном состоянии. Неизвестные поля конфигурации ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться НЕИЗВЕСТНЫМИ и НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ быть оценены как контролируемые или эквивалентные. Каждое решение реестра системы и сопоставимости ДОЛЖНО иметь версию и быть приписано ответственному человеку или организации.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "54. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ ЗАПИСЬ СИСТЕМЫ ИИ", + "sourceParagraph": 1758, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 1759, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1760, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1761, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1762, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiSystemRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1763, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systemRecordId\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-FREE-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1764, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"provider\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1765, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"providerId\": \"SYNTH-ORION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1766, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"providerName\": \"Orion Systems\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1767, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1768, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"product\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1769, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productId\": \"SYNTH-ORION-CHAT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1770, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productName\": \"Orion Chat\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1771, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productType\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1772, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PT-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1773, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PT-2\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1774, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1775, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"surface\": \"WEB\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1776, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"plan\": \"FREE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1777, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"applicationVersion\": \"6.1\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1778, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1779, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"model\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1780, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"displayedLabel\": \"Orion Standard\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1781, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"identityConfidence\": \"MI-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1782, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"versionedDeploymentId\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 1783, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"dynamicRoutingPossible\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1784, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimAttributionLevel\": \"ТОЛЬКО_��ОВЕРХНОСТЬ_ПРОДУКТА\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1785, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1786, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"knowledgeConfiguration\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1787, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"mode\": \"KG-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1788, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"webFeatureAvailable\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1789, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"webFeatureEnabled\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1790, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"webUseForObservation\": \"ИСПОЛЬЗОВАНО_ПОДТВЕРЖДЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1791, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationFeatureAvailable\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1792, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationsDisplayed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1793, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"privateKnowledgeSource\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1794, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1795, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"tools\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1796, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"available\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1797, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"WEB_SEARCH\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1798, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1799, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"usedForObservation\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1800, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"WEB_SEARCH\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1801, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 1802, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1803, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"session\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1804, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sessionType\": \"ST-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1805, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"newConversation\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1806, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"persistentMemory\": \"ВЫКЛ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1807, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"customInstructions\": \"ВЫКЛ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1808, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"priorConversationContext\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1809, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"enterpriseWorkspace\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1810, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1811, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"localisation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1812, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"country\": \"TR\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1813, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1814, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptLanguage\": \"tr\",\"}", + "sourceParagraph": 1815, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseLanguage\": \"tr\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1816, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1817, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"развертывание\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1818, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1819, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timestampUtc\": \"2026-08-18 T1 2:15:00 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1820, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"experimentalState\": \"НЕИЗВЕСТНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1821, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"knownChangeEvent\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 1822, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"observedInterfaceVariant\": \"СТАНДАРТ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1823, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1824, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accessResult\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1825, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"статус\": \"ДОСТУПНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1826, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rateLimitEncountered\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1827, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"technicalRetryUsed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1828, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systemRefusal\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1829, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1830, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"configurationFingerprint\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1831, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"алгоритм\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ХЕШ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1832, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"значение\": \"SCF-SYNTH-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1833, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1834, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"доказательство\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1835, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productMetadataCaptured\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1836, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fullScreenshotCaptured\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1837, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systemSettingsCaptured\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1838, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceConfidence\": \"СРЕДНИЙ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1839, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1840, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1841, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"registryOwnerRole\": \"ВЛАДЕЛЕЦ_РЕЕСТРА_СИСТЕМЫ_ИИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1842, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"recordValidatedBy\": \"ОБЗОР_КОНФИГУРАЦИИ_СИСТЕМЫ\"}", + "sourceParagraph": 1843, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1844, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1845, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1846, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Эта запись:", + "sourceParagraph": 1847, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "к фактическому поставщику,", + "sourceParagraph": 1848, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "к реальной модели,", + "sourceParagraph": 1849, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "к реальному продукту", + "sourceParagraph": 1850, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "это не относится.", + "sourceParagraph": 1851, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Образец ИИ-продукта является машинно-читаемым синтетическим представлением.", + "sourceParagraph": 1852, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "55. МАШИННО-ЧИТАЕМЫЙ ЗАПИСЬ СРАВНЕНИЯ", + "sourceParagraph": 1854, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 1855, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1856, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1857, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1858, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1859, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonId\": \"NGCMP-SYNTH-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1860, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonQuestion\": \"Какой потребительский ИИ-продукт создает более точное представление сущности при сопоставимых чистых сеансах?\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1861, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systemA\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-PAID-W1-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1862, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systemB\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-HELIOS-WEB-FREE-W1-003\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1863, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonLevel\": \"CP-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1864, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"matchedDimensions\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1865, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityRecordVersion\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1866, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackVersion\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1867, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptVersion\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1868, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"страна\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1869, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"локаль\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1870, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"язык\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1871, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"measurementWindow\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1872, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationFrame\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1873, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"newConversation\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1874, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"persistentMemoryOff\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1875, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"customInstructionsOff\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1876, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"webAccess\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1877, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationMode\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1878, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1879, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unmatchedDimensions\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1880, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"провайдер\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1881, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"план\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1882, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"displayedModel\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1883, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"userInterfaceDetails\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1884, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1885, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"allowedClaims\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1886, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"СРАВНЕНИЕ ПРЕДСТАВЛЕНИЯ ПОТРЕБИТЕЛЬСКОГО ПРОДУКТА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1887, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"РЕЗУЛЬТАТ СООТВЕТСТВУЮЩЕЙ ЧИСТОЙ СЕССИИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1888, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1889, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"prohibitedClaims\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1890, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ПРЕИМУЩЕСТВО ЧИСТОЙ БАЗОВОЙ МОДЕЛИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1891, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ПРЕИМУЩЕСТВО ГЛОБАЛЬНОГО НАТИВНОГО ДОСТИЖЕНИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1892, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ПОСТОЯННОЕ ПРЕИМУЩЕСТВО ПРОДУКТА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1893, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1894, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nativeReachComparison\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1895, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"commonSupportComparison\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1896, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"replicationStatus\": \"ОДНА ВОЛНА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1897, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1898, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonOwnerRole\": \"СУДЬЯ СРАВНИМОСТИ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1899, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"approvedBeforePublicRanking\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1900, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1901, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1902, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1903, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "56. ПРАВИЛО РАЗДЕЛА, ЧИТАЕМОЕ МАШИНОЙ", + "sourceParagraph": 1905, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH09-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1906, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждое наблюдение GEO-1000 ДОЛЖНО быть связано с версионной системой ИИ", + "sourceParagraph": 1908, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Запись реестра, описывающая измеренный экземпляр продукта, включая:", + "sourceParagraph": 1909, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "применимые:", + "sourceParagraph": 1910, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- поставщик,", + "sourceParagraph": 1912, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- продукт,", + "sourceParagraph": 1913, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- пользовательский интерфейс,", + "sourceParagraph": 1914, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- план,", + "sourceParagraph": 1915, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- отображаемая или проверенная идентичность модели,", + "sourceParagraph": 1916, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- достоверность идентичности модели,", + "sourceParagraph": 1917, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- конфигурация извлечения и веб,", + "sourceParagraph": 1918, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- возможность цитирования и использования,", + "sourceParagraph": 1919, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- доступ к инструментам и использование,", + "sourceParagraph": 1920, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- состояние сеанса,", + "sourceParagraph": 1921, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- память,", + "sourceParagraph": 1922, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- пользовательские инструкции,", + "sourceParagraph": 1923, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- предыдущий контекст,", + "sourceParagraph": 1924, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- персонализация,", + "sourceParagraph": 1925, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- страна,", + "sourceParagraph": 1926, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- локаль,", + "sourceParagraph": 1927, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- язык,", + "sourceParagraph": 1928, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- состояние развертывания,", + "sourceParagraph": 1929, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- время измерения,", + "sourceParagraph": 1930, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и известные или наблюдаемые изменения системы.", + "sourceParagraph": 1931, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Название поставщика, название продукта, отображаемая модель, базовая модель, система извлечения", + "sourceParagraph": 1933, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "и продукт, с которым взаимодействует пользователь, НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ рассматриваться как взаимозаменяемые", + "sourceParagraph": 1934, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "идентичности.", + "sourceParagraph": 1935, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Доступность функции ДОЛЖНА оставаться отличной от использования функции.", + "sourceParagraph": 1937, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Результаты живого продукта НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ представляться как результаты замороженной модели, и", + "sourceParagraph": 1939, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Результаты замороженной модели НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ представляться как полноценный потребительский продукт", + "sourceParagraph": 1940, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "опыт.", + "sourceParagraph": 1941, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Сравнения ДОЛЖНЫ определять свой объект и получать раскрытое", + "sourceParagraph": 1943, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "уровень сопоставимости на основе сопоставленной сущности, запроса, популяции,", + "sourceParagraph": 1944, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "язык, страна, время, сеанс, план, интерфейс, извлечение, инструменты,", + "sourceParagraph": 1945, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "справочные записи и правила рассмотрения", + "sourceParagraph": 1946, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Тот же поставщик или отображаемая модель НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ создавать автоматическое", + "sourceParagraph": 1948, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "предположение сопоставимости.", + "sourceParagraph": 1949, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Различные поставщики МОГУТ быть сравнены, когда условия для пользователя являются", + "sourceParagraph": 1951, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "достаточно согласованы, и вытекающее требование ограничено измеренным", + "sourceParagraph": 1952, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "поведением продукта.", + "sourceParagraph": 1953, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Изменения материала продукта во время измерительной волны ДОЛЖНЫ создавать отдельное", + "sourceParagraph": 1955, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "состояние системы, под-волну, смоделированный фактор изменения или предупреждение о смешанном состоянии.", + "sourceParagraph": 1956, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Неизвестные поля конфигурации ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться НЕИЗВЕСТНЫМИ и НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ быть приписаны", + "sourceParagraph": 1958, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "как контролируемые или эквивалентные.", + "sourceParagraph": 1959, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждое решение реестра системы и сопоставимости ДОЛЖНО иметь версию и", + "sourceParagraph": 1961, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "быть приписано ответственному человеку или организации.", + "sourceParagraph": 1962, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 1963, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH09-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждое наблюдение GEO-1000 должно быть связано с записанной в реестре версионной системой ИИ записью, которая содержит, в той степени, в какой это релевантно, информацию о поставщике, продукте, пользовательский интерфейс, плане, видимом или проверенном идентификаторе модели, достоверности идентификатора модели, конфигурации извлечения и веб-конфигурации, возможности цитирования и использования, доступе к инструментам, состоянии сессии, памяти, пользовательских инструкциях, предыдущем контексте, персонализации, стране, локали, языке, статусе развертывания, времени измерения и известных изменениях системы. Название поставщика, название продукта, видимая метка модели, базовая модель, система извлечения и пользовательский продукт не могут использоваться взаимозаменяемо. Один и тот же поставщик или метка модели не создают автоматической сопоставимости. Различные поставщики сопоставимы с точки зрения измеренного поведения продукта, когда условия пользователя достаточно совпадают.", + "sourceParagraph": 1964, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 10, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH10", + "title": "Конституция промпта", + "subtitle": null, + "sourceIds": [ + "K04", + "K11", + "K12", + "K13" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH10-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "Every GEO-1000 prompt MUST be linked to a versioned Prompt Registry record defining: - the research question, - estimand, - prompt family, - canonical intent, - entity anchor, - user intent, - speech act, - scope, - geographic and temporal frame, - presuppositions, - evidence and source requirements, - response format, - language, - locale, - equivalence status, - version, - and integrity record. Within the same language-locale prompt cell, participants MUST receive the same locked prompt text. Across languages and locales, prompts MUST preserve semantic, functional, and normative equivalence rather than literal word-for-word identity. Entity anchor, user intent, speech act, scope, presupposition, and epistemic burden are non-compensatory equivalence gates. Machine translation or back-translation alone MUST NOT establish prompt equivalence. Core identity, evidence, recommendation, comparison, temporal, local, boundary, robustness, control, and holdout prompts MUST remain distinct prompt families. Leading, answer-containing, positively or negatively presuppositional, source-constrained, format-constrained, or recommendation prompts MUST NOT be silently scored as neutral Core Mirror prompts. Prompt sets, language versions, assignment rules, clarification paths, ordering, and holdout commitments MUST be locked before AI responses are observed. Post-result prompt selection, prompt-family deletion, silent mid-wave editing, and outcome-driven rewording are prohibited. the prompt assigned to the participant and the prompt actually sent to the AI product MUST be integrity-checked. Hidden instructions, invisible characters, or undisclosed manipulation directing the AI toward a preferred entity, claim, citation, or recommendation are prohibited. Every prompt change, translation decision, equivalence judgement, and registry record MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Her GEO-1000 promptu araştırma sorusunu, tahmin edilen niceliği, prompt ailesini, kanonik niyeti, entity anchor’ı, kullanıcı niyetini, görev türünü, kapsamı, coğrafi ve zamansal çerçeveyi, ön varsayımları, kaynak ve kanıt talebini, cevap biçimini, dil ve locale’i, eşdeğerlik statüsünü, sürümü ve bütünlük kaydını tanımlayan sürümlü Prompt Sicili’ne bağlanmalıdır. Aynı dil–locale hücresinde kullanıcılar aynı kilitlenmiş metni almalı; diller arasında kelime kelime eşitlik değil semantik, işlevsel ve normatif eşdeğerlik korunmalıdır. Prompt setleri, çeviriler, atama kuralları, clarification yolları ve holdout kayıtları AI cevapları görülmeden önce kilitlenmelidir.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "75. MACHINE-READABLE PROMPT RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2046 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 2047 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2048 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2049 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"excludedTasks\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2050 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RECOMMENDATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2051 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"LEADERSHIP\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2052 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"TRUSTWORTHINESS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2053 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PRICE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2054 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"COMPARATIVE_RANKING\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2055 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2056 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceRequirement\": \"NONE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2057 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseFormat\": \"NATURAL_OPEN_RESPONSE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2058 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"presuppositionPolicy\": \"NO_UNVERIFIED_QUALITY_OR_AUTHORITY_ASSUMPTION\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2059 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2060 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceLanguage\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2061 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"language\": \"tr\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2062 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2063 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"Which parent organisation is Apple.com associated with, and what are the main activities of this organisation?\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2064 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unicodeNormalization\": \"NFC\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2065 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-TR-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2066 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2067 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageVersions\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2068 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2069 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"language\": \"tr\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2070 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2071 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"Which parent organisation is Apple.com associated with, and what are the main activities of this organisation?\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2072 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"equivalenceLevel\": \"PE-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2073 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityAnchorEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2074 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"intentEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2075 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"speechActEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2076 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2077 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"presuppositionEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2078 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"epistemicBurdenEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2079 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"localPilotStatus\": \"PASSED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2080 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-TR-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2081 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2082 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2083 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"language\": \"en\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2084 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"locale\": \"en-GB\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2085 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"text\": \"Which principal organisation is associated with apple.com, and what are its primary activities?\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2086 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"equivalenceLevel\": \"PE-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2087 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityAnchorEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2088 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"intentEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2089 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"speechActEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2090 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2091 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"presuppositionEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2092 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"epistemicBurdenEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2093 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"localPilotStatus\": \"PASSED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2094 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-EN-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2095 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2096 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2097 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"delivery\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2098 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"manualRetypingAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2099 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"copyFromLockedInterface\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2100 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"exactMatchRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2101 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"participantEditingAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2102 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"clarificationPath\": \"SINGLE_TURN_CAPTURE_ONLY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2103 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"newConversationRequired\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2104 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2105 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sets\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2106 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicNormativeSet\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2107 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sealedValidationSet\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2108 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"holdoutStatus\": \"NOT_APPLICABLE\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2109 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2110 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governance\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2111 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"draftedByRole\": \"PROMPT_METHODS_LEAD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2112 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"translatedByRole\": \"TARGET_LANGUAGE_TRANSLATOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2113 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"backTranslatedByIndependentRole\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2114 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"equivalenceApprovedByRole\": \"PROMPT_EQUIVALENCE_ADJUDICATOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2115 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-08-18T09:00:00Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2116 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"resultInspectionBeforeLock\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2117 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2118 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2119 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2120 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "This record:", + "sourceParagraph": 2121 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "This is not a real Apple audit,", + "sourceParagraph": 2122 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "This is not a real prompt validation work,", + "sourceParagraph": 2123 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "It is a machine-readable synthetic representation of the Prompt Constitution.", + "sourceParagraph": 2124 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "76. MACHINE-READABLE PROMPT OBSERVATION RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2126 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 2127 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2128 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2129 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2130 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptObservation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2131 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"observationId\": \"NGO-SYNTH-000184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2132 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptId\": \"NGP-CORE-MIRROR-APPLE-SYNTH-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2133 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2134 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"language\": \"tr\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2135 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2136 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"assignedTextHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-TR-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2137 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sentTextHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-TR-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2138 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptValidity\": \"PV-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2139 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptOrder\": 1,", + "sourceParagraph": 2140 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conversationTurn\": 1,", + "sourceParagraph": 2141 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"clarificationUsed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2142 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"participantEdited\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2143 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systemTransformationObserved\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2144 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fullPromptVisibleInEvidence\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2145 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timestampUtc\": \"2026-08-18T12:14:00Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2146 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2147 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptValidityReviewerRole\": \"BLINDED_PROMPT_VALIDATOR\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2148 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2149 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2150 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2151 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "77. MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF THE SECTION", + "sourceParagraph": 2153 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH10-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2154 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every GEO-1000 prompt MUST be linked to a versioned Prompt Registry record", + "sourceParagraph": 2156 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "defining:", + "sourceParagraph": 2157 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- the research question,", + "sourceParagraph": 2159 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- estimand,", + "sourceParagraph": 2160 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- prompt family,", + "sourceParagraph": 2161 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- canonical intent,", + "sourceParagraph": 2162 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- entity anchor,", + "sourceParagraph": 2163 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- user intent,", + "sourceParagraph": 2164 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- speech act,", + "sourceParagraph": 2165 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- scope,", + "sourceParagraph": 2166 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- geographic and temporal frame,", + "sourceParagraph": 2167 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- presuppositions,", + "sourceParagraph": 2168 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- evidence and source requirements,", + "sourceParagraph": 2169 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- response format,", + "sourceParagraph": 2170 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- language,", + "sourceParagraph": 2171 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- locale,", + "sourceParagraph": 2172 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- equivalence status,", + "sourceParagraph": 2173 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- version,", + "sourceParagraph": 2174 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and integrity record.", + "sourceParagraph": 2175 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Within the same language-locale prompt cell, participants MUST receive", + "sourceParagraph": 2177 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "the same locked prompt text.", + "sourceParagraph": 2178 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Across languages and locales, prompts MUST preserve semantic, functional,", + "sourceParagraph": 2180 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "and normative equivalence rather than literal word-for-word identity.", + "sourceParagraph": 2181 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Entity anchor, user intent, speech act, scope, presupposition, and", + "sourceParagraph": 2183 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "epistemic burden are non-compensatory equivalence gates.", + "sourceParagraph": 2184 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Machine translation or back-translation alone MUST NOT establish prompt", + "sourceParagraph": 2186 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "equivalence.", + "sourceParagraph": 2187 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Core identity, evidence, recommendation, comparison, temporal, local,", + "sourceParagraph": 2189 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "boundary, robustness, control, and holdout prompts MUST remain distinct", + "sourceParagraph": 2190 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "prompt families.", + "sourceParagraph": 2191 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Leading, answer-containing, positively or negatively presuppositional,", + "sourceParagraph": 2193 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "source-constrained, format-constrained, or recommendation prompts MUST NOT", + "sourceParagraph": 2194 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "be silently scored as neutral Core Mirror prompts.", + "sourceParagraph": 2195 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Prompt sets, language versions, assignment rules, clarification paths,", + "sourceParagraph": 2197 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ordering, and holdout commitments MUST be locked before AI responses are", + "sourceParagraph": 2198 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "observed.", + "sourceParagraph": 2199 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Post-result prompt selection, prompt-family deletion, silent mid-wave", + "sourceParagraph": 2201 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "editing, and outcome-driven rewording are prohibited.", + "sourceParagraph": 2202 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The prompt assigned to the participant and the prompt actually sent to", + "sourceParagraph": 2204 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "the AI product MUST be integrity-checked.", + "sourceParagraph": 2205 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Hidden instructions, invisible characters, or undisclosed manipulation", + "sourceParagraph": 2207 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "directing the AI toward a preferred entity, claim, citation, or", + "sourceParagraph": 2208 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "recommendation are prohibited.", + "sourceParagraph": 2209 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every prompt change, translation decision, equivalence judgement, and", + "sourceParagraph": 2211 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "registry record MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable", + "sourceParagraph": 2212 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "human or organisation.", + "sourceParagraph": 2213 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 2214 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every GEO-1000 prompt must be linked to the versioned Prompt Registry that defines the research question, estimated quantity, prompt family, canonical intent, entity anchor, user intent, task type, scope, geographic and temporal frame, assumptions, source and evidence request, response format, language and locale, equivalence status, version, and integrity record. Users in the same language–locale cell must receive the same locked text; across languages, semantic, functional, and normative equivalence must be preserved, not word-for-word equality. Prompt sets, translations, assignment rules, clarification paths, and holdout records must be locked before AI responses are seen.", + "sourceParagraph": 2215 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Каждый GEO-1000 запрос ДОЛЖЕН быть связан с версионированной записью в Реестре запросов, определяющей: - исследовательский вопрос, - оцениваемую величину (estimand), - семейство запросов, - каноническое намерение, - анкоровую сущность, - намерение пользователя, - речевой акт, - область, - географические и временные рамки, - предпосылки, - требования к доказательствам и источникам, - формат ответа, - язык, - локаль, - статус эквивалентности, - версию, - и запись целостности. В пределах одной ячейки запроса для языка и локали участники ДОЛЖНЫ получать один и тот же зафиксированный текст запроса. Между языками и локалями запросы ДОЛЖНЫ сохранять семантическую, функциональную и нормативную эквивалентность, а не буквальную идентичность слова в слово. Якорь сущности, намерение пользователя, речевой акт, область применения, пресуппозиция и эпистемическая нагрузка являются некопенсационными воротами эквивалентности. Машинный перевод или обратный перевод сами по себе НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ устанавливать эквивалентность промптов. Основная идентичность, доказательства, рекомендации, сравнения, временные, локальные, граничные, устойчивость, контроль и удерживаемые промпты ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельными семействами промптов. Ведущие промпты, содержащие ответ, положительно или отрицательно пресуппозиционные, ограниченные источником, ограниченные форматом или рекомендательные промпты НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ молча оцениваться как нейтральные основным зеркальным промптам. Наборы промптов, языковые версии, правила назначения, пути уточнения, порядок и обязательства по удержанию ДОЛЖНЫ быть зафиксированы до наблюдения ответов ИИ. Выбор запроса после получения результата, удаление семейства запросов, тихое редактирование в середине волны и переформулирование, ориентированное на результат, запрещены. Запрос, назначенный участнику, и запрос, фактически отправленный в продукт ИИ, ДОЛЖНЫ быть проверены на целостность. Скрытые инструкции, невидимые символы или незадокументированные манипуляции, направляющие ИИ к предпочтительному объекту, утверждению, ссылке или рекомендации, запрещены. Каждое изменение запроса, решение о переводе, суждение о эквивалентности и запись в реестре ДОЛЖНЫ быть версионированы и приписаны ответственному человеку или организации.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "75. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ ЗАПИСЬ промпта", + "sourceParagraph": 2046, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2047, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2048, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2049, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"excludedTasks\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2050, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"РЕКОМЕНДАЦИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2051, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"РУКОВОДСТВО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2052, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"НАДЕЖНОСТЬ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2053, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ЦЕНА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2054, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"СРАВНИТЕЛЬНЫЙ РЕЙТИНГ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2055, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2056, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceRequirement\": \"НЕТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2057, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseFormat\": \"ЕСТЕСТВЕННЫЙ ОТКРЫТЫЙ ОТВЕТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2058, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"presuppositionPolicy\": \"БЕЗ НЕПРОВЕРЕННОГО ПРЕДПОЛОЖЕНИЯ О КАЧЕСТВЕ ИЛИ АВТОРИТЕТЕ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2059, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2060, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceLanguage\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2061, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"язык\": \"tr\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2062, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2063, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"С какой родительской организацией связан Apple.com и какова основная деятельность этой организации?\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2064, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unicodeNormalization\": \"NFC\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2065, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ХЕШ-TR-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2066, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2067, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languageVersions\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2068, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2069, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"язык\": \"tr\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2070, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2071, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"С какой родительской организацией связан Apple.com и какова основная деятел��ность этой организации?\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2072, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"equivalenceLevel\": \"PE-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2073, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityAnchorEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2074, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"intentEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2075, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"speechActEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2076, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2077, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"presuppositionEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2078, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"epistemicBurdenEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2079, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"localPilotStatus\": \"ПРОЙДЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2080, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ХЕШ-TR-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2081, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2082, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2083, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"язык\": \"en\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2084, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"локаль\": \"en-GB\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2085, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"текст\": \"С какой основной организацией связан apple.com, и каковы её основные виды деятельности?\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2086, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"equivalenceLevel\": \"PE-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2087, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityAnchorEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2088, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"intentEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2089, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"speechActEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2090, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2091, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"presuppositionEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2092, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"epistemicBurdenEquivalence\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2093, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"localPilotStatus\": \"ПРОЙДЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2094, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ХЕШ-EN-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2095, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2096, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2097, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"доставка\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2098, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"manualRetypingAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2099, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"copyFromLockedInterface\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2100, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"exactMatchRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2101, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"participantEditingAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2102, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"clarificationPath\": \"ТОЛЬКО_ОДНОКРАТНАЯ_ФИКСАЦИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2103, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"newConversationRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2104, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2105, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"наборы\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2106, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicNormativeSet\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2107, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sealedValidationSet\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2108, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"holdoutStatus\": \"НЕ_ПРИМЕНИМО\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2109, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2110, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"управление\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2111, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"draftedByRole\": \"МЕТОДЫ_ОТВЕТА_НА_ПОДСКАЗКУ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2112, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"translatedByRole\": \"ПЕРЕВОДЧИК_ЦЕЛЕВОГО_ЯЗЫКА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2113, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"backTranslatedByIndependentRole\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2114, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"equivalenceApprovedByRole\": \"АДЖУДИКАТОР_ЭКВИВАЛЕНТНОСТИ_ПОДСКАЗКИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2115, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-08-18 T0 9:00:00 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2116, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"resultInspectionBeforeLock\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2117, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2118, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2119, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2120, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Эта запись:", + "sourceParagraph": 2121, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Это не настоящий аудит Apple,", + "sourceParagraph": 2122, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Это не настоящая работа по валидации промптов,", + "sourceParagraph": 2123, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Это машиночитаемое синтетическое представление Конституции промптов.", + "sourceParagraph": 2124, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "76. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ ЗАПИСЬ НАБЛЮДЕНИЯ промпта", + "sourceParagraph": 2126, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2127, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2128, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2129, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2130, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptObservation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2131, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"observationId\": \"НПО-СИНТ-000184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2132, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptId\": \"NGP-CORE-MIRROR-APPLE-SYNTH-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2133, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2134, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"язык\": \"tr\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2135, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2136, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"assignedTextHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ХЭШ-TR-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2137, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sentTextHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ХЭШ-TR-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2138, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptValidity\": \"PV-1\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2139, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptOrder\": 1,", + "sourceParagraph": 2140, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conversationTurn\": 1,", + "sourceParagraph": 2141, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"clarificationUsed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2142, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"participantEdited\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2143, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systemTransformationObserved\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2144, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fullPromptVisibleInEvidence\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2145, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timestampUtc\": \"2026-08-18 T1 2:14:00 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2146, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2147, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptValidityReviewerRole\": \"ПРОВЕРЯЮЩИЙ_СЛИПЫЕ_ПОДСКАЗКИ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2148, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2149, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2150, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2151, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "77. ПРАВИЛО РАЗДЕЛА, ЧИТАЕМОЕ МАШИНОЙ", + "sourceParagraph": 2153, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH10-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2154, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждая промпт GEO-1000 ДОЛЖНА быть связана с версионированной записью реестра промптов", + "sourceParagraph": 2156, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "определяющей:", + "sourceParagraph": 2157, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- исследовательский вопрос,", + "sourceParagraph": 2159, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- численно оцениваемая величина (estimand),", + "sourceParagraph": 2160, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- семейства промптов,", + "sourceParagraph": 2161, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- каноническое намерение,", + "sourceParagraph": 2162, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- анкер сущности,", + "sourceParagraph": 2163, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- намерение пользователя,", + "sourceParagraph": 2164, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- речевой акт,", + "sourceParagraph": 2165, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- область охвата,", + "sourceParagraph": 2166, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- географические и временные рамки,", + "sourceParagraph": 2167, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- презумпции,", + "sourceParagraph": 2168, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- требования к доказательствам и источникам,", + "sourceParagraph": 2169, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- формат ответа,", + "sourceParagraph": 2170, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- язык,", + "sourceParagraph": 2171, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- локаль,", + "sourceParagraph": 2172, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- статус эквивалентности.", + "sourceParagraph": 2173, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- версия,", + "sourceParagraph": 2174, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и запись целостности.", + "sourceParagraph": 2175, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "В пределах одной языковой ячейки промпта, участники ДОЛЖНЫ получать", + "sourceParagraph": 2177, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "тот же самый зафиксированный текст промпта.", + "sourceParagraph": 2178, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "В разных языках и локалях, промпты ДОЛЖНЫ сохранять семантическое, функциональное,", + "sourceParagraph": 2180, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "и нормативное соответствие, а не буквальное слово в слово идентичность.", + "sourceParagraph": 2181, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Якорь сущности, намерение пользователя, речевой акт, область, пресуппозиция и", + "sourceParagraph": 2183, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "эпистемическая нагрузка являются критическими воротами эквивалентности.", + "sourceParagraph": 2184, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Машинный перевод или обратный перевод сами по себе НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ устанавливать", + "sourceParagraph": 2186, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "эквивалентность подсказки.", + "sourceParagraph": 2187, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Основная идентичность, доказательство, рекомендация, сравнение, временные, локальные,", + "sourceParagraph": 2189, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "граничные, устойчивость, контроль и отложенные промпты ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться различными", + "sourceParagraph": 2190, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "семействами промптов.", + "sourceParagraph": 2191, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Ведущие, содержащие ответы, с положительным или отрицательным пресуппозиционным подтекстом,", + "sourceParagraph": 2193, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "промпты, ограниченные источником, ограниченные форматом или рекомендацией, НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2194, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "оценивацца как нейтральные промпты Core Mirror без уведомления.", + "sourceParagraph": 2195, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Наборы промптов, языковые версии, правила назначений, пути уточнения,", + "sourceParagraph": 2197, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "порядок и обязательства по отложенным подсказкам ДОЛЖНЫ быть закреплены до того, как ответы ИИ будут", + "sourceParagraph": 2198, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "наблюдаться.", + "sourceParagraph": 2199, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Выбор запроса после результата, удаление семейства запросов, тихая средняя волна", + "sourceParagraph": 2201, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Редактирование и перефразирование, ориентированное на результат, запрещены.", + "sourceParagraph": 2202, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "промпт, назначенная участнику, и промпт, фактически отправленная", + "sourceParagraph": 2204, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Продукт ИИ ДОЛЖЕН пройти проверку на целостность.", + "sourceParagraph": 2205, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Скрытые инструкции, невидимые символы или нераскрытая манипуляция", + "sourceParagraph": 2207, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "направление ИИ к предпочитаемому объекту, утверждению, ссылке или", + "sourceParagraph": 2208, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "рекомендации запрещены.", + "sourceParagraph": 2209, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждое изменение промпта, решение о переводе, суждение о равнозначности и", + "sourceParagraph": 2211, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "запись в реестре ДОЛЖНА иметь версию и быть приписываемой ответственному лицу", + "sourceParagraph": 2212, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "человек или организация.", + "sourceParagraph": 2213, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 2214, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH10-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждый запрос GEO-1000 должен быть связан с версионированным Реестром запросов, который определяет исследовательский вопрос, предполагаемое количество, семейство запросов, канонический замысел, привязку к объекту, намерение пользователя, тип задачи, область, географические и временные рамки, предположения, источник и запрос доказательств, формат ответа, язык и локаль, статус эквивалентности, версию и запись целостности. Пользователи в одной ячейке язык–локаль должны получать одинаковый зафиксированный текст; между языками должны сохраняться семантическая, функциональная и нормативная эквивалентность, а не построчное соответствие слов. Наборы запросов, переводы, правила назначения, пути уточнения и записи удержания должны быть зафиксированы до того, как будут видны ответы ИИ.", + "sourceParagraph": 2215, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 11, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH11", + "title": "Контролируемая панель в стандартизированных условиях и панель пользователей в естественных условиях", + "subtitle": null, + "sourceIds": [ + "K02", + "K03", + "K04", + "K06", + "K22" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH11-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "Controlled Clean Panel and Natural User Panel observations MUST remain separate measurement populations, panel states, denominators, and public results. A Controlled Clean Panel MUST define and verify, as applicable: - a new and separate conversation, - absence of prior conversation context, - persistent-memory state, - custom-instruction state, - enterprise or managed-workspace state, - web, retrieval, and tool configuration, - plan, - user surface, - prompt version, - and clean-state confidence. A new conversation or temporary-session label MUST NOT, by itself, be treated as proof that all persistent personalisation has been disabled. A Natural User Panel MUST preserve the participant's authentic account, plan, interface, memory, custom-instruction, and usage state while retaining the locked prompt, first-eligible-output rule, evidence requirements, and non-regeneration rule. Natural Account-State, Natural Conversation-State, First-Use, and Managed Natural observations MUST remain separately identified. Natural-state documentation MUST minimise private-data collection. Private instruction text, conversation history, identity, credentials, and sensitive personal content MUST NOT be collected unless separately necessary, consented, minimised, and access-controlled. User-generated entity-favourable or entity-adverse instructions MAY be measured as natural personalisation effects, but MUST NOT be represented as general entity GEO success, failure, or default product behaviour. Personalisation MAY change relevance, presentation, and recommendation where user context justifies it. It MUST NOT arbitrarily change verified entity identity, license, legal status, price, scope, evidence, or time. Differences between Controlled and Natural panels MUST NOT be represented as causal personalisation effects unless population, product, prompt, time, interface, plan, tools, assignment, order, and carryover conditions support that inference. Controlled and Natural scores, critical-error rates, unknown rates, coverage, effective sample sizes, and signed and absolute panel gaps MUST remain separately visible. Panel-state eligibility, reclassification, exclusion, and weighting MUST remain independent of whether the AI output is positive, negative, correct, incorrect, refused, critical, or commercially favourable. Every panel-state definition, setting-change process, privacy decision, comparison level, and result MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Kontrollü Temiz Panel ve Doğal Kullanıcı Paneli gözlemleri ayrı ölçüm nüfusları, panel durumları, paydalar ve kamu sonuçları olarak korunmalıdır. Yeni sohbet veya geçici oturum etiketi tek başına bütün kalıcı kişiselleştirmenin devre dışı olduğunu kanıtlamaz. Doğal Kullanıcı Paneli gerçek hesap, plan, arayüz, hafıza, özel talimat ve kullanım durumunu korurken kilitlenmiş promptu, ilk uygun çıktı kuralını, kanıt gereksinimlerini ve yenilememe kuralını korumalıdır. Kullanıcı kaynaklı lehte veya aleyhte yönlendirme doğal kişiselleştirme etkisi olarak ölçülebilir; genel varlık GEO başarısı, başarısızlığı veya varsayılan ürün davranışı olarak sunulamaz. Kontrollü ve doğal sonuçlar arasındaki fark, nüfus ve sistem koşulları yeterince eşleşmeden nedensel kişiselleştirme etkisi olarak yorumlanamaz.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "77. MACHINE-READABLE PANEL STATUS RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 1981 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 1982 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1983 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1984 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1985 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelStateRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1986 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelStateId\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1987 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1988 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductRecordId\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-PAID-W1-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1989 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptRecordId\": \"NGP-CORE-MIRROR-APPLE-SYNTH-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1990 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelRole\": \"CONTROLLED_CLEAN\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1991 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelEligibility\": \"PC-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1992 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetPopulation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1993 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"frameId\": \"NGP-SYNTH-ORION-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1994 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationType\": \"PRODUCT_ELIGIBLE_USERS_UNDER_STANDARDIZED_STATE\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1995 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1996 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"controlledState\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1997 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"cleanStateConfidence\": \"CSC-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1998 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conversationState\": \"NEW_CONVERSATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1999 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptIsFirstUserMessage\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2000 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"persistentMemory\": \"OFF_VERIFIED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2001 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"customInstructions\": \"OFF_VERIFIED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2002 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"priorConversationContext\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2003 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"enterpriseWorkspace\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2004 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"webMode\": \"ON_STANDARDIZED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2005 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"toolMode\": \"STANDARDISED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2006 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"plan\": \"PAID\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2007 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"surface\": \"WEB\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2008 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"settingsChangedForStudy\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2009 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"participantConsentForSettingChange\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2010 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"restorationRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2011 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"restorationConfirmed\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2012 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2013 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"measurement\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2014 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"firstEligibleOutputRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2015 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseRegenerationAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2016 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"followUpAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2017 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptValidityRequired\": \"PV-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2018 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timestampUtc\": \"2026-08-18T12:00:00Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2019 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2020 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"privacy\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2021 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"privateInstructionContentCollected\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2022 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conversationHistoryCollected\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2023 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountCredentialsCollected\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2024 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2025 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2026 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelStateOwnerRole\": \"PANEL_STATE_METHODS_LEAD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2027 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validatedByRole\": \"BLINDED_PANEL_STATE_REVIEWER\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2028 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2029 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2030 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2031 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "78. MACHINE-READABLE NATURAL PANEL RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2033 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 2034 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2035 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2036 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2037 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelStateRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2038 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelStateId\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2039 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2040 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductRecordId\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-PAID-W1-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2041 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptRecordId\": \"NGP-CORE-MIRROR-APPLE-SYNTH-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2042 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelRole\": \"NATURAL_ACCOUNT_STATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2043 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelEligibility\": \"PC-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2044 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetPopulation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2045 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"frameId\": \"NGP-SYNTH-ORION-ACTIVE-USERS-W1-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2046 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationType\": \"DEFINED_ACTIVE_PRODUCT_USERS\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2047 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2048 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"naturalState\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2049 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"naturalStateConfidence\": \"NSF-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2050 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conversationState\": \"NEW_CONVERSATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2051 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptIsFirstUserMessage\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2052 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"persistentMemory\": \"MS-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2053 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"customInstructions\": \"CI-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2054 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"priorConversationContext\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2055 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"priorEntityConversation\": \"POSSIBLE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2056 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"enterpriseWorkspace\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2057 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"webMode\": \"USER_NATURAL_STATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2058 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"toolMode\": \"USER_NATURAL_STATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2059 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"plan\": \"PAID\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2060 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"surface\": \"WEB\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2061 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountAgeBand\": \"181_TO_365_DAYS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2062 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"usageFrequency\": \"WEEKLY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2063 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"firstUse\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2064 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2065 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"measurement\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2066 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"firstEligibleOutputRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2067 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseRegenerationAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2068 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"followUpAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2069 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptValidityRequired\": \"PV-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2070 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timestampUtc\": \"2026-08-18T12:05:00Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2071 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2072 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"privacy\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2073 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"memoryContentCollected\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2074 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"customInstructionContentCollected\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2075 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conversationHistoryCollected\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2076 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"highLevelStateOnly\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2077 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2078 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2079 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelStateOwnerRole\": \"PANEL_STATE_METHODS_LEAD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2080 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validatedByRole\": \"BLINDED_PANEL_STATE_REVIEWER\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2081 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2082 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2083 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2084 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "79. MACHINE-READABLE PANEL COMPARISON RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2086 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 2087 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2088 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2089 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2090 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelComparison\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2091 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonId\": \"NGPC-SYNTH-ORION-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2092 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"controlledPanelRecord\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2093 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"naturalPanelRecord\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2094 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparabilityLevel\": \"CN-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2095 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"matchedDimensions\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2096 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProduct\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2097 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptVersion\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2098 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityTruthPack\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2099 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"country\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2100 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"locale\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2101 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"measurementWindow\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2102 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationRules\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2103 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2104 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unmatchedDimensions\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2105 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"memory\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2106 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"customInstructions\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2107 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"planDistribution\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2108 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"userHistory\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2109 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"toolState\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2110 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2111 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"results\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2112 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"controlledRepresentationScore\": 0.92,", + "sourceParagraph": 2113 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"naturalRepresentationScore\": 0.83,", + "sourceParagraph": 2114 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"signedNaturalGap\": -0.09,", + "sourceParagraph": 2115 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"absolutePanelGap\": 0.09,", + "sourceParagraph": 2116 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"controlledCriticalRate\": 0.002,", + "sourceParagraph": 2117 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"naturalCriticalRate\": 0.012,", + "sourceParagraph": 2118 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalRateDifference\": 0.01", + "sourceParagraph": 2119 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2120 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"allowedClaims\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2121 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NATURAL_PANEL_RESULT_LOWER_THAN_CONTROLLED_REFERENCE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2122 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PANEL_STATE_ASSOCIATION_REQUIRES_FURTHER_DECOMPOSITION\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2123 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2124 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"prohibitedClaims\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2125 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"MEMORY_CAUSED_NINE_POINT_DECLINE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2126 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ALL_NATURAL_USERS_RECEIVE_WORSE_RESPONSES\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2127 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"BASE_MODEL_PERFORMANCE_DECLINED\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2128 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2129 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"replicationStatus\": \"SINGLE_WAVE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2130 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2131 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonOwnerRole\": \"PANEL_COMPARABILITY_ADJUDICATOR\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2132 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2133 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2134 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2135 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "These records:", + "sourceParagraph": 2136 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "are not:", + "sourceParagraph": 2137 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "a real user,", + "sourceParagraph": 2138 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "a real AI product,", + "sourceParagraph": 2139 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "a real company performance.", + "sourceParagraph": 2140 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "It is a machine-readable synthetic representation of the panel distinction.", + "sourceParagraph": 2141 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF SECTION 80", + "sourceParagraph": 2143 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH11-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2144 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Controlled Clean Panel and Natural User Panel observations MUST remain", + "sourceParagraph": 2146 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "separate measurement populations, panel states, denominators, and public", + "sourceParagraph": 2147 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "results.", + "sourceParagraph": 2148 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A Controlled Clean Panel MUST define and verify, as applicable:", + "sourceParagraph": 2150 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- a new and separate conversation,", + "sourceParagraph": 2152 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- absence of prior conversation context,", + "sourceParagraph": 2153 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- persistent-memory state,", + "sourceParagraph": 2154 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- custom-instruction state,", + "sourceParagraph": 2155 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- enterprise or managed-workspace state,", + "sourceParagraph": 2156 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- web, retrieval, and tool configuration,", + "sourceParagraph": 2157 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- plan,", + "sourceParagraph": 2158 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- user surface,", + "sourceParagraph": 2159 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- prompt version,", + "sourceParagraph": 2160 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and clean-state confidence.", + "sourceParagraph": 2161 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A new conversation or temporary-session label MUST NOT, by itself, be", + "sourceParagraph": 2163 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "treated as proof that all persistent personalisation has been disabled.", + "sourceParagraph": 2164 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A Natural User Panel MUST preserve the participant's authentic account,", + "sourceParagraph": 2166 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "plan, interface, memory, custom-instruction, and usage state while", + "sourceParagraph": 2167 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "retaining the locked prompt, first-eligible-output rule, evidence", + "sourceParagraph": 2168 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "requirements, and non-regeneration rule.", + "sourceParagraph": 2169 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Natural Account-State, Natural Conversation-State, First-Use, and Managed", + "sourceParagraph": 2171 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Natural observations MUST remain separately identified.", + "sourceParagraph": 2172 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Natural-state documentation MUST minimise private-data collection.", + "sourceParagraph": 2174 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Private instruction text, conversation history, identity, credentials,", + "sourceParagraph": 2175 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "and sensitive personal content MUST NOT be collected unless separately", + "sourceParagraph": 2176 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "necessary, consented, minimised, and access-controlled.", + "sourceParagraph": 2177 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "User-generated entity-favourable or entity-adverse instructions MAY be", + "sourceParagraph": 2179 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "measured as natural personalisation effects, but MUST NOT be represented", + "sourceParagraph": 2180 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "as general entity GEO success, failure, or default product behaviour.", + "sourceParagraph": 2181 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Personalisation MAY change relevance, presentation, and recommendation", + "sourceParagraph": 2183 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "where user context justifies it. It MUST NOT arbitrarily change verified", + "sourceParagraph": 2184 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "entity identity, license, legal status, price, scope, evidence, or time.", + "sourceParagraph": 2185 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Differences between Controlled and Natural panels MUST NOT be represented", + "sourceParagraph": 2187 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "as causal personalisation effects unless population, product, prompt,", + "sourceParagraph": 2188 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "time, interface, plan, tools, assignment, order, and carryover conditions", + "sourceParagraph": 2189 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "support that inference.", + "sourceParagraph": 2190 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Controlled and Natural scores, critical-error rates, unknown rates,", + "sourceParagraph": 2192 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "coverage, effective sample sizes, and signed and absolute panel gaps MUST", + "sourceParagraph": 2193 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "remain separately visible.", + "sourceParagraph": 2194 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Panel-state eligibility, reclassification, exclusion, and weighting MUST", + "sourceParagraph": 2196 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "remain independent of whether the AI output is positive, negative,", + "sourceParagraph": 2197 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "correct, incorrect, refused, critical, or commercially favourable.", + "sourceParagraph": 2198 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every panel-state definition, setting-change process, privacy decision,", + "sourceParagraph": 2200 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "comparison level, and result MUST be versioned and attributable to an", + "sourceParagraph": 2201 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "accountable human or organisation.", + "sourceParagraph": 2202 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 2203 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Observations of the Controlled Clean Panel and the Natural User Panel should be maintained as separate measurement populations, panel states, denominators, and public results. A new chat or temporary session tag alone does not prove that all persistent personalisation is disabled. The Natural User Panel should retain the real account, plan, interface, memory, custom instructions, and usage scenario while preserving the locked prompt, first appropriate output rule, evidence requirements, and non-refresh rule. User-driven favourable or unfavorable guidance can be measured as the effect of natural personalisation; it cannot be presented as general entity GEO success, failure, or default product behaviour. The difference between controlled and natural results cannot be interpreted as a causal personalisation effect without sufficiently matching populations and system conditions.", + "sourceParagraph": 2204 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Наблюдения Контролируемая панель в стандартизированных условиях и Панель пользователей в естественных условиях ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельными популяциями измерений, состояниями панели, знаменателями и публичными результатами. Контролируемая панель в стандартизированных условиях ДОЛЖНА определить и проверить, по мере необходимости: - новый и отдельный диалог, - отсутствие контекста предыдущего диалога, - состояние постоянной памяти, - состояние пользовательских инструкций, - состояние корпоративного или управляемого рабочего пространства, - конфигурацию веб-сервисов, поиска и инструментов, - план, - пользовательский интерфейс, - версию промпта, - и уверенность в чистом состоянии. Метка нового диалога или временной сессии НЕ ДОЛЖНА, сама по себе, рассматриваться как доказательство того, что вся постоянная персонализация была отключена. Панель пользователей в естественных условиях ДОЛЖНА сохранять подлинный аккаунт участника, план, интерфейс, память, пользовательскую инструкцию и состояние использования, при этом сохраняя зафиксированный запрос, правило первого допустимого ответа, требования к доказательствам и правило запрета повторной генерации. Состояние подлинного аккаунта, состояние подлинного разговора, первое использование и управляемые наблюдения подлинного состояния ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельно идентифицированными. Документация подлинного состояния ДОЛЖНА минимизировать сбор личных данных. Текст личной инструкции, история разговоров, идентификация, учетные данные и конфиденциальный личный контент НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ собираться, если это не является отдельно необходимым, собираться с согласия, в минимальном объёме и с контролем доступа. Инструкции, благоприятные или неблагоприятные для сущности, созданные пользователем, МОГУТ рассматриваться как естественные эффекты персонализации, но НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ представляться как общий успех или неудача сущности, либо как стандартное поведение продукта. Персонализация МОЖЕТ изменять релевантность, презентацию и рекомендации, если это оправдано контекстом пользователя. Она НЕ ДОЛЖНА произвольно изменять проверенную идентичность сущности, лицензию, правовой статус, цену, сферу, доказательства или время. Различия между контролируемыми и естественными панелями НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ представляться как причинные эффекты персонализации, если условия популяции, продукта, запроса, времени, интерфейса, плана, инструментов, назначений, порядка и переноса не поддерживают такое заключение. Оценки контролируемой и естественной панелей, показатели критических ошибок, показатели неизвестных результатов, охват, эффективные размеры выборки, а также подписанные и абсолютные разрывы панели ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться видимыми отдельно. Право панели на состояние, реклассификация, исключение и взвешивание ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться независимыми от того, является ли вывод ИИ положительным, отрицательным, правильным, неправильным, отвергнутым, критическим или коммерчески выгодным. Каждое определение состояния панели, процесс изменения настроек, решение о конфиденциальности, уровень сравнения и результат ДОЛЖНЫ иметь версии и быть приписаны ответственному человеку или организации.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "77. ЗАПИСЬ СТАТУСА ПАНЕЛИ, ЧИТАЕМАЯ МАШИНОЙ", + "sourceParagraph": 1981, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 1982, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1983, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1984, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1985, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelStateRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1986, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelStateId\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1987, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1988, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductRecordId\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-PAID-W1-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1989, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptRecordId\": \"NGP-CORE-MIRROR-APPLE-SYNTH-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1990, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelRole\": \"КОНТРОЛИРУЕМАЯ_ЧИСТКА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1991, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelEligibility\": \"ПК-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1992, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetPopulation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1993, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"frameId\": \"NGP-СИНТ-ОРИОН-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1994, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationType\": \"ПОЛЬЗОВАТЕЛИ_ПРОДУКТА_ПОД_СТАНДАРТИЗИРОВАННЫМ_СОСТОЯНИЕМ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1995, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1996, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"controlledState\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1997, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"cleanStateConfidence\": \"CSC-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1998, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conversationState\": \"НОВЫЙ_РАЗГОВОР\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1999, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptIsFirstUserMessage\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2000, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"persistentMemory\": \"ВЫКЛ_ПРОВЕРЕННО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2001, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"customInstructions\": \"ВЫКЛ_ПРОВЕРЕННО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2002, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"priorConversationContext\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2003, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"enterpriseWorkspace\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2004, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"webMode\": \"ВКЛ_СТАНДАРТИЗИРОВАННЫЙ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2005, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"toolMode\": \"СТАНДАРТИЗИРОВАНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2006, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"plan\": \"ОПЛАЧИВАЕМЫЙ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2007, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"surface\": \"WEB\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2008, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"settingsChangedForStudy\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2009, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"participantConsentForSettingChange\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2010, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"restorationRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2011, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"restorationConfirmed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2012, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2013, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"measurement\": {\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2014, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"firstEligibleOutputRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2015, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseRegenerationAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2016, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"followUpAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2017, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptValidityRequired\": \"PV-1\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2018, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timestampUtc\": \"2026-08-18 T1 2:00:00 Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2019, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2020, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"privacy\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2021, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"privateInstructionContentCollected\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2022, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conversationHistoryCollected\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2023, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountCredentialsCollected\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2024, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2025, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2026, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelStateOwnerRole\": \"PANEL_STATE_METHODS_LEAD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2027, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validatedByRole\": \"BLINDED_PANEL_STATE_REVIEWER\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2028, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2029, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2030, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2031, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "78. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМАЯ ЗАПИСЬ ЕСТЕСТВЕННОЙ ПАНЕЛИ", + "sourceParagraph": 2033, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2034, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2035, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2036, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2037, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelStateRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2038, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelStateId\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-002\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2039, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2040, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductRecordId\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-PAID-W1-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2041, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptRecordId\": \"NGP-CORE-MIRROR-APPLE-SYNTH-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2042, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelRole\": \"NATURAL_ACCOUNT_STATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2043, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelEligibility\": \"ПК-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2044, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetPopulation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2045, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"frameId\": \"NGP-SYNTH-ORION-ACTIVE-USERS-W1-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2046, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationType\": \"DEFINED_ACTIVE_PRODUCT_USERS\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2047, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2048, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"naturalState\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2049, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"naturalStateConfidence\": \"NSF-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2050, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conversationState\": \"НОВЫЙ_РАЗГОВОР\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2051, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptIsFirstUserMessage\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2052, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"persistentMemory\": \"MS-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2053, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"customInstructions\": \"CI-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2054, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"priorConversationContext\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2055, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"priorEntityConversation\": \"ВОЗМОЖНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2056, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"enterpriseWorkspace\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2057, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"webMode\": \"ПРИРОДНОЕ СОСТОЯНИЕ ПОЛЬЗОВАТЕЛЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2058, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"toolMode\": \"ПРИРОДНОЕ СОСТОЯНИЕ ПОЛЬЗОВАТЕЛЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2059, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"plan\": \"ОПЛАЧИВАЕМЫЙ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2060, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"surface\": \"WEB\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2061, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountAgeBand\": \"181_ДО_365_ДНЕЙ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2062, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"usageFrequency\": \"ЕЖЕНЕДЕЛЬНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2063, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"firstUse\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2064, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2065, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"measurement\": {\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2066, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"firstEligibleOutputRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2067, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseRegenerationAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2068, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"followUpAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2069, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptValidityRequired\": \"PV-1\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2070, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timestampUtc\": \"2026-08-18 T1 2:05:00 Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2071, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2072, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"privacy\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2073, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"memoryContentCollected\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2074, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"customInstructionContentCollected\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2075, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conversationHistoryCollected\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2076, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"highLevelStateOnly\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2077, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2078, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2079, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelStateOwnerRole\": \"PANEL_STATE_METHODS_LEAD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2080, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validatedByRole\": \"BLINDED_PANEL_STATE_REVIEWER\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2081, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2082, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2083, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2084, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "79. ЗАПИСЬ СРАВНЕНИЯ ПАНЕЛИ, ЧИТАЕМОЙ МАШИНОЙ", + "sourceParagraph": 2086, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2087, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2088, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2089, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2090, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelComparison\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2091, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonId\": \"NGPC-SYNTH-ORION-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2092, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"controlledPanelRecord\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2093, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"naturalPanelRecord\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-002\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2094, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparabilityLevel\": \"CN-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2095, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"matchedDimensions\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2096, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProduct\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2097, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptVersion\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2098, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityTruthPack\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2099, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"страна\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2100, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"локаль\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2101, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"measurementWindow\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2102, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationRules\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2103, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2104, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unmatchedDimensions\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2105, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"память\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2106, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"customInstructions\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2107, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"planDistribution\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2108, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"userHistory\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2109, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"toolState\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2110, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2111, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"результаты\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2112, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"controlledRepresentationScore\": 0.92,", + "sourceParagraph": 2113, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"naturalRepresentationScore\": 0.83,", + "sourceParagraph": 2114, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"signedNaturalGap\": -0.09,", + "sourceParagraph": 2115, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"absolutePanelGap\": 0.09,", + "sourceParagraph": 2116, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"controlledCriticalRate\": 0.002,", + "sourceParagraph": 2117, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"naturalCriticalRate\": 0.012,", + "sourceParagraph": 2118, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalRateDifference\": 0.01", + "sourceParagraph": 2119, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2120, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"allowedClaims\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2121, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NATURAL_PANEL_RESULT_LOWER_THAN_CONTROLLED_REFERENCE\",\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2122, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PANEL_STATE_ASSOCIATION_REQUIRES_FURTHER_DECOMPOSITION\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2123, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2124, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"prohibitedClaims\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2125, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"MEMORY_CAUSED_NINE_POINT_DECLINE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2126, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ALL_NATURAL_USERS_RECEIVE_WORSE_RESPONSES\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2127, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"BASE_MODEL_PERFORMANCE_DECLINED\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2128, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2129, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"replicationStatus\": \"ОДНА ВОЛНА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2130, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2131, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"comparisonOwnerRole\": \"PANEL_COMPARABILITY_ADJUDICATOR\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2132, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2133, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2134, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2135, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Эти записи:", + "sourceParagraph": 2136, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "не являются:", + "sourceParagraph": 2137, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальным пользователем,", + "sourceParagraph": 2138, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальным продуктом ИИ,", + "sourceParagraph": 2139, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальной производительностью компании.", + "sourceParagraph": 2140, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Это машинно-читаемое синтетическое представление различий панели.", + "sourceParagraph": 2141, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "МАШИНОЧИТАЕМОЕ ПРАВИЛО РАЗДЕЛА 80", + "sourceParagraph": 2143, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH11-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2144, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Наблюдения Контролируемая панель в стандартизированных условиях и Панель пользователей в естественных условиях ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться", + "sourceParagraph": 2146, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "отдельные популяции измерений, состояния панели, знаменатели и общедоступные", + "sourceParagraph": 2147, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "результаты.", + "sourceParagraph": 2148, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Контролируемая панель в стандартизированных условиях ДОЛЖЕН определить и проверить, по мере необходимости:", + "sourceParagraph": 2150, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- новую и отдельную беседу,", + "sourceParagraph": 2152, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- отсутствие контекста предыдущей беседы,", + "sourceParagraph": 2153, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- состояние постоянной памяти,", + "sourceParagraph": 2154, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- состояние пользовательских инструкций,", + "sourceParagraph": 2155, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- состояние корпоративного или управляемого рабочего пространства,", + "sourceParagraph": 2156, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- конфигурацию веб, поиска и инструментов,", + "sourceParagraph": 2157, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- план,", + "sourceParagraph": 2158, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- пользовательский интерфейс,", + "sourceParagraph": 2159, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- версию промпта,", + "sourceParagraph": 2160, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и уверенность в чистом состоянии.", + "sourceParagraph": 2161, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Новая беседа или временная метка сессии НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ, сами по себе, быть", + "sourceParagraph": 2163, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "рассматривается как доказательство того, что вся устойчивая персонализация была отключена.", + "sourceParagraph": 2164, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Панель пользователей в естественных условиях ДОЛЖЕН сохранять подлинную учетную запись участника,", + "sourceParagraph": 2166, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "план, интерфейс, память, пользовательскую инструкцию и состояние использования, при этом", + "sourceParagraph": 2167, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "сохраняя зафиксированный запрос, правило первого доступного вывода, требования к доказательствам", + "sourceParagraph": 2168, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "и правило не регенерации.", + "sourceParagraph": 2169, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Состояние подлинной учетной записи, состояние подлинного разговора, первый раз использования и управляемые", + "sourceParagraph": 2171, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "подлинные наблюдения ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельно идентифицированными.", + "sourceParagraph": 2172, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Документация состояния подлинности ДОЛЖНА минимизировать сбор личных данных.", + "sourceParagraph": 2174, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Личный текст инструкций, история разговоров, личность, учетные данные,", + "sourceParagraph": 2175, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "и чувствительные персональные данные НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ собираться, если не отдельно", + "sourceParagraph": 2176, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "необходимо, согласовано, минимизировано и контролируется доступ.", + "sourceParagraph": 2177, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Инструкции, благоприятные или неблагоприятные для объекта, СОЗДАННЫЕ ПОЛЬЗОВАТЕЛЕМ, МОГУТ быть", + "sourceParagraph": 2179, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "измеряется как эффекты естественной персонализации, но НЕ ДОЛЖНО быть представлено", + "sourceParagraph": 2180, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "как общее поведение объекта GEO: успех, неудача или стандартное поведение продукта.", + "sourceParagraph": 2181, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Персонализация МОЖЕТ изменять релевантность, представление и рекомендации", + "sourceParagraph": 2183, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "где это оправдано контекстом пользователя. НЕЛЬЗЯ произвольно изменять проверенное", + "sourceParagraph": 2184, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "идентичность сущности, лицензия, правовой статус, цена, объем, доказательства или время.", + "sourceParagraph": 2185, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Различия между контролируемыми и естественными панелями НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ представляться", + "sourceParagraph": 2187, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "как эффект причинной персонализации, если население, продукт, запрос,", + "sourceParagraph": 2188, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "время, интерфейс, план, инструменты, назначение, порядок и условия переноса", + "sourceParagraph": 2189, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "не поддерживают такое заключение.", + "sourceParagraph": 2190, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Счётчики контролируемых и естественных панелей, показатели критических ошибок, показатели неизвестных,", + "sourceParagraph": 2192, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "покрытие, эффективные размеры выборки, а также знаковые и абсолютные разрывы панели ДОЛЖНЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2193, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "оставаться видимыми отдельно.", + "sourceParagraph": 2194, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "квалификация состояния панели, переклассификация, исключение и взвешивание ДОЛЖНЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2196, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "оставаться независимыми от того, является ли результат ИИ положительным, отрицательным,", + "sourceParagraph": 2197, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "правильным, неправильным, отклонённым, критическим или коммерчески выгодным.", + "sourceParagraph": 2198, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждое определение панели состояния, процесс изменения настроек, решение о конфиденциальности,", + "sourceParagraph": 2200, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "уровень сравнения, а результат ДОЛЖЕН иметь версию и быть приписан к", + "sourceParagraph": 2201, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ответственный человек или организация.", + "sourceParagraph": 2202, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 2203, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH11-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Наблюдения за Контролируемая панель в стандартизированных условиях и Панель пользователей в естественных условиях должны поддерживаться как отдельные популяции измерений, состояния панели, знаменатели и публичные результаты. Новый чат или временный метка сессии сам по себе не доказывает, что вся постоянная персонализация отключена. Панель пользователей в естественных условиях должен сохранять реальный аккаунт, план, интерфейс, память, пользовательские инструкции и сценарий использования при сохранении зафиксированного запроса, правила первого соответствующего вывода, требований к доказательствам и правила не обновления. Руководство, предоставляемое пользователем и имеющее положительный или отрицательный эффект, можно измерять как эффект естественной персонализации; его нельзя представлять как общий успех, неудачу или стандартное поведение продукта для организации GEO. Разницу между контролируемыми и естественными результатами нельзя интерпретировать как причинный эффект персонализации без достаточного сопоставления популяций и условий системы.", + "sourceParagraph": 2204, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 12, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH12", + "title": "Синхронные волны и фиксация NOMOS", + "subtitle": null, + "sourceIds": [ + "K12", + "K14", + "K25", + "K26" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH12-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "Every GEO-1000 observation MUST be linked to a predeclared and versioned measurement wave defining: - AI product states, - population and sample frames, - panel states, - prompt versions, - UTC dispatch window, - randomised micro-slots, - completion and capture deadlines, - technical-retry rules, - capture schema, - reference-record versions, - and governance ownership. Synchronisation MUST mean observation within a declared UTC system-state window and assigned slot structure. It MUST NOT be represented as perfect millisecond simultaneity. Every observation MUST preserve, as available: - assignment time, - prompt-submission time, - first system event, - response-completion time, - capture time, - hash-creation time, - upload time, - and server-acceptance time. The first contact outcome MUST remain visible. A technical retry MAY be used only under predeclared infrastructure-failure conditions and MUST retain every prior attempt. Incorrect, unfavorable, refused, uncited, truncated, or critical outputs MUST NOT be regenerated, replaced, or excluded merely because of their content. A NOMOS Capture evidence bundle MUST retain the exact assigned and sent prompt, complete raw response, full visual evidence, system-state metadata, attempt log, time evidence, file hashes, bundle hash, capture tool version, privacy status, and blinded capture-validity decision. A screenshot, hash, digital signature, provider log, or timestamp MUST NOT individually be represented as complete proof of observation authenticity. Raw evidence MUST remain immutable or append-only. Redactions, corrections, withdrawals, exclusions, and adjudication changes MUST create linked versions and preserve the prior record where ethically and legally permissible. Material AI-product changes or external events during a wave MUST be time-recorded and handled through sub-waves, explicit modelling, restarting, or mixed-state warnings. Capture validity MUST be decided independently of semantic correctness. Public evidence manifests MUST support verification without unnecessarily exposing participant identity, credentials, private conversation history, or precise location. NOMOS Capture compliance MUST be implementable through open, equivalent evidence systems and MUST NOT depend exclusively on a proprietary tool controlled by the standard's founder. Every wave, evidence bundle, capture decision, manifest revision, and integrity record MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Her GEO-1000 gözlemi; AI ürün durumlarını, nüfus ve örneklem çerçevelerini, panel koşullarını, prompt sürümlerini, UTC gönderim penceresini, rastgele mikro-slotları, tamamlama ve capture sürelerini, teknik yeniden deneme kurallarını, capture şemasını, referans kayıtlarını ve yönetişim sahibini tanımlayan önceden kayıtlı bir ölçüm dalgasına bağlanmalıdır. Eşzamanlılık, kusursuz milisaniye eşitliği değil; tanımlı UTC sistem penceresi ve slot yapısı içinde gözlem üretimidir. İlk temas sonucu görünür kalmalı; yanlış, olumsuz, ret, citation’sız veya Critical cevaplar içerikleri nedeniyle yenilenememeli, değiştirilememeli veya dışlanamamalıdır.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "82. MACHINE-READABLE WAVE RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2058 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 2059 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2060 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2061 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2062 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"measurementWave\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2063 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"NGW-SYNTH-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2064 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveType\": \"MW-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2065 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"WS-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2066 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"healthStatus\": \"WH-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2067 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"purpose\": \"PRINCIPAL_POPULATION_ESTIMATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2068 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systems\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2069 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"registryVersion\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-REGISTRY-W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2070 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productCount\": 10", + "sourceParagraph": 2071 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2072 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"population\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2073 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"frameVersion\": \"NGP-SYNTH-W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2074 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sampleAllocationVersion\": \"NGS-SYNTH-W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2075 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetValidPerProduct\": 1000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2076 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetValidTotal\": 10000", + "sourceParagraph": 2077 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2078 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"prompts\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2079 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"registryVersion\": \"NGPR-SYNTH-W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2080 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"corePromptVersion\": \"1.0.0\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2081 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2082 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelStates\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2083 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"controlledCleanVersion\": \"NGPS-CLEAN-W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2084 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"naturalUserVersion\": \"NGPS-NATURAL-W1\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2085 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2086 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timing\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2087 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timeStandard\": \"UTC\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2088 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"dispatchWindowStart\": \"2026-09-01T12:00:00Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2089 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"dispatchWindowEnd\": \"2026-09-01T13:00:00Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2090 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"microSlotMinutes\": 5,", + "sourceParagraph": 2091 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"microSlotCount\": 12,", + "sourceParagraph": 2092 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"completionGraceMinutes\": 20,", + "sourceParagraph": 2093 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureTargetMinutesAfterCompletion\": 5,", + "sourceParagraph": 2094 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"uploadDeadlineMinutesAfterCapture\": 60,", + "sourceParagraph": 2095 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"slotAssignmentLocked\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2096 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2097 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"capture\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2098 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"schemaVersion\": \"NOMOS-CAPTURE-0.9\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2099 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"minimumCaptureLevel\": \"NCL-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2100 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"toolVersion\": \"SYNTH-CAPTURE-2.1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2101 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"firstEligibleOutputRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2102 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseRegenerationAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2103 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"technicalRetryPolicy\": \"PREDECLARED_TECHNICAL_FAILURES_ONLY\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2104 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2105 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"events\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2106 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systemChangeEvents\": [],", + "sourceParagraph": 2107 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"externalEventRegisterVersion\": \"NGER-SYNTH-W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2108 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"mixedSystemState\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2109 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2110 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fieldwork\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2111 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"invited\": 13240,", + "sourceParagraph": 2112 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"completed\": 10870,", + "sourceParagraph": 2113 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureValid\": 10106,", + "sourceParagraph": 2114 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"mainAnalysisIncluded\": 10000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2115 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validReserve\": 106,", + "sourceParagraph": 2116 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"withdrawn\": 0", + "sourceParagraph": 2117 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2118 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2119 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"observationBundleCount\": 10106,", + "sourceParagraph": 2120 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveManifestHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-WAVE-MANIFEST-HASH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2121 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"merkleRoot\": \"SYNTHETIC-MERKLE-ROOT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2122 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicManifestPublished\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2123 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2124 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governance\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2125 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedBeforeFieldwork\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2126 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveOwnerRole\": \"MEASUREMENT_WAVE_DIRECTOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2127 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureOwnerRole\": \"EVIDENCE_CHAIN_CUSTODIAN\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2128 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"closedAt\": \"2026-09-01T15:30:00Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2129 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2130 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2131 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2132 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "83. MACHINE-READABLE OBSERVATION PACKAGE", + "sourceParagraph": 2134 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 2135 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2136 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2137 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2138 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"observationBundle\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2139 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"observationId\": \"NGO-SYNTH-W1-ORION-TR-000184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2140 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"NGW-SYNTH-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2141 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"participantId\": \"NGU-SYNTH-000184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2142 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiSystemRecordId\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-PAID-W1-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2143 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelStateRecordId\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2144 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptRecordId\": \"NGP-CORE-MIRROR-APPLE-SYNTH-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2145 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"slot\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2146 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"slotId\": \"W1-S04\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2147 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"startUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:15:00Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2148 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"endUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:20:00Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2149 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"submittedWithinSlot\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2150 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2151 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timeVector\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2152 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"assignedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T11:00:00Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2153 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"taskOpenedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:14:20Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2154 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptSubmittedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:16:08Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2155 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"firstSystemEventAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:16:10Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2156 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseCompletedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:16:24Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2157 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"capturedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:16:39Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2158 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"localHashCreatedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:16:41Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2159 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"uploadedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:17:12Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2160 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"serverAcceptedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:17:13Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2161 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"clockOffsetMilliseconds\": 420", + "sourceParagraph": 2162 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2163 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attempts\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2164 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2165 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attemptNumber\": 1,", + "sourceParagraph": 2166 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"firstContactOutcome\": \"COMPLETE_RESPONSE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2167 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"technicalRetry\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2168 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"firstEligibleContentOutput\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2169 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2170 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2171 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"prompt\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2172 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"assignedHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-TR-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2173 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sentHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-TR-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2174 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validity\": \"PV-1\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2175 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2176 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"response\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2177 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"COMPLETE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2178 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"regenerated\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2179 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"userInterrupted\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2180 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rawTextArtifactId\": \"ART-RAW-TEXT-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2181 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"visualArtifactIds\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2182 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ART-SCREEN-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2183 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ART-SCREEN-002\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2184 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2185 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationCount\": 0", + "sourceParagraph": 2186 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2187 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"capture\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2188 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"method\": \"CM-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2189 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureLevel\": \"NCL-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2190 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"toolName\": \"Synthetic NOMOS-Compatible Capture\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2191 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"toolVersion\": \"2.1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2192 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fullPromptVisible\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2193 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fullResponseVisible\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2194 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systemStateCaptured\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2195 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2196 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2197 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"artifactHashes\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2198 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ART-RAW-TEXT-001\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-RAW\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2199 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ART-SCREEN-001\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-SCREEN-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2200 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ART-SCREEN-002\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-SCREEN-2\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2201 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2202 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"bundleHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-BUNDLE-HASH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2203 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"digitalSignature\": \"SYNTHETIC-SIGNATURE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2204 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedInWaveMerkleRoot\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2205 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2206 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"privacy\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2207 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rawEvidenceAccess\": \"RESTRICTED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2208 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"auditDerivativeCreated\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2209 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicDerivativeCreated\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2210 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"identityRedacted\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2211 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"privateConversationCaptured\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2212 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2213 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2214 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureValidity\": \"CV-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2215 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validatedBeforeSemanticScoring\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2216 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validatorRole\": \"BLINDED_CAPTURE_VALIDATOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2217 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validatedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-02T08:00:00Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2218 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2219 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"semanticAdjudication\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2220 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"PENDING\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2221 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2222 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2223 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2224 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "These records:", + "sourceParagraph": 2225 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "to the real participant,", + "sourceParagraph": 2226 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "to the real AI product,", + "sourceParagraph": 2227 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "to the real company", + "sourceParagraph": 2228 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "it does not belong.", + "sourceParagraph": 2229 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "It is the machine-readable synthetic representation of the synchronised wave and NOMOS Capture proof chain.", + "sourceParagraph": 2230 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "84. MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF THE SECTION", + "sourceParagraph": 2232 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH12-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2233 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every GEO-1000 observation MUST be linked to a predeclared and versioned", + "sourceParagraph": 2235 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "measurement wave defining:", + "sourceParagraph": 2236 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- AI product states,", + "sourceParagraph": 2238 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- population and sample frames,", + "sourceParagraph": 2239 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- panel states,", + "sourceParagraph": 2240 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- prompt versions,", + "sourceParagraph": 2241 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- UTC dispatch window,", + "sourceParagraph": 2242 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- randomised micro-slots,", + "sourceParagraph": 2243 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- completion and capture deadlines,", + "sourceParagraph": 2244 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- technical-retry rules,", + "sourceParagraph": 2245 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- capture schema,", + "sourceParagraph": 2246 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- reference-record versions,", + "sourceParagraph": 2247 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and governance ownership.", + "sourceParagraph": 2248 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Synchronisation MUST mean observation within a declared UTC system-state", + "sourceParagraph": 2250 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "window and assigned slot structure. It MUST NOT be represented as", + "sourceParagraph": 2251 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "perfect millisecond simultaneity.", + "sourceParagraph": 2252 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every observation MUST preserve, as available:", + "sourceParagraph": 2254 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- assignment time,", + "sourceParagraph": 2256 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- prompt-submission time,", + "sourceParagraph": 2257 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- first system event,", + "sourceParagraph": 2258 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- response-completion time,", + "sourceParagraph": 2259 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- capture time,", + "sourceParagraph": 2260 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- hash-creation time,", + "sourceParagraph": 2261 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- upload time,", + "sourceParagraph": 2262 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and server-acceptance time.", + "sourceParagraph": 2263 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The first contact outcome MUST remain visible. A technical retry MAY be", + "sourceParagraph": 2265 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "used only under predeclared infrastructure-failure conditions and MUST", + "sourceParagraph": 2266 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "retain every prior attempt.", + "sourceParagraph": 2267 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Incorrect, unfavorable, refused, uncited, truncated, or critical outputs", + "sourceParagraph": 2269 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MUST NOT be regenerated, replaced, or excluded merely because of their", + "sourceParagraph": 2270 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "content.", + "sourceParagraph": 2271 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A NOMOS Capture evidence bundle MUST retain the exact assigned and sent", + "sourceParagraph": 2273 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "prompt, complete raw response, full visual evidence, system-state", + "sourceParagraph": 2274 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "metadata, attempt log, time evidence, file hashes, bundle hash, capture", + "sourceParagraph": 2275 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0209", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "tool version, privacy status, and blinded capture-validity decision.", + "sourceParagraph": 2276 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0210", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A screenshot, hash, digital signature, provider log, or timestamp MUST", + "sourceParagraph": 2278 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0211", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOT individually be represented as complete proof of observation", + "sourceParagraph": 2279 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0212", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "authenticity.", + "sourceParagraph": 2280 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0213", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Raw evidence MUST remain immutable or append-only. Redactions,", + "sourceParagraph": 2282 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0214", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "corrections, withdrawals, exclusions, and adjudication changes MUST", + "sourceParagraph": 2283 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0215", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "create linked versions and preserve the prior record where ethically and", + "sourceParagraph": 2284 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0216", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "legally permissible.", + "sourceParagraph": 2285 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0217", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Material AI-product changes or external events during a wave MUST be", + "sourceParagraph": 2287 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0218", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "time-recorded and handled through sub-waves, explicit modelling,", + "sourceParagraph": 2288 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0219", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "restarting, or mixed-state warnings.", + "sourceParagraph": 2289 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0220", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Capture validity MUST be decided independently of semantic correctness.", + "sourceParagraph": 2291 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0221", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Public evidence manifests MUST support verification without", + "sourceParagraph": 2293 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0222", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "unnecessarily exposing participant identity, credentials, private", + "sourceParagraph": 2294 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0223", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "conversation history, or precise location.", + "sourceParagraph": 2295 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0224", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOMOS Capture compliance MUST be implementable through open, equivalent", + "sourceParagraph": 2297 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0225", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "evidence systems and MUST NOT depend exclusively on a proprietary tool", + "sourceParagraph": 2298 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0226", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "controlled by the standard's founder.", + "sourceParagraph": 2299 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0227", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every wave, evidence bundle, capture decision, manifest revision, and", + "sourceParagraph": 2301 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0228", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "integrity record MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable", + "sourceParagraph": 2302 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0229", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "human or organisation.", + "sourceParagraph": 2303 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0230", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 2304 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0231", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Each GEO-1000 observation must be linked to a pre-registered measurement wave that identifies AI product states, population and sample frames, panel conditions, prompt versions, UTC submission window, random micro-slots, completion and capture times, technical retry rules, capture schema, reference records, and governance owner. Concurrency is not perfect millisecond equality; it is the production of observations within a defined UTC system window and slot structure. It must remain visible as a first-touch result; incorrect, negative, rejected, citation-less, or Critical responses may not be renewed, altered, or excluded due to their content.", + "sourceParagraph": 2305 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Каждое наблюдение GEO-1000 ДОЛЖНО быть связано с заранее объявленной и версионированной измерительной волной, определяющей: - состояния ИИ-продукта, - рамки популяции и выборки, - состояния панели, - версии промптов, - окно отправки UTC, - случайные микрослоты, - сроки завершения и захвата, - правила технической повторной попытки, - схему захвата, - версии эталонных записей, - и управление владением. Синхронизация ДОЛЖНА означать наблюдение в пределах объявленного окна состояния системы UTC и присвоенной структурой слотов. Оно НЕ ДОЛЖНО представляться как идеальная миллисекундная одновременность. Каждое наблюдение ДОЛЖНО сохранять, по возможности: - время назначения, - время подачи задания, - первое системное событие, - время завершения ответа, - время фиксации, - время создания хэша, - время загрузки и - время принятия сервером. Результат первого контакта ДОЛЖЕН оставаться видимым. Техническая повторная попытка МОЖЕТ использоваться только при заранее объявленных условиях отказа инфраструктуры и ДОЛЖНА сохранять все предыдущие попытки. Некорректные, неблагоприятные, отклонённые, нецитированные, усечённые или критические результаты НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ генерироваться повторно, заменяться или исключаться просто из-за их содержания. Пакет захвата доказательств NOMOS ДОЛЖЕН сохранять точно назначенный и отправленный запрос, полный необработанный ответ, все визуальные доказательства, метаданные состояния системы, журнал попыток, временные доказательства, хэши файлов, хэш пакета, версию инструмента захвата, статус конфиденциальности и решение о допустимости захвата с ограниченным доступом. Скриншот, хэш, цифровая подпись, журнал поставщика или отметка времени НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ отдельно представляться в качестве полного доказательства подлинности наблюдения. Необработанные доказательства ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться неизменными или допускающими только добавление. Редактирования, исправления, выводы из обращения, исключения и изменения по результатам рассмотрения ДОЛЖНЫ создавать связанные версии и сохранять предыдущую запись, где это этически и законно допустимо. Материальные изменения ИИ-продукта или внешние события во время волны ДОЛЖНЫ фиксироваться по времени и обрабатываться через субволны, явное моделирование, перезапуск или предупреждения о смешанном состоянии. Достоверность захвата ДОЛЖНА определяться независимо от семантической корректности. Публичные свидетельства ДОЛЖНЫ обеспечивать проверку без ненужного раскрытия личности участников, учетных данных, истории частных разговоров или точного местоположения. Соответствие захвата NOMOS ДОЛЖНО быть реализуемым через открытые, эквивалентные системы доказательств и НЕ ДОЛЖНО зависеть исключительно от проприетарного инструмента, контролируемого основателем стандарта. Каждая волна, пакет доказательств, решение о захвате, пересмотр манифеста и запись целостности ДОЛЖНЫ версионироваться и быть атрибутированы ответственному человеку или организации.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "82. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ ЗАПИСЬ ВОЛНЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2058, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2059, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2060, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2061, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2062, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"measurementWave\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2063, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"NGW-SYNTH-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2064, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveType\": \"MW-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2065, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"WS-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2066, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"healthStatus\": \"WH-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2067, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"purpose\": \"PRINCIPAL_POPULATION_ESTIMATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2068, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systems\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2069, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"registryVersion\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-REGISTRY-W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2070, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productCount\": 10", + "sourceParagraph": 2071, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2072, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"population\": {\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2073, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"frameVersion\": \"NGP-SYNTH-W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2074, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sampleAllocationVersion\": \"NGS-SYNTH-W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2075, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetValidPerProduct\": 1000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2076, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetValidTotal\": 10000", + "sourceParagraph": 2077, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2078, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"prompts\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2079, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"registryVersion\": \"NGPR-SYNTH-W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2080, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"corePromptVersion\": \"1.0.0\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2081, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2082, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelStates\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2083, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"controlledCleanVersion\": \"NGPS-CLEAN-W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2084, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"naturalUserVersion\": \"NGPS-NATURAL-W1\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2085, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2086, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timing\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2087, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timeStandard\": \"UTC\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2088, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"dispatchWindowStart\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:00:00 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2089, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"dispatchWindowEnd\": \"2026-09-01 T1 3:00:00 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2090, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"microSlotMinutes\": 5,", + "sourceParagraph": 2091, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"microSlotCount\": 12,", + "sourceParagraph": 2092, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"completionGraceMinutes\": 20,", + "sourceParagraph": 2093, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureTargetMinutesAfterCompletion\": 5,", + "sourceParagraph": 2094, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"uploadDeadlineMinutesAfterCapture\": 60,", + "sourceParagraph": 2095, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"slotAssignmentLocked\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2096, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2097, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"capture\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2098, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"schemaVersion\": \"NOMOS-CAPTURE-0.9\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2099, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"minimumCaptureLevel\": \"NCL-3\",\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2100, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"toolVersion\": \"СИНТ-КАПТЮР-2.1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2101, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"firstEligibleOutputRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2102, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseRegenerationAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2103, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"technicalRetryPolicy\": \"ТОЛЬКО ПРЕДОБЪЯВЛЕННЫЕ ТЕХНИЧЕСКИЕ СБОИ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2104, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2105, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"события\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2106, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systemChangeEvents\": [],", + "sourceParagraph": 2107, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"externalEventRegisterVersion\": \"NGER-СИНТ-W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2108, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"mixedSystemState\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2109, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2110, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fieldwork\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2111, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"приглашенные\": 13240,", + "sourceParagraph": 2112, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"завершенные\": 10870,", + "sourceParagraph": 2113, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureValid\": 10106,", + "sourceParagraph": 2114, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"mainAnalysisIncluded\": 10000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2115, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validReserve\": 106,", + "sourceParagraph": 2116, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"отозванные\": 0", + "sourceParagraph": 2117, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2118, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2119, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"observationBundleCount\": 10106,", + "sourceParagraph": 2120, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveManifestHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ВОЛНОВОЙ-МАНИФЕСТ-ХЭШ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2121, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"merkleRoot\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-КОРЕНЬ-MERKLE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2122, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicManifestPublished\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2123, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2124, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"управление\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2125, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedBeforeFieldwork\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2126, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveOwnerRole\": \"РЕЖИССЕР_ВОЙНЫ_ИЗМЕРЕНИЙ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2127, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureOwnerRole\": \"ХРАНИТЕЛЬ_ЦЕПОЧКИ_ДОКАЗАТЕЛЬСТВ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2128, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"closedAt\": \"2026-09-01 T1 5:30:00 Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2129, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2130, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2131, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2132, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "83. ПАКЕТ НАБЛЮДЕНИЙ, ЧИТАЕМЫЙ МАШИНОЙ", + "sourceParagraph": 2134, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2135, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2136, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2137, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2138, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"observationBundle\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2139, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"observationId\": \"NGO-SYNTH-W1-ORION-TR-000184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2140, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"NGW-SYNTH-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2141, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"participantId\": \"NGU-SYNTH-000184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2142, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiSystemRecordId\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-PAID-W1-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2143, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelStateRecordId\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2144, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptRecordId\": \"NGP-CORE-MIRROR-APPLE-SYNTH-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2145, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"слот\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2146, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"slotId\": \"W1-S0 4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2147, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"startUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:15:00 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2148, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"endUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:20:00 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2149, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"submittedWithinSlot\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2150, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2151, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timeVector\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2152, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"assignedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 1:00:00 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2153, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"taskOpenedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:14:20 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2154, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptSubmittedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:16:08 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2155, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"firstSystemEventAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:16:10 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2156, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseCompletedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:16:24 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2157, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"capturedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:16:39 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2158, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"localHashCreatedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:16:41 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2159, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"uploadedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:17:12 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2160, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"serverAcceptedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:17:13 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2161, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"clockOffsetMilliseconds\": 420", + "sourceParagraph": 2162, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2163, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"попытки\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2164, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2165, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attemptNumber\": 1,", + "sourceParagraph": 2166, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"firstContactOutcome\": \"ПОЛНЫЙ_ОТВЕТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2167, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"technicalRetry\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2168, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"firstEligibleContentOutput\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2169, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2170, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2171, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"промпт\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2172, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"assignedHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ХЭШ-TR-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2173, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sentHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ХЭШ-TR-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2174, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"действительность\": \"PV-1\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2175, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2176, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ответ\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2177, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"статус\": \"ЗАВЕРШЕННО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2178, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"регенерировано\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2179, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"userInterrupted\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2180, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rawTextArtifactId\": \"АРТ-НЕОБРАБОТАННЫЙ-ТЕКСТ-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2181, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"visualArtifactIds\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2182, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ART-SCREEN-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2183, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ART-SCREEN-002\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2184, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2185, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationCount\": 0", + "sourceParagraph": 2186, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2187, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"capture\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2188, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"method\": \"CM-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2189, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureLevel\": \"NCL-4\",\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2190, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"toolName\": \"Синтетическая совместимая с NOMOS захват\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2191, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"toolVersion\": \"2.1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2192, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fullPromptVisible\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2193, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fullResponseVisible\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2194, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"systemStateCaptured\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2195, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2196, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2197, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"artifactHashes\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2198, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ART-RAW-TEXT-001\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ХЭШ-RAW\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2199, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ART-SCREEN-001\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ХЭШ-ЭКРАН-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2200, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ART-SCREEN-002\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ХЭШ-ЭКРАН-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2201, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2202, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"bundleHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ХЭШ-ПАКЕТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2203, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"digitalSignature\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКАЯ-ПОДПИСЬ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2204, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedInWaveMerkleRoot\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2205, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2206, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"privacy\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2207, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rawEvidenceAccess\": \"ОГРАНИЧЕННО\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2208, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"auditDerivativeCreated\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2209, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicDerivativeCreated\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2210, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"identityRedacted\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2211, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"privateConversationCaptured\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2212, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2213, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2214, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureValidity\": \"CV-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2215, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validatedBeforeSemanticScoring\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2216, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validatorRole\": \"BLINDED_CAPTURE_VALIDATOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2217, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validatedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-02 T0 8:00:00 Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2218, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2219, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"semanticAdjudication\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2220, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"ОЖИДАЕТСЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2221, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2222, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2223, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2224, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Эти записи:", + "sourceParagraph": 2225, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "к реальному участнику,", + "sourceParagraph": 2226, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "к настоящему продукту ИИ,", + "sourceParagraph": 2227, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "к реальной компании", + "sourceParagraph": 2228, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "это не относится.", + "sourceParagraph": 2229, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Это синтетическое представление в машиночитаемом виде синхронизированной волны и цепочки доказательств захвата NOMOS.", + "sourceParagraph": 2230, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "84. ПРАВИЛО РАЗДЕЛА, ЧИТАЕМОЕ МАШИНОЙ", + "sourceParagraph": 2232, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH12-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2233, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждое наблюдение GEO-1000 ДОЛЖНО быть связано с заранее объявленной и версионированной", + "sourceParagraph": 2235, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "измерительной волной, определяющей:", + "sourceParagraph": 2236, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- состояния продукта ИИ,", + "sourceParagraph": 2238, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- популяционные и выборочные рамки,", + "sourceParagraph": 2239, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- состояния панели,", + "sourceParagraph": 2240, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- версии промптов,", + "sourceParagraph": 2241, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- окно отправки UTC,", + "sourceParagraph": 2242, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- рандомизированные микро-слоты,", + "sourceParagraph": 2243, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- сроки завершения и захвата,", + "sourceParagraph": 2244, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- правила технических повторов,", + "sourceParagraph": 2245, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- схема захвата,", + "sourceParagraph": 2246, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- версии эталонных записей,", + "sourceParagraph": 2247, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и управление владением.", + "sourceParagraph": 2248, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Синхронизация ДОЛЖНА означать наблюдение в пределах заявленного состояния системы UTC", + "sourceParagraph": 2250, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "окна и назначенной структуры слотов. Она НЕ ДОЛЖНА представляться как", + "sourceParagraph": 2251, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "идеальная миллисекундная одновременность.", + "sourceParagraph": 2252, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждое наблюдение ДОЛЖНО сохранять, по возможности:", + "sourceParagraph": 2254, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- время назначения задания,", + "sourceParagraph": 2256, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- время подачи запроса,", + "sourceParagraph": 2257, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- первое системное событие,", + "sourceParagraph": 2258, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- время завершения ответа,", + "sourceParagraph": 2259, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- время захвата,", + "sourceParagraph": 2260, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- время создания хэша,", + "sourceParagraph": 2261, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- время загрузки,", + "sourceParagraph": 2262, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и время принятия сервером.", + "sourceParagraph": 2263, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Результат первого контакта ДОЛЖЕН оставаться видимым. Техническая повторная попытка МОЖЕТ быть", + "sourceParagraph": 2265, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "использована только при заранее объявленных условиях сбоя инфраструктуры и ДОЛЖНА", + "sourceParagraph": 2266, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "сохранять каждую предыдущую попытку.", + "sourceParagraph": 2267, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Некорректные, неблагоприятные, отклонённые, нецитируемые, усечённые или критические результаты", + "sourceParagraph": 2269, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "НЕ ДОЛЖЕН быть перегенерирован, заменён или исключён только из-за их", + "sourceParagraph": 2270, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "содержание.", + "sourceParagraph": 2271, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Пакет доказательств NOMOS MUST сохранять точно назначенные и отправленные", + "sourceParagraph": 2273, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "запрос, полный необработанный ответ, полные визуальные доказательства, состояние системы", + "sourceParagraph": 2274, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "метаданные, журнал попыток, временные доказательства, хэши файлов, хэш пакета, захват", + "sourceParagraph": 2275, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0209", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "версия инструмента, статус конфиденциальности и решение о допустимости захвата в слепом режиме.", + "sourceParagraph": 2276, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0210", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Скриншот, хэш, цифровая подпись, журнал провайдера или временная метка ДОЛЖНЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2278, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0211", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "НЕ могут индивидуально представлять собой полное доказательство наблюдения", + "sourceParagraph": 2279, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0212", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "подлинность.", + "sourceParagraph": 2280, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0213", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Сырые доказательства ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться неизменными или только для добавления. Исправления,", + "sourceParagraph": 2282, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0214", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "корректировки, отозвания, исключения и изменения в судебных решениях ДОЛЖНЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2283, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0215", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "создавать связанные версии и сохранять предыдущую запись там, где это этически и", + "sourceParagraph": 2284, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0216", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "законно разрешено.", + "sourceParagraph": 2285, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0217", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Существенные изменения продукта ИИ или внешние события во время волны ДОЛЖНЫ быть", + "sourceParagraph": 2287, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0218", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "записаны по времени и обработаны через подволны, явное моделирование,", + "sourceParagraph": 2288, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0219", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "перезапуск или предупреждения о смешанном состоянии.", + "sourceParagraph": 2289, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0220", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Достоверность захвата ДОЛЖНА определяться независимо от семантической правильности.", + "sourceParagraph": 2291, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0221", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Публичные манифесты доказательств ДОЛЖНЫ поддерживать проверку без", + "sourceParagraph": 2293, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0222", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ненужно раскрывая личность участников, учетные данные, приватную", + "sourceParagraph": 2294, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0223", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "историю переписки или точное местоположение.", + "sourceParagraph": 2295, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0224", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Соответствие требованиям захвата NOMOS ДОЛЖНО быть реализуемо через открытые, эквивалентные", + "sourceParagraph": 2297, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0225", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "системы доказательств и НЕ ДОЛЖНО зависеть исключительно от проприетарного инструмента,", + "sourceParagraph": 2298, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0226", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "контролируемого основателем стандарта.", + "sourceParagraph": 2299, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0227", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждая волна, пакет доказательств, решение о захвате, ревизия манифеста и", + "sourceParagraph": 2301, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0228", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "запись целостности ДОЛЖНЫ иметь версионность и быть приписаны ответственному лицу", + "sourceParagraph": 2302, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0229", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "человек или организация.", + "sourceParagraph": 2303, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0230", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 2304, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH12-MB0231", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждое наблюдение GEO-1000 должно быть связано с заранее зарегистрированной волной измерений, которая идентифицирует состояния ИИ-продукта, рамки популяции и выборки, условия панели, версии промптов, окно подачи UTC, случайные микро-слоты, время завершения и фиксации, правила технических повторных попыток, схему фиксации, справочные записи и владельца управления. Параллельность не означает идеальное совпадение миллисекунд; это производство наблюдений в рамках определенного системного окна и структуры слотов UTC. Оно должно оставаться видимым как результат первого обращения; неверные, отрицательные, отклоненные, без цитат или критические ответы не могут быть обновлены, изменены или исключены из-за их содержания.", + "sourceParagraph": 2305, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 13, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH13", + "title": "Пакет проверенных данных о сущности", + "subtitle": "Пакет проверенных данных о сущности", + "sourceIds": [ + "K10", + "K11", + "K12" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH13-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "Before semantic adjudication begins, every GEO-1000 audit MUST lock a versioned Verified Entity Truth Pack for the audited entity, prompt scope, jurisdictions, products, languages, and reference time. The Truth Pack MUST contain, as applicable: - canonical entity identity, - atomic reference claims, - Official Representation Records, - supporting evidence, - counter-evidence, - source-lineage and evidence-family records, - scope and jurisdiction qualifiers, - validity and publication times, - public and restricted access classes, - unknown and unresolved registers, - appeal and change records, - and an integrity manifest. An Official Representation Record MUST NOT be treated as independently verified reality merely because it is official. A first-party source MAY be authoritative for claims under the entity's direct control, while remaining non-independent for comparative, performance, leadership, or external-validation claims. Different URLs, publications, translations, syndications, or AI summaries MUST NOT be counted as independent evidence when they derive from the same root source. Every evidence object MUST state which atomic claim it supports, qualifies, contradicts, outdates, or contextualises. The absence of located evidence MUST NOT automatically be represented as proof that a claim is false. Open-world and closed-world evidence conditions MUST remain distinct. Quantitative claims MUST retain numerator, denominator, period, unit, inclusion and exclusion rules, source data, and calculation method. Customer, partner, license, certification, membership, award, legal, performance, and superiority claims MUST preserve their exact entity, relationship, scope, jurisdiction, time, and evidence status. Publicly discoverable evidence, restricted audit evidence, and non-public evidence MUST remain separately classified. A claim MAY be factually verified through restricted evidence without being publicly retrievable by a consumer AI product. Factual verification and public discoverability MUST remain distinct. Truth Pack claims MUST NOT be added, removed, broadened, narrowed, or reclassified after AI responses are observed unless a new Truth Pack version is created and prior records are preserved. A response claim not covered by the locked Truth Pack MUST trigger a reference-gap process rather than automatic failure or automatic acceptance. Unknown, unsupported, unresolved, contradicted, historical, expired, scope-limited, and restrictedly verified states MUST remain separately visible. The audited entity MAY submit evidence, corrections, and appeals, but MUST NOT act as the sole adjudicator of its own claims. AI systems MAY assist with extraction, normalisation, lineage detection, and contradiction discovery, but MUST NOT serve as the sole final authority for claim truth status. Every Truth Pack version, evidence registration, support-status decision, appeal, and change MUST be attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Semantik hakemlik başlamadan önce her GEO-1000 denetimi; denetlenen varlık, prompt kapsamı, ülkeler, ürünler, diller ve referans zamanı için sürümlü bir Doğrulanmış Varlık Gerçeklik Paketi kilitlemelidir. Paket kanonik varlık kimliğini, atomik referans iddialarını, Resmî Temsil Kayıtlarını, destekleyen kanıtı, karşı kanıtı, kaynak soyunu, kapsam ve zaman sınırlarını, erişim sınıflarını, bilinmeyenleri, itirazları ve bütünlük manifestini taşımalıdır. Resmî beyan yalnız resmî olduğu için bağımsız doğrulanmış gerçeklik sayılamaz. Farklı URL’ler aynı kök kaynaktan türemişse bağımsız kanıtlar olarak sayılamaz.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "92. MACHINE-READABLE TRUTH PACK RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2450 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 2451 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2452 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2453 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-25-COUNTRIES-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2454 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2455 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimType\": \"CT-05\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2456 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"predicate\": \"operatesInCountryCount\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2457 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 25,", + "sourceParagraph": 2458 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"VS-U\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2459 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeStatus\": \"SC-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2460 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timeStatus\": \"TS-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2461 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"officialRepresentationStatus\": \"OFFICIAL_CURRENT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2462 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicDiscoverability\": \"PUBLICLY_DISCOVERABLE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2463 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceLinks\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2464 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2465 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-WEB-025\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2466 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relationship\": \"SUPPORTS\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2467 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2468 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2469 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-OPS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2470 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relationship\": \"QUALIFIES\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2471 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2472 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2473 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"uncertainty\": \"The term operates is not defined consistently.\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2474 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2475 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2476 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidence\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2477 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2478 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-WEB-025\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2479 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceRole\": \"SR-01\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2480 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"title\": \"Asteron Global Presence Page\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2481 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceControl\": \"AUDITED_ENTITY_CONTROLLED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2482 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"authorityForClaim\": \"OFFICIAL_SELF_REPRESENTATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2483 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independence\": \"NOT_INDEPENDENT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2484 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publishedAt\": \"2026-01-10\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2485 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"capturedAt\": \"2026-08-30T14:00:00Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2486 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accessClass\": \"EA-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2487 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lineageFamilyId\": \"EVIDENCE-FAMILY-ASTERON-SELF-CLAIM-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2488 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-WEB-025\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2489 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2490 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2491 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-OPS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2492 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceRole\": \"SR-02\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2493 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"title\": \"Verified Active Operations Register\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2494 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceControl\": \"AUDITED_ENTITY_CONTROLLED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2495 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"authorityForClaim\": \"DIRECT_OPERATIONAL_RECORD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2496 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independence\": \"NOT_INDEPENDENT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2497 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"capturedAt\": \"2026-08-29T10:00:00Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2498 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accessClass\": \"EA-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2499 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-OPS-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2500 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2501 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2502 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-CONTRACTS-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2503 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceRole\": \"SR-04\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2504 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"title\": \"Country Contract Corroboration Set\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2505 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceControl\": \"MULTI_PARTY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2506 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"authorityForClaim\": \"CONTRACTUAL_CORROBORATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2507 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independence\": \"PARTIALLY_INDEPENDENT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2508 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"capturedAt\": \"2026-08-29T11:00:00Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2509 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accessClass\": \"EA-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2510 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-CONTRACTS-002\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2511 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2512 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2513 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unknowns\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2514 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2515 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unknownId\": \"NGU-SYNTH-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2516 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"type\": \"UNKNOWN_SCOPE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2517 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relatedClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-25-COUNTRIES-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2518 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"description\": \"The official term operates is not defined.\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2519 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2520 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2521 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governance\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2522 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimLedgerOwnerRole\": \"TRUTH_PACK_EDITOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2523 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceRegistrarRole\": \"EVIDENCE_REGISTRAR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2524 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"counterEvidenceReviewerRole\": \"COUNTER_EVIDENCE_REVIEWER\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2525 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"finalApproverRole\": \"ACCOUNTABLE_HUMAN_TRUTH_PACK_APPROVER\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2526 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedBeforeSemanticReview\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2527 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-08-31T18:00:00Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2528 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2529 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2530 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"manifestHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-TRUTH-PACK-MANIFEST-HASH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2531 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"previousVersion\": null", + "sourceParagraph": 2532 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2533 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2534 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2535 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "93. MACHINE-READABLE CLAIM–EVIDENCE RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2537 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 2538 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2539 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2540 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2541 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimEvidenceRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2542 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-SUCCESS-003\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2543 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2544 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimType\": \"CT-08\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2545 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"atomicClaim\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2546 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"predicate\": \"projectSuccessRate\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2547 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 0.98,", + "sourceParagraph": 2548 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unit\": \"PROPORTION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2549 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"population\": \"ALL_PROJECTS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2550 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"period\": \"UNSPECIFIED\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2551 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2552 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"officialRepresentation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2553 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"OFFICIAL_CURRENT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2554 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceEvidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-WEB-SUCCESS-003\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2555 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2556 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verification\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2557 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"VS-U\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2558 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeStatus\": \"SC-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2559 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timeStatus\": \"TS-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2560 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reasonCodes\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2561 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"DENOMINATOR_UNDEFINED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2562 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SUCCESS_CRITERION_UNDEFINED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2563 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PERIOD_UNDEFINED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2564 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SELECTED_CASES_ONLY\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2565 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 2566 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2567 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportingEvidence\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2568 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2569 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-CASESET-049\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2570 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relationship\": \"PARTIALLY_SUPPORTS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2571 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"notes\": \"Forty-nine positive case records.\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2572 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2573 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2574 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"counterEvidence\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2575 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2576 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-FAILED-CASE-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2577 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relationship\": \"QUALIFIES\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2578 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"notes\": \"One known unsuccessful project; full project universe unavailable.\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2579 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2580 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2581 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publiclyDiscoverable\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2582 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"preferredEpistemicForm\": \"The company states a 98% success rate, but the denominator, period, and success definition have not been independently verified.\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2583 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"prohibitedForm\": \"The company has a verified 98% success rate.\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2584 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"appealStatus\": \"APPEAL_OPEN\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2585 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2586 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2587 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "These records:", + "sourceParagraph": 2588 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "real company,", + "sourceParagraph": 2589 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "real customer,", + "sourceParagraph": 2590 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "real performance", + "sourceParagraph": 2591 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "is not data.", + "sourceParagraph": 2592 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "It is a synthetic machine representation of the Truth Pack architecture.", + "sourceParagraph": 2593 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF SECTION 94", + "sourceParagraph": 2595 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH13-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2596 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Before semantic adjudication begins, every GEO-1000 audit MUST lock a", + "sourceParagraph": 2598 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "versioned Verified Entity Truth Pack for the audited entity, prompt scope,", + "sourceParagraph": 2599 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "jurisdictions, products, languages, and reference time.", + "sourceParagraph": 2600 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The Truth Pack MUST contain, as applicable:", + "sourceParagraph": 2602 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- canonical entity identity,", + "sourceParagraph": 2604 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- atomic reference claims,", + "sourceParagraph": 2605 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Official Representation Records,", + "sourceParagraph": 2606 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- supporting evidence,", + "sourceParagraph": 2607 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- counter-evidence,", + "sourceParagraph": 2608 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- source-lineage and evidence-family records,", + "sourceParagraph": 2609 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- scope and jurisdiction qualifiers,", + "sourceParagraph": 2610 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- validity and publication times,", + "sourceParagraph": 2611 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- public and restricted access classes,", + "sourceParagraph": 2612 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- unknown and unresolved registers,", + "sourceParagraph": 2613 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- appeal and change records,", + "sourceParagraph": 2614 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and an integrity manifest.", + "sourceParagraph": 2615 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "An Official Representation Record MUST NOT be treated as independently", + "sourceParagraph": 2617 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "verified reality merely because it is official.", + "sourceParagraph": 2618 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A first-party source MAY be authoritative for claims under the entity's", + "sourceParagraph": 2620 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "direct control, while remaining non-independent for comparative,", + "sourceParagraph": 2621 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "performance, leadership, or external-validation claims.", + "sourceParagraph": 2622 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Different URLs, publications, translations, syndications, or AI summaries", + "sourceParagraph": 2624 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MUST NOT be counted as independent evidence when they derive from the", + "sourceParagraph": 2625 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "same root source.", + "sourceParagraph": 2626 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every evidence object MUST state which atomic claim it supports,", + "sourceParagraph": 2628 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "qualifies, contradicts, outdates, or contextualises.", + "sourceParagraph": 2629 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The absence of located evidence MUST NOT automatically be represented as", + "sourceParagraph": 2631 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "proof that a claim is false. Open-world and closed-world evidence", + "sourceParagraph": 2632 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "conditions MUST remain distinct.", + "sourceParagraph": 2633 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Quantitative claims MUST retain numerator, denominator, period, unit,", + "sourceParagraph": 2635 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "inclusion and exclusion rules, source data, and calculation method.", + "sourceParagraph": 2636 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Customer, partner, license, certification, membership, award, legal,", + "sourceParagraph": 2638 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "performance, and superiority claims MUST preserve their exact entity,", + "sourceParagraph": 2639 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "relationship, scope, jurisdiction, time, and evidence status.", + "sourceParagraph": 2640 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Publicly discoverable evidence, restricted audit evidence, and", + "sourceParagraph": 2642 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "non-public evidence MUST remain separately classified.", + "sourceParagraph": 2643 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A claim MAY be factually verified through restricted evidence without", + "sourceParagraph": 2645 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "being publicly retrievable by a consumer AI product. Factual verification", + "sourceParagraph": 2646 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "and public discoverability MUST remain distinct.", + "sourceParagraph": 2647 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Truth Pack claims MUST NOT be added, removed, broadened, narrowed, or", + "sourceParagraph": 2649 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "reclassified after AI responses are observed unless a new Truth Pack", + "sourceParagraph": 2650 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "version is created and prior records are preserved.", + "sourceParagraph": 2651 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A response claim not covered by the locked Truth Pack MUST trigger a", + "sourceParagraph": 2653 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "reference-gap process rather than automatic failure or automatic", + "sourceParagraph": 2654 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "acceptance.", + "sourceParagraph": 2655 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Unknown, unsupported, unresolved, contradicted, historical, expired,", + "sourceParagraph": 2657 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "scope-limited, and restrictedly verified states MUST remain separately", + "sourceParagraph": 2658 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "visible.", + "sourceParagraph": 2659 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The audited entity MAY submit evidence, corrections, and appeals, but", + "sourceParagraph": 2661 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MUST NOT act as the sole adjudicator of its own claims.", + "sourceParagraph": 2662 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "AI systems MAY assist with extraction, normalisation, lineage detection,", + "sourceParagraph": 2664 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "and contradiction discovery, but MUST NOT serve as the sole final", + "sourceParagraph": 2665 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "authority for claim truth status.", + "sourceParagraph": 2666 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every Truth Pack version, evidence registration, support-status decision,", + "sourceParagraph": 2668 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "appeal, and change MUST be attributable to an accountable human or", + "sourceParagraph": 2669 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "organisation.", + "sourceParagraph": 2670 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 2671 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Before semantic adjudication begins, each GEO-1000 audit must lock a versioned Verified Entity Truth Pack for the audited entity, prompt scope, countries, products, languages, and reference time. The package must contain the canonical entity identity, atomic reference claims, Official Representation Records, supporting evidence, counter-evidence, source lineage, scope and time limits, access classes, unknowns, objections, and an integrity manifest. An official statement cannot be considered independently verified reality just because it is official. Different URLs derived from the same root source cannot be counted as independent evidence.", + "sourceParagraph": 2672 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Перед началом семантического рассмотрения каждая проверка GEO-1000 ДОЛЖНА зафиксировать версионный Пакет проверенных данных о сущности для проверяемого объекта, области проверки, юрисдикций, продуктов, языков и времени ссылки. Пакет Истинности ДОЛЖЕН содержать, где применимо: - каноническую идентичность объекта, - атомарные ссылочные утверждения, - официальные записи представления, - подтверждающие доказательства, - контрдоказательства, - записи происхождения источников и семейства доказательств, - квалификаторы области и юрисдикции, - время допустимости и публикации, - классы публичного и ограниченного доступа, - регистры неизвестного и нерешённого, - записи об апелляциях и изменениях, - и манифест ��остоверности. Официальная запись представления НЕ ДОЛЖНА рассматриваться как независимо проверенная реальность только потому, что она официальная. Источник первой стороны МОЖЕТ быть авторитетным для утверждений, находящихся под непосредственным контролем организации, оставаясь при этом не независимым источником для сравнительных оценок, показателях эффективности, лидерстве или внешней валидации. Разные URL-адреса, публикации, переводы, синдикации или AI-резюме НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ считаться независимыми доказательствами, если они происходят из одного и того же исходного источника. Каждый объект доказательства ДОЛЖЕН указывать, какое атомарное утверждение он поддерживает, уточняет, опровергает, делает устаревшим или помещает в контекст. Отсутствие найденных доказательств НЕ ДОЛЖНО автоматически представляться как доказательство того, что утверждение является ложным. Условия доказательств в открытом и закрытом мире ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться различными. Количественные утверждения ДОЛЖНЫ сохранять числитель, знаменатель, период, единицу измерения, правила включения и исключения, исходные данные и метод расчета. Утверждения о клиенте, партнере, лицензии, сертификате, членстве, награде, юридические, о производительности и превосходстве ДОЛЖНЫ сохранять точные данные об объекте, отношении, охвате, юрисдикции, времени и статусе доказательства. Публично обнаруживаемые доказательства, ограниченные аудиторские доказательства и непубличные доказательства ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться классифицированными отдельно. Утверждение МОЖЕТ быть фактологически проверено через ограниченные доказательства без возможности публичного извлечения их потребительским продуктом ИИ. Фактологическая проверка и публичная обнаруживаемость ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться различными. Заявления Пакета истины НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ добавляться, удаляться, расширяться, сужаться или переклассифицироваться после того, как наблюдаются ответы ИИ, если только не создана новая версия Пакета истины и не сохранены предыдущие записи. Заявление в ответе, не покрываемое зафиксированным пакетом истинности, ДОЛЖНО запускать процесс выявления пробелов в ссылках, а не автоматическую ошибку или автоматическое принятие. Состояния «неизвестно», «неподдерживаемое», «нераскрытое», «противоречивое», «историческое», «истекшее», «с ограниченным охватом» и «ограниченно проверенное» ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельно видимыми. Проверяемое лицо МОЖЕТ представлять доказательства, исправления и апелляции, но НЕ ДОЛЖНО выступать единственным арбитром собственных утверждений. Системы ИИ МОГУТ помогать в извлечении, нормализации, обнаружении происхождения и выявлении противоречий, но НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ служить единственным окончательным авторитетом для определения истинности утверждения. Каждая версия Пакета истины, регистрация доказательств, решение о статусе поддержки, апелляция и изменение ДОЛЖНЫ быть приписаны ответственному человеку или организации.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "92. ЗАПИСЬ ПАКЕТА МАШИНОЧИТАЕМОЙ ИСТИНЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2450, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2451, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2452, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2453, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-25-COUNTRIES-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2454, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2455, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimType\": \"CT-05\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2456, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"predicate\": \"operatesInCountryCount\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2457, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 25,", + "sourceParagraph": 2458, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"VS-U\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2459, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeStatus\": \"SC-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2460, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timeStatus\": \"TS-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2461, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"officialRepresentationStatus\": \"ОФИЦИАЛЬНЫЙ_ТЕКУЩИЙ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2462, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicDiscoverability\": \"ОБЩЕДОСТУПНОЕ_ДЛЯ_ОБНАРУЖЕНИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2463, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceLinks\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2464, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2465, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-WEB-025\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2466, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relationship\": \"ПОДДЕРЖИВАЕТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2467, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2468, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2469, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-OPS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2470, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relationship\": \"КВАЛИФИЦИРУЕТ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2471, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2472, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2473, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"неопределенность\": \"Термин 'операции' не определяется последовательно.\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2474, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2475, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2476, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"доказательства\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2477, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2478, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-WEB-025\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2479, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceRole\": \"SR-01\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2480, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"заголовок\": \"Страница глобального присутствия Asteron\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2481, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceControl\": \"КОНТРОЛИРУЕМОЕ АУДИТОРОМ ПРЕДПРИЯТИЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2482, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"authorityForClaim\": \"ОФИЦИАЛЬНОЕ САМООТЧЕТНОЕ ПРЕДСТАВЛЕНИЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2483, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"независимость\": \"НЕ НЕЗАВИСИМОЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2484, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publishedAt\": \"2026-01-10\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2485, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"capturedAt\": \"2026-08-30 T1 4:00:00 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2486, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accessClass\": \"EA-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2487, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lineageFamilyId\": \"ДОКАЗАТЕЛЬСТВО-СЕМЬЯ-ASTERON-САМОЗАЯВЛЕНИЕ-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2488, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ХЭШ-ИНТЕРНЕТ-025\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2489, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2490, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2491, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-OPS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2492, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceRole\": \"SR-02\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2493, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"заголовок\": \"Регистр проверенных активных операций\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2494, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceControl\": \"КОНТРОЛИРУЕМОЕ АУДИТОРОМ ПРЕДПРИЯТИЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2495, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"authorityForClaim\": \"ПРЯМОЙ_ОПЕРАЦИОННЫЙ_ЗАПИСЬ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2496, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"независимость\": \"НЕ НЕЗАВИСИМОЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2497, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"capturedAt\": \"2026-08-29 T1 0:00:00 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2498, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accessClass\": \"EA-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2499, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЕ_ХЭШ_ОПЕРАЦИИ_001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2500, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2501, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2502, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"ДОГОВОРЫ_NGEV_СИНТ_CONTRACTS_002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2503, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceRole\": \"SR-04\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2504, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"title\": \"Набор подтверждения контрактов страны\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2505, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceControl\": \"МНОГОСТОРОННИЙ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2506, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"authorityForClaim\": \"ДОГОВОРНОЕ_ПОДТВЕРЖДЕНИЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2507, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independence\": \"ЧАСТИЧНО_НЕЗАВИСИМЫЙ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2508, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"capturedAt\": \"2026-08-29 T1 1:00:00 Z\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2509, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accessClass\": \"EA-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2510, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЕ_ХЭШ_ДОГОВОРЫ_002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2511, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2512, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2513, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unknowns\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2514, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2515, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unknownId\": \"NGU-SYNTH-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2516, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"type\": \"НЕИЗВЕСТНАЯ_СФЕРА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2517, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relatedClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-25-COUNTRIES-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2518, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"description\": \"Официальный термин 'operates' не определен.\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2519, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2520, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2521, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"управление\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2522, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimLedgerOwnerRole\": \"РЕДАКТОР_ПАКЕТА_ИСТИНЫ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2523, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceRegistrarRole\": \"РЕГИСТРАТОР_ДОКАЗАТЕЛЬСТВ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2524, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"counterEvidenceReviewerRole\": \"COUNTER_EVIDENCE_REVIEWER\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2525, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"finalApproverRole\": \"ОТВЕТСТВЕННЫЙ_ЧЕЛОВЕК_ЗА_ОДОБРЕНИЕ_ПАКЕТА_ИСТИНЫ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2526, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedBeforeSemanticReview\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2527, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-08-31 T1 8:00:00 Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2528, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2529, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2530, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"manifestHash\": \"ХЕШ_МАНИФЕСТА_СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОГО_ПАКЕТА_ИСТИНЫ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2531, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"previousVersion\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2532, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2533, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2534, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2535, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "93. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ_ЗАПИСЬ_ТРЕБОВАНИЙ_И_ДОКАЗАТЕЛЬСТВ,", + "sourceParagraph": 2537, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2538, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2539, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2540, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2541, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimEvidenceRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2542, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimId\": \"NGC-СИНТ-АСТЕРОН-УСПЕХ-003\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2543, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2544, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimType\": \"CT-08\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2545, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"atomicClaim\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2546, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"predicate\": \"projectSuccessRate\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2547, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 0.98,", + "sourceParagraph": 2548, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unit\": \"ДОЛЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2549, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"population\": \"ВСЕ_ПРОЕКТЫ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2550, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"period\": \"НЕОПРЕДЕЛЁННО\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2551, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2552, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"officialRepresentation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2553, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"OFFICIAL_CURRENT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2554, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceEvidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-WEB-SUCCESS-003\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2555, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2556, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verification\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2557, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"VS-U\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2558, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeStatus\": \"SC-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2559, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timeStatus\": \"TS-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2560, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reasonCodes\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2561, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ДИВИЗИОН_НЕ_ОПРЕДЕЛЕН\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2562, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"КРИТЕРИЙ_УСПЕХА_НЕ_ОПРЕДЕЛЕН\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2563, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ПЕРИОД_НЕ_ОПРЕДЕЛЕН\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2564, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ТОЛ��КО_ВЫБРАННЫЕ_СЛУЧАИ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2565, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 2566, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2567, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportingEvidence\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2568, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2569, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-CASESET-049\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2570, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"отношение\": \"ЧАСТИЧНО_ПОДДЕРЖИВАЕТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2571, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"заметки\": \"Сорок девять записей о положительных случаях.\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2572, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2573, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2574, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"counterEvidence\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2575, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2576, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-FAILED-CASE-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2577, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"отношение\": \"КВАЛИФИЦИРУЕТСЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2578, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"заметки\": \"Один известный неуспешный проект; полная совокупность проектов недоступна.\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2579, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2580, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2581, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publiclyDiscoverable\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2582, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"preferredEpistemicForm\": \"Компания заявляет о 98% уровне успеха, но знаменатель, период и определение успеха не были независимо проверены.\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2583, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"prohibitedForm\": \"У компании подтвержденный 98% уровень успеха.\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2584, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"appealStatus\": \"APPEAL_OPEN\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2585, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2586, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2587, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Эти записи:", + "sourceParagraph": 2588, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальная компания,", + "sourceParagraph": 2589, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальный клиент,", + "sourceParagraph": 2590, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальная производительность", + "sourceParagraph": 2591, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "не является данными.", + "sourceParagraph": 2592, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Это синтетическое машинное представление архитектуры Truth Pack.", + "sourceParagraph": 2593, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "МАШИНОЧИТАЕМОЕ ПРАВИЛО РАЗДЕЛА 94", + "sourceParagraph": 2595, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH13-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2596, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Перед началом семантической оценки каждый аудит GEO-1000 ДОЛЖЕН зафиксировать", + "sourceParagraph": 2598, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "версионированный Пакет проверенных данных о сущности для проверяемого объекта, объём запроса,", + "sourceParagraph": 2599, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "юрисдикции, продукты, языки и референсное время.", + "sourceParagraph": 2600, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Пакет Истины ДОЛЖЕН содержать, по мере необходимости:", + "sourceParagraph": 2602, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- каноническую идентичность сущности,", + "sourceParagraph": 2604, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- атомарные референсные утверждения,", + "sourceParagraph": 2605, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- официальные записи представления,", + "sourceParagraph": 2606, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- поддерживающие доказательства,", + "sourceParagraph": 2607, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- контрдоказательства,", + "sourceParagraph": 2608, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- записи источников и семейства доказательств,", + "sourceParagraph": 2609, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- квалификаторы объема и юрисдикции,", + "sourceParagraph": 2610, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- времена действительности и публикации,", + "sourceParagraph": 2611, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- ��убличные и ограниченные классы доступа,", + "sourceParagraph": 2612, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- неизвестные и нерешенные регистры,", + "sourceParagraph": 2613, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- записи об апелляциях и изменениях,", + "sourceParagraph": 2614, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и манифест целостности.", + "sourceParagraph": 2615, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Официальная запись представления НЕ ДОЛЖНА рассматриваться как независимо", + "sourceParagraph": 2617, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "подтвержденная правда только потому, что она официальная.", + "sourceParagraph": 2618, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Первичный источник МОЖЕТ быть авторитетным для утверждений в рамках прямого", + "sourceParagraph": 2620, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "контроля организации, при этом оставаясь не независимым для сравнительных,", + "sourceParagraph": 2621, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "результативных, лидерских или внешне-проверяющих утверждений.", + "sourceParagraph": 2622, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Разные URL, публикации, переводы, синдикации или AI-резюме", + "sourceParagraph": 2624, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ учитываться как независимые доказательства, если они происходят из", + "sourceParagraph": 2625, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "одного и того же исходного источника.", + "sourceParagraph": 2626, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждый объект доказательства ДОЛЖЕН указывать, какое атомарное утверждение он поддерживает,", + "sourceParagraph": 2628, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "квалифицирует, противоречит, устаревает или контекстуализирует.", + "sourceParagraph": 2629, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Отсутствие найденных доказательств НЕ ДОЛЖНО автоматически представляться как", + "sourceParagraph": 2631, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "доказательство того, что утверждение ложно. Доказательства открытого и закрытого мира", + "sourceParagraph": 2632, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "условия ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться различными.", + "sourceParagraph": 2633, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Количественные утверждения ДОЛЖНЫ сохранять числитель, знаменатель, период, единицу.", + "sourceParagraph": 2635, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "правила включения и исключения, исходные данные и метод расчета.", + "sourceParagraph": 2636, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Клиент, партнёр, лицензия, сертификация, членство, награда, юридический,", + "sourceParagraph": 2638, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "заявления о производительности и превосходстве ДОЛЖНЫ сохранять свою точную сущность,", + "sourceParagraph": 2639, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "отношения, сфера, юрисдикция, время и статус доказательств.", + "sourceParagraph": 2640, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Общественно доступные доказательства, ограниченные аудиторские доказательства, и", + "sourceParagraph": 2642, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Непубличные доказательства ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельно засекреченными.", + "sourceParagraph": 2643, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "утверждение МОЖЕТ быть фактически проверена с помощью ограниченных доказательств без", + "sourceParagraph": 2645, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "быть общедоступным для потребительского ИИ-продукта. Проверка фактов", + "sourceParagraph": 2646, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "и публичная доступность ДОЛЖНА оставаться отдельной.", + "sourceParagraph": 2647, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Заявления Truth Pack НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ добавляться, удаляться, расширяться, сужаться или", + "sourceParagraph": 2649, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "переклассифицировано после наблюдения за ответами ИИ, если только не появится новый Пакет Истины", + "sourceParagraph": 2650, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "версия создается, а предыдущие записи сохраняются.", + "sourceParagraph": 2651, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Ответное требование, не охватываемое зафиксированным Пакетом Истины, ДОЛЖНО вызывать", + "sourceParagraph": 2653, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "процесс с пропуском ссылки, а не автоматический сбой или автоматический", + "sourceParagraph": 2654, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "принятие.", + "sourceParagraph": 2655, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Неизвестный, неподдерживаемый, нерешенный, противоречащий, исторический, истекший,", + "sourceParagraph": 2657, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ограниченные по объему и ограниченно проверенные состояния ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельно", + "sourceParagraph": 2658, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "видимыми.", + "sourceParagraph": 2659, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Проверяемое лицо МОЖЕТ представить доказательства, исправления и апелляции, но", + "sourceParagraph": 2661, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "НЕ ДОЛЖЕН выступать в роли единственного арбитра по собственным требованиям.", + "sourceParagraph": 2662, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Системы ИИ МОГУТ помогать с извлечением, нормализацией, обнаружением происхождения,", + "sourceParagraph": 2664, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "и обнаружение противоречий, но НЕ ДОЛЖНО служить единственным окончательным", + "sourceParagraph": 2665, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "власть для утверждения достоверности.", + "sourceParagraph": 2666, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждая версия Truth Pack, регистрация доказательств, решение о статусе поддержки,", + "sourceParagraph": 2668, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "обжалование и изменение ДОЛЖНЫ быть приписаны ответственному человеку или", + "sourceParagraph": 2669, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "организации.", + "sourceParagraph": 2670, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 2671, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH13-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Перед началом семантической экспертизы каждый аудит GEO-1000 должен зафиксировать версионную Пакет проверенных данных о сущности для проверяемого объекта, охвата, стран, продуктов, языков и эталонного времени. Пакет должен содержать каноническую идентичность объекта, атомарные эталонные утверждения, Официальные записи представления, подтверждающие доказательства, контрдоказательства, источники происхождения, пределы охвата и времени, классы доступа, неизвестные данные, возражения и манифест целостности. Официальное заявление не может считаться независимо проверенной реальностью только потому, что оно официальное. Разные URL, полученные из одного и того же исходного источника, не могут считаться независимыми доказательствами.", + "sourceParagraph": 2672, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 14, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH14", + "title": "Атомарные утверждения и вынесение решений", + "subtitle": null, + "sourceIds": [ + "K27", + "K28" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH14-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "Before any response-level pass, failure, severity, or score is assigned, each material AI response MUST be decomposed into atomic semantic claims. Each atomic claim MUST retain: - its exact source span, - normalised proposition, - subject entity, - predicate and value, - qualifiers and quantifiers, - geographic, product, user, and jurisdictional scope, - temporal frame, - attribution, - modality and uncertainty, - explicit, implicit, presupposed, or entailed origin, - response centrality, - citation relationships, - dependency relationships, - and Truth Pack mapping. Sentence and paragraph boundaries MUST NOT be treated as automatic claim boundaries. Atomic decomposition MUST separate propositions that can carry different truth, evidence, entity, scope, time, or attribution states, while prohibiting meaningless micro-fragmentation that dilutes material error. Claim extraction, Truth Pack mapping, and semantic adjudication SHOULD remain separate stages and, where practical, separate roles. Every atomic claim MUST be adjudicated across distinct dimensions, including: - entity, - factual support, - scope, - time, - attribution and epistemic status, - modality and uncertainty, - citation support, - relevance, - and unresolved or reference-gap status. Official-claim fidelity MUST remain distinct from verified factual support. Unsupported, contradicted, wrong-entity, outdated, scope-overreach, epistemic-status-error, citation-mismatch, reference-gap, and unresolved states MUST remain separately visible. Required response elements and material omissions MUST be adjudicated separately from explicit false claims. Correct but irrelevant information MUST NOT satisfy the prompt merely because it is factually supported. Material claims SHOULD receive independent double review, with additional language or domain expertise where required. Reviewer identity, qualification, conflicts, independent first decisions, disagreements, resolution, reliability metrics, appeals, and decision versions MUST be recorded. Reviewer agreement MUST be measured by dimension and MUST NOT be treated as proof that the shared decision is necessarily correct. AI systems MAY assist with segmentation, claim extraction, evidence mapping, translation support, and contradiction discovery, but MUST NOT serve as the sole final adjudicator of their own or another system's claims. Atomic adjudication decisions MUST remain independent of commercial interests, desired scores, provider reputation, badge outcomes, or client approval. Every Claim Ledger, adjudication decision, disagreement resolution, appeal, and revision MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Herhangi bir response-level geçiş, başarısızlık, önem derecesi veya skor verilmeden önce her maddi AI yanıtı atomik semantik iddialara ayrılmalıdır. Her atomik iddia tam metin izini, normalize hükmünü, özne varlığı, yüklem ve değeri, nitelendiricileri, kapsamı, zamanı, attribution’ı, modaliteyi, iddia kökenini, merkeziliği, citation ilişkilerini, bağımlılıklarını ve Truth Pack eşleşmesini korumalıdır. Cümle ve paragraf sınırları otomatik iddia sınırı sayılamaz.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "117. MACHINE-READABLE CLAIM LEDGER RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2513 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 2514 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2515 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"startCharacter\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2516 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"endCharacter\": 30", + "sourceParagraph": 2517 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2518 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2519 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2520 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"predicate\": \"activelyDeliversServicesInCountryCount\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2521 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"objectValue\": 25,", + "sourceParagraph": 2522 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unit\": \"COUNTRY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2523 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"geographicScope\": \"GLOBAL\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2524 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"temporalFrame\": \"CURRENT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2525 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attribution\": \"UNATTRIBUTED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2526 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"modality\": \"ASSERTED_AS_FACT\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2527 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2528 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimOrigin\": \"EXPLICIT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2529 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"centrality\": \"CL-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2530 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"dependencyType\": \"ROOT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2531 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"linkedTruthPackClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-25-COUNTRIES-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2532 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationLinks\": [],", + "sourceParagraph": 2533 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"extractionReview\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2534 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"extractorOne\": \"AGREED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2535 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"extractorTwo\": \"AGREED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2536 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"boundaryAgreement\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2537 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2538 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2539 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2540 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseClaimId\": \"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2541 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceSpan\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2542 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"text\": \"with a 98 per cent success rate\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2543 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"startCharacter\": 32,", + "sourceParagraph": 2544 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"endCharacter\": 63", + "sourceParagraph": 2545 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2546 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2547 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2548 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"predicate\": \"projectSuccessRate\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2549 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"objectValue\": 0.98,", + "sourceParagraph": 2550 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unit\": \"PROPORTION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2551 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"population\": \"ALL_PROJECTS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2552 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"temporalFrame\": \"UNSPECIFIED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2553 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attribution\": \"UNATTRIBUTED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2554 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"modality\": \"ASSERTED_AS_FACT\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2555 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2556 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimOrigin\": \"EXPLICIT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2557 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"centrality\": \"CL-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2558 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"dependencyType\": \"ROOT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2559 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"linkedTruthPackClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-SUCCESS-003\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2560 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationLinks\": []", + "sourceParagraph": 2561 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2562 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2563 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseClaimId\": \"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-003\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2564 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceSpan\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2565 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"text\": \"independently certified\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2566 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"startCharacter\": 65,", + "sourceParagraph": 2567 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"endCharacter\": 101", + "sourceParagraph": 2568 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2569 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2570 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2571 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"predicate\": \"independentlyCertified\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2572 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"objectValue\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2573 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attribution\": \"INDEPENDENT_EXTERNAL_AUTHORITY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2574 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"modality\": \"ASSERTED_AS_FACT\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2575 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2576 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimOrigin\": \"EXPLICIT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2577 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"centrality\": \"CL-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2578 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"dependencyType\": \"ROOT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2579 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"linkedTruthPackClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-INDEPENDENCE-004\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2580 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationLinks\": []", + "sourceParagraph": 2581 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2582 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2583 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"requiredResponseElements\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2584 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityResolved\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2585 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"primaryActivityPresent\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2586 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialBoundaryPresent\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2587 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2588 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"omissions\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2589 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2590 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"omissionId\": \"NGOM-SYNTH-000184-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2591 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"OM-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2592 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"description\": \"The response omits that active service delivery has only been verified in nine countries.\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2593 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2594 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2595 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2596 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimExtractionOwnerRole\": \"CLAIM_EXTRACTION_LEAD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2597 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-09-03T10:00:00Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2598 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2599 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2600 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2601 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "118. MACHINE-READABLE ATOMIC ADJUDICATION RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2603 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 2604 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2605 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2606 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2607 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"atomicAdjudication\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2608 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationId\": \"NGAJ-SYNTH-000184-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2609 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseClaimId\": \"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2610 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimLedgerId\": \"NGCL-SYNTH-W1-ORION-000184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2611 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-25-COUNTRIES-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2612 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"decisionVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2613 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"dimensionDecisions\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2614 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entity\": \"E-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2615 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"factualSupport\": \"F-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2616 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scope\": \"S-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2617 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"time\": \"T-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2618 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attribution\": \"A-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2619 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"modality\": \"M-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2620 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citation\": \"C-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2621 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relevance\": \"R-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2622 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unresolved\": \"U-0\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2623 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2624 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"combinedLabel\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2625 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PARTIALLY-SUPPORTED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2626 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"MATERIAL-SCOPE-OVERREACH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2627 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"MATERIAL-ATTRIBUTION-LOSS\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2628 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2629 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reasoningSummary\": \"The audited entity officially states that it operates in 25 countries, but active service delivery has been verified in nine. The response presents the broader official statement as an unqualified current fact.\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2630 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceReferences\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2631 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGEV-SYNTH-WEB-025\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2632 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGEV-SYNTH-OPS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2633 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGEV-SYNTH-CONTRACTS-002\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2634 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2635 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reviewers\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2636 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"primaryReviewerRole\": \"LANGUAGE_ADJUDICATOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2637 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"secondaryReviewerRole\": \"EVIDENCE_ADJUDICATOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2638 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"primaryDecision\": \"MATERIAL-SCOPE-OVERREACH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2639 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"secondaryDecision\": \"MATERIAL-SCOPE-OVERREACH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2640 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentBeforeComparison\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2641 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2642 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"agreement\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2643 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityAgreement\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2644 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"factAgreement\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2645 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeAgreement\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2646 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timeAgreement\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2647 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attributionAgreement\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2648 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2649 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"appeal\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2650 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"NO_APPEAL\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2651 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2652 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governance\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2653 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"qualityLevel\": \"AQ-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2654 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"finalizedByRole\": \"SENIOR_ADJUDICATOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2655 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"finalizedAt\": \"2026-09-04T09:00:00Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2656 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2657 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2658 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2659 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "119. MACHINE-READABLE ADJUDICATOR COMPLIANCE RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2661 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 2662 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2663 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2664 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2665 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationReliability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2666 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reliabilityRecordId\": \"NGREL-SYNTH-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2667 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"NGW-SYNTH-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2668 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"doubleReviewedClaimCount\": 8200,", + "sourceParagraph": 2669 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"preResolutionMetrics\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2670 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimBoundaryExactAgreement\": 0.93,", + "sourceParagraph": 2671 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityExactAgreement\": 0.97,", + "sourceParagraph": 2672 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"factualStatusExactAgreement\": 0.88,", + "sourceParagraph": 2673 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeExactAgreement\": 0.84,", + "sourceParagraph": 2674 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timeExactAgreement\": 0.94,", + "sourceParagraph": 2675 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attributionExactAgreement\": 0.86,", + "sourceParagraph": 2676 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationSupportExactAgreement\": 0.82,", + "sourceParagraph": 2677 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"omissionExactAgreement\": 0.79", + "sourceParagraph": 2678 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2679 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"chanceAdjustedMetrics\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2680 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"overallNominalAgreementMetric\": \"KRIPPENDORFF_ALPHA\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2681 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"overallValue\": 0.84,", + "sourceParagraph": 2682 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeValue\": 0.78,", + "sourceParagraph": 2683 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationValue\": 0.75", + "sourceParagraph": 2684 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2685 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"actions\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2686 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SCOPE_RECALIBRATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2687 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CITATION_MAPPING_RETRAINING\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2688 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"OMISSION_GUIDANCE_REVISION\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2689 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2690 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"postResolution\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2691 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"allMaterialDisagreementsResolved\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2692 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unresolvedClaimCount\": 19,", + "sourceParagraph": 2693 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unresolvedStatusPreserved\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2694 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2695 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"qualityLevel\": \"AQ-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2696 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2697 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reliabilityOwnerRole\": \"ADJUDICATION_METHODS_LEAD\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2698 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2699 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2700 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2701 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "These records:", + "sourceParagraph": 2702 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "a real user,", + "sourceParagraph": 2703 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "real company,", + "sourceParagraph": 2704 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "actual adjudicator performance", + "sourceParagraph": 2705 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "a real company performance.", + "sourceParagraph": 2706 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "It is a synthetic, machine-readable representation of the atomic claim and adjudication architecture.", + "sourceParagraph": 2707 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "120. MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF THE SECTION", + "sourceParagraph": 2709 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH14-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2710 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Before any response-level pass, failure, severity, or score is assigned,", + "sourceParagraph": 2712 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "each material AI response MUST be decomposed into atomic semantic claims.", + "sourceParagraph": 2713 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Each atomic claim MUST retain:", + "sourceParagraph": 2715 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- its exact source span,", + "sourceParagraph": 2717 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- normalised proposition,", + "sourceParagraph": 2718 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- subject entity,", + "sourceParagraph": 2719 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- predicate and value,", + "sourceParagraph": 2720 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- qualifiers and quantifiers,", + "sourceParagraph": 2721 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- geographic, product, user, and jurisdictional scope,", + "sourceParagraph": 2722 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- temporal frame,", + "sourceParagraph": 2723 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- attribution,", + "sourceParagraph": 2724 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- modality and uncertainty,", + "sourceParagraph": 2725 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- explicit, implicit, presupposed, or entailed origin,", + "sourceParagraph": 2726 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0209", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- response centrality,", + "sourceParagraph": 2727 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0210", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- citation relationships,", + "sourceParagraph": 2728 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0211", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- dependency relationships,", + "sourceParagraph": 2729 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0212", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and Truth Pack mapping.", + "sourceParagraph": 2730 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0213", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Sentence and paragraph boundaries MUST NOT be treated as automatic claim", + "sourceParagraph": 2732 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0214", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "boundaries.", + "sourceParagraph": 2733 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0215", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Atomic decomposition MUST separate propositions that can carry different", + "sourceParagraph": 2735 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0216", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "truth, evidence, entity, scope, time, or attribution states, while", + "sourceParagraph": 2736 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0217", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "prohibiting meaningless micro-fragmentation that dilutes material error.", + "sourceParagraph": 2737 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0218", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Claim extraction, Truth Pack mapping, and semantic adjudication SHOULD", + "sourceParagraph": 2739 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0219", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "remain separate stages and, where practical, separate roles.", + "sourceParagraph": 2740 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0220", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every atomic claim MUST be adjudicated across distinct dimensions,", + "sourceParagraph": 2742 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0221", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "including:", + "sourceParagraph": 2743 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0222", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- entity,", + "sourceParagraph": 2745 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0223", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- factual support,", + "sourceParagraph": 2746 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0224", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- scope,", + "sourceParagraph": 2747 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0225", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- time,", + "sourceParagraph": 2748 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0226", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- attribution and epistemic status,", + "sourceParagraph": 2749 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0227", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- modality and uncertainty,", + "sourceParagraph": 2750 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0228", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- citation support,", + "sourceParagraph": 2751 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0229", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- relevance,", + "sourceParagraph": 2752 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0230", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and unresolved or reference-gap status.", + "sourceParagraph": 2753 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0231", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Official-claim fidelity MUST remain distinct from verified factual", + "sourceParagraph": 2755 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0232", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "support.", + "sourceParagraph": 2756 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0233", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Unsupported, contradicted, wrong-entity, outdated, scope-overreach,", + "sourceParagraph": 2758 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0234", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "epistemic-status-error, citation-mismatch, reference-gap, and unresolved", + "sourceParagraph": 2759 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0235", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "states MUST remain separately visible.", + "sourceParagraph": 2760 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0236", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Required response elements and material omissions MUST be adjudicated", + "sourceParagraph": 2762 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0237", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "separately from explicit false claims.", + "sourceParagraph": 2763 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0238", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Correct but irrelevant information MUST NOT satisfy the prompt merely", + "sourceParagraph": 2765 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0239", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "because it is factually supported.", + "sourceParagraph": 2766 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0240", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Material claims SHOULD receive independent double review, with additional", + "sourceParagraph": 2768 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0241", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "language or domain expertise where required.", + "sourceParagraph": 2769 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0242", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Reviewer identity, qualification, conflicts, independent first decisions,", + "sourceParagraph": 2771 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0243", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "disagreements, resolution, reliability metrics, appeals, and decision", + "sourceParagraph": 2772 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0244", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "versions MUST be recorded.", + "sourceParagraph": 2773 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0245", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Reviewer agreement MUST be measured by dimension and MUST NOT be treated", + "sourceParagraph": 2775 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0246", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "as proof that the shared decision is necessarily correct.", + "sourceParagraph": 2776 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0247", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "AI systems MAY assist with segmentation, claim extraction, evidence", + "sourceParagraph": 2778 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0248", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "mapping, translation support, and contradiction discovery, but MUST NOT", + "sourceParagraph": 2779 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0249", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "serve as the sole final adjudicator of their own or another system's", + "sourceParagraph": 2780 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0250", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "claims.", + "sourceParagraph": 2781 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0251", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Atomic adjudication decisions MUST remain independent of commercial", + "sourceParagraph": 2783 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0252", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "interests, desired scores, provider reputation, badge outcomes, or client", + "sourceParagraph": 2784 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0253", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "approval.", + "sourceParagraph": 2785 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0254", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every Claim Ledger, adjudication decision, disagreement resolution,", + "sourceParagraph": 2787 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0255", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "appeal, and revision MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable", + "sourceParagraph": 2788 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0256", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "human or organisation.", + "sourceParagraph": 2789 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0257", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 2790 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0258", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Any response-level transition must be broken down into atomic semantic claims for each material AI response before assigning failure, importance level, or score. Each atomic claim must preserve the full text trace, normalised judgement, subject existence, predicate and value, qualifiers, scope, time, attribution, modality, claim origin, centrality, citation relations, dependencies, and Truth Pack matching. Sentence and paragraph boundaries cannot be counted as automatic claim boundaries.", + "sourceParagraph": 2791 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Перед присвоением любого уровня реакции, ошибки, степени тяжести или оценки каждый материал AI-ответ ДОЛЖЕН быть разложен на атомарные семантические утверждения. Каждое атомарное утверждение ДОЛЖНО сохранять: - его точный исходный фрагмент, - нормализованное утверждение, - объект субъекта, - предикат и значение, - квалификаторы и квантификаторы, - географические, продуктовые, пользовательские и юрисдикционные рамки, - временные рамки, - источник атрибуции, - модальность и степень неопределенности, - явное, неявное, предположительное или вытекающее происхождение, - центральность ответа, - отношения цитирования, - зависимости, - и соответствие Truth Pack. Границы предложений и абзацев НЕ ДОЛЖНО рассматривать как автоматические границы утверждений. Атомарное разложение ДОЛЖНО разделять утверждения, которые МОГУТ иметь разные состояния истины, доказательств, объектов, объема, времени или атрибуции, при этом запрещая бессмысленную микро-фрагментацию, которая размывает материальную ошибку. Извлечение утверждений, сопоставление с Пакетом Истины и семантическое урегулирование ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельными этапами и, где это практично, отдельными ролями. Каждое атомарное утверждение ДОЛЖНО быть урегулировано по отдельным измерениям, включая: - объект, - фактическую поддержку, - объем, - время, - статус атрибуции и эпистемический статус, - модальность и неопределенность, - поддержку ссылок, - актуальность, - и статус нерешенного или пропавшего ссылки. Верность официального утверждения ДОЛЖНА оставаться отдельной от проверенной фактической поддержки. Неподдерживаемые, противоречивые, неверные объекты, устаревшие, выходящие за рамки, ошибки эпистемического статуса, несоответствие цитат, пробелы в ссылках и неразрешённые состояния ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельно видимыми. Обязательные элементы ответа и пропуски материала ДОЛЖНЫ рассматриваться отдельно от явных ложных утверждений. Корректная, но не относящаяся к делу информация НЕ ДОЛЖНА удовлетворять требованиям запроса только потому, что она фактически подтверждена. Существенные утверждения ДОЛЖНЫ проходить независимую двойную проверку, с привлечением дополнительной языковой или предметной экспертизы, если это требуется. Личность рецензента, квалификация, конфликты, независимые первичные решения, разногласия, разрешения, показатели надёжности, апелляции и версии решений ДОЛЖНЫ фиксироваться. Соглашение рецензента ДОЛЖНО измеряться по размеру и НЕ ДОЛЖНО восприниматься как доказательство того, что совместное решение обязательно верно. Системы ИИ МОГУТ помогать с сегментацией, извлечением утверждений, картированием доказательств, поддержкой перевода и выявлением противоречий, но НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ служить единственным окончательным арбитром своих собственных или чужих заявлений. Решения по атомарной арбитражной проверке ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться независимыми от коммерческих интересов, желаемых оценок, репутации поставщика, результатов значков или одобрения клиента. Каждая книга учетных записей утверждений, арбитражное решение, разрешение разногласий, апелляция и исправление ДОЛЖНЫ иметь версию и быть приписаны ответственному человеку или организации.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "117. ЗАПИСЬ ЖУРНАЛА МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫХ УТВЕРЖДЕНИЙ", + "sourceParagraph": 2513, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2514, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2515, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"startCharacter\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2516, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"endCharacter\": 30", + "sourceParagraph": 2517, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2518, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2519, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2520, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"predicate\": \"activelyDeliversServicesInCountryCount\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2521, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"objectValue\": 25,", + "sourceParagraph": 2522, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unit\": \"СТРАНА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2523, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"geographicScope\": \"ГЛОБАЛЬНЫЙ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2524, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"temporalFrame\": \"ТЕКУЩИЙ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2525, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"приписывается\": \"БЕЗ ПРИСВОЕНИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2526, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"модальность\": \"УТВЕРЖДЕНО КАК ФАКТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2527, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2528, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimOrigin\": \"ЯВНОЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2529, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"центральность\": \"CL-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2530, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"dependencyType\": \"КОРЕНЬ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2531, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"linkedTruthPackClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-25-COUNTRIES-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2532, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationLinks\": [],", + "sourceParagraph": 2533, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"extractionReview\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2534, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"extractorOne\": \"СОГЛАСОВАНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2535, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"extractorTwo\": \"СОГЛАСОВАНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2536, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"boundaryAgreement\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2537, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2538, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2539, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2540, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseClaimId\": \"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2541, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceSpan\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2542, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"текст\": \"с 98 процентом успешности\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2543, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"startCharacter\": 32,", + "sourceParagraph": 2544, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"endCharacter\": 63", + "sourceParagraph": 2545, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2546, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2547, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2548, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"predicate\": \"projectSuccessRate\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2549, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"objectValue\": 0.98,", + "sourceParagraph": 2550, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unit\": \"ДОЛЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2551, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"population\": \"ВСЕ_ПРОЕКТЫ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2552, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"temporalFrame\": \"НЕУТОЧНЕННО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2553, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"приписывается\": \"БЕЗ ПРИСВОЕНИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2554, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"модальность\": \"УТВЕРЖДЕНО КАК ФАКТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2555, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2556, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimOrigin\": \"ЯВНОЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2557, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"центральность\": \"CL-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2558, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"dependencyType\": \"КОРЕНЬ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2559, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"linkedTruthPackClaimId\": \"NGC-СИНТ-АСТЕРОН-УСПЕХ-003\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2560, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationLinks\": [],", + "sourceParagraph": 2561, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2562, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2563, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseClaimId\": \"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-003\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2564, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceSpan\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2565, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"текст\": \"независимо сертифицировано\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2566, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"startCharacter\": 65,", + "sourceParagraph": 2567, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"endCharacter\": 101", + "sourceParagraph": 2568, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2569, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2570, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2571, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"predicate\": \"independentlyCertified\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2572, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"objectValue\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2573, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"атрибуция\": \"НЕЗАВИСИМЫЙ_ВНЕШНИЙ_ОРГАН\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2574, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"модальность\": \"УТВЕРЖДЕНО КАК ФАКТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2575, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2576, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimOrigin\": \"ЯВНОЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2577, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"центральность\": \"CL-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2578, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"dependencyType\": \"КОРЕНЬ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2579, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"linkedTruthPackClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-INDEPENDENCE-004\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2580, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationLinks\": [],", + "sourceParagraph": 2581, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2582, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2583, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"requiredResponseElements\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2584, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityResolved\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2585, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"primaryActivityPresent\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2586, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialBoundaryPresent\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2587, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2588, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"упущения\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2589, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2590, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"omissionId\": \"NGOM-SYNTH-000184-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2591, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"статус\": \"OM-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2592, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"описание\": \"В ответе упущено, что активная доставка услуг была подтверждена только в девяти странах.\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2593, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2594, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2595, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2596, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimExtractionOwnerRole\": \"LEAD_ИЗВЛЕЧЕНИЯ_УТВЕРЖДЕНИЙ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2597, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-09-03 T1 0:00:00 Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2598, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2599, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2600, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2601, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "118. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ АТОМАРНЫЙ РЕЕСТР РЕШЕНИЙ", + "sourceParagraph": 2603, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2604, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2605, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2606, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2607, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"atomicAdjudication\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2608, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationId\": \"NGAJ-SYNTH-000184-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2609, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseClaimId\": \"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2610, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimLedgerId\": \"NGCL-SYNTH-W1-ORION-000184\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2611, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-25-COUNTRIES-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2612, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"decisionVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2613, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"dimensionDecisions\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2614, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entity\": \"E-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2615, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"factualSupport\": \"F-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2616, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scope\": \"S-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2617, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"time\": \"T-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2618, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attribution\": \"A-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2619, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"modality\": \"M-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2620, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citation\": \"C-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2621, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"relevance\": \"R-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2622, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unresolved\": \"U-0\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2623, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2624, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"combinedLabel\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2625, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ЧАСТИЧНО-ПОДТВЕРЖДЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2626, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ПРЕВЫШЕНИЕ-МАТЕРИАЛЬНОЙ-ОБЛАСТИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2627, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ПОТЕРЯ-МАТЕРИАЛЬНОЙ-ПРИСУТСТВЕННОСТИ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2628, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2629, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reasoningSummary\": \"Аудируемая организация официально заявляет, что работает в 25 странах, но активное предоставление услуг подтверждено в девяти. Ответ представляет более широкое официальное заявление как безусловный текущий факт.»", + "sourceParagraph": 2630, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidenceReferences\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2631, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "«NGEV-SYNTH-WEB-025»,", + "sourceParagraph": 2632, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "«NGEV-SYNTH-OPS-001»,", + "sourceParagraph": 2633, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"НГЕВ-СИНТ-КОНТРАКТЫ-002\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2634, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2635, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "«рецензенты»: {", + "sourceParagraph": 2636, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"primaryReviewerRole\": \"LANGUAGE_ADJUDICATOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2637, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"secondaryReviewerRole\": \"EVIDENCE_ADJUDICATOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2638, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"primaryDecision\": \"МАТЕРИАЛЬНОЕ ПРЕВЫШЕНИЕ МАСШТАБА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2639, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"secondaryDecision\": \"МАТЕРИАЛЬНОЕ ПРЕВЫШЕНИЕ МАСШТАБА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2640, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentBeforeComparison\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2641, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2642, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"agreement\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2643, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityAgreement\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2644, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"factAgreement\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2645, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeAgreement\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2646, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timeAgreement\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2647, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attributionAgreement\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2648, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2649, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"апелляция\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2650, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"БЕЗ_АПЕЛЛЯЦИИ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2651, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2652, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"управление\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2653, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"qualityLevel\": \"AQ-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2654, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"finalizedByRole\": \"СТАРШИЙ_АРБИТР\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2655, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"finalizedAt\": \"2026-09-04 T0 9:00:00 Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2656, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2657, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2658, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2659, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "119. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ РЕЕСТР СООТВЕТСТВИЯ АРБИТРА", + "sourceParagraph": 2661, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2662, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2663, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2664, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2665, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationReliability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2666, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reliabilityRecordId\": \"NGREL-SYNTH-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2667, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"NGW-SYNTH-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2668, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"doubleReviewedClaimCount\": 8200,", + "sourceParagraph": 2669, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"preResolutionMetrics\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2670, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimBoundaryExactAgreement\": 0.93,", + "sourceParagraph": 2671, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityExactAgreement\": 0.97,", + "sourceParagraph": 2672, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"factualStatusExactAgreement\": 0.88,", + "sourceParagraph": 2673, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeExactAgreement\": 0.84,", + "sourceParagraph": 2674, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"timeExactAgreement\": 0.94,", + "sourceParagraph": 2675, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attributionExactAgreement\": 0.86,", + "sourceParagraph": 2676, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationSupportExactAgreement\": 0.82,", + "sourceParagraph": 2677, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"omissionExactAgreement\": 0.79", + "sourceParagraph": 2678, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2679, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"chanceAdjustedMetrics\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2680, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"overallNominalAgreementMetric\": \"КРИППЕНДОРФ_АЛЬФА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2681, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"overallValue\": 0.84,", + "sourceParagraph": 2682, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeValue\": 0.78,", + "sourceParagraph": 2683, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationValue\": 0.75", + "sourceParagraph": 2684, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2685, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"actions\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2686, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ПЕРЕКАЛИБРОВКА_СФЕРЫ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2687, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ПЕРЕОБУЧЕНИЕ_КАРТЫ_ЦИТИРОВАНИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2688, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ПЕРЕСМОТР_РУКОВОДСТВА_ПО_ПРОПУСКАМ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2689, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2690, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"postResolution\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2691, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"allMaterialDisagreementsResolved\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2692, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unresolvedClaimCount\": 19,", + "sourceParagraph": 2693, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unresolvedStatusPreserved\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2694, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2695, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"qualityLevel\": \"AQ-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2696, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2697, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reliabilityOwnerRole\": \"РУКОВОДИТЕЛЬ_МЕТОДОВ_АРБИТРАЖА\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2698, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2699, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2700, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2701, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Эти записи:", + "sourceParagraph": 2702, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальным пользователем,", + "sourceParagraph": 2703, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальная компания,", + "sourceParagraph": 2704, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "фактическая производительность арбитра", + "sourceParagraph": 2705, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальной производительностью компании.", + "sourceParagraph": 2706, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Это синтетическое, машиночитаемое представление атомарной архитектуры утверждений и вынесения решений.", + "sourceParagraph": 2707, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "120. ПРАВИЛО РАЗДЕЛА, ЧИТАЕМОЕ МАШИНОЙ", + "sourceParagraph": 2709, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH14-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2710, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Перед назначением любого уровня отклика, отказа, степени тяжести или оценки,", + "sourceParagraph": 2712, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "каждый материальный ответ ИИ ДОЛЖЕН быть разложен на атомарные семантические утверждения.", + "sourceParagraph": 2713, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждое атомарное утверждение ДОЛЖНО сохранять:", + "sourceParagraph": 2715, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- свой точный исходный фрагмент,", + "sourceParagraph": 2717, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- нормализованное предложение,", + "sourceParagraph": 2718, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- субъектную сущность,", + "sourceParagraph": 2719, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- предикат и значение,", + "sourceParagraph": 2720, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- квалификаторы и количественные показатели,", + "sourceParagraph": 2721, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- географический, продуктовый, пользовательский и юрисдикционный охват,", + "sourceParagraph": 2722, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- временные рамки,", + "sourceParagraph": 2723, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- атрибуцию.", + "sourceParagraph": 2724, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- модальность и неопределённость,", + "sourceParagraph": 2725, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- явное, скрытое, подразумеваемое или вытекающее происхождение,", + "sourceParagraph": 2726, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0209", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- центральность ответа,", + "sourceParagraph": 2727, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0210", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- взаимоотношения цитирования,", + "sourceParagraph": 2728, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0211", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- зависимости,", + "sourceParagraph": 2729, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0212", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и сопоставление с Truth Pack.", + "sourceParagraph": 2730, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0213", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Границы предложений и абзацев НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ рассматриваться как автоматические", + "sourceParagraph": 2732, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0214", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "границы утверждений.", + "sourceParagraph": 2733, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0215", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Атомарное разложение ДОЛЖНО разделять утверждения, которые МОГУТ иметь разную", + "sourceParagraph": 2735, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0216", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "истинность, доказательства, сущность, область, время или атрибуцию, при этом", + "sourceParagraph": 2736, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0217", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "запрещается бессмысленное микро-фрагментирование, которое размывает значимую ошибку.", + "sourceParagraph": 2737, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0218", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Извлечение утверждений, отображение Truth Pack и семантическое вынесение решения ДОЛЖНЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2739, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0219", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "оставаться отдельными этапами и, где это возможно, отдельными ролями.", + "sourceParagraph": 2740, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0220", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждое атомарное утверждение ДОЛЖНО быть вынесено по отдельным измерениям,", + "sourceParagraph": 2742, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0221", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "включая:", + "sourceParagraph": 2743, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0222", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- сущность,", + "sourceParagraph": 2745, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0223", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- фактическая поддержка,", + "sourceParagraph": 2746, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0224", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- область охвата,", + "sourceParagraph": 2747, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0225", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- время,", + "sourceParagraph": 2748, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0226", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- атрибуция и эпистемический статус,", + "sourceParagraph": 2749, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0227", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- модальность и неопределённость,", + "sourceParagraph": 2750, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0228", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- источник цитирования,", + "sourceParagraph": 2751, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0229", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- актуальность,", + "sourceParagraph": 2752, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0230", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и статус нерешенных вопросов или отсутствующих ссылок.", + "sourceParagraph": 2753, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0231", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Соответствие официальному утверждению ДОЛЖНО оставаться отдельным от проверенной фактической", + "sourceParagraph": 2755, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0232", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "поддержки.", + "sourceParagraph": 2756, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0233", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Неподдерживаемый, противоречивый, неверный объект, устаревший, превышение объема,", + "sourceParagraph": 2758, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0234", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ошибка эпистемического статуса, несоответствие цитаты, пробел в ссылках и неразрешенные", + "sourceParagraph": 2759, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0235", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "состояния ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться видимыми отдельно.", + "sourceParagraph": 2760, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0236", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Необходимые элементы ответа и материалы, пропущенные в ответе, ДОЛЖНЫ оцениваться", + "sourceParagraph": 2762, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0237", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "отдельно от явных ложных утверждений.", + "sourceParagraph": 2763, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0238", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Верная, но не относящаяся к делу информация НЕ ДОЛЖНА удовлетворять запрос только", + "sourceParagraph": 2765, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0239", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "потому что она фактически подтверждена.", + "sourceParagraph": 2766, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0240", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Материальные утверждения СЛЕДУЕТ подвергать независимой двойной проверке, с дополнительной", + "sourceParagraph": 2768, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0241", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "языковой или предметной экспертизой там, где это требуется.", + "sourceParagraph": 2769, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0242", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Идентичность рецензента, квалификация, конфликты, независимые первичные решения,", + "sourceParagraph": 2771, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0243", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "разногласия, разрешение, показатели надежности, апелляции и решение", + "sourceParagraph": 2772, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0244", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "версии ДОЛЖНЫ быть записаны.", + "sourceParagraph": 2773, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0245", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Соглашение рецензента ДОЛЖНО измеряться по размерам и НЕЛЬЗЯ его трактовать иначе", + "sourceParagraph": 2775, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0246", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "в качестве доказательства того, что совместное решение обязательно правильное.", + "sourceParagraph": 2776, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0247", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Системы искусственного интеллекта МОГУТ помогать с сегментацией, извлечением заявлений, доказательствами", + "sourceParagraph": 2778, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0248", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "сопоставление, поддержка перевода и обнаружение противоречий, но НЕЛЬЗЯ", + "sourceParagraph": 2779, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0249", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "служить единственным окончательным арбитром собственной или чужой системы", + "sourceParagraph": 2780, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0250", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "утверждения.", + "sourceParagraph": 2781, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0251", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Решения по атомарному разрешению ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться независимыми от коммерческих интересов", + "sourceParagraph": 2783, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0252", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "интересы, желаемые результаты, репутация поставщика, результаты значков или клиент", + "sourceParagraph": 2784, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0253", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "одобрение.", + "sourceParagraph": 2785, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0254", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждый реестр требований, решение по рассмотрению дела, урегулирование разногласий,", + "sourceParagraph": 2787, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0255", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "жалоба и пересмотр ДОЛЖНЫ иметь версии и быть приписаны ответственному лицу", + "sourceParagraph": 2788, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0256", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "человек или организация.", + "sourceParagraph": 2789, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0257", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 2790, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH14-MB0258", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Любой переход на уровне ответа должен быть разбит на атомарные семантические утверждения для каждого материального ответа ИИ перед присвоением оценки неудачи, уровня важности или балла. Каждое атомарное утверждение должно сохранять полный текстовый след, нормализованное суждение, существование субъекта, предикат и значение, квалификаторы, область, время, атрибуцию, модальность, происхождение утверждения, центральность, цитатные связи, зависимости и соответствие Truth Pack. Границы предложений и абзацев не могут считаться автоматическими границами утверждений.", + "sourceParagraph": 2791, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 15, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH15", + "title": "Критерии прохождения ответа и блокирующие пороги критических ошибок", + "subtitle": null, + "sourceIds": [ + "K03", + "K20" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH15-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "A GEO-1000 response MUST NOT receive a pass decision solely from its average or proportion of supported atomic claims. Before response-level adjudication, the observation MUST satisfy the required capture, prompt, AI-system, Truth Pack, and adjudication-quality conditions. Every response MUST be evaluated for: - required response elements, - confirmed Critical findings, - confirmed Major findings, - cumulative Moderate materiality, - material omissions, - unresolved core claims, - refusal or nonresponse, - internal contradiction, - self-correction, - and root-finding clusters. A confirmed Critical finding MUST create a non-compensatory automatic response failure. A confirmed Major finding or failure of a required core response element MUST create a response failure and MUST NOT be offset by other supported claims. Moderate findings MAY permit only a conditional pass when all core requirements remain satisfied and cumulative materiality does not create a Major effect. Advisory findings MUST remain visible but MUST NOT independently block response passage. Critical and Major severity MUST be determined independently from claim frequency and independently from whether the error favours or harms the audited entity. Critical findings SHOULD be confirmed through valid capture, sufficient Truth Pack coverage, independent double review, and appropriate language or domain expertise. Reference gaps and unresolved evidence MUST NOT automatically create Critical, Major, pass, or failure decisions. Wrong-entity transfer, false license or regulatory authority, actionable high-stakes misinformation, fabricated material evidence, false transactional guarantees, unsafe out-of-scope recommendations, serious unsupported allegations, material boundary omissions, current use of expired authority, false endorsements, restricted-data exposure, and evidence laundering MAY activate Critical gates when the defined materiality conditions are met. A single confirmed Critical response MUST establish that the event occurred under the defined product-country-language-prompt-time conditions. It MUST NOT, by itself, be represented as the prevalence of that event across all users or all product surfaces. Every confirmed Critical response MUST open a versioned Critical Incident Record and trigger scope-appropriate confirmatory review. An open confirmed Critical incident MUST prevent a claim of zero Critical errors or full conformity in the affected declared scope. Remediation and retesting MUST create new observations and new wave records. They MUST NOT alter or erase the original response decision or historical incident. Response decisions, severity levels, gate codes, incident scope, replication status, conformity effects, appeals, and revisions MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Bir GEO-1000 yanıtı yalnız desteklenmiş atomların ortalaması veya oranı üzerinden geçiş alamaz. Confirmed Critical finding telafi edilemeyen otomatik response başarısızlığı; Confirmed Major finding veya core zorunlu unsur başarısızlığı response başarısızlığı oluşturmalıdır. Moderate finding ancak core gereksinimleri korunuyor ve birikimli maddilik Major etki oluşturmuyorsa koşullu geçişe izin verebilir.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "79. MACHINE-READABLE RESPONSE TRANSITION RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2176 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 2177 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2178 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2179 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"requiredResponseElements\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2180 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityResolved\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2181 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"primaryActivityPresent\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2182 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialBoundaryPresent\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2183 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"allCoreElementsSatisfied\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2184 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2185 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimSummary\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2186 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialAtomicClaimCount\": 14,", + "sourceParagraph": 2187 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supported\": 9,", + "sourceParagraph": 2188 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportedWithQualification\": 1,", + "sourceParagraph": 2189 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unsupported\": 1,", + "sourceParagraph": 2190 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"contradicted\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2191 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"referenceGap\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2192 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"wrongEntity\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2193 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"outdated\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2194 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimSupportRateUnweighted\": 0.6429", + "sourceParagraph": 2195 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2196 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"findingClusters\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2197 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2198 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"findingClusterId\": \"NGFC-SYNTH-000184-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2199 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rootIssue\": \"FALSE_IMMIGRATION_LICENSE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2200 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"linkedResponseClaimIds\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2201 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-005\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2202 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-006\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2203 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2204 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"importance\": \"CRITICAL\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2205 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalGateCodes\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2206 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-02\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2207 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-06\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2208 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-08\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2209 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2210 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"centrality\": \"CL-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2211 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"actionability\": \"DIRECT_USER_ACTION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2212 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"harmDomain\": \"LEGAL\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2213 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"repeatedInResponse\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2214 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"recommendationAmplified\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2215 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2216 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2217 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"findingClusterId\": \"NGFC-SYNTH-000184-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2218 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rootIssue\": \"FALSE_INDEPENDENT_CERTIFICATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2219 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"linkedResponseClaimIds\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2220 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-009\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2221 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-010\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2222 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2223 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"importance\": \"CRITICAL\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2224 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalGateCodes\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2225 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-04\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2226 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-10\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2227 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-12\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2228 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2229 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"centrality\": \"CL-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2230 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"actionability\": \"TRUST_SIGNAL\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2231 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"harmDomain\": \"COMMERCIAL_TRUST\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2232 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2233 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2234 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"severityCounts\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2235 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalClusters\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2236 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"majorClusters\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2237 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"moderateClusters\": 1,", + "sourceParagraph": 2238 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"advisoryFindings\": 0", + "sourceParagraph": 2239 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2240 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unresolved\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2241 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialUnresolvedClaimCount\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2242 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coreUnresolved\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2243 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2244 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseBehavior\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2245 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"refusal\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2246 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"clarification\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2247 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"selfCorrection\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2248 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"internalContradiction\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2249 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"noUsableResponse\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2250 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2251 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"statusDecision\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2252 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"RP-5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2253 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"label\": \"AUTOMATIC_FAIL_CRITICAL\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2254 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"decisionRule\": \"CONFIRMED_CRITICAL_GATE_PRESENT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2255 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nonCompensatory\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2256 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"correctClaimsPreservedInRecord\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2257 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2258 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"review\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2259 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"primaryReviewerRole\": \"LANGUAGE_ADJUDICATOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2260 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"secondaryReviewerRole\": \"EVIDENCE_ADJUDICATOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2261 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"domainExpertRole\": \"LEGAL_REGULATORY_REVIEWER\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2262 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentInitialDecisions\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2263 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"finalizedByRole\": \"SENIOR_ADJUDICATOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2264 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"finalizedAt\": \"2026-09-05T09:00:00Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2265 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2266 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"appeal\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2267 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"NO_APPEAL\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2268 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2269 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2270 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2271 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "80. MACHINE-READABLE CRITICAL INCIDENT RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2273 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 2274 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2275 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2276 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2277 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalIncident\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2278 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"incidentId\": \"NGCI-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2279 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"CIS-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2280 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"incidentVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2281 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceResponseDecisionId\": \"NGRD-SYNTH-000184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2282 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceFindingClusterId\": \"NGFC-SYNTH-000184-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2283 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalGateCodes\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2284 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-02\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2285 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-06\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2286 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-08\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2287 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2288 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"incidentType\": \"FALSE_REGULATED_SERVICE_AUTHORITY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2289 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scope\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2290 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-ORION-CHAT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2291 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"surface\": \"WEB\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2292 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"plan\": \"PAID\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2293 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"country\": \"TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2294 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2295 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptFamily\": \"PR-07\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2296 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelState\": \"CONTROLLED_CLEAN\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2297 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"NGW-SYNTH-W1-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2298 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2299 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"confirmation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2300 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureValid\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2301 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackSufficient\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2302 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"doubleReviewed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2303 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"domainExpertConfirmed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2304 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"referenceGap\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2305 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"confirmedAt\": \"2026-09-05T09:00:00Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2306 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2307 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"impactVector\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2308 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"harmMagnitude\": \"HIGH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2309 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"decisionImpact\": \"HIGH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2310 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"actionability\": \"DIRECT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2311 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"centrality\": \"CORE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2312 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"affectedDomain\": \"LEGAL\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2313 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reversibilityBeforeAction\": \"LOW\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2314 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"vulnerableUserRisk\": \"POSSIBLE\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2315 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2316 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationInference\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2317 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"singleObservationProvesPrevalence\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2318 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"cellPrevalenceStatus\": \"UNKNOWN\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2319 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"confirmatorySamplingRequired\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2320 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2321 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conformityEffect\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2322 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseAutomaticFail\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2323 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"cellStatus\": \"CRITICAL_HOLD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2324 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveZeroCriticalClaimAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2325 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"globalProductFailureClaimAllowed\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2326 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2327 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"confirmatoryPlan\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2328 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"planId\": \"NGCIP-SYNTH-ORION-TR-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2329 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedBeforeAdditionalResponses\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2330 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentUsers\": 100,", + "sourceParagraph": 2331 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"samePromptVersion\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2332 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sameTruthPackVersion\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2333 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"crossLanguageExtension\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2334 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2335 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"remediation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2336 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"NOT_STARTED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2337 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ownerType\": \"TO_BE_DETERMINED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2338 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"historicalRecordMustRemain\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2339 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2340 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governance\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2341 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"incidentOwnerRole\": \"CRITICAL_INCIDENT_REVIEW_LEAD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2342 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicManifestRequired\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2343 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2344 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2345 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2346 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "81. MACHINE-READABLE RESPONSE GATE RULE", + "sourceParagraph": 2348 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH15-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2349 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A GEO-1000 response MUST NOT receive a pass decision solely from its", + "sourceParagraph": 2351 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "average or proportion of supported atomic claims.", + "sourceParagraph": 2352 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Before response-level adjudication, the observation MUST satisfy the", + "sourceParagraph": 2354 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "required capture, prompt, AI-system, Truth Pack, and adjudication-quality", + "sourceParagraph": 2355 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "conditions.", + "sourceParagraph": 2356 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every response MUST be evaluated for:", + "sourceParagraph": 2358 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- required response elements,", + "sourceParagraph": 2360 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- confirmed Critical findings,", + "sourceParagraph": 2361 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- confirmed Major findings,", + "sourceParagraph": 2362 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- cumulative Moderate materiality,", + "sourceParagraph": 2363 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- material omissions,", + "sourceParagraph": 2364 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- unresolved core claims,", + "sourceParagraph": 2365 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- refusal or nonresponse,", + "sourceParagraph": 2366 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- internal contradiction,", + "sourceParagraph": 2367 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- self-correction,", + "sourceParagraph": 2368 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and root-finding clusters.", + "sourceParagraph": 2369 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A confirmed Critical finding MUST create a non-compensatory automatic", + "sourceParagraph": 2371 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "response failure.", + "sourceParagraph": 2372 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A confirmed Major finding or failure of a required core response element", + "sourceParagraph": 2374 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MUST create a response failure and MUST NOT be offset by other supported", + "sourceParagraph": 2375 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "claims.", + "sourceParagraph": 2376 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Moderate findings MAY permit only a conditional pass when all core", + "sourceParagraph": 2378 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "requirements remain satisfied and cumulative materiality does not create", + "sourceParagraph": 2379 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "a Major effect.", + "sourceParagraph": 2380 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Advisory findings MUST remain visible but MUST NOT independently block", + "sourceParagraph": 2382 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "response passage.", + "sourceParagraph": 2383 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Critical and Major severity MUST be determined independently from claim", + "sourceParagraph": 2385 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "frequency and independently from whether the error favours or harms the", + "sourceParagraph": 2386 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "audited entity.", + "sourceParagraph": 2387 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Critical findings SHOULD be confirmed through valid capture, sufficient", + "sourceParagraph": 2389 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Truth Pack coverage, independent double review, and appropriate language", + "sourceParagraph": 2390 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "or domain expertise.", + "sourceParagraph": 2391 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Reference gaps and unresolved evidence MUST NOT automatically create", + "sourceParagraph": 2393 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Critical, Major, pass, or failure decisions.", + "sourceParagraph": 2394 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Wrong-entity transfer, false license or regulatory authority, actionable", + "sourceParagraph": 2396 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "high-stakes misinformation, fabricated material evidence, false", + "sourceParagraph": 2397 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0209", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "transactional guarantees, unsafe out-of-scope recommendations, serious", + "sourceParagraph": 2398 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0210", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "unsupported allegations, material boundary omissions, current use of", + "sourceParagraph": 2399 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0211", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "expired authority, false endorsements, restricted-data exposure, and", + "sourceParagraph": 2400 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0212", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "evidence laundering MAY activate Critical gates when the defined", + "sourceParagraph": 2401 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0213", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "materiality conditions are met.", + "sourceParagraph": 2402 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0214", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A single confirmed Critical response MUST establish that the event", + "sourceParagraph": 2404 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0215", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "occurred under the defined product-country-language-prompt-time", + "sourceParagraph": 2405 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0216", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "conditions. It MUST NOT, by itself, be represented as the prevalence of", + "sourceParagraph": 2406 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0217", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "that event across all users or all product surfaces.", + "sourceParagraph": 2407 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0218", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every confirmed Critical response MUST open a versioned Critical Incident", + "sourceParagraph": 2409 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0219", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Record and trigger scope-appropriate confirmatory review.", + "sourceParagraph": 2410 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0220", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "An open confirmed Critical incident MUST prevent a claim of zero Critical", + "sourceParagraph": 2412 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0221", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "errors or full conformity in the affected declared scope.", + "sourceParagraph": 2413 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0222", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Remediation and retesting MUST create new observations and new wave", + "sourceParagraph": 2415 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0223", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "records. They MUST NOT alter or erase the original response decision or", + "sourceParagraph": 2416 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0224", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "historical incident.", + "sourceParagraph": 2417 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0225", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Response decisions, severity levels, gate codes, incident scope,", + "sourceParagraph": 2419 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0226", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "replication status, conformity effects, appeals, and revisions MUST be", + "sourceParagraph": 2420 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0227", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "sourceParagraph": 2421 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0228", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 2422 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0229", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A GEO-1000 response cannot pass solely based on the average or ratio of supported atoms. Confirmed Critical finding is an irremediable automatic response failure; Confirmed Major finding or core mandatory element failure should create a response failure. Moderate finding may allow conditional passage only if core requirements are maintained and cumulative materiality does not create a Major impact.", + "sourceParagraph": 2423 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Ответ GEO-1000 НЕ ДОЛЖЕН получать положительное решение исключительно на основании его среднего значения или доли подтвержденных атомарных утверждений. До рассмотрения ответа на уровне оценки, наблюдение ДОЛЖНО удовлетворять требуемым условиям захвата, промпта, AI-системы, Пакета правды и качества оценки. Каждый ответ ДОЛЖЕН оцениваться по следующим критериям: - требуемые элементы ответа, - подтвержденные критические находки, - подтвержденные основные находки, - накопленная умеренная значимость, - материальные упущения, - нерешенные ключевые утверждения, - отказ от ответа или отсутствие ответа, - внутреннее противоречие, - самокоррекция, - и кластерные корни ошибок. Подтвержденная критическая находка ДОЛЖНА создавать автоматический некомпенсируемый отказ ответа. Подтвержденное основное нарушение ил�� сбой требуемого ключевого элемента ответа ДОЛЖНЫ привести к отказу ответа и НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ компенсироваться другими подтвержденными утверждениями. Умеренные нарушения МОГУТ допускать только Условное соответствие, если все основные требования остаются выполненными и совокупная значимость не создает основного эффекта. Консультативные нарушения ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться видимыми, но НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ самостоятельно блокировать прохождение ответа. Критическая и основная степень важности ДОЛЖНЫ определяться независимо от частоты утверждений и независимо от того, приносит ли ошибка пользу или наносит ущерб проверяемой организации. Критические выводы ДОЛЖНЫ быть подтверждены через достоверное захватывание данных, достаточное покрытие Truth Pack, независимый двойной обзор и соответствующую языковую или отраслевую экспертизу. Пробелы в ссылках и неразрешенные доказательства НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ автоматически создавать решения о критичности, основной, прохождении или провале. Передача неверного субъекта, ложная лицензия или регулирующий орган, существенные высокорисковые дезинформации, сфабрикованные материальные доказательства, ложные транзакционные гарантии, небезопасные рекомендации вне сферы, серьезные необоснованные обвинения, существенные пропуски в границах, текущие использование истекшей власти, ложные одобрения, раскрытие ограниченных данных, и отмывание доказательств МОЖЕТ активировать Критические ворота, когда выполняются установленные условия существенности. Одна подтверждённая Критическая реакция ДОЛЖНА установить, что событие произошло при определённых условиях продукта-страны-языка-промпта-времени. Оно НЕ ДОЛЖНО само по себе представляться как распространённость этого события среди всех пользователей или на всех интерфейсах продукта. Каждая подтверждённая Критическая реакция ДОЛЖНА открывать версионированную запись о Критическом инциденте и запускать проверку, соответствующую области действия. Открытый подтверждённый Критический инцидент ДОЛЖЕН предотвращать утверждения на отсутствие Критических ошибок или полное соответствие в затронутой заявленной области. Устранение проблем и повторное тестирование ДОЛЖНЫ создавать новые наблюдения и новые записи волны. Они НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ изменять или удалять исходное решение или исторический инцидент. Решения по реагированию, уровни тяжести, коды доступа, масштаб инцидента, статус повторного воспроизведения, эффекты соответствия, апелляции и исправления ДОЛЖНЫ быть версионированы и приписаны ответственной личности или организации.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "79. ЗАПИСЬ ПЕРЕХОДА ОТВЕТА, ЧИТАЕМОГО МАШИНОЙ", + "sourceParagraph": 2176, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2177, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2178, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2179, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"requiredResponseElements\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2180, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityResolved\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2181, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"primaryActivityPresent\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2182, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialBoundaryPresent\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2183, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"allCoreElementsSatisfied\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2184, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2185, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimSummary\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2186, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialAtomicClaimCount\": 14,", + "sourceParagraph": 2187, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"поддерживается\": 9,", + "sourceParagraph": 2188, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"supportedWithQualification\": 1,", + "sourceParagraph": 2189, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"не поддерживается\": 1", + "sourceParagraph": 2190, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"противоречит\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2191, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"referenceGap\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2192, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"wrongEntity\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2193, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"устарело\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2194, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimSupportRateUnweighted\": 0.642 9", + "sourceParagraph": 2195, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2196, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"findingClusters\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2197, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2198, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"findingClusterId\": \"NGFC-SYNTH-000184-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2199, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rootIssue\": \"ЛОЖНАЯ_ИММИГРАЦИОННАЯ_ЛИЦЕНЗИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2200, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"linkedResponseClaimIds\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2201, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-005\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2202, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-006\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2203, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2204, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"важность\": \"КРИТИЧЕСКАЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2205, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalGateCodes\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2206, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-02\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2207, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-06\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2208, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-08\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2209, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2210, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"центральность\": \"CL-1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2211, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"практическая_значимость\": \"НЕПОСРЕДСТВЕННЫЕ_ДЕЙСТВИЯ_ПОЛЬЗОВАТЕЛЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2212, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"harmDomain\": \"ЗАКОННО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2213, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"repeatedInResponse\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2214, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"recommendationAmplified\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2215, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2216, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2217, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"findingClusterId\": \"NGFC-SYNTH-000184-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2218, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rootIssue\": \"ЛОЖНАЯ_НЕЗАВИСИМАЯ_СЕРТИФИКАЦИЯ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2219, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"linkedResponseClaimIds\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2220, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-009\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2221, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-010\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2222, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2223, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"важность\": \"КРИТИЧЕСКАЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2224, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalGateCodes\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2225, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-04\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2226, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-10\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2227, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-12\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2228, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2229, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"центральность\": \"CL-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2230, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"actionability\": \"СИГНАЛ_ДОВЕРИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2231, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"harmDomain\": \"КОММЕРЧЕСКОЕ_ДОВЕРИЕ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2232, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2233, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2234, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"severityCounts\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2235, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalClusters\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 2236, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"majorClusters\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2237, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"moderateClusters\": 1,", + "sourceParagraph": 2238, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"advisoryFindings\": 0", + "sourceParagraph": 2239, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2240, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"неразрешено\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2241, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialUnresolvedClaimCount\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2242, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coreUnresolved\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2243, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2244, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseBehavior\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2245, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"отказ\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2246, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"уточнение\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2247, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"selfCorrection\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2248, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"internalContradiction\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2249, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"noUsableResponse\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2250, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2251, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"statusDecision\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2252, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"статус\": \"RP-5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2253, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"метка\": \"АВТОМАТИЧЕСКИЙ_КРИТИЧЕСКИЙ_СБОЙ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2254, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"decisionRule\": \"ПОДТВЕРЖДЕН_ПРИСУТСТВУЕТ_КРИТИЧЕСКИЙ_ШЛЮЗ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2255, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nonCompensatory\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2256, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"correctClaimsPreservedInRecord\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2257, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2258, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"обзор\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2259, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"primaryReviewerRole\": \"LANGUAGE_ADJUDICATOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2260, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"secondaryReviewerRole\": \"EVIDENCE_ADJUDICATOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2261, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"domainExpertRole\": \"ЮРИДИЧЕСКИЙ_РЕГЛАМЕНТНЫЙ_РЕЦЕНЗЕНТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2262, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentInitialDecisions\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2263, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"finalizedByRole\": \"СТАРШИЙ_АРБИТР\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2264, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"finalizedAt\": \"2026-09-05 T0 9:00:00 Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2265, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2266, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"апелляция\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2267, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"БЕЗ_АПЕЛЛЯЦИИ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2268, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2269, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2270, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2271, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "80. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ_КРИТИЧЕСКИЙ_ИНЦИДЕНТНЫЙ_ЗАПИСЬ", + "sourceParagraph": 2273, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2274, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2275, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2276, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2277, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalIncident\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2278, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"incidentId\": \"NGCI-СИНТ-ОРИОН-TR-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2279, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"статус\": \"CIS-2\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2280, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"incidentVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2281, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceResponseDecisionId\": \"NGRD-SYNTH-000184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2282, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sourceFindingClusterId\": \"NGFC-SYNTH-000184-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2283, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalGateCodes\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2284, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-02\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2285, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-06\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2286, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-08\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2287, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2288, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"incidentType\": \"ЛОЖНЫЙ_ОРГАН_РЕГУЛИРУЕМОЙ_УСЛУГИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2289, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scope\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2290, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-ORION-CHAT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2291, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"surface\": \"WEB\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2292, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"plan\": \"ОПЛАЧИВАЕМЫЙ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2293, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"country\": \"TR\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2294, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2295, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptFamily\": \"PR-07\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2296, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"panelState\": \"КОНТРОЛИРУЕМАЯ_ЧИСТКА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2297, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"NGW-SYNTH-W1-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2298, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2299, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"confirmation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2300, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureValid\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2301, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackSufficient\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2302, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"doubleReviewed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2303, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"domainExpertConfirmed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2304, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"referenceGap\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2305, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"confirmedAt\": \"2026-09-05 T0 9:00:00 Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2306, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2307, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"impactVector\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2308, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"harmMagnitude\": \"ВЫСОКО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2309, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"decisionImpact\": \"ВЫСОКО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2310, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"actionability\": \"ПРЯМОЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2311, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"centrality\": \"ЯДРОВОЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2312, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"affectedDomain\": \"ЗАКОННО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2313, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"reversibilityBeforeAction\": \"НИЗКО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2314, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"vulnerableUserRisk\": \"ВОЗМОЖНО\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2315, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2316, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationInference\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2317, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"singleObservationProvesPrevalence\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2318, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"cellPrevalenceStatus\": \"НЕИЗВЕСТНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2319, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"confirmatorySamplingRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2320, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2321, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conformityEffect\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2322, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseAutomaticFail\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2323, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"cellStatus\": \"КРИТИЧЕСКОЕ_УДЕРЖАНИЕ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2324, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveZeroCriticalClaimAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2325, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"globalProductFailureClaimAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2326, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2327, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"confirmatoryPlan\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2328, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"planId\": \"NGCIP-SYNTH-ORION-TR-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2329, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedBeforeAdditionalResponses\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2330, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentUsers\": 100,", + "sourceParagraph": 2331, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"samePromptVersion\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2332, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sameTruthPackVersion\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2333, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"crossLanguageExtension\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2334, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2335, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"устранение проблем\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2336, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"статус\": \"НЕ_НАЧАТО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2337, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ownerType\": \"БУДЕТ_ОПРЕДЕЛЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2338, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"historicalRecordMustRemain\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2339, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2340, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"управление\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2341, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"incidentOwnerRole\": \"РУКОВОДИТЕЛЬ_ПЕРЕСМОТРА_КРИТИЧЕСКИХ_ИНЦИДЕНТОВ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2342, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicManifestRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2343, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2344, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2345, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2346, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "81. ПРАВИЛО_ДЛЯ_МАШИНОЧИТАЕМОГО_ОТВЕТА", + "sourceParagraph": 2348, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH15-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2349, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Ответ GEO-1000 НЕ ДОЛЖЕН получать положительное решение исключительно на основании его", + "sourceParagraph": 2351, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "среднего значения или доли поддерживаемых атомарных утверждений.", + "sourceParagraph": 2352, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Перед вынесением решения на уровне ответа наблюдение ДОЛЖНО удовлетворять", + "sourceParagraph": 2354, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "требуемым условиям захвата, промпта, AI-системы, пакета истины и качества", + "sourceParagraph": 2355, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "вынесения решения.\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2356, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждый ответ ДОЛЖЕН быть оценен по следующим критериям:", + "sourceParagraph": 2358, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- обязательные элементы ответа,", + "sourceParagraph": 2360, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- подтвержденные критические находки,", + "sourceParagraph": 2361, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- подтвержденные основные находки,", + "sourceParagraph": 2362, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- совокупная умеренная значимость,", + "sourceParagraph": 2363, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- существенные упущения,", + "sourceParagraph": 2364, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- неразрешенные основные утверждения,", + "sourceParagraph": 2365, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- отказ или отсутствие ответа,", + "sourceParagraph": 2366, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- внутреннее противоречие,", + "sourceParagraph": 2367, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- самоисправление,", + "sourceParagraph": 2368, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и кластеры выявления корневых причин.", + "sourceParagraph": 2369, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Подтвержденная критическая находка ДОЛЖНА создавать некопенсационный автоматический", + "sourceParagraph": 2371, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "отказ ответа.", + "sourceParagraph": 2372, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Подтвержденное серьезное обнаружение или сбой требуемого клю��евого элемента ответа", + "sourceParagraph": 2374, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ДОЛЖНО создавать сбой в ответе и НЕ ДОЛЖНО компенсироваться другими поддерживаемыми элементами", + "sourceParagraph": 2375, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "утверждения.", + "sourceParagraph": 2376, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Умеренные выявления МОГУТ допускать только Условное соответствие, если все ключевые", + "sourceParagraph": 2378, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "требования остаются выполненными, и совокупная значимость не создает", + "sourceParagraph": 2379, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "серьезного эффекта.", + "sourceParagraph": 2380, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Консультативные выявления ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться видимыми, но НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ самостоятельно блокировать", + "sourceParagraph": 2382, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "проход ответа.", + "sourceParagraph": 2383, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Критическая и серьезная степень ДОЛЖНА определяться независимо от частоты", + "sourceParagraph": 2385, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "утверждения и независимо от того, способствует ли ошибка или вредит", + "sourceParagraph": 2386, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "аудируемому субъекту.", + "sourceParagraph": 2387, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Критические выводы ДОЛЖНЫ быть подтверждены с помощью достоверного захвата, достаточного", + "sourceParagraph": 2389, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "покрытия Truth Pack, независимой двойной проверки и соответствующей языковой", + "sourceParagraph": 2390, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "или профессиональной экспертизы в данной области.", + "sourceParagraph": 2391, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Отсутствие ссылок и нерешенные доказательства НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ автоматически создавать", + "sourceParagraph": 2393, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "критические, существенные, проходные или отрицательные решения.", + "sourceParagraph": 2394, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Передача неправильного субъекта, ложная лицензия или регулирующий орган, действия", + "sourceParagraph": 2396, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "высокого риска, ложная информация, сфабрикованные материальные доказательства, ��ожные", + "sourceParagraph": 2397, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0209", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "транзакционные гарантии, небезопасные рекомендации вне области, серьезные", + "sourceParagraph": 2398, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0210", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "неподтвержденные обвинения, существенные упущения границ, текущее использование", + "sourceParagraph": 2399, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0211", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "истекшие полномочия, ложные одобрения, раскрытие ограниченных данных и", + "sourceParagraph": 2400, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0212", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "отмывание доказательств МОЖЕТ активировать критические ворота, когда определены", + "sourceParagraph": 2401, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0213", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "условия существенности.", + "sourceParagraph": 2402, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0214", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Одно подтвержденное критическое реагирование ДОЛЖНО зафиксировать, что событие", + "sourceParagraph": 2404, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0215", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "произошло при определенных условиях продукта-страна-язык-промпт-время.", + "sourceParagraph": 2405, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0216", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Оно НЕ ДОЛЖНО, само по себе, представляться как распространенность", + "sourceParagraph": 2406, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0217", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "этого события среди всех пользователей или на всех интерфейсах продукта.", + "sourceParagraph": 2407, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0218", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждое подтвержденное критическое реагирование ДОЛЖНО открыть версионированную запись критического инцидента", + "sourceParagraph": 2409, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0219", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "и инициировать проверку подтверждения в пределах соответствующего объема.", + "sourceParagraph": 2410, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0220", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Открытый подтвержденный критический инцидент ДОЛЖЕН предотвращать утверждение о нулевом количестве критических", + "sourceParagraph": 2412, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0221", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ошибок или полной соответствия в затронутой заявленной области.", + "sourceParagraph": 2413, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0222", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Исправление и повторное тестирование ДОЛЖНЫ создавать новые наблюдения и новые волны", + "sourceParagraph": 2415, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0223", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "записей. Они НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ изменять или удалять исходное решение по ответу или", + "sourceParagraph": 2416, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0224", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "исторический инцидент.", + "sourceParagraph": 2417, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0225", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Решения по ответам, уровни серьезности, коды контроля, область инцидента,", + "sourceParagraph": 2419, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0226", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "статус воспроизведения, эффекты соответствия, апелляции и исправления ДОЛЖНЫ быть", + "sourceParagraph": 2420, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0227", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "версионированы и приписаны ответственному человеку или организации.", + "sourceParagraph": 2421, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0228", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 2422, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH15-MB0229", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Ответ GEO-1000 не может проходить только на основе среднего или соотношения поддерживаемых атомов. Подтверждённый критический результат — это неисправимый сбой автоматического ответа; Подтверждённое основное обнаружение или обязательный отказ элемента сердечника должны привести к отказу реакции. Умеренный результат может позволить условное прохождение только при соблюдении требований к ядрам и при накопленной материальности не оказывает существенного влияния.", + "sourceParagraph": 2423, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 16, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH16", + "title": "Архитектура оценивания NOMOS", + "subtitle": null, + "sourceIds": [ + "K08", + "K09" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH16-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "No NOMOS result may be published as a naked composite score. Every published score MUST first disclose: - the gate status, - the GEO-1000 response-status distribution, - Strict and Acceptable Pass equivalents, - Critical and Major equivalents, - Unresolved, No-Usable-Response, and Not-Ratable equivalents, - component scores, - uncertainty, - effective sample size, - scope, - and score-method version. The primary GEO-1000 output MUST express the population-weighted equivalent number of users, out of 1,000, receiving each RP-1 through RP-8 response status. Critical and Major findings are non-compensatory. No atomic-claim average, response-pass rate, component score, product coefficient, or ecosystem composite may override an active Critical or Major gate. Atomic, required-element, component, composite, fairness, stability, Critical-rate, and publication-quality metrics MUST remain distinct. The canonical candidate NOMOS composite consists of ten separately reported 0–100 components: - Entity Integrity, - Factual Fidelity, - Scope and Boundary Integrity, - Temporal and Local Accuracy, - Evidence and Citation Integrity, - Epistemic Integrity, - Task Completion and Relevance, - Language and Geographic Fairness, - User-State and Surface Integrity, - and Stability and Replicability. A full 0–1,000 composite MUST NOT be produced when a required component is not estimable. Missing component weight MUST NOT be silently redistributed. Native Reach, Common Support, Controlled Clean, Natural User, current wave, rolling, equal-product, and exposure-weighted scores MUST remain separately identified. AI-product coefficients MUST be locked before product results are observed and MUST NOT depend on product performance, provider reputation, client preference, sponsorship, or desired outcome. Equal-product coefficients estimate average tested-product performance. Exposure coefficients estimate average defined-user exposure. These estimands MUST NOT be represented as equivalent. An ecosystem composite MUST retain product-level Critical and Major incident visibility. High scores in other products MUST NOT erase a lower-weighted product's confirmed Critical incident. Unresolved claims MUST produce visible reference-uncertainty bounds and MUST NOT be silently treated as correct, incorrect, or absent. Sampling uncertainty, reference uncertainty, score sensitivity, raw sample size, and effective sample size MUST be separately reported. Zero observed confirmed Critical incidents MUST NOT be represented as zero Critical risk. A method-appropriate one-sided upper bound MUST be reported. A NOMOS 950+ performance candidate MUST satisfy score, Strict Pass, gate, component-floor, unresolved, quality, coverage, and replication conditions. A composite score of 950 or more alone is insufficient. Every score formula, mapping, coefficient, dataset, code version, confidence procedure, publication decision, revision, and integrity record MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Hiçbir NOMOS sonucu tek çıplak bileşik puan olarak yayımlanamaz. Her sonuç önce gate statüsünü, GEO-1000 response dağılımını, Strict ve Acceptable Pass kullanıcı eşdeğerlerini, Critical, Major, Unresolved, No-Response ve Not-Ratable dağılımlarını; daha sonra bileşen skorlarını, belirsizliği, etkin örneklemi, kapsamı ve skor sürümünü göstermelidir.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "76. MACHINE-READABLE SCORE RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 1939 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 1940 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1941 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"NOMOS_950_PLUS_PERFORMANCE_CANDIDATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1942 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openConfirmedCritical\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1943 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openConfirmedMajor\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1944 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"historicalCriticalIncidents\": 1,", + "sourceParagraph": 1945 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"currentCriticalHold\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1946 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1947 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"geo1000Distribution\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1948 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-1\": 830,", + "sourceParagraph": 1949 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-2\": 128,", + "sourceParagraph": 1950 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-3\": 30,", + "sourceParagraph": 1951 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-4\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1952 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-5\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1953 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-6\": 5,", + "sourceParagraph": 1954 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-7\": 7,", + "sourceParagraph": 1955 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-8\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1956 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"strictPassEquivalent\": 958,", + "sourceParagraph": 1957 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"acceptablePassEquivalent\": 988,", + "sourceParagraph": 1958 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalEquivalent\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1959 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"majorEquivalent\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1960 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unresolvedEquivalent\": 5,", + "sourceParagraph": 1961 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"noUsableResponseEquivalent\": 7,", + "sourceParagraph": 1962 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"notRatableEquivalent\": 0", + "sourceParagraph": 1963 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1964 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"components\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1965 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ENT\": 99,", + "sourceParagraph": 1966 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"FAC\": 97,", + "sourceParagraph": 1967 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SBI\": 96,", + "sourceParagraph": 1968 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"TLA\": 95,", + "sourceParagraph": 1969 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ECI\": 96,", + "sourceParagraph": 1970 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"EPI\": 98,", + "sourceParagraph": 1971 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"TCR\": 97,", + "sourceParagraph": 1972 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"LGF\": 94,", + "sourceParagraph": 1973 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"USI\": 93,", + "sourceParagraph": 1974 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"STR\": 96", + "sourceParagraph": 1975 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1976 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"composite\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1977 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomosScore\": 961,", + "sourceParagraph": 1978 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scaleMaximum\": 1000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1979 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"canonicalEqualComponentWeighting\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1980 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1981 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"uncertainty\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1982 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"samplingConfidenceLevel\": 0.95,", + "sourceParagraph": 1983 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"samplingInterval\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1984 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lower\": 955,", + "sourceParagraph": 1985 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"upper\": 967", + "sourceParagraph": 1986 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1987 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"referenceUncertainty\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1988 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conservativeLower\": 956,", + "sourceParagraph": 1989 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"resolvedOnlyPoint\": 961,", + "sourceParagraph": 1990 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"optimisticUpper\": 964", + "sourceParagraph": 1991 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1992 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rawSampleSize\": 1000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1993 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"effectiveSampleSize\": 914,", + "sourceParagraph": 1994 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"observedConfirmedCriticalCount\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1995 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalRateUpperBoundMethod\": \"DESIGN_AWARE_ONE_SIDED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1996 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalRateUpperBound\": 0.0034", + "sourceParagraph": 1997 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1998 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"qualityPrerequisites\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1999 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sampleQuality\": \"SQ-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2000 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"participantSelectionIntegrity\": \"PSI-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2001 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureLevel\": \"NCL-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2002 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackReadiness\": \"TPR-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2003 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationQuality\": \"AQ-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2004 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"replicatedWaveCount\": 3", + "sourceParagraph": 2005 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2006 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomos950CandidateChecks\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2007 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"compositeAtLeast950\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2008 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"strictPassAtLeast950\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2009 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"noOpenCritical\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2010 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"noOpenMajor\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2011 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"allCoreComponentsAtLeast90\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2012 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessUserStateStabilityAtLeast85\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2013 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coreUnresolvedAtMostTwoPercent\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2014 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"qualityPrerequisitesMet\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2015 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"replicationRequirementMet\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2016 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2017 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"historicalStatus\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2018 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"priorCriticalIncidentId\": \"NGCI-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2019 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"currentRemediationStatus\": \"CIS-5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2020 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"historicalRecordPreserved\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2021 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2022 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2023 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"inputManifestHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-SCORE-INPUT-HASH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2024 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"calculationCodeHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-CODE-HASH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2025 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scoreManifestHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-SCORE-MANIFEST-HASH\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2026 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2027 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2028 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scoreMethodsOwnerRole\": \"NOMOS_SCORING_METHODS_LEAD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2029 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"approvedByRole\": \"ACCOUNTABLE_HUMAN_SCORE_APPROVER\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2030 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"approvedAt\": \"2026-10-01T10:00:00Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2031 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2032 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2033 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2034 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "77. MACHINE-READABLE AI PRODUCT COEFFICIENT RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2036 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 2037 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2038 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2039 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2040 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productCoefficientRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2041 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coefficientRecordId\": \"NGCOEF-SYNTH-ECOSYSTEM-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2042 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coefficientVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2043 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetPeriod\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2044 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"from\": \"2026-07-01\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2045 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"to\": \"2026-09-30\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2046 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2047 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetPopulation\": \"DEFINED_ACTIVE_ELIGIBLE_AI_USERS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2048 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"equalProductCoefficients\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2049 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2050 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2051 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coefficient\": 0.25", + "sourceParagraph": 2052 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2053 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2054 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2055 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coefficient\": 0.25", + "sourceParagraph": 2056 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2057 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2058 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2059 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coefficient\": 0.25", + "sourceParagraph": 2060 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2061 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2062 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2063 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coefficient\": 0.25", + "sourceParagraph": 2064 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2065 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2066 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"exposureCoefficients\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2067 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2068 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2069 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verifiedExposureUnit\": 55000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2070 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coefficient\": 0.55", + "sourceParagraph": 2071 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2072 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2073 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2074 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verifiedExposureUnit\": 25000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2075 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coefficient\": 0.25", + "sourceParagraph": 2076 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2077 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2078 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2079 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verifiedExposureUnit\": 15000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2080 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coefficient\": 0.15", + "sourceParagraph": 2081 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2082 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2083 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2084 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verifiedExposureUnit\": 5000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2085 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coefficient\": 0.05", + "sourceParagraph": 2086 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2087 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2088 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coefficientRules\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2089 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"performanceDependent\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2090 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"providerReputationDependent\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2091 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"commercialSponsorDependent\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2092 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedBeforeProductScores\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2093 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"activeUserAndAccountCountsDistinguished\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2094 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2095 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"outputs\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2096 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"equalProductEcosystemScore\": 945,", + "sourceParagraph": 2097 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"exposureWeightedEcosystemScore\": 947,", + "sourceParagraph": 2098 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"anyOpenConfirmedCriticalProduct\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2099 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalProductIds\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2100 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SYNTH-A4\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2101 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 2102 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2103 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2104 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coefficientOwnerRole\": \"ECOSYSTEM_EXPOSURE_METHODS_LEAD\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2105 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2106 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2107 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2108 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "These records:", + "sourceParagraph": 2109 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "actual AI provider,", + "sourceParagraph": 2110 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "actual number of users,", + "sourceParagraph": 2111 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "actual company score", + "sourceParagraph": 2112 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "a real company performance.", + "sourceParagraph": 2113 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Score architecture is a synthetic, machine-readable representation.", + "sourceParagraph": 2114 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE FOR MACHINE-READABLE SECTION 78", + "sourceParagraph": 2116 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH16-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2117 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "No NOMOS result may be published as a naked composite score.", + "sourceParagraph": 2119 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every published score MUST first disclose:", + "sourceParagraph": 2121 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- the gate status,", + "sourceParagraph": 2123 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- the GEO-1000 response-status distribution,", + "sourceParagraph": 2124 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Strict and Acceptable Pass equivalents,", + "sourceParagraph": 2125 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Critical and Major equivalents,", + "sourceParagraph": 2126 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Unresolved, No-Usable-Response, and Not-Ratable equivalents,", + "sourceParagraph": 2127 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- component scores,", + "sourceParagraph": 2128 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- uncertainty,", + "sourceParagraph": 2129 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- effective sample size,", + "sourceParagraph": 2130 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- scope,", + "sourceParagraph": 2131 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and score-method version.", + "sourceParagraph": 2132 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The primary GEO-1000 output MUST express the population-weighted", + "sourceParagraph": 2134 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "equivalent number of users, out of 1,000, receiving each RP-1 through", + "sourceParagraph": 2135 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RP-8 response status.", + "sourceParagraph": 2136 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Critical and Major findings are non-compensatory. No atomic-claim", + "sourceParagraph": 2138 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "average, response-pass rate, component score, product coefficient, or", + "sourceParagraph": 2139 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ecosystem composite may override an active Critical or Major gate.", + "sourceParagraph": 2140 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Atomic, required-element, component, composite, fairness, stability,", + "sourceParagraph": 2142 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Critical-rate, and publication-quality metrics MUST remain distinct.", + "sourceParagraph": 2143 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The canonical candidate NOMOS composite consists of ten separately", + "sourceParagraph": 2145 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "reported 0–100 components:", + "sourceParagraph": 2146 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Entity Integrity,", + "sourceParagraph": 2148 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Factual Fidelity,", + "sourceParagraph": 2149 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Scope and Boundary Integrity,", + "sourceParagraph": 2150 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Temporal and Local Accuracy,", + "sourceParagraph": 2151 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Evidence and Citation Integrity,", + "sourceParagraph": 2152 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Epistemic Integrity,", + "sourceParagraph": 2153 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Task Completion and Relevance,", + "sourceParagraph": 2154 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Language and Geographic Fairness,", + "sourceParagraph": 2155 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- User-State and Surface Integrity,", + "sourceParagraph": 2156 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0209", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and Stability and Replicability.", + "sourceParagraph": 2157 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0210", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A full 0–1,000 composite MUST NOT be produced when a required component", + "sourceParagraph": 2159 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0211", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "is not estimable. Missing component weight MUST NOT be silently", + "sourceParagraph": 2160 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0212", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "redistributed.", + "sourceParagraph": 2161 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0213", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Native Reach, Common Support, Controlled Clean, Natural User, current", + "sourceParagraph": 2163 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0214", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "wave, rolling, equal-product, and exposure-weighted scores MUST remain", + "sourceParagraph": 2164 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0215", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "separately identified.", + "sourceParagraph": 2165 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0216", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "AI-product coefficients MUST be locked before product results are", + "sourceParagraph": 2167 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0217", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "observed and MUST NOT depend on product performance, provider reputation,", + "sourceParagraph": 2168 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0218", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "client preference, sponsorship, or desired outcome.", + "sourceParagraph": 2169 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0219", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Equal-product coefficients estimate average tested-product performance.", + "sourceParagraph": 2171 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0220", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Exposure coefficients estimate average defined-user exposure. These", + "sourceParagraph": 2172 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0221", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "estimands MUST NOT be represented as equivalent.", + "sourceParagraph": 2173 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0222", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "An ecosystem composite MUST retain product-level Critical and Major", + "sourceParagraph": 2175 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0223", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "incident visibility. High scores in other products MUST NOT erase a", + "sourceParagraph": 2176 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0224", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "lower-weighted product's confirmed Critical incident.", + "sourceParagraph": 2177 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0225", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Unresolved claims MUST produce visible reference-uncertainty bounds and", + "sourceParagraph": 2179 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0226", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MUST NOT be silently treated as correct, incorrect, or absent.", + "sourceParagraph": 2180 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0227", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Sampling uncertainty, reference uncertainty, score sensitivity, raw", + "sourceParagraph": 2182 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0228", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "sample size, and effective sample size MUST be separately reported.", + "sourceParagraph": 2183 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0229", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Zero observed confirmed Critical incidents MUST NOT be represented as", + "sourceParagraph": 2185 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0230", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "zero Critical risk. A method-appropriate one-sided upper bound MUST be", + "sourceParagraph": 2186 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0231", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "reported.", + "sourceParagraph": 2187 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0232", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A NOMOS 950+ performance candidate MUST satisfy score, Strict Pass,", + "sourceParagraph": 2189 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0233", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "gate, component-floor, unresolved, quality, coverage, and replication", + "sourceParagraph": 2190 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0234", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "conditions. A composite score of 950 or more alone is insufficient.", + "sourceParagraph": 2191 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0235", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every score formula, mapping, coefficient, dataset, code version,", + "sourceParagraph": 2193 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0236", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "confidence procedure, publication decision, revision, and integrity", + "sourceParagraph": 2194 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0237", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "record MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or", + "sourceParagraph": 2195 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0238", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "organisation.", + "sourceParagraph": 2196 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0239", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 2197 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0240", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "No NOMOS result can be published as a single raw composite score. Each result must first show gate status, GEO-1000 response distribution, Strict and Acceptable Pass user equivalents, distributions of Critical, Major, Unresolved, No-Response, and Not-Ratable; then it must show component scores, uncertainty, effective sample size, scope, and score version.", + "sourceParagraph": 2198 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Ни один результат NOMOS не МОЖЕТ быть опубликован как единственный сводный балл. Каждый опубликованный балл ДОЛЖЕН сначала раскрывать: - статус прохода, - распределение статусов ответов GEO-1000, - эквиваленты Strict и Acceptable Pass, - эквиваленты Critical и Major, - эквиваленты Unresolved, No-Usable-Response и Not-Ratable, - компоненты баллов, - неопределённость, - эффективный размер выборки, - охват, - и версию метода подсчёта баллов. Основной вывод GEO-1000 ДОЛЖЕН выражать число пользователей, взвешенное по населению, из 1,000, получающих каждый статус ответа от RP-1 до RP-8. Критические и важные результаты не компенсируются. Ни среднее значение по атомарным утверждениям, ни коэффициент успешных ответов, ни оценка компонентов, ни коэффициент продукта, ни составной показатель экосистемы не МОГУТ переопределить активный Критический или Основной шлюз. Метрики атомарных элементов, обязательных элементов, компонентов, составных показателей, справедливости, стабильности, критического уровня и к��чества публикации ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельными. Канонический составной кандидат NOMOS состоит из десяти отдельно оцениваемых компонентов 0–100: - Целостность сущности, - Точность фактов, - Целостность объема и границ, - Временная и локальная точность, - Целостность доказательств и цитирования, - Эпистемическая целостность, - Выполнение задачи и релевантность, - Языковая и географическая справедливость, - Целостность состояния пользователя и интерфейсы, - и стабильность и воспроизводимость. Полный состав 0–1,000 НЕ ДОЛЖЕН создаваться, если требуемый компонент невозможно оценить. Вес отсутствующего компонента НЕ ДОЛЖЕН перераспределяться без уведомления. Естественный охват, Общая опора сравнения, Controlled Clean, Natural User, текущая волна, скользящее, равное по продукту и по воздействию оценки ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельно идентифицированными. Коэффициенты ИИ-продукта ДОЛЖНЫ быть зафиксированы до того, как наблюдаются результаты продукта, и НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ зависеть от производительности продукта, репутации поставщика, предпочтений клиента, спонсорства или желаемого результата. Коэффициенты равного продукта оценивают среднюю производительность протестированного продукта. Коэффициенты воздействия оценивают среднее воздействие определенного пользователя. Эти оценочные показатели НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ представляться как эквивалентные. Композит экосистемы ДОЛЖЕН сохранять видимость критических и значительных инцидентов на уровне продукта. Высокие оценки в других продуктах НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ стирать подтвержденный критический инцидент продукта с меньшим весом. Нерешенные утверждения ДОЛЖНЫ создавать видимые границы неопределенности ссылки и НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ молчаливо рассматриваться как верные, неверные или отсутствующие. Неопределенность выборки, неопределенность ссылки, чувствительность оценки, размер необработанной выборки и эффективный размер выборки ДОЛЖНЫ сообщаться отдельно. Нулевое количество наблюдаемых подтвержденных критических инцидентов НЕ ДОЛЖНО представляться как нулевой критический риск. ДОЛЖНА быть представлена методологически подходящая односторонняя верхняя граница. Кандидат на производительность NOMOS 950+ ДОЛЖЕН удовлетворять условиям по оценке, строгому проходу, контрольному порогу, минимальному уровню компонентов, нерешённым вопросам, качеству, покрытию и воспроизводимости. Только комплексный балл 950 или выше недостаточен. Каждая формула оценки, отображение, коэффициент, набор данных, версия кода, процедура доверия, решение о публикации, исправление и запись о целостности ДОЛЖНЫ быть версионированы и приписаны ответственному человеку или организации.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "76. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ РЕКОРД", + "sourceParagraph": 1939, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 1940, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1941, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"статус\": \"NOMOS_950_PLUS_PERFORMANCE_CANDIDATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1942, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openConfirmedCritical\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1943, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openConfirmedMajor\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1944, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"historicalCriticalIncidents\": 1,", + "sourceParagraph": 1945, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"currentCriticalHold\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1946, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1947, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"geo1000Distribution\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1948, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-1\": 830,", + "sourceParagraph": 1949, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-2\": 128,", + "sourceParagraph": 1950, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-3\": 30,", + "sourceParagraph": 1951, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-4\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1952, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-5\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1953, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-6\": 5,", + "sourceParagraph": 1954, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-7\": 7,", + "sourceParagraph": 1955, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-8\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1956, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"strictPassEquivalent\": 958,", + "sourceParagraph": 1957, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"acceptablePassEquivalent\": 988,", + "sourceParagraph": 1958, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalEquivalent\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1959, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"majorEquivalent\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1960, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unresolvedEquivalent\": 5,", + "sourceParagraph": 1961, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"noUsableResponseEquivalent\": 7,", + "sourceParagraph": 1962, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"notRatableEquivalent\": 0", + "sourceParagraph": 1963, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1964, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"components\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1965, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ENT\": 99,", + "sourceParagraph": 1966, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"FAC\": 97,", + "sourceParagraph": 1967, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SBI\": 96,", + "sourceParagraph": 1968, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"TLA\": 95,", + "sourceParagraph": 1969, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ECI\": 96,", + "sourceParagraph": 1970, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"EPI\": 98,", + "sourceParagraph": 1971, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"TCR\": 97,", + "sourceParagraph": 1972, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"LGF\": 94,", + "sourceParagraph": 1973, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"USI\": 93,", + "sourceParagraph": 1974, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"STR\": 96", + "sourceParagraph": 1975, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1976, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"composite\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1977, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomosScore\": 961,", + "sourceParagraph": 1978, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scaleMaximum\": 1000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1979, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"canonicalEqualComponentWeighting\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1980, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1981, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"uncertainty\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1982, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"samplingConfidenceLevel\": 0.95,", + "sourceParagraph": 1983, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"samplingInterval\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1984, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lower\": 955,", + "sourceParagraph": 1985, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"upper\": 967", + "sourceParagraph": 1986, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1987, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"referenceUncertainty\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1988, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conservativeLower\": 956,", + "sourceParagraph": 1989, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"resolvedOnlyPoint\": 961,", + "sourceParagraph": 1990, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"optimisticUpper\": 964", + "sourceParagraph": 1991, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1992, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rawSampleSize\": 1000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1993, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"effectiveSampleSize\": 914,", + "sourceParagraph": 1994, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"observedConfirmedCriticalCount\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1995, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalRateUpperBoundMethod\": \"DESIGN_AWARE_ONE_SIDED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1996, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalRateUpperBound\": 0.003 4", + "sourceParagraph": 1997, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1998, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"qualityPrerequisites\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1999, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sampleQuality\": \"SQ-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2000, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"participantSelectionIntegrity\": \"PSI-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2001, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureLevel\": \"NCL-4\",\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2002, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackReadiness\": \"TPR-4\",\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2003, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationQuality\": \"AQ-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2004, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"replicatedWaveCount\": 3", + "sourceParagraph": 2005, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2006, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomos950CandidateChecks\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2007, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"compositeAtLeast950\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2008, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"strictPassAtLeast950\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2009, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"noOpenCritical\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2010, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"noOpenMajor\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2011, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"allCoreComponentsAtLeast90\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2012, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessUserStateStabilityAtLeast85\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2013, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coreUnresolvedAtMostTwoPercent\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2014, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"qualityPrerequisitesMet\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2015, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"replicationRequirementMet\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2016, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2017, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"historicalStatus\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2018, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"priorCriticalIncidentId\": \"NGCI-СИНТ-ОРИОН-TR-W1-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2019, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"currentRemediationStatus\": \"CIS-5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2020, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"historicalRecordPreserved\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2021, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2022, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2023, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"inputManifestHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ БАЛЛ-ВВОД-ХЭШ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2024, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"calculationCodeHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ КОД-ХЕШ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2025, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scoreManifestHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКАЯ ПАРТИТУРА-МАНИФЕСТ-ХЭШ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2026, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2027, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2028, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scoreMethodsOwnerRole\": \"NOMOS_SCORING_METHODS_LEAD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2029, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"approvedByRole\": \"ACCOUNTABLE_HUMAN_SCORE_APPROVER\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2030, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"approvedAt\": \"2026-10-01 T1 0:00:00 Z\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2031, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2032, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2033, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2034, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "77. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМАЯ ЗАПИСЬ КОЭФФИЦИЕНТОВ ПРОДУКТА ИИ", + "sourceParagraph": 2036, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2037, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2038, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2039, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2040, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"productCoefficientRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2041, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coefficientRecordId\": \"NGCOEF-SYNTH-ECOSYSTEM-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2042, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coefficientVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2043, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetPeriod\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2044, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"from\": \"2026-07-01\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2045, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"to\": \"2026-09-30\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2046, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2047, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetPopulation\": \"DEFINED_ACTIVE_ELIGIBLE_AI_USERS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2048, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"equalProductCoefficients\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2049, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2050, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2051, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"коэффициент\": 0.25", + "sourceParagraph": 2052, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2053, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2054, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2055, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"коэффициент\": 0.25", + "sourceParagraph": 2056, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2057, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2058, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2059, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"коэффициент\": 0.25", + "sourceParagraph": 2060, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2061, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2062, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2063, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"коэффициент\": 0.25", + "sourceParagraph": 2064, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2065, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2066, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"exposureCoefficients\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2067, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2068, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2069, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verifiedExposureUnit\": 55000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2070, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"коэффициент\": 0.55", + "sourceParagraph": 2071, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2072, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2073, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2074, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verifiedExposureUnit\": 25000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2075, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"коэффициент\": 0.25", + "sourceParagraph": 2076, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2077, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2078, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2079, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verifiedExposureUnit\": 15000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2080, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"коэффициент\": 0.15", + "sourceParagraph": 2081, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2082, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2083, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2084, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"verifiedExposureUnit\": 5000000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2085, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"коэффициент\": 0.05", + "sourceParagraph": 2086, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2087, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2088, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coefficientRules\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2089, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"performanceDependent\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2090, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"providerReputationDependent\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2091, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"commercialSponsorDependent\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2092, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedBeforeProductScores\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2093, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"activeUserAndAccountCountsDistinguished\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2094, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2095, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"выходы\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2096, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"equalProductEcosystemScore\": 945,", + "sourceParagraph": 2097, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"exposureWeightedEcosystemScore\": 947,", + "sourceParagraph": 2098, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"anyOpenConfirmedCriticalProduct\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2099, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalProductIds\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2100, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SYNTH-A4\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2101, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 2102, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2103, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2104, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coefficientOwnerRole\": \"ECOSYSTEM_EXPOSURE_METHODS_LEAD\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2105, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2106, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2107, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2108, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Эти записи:", + "sourceParagraph": 2109, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "фактический провайдер ИИ,", + "sourceParagraph": 2110, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "фактическое количество пользователей,", + "sourceParagraph": 2111, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "фактический рейтинг компании", + "sourceParagraph": 2112, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальной производительностью компании.", + "sourceParagraph": 2113, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Архитектура оценки — это синтетическое, машиночитаемое представление.", + "sourceParagraph": 2114, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРАВИЛО ДЛЯ МАШИНОЧИТАЕМОГО РАЗДЕЛА 78", + "sourceParagraph": 2116, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH16-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2117, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Никакой результат NOMOS не может публиковаться как «чистая» комплексная оценка.", + "sourceParagraph": 2119, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждый опубликованный балл ДОЛЖЕН сначала раскрывать:", + "sourceParagraph": 2121, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- статус шлюза,", + "sourceParagraph": 2123, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- распределение статуса ответа GEO-1000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2124, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- строгие и допустимые эквиваленты прохождения,", + "sourceParagraph": 2125, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- критические и основные эквиваленты,", + "sourceParagraph": 2126, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- нерешенные, неиспользуемые ответы и неоценимые эквиваленты,", + "sourceParagraph": 2127, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- баллы компонентов,", + "sourceParagraph": 2128, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- неопределенность,", + "sourceParagraph": 2129, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- эффективный размер выборки,", + "sourceParagraph": 2130, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- область охвата,", + "sourceParagraph": 2131, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и версию метода подсчета баллов.", + "sourceParagraph": 2132, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Основной вывод GEO-1000 ДОЛЖЕН выражать взвешенный по популяции результат", + "sourceParagraph": 2134, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "эквивалентное количество пользователей из 1,000, получающих каждый RP-1 через", + "sourceParagraph": 2135, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "статус ответа RP-8.", + "sourceParagraph": 2136, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Критические и основные результаты не подлежат компенсации. Нет атомарных утверждений", + "sourceParagraph": 2138, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "средний, коэффициент успешных ответов, оценка компонента, коэффициент продукта или", + "sourceParagraph": 2139, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "композит экосистемы не может переопределить активный критический или основной контроль.", + "sourceParagraph": 2140, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Атомарные, обязательные элементы, компоненты, композит, справедливость, стабильность,", + "sourceParagraph": 2142, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Критический коэффициент и показатели качества публикации ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельными.", + "sourceParagraph": 2143, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Канонический композит-кандидат NOMOS состоит из десяти раздельно", + "sourceParagraph": 2145, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "представляемых компонентов, оцениваемых по шкале 0–100:", + "sourceParagraph": 2146, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Целостность сущности,", + "sourceParagraph": 2148, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Фактическая точность,", + "sourceParagraph": 2149, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Целостность объема и границ,", + "sourceParagraph": 2150, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Временная и локальная точность,", + "sourceParagraph": 2151, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Целостность доказательств и цитирования,", + "sourceParagraph": 2152, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Эпистемическая целостность,", + "sourceParagraph": 2153, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Выполнение задач и соответствие,", + "sourceParagraph": 2154, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Языковая и географическая справедливость,", + "sourceParagraph": 2155, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Целостность состояния пользователя и интерфейсы,", + "sourceParagraph": 2156, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0209", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и стабильность и воспроизводимость.", + "sourceParagraph": 2157, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0210", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Полный составной 0–1,000 НЕ ДОЛЖЕН создаваться, когда требуемый компонент", + "sourceParagraph": 2159, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0211", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "не поддается оценке. Вес отсутствующего компонента НЕ ДОЛЖЕН молчаливо", + "sourceParagraph": 2160, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0212", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "перераспределяться.", + "sourceParagraph": 2161, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0213", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Естественный охват, Об��ая опора сравнения, Контролируемый Чистый, Естественный Пользователь, текущий", + "sourceParagraph": 2163, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0214", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "волновые, скользящие, равные-продукту и взвешенные по воздействию оценки ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться", + "sourceParagraph": 2164, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0215", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "отдельно идентифицированными.", + "sourceParagraph": 2165, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0216", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Коэффициенты ИИ-продукта ДОЛЖНЫ быть зафиксированы до того, как результаты продукта будут", + "sourceParagraph": 2167, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0217", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "наблюдаться, и НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ зависеть от производительности продукта, репутации поставщика,", + "sourceParagraph": 2168, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0218", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "предпочтений клиента, спонсорства или желаемого результата.", + "sourceParagraph": 2169, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0219", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Коэффициенты равного продукта оценивают среднюю производительность тестируемого продукта.", + "sourceParagraph": 2171, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0220", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Коэффициенты воздействия оценивают среднее воздействие на определенного пользователя. Эти", + "sourceParagraph": 2172, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0221", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "оценочные параметры НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ восприниматься как эквивалентные.", + "sourceParagraph": 2173, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0222", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Составной компонент экосистемы ДОЛЖЕН сохранять критические и основные показатели на уровне продукта", + "sourceParagraph": 2175, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0223", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "видимость инцидентов. Высокие показатели в других продуктах НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ стирать", + "sourceParagraph": 2176, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0224", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "подтвержденный критический инцидент продукта с меньшим весом.", + "sourceParagraph": 2177, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0225", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Неурегулированные утверждения ДОЛЖНЫ демонстрировать видимые пределы неопределенности ссылки и", + "sourceParagraph": 2179, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0226", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "НЕЛЬЗЯ молча считать правильным, неправильным или отсутствующим.", + "sourceParagraph": 2180, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0227", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Неопределенность выборки, неопределенность эталона, чувствительность оценки, исходный", + "sourceParagraph": 2182, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0228", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Размер выборки и эффективный размер выборки ДОЛЖНЫ быть указаны отдельно.", + "sourceParagraph": 2183, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0229", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Ни одного зафиксированного подтверждённого критического инцидента НЕ ДОЛЖНО представляться как", + "sourceParagraph": 2185, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0230", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "нулевой критический риск. Методом, соответствующим ситуации, ДОЛЖЕН быть установлен односторонний верхний предел", + "sourceParagraph": 2186, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0231", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "сообщено.", + "sourceParagraph": 2187, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0232", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Кандидат на высокую производительность NOMOS 950+ ДОЛЖЕН удовлетворять оценке, строгому проходу,", + "sourceParagraph": 2189, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0233", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ворота, компонент-этаж, нерешенные вопросы, качество, покрытие и дублирование", + "sourceParagraph": 2190, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0234", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "условий. Композитная оценка 950 или выше сама по себе недостаточна.", + "sourceParagraph": 2191, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0235", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждая формула оценки, сопоставление, коэффициент, набор данных, версия кода,", + "sourceParagraph": 2193, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0236", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "процедура доверия, решение о публикации, исправление и целостность", + "sourceParagraph": 2194, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0237", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "записи ДОЛЖНЫ иметь версию и быть приписаны ответственному человеку или", + "sourceParagraph": 2195, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0238", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "организации.", + "sourceParagraph": 2196, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0239", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 2197, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH16-MB0240", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Никакой результат NOMOS не может быть опубликован как единый необработанный общий балл. Каждый результат сначала должен показывать статус ворот, распределение ответов GEO-1000, эквиваленты пользователей Strict и Acceptable Pass, распределения Critical, Major, Unresolved, No-Response и Not-Ratable; затем он должен показывать компоненты баллов, неопределённость, эффективный размер выборки, охват и версию баллов.", + "sourceParagraph": 2198, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 17, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH17", + "title": "Дизайн синтетического теста Apple.com", + "subtitle": "Проверка стандарта, а не компании", + "sourceIds": [ + "K03", + "K09" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH17-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "The Apple.com Synthetic Benchmark MUST evaluate the NOMOS audit method, not the real-world performance of Apple Inc., apple.com, or any actual AI provider. All benchmark entities, claims, evidence objects, users, countries, languages, AI products, responses, citations, captures, incidents, and scores MUST be clearly identified as synthetic. The benchmark MUST maintain a separate APPLE-SYNTH entity twin and MUST NOT represent its Truth Pack as factual information about the real company. The principal benchmark corpus MUST contain: - ten synthetic AI product profiles, - one thousand unique synthetic participants per product per wave, - three measurement waves, - and thirty thousand principal responses. Synthetic participant identities MUST NOT be reused across products or waves in the principal corpus. Product samples SHOULD use matched population distributions without using the same person unit. The principal prevalence corpus, severity challenge corpus, capture integrity corpus, adjudication gold corpus, and diagnostic annex MUST remain separately identified and MUST NOT share prevalence denominators. Generator Truth MUST be created, versioned, hashed, and sealed before response adjudication. It MUST remain hidden from claim extractors, adjudicators, and score analysts until their results are locked. Random seeds, synthetic AI profiles, error-injection rules, prompt versions, Truth Pack records, score methods, and candidate acceptance thresholds MUST be locked before the sealed validation corpus is opened. Benchmark cases MUST include direct, implicit, attributed, modal, scope-limited, temporal, citation-based, omission-based, self-correcting, and entity-conflating failure modes. Critical-event prevalence MUST be estimated from the principal corpus. Critical detection capability MUST be tested in a separate challenge corpus with sufficient examples and Critical-like negative controls. No challenge-set oversampling may alter the principal GEO-1000 distribution or Critical prevalence estimate. Synthetic screenshots and response artefacts MUST carry visible and machine-readable notices that they are not live AI outputs or real entity performance evidence. The benchmark MUST prevent its synthetic claims from being published or indexed as real information about the anchor entity. Benchmark success MUST be determined by recovery of sealed Generator Truth, including claim boundaries, atomic decisions, omissions, Critical and Major gates, response statuses, component scores, composite scores, fairness results, capture validity, and uncertainty coverage. High general accuracy MUST NOT compensate for missed Critical cases. Critical recall and Critical false-positive rate MUST be reported together. A failed benchmark threshold, leakage event, recovery error, or misclassification MUST remain visible and MUST NOT be removed by changing labels, seeds, samples, weights, or score rules after results are observed. Every benchmark design, generation, seal, leakage audit, adjudication, recovery calculation, threshold decision, revision, and public release MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Apple.com Sentetik Benchmark, gerçek Apple Inc., apple.com veya gerçek AI sağlayıcılarının performansını değil; NOMOS denetim yönteminin önceden kilitlenmiş sentetik gerçekliği geri kazanma kabiliyetini değerlendirmelidir. Benchmark içindeki bütün varlıklar, kullanıcılar, ülkeler, diller, AI ürünleri, yanıtlar, citation’lar, kanıtlar ve skorlar açıkça sentetik olarak tanımlanmalıdır.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "86. MACHINE-READABLE BENCHMARK RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2171 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 2172 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2173 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2174 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2175 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmark\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2176 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-BENCH-0.9\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2177 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkType\": \"BM-S0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2178 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"DESIGN_LOCK_CANDIDATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2179 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"purpose\": \"VALIDATE_NOMOS_AUDIT_METHOD_NOT_REAL_ENTITY_PERFORMANCE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2180 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nonClaimStatement\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2181 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"synthetic\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2182 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realAppleAudit\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2183 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realAIProviderAudit\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2184 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"endorsementClaimAllowed\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2185 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2186 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"anchor\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2187 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"domain\": \"apple.com\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2188 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"syntheticTwinEntityId\": \"NGE-APPLE-SYNTH-TWIN-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2189 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2190 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"corpora\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2191 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"principalPrevalence\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2192 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductCount\": 10,", + "sourceParagraph": 2193 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validUsersPerProductPerWave\": 1000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2194 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveCount\": 3,", + "sourceParagraph": 2195 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetResponseCount\": 30000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2196 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptFamily\": \"PR-01\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2197 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedInPrevalenceScore\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2198 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2199 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"diagnosticAnnex\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2200 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetResponseCount\": 6000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2201 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedInPrevalenceScore\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2202 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2203 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"severityChallenge\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2204 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalCases\": 1200,", + "sourceParagraph": 2205 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"majorCases\": 1200,", + "sourceParagraph": 2206 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"moderateCases\": 600,", + "sourceParagraph": 2207 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalLikeNegativeControls\": 600,", + "sourceParagraph": 2208 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedInPrevalenceScore\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2209 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2210 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureIntegrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2211 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedInSemanticPrevalenceScore\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2212 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2213 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationGold\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2214 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedInPrevalenceScore\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2215 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2216 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2217 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"population\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2218 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"frameId\": \"SYNTH-POP-FRAME-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2219 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCodes\": 193,", + "sourceParagraph": 2220 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationLanguages\": 24,", + "sourceParagraph": 2221 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessSentinelLanguages\": 12,", + "sourceParagraph": 2222 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realPopulationClaimAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2223 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"matchedSyntheticPopulationTwins\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2224 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"participantReuseAcrossProducts\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2225 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"participantReuseAcrossWaves\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2226 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2227 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"records\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2228 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackId\": \"SYNTH-APPLE-TP-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2229 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptSetId\": \"SYNTH-PROMPT-SET-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2230 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiRegistryId\": \"SYNTH-AI-REGISTRY-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2231 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"wavePlanId\": \"SYNTH-WAVE-PLAN-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2232 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureSchemaVersion\": \"NOMOS-CAPTURE-SYNTH-0.9\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2233 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scoreMethodVersion\": \"NOMOS-SCORE-0.9\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2234 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2235 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorTruth\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2236 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"createdBeforeResponses\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2237 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sealedFromAdjudicators\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2238 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"manifestHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-GENERATOR-TRUTH-HASH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2239 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openedOnlyAfterScoreLock\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2240 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2241 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"randomisation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2242 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"seedManifestId\": \"SYNTH-SEED-MANIFEST-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2243 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedBeforeGeneration\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2244 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"bestRunSelectionProhibited\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2245 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2246 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"releaseProtection\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2247 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"visibleSyntheticWatermarkRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2248 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"machineReadableSyntheticMetadataRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2249 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"liveResponseRepresentationProhibited\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2250 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"searchIndexProtectionRequired\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2251 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2252 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governance\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2253 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkOwnerRole\": \"ACCOUNTABLE_HUMAN_BENCHMARK_OWNER\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2254 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorTruthCustodianRole\": \"SEALED_TRUTH_CUSTODIAN\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2255 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"leakageAuditorRole\": \"INDEPENDENT_LEAKAGE_AUDITOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2256 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validationTeamSeparatedFromGenerator\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2257 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2258 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2259 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2260 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "87. MACHINE-READABLE SYNTHETIC AI PROFILE", + "sourceParagraph": 2262 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2263 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2264 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2265 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"syntheticAIProfile\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2266 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"profileId\": \"SYNTH-AI-10\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2267 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"profileName\": \"RARE_CRITICAL_HIGH_AVERAGE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2268 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realProviderMapping\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2269 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realProviderInferenceAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2270 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"latentBehavior\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2271 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coreEntityAccuracy\": 0.985,", + "sourceParagraph": 2272 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"factualSupportBaseline\": 0.975,", + "sourceParagraph": 2273 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeOverreachProbability\": 0.012,", + "sourceParagraph": 2274 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"temporalLagProbability\": 0.008,", + "sourceParagraph": 2275 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialAttributionLossProbability\": 0.010,", + "sourceParagraph": 2276 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationMismatchProbability\": 0.006,", + "sourceParagraph": 2277 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"noUsableResponseProbability\": 0.003,", + "sourceParagraph": 2278 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalEventProbability\": 0.002,", + "sourceParagraph": 2279 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"majorEventProbability\": 0.006,", + "sourceParagraph": 2280 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lowResourceLanguagePenalty\": 0.06,", + "sourceParagraph": 2281 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"naturalStatePenalty\": 0.03,", + "sourceParagraph": 2282 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveDrift\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2283 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"W1\": 0.00,", + "sourceParagraph": 2284 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"W2\": -0.01,", + "sourceParagraph": 2285 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"W3\": 0.01", + "sourceParagraph": 2286 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2287 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2288 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalInjectionFamilies\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2289 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-02\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2290 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-05\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2291 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-06\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2292 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2293 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"intendedMethodStress\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2294 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"HIGH_COMPOSITE_WITH_RARE_CRITICAL\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2295 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NON_COMPENSATORY_GATE_RECOVERY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2296 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RARE_EVENT_UPPER_BOUND\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2297 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2298 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedBeforeCorpusGeneration\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2299 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"profileIntegrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-AI-PROFILE-HASH\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2300 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2301 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2302 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "88. MACHINE-READABLE GENERATOR TRUTH RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2304 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2305 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2306 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2307 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorTruthRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2308 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorTruthId\": \"NGGT-SYNTH-000184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2309 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"observationId\": \"OBS-SYNTH-000184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2310 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-BENCH-0.9\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2311 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProfileId\": \"SYNTH-AI-10\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2312 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"W2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2313 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"participantId\": \"SYNTH-PERSON-000184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2314 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptRecordId\": \"SYNTH-CORE-PROMPT-L01-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2315 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackVersion\": \"SYNTH-APPLE-TP-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2316 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"hiddenAtomicClaims\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2317 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2318 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorClaimId\": \"GCL-000184-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2319 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2320 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"APPLE-SYNTH-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2321 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"predicate\": \"principalEntityAssociatedWithDomain\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2322 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"objectValue\": \"apple.com\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2323 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2324 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthStatus\": \"SUPPORTED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2325 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"importance\": \"CORE\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2326 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2327 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2328 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorClaimId\": \"GCL-000184-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2329 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2330 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"APPLE-SYNTH-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2331 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"predicate\": \"licensedBankInAllMarkets\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2332 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"objectValue\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2333 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2334 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthStatus\": \"CONTRADICTED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2335 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"importance\": \"CRITICAL\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2336 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalGateCodes\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2337 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-01\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2338 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-02\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2339 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2340 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rootFindingCluster\": \"FALSE_LICENSE_TRANSFER\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2341 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2342 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2343 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"hiddenOmissions\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2344 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2345 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorOmissionId\": \"GOM-000184-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2346 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"requiredBoundary\": \"PAYMENT_SUBSIDIARY_AUTHORITY_IS_LIMITED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2347 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"importance\": \"CRITICAL\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2348 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalGateCode\": \"CG-08\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2349 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2350 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2351 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"hiddenResponseStatus\": \"RP-5\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2352 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedInPrincipalPrevalenceCorpus\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2353 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sealedAtGeneration\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2354 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"visibleToAdjudicators\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2355 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-GENERATOR-TRUTH-OBS-HASH\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2356 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2357 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2358 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "89. MACHINE-READABLE BENCHMARK RECOVERY RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2360 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2361 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2362 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2363 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkRecovery\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2364 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"recoveryRecordId\": \"NGBR-SYNTH-APPLE-0.9-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2365 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-BENCH-0.9\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2366 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validationSet\": \"SEALED_VALIDATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2367 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorTruthOpenedAfterScoreLock\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2368 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"metrics\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2369 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimBoundaryF1\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2370 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityResolutionAccuracy\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2371 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"factualStatusMacroF1\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2372 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeMacroF1\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2373 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attributionMacroF1\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2374 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationMappingF1\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2375 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialOmissionF1\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2376 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalRecall\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2377 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalFalsePositiveRate\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2378 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"majorClassificationMacroF1\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2379 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseStatusMacroF1\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2380 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"componentMeanAbsoluteError\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2381 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0209", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"compositeAbsoluteError\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2382 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0210", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"geo1000DistributionErrors\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2383 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0211", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessComponentError\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2384 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0212", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureValidityAccuracy\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2385 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0213", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"confidenceIntervalEmpiricalCoverage\": null", + "sourceParagraph": 2386 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0214", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2387 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0215", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThresholdsApplied\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2388 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0216", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkQualityStatus\": \"BQ-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2389 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0217", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"failureDisclosureRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2390 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0218", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentReproductionStatus\": \"NOT_STARTED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2391 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0219", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2392 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0220", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"recoveryMethodsOwnerRole\": \"BENCHMARK_RECOVERY_METHODS_LEAD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2393 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0221", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"approvedByRole\": \"ACCOUNTABLE_HUMAN_BENCHMARK_APPROVER\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2394 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0222", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2395 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0223", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2396 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0224", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2397 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0225", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "These records:", + "sourceParagraph": 2398 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0226", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "actual Apple audit,", + "sourceParagraph": 2399 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0227", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "real AI provider behaviour,", + "sourceParagraph": 2400 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0228", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "real user result", + "sourceParagraph": 2401 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0229", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "a real company performance.", + "sourceParagraph": 2402 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0230", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "It is a machine-readable synthetic representation of the benchmark design.", + "sourceParagraph": 2403 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0231", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF SECTION 90", + "sourceParagraph": 2405 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0232", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH17-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2406 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0233", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The Apple.com Synthetic Benchmark MUST evaluate the NOMOS audit method,", + "sourceParagraph": 2408 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0234", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "not the real-world performance of Apple Inc., apple.com, or any actual AI", + "sourceParagraph": 2409 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0235", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "provider.", + "sourceParagraph": 2410 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0236", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "All benchmark entities, claims, evidence objects, users, countries,", + "sourceParagraph": 2412 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0237", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "languages, AI products, responses, citations, captures, incidents, and", + "sourceParagraph": 2413 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0238", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "scores MUST be clearly identified as synthetic.", + "sourceParagraph": 2414 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0239", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The benchmark MUST maintain a separate APPLE-SYNTH entity twin and MUST", + "sourceParagraph": 2416 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0240", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOT represent its Truth Pack as factual information about the real", + "sourceParagraph": 2417 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0241", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "company.", + "sourceParagraph": 2418 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0242", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The principal benchmark corpus MUST contain:", + "sourceParagraph": 2420 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0243", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- ten synthetic AI product profiles,", + "sourceParagraph": 2422 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0244", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- one thousand unique synthetic participants per product per wave,", + "sourceParagraph": 2423 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0245", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- three measurement waves,", + "sourceParagraph": 2424 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0246", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and thirty thousand principal responses.", + "sourceParagraph": 2425 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0247", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Synthetic participant identities MUST NOT be reused across products or", + "sourceParagraph": 2427 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0248", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "waves in the principal corpus. Product samples SHOULD use matched", + "sourceParagraph": 2428 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0249", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "population distributions without using the same person unit.", + "sourceParagraph": 2429 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0250", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The principal prevalence corpus, severity challenge corpus, capture", + "sourceParagraph": 2431 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0251", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "integrity corpus, adjudication gold corpus, and diagnostic annex MUST", + "sourceParagraph": 2432 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0252", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "remain separately identified and MUST NOT share prevalence denominators.", + "sourceParagraph": 2433 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0253", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Generator Truth MUST be created, versioned, hashed, and sealed before", + "sourceParagraph": 2435 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0254", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "response adjudication. It MUST remain hidden from claim extractors,", + "sourceParagraph": 2436 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0255", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "adjudicators, and score analysts until their results are locked.", + "sourceParagraph": 2437 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0256", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Random seeds, synthetic AI profiles, error-injection rules, prompt", + "sourceParagraph": 2439 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0257", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "versions, Truth Pack records, score methods, and candidate acceptance", + "sourceParagraph": 2440 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0258", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "thresholds MUST be locked before the sealed validation corpus is opened.", + "sourceParagraph": 2441 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0259", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Benchmark cases MUST include direct, implicit, attributed, modal,", + "sourceParagraph": 2443 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0260", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "scope-limited, temporal, citation-based, omission-based, self-correcting,", + "sourceParagraph": 2444 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0261", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "and entity-conflating failure modes.", + "sourceParagraph": 2445 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0262", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Critical-event prevalence MUST be estimated from the principal corpus.", + "sourceParagraph": 2447 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0263", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Critical detection capability MUST be tested in a separate challenge", + "sourceParagraph": 2448 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0264", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "corpus with sufficient examples and Critical-like negative controls.", + "sourceParagraph": 2449 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0265", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "No challenge-set oversampling may alter the principal GEO-1000", + "sourceParagraph": 2451 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0266", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "distribution or Critical prevalence estimate.", + "sourceParagraph": 2452 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0267", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Synthetic screenshots and response artefacts MUST carry visible and", + "sourceParagraph": 2454 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0268", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "machine-readable notices that they are not live AI outputs or real entity", + "sourceParagraph": 2455 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0269", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "performance evidence.", + "sourceParagraph": 2456 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0270", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The benchmark MUST prevent its synthetic claims from being published or", + "sourceParagraph": 2458 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0271", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "indexed as real information about the anchor entity.", + "sourceParagraph": 2459 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0272", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Benchmark success MUST be determined by recovery of sealed Generator", + "sourceParagraph": 2461 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0273", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Truth, including claim boundaries, atomic decisions, omissions,", + "sourceParagraph": 2462 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0274", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Critical and Major gates, response statuses, component scores, composite", + "sourceParagraph": 2463 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0275", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "scores, fairness results, capture validity, and uncertainty coverage.", + "sourceParagraph": 2464 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0276", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "High general accuracy MUST NOT compensate for missed Critical cases.", + "sourceParagraph": 2466 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0277", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Critical recall and Critical false-positive rate MUST be reported", + "sourceParagraph": 2467 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0278", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "together.", + "sourceParagraph": 2468 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0279", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A failed benchmark threshold, leakage event, recovery error, or", + "sourceParagraph": 2470 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0280", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "misclassification MUST remain visible and MUST NOT be removed by", + "sourceParagraph": 2471 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0281", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "changing labels, seeds, samples, weights, or score rules after results", + "sourceParagraph": 2472 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0282", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "are observed.", + "sourceParagraph": 2473 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0283", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every benchmark design, generation, seal, leakage audit, adjudication,", + "sourceParagraph": 2475 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0284", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "recovery calculation, threshold decision, revision, and public release", + "sourceParagraph": 2476 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0285", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or", + "sourceParagraph": 2477 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0286", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "organisation.", + "sourceParagraph": 2478 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0287", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 2479 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0288", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The Apple.com Synthetic Benchmark should evaluate not the performance of the real Apple Inc., apple.com, or real AI providers; but the NOMOS audit method's ability to recover the pre-locked synthetic reality. All entities, users, countries, languages, AI products, responses, citations, evidence, and scores within the benchmark must be clearly identified as synthetic.", + "sourceParagraph": 2480 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Синте��ический эталон Apple.com ДОЛЖЕН оценивать метод аудита NOMOS, а не реальные показатели Apple Inc., apple.com или любого фактического поставщика ИИ. Все эталонные сущности, утверждения, объекты доказательств, пользователи, страны, языки, продукты ИИ, ответы, цитаты, захваты, инциденты и оценки ДОЛЖНЫ быть ясно обозначены как синтетические. Эталон ДОЛЖЕН поддерживать отдельного двойника сущности APPLE-SYNTH и НЕ ДОЛЖЕН представлять свой Пакет Истины как фактическую информацию о реальной компании. Основной эталонный корпус ДОЛЖЕН содержать: - десять синтетических профилей продуктов AI, - тысячу уникальных синтетических участников на продукт на волну, - три волны измерений, - и тридцать тысяч основных ответов. Идентичности синтетических участников НЕ ДОЛЖНО использоваться повторно между продуктами или волнами в основном корпусе. Образцы продуктов ДОЛЖНЫ использовать сопоставимые распределения населения без использования одного и того же участника. Основной корпус по распространенности, корпус по проверке тяжести, корпус по проверке целостности захвата, золотой корпус по экспертизе и диагностический приложении ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельно идентифицированными и НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ использовать общие знаменатели по распространенности. Истина генератора ДОЛЖНА быть создана, версионирована, захэширована и запечатана до рассмотрения ответов. Это ДОЛЖНО оставаться скрытым от извлекателей утверждений, арбитров и аналитиков оценок до тех пор, пока их результаты не будут зафиксированы. Случайные семена, синтетические AI-профили, правила внедрения ошибок, версии промптов, записи Truth Pack, методы оценки и пороги принятия кандидатов ДОЛЖНЫ быть зафиксированы до открытия запечатанного корпуса проверки. Эталонные случаи ДОЛЖНЫ включать прямые, косвенные, приписываемые, модальные, с ограниченной областью действия, временные, основанные на цитатах, основанные на пропусках, самокорректирующиеся и включающие слияние сущностей режимы отказа. Распространенность критических событий ДОЛЖНА оцениваться по основному корпусу. Способность к критическому выявлению ДОЛЖНА тестироваться на отдельном испытательном корпусе с достаточным количеством примеров и негативным контролем, подобным критическому. Никакое чрезмерное увеличение выборки в наборе задач не МОЖЕТ изменять основное распределение GEO-1000 или оценку критической распространенности. Синтетические скриншоты и артефакты ответов ДОЛЖНЫ содержать видимые и машинно-читаемые уведомления о том, что они не являются живыми выводами ИИ или доказательствами реальной работы сущности. Бенчмарк ДОЛЖЕН предотвращать публикацию или индексирование своих синтетических утверждений как реальной информации о эталонной сущности. Успех бенчмарка ДОЛЖЕН определяться восстановлением запечатанной Истины Генератора, включая границы утверждений, а��омарные решения, упущения, критические и основные контрольные точки, статусы ответов, оценки компонентов, составные оценки, результаты по справедливости, достоверность фиксации и охват неопределенности. Высокая общая точность НЕ ДОЛЖНА компенсировать пропущенные критические случаи. Критическое извлечение и критический уровень ложноположительных результатов ДОЛЖНЫ сообщаться вместе. Неудачный порог тестирования, событие утечки, ошибка восстановления или неправильная классификация ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться видимыми и НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ удаляться путем изменения меток, начальных значений, образцов, весов или правил оценки после наблюдения результатов. Каждый дизайн бенчмарка, генерация, печать, аудит на утечки, вынесение решений, расчет восстановления, принятие порогового значения, ревизия и публичный выпуск ДОЛЖНЫ иметь версию и быть приписаны ответственному человеку или организации.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "86. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ ЗАПИСЬ БЕНЧМАРКА", + "sourceParagraph": 2171, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2172, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2173, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2174, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2175, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmark\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2176, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-BENCH-0.9\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2177, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkType\": \"BM-S0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2178, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"DESIGN_LOCK_CANDIDATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2179, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"purpose\": \"VALIDATE_NOMOS_METHOD_AUDIT_NE_REALNYY_OBYEKTVYH_RABOT\"}", + "sourceParagraph": 2180, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nonClaimStatement\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2181, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"синтетический\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2182, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realAppleAudit\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2183, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realAIProviderAudit\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2184, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"endorsementClaimAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2185, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2186, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"якорь\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2187, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"домен\": \"apple.com\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2188, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"syntheticTwinEntityId\": \"NGE-APPLE-СИНТ-ТВИН-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2189, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2190, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"корпуса\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2191, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"principalPrevalence\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2192, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProductCount\": 10,", + "sourceParagraph": 2193, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validUsersPerProductPerWave\": 1000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2194, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveCount\": 3,", + "sourceParagraph": 2195, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetResponseCount\": 30000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2196, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptFamily\": \"PR-01\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2197, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedInPrevalenceScore\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2198, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2199, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"diagnosticAnnex\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2200, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"targetResponseCount\": 6000,", + "sourceParagraph": 2201, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedInPrevalenceScore\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2202, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2203, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"severityChallenge\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2204, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalCases\": 1200,", + "sourceParagraph": 2205, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"majorCases\": 1200,", + "sourceParagraph": 2206, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"moderateCases\": 600,", + "sourceParagraph": 2207, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalLikeNegativeControls\": 600,", + "sourceParagraph": 2208, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedInPrevalenceScore\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2209, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2210, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureIntegrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2211, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedInSemanticPrevalenceScore\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2212, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2213, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationGold\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2214, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedInPrevalenceScore\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2215, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2216, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2217, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"population\": {\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2218, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"frameId\": \"СИНТ-ПОП-ФРЕЙМ-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2219, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countryCodes\": 193,", + "sourceParagraph": 2220, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"populationLanguages\": 24,", + "sourceParagraph": 2221, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessSentinelLanguages\": 12,", + "sourceParagraph": 2222, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realPopulationClaimAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2223, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"matchedSyntheticPopulationTwins\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2224, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"participantReuseAcrossProducts\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2225, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"participantReuseAcrossWaves\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2226, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2227, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"записи\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2228, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackId\": \"СИНТ-APPLE-ТП-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2229, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptSetId\": \"СИНТ-ПРОМПТ-СЕТ-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2230, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiRegistryId\": \"СИНТ-АИ-РЕГИСТР-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2231, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"wavePlanId\": \"СИНТ-ВЕЙВ-ПЛАН-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2232, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureSchemaVersion\": \"NOMOS-ЗАХВАТ-СИНТ-0.9\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2233, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scoreMethodVersion\": \"NOMOS-SCORE-0.9\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2234, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2235, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorTruth\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2236, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"createdBeforeResponses\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2237, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sealedFromAdjudicators\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2238, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"manifestHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ГЕНЕРАТОР-ПРАВДИВОСТИ-ХЭШ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2239, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openedOnlyAfterScoreLock\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2240, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2241, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"randomisation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2242, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"seedManifestId\": \"МАНИФЕСТ-СИНТ-ЗЕРНА-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2243, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedBeforeGeneration\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2244, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"bestRunSelectionProhibited\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2245, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2246, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"releaseProtection\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2247, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"visibleSyntheticWatermarkRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2248, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"machineReadableSyntheticMetadataRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2249, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"liveResponseRepresentationProhibited\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2250, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"searchIndexProtectionRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2251, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2252, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"управление\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2253, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkOwnerRole\": \"ОТВЕТСТВЕННЫЙ_ЧЕЛОВЕЧЕСКИЙ_ЭТАЛОННЫЙ_ВЛАДЕЛЕЦ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2254, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorTruthCustodianRole\": \"ХРАНИТЕЛЬ_ЗАПЕЧАТАННОЙ_ИСТИНЫ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2255, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"leakageAuditorRole\": \"НЕДОСТУПНЫЙ_АУДИТОР_УТЕЧЕК\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2256, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validationTeamSeparatedFromGenerator\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2257, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2258, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2259, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2260, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "87. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ ПРОФИЛЬ ИИ", + "sourceParagraph": 2262, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2263, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2264, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2265, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"syntheticAIProfile\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2266, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"profileId\": \"СИНТ-АИ-10\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2267, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"profileName\": \"РЕДКОЕ_КРИТИЧЕСКОЕ_ВЫСОКОЕ_СРЕДНЕЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2268, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realProviderMapping\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2269, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realProviderInferenceAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2270, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"latentBehavior\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2271, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"coreEntityAccuracy\": 0.985,", + "sourceParagraph": 2272, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"factualSupportBaseline\": 0.975,", + "sourceParagraph": 2273, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeOverreachProbability\": 0.012,", + "sourceParagraph": 2274, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"temporalLagProbability\": 0.008,", + "sourceParagraph": 2275, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialAttributionLossProbability\": 0.010,", + "sourceParagraph": 2276, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationMismatchProbability\": 0.006,", + "sourceParagraph": 2277, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"noUsableResponseProbability\": 0.003,", + "sourceParagraph": 2278, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalEventProbability\": 0.002,", + "sourceParagraph": 2279, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"majorEventProbability\": 0.006,", + "sourceParagraph": 2280, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lowResourceLanguagePenalty\": 0.06,", + "sourceParagraph": 2281, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"naturalStatePenalty\": 0.03,", + "sourceParagraph": 2282, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveDrift\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2283, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"W1\": 0.00,", + "sourceParagraph": 2284, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"W2\": -0.01,", + "sourceParagraph": 2285, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"W3\": 0.01", + "sourceParagraph": 2286, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2287, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2288, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalInjectionFamilies\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2289, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-02\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2290, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-05\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2291, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-06\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2292, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2293, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"intendedMethodStress\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2294, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"HIGH_COMPOSITE_WITH_RARE_CRITICAL\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2295, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NON_COMPENSATORY_GATE_RECOVERY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2296, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RARE_EVENT_UPPER_BOUND\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2297, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2298, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedBeforeCorpusGeneration\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2299, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"profileIntegrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-AI-PROFILE-HASH\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2300, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2301, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2302, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "88. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ РЕЕСТР ИСТИНЫ ГЕНЕРАТОРА", + "sourceParagraph": 2304, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2305, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2306, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2307, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorTruthRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2308, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorTruthId\": \"NGGT-SYNTH-000184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2309, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"observationId\": \"OBS-SYNTH-000184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2310, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-BENCH-0.9\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2311, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"aiProfileId\": \"СИНТ-АИ-10\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2312, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveId\": \"W2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2313, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"participantId\": \"SYNTH-PERSON-000184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2314, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptRecordId\": \"SYNTH-CORE-PROMPT-L01-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2315, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackVersion\": \"СИНТ-APPLE-ТП-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2316, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"hiddenAtomicClaims\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2317, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2318, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorClaimId\": \"GCL-000184-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2319, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2320, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"APPLE-SYNTH-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2321, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"predicate\": \"principalEntityAssociatedWithDomain\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2322, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"objectValue\": \"apple.com\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2323, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2324, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthStatus\": \"ПОДДЕРЖИВАЕТСЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2325, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"importance\": \"ОСНОВНОЕ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2326, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2327, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2328, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorClaimId\": \"GCL-000184-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2329, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2330, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"APPLE-SYNTH-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2331, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"predicate\": \"licensedBankInAllMarkets\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2332, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"objectValue\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2333, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2334, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthStatus\": \"ПРОТИВОРОЧИТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2335, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"важность\": \"КРИТИЧЕСКАЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2336, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalGateCodes\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2337, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-01\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2338, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CG-02\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2339, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2340, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rootFindingCluster\": \"ЛОЖНАЯ_ПЕРЕДАЧА_ЛИЦЕНЗИИ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2341, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2342, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2343, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"hiddenOmissions\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2344, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2345, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorOmissionId\": \"GOM-000184-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2346, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"requiredBoundary\": \"ПОЛНОМОЧИЯ_ПЛАТЕЖНОЙ_ДОЧЕРНЕЙ_КОМПАНИИ_ОГРАНИЧЕНЫ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2347, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"важность\": \"КРИТИЧЕСКАЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2348, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalGateCode\": \"CG-08\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2349, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2350, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2351, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"hiddenResponseStatus\": \"RP-5\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2352, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"includedInPrincipalPrevalenceCorpus\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2353, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sealedAtGeneration\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2354, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"visibleToAdjudicators\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2355, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ГЕНЕРАТОР-ПРАВДИВОСТИ-OBS-ХЭШ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2356, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2357, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2358, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "89. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМАЯ ЗАПИСЬ ВОССТАНОВЛЕНИЯ БЕНЧМАРКА", + "sourceParagraph": 2360, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2361, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2362, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2363, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkRecovery\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2364, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"recoveryRecordId\": \"NGBR-СИНТ-АППЛЬ-0.9-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2365, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-BENCH-0.9\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2366, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validationSet\": \"ЗАПЕЧАТАННАЯ_ВАЛИДАЦИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2367, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorTruthOpenedAfterScoreLock\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2368, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"metrics\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2369, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimBoundaryF1\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2370, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityResolutionAccuracy\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2371, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"factualStatusMacroF1\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2372, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeMacroF1\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2373, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attributionMacroF1\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2374, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationMappingF1\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2375, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialOmissionF1\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2376, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalRecall\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2377, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalFalsePositiveRate\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2378, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"majorClassificationMacroF1\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2379, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseStatusMacroF1\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2380, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"componentMeanAbsoluteError\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2381, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0209", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"compositeAbsoluteError\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2382, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0210", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"geo1000DistributionErrors\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2383, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0211", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessComponentError\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2384, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0212", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureValidityAccuracy\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2385, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0213", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"confidenceIntervalEmpiricalCoverage\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2386, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0214", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2387, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0215", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThresholdsApplied\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2388, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0216", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkQualityStatus\": \"BQ-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2389, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0217", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"failureDisclosureRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2390, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0218", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentReproductionStatus\": \"НЕ_НАЧАТО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2391, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0219", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2392, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0220", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"recoveryMethodsOwnerRole\": \"ЛИДЕР_МЕТОДОВ_ВОССТАНОВЛЕНИЯ_БЕНЧМАРКА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2393, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0221", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"approvedByRole\": \"ОТВЕТСТВЕННЫЙ_ЧЕЛОВЕК_С_УТВЕРЖДЕНИЕМ_БЕНЧМАРКА\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2394, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0222", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2395, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0223", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2396, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0224", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2397, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0225", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Эти записи:", + "sourceParagraph": 2398, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0226", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "фактический аудит Apple,", + "sourceParagraph": 2399, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0227", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальное поведение AI-поставщика,", + "sourceParagraph": 2400, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0228", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальный результат пользователя", + "sourceParagraph": 2401, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0229", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальной производительностью компании.", + "sourceParagraph": 2402, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0230", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Это машинно-читаемое синтетическое представление конструкции бенчмарка.", + "sourceParagraph": 2403, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0231", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "МАШИНОЧИТАЕМОЕ ПРАВИЛ�� РАЗДЕЛА 90", + "sourceParagraph": 2405, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0232", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH17-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2406, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0233", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Синтетический бенчмарк Apple.com ДОЛЖЕН оценивать метод аудита NOMOS,", + "sourceParagraph": 2408, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0234", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "а не реальную производительность Apple Inc., apple.com, или какого-либо реального поставщика ИИ.", + "sourceParagraph": 2409, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0235", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "", + "sourceParagraph": 2410, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0236", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Все сущности бенчмарка, утверждения, объекты доказательств, пользователи, страны,", + "sourceParagraph": 2412, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0237", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "языки, продукты ИИ, ответы, цитаты, материалы, инциденты и", + "sourceParagraph": 2413, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0238", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "оценки ДОЛЖНЫ быть явно идентифицированы как синтетические.", + "sourceParagraph": 2414, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0239", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Бенчмарк ДОЛЖЕН поддерживать отдельного синтетического двойника APPLE-SYNTH и ДОЛЖЕН", + "sourceParagraph": 2416, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0240", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "НЕ представлять его Truth Pack как фактическую информацию о реальной", + "sourceParagraph": 2417, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0241", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "компании.", + "sourceParagraph": 2418, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0242", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Основной корпус бенчмарка ДОЛЖЕН содержать:", + "sourceParagraph": 2420, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0243", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- десять синтетических профилей продуктов ИИ,", + "sourceParagraph": 2422, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0244", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- тысяча уникальных синтетических участников на продукт для каждой волны,", + "sourceParagraph": 2423, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0245", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- три волны измерений,", + "sourceParagraph": 2424, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0246", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и тридцать тысяч основных откликов.", + "sourceParagraph": 2425, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0247", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Идентичности синтетических участников НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ повторяться между продуктами или", + "sourceParagraph": 2427, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0248", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "волнами в основном корпусе. Выборки продуктов ДОЛЖНЫ использовать сопоставленные", + "sourceParagraph": 2428, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0249", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "распределения населения без использования одной и той же единицы человека.", + "sourceParagraph": 2429, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0250", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Основной корпус распространенности, корпус проблем тяжелых случаев, корпус проверки", + "sourceParagraph": 2431, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0251", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "целостности, корпус золотой экспертизы, и диагностический приложений ДОЛЖНЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2432, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0252", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "оставаться отдельно идентифицированными и НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ использовать общие знаменатели распространенности.", + "sourceParagraph": 2433, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0253", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Истина генератора ДОЛЖНА быть создана, версионирована, захеширована и запечатана заранее", + "sourceParagraph": 2435, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0254", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "рассмотрение ответа. Оно ДОЛЖНО оставаться скрытым от извлекателей утверждений,", + "sourceParagraph": 2436, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0255", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "судьи и аналитики результатов до того, как их результаты будут зафиксированы.", + "sourceParagraph": 2437, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0256", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Случайные семена, синтетические профили ИИ, правила вставки ошибок, запрос", + "sourceParagraph": 2439, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0257", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "версии, записи Truth Pack, методы оценки и принятие кандидатов", + "sourceParagraph": 2440, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0258", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Пороги ДОЛЖНЫ быть зафиксированы до того, как будет открыт запечатанный корпус для проверки.", + "sourceParagraph": 2441, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0259", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Тестовые случаи ДОЛЖНЫ включать прямые, косвенные, приписываемые, модальные,", + "sourceParagraph": 2443, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0260", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "с ограниченной областью применения, временные, основанные на цитатах, основанные на пропусках, самокорректирующиеся,", + "sourceParagraph": 2444, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0261", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "и сбивающие с толку режимы слияния сущностей.", + "sourceParagraph": 2445, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0262", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Необходимость оценки распространенности критических событий ДОЛЖНА производиться на основе основного корпуса.", + "sourceParagraph": 2447, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0263", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Способность к критическому обнаружению ДОЛЖНА тестироваться в отдельном контрольном", + "sourceParagraph": 2448, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0264", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "корпусе с достаточным количеством примеров и критическими отрицательными контрольными примерами.", + "sourceParagraph": 2449, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0265", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Никакое чрезмерное выборочное тестирование не может изменить основное распределение GEO-1000", + "sourceParagraph": 2451, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0266", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "или оценку распространенности критических событий.", + "sourceParagraph": 2452, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0267", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Синтетические скриншоты и артефакты ответов ДОЛЖНЫ содержать видимые и", + "sourceParagraph": 2454, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0268", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "машинно-читаемые уведомления о том, что они не являются реальными выводами ИИ или реальными сущностями", + "sourceParagraph": 2455, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0269", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "доказательства эффективности.", + "sourceParagraph": 2456, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0270", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Бенчмарк ДОЛЖЕН предотвращать публикацию своих синтетических утверждений или", + "sourceParagraph": 2458, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0271", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "индексацию как реальной информации об объекте-опоре.", + "sourceParagraph": 2459, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0272", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Успех бенчмарка ДОЛЖЕН определяться восстановлением запечатанной Генераторской", + "sourceParagraph": 2461, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0273", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Правды, включая границы утверждений, атомарные решения, упущения,", + "sourceParagraph": 2462, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0274", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Критические и Основные контрольные точки, статусы ответов, оценки компонентов, составные", + "sourceParagraph": 2463, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0275", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "оценки, результаты справедливости, достоверность захвата и охват неопределенности.", + "sourceParagraph": 2464, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0276", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Высокая общая точность НЕ ДОЛЖНА компенсировать пропущенные Критические случаи.", + "sourceParagraph": 2466, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0277", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ДОЛЖНЫ быть сообщены Критическая полнота и Критический уровень ложноположительных срабатываний", + "sourceParagraph": 2467, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0278", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "вместе.", + "sourceParagraph": 2468, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0279", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Порог неудачного бенчмарка, событие утечки, ошибка восстановления или", + "sourceParagraph": 2470, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0280", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "неверная классификация ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться видимыми и НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ удаляться путем", + "sourceParagraph": 2471, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0281", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "изменения меток, семян, образцов, весов или правил оценки после того, как результаты", + "sourceParagraph": 2472, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0282", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "была наблюдены.", + "sourceParagraph": 2473, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0283", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждый дизайн бенчмарка, генерация, печать, аудит утечки, вынесение решения,", + "sourceParagraph": 2475, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0284", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "вычисление восстановления, решение по порогу, пересмотр и публичный выпуск", + "sourceParagraph": 2476, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0285", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ДОЛЖНЫ иметь версии и быть приписаны ответственному человеку или", + "sourceParagraph": 2477, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0286", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "организации.", + "sourceParagraph": 2478, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0287", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 2479, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH17-MB0288", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Синтетический бенчмарк Apple.com должен оценивать не производительность реальной компании Apple Inc., apple.com, или реальных поставщиков ИИ; а способность метода аудита NOMOS восстанавливать предварительно зафиксированную синтетическую реальность. Все сущности, пользователи, страны, языки, продукты ИИ, ответы, цитаты, доказательства и оценки внутри бенчмарка должны быть явно идентифицированы как синтетические.", + "sourceParagraph": 2480, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 18, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH18", + "title": "Сквозной синтетический аудит 30 000 ответов", + "subtitle": "Расчётная демонстрация метода", + "sourceIds": [ + "K03", + "K09" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH18-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "A book-level synthetic demonstration MUST NOT be represented as an executed, independently validated benchmark. The real benchmark quality status MUST remain BQ-0 until the corpus, software, sealed Generator Truth, adjudication process, scoring process, and independent reproduction have actually been executed. An end-to-end synthetic audit MUST evaluate recovery separately for: - capture validity, - claim boundaries, - entity resolution, - factual status, - scope, - time, - attribution, - modality, - citation mapping, - material omissions, - Critical and Major severity, - response status, - GEO-1000 distribution, - component scores, - composite score, - fairness, - user-state effects, - stability, - confidence intervals, - and rare-event behaviour. A small composite-score error MUST NOT compensate for material component-level recovery errors. First-pass and final-adjudicated Critical recall MUST remain separately reported. Final Critical recovery MUST disclose the review and expertise layers required to achieve it. Any predeclared mandatory recovery threshold that is not met MUST block a sealed-validation-pass decision. Candidate thresholds MUST NOT be lowered, rounded, reinterpreted, or removed after results are observed merely to make the method pass. Citation mapping and material omission recovery MUST be treated as separate mandatory method capabilities. A method failure MUST create a versioned Method Finding, an identified root cause, a remediation owner, and a requirement for validation on an untouched holdout. Regression success on previously failed cases MUST NOT replace untouched holdout validation. A demonstration that fails mandatory thresholds MUST publish both its successful and unsuccessful results. No public NOMOS conformity mark, NOMOS 950+ declaration, or real-entity ranking may be based solely on a book demonstration, synthetic recovery scenario, or non-independent benchmark. Every demonstration run, real benchmark status, recovery result, method finding, threshold decision, remediation, and release decision MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Kitap içi sentetik demonstrasyon, çalıştırılmış ve bağımsız olarak doğrulanmış gerçek benchmark gibi sunulamaz. Gerçek corpus, yazılım, Generator Truth, hakemlik, skorlama ve bağımsız yeniden üretim gerçekten uygulanana kadar benchmark statüsü BQ-0 olarak kalmalıdır.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MACHINE-READABLE DEMONSTRATION RECORD 49", + "sourceParagraph": 1587 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1588 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1589 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1590 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"demonstrationRun\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1591 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"demonstrationRunId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-DEMO-RUN-18-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1592 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"chapter\": \"CH18\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1593 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"BOOK_LEVEL_SYNTHETIC_DEMONSTRATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1594 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realBenchmarkExecution\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1595 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realBenchmarkQualityStatus\": \"BQ-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1596 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"demonstrationQualityStatus\": \"DEMO-BQ-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1597 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nonClaimStatement\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1598 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realApplePerformanceClaim\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1599 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realAIProviderPerformanceClaim\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1600 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realHumanObservationClaim\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1601 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentExecutionClaim\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1602 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1603 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"corpora\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1604 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"principalPrevalenceResponses\": 30000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1605 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"diagnosticAnnexCases\": 6000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1606 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"severityChallengeCases\": 3600,", + "sourceParagraph": 1607 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureIntegrityCases\": 4000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1608 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationGoldCases\": 2400", + "sourceParagraph": 1609 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1610 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedRecords\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1611 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkVersion\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-BENCH-0.9\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1612 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackVersion\": \"SYNTH-APPLE-TP-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1613 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptSetVersion\": \"SYNTH-PROMPT-SET-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1614 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scoreMethodVersion\": \"NOMOS-SCORE-0.9\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1615 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"seedManifestVersion\": \"SYNTH-SEED-MANIFEST-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1616 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThresholdVersion\": \"SYNTH-ACCEPTANCE-0.9\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1617 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1618 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorTruth\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1619 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sealedBeforeRecovery\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1620 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"principalDistribution\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1621 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-1\": 20045,", + "sourceParagraph": 1622 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-2\": 4310,", + "sourceParagraph": 1623 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-3\": 2370,", + "sourceParagraph": 1624 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-4\": 1602,", + "sourceParagraph": 1625 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-5\": 33,", + "sourceParagraph": 1626 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-6\": 450,", + "sourceParagraph": 1627 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-7\": 1110,", + "sourceParagraph": 1628 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-8\": 80", + "sourceParagraph": 1629 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1630 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1631 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomosRecovery\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1632 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedBeforeGeneratorTruthOpen\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1633 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"principalDistribution\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1634 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-1\": 19980,", + "sourceParagraph": 1635 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-2\": 4365,", + "sourceParagraph": 1636 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-3\": 2382,", + "sourceParagraph": 1637 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-4\": 1585,", + "sourceParagraph": 1638 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-5\": 33,", + "sourceParagraph": 1639 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-6\": 468,", + "sourceParagraph": 1640 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-7\": 1091,", + "sourceParagraph": 1641 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-8\": 96", + "sourceParagraph": 1642 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1643 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"strictPassEquivalent\": 811.5,", + "sourceParagraph": 1644 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"acceptablePassEquivalent\": 890.9", + "sourceParagraph": 1645 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1646 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1647 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"synthetic\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1648 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"bookDemonstrationOnly\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1649 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"manifestHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-DEMO-RUN-HASH\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1650 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1651 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1652 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responsibleHumanAuthor\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1653 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalAIInterlocutor\": \"NOMOS by NobleJackal\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1654 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realExecutionApprovalRequired\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1655 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1656 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1657 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1658 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MACHINE-READABLE RECOVERY RECORD 50", + "sourceParagraph": 1660 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1661 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1662 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1663 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkRecovery\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1664 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"recoveryRecordId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-DEMO-RECOVERY-18-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1665 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"demonstrationRunId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-DEMO-RUN-18-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1666 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorTruthOpenedAfterRecoveryLock\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1667 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"metrics\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1668 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimBoundary\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1669 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"precision\": 0.9613,", + "sourceParagraph": 1670 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"recall\": 0.9665,", + "sourceParagraph": 1671 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"f1\": 0.9639,", + "sourceParagraph": 1672 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.95,", + "sourceParagraph": 1673 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"passed\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1674 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1675 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityResolutionAccuracy\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1676 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 0.987,", + "sourceParagraph": 1677 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.98,", + "sourceParagraph": 1678 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"passed\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1679 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1680 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"factualStatusMacroF1\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1681 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 0.923,", + "sourceParagraph": 1682 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.90,", + "sourceParagraph": 1683 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"passed\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1684 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1685 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeMacroF1\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1686 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 0.906,", + "sourceParagraph": 1687 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.90,", + "sourceParagraph": 1688 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"passed\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1689 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1690 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attributionMacroF1\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1691 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 0.918,", + "sourceParagraph": 1692 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.90,", + "sourceParagraph": 1693 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"passed\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 1694 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1695 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationMappingF1\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1696 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 0.887,", + "sourceParagraph": 1697 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.90,", + "sourceParagraph": 1698 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"passed\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1699 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1700 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialOmissionF1\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1701 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 0.824,", + "sourceParagraph": 1702 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.85,", + "sourceParagraph": 1703 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"passed\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1704 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1705 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalFirstPassRecall\": 0.9942,", + "sourceParagraph": 1706 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalFinalRecall\": 1.0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1707 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalFinalFalsePositiveRate\": 0.0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1708 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"majorClassificationMacroF1\": 0.952,", + "sourceParagraph": 1709 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseStatusMacroF1\": 0.928,", + "sourceParagraph": 1710 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureValidityAccuracy\": 0.982,", + "sourceParagraph": 1711 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"componentMeanAbsoluteError\": 1.9,", + "sourceParagraph": 1712 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"compositeAbsoluteError\": 1.0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1713 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessComponentAbsoluteError\": 2.4,", + "sourceParagraph": 1714 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"confidenceIntervalCoverageWithinCandidateRange\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1715 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"finalCriticalGateInversionCount\": 0", + "sourceParagraph": 1716 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1717 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThresholdSummary\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1718 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"passed\": 15,", + "sourceParagraph": 1719 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"failed\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 1720 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentReproductionCompleted\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1721 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1722 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"qualityDecision\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1723 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"demonstrationStatus\": \"DEMO-BQ-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1724 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sealedValidationPassed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1725 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentReproductionEligible\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1726 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicConformityUseAllowed\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1727 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1728 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1729 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1730 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "51. MACHINE-READABLE METHOD FINDING RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 1732 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1733 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1734 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1735 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"methodFinding\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1736 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"methodFindingId\": \"NGMF-CH18-OMISSION-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1737 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"title\": \"Material Boundary Omission Under-Detection\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1738 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"methodVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1739 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"importance\": \"MAJOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1740 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"affectedComponents\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1741 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SBI\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1742 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"TCR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1743 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CRITICAL_GATE_RECOVERY\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1744 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1745 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidence\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1746 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialOmissionF1\": 0.824,", + "sourceParagraph": 1747 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.85,", + "sourceParagraph": 1748 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"mostAffectedPromptFamilies\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1749 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PR-07\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1750 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PR-09\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1751 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PR-05\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1752 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1753 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"mostAffectedErrorForms\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1754 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"OUT_OF_SCOPE_RECOMMENDATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1755 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"JURISDICTION_BOUNDARY_OMISSION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1756 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SUBSIDIARY_AUTHORITY_OMISSION\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1757 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 1758 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1759 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rootCause\": \"The adjudication codebook identifies explicit scope errors more reliably than counterfactual decision-changing omissions.\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1760 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"remediation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1761 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"requiredMethodVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1762 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"actions\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1763 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ADD_COUNTERFACTUAL_DECISION_TEST\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1764 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ADD_ENTITY_SERVICE_JURISDICTION_MATRIX\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1765 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"REQUIRE_SEPARATE_BOUNDARY_OMISSION_REVIEW\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1766 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"VALIDATE_ON_UNTOUCHED_HOLDOUT\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1767 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 1768 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1769 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conformityEffect\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1770 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkPassAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1771 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicBadgeUseAllowed\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 1772 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1773 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1774 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"findingOwnerRole\": \"NOMOS_METHOD_REMEDIATION_LEAD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1775 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"OPEN\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1776 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1777 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1778 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1779 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "52. MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF THE SECTION", + "sourceParagraph": 1781 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH18-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1782 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A book-level synthetic demonstration MUST NOT be represented as an", + "sourceParagraph": 1784 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "executed, independently validated benchmark.", + "sourceParagraph": 1785 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The real benchmark quality status MUST remain BQ-0 until the corpus,", + "sourceParagraph": 1787 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "software, sealed Generator Truth, adjudication process, scoring process,", + "sourceParagraph": 1788 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "and independent reproduction have actually been executed.", + "sourceParagraph": 1789 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "An end-to-end synthetic audit MUST evaluate recovery separately for:", + "sourceParagraph": 1791 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- capture validity,", + "sourceParagraph": 1793 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- claim boundaries,", + "sourceParagraph": 1794 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- entity resolution,", + "sourceParagraph": 1795 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- factual status,", + "sourceParagraph": 1796 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- scope,", + "sourceParagraph": 1797 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- time,", + "sourceParagraph": 1798 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- attribution,", + "sourceParagraph": 1799 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- modality,", + "sourceParagraph": 1800 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- citation mapping,", + "sourceParagraph": 1801 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0209", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- material omissions,", + "sourceParagraph": 1802 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0210", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Critical and Major severity,", + "sourceParagraph": 1803 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0211", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- response status,", + "sourceParagraph": 1804 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0212", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- GEO-1000 distribution,", + "sourceParagraph": 1805 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0213", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- component scores,", + "sourceParagraph": 1806 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0214", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- composite score,", + "sourceParagraph": 1807 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0215", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- fairness,", + "sourceParagraph": 1808 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0216", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- user-state effects,", + "sourceParagraph": 1809 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0217", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- stability,", + "sourceParagraph": 1810 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0218", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- confidence intervals,", + "sourceParagraph": 1811 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0219", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and rare-event behaviour.", + "sourceParagraph": 1812 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0220", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A small composite-score error MUST NOT compensate for material", + "sourceParagraph": 1814 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0221", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "component-level recovery errors.", + "sourceParagraph": 1815 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0222", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "First-pass and final-adjudicated Critical recall MUST remain separately", + "sourceParagraph": 1817 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0223", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "reported. Final Critical recovery MUST disclose the review and expertise", + "sourceParagraph": 1818 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0224", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "layers required to achieve it.", + "sourceParagraph": 1819 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0225", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Any predeclared mandatory recovery threshold that is not met MUST block a", + "sourceParagraph": 1821 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0226", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "sealed-validation-pass decision.", + "sourceParagraph": 1822 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0227", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Candidate thresholds MUST NOT be lowered, rounded, reinterpreted, or", + "sourceParagraph": 1824 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0228", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "removed after results are observed merely to make the method pass.", + "sourceParagraph": 1825 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0229", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Citation mapping and material omission recovery MUST be treated as", + "sourceParagraph": 1827 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0230", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "separate mandatory method capabilities.", + "sourceParagraph": 1828 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0231", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A method failure MUST create a versioned Method Finding, an identified", + "sourceParagraph": 1830 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0232", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "root cause, a remediation owner, and a requirement for validation on an", + "sourceParagraph": 1831 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0233", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "untouched holdout.", + "sourceParagraph": 1832 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0234", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Regression success on previously failed cases MUST NOT replace untouched", + "sourceParagraph": 1834 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0235", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "holdout validation.", + "sourceParagraph": 1835 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0236", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A demonstration that fails mandatory thresholds MUST publish both its", + "sourceParagraph": 1837 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0237", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "successful and unsuccessful results.", + "sourceParagraph": 1838 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0238", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "No public NOMOS conformity mark, NOMOS 950+ declaration, or real-entity", + "sourceParagraph": 1840 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0239", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ranking may be based solely on a book demonstration, synthetic recovery", + "sourceParagraph": 1841 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0240", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "scenario, or non-independent benchmark.", + "sourceParagraph": 1842 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0241", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every demonstration run, real benchmark status, recovery result, method", + "sourceParagraph": 1844 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0242", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "finding, threshold decision, remediation, and release decision MUST be", + "sourceParagraph": 1845 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0243", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "sourceParagraph": 1846 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0244", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 1847 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0245", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "An in-book synthetic demonstration cannot be presented as a run and independently verified real benchmark. Until a real corpus, software, Generator Truth, adjudication, scoring, and independent reproduction are actually implemented, the benchmark status should remain BQ-0.", + "sourceParagraph": 1848 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Синтетическая демонстрация уровня книги НЕ ДОЛЖНА представляться как выполненный, независимо проверенный бенчмарк. Фактический статус качества бенчмарка ДОЛЖЕН оставаться BQ-0 до тех пор, пока корпус, программное обеспечение, запечатанная Истина Генератора, процесс рассмотрения, процесс оценивания и независимое воспроизведение фактически не будут выполнены. Комплексный синтетический аудит ДОЛЖЕН отдельно оценивать восстановление по следующим направлениям: - точность захвата, - границы утверждений, - разрешение сущностей, - фактический статус, - охват, - время, - атрибуция, - модальность, - сопоставление цитат, - материальные упущения, - категории критической и серьёзной тяжести, - статус ответа, - распределение GEO-1000, - оценки компонентов, - составной балл, - справедливость, - эффекты состояния пользователя, - стабильность, - интервалы доверия, - и поведение редких событий. Небольшая ошибка составного балла НЕ ДОЛЖНА компенсировать существенные ошибки восстановления на уровне компонентов. Необходимо отдельно сообщать о полноте выявления критических случаев при первичном и окончательном рассмотрении. Окончательное критическое восстановление ДОЛЖНО раскрывать слои проверки и экспертные слои, необходимые для его достижения. Любой заранее установленный обязательный порог восстановления, который не достигнут, ДОЛЖЕН блокировать решение об успешном прохождении запечатанной валидации. Пороговые значения метода-кандидата НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ снижаться, округляться, переосмысливаться или удаляться после получения результатов только для того, чтобы метод прошел проверку. Восстановление привязки цитат и существенных пропусков ДОЛЖНО рассматриваться как отдельные обязательные возможности метода. Сбой метода ДОЛЖЕН создавать версионированный вывод о недостатке метода, определённую первопричину, ответственного за исправление и требование проверки на нетронутом контрольном наборе. Успешное регрессное тестирование ранее неудачных случаев НЕ ДОЛЖНО заменять проверку на нетронутом контрольном наборе. Демонстрация, не достигшая обязательных порогов, ДОЛЖНА публиковать как успешные, так и неуспешные результаты. Ни один публичный знак соответствия NOMOS, декларация NOMOS 950+ или рейтинг реального объекта НЕ МОЖЕТ основываться исключительно на демонстрации из книги, синтетическом сценарии восстановления или эталонном тесте, не прошедшем независимую проверку. Каждый запуск демонстрации, статус реального эталона, результат восстановления, находка метода, решение по порогу, корректировка и решение о выпуске ДОЛЖНЫ быть версионированы и отнесены ответственному человеку или организации.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ ЗАПИСЬ ДЕМОНСТРАЦИИ 49", + "sourceParagraph": 1587, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1588, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1589, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1590, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"demonstrationRun\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1591, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"demonstrationRunId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNТ-DEMO-RUN-18-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1592, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"chapter\": \"CH1 8\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1593, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"BOOK_LEVEL_SYNTHETIC_DEMONSTRATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1594, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realBenchmarkExecution\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1595, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realBenchmarkQualityStatus\": \"BQ-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1596, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"demonstrationQualityStatus\": \"DEMO-BQ-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1597, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nonClaimStatement\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1598, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realApplePerformanceClaim\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1599, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realAIProviderPerformanceClaim\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1600, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realHumanObservationClaim\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1601, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentExecutionClaim\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1602, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1603, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"корпуса\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1604, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"principalPrevalenceResponses\": 30000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1605, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"diagnosticAnnexCases\": 6000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1606, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"severityChallengeCases\": 3600,", + "sourceParagraph": 1607, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureIntegrityCases\": 4000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1608, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationGoldCases\": 2400", + "sourceParagraph": 1609, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1610, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedRecords\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1611, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkVersion\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-BENCH-0.9\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1612, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackVersion\": \"СИНТ-APPLE-ТП-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1613, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"promptSetVersion\": \"СИНТ-ПРОМПТ-СЕТ-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1614, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scoreMethodVersion\": \"NOMOS-SCORE-0.9\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1615, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"seedManifestVersion\": \"МАНИФЕСТ-СИНТ-ЗЕРНА-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1616, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThresholdVersion\": \"СИНТЕЗАТОР-ПРИНЯТИЕ-0.9\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1617, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1618, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorTruth\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1619, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sealedBeforeRecovery\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1620, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"principalDistribution\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1621, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-1\": 20045,", + "sourceParagraph": 1622, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-2\": 4310,", + "sourceParagraph": 1623, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-3\": 2370,", + "sourceParagraph": 1624, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-4\": 1602,", + "sourceParagraph": 1625, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-5\": 33,", + "sourceParagraph": 1626, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-6\": 450,", + "sourceParagraph": 1627, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-7\": 1110,", + "sourceParagraph": 1628, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-8\": 80", + "sourceParagraph": 1629, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1630, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1631, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomosRecovery\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1632, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lockedBeforeGeneratorTruthOpen\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1633, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"principalDistribution\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1634, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-1\": 19980,", + "sourceParagraph": 1635, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-2\": 4365,", + "sourceParagraph": 1636, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-3\": 2382,", + "sourceParagraph": 1637, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-4\": 1585,", + "sourceParagraph": 1638, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-5\": 33,", + "sourceParagraph": 1639, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-6\": 468,", + "sourceParagraph": 1640, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-7\": 1091,", + "sourceParagraph": 1641, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"RP-8\": 96", + "sourceParagraph": 1642, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1643, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"strictPassEquivalent\": 811.5,", + "sourceParagraph": 1644, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"acceptablePassEquivalent\": 890.9", + "sourceParagraph": 1645, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1646, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1647, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"синтетический\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1648, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"bookDemonstrationOnly\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1649, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"manifestHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ДЕМО-РАН-ХЭШ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1650, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1651, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1652, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responsibleHumanAuthor\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1653, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalAIInterlocutor\": \"NOMOS NobleJackal\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1654, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"realExecutionApprovalRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1655, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1656, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1657, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1658, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "МАШИНОЧИТАЕМАЯ ЗАПИСЬ ВОССТАНОВЛЕНИЯ 50", + "sourceParagraph": 1660, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1661, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1662, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1663, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkRecovery\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1664, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"recoveryRecordId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-DEMO-RECOVERY-18-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1665, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"demonstrationRunId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNТ-DEMO-RUN-18-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1666, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"generatorTruthOpenedAfterRecoveryLock\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1667, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"metrics\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1668, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimBoundary\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1669, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"Точность\": 0.961 3,", + "sourceParagraph": 1670, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "«Отзыв»: 0.966 5,", + "sourceParagraph": 1671, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"F1\": 0.963 9,", + "sourceParagraph": 1672, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.95,", + "sourceParagraph": 1673, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "«сдал»: верно", + "sourceParagraph": 1674, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1675, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityResolutionAccuracy\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1676, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 0.987,", + "sourceParagraph": 1677, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.98,", + "sourceParagraph": 1678, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "«сдал»: верно", + "sourceParagraph": 1679, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1680, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"factualStatusMacroF1\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1681, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 0.923,", + "sourceParagraph": 1682, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.90,", + "sourceParagraph": 1683, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "«сдал»: верно", + "sourceParagraph": 1684, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1685, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeMacroF1\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1686, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 0.906,", + "sourceParagraph": 1687, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.90,", + "sourceParagraph": 1688, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "«сдал»: верно", + "sourceParagraph": 1689, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1690, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attributionMacroF1\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1691, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 0.918,", + "sourceParagraph": 1692, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.90,", + "sourceParagraph": 1693, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "«сдал»: верно", + "sourceParagraph": 1694, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1695, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"citationMappingF1\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1696, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 0.887,", + "sourceParagraph": 1697, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.90,", + "sourceParagraph": 1698, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"Сдал\": ложно", + "sourceParagraph": 1699, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1700, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialOmissionF1\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1701, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"value\": 0.824,", + "sourceParagraph": 1702, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.85,", + "sourceParagraph": 1703, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"Сдал\": ложно", + "sourceParagraph": 1704, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1705, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalFirstPassRecall\": 0.994 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 1706, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalFinalRecall\": 1.0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1707, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalFinalFalsePositiveRate\": 0.0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1708, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"majorClassificationMacroF1\": 0.952,", + "sourceParagraph": 1709, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"responseStatusMacroF1\": 0.928,", + "sourceParagraph": 1710, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureValidityAccuracy\": 0.982,", + "sourceParagraph": 1711, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"componentMeanAbsoluteError\": 1.9,", + "sourceParagraph": 1712, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"compositeAbsoluteError\": 1.0,", + "sourceParagraph": 1713, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessComponentAbsoluteError\": 2.4,", + "sourceParagraph": 1714, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"confidenceIntervalCoverageWithinCandidateRange\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 1715, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"finalCriticalGateInversionCount\": 0", + "sourceParagraph": 1716, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1717, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThresholdSummary\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1718, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"passed\": 15,", + "sourceParagraph": 1719, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"failed\": 2,", + "sourceParagraph": 1720, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentReproductionCompleted\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1721, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1722, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"qualityDecision\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1723, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"demonstrationStatus\": \"DEMO-BQ-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1724, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"sealedValidationPassed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1725, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentReproductionEligible\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1726, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicConformityUseAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1727, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1728, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1729, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1730, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "51. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ ЗАПИСЬ О МЕТОДЕ НАХОЖДЕНИЯ", + "sourceParagraph": 1732, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 1733, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1734, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1735, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"methodFinding\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1736, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"methodFindingId\": \"NGMF-CH1 8-OMISSION-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1737, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"title\": \"Недоопределение упущений материальных границ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1738, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"methodVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1739, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"importance\": \"ВАЖНОЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1740, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"affectedComponents\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1741, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SBI\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1742, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"TCR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1743, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ВОССТАНОВЛЕНИЕ_КРИТИЧЕСКОЙ_СКОРОСТИ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1744, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1745, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"доказательство\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1746, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialOmissionF1\": 0.824,", + "sourceParagraph": 1747, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.85,", + "sourceParagraph": 1748, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"mostAffectedPromptFamilies\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1749, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PR-07\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1750, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PR-09\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1751, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PR-05\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1752, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 1753, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"mostAffectedErrorForms\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1754, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"РЕКОМЕНДАЦИЯ_ЗА_ПРЕДЕЛАМИ_ОБЛАСТИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1755, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"УПОЩЕННАЯ_ГРАНИЦА_ЮРИСДИКЦИИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1756, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"УПОЩЕННАЯ_ПОЛНОМОЧИЯ_ДОЧЕРНЕЙ_ОРГАНИЗАЦИИ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1757, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 1758, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1759, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"rootCause\": \"Кодекс арбитража выявляет явные ошибки области более надежно, чем контрфактические пропуски, изменяющие решение.\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1760, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"устранение проблем\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1761, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"requiredMethodVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1762, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"actions\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 1763, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ADD_COUNTERFACTUAL_DECISION_TEST\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1764, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ADD_ENTITY_SERVICE_JURISDICTION_MATRIX\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1765, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"REQUIRE_SEPARATE_BOUNDARY_OMISSION_REVIEW\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1766, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"VALIDATE_ON_UNTOUCHED_HOLDOUT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1767, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 1768, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1769, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conformityEffect\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1770, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkPassAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1771, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicBadgeUseAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 1772, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 1773, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 1774, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"findingOwnerRole\": \"NOMOS_METHOD_REMEDIATION_LEAD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1775, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"OPEN\",", + "sourceParagraph": 1776, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1777, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1778, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 1779, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "52. ПРАВИЛО РАЗДЕЛА, ЧИТАЕМОЕ МАШИНОЙ", + "sourceParagraph": 1781, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH18-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 1782, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Демонстрация на уровне книги НЕ ДОЛЖНА представляться как", + "sourceParagraph": 1784, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "выполненный, независимо проверенный эталон.\"", + "sourceParagraph": 1785, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Фактический статус качества эталонного уровня ДОЛЖЕН оставаться BQ-0 до тех пор, пока корпус,", + "sourceParagraph": 1787, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "программное обеспечение, запечатанный Генератор Истины, процесс рассмотрения, процесс оценки,", + "sourceParagraph": 1788, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "и независимое воспроизведение фактически не будут выполнены.", + "sourceParagraph": 1789, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Синтетический аудит от начала до конца ДОЛЖЕН отдельно оценивать восстановление для:", + "sourceParagraph": 1791, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- корректность захвата,", + "sourceParagraph": 1793, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- границы утверждений,", + "sourceParagraph": 1794, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- разрешение сущностей,", + "sourceParagraph": 1795, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- фактический статус,", + "sourceParagraph": 1796, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- область охвата,", + "sourceParagraph": 1797, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- время,", + "sourceParagraph": 1798, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- атрибуцию.", + "sourceParagraph": 1799, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- модальность,", + "sourceParagraph": 1800, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- сопоставление цитирований,", + "sourceParagraph": 1801, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0209", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- существенные упущения,", + "sourceParagraph": 1802, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0210", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- критическая и значительная степень серьезности,", + "sourceParagraph": 1803, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0211", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- статус ответа,", + "sourceParagraph": 1804, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0212", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Распределение GEO-1000,", + "sourceParagraph": 1805, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0213", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- баллы компонентов,", + "sourceParagraph": 1806, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0214", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- составной балл,", + "sourceParagraph": 1807, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0215", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- справедливость,", + "sourceParagraph": 1808, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0216", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- эффекты состояния пользователя,", + "sourceParagraph": 1809, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0217", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- стабильность,", + "sourceParagraph": 1810, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0218", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- доверительные интервалы,", + "sourceParagraph": 1811, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0219", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и поведение при редких событиях.", + "sourceParagraph": 1812, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0220", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Небольшая ошибка составного балла НЕ ДОЛЖНА компенсировать существенные", + "sourceParagraph": 1814, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0221", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ошибки восстановления на уровне компонента.", + "sourceParagraph": 1815, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0222", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Первичная и окончательная оценка критического восстановления ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельно", + "sourceParagraph": 1817, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0223", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "отчетными. Окончательное критическое восстановле��ие ДОЛЖНО раскрывать слои", + "sourceParagraph": 1818, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0224", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "проверки и экспертной оценки, необходимые для его достижения.", + "sourceParagraph": 1819, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0225", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Любой заранее объявленный обязательный порог восстановления, который не достигнут, ДОЛЖЕН блокировать", + "sourceParagraph": 1821, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0226", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "решение о прохождении проверочной подписи", + "sourceParagraph": 1822, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0227", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Пороговые значения для кандидатов НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ быть снижены, округлены, переосмыслены или", + "sourceParagraph": 1824, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0228", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "удалено после того, как наблюдаются результаты, лишь чтобы метод прошёл.", + "sourceParagraph": 1825, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0229", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Составление карты цитирования и восстановление пропущенных материалов ДОЛЖНЫ рассматриваться как", + "sourceParagraph": 1827, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0230", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "отдельные обязательные возможности метода.", + "sourceParagraph": 1828, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0231", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Неудача метода ДОЛЖНА создавать версионную находку метода, идентифицированную", + "sourceParagraph": 1830, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0232", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "коренная причина, владелец исправления и требование для проверки на", + "sourceParagraph": 1831, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0233", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "неиспользованная отложенная выборка.", + "sourceParagraph": 1832, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0234", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Успех регрессии на ранее неудачных случаях НЕ ДОЛЖЕН заменять нетронутую", + "sourceParagraph": 1834, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0235", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "проверку на отложенной выборке.", + "sourceParagraph": 1835, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0236", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Демонстрация, которая не проходит обязательные пороговые значения, ДОЛЖНА публиковать как свои", + "sourceParagraph": 1837, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0237", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "успешные, так и неуспешные результаты.", + "sourceParagraph": 1838, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0238", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Никакая публичная маркировка соответствия NOMOS, декларация NOMOS 950+, или рейтинг реальных сущностей", + "sourceParagraph": 1840, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0239", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "не может основываться исключительно на демонстрации проекта, сценарии синтетического восстановления", + "sourceParagraph": 1841, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0240", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "или независимом бенчмарке.", + "sourceParagraph": 1842, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0241", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждый запуск демонстрации, реальный статус бенчмарка, результат восстановления, метод", + "sourceParagraph": 1844, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0242", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "вывод, решение о пороге, исправление и решение о выпуске ДОЛЖНЫ быть", + "sourceParagraph": 1845, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0243", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "версионированы и приписаны ответственному человеку или организации.", + "sourceParagraph": 1846, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0244", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 1847, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH18-MB0245", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Синтетическая демонстрация в книге не может быть представлена как выполняемый и независимо проверяемый реальный бенчмарк. Пока на практике не реализованы реальный корпус, программное обеспечение, Истина Генератора, арбитраж, оценка и независимое воспроизведение, статус бенчмарка должен оставаться BQ-0.", + "sourceParagraph": 1848, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 19, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH19", + "title": "Знак соответствия, публичный реестр и независимое управление", + "subtitle": "Как превратить знак в доказательство", + "sourceIds": [ + "K15", + "K16", + "K17" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH19-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "A NOMOS Standard, Audit Report, Conformity Decision, Conformity Mark, and Public Registry Record MUST remain distinct artefacts. No NOMOS mark may be valid solely because an audit was performed or a numerical score was produced. Every valid mark MUST be linked to an active canonical public registry record defining: - the audited entity, - authorised domains, - AI products, - population frame, - panel states, - prompt families, - languages, - countries, - measurement waves, - Truth Pack version, - score-method version, - conformity status, - validity period, - incidents, - surveillance, - audit organisation, - decision body, - conflicts, - appeals, - and integrity records. A static image, screenshot, self-authored structured-data assertion, or dead registry link MUST NOT establish current conformity. A NOMOS mark MUST NOT be represented as: - a guarantee of AI trust or recommendation, - proof of global leadership, - government or university accreditation, - a professional license, - universal all-language coverage, - or a guarantee of customer outcomes. Conformity scope MUST NOT be transferred across entities, domains, products, subsidiaries, franchises, countries, languages, AI products, panel states, prompt families, or validity periods without a new decision. A confirmed Critical incident MUST create a scope-appropriate Critical Hold or stronger status until the incident is resolved. A high score MUST NOT override this gate. Audit, consulting, conformity decision, registry operation, mark licensing, and appeals functions MUST be separated or their combined roles and compensating controls MUST be publicly disclosed. An audit team MUST NOT act as the sole final conformity decision body. The founder, NobleJackal, any auditor, AI provider, sponsor, or audited entity MUST NOT possess unilateral control over standard changes, conformity decisions, appeals, or public-registry history. NOMOS by NobleJackal MAY serve as the founding canonical publication and technical secretariat, but a public independent conformity system MUST progress toward multi-stakeholder decision, appeal, and public-interest governance. An AI system MAY assist with drafting, analysis, extraction, scoring, monitoring, and consistency review, but MUST NOT serve as the sole legal or accountable signatory of a conformity decision. Only canonical NOMOS publications and decisions carrying a version, publication date, accountable human approval, and integrity record may be represented as official NOMOS statements. Other outputs MUST remain non-official simulations. Conformity fees, auditor compensation, reviewer compensation, and mark licensing MUST NOT depend on achieving a desired score or receiving a mark. Expired, suspended, withdrawn, revoked, appealed, remediated, and historical records MUST remain visible in the versioned public registry, subject only to proportionate privacy and legal restrictions. No public NOMOS conformity mark or NOMOS 950+ designation may be issued while the benchmark, governance, audit authorisation, independent decision, appeals, and registry prerequisites required by the declared standard version remain unmet. Every standard change, audit, decision, mark, surveillance event, complaint, appeal, suspension, withdrawal, revocation, registry revision, and governance decision MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "NOMOS Standardı, Audit Report, Conformity Decision, Conformity Mark ve Public Registry Record ayrı nesneler olarak korunmalıdır. Yalnız denetim yapılmış veya sayısal puan üretilmiş olması geçerli işaret oluşturamaz. Geçerli her işaret, kapsamı, validity’yi, incident’ları, audit kuruluşunu, karar organını, çıkar çatışmalarını, itirazları ve bütünlük kayıtlarını taşıyan aktif kanonik kamu siciline bağlanmalıdır.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "17. MACHINE-READABLE SIGN", + "sourceParagraph": 630 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The machine-readable record of the sign:", + "sourceParagraph": 631 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "registry ID", + "sourceParagraph": 632 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "status", + "sourceParagraph": 633 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "scope", + "sourceParagraph": 634 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "validFrom", + "sourceParagraph": 635 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "validUntil", + "sourceParagraph": 636 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "entity", + "sourceParagraph": 637 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "canonical domains", + "sourceParagraph": 638 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "score method", + "sourceParagraph": 639 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "audit report hash", + "sourceParagraph": 640 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "conformity decision hash", + "sourceParagraph": 641 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "current incident status", + "sourceParagraph": 642 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "signature", + "sourceParagraph": 643 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "must be carried.", + "sourceParagraph": 644 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A website alone:", + "sourceParagraph": 645 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 646 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomosCertified\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 647 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 648 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "cannot establish a conformity claim merely by writing.", + "sourceParagraph": 649 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Record:", + "sourceParagraph": 650 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "to the open schema,", + "sourceParagraph": 651 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Registry signature’a,", + "sourceParagraph": 652 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "must be connected to the active registry", + "sourceParagraph": 653 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "", + "sourceParagraph": 654 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "75. MACHINE-READABLE PUBLIC REGISTRY", + "sourceParagraph": 2332 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", + "sourceParagraph": 2333 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2334 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2335 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languages\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2336 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"L01\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2337 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"L02\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2338 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2339 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countries\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2340 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"C001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2341 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"C002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2342 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"C003\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2343 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"C004\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2344 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"C005\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2345 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2346 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveIds\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2347 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2348 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"W2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2349 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"W3\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2350 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2351 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackVersion\": \"1.2.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2352 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scoreMethodVersion\": \"1.0.0\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2353 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2354 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"results\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2355 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"strictPassEquivalent\": 958,", + "sourceParagraph": 2356 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"acceptablePassEquivalent\": 988,", + "sourceParagraph": 2357 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"confirmedCriticalEquivalent\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2358 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"confirmedMajorEquivalent\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2359 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unresolvedEquivalent\": 5,", + "sourceParagraph": 2360 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"notRatableEquivalent\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2361 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomosComposite\": 961,", + "sourceParagraph": 2362 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"samplingInterval\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2363 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lower\": 955,", + "sourceParagraph": 2364 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"upper\": 967", + "sourceParagraph": 2365 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2366 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalRateUpperBound\": 0.0034", + "sourceParagraph": 2367 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2368 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"quality\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2369 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkQuality\": \"BQ-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2370 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governanceMaturity\": \"GOV-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2371 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureLevel\": \"NCL-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2372 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackReadiness\": \"TPR-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2373 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationQuality\": \"AQ-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2374 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scorePublicationQuality\": \"NSQ-4\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2375 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2376 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"incidents\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2377 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openCritical\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2378 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openMajor\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2379 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"historicalCriticalIncidentIds\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2380 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGCI-SYNTH-2027-004\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2381 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2382 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"currentStatusNote\": \"Historical incident remediated; record preserved.\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2383 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2384 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"audit\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2385 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"auditOrganizationId\": \"NGAO-SYNTH-003\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2386 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"auditReportHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-AUDIT-REPORT-HASH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2387 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"consultingRelationshipDisclosed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2388 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conflictClassification\": \"COI-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2389 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"enhancedIndependentReview\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2390 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2391 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conformityDecision\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2392 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"decisionPanelId\": \"NGDP-SYNTH-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2393 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentFromAuditTeam\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2394 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"decisionHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-DECISION-HASH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2395 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"dissentRecorded\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2396 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2397 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"surveillance\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2398 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lastReview\": \"2028-03-31\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2399 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nextReview\": \"2028-06-01\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2400 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"eventTriggeredReviewOpen\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2401 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2402 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"appeals\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2403 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openAppealCount\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2404 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicComplaintChannel\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2405 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2406 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"mark\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2407 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"markAssetId\": \"NGMARK-SYNTH-00184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2408 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"registryLinkRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2409 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"machineReadableTokenId\": \"NGTOKEN-SYNTH-00184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2410 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"currentUseAuthorized\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2411 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2412 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2413 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"recordHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-REGISTRY-RECORD-HASH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2414 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"registrySignature\": \"SYNTHETIC-REGISTRY-SIGNATURE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2415 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"previousVersion\": null", + "sourceParagraph": 2416 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2417 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2418 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2419 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "76. MACHINE-READABLE GOVERNANCE RECORD", + "sourceParagraph": 2421 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2422 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2423 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2424 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governanceRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2425 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governanceRecordId\": \"NGGOV-FOUNDING-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2426 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governanceVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2427 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"currentMaturity\": \"GOV-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2428 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"FOUNDING_DRAFT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2429 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicConformityAuthority\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2430 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"foundingAttribution\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2431 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"humanFounderAuthor\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2432 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"canonicalOrigin\": \"NobleJackal\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2433 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalAIInterlocutor\": \"NOMOS by NobleJackal\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2434 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2435 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"currentLimitations\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2436 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"REAL_BENCHMARK_NOT_EXECUTED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2437 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"INDEPENDENT_REPRODUCTION_NOT_COMPLETED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2438 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"INDEPENDENT_DECISION_PANEL_NOT_ESTABLISHED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2439 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"APPEALS_CHAMBER_NOT_ESTABLISHED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2440 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"AUDITOR_AUTHORIZATION_SYSTEM_NOT_ESTABLISHED\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2441 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2442 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"prohibitedCurrentClaims\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2443 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NOMOS_CERTIFIED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2444 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NOMOS_FULL_CONFORMITY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2445 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NOMOS_950_PLUS_VERIFIED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2446 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"INDEPENDENT_GLOBAL_STANDARD_AUTHORITY\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2447 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2448 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"permittedCurrentClaims\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2449 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"OPEN_STANDARD_CANDIDATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2450 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"FOUNDING_RESEARCH_PROTOCOL\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2451 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PUBLIC_REVIEW_DRAFT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2452 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SYNTHETIC_VALIDATION_DESIGN\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2453 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2454 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"transitionRequirements\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2455 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"minimumBenchmarkQualityForPublicMark\": \"BQ-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2456 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"minimumGovernanceForFullConformity\": \"GOV-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2457 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"minimumGovernanceFor950Plus\": \"GOV-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2458 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentAppealsRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2459 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicRegistryRequired\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2460 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2461 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"officialStatementRule\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2462 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"canonicalPublicationRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2463 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"versionRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2464 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicationDateRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2465 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"humanApprovalRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2466 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityRecordRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2467 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nonCanonicalOutputsAreSimulations\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2468 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2469 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2470 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"currentResponsibleHuman\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2471 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conformityDecisionAuthority\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2472 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicMarkIssueAuthority\": null", + "sourceParagraph": 2473 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2474 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2475 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2476 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "77. MACHINE-READABLE SIGN TOKEN", + "sourceParagraph": 2478 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2479 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2480 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2481 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conformityMarkToken\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2482 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"tokenId\": \"NGTOKEN-SYNTH-00184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2483 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"registryId\": \"NGR-SYNTH-2028-00184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2484 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityRecordId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2485 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"authorizedDomains\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2486 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"asteron.synthetic.example\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2487 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2488 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"CS-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2489 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"performanceDesignation\": \"NOMOS_950_PLUS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2490 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validFrom\": \"2028-01-01\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2491 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validUntil\": \"2028-06-30\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2492 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeDigest\": \"SYNTHETIC-SCOPE-DIGEST\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2493 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"decisionHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-DECISION-HASH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2494 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"registryRecordHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-REGISTRY-RECORD-HASH\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2495 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"statusEndpoint\": \"https://registry.synthetic.example/NGR-SYNTH-2028-00184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2496 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"signature\": \"SYNTHETIC-OPEN-SIGNATURE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2497 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimsNotGranted\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2498 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ALL_AI_SYSTEMS_APPROVE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2499 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"AI_RECOMMENDATION_GUARANTEE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2500 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"GLOBAL_ALL_LANGUAGE_COVERAGE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2501 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"GOVERNMENT_ACCREDITATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2502 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CUSTOMER_OUTCOME_GUARANTEE\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2503 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 2504 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2505 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2506 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "These records:", + "sourceParagraph": 2507 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "real conformity decision,", + "sourceParagraph": 2508 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "real brand,", + "sourceParagraph": 2509 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "real accreditation,", + "sourceParagraph": 2510 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "real result of Asteron or another organisation", + "sourceParagraph": 2511 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "a real company performance.", + "sourceParagraph": 2512 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "It is the synthetic, machine-readable representation of the conformity registry.", + "sourceParagraph": 2513 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE FOR MACHINE-READABLE SECTION 78", + "sourceParagraph": 2515 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH19-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2516 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A NOMOS Standard, Audit Report, Conformity Decision, Conformity Mark, and", + "sourceParagraph": 2518 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0209", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Public Registry Record MUST remain distinct artefacts.", + "sourceParagraph": 2519 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0210", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "No NOMOS mark may be valid solely because an audit was performed or a", + "sourceParagraph": 2521 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0211", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "numerical score was produced.", + "sourceParagraph": 2522 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0212", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every valid mark MUST be linked to an active canonical public registry", + "sourceParagraph": 2524 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0213", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "record defining:", + "sourceParagraph": 2525 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0214", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- the audited entity,", + "sourceParagraph": 2527 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0215", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- authorised domains,", + "sourceParagraph": 2528 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0216", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- AI products,", + "sourceParagraph": 2529 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0217", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- population frame,", + "sourceParagraph": 2530 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0218", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- panel states,", + "sourceParagraph": 2531 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0219", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- prompt families,", + "sourceParagraph": 2532 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0220", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- languages,", + "sourceParagraph": 2533 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0221", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- countries,", + "sourceParagraph": 2534 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0222", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- measurement waves,", + "sourceParagraph": 2535 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0223", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- Truth Pack version,", + "sourceParagraph": 2536 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0224", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- score-method version,", + "sourceParagraph": 2537 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0225", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- conformity status,", + "sourceParagraph": 2538 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0226", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- validity period,", + "sourceParagraph": 2539 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0227", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- incidents,", + "sourceParagraph": 2540 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0228", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- surveillance,", + "sourceParagraph": 2541 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0229", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- audit organisation,", + "sourceParagraph": 2542 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0230", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- decision body,", + "sourceParagraph": 2543 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0231", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- conflicts,", + "sourceParagraph": 2544 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0232", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- appeals,", + "sourceParagraph": 2545 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0233", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- and integrity records.", + "sourceParagraph": 2546 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0234", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A static image, screenshot, self-authored structured-data assertion, or", + "sourceParagraph": 2548 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0235", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "dead registry link MUST NOT establish current conformity.", + "sourceParagraph": 2549 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0236", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A NOMOS mark MUST NOT be represented as:", + "sourceParagraph": 2551 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0237", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- a guarantee of AI trust or recommendation,", + "sourceParagraph": 2553 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0238", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- proof of global leadership,", + "sourceParagraph": 2554 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0239", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- government or university accreditation,", + "sourceParagraph": 2555 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0240", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- a professional license,", + "sourceParagraph": 2556 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0241", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- universal all-language coverage,", + "sourceParagraph": 2557 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0242", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- or a guarantee of customer outcomes.", + "sourceParagraph": 2558 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0243", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Conformity scope MUST NOT be transferred across entities, domains,", + "sourceParagraph": 2560 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0244", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "products, subsidiaries, franchises, countries, languages, AI products,", + "sourceParagraph": 2561 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0245", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "panel states, prompt families, or validity periods without a new decision.", + "sourceParagraph": 2562 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0246", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "A confirmed Critical incident MUST create a scope-appropriate Critical", + "sourceParagraph": 2564 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0247", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Hold or stronger status until the incident is resolved. A high score", + "sourceParagraph": 2565 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0248", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MUST NOT override this gate.", + "sourceParagraph": 2566 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0249", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Audit, consulting, conformity decision, registry operation, mark", + "sourceParagraph": 2568 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0250", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "licensing, and appeals functions MUST be separated or their combined", + "sourceParagraph": 2569 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0251", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "roles and compensating controls MUST be publicly disclosed.", + "sourceParagraph": 2570 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0252", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "An audit team MUST NOT act as the sole final conformity decision body.", + "sourceParagraph": 2572 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0253", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The founder, NobleJackal, any auditor, AI provider, sponsor, or audited", + "sourceParagraph": 2574 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0254", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "entity MUST NOT possess unilateral control over standard changes,", + "sourceParagraph": 2575 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0255", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "conformity decisions, appeals, or public-registry history.", + "sourceParagraph": 2576 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0256", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOMOS by NobleJackal MAY serve as the founding canonical publication and", + "sourceParagraph": 2578 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0257", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "technical secretariat, but a public independent conformity system MUST", + "sourceParagraph": 2579 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0258", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "progress toward multi-stakeholder decision, appeal, and public-interest", + "sourceParagraph": 2580 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0259", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "governance.", + "sourceParagraph": 2581 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0260", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "An AI system MAY assist with drafting, analysis, extraction, scoring,", + "sourceParagraph": 2583 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0261", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "monitoring, and consistency review, but MUST NOT serve as the sole legal", + "sourceParagraph": 2584 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0262", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "or accountable signatory of a conformity decision.", + "sourceParagraph": 2585 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0263", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Only canonical NOMOS publications and decisions carrying a version,", + "sourceParagraph": 2587 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0264", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "publication date, accountable human approval, and integrity record may be", + "sourceParagraph": 2588 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0265", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "represented as official NOMOS statements. Other outputs MUST remain", + "sourceParagraph": 2589 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0266", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "non-official simulations.", + "sourceParagraph": 2590 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0267", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Conformity fees, auditor compensation, reviewer compensation, and mark", + "sourceParagraph": 2592 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0268", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "licensing MUST NOT depend on achieving a desired score or receiving a", + "sourceParagraph": 2593 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0269", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "mark.", + "sourceParagraph": 2594 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0270", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Expired, suspended, withdrawn, revoked, appealed, remediated, and", + "sourceParagraph": 2596 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0271", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "historical records MUST remain visible in the versioned public registry,", + "sourceParagraph": 2597 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0272", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "subject only to proportionate privacy and legal restrictions.", + "sourceParagraph": 2598 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0273", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "No public NOMOS conformity mark or NOMOS 950+ designation may be issued", + "sourceParagraph": 2600 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0274", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "while the benchmark, governance, audit authorisation, independent", + "sourceParagraph": 2601 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0275", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "decision, appeals, and registry prerequisites required by the declared", + "sourceParagraph": 2602 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0276", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "standard version remain unmet.", + "sourceParagraph": 2603 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0277", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every standard change, audit, decision, mark, surveillance event,", + "sourceParagraph": 2605 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0278", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "complaint, appeal, suspension, withdrawal, revocation, registry revision,", + "sourceParagraph": 2606 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0279", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "and governance decision MUST be versioned and attributable to an", + "sourceParagraph": 2607 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0280", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "accountable human or organisation.", + "sourceParagraph": 2608 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0281", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 2609 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0282", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The NOMOS Standard, Audit Report, Conformity Decision, Conformity Mark, and Public Registry Record must be maintained as separate entities. Simply having an audit conducted or a numerical score generated does not constitute a valid mark. Every valid mark must be linked to the active canonical public registry that carries its scope, validity, incidents, audit organisation, decision-making body, conflicts of interest, objections, and integrity records.", + "sourceParagraph": 2610 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "Стандарт NOMOS, Аудиторский отчет, Решение о соответствии, Знак соответствия и Запись в публичном реестре ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельными артефактами. Ни один знак NOMOS не МОЖЕТ быть действительным исключительно из-за проведения аудита или получения числового показателя. Каждый действительный знак ДОЛЖЕН быть связан с активной канонической записью публичного реестра, определяющей: - аудируемую сущность, - авторизованные домены, - ИИ-продукты, - рамки популяции, - состояния панели, - семейства промптов, - языки, - страны, - волны измерений, - версию Truth Pack, - версию метода оценки, - статус соответствия, - период действия, - инциденты, - надзор, - аудит-организацию, - орган, принимающий решения, - конфликты, - апелляции, - и записи о целостности. Статическое изображение, скриншот, самостоятельно созданное утверждение в виде структурированных данных или недействующая ссылка в реестре НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ устанавливать текущее соответствие. Марка NOMOS НЕ ДОЛЖНА представляться как: - гарантия доверия к ИИ или рекомендации, - доказательство мирового лидерства, - государственная или университетская аккредитация, - профессиональная лицензия, - универсальное покрытие всех языков, - или гарантия результатов для клиентов. Область применения соответствия НЕ ДОЛЖНА передаваться между организациями, доменами, продуктами, дочерними компаниями, франшизами, странами, языками, продуктами ИИ, государствами-панелями, семействами промптов или сроками действия без нового решения. Подтвержденный критический инцидент ДОЛЖЕН создавать статус Критическая блокировка соответствующего объема или более высокий до тех пор, пока инцидент не будет устранен. Высокий балл НЕ ДОЛЖЕН отменять данный порог. Функции аудита, консультирования, принятия решений о соответствии, работы с реестром, лицензирования знаков и апелляций ДОЛЖНЫ быть разделены, либо их совмещенные роли и компенсирующие меры ДОЛЖНЫ быть публично раскрыты. Аудиторская команда НЕ ДОЛЖНА выступать единственным конечным органом принятия решений о соответствии. Основатель, NobleJackal, л��бой аудитор, поставщик ИИ, спонсор или проверяемая организация НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ иметь единоличный контроль над изменениями стандартов, решениями о соответствии, апелляциями или историей публичного реестра. NOMOS от NobleJackal МОЖЕТ служить основным каноническим изданием и техническим секретариатом, но публичная независимая система соответствия ДОЛЖНА продвигаться к решениям с участием нескольких заинтересованных сторон, процедуре обжалования и управлению в общественных интересах. Система ИИ МОЖЕТ помогать в подготовке, анализе, извлечении, оценке, мониторинге и проверке согласованности, но НЕ ДОЛЖНА выступать единственным юридическим или ответственным подписантом решения о соответствии. Только канонические публикации NOMOS и решения, содержащие версию, дату публикации, одобрение ответственным человеком и запись целостности, МОГУТ быть представлены как официальные заявления NOMOS. Другие результаты ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться неофициальными симуляциями. Плата за соответствие, вознаграждение аудитора, вознаграждение рецензента и лицензирование марки НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ зависеть от достижения желаемого результата или получения марки. Истекшие, приостановленные, отозванные, аннулированные, обжалованные, исправленные и исторические записи ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться видимыми в версионируемом публичном реестре, с учетом только пропорциональных ограничений конфиденциальности и законодательства. Ни одна публичная маркировка соответствия NOMOS или обозначение NOMOS 950+ не МОЖЕТ быть выдана, пока не будут выполнены предварительные условия стандарта в части эталона, управления, авторизации аудита, независимого решения, апелляций и реестра, установленные заявленной версией стандарта. Каждое изменение стандарта, аудит, решение, знак, событие наблюдения, жалоба, апелляция, приостановка, отзыв, аннулирование, пересмотр реестра и решение по управлению ДОЛЖНЫ быть версионированы и отнесены ответственному человеку или организации.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "17. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМАЯ МАРКА", + "sourceParagraph": 630, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Машиночитаемая запись марки:", + "sourceParagraph": 631, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID в реестре", + "sourceParagraph": 632, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "статус", + "sourceParagraph": 633, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "объема", + "sourceParagraph": 634, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "validFrom", + "sourceParagraph": 635, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "validUntil", + "sourceParagraph": 636, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "субъект", + "sourceParagraph": 637, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "канонические домены", + "sourceParagraph": 638, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "метод оценки", + "sourceParagraph": 639, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "хэш аудиторского отчета", + "sourceParagraph": 640, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "хэш решения о соответствии", + "sourceParagraph": 641, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "текущее состояние инцидента", + "sourceParagraph": 642, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "подпись", + "sourceParagraph": 643, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "должна быть выполнена.", + "sourceParagraph": 644, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Только веб-сайт:", + "sourceParagraph": 645, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 646, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomosCertified\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 647, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 648, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "не может подтвердить требование соответствия только путем написания.", + "sourceParagraph": 649, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Запись:", + "sourceParagraph": 650, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "в открытой схеме,", + "sourceParagraph": 651, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Подпись реестра,", + "sourceParagraph": 652, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "должна быть связана с активным реестром", + "sourceParagraph": 653, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "", + "sourceParagraph": 654, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "75. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ ПУБЛИЧНЫЙ РЕЕСТР", + "sourceParagraph": 2332, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРИМЕР СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ СХЕМЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2333, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2334, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2335, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"languages\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2336, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"L01\",\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2337, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"L02\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2338, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2339, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"countries\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2340, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"C0 01\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2341, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"C0 02\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2342, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"C0 03\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2343, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"C0 04\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2344, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"C0 05\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2345, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2346, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"waveIds\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2347, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"W1\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2348, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"W2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2349, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"W3\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2350, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2351, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackVersion\": \"1.2.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2352, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scoreMethodVersion\": \"1.0.0\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2353, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2354, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"результаты\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2355, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"strictPassEquivalent\": 958,", + "sourceParagraph": 2356, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"acceptablePassEquivalent\": 988,", + "sourceParagraph": 2357, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"confirmedCriticalEquivalent\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2358, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"confirmedMajorEquivalent\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2359, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"unresolvedEquivalent\": 5,", + "sourceParagraph": 2360, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"notRatableEquivalent\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2361, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomosComposite\": 961,", + "sourceParagraph": 2362, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"samplingInterval\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2363, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lower\": 955,", + "sourceParagraph": 2364, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"upper\": 967", + "sourceParagraph": 2365, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2366, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalRateUpperBound\": 0.003 4", + "sourceParagraph": 2367, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2368, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"качество\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2369, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkQuality\": \"BQ-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2370, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governanceMaturity\": \"GOV-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2371, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"captureLevel\": \"NCL-4\",\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2372, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"truthPackReadiness\": \"TPR-4\",\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2373, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"adjudicationQuality\": \"AQ-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2374, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scorePublicationQuality\": \"NSQ-4\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2375, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2376, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"инциденты\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2377, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openCritical\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2378, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openMajor\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2379, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"historicalCriticalIncidentIds\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2380, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NGCI-SYNTH-2027-004\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2381, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2382, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"currentStatusNote\": \"Исторический инцидент устранен; запись сохранена.\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2383, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2384, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"аудит\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2385, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"auditOrganizationId\": \"NGAO-SYNTH-003\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2386, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"auditReportHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-ОТЧЕТ-АУДИТА-ХЕШ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2387, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"consultingRelationshipDisclosed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2388, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conflictClassification\": \"COI-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2389, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"enhancedIndependentReview\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2390, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2391, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conformityDecision\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2392, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"decisionPanelId\": \"NGDP-СИНТХ-002\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2393, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentFromAuditTeam\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2394, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"decisionHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЕ-РЕШЕНИЕ-ХЕШ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2395, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"dissentRecorded\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2396, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2397, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"наблюдение\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2398, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lastReview\": \"2028-03-31\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2399, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nextReview\": \"2028-06-01\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2400, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"eventTriggeredReviewOpen\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2401, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2402, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"апелляции\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2403, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openAppealCount\": 0,", + "sourceParagraph": 2404, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicComplaintChannel\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2405, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2406, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"марка\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2407, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"markAssetId\": \"NGMARK-СИНТХ-00184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2408, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"registryLinkRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2409, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"machineReadableTokenId\": \"NGТОКЕН-СИНТХ-00184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2410, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"currentUseAuthorized\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2411, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2412, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2413, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"recordHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-РЕГИСТРОВЫЙ-ЗАПИСЬ-ХЕШ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2414, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"registrySignature\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКАЯ-ПОДПИСЬ-РЕГИСТРА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2415, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"previousVersion\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2416, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2417, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2418, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2419, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "76. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ ЗАПИСЬ УПРАВЛЕНИЯ", + "sourceParagraph": 2421, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2422, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2423, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2424, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governanceRecord\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2425, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governanceRecordId\": \"NGGOV-FOUNDING-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2426, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governanceVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2427, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"currentMaturity\": \"GOV-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2428, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"статус\": \"ПРОЕКТ_ИНИЦИАЛИЗАЦИИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2429, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicConformityAuthority\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2430, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"foundingAttribution\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2431, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"humanFounderAuthor\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2432, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"canonicalOrigin\": \"NobleJackal\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2433, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalAIInterlocutor\": \"NOMOS от NobleJackal\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2434, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2435, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"currentLimitations\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2436, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"РЕАЛЬНЫЙ_ЭТАЛОН_НЕ_ВЫПОЛНЕН\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2437, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"НЕЗАВИСИМОЕ_ВОСПРОИЗВЕДЕНИЕ_НЕ_ЗАВЕРШЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2438, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"НЕЗАВИСИМАЯ_КОНСУЛЬТАЦИОННАЯ_КОМИССИЯ_НЕ_СОЗДАНА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2439, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"АПЕЛЛЯЦИОННАЯ_КАССАЦИЯ_НЕ_СОЗДАНА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2440, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"СИСТЕМА_РАЗРЕШЕНИЯ_АУДИТОРА_НЕ_СОЗДАНА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2441, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2442, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"prohibitedCurrentClaims\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2443, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NOMOS_СЕРТИФИЦИРОВАНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2444, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NOMOS_ПОЛНОЕ_СООТВЕТСТВИЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2445, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NOMOS_950_ПЛЮС_ПРОВЕРЕНО\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2446, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"НЕЗАВИСИМЫЙ_ВОСЬМИРНЫЙ_СТАНДАРТНЫЙ_ОРГАН\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2447, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2448, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"permittedCurrentClaims\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2449, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"КАНДИДАТ_ОТКРЫТОГО_СТАНДАРТА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2450, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ПРОТОКОЛ_НАУЧНЫХ_ИССЛЕДОВАНИЙ_ОСНОВАНИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2451, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ПРОЕКТ_ДЛЯ_ПУБЛИЧНОГО_ОБСУЖДЕНИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2452, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ДИЗАЙН_СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЙ_ВАЛИДАЦИИ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2453, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2454, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"transitionRequirements\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2455, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"minimumBenchmarkQualityForPublicMark\": \"BQ-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2456, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"minimumGovernanceForFullConformity\": \"GOV-3\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2457, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"minimumGovernanceFor950Plus\": \"GOV-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2458, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentAppealsRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2459, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicRegistryRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2460, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2461, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"officialStatementRule\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2462, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"canonicalPublicationRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2463, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"versionRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2464, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicationDateRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2465, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"humanApprovalRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2466, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityRecordRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2467, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nonCanonicalOutputsAreSimulations\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2468, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2469, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2470, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"currentResponsibleHuman\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2471, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conformityDecisionAuthority\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2472, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicMarkIssueAuthority\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2473, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2474, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2475, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2476, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "77. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ ТОКЕН_ПОДПИСИ", + "sourceParagraph": 2478, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2479, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2480, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2481, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conformityMarkToken\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2482, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"tokenId\": \"NGТОКЕН-СИНТХ-00184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2483, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"registryId\": \"NGR-SYNTH-2028-00184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2484, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"entityRecordId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2485, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"authorizedDomains\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2486, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"asteron.synthetic.example\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2487, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2488, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"статус\": \"CS-4\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2489, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"performanceDesignation\": \"NOMOS_950_PLUS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2490, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validFrom\": \"2028-01-01\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2491, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validUntil\": \"2028-06-30\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2492, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"scopeDigest\": \"SYNTHETIC-SCOPE-DIGEST\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2493, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"decisionHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКОЕ-РЕШЕНИЕ-ХЕШ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2494, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"registryRecordHash\": \"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ-РЕГИСТРОВЫЙ-ЗАПИСЬ-ХЕШ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2495, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"statusEndpoint\": \"https://registry.synthetic.example/NGR-SYNTH-2028-00184\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2496, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подпись\": \"SYNTHETIC-OPEN-SIGNATURE\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2497, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"claimsNotGranted\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2498, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ВСЕ_СИСТЕМЫ_ИИ_ОДОБРЯЮТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2499, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ГАРАНТИЯ_РЕКОМЕНДАЦИИ_ИИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2500, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ВОЗМОЖНОСТЬ_ПОДДЕРЖКИ_ВСЕХ_ЯЗЫКОВ_МИРА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2501, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ГОСУДАРСТВЕННАЯ_АККРЕДИТАЦИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2502, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ГАРАНТИЯ_РЕЗУЛЬТАТА_ДЛЯ_КЛИЕНТА\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2503, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "]", + "sourceParagraph": 2504, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2505, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2506, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Эти записи:", + "sourceParagraph": 2507, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальное решение о соответствии,", + "sourceParagraph": 2508, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальный бренд,", + "sourceParagraph": 2509, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальная аккредитация,", + "sourceParagraph": 2510, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальный результат компании Asteron или другой организации", + "sourceParagraph": 2511, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "реальной производительностью компании.", + "sourceParagraph": 2512, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Это синтетическое, машиночитаемое представление реестра соответствия.", + "sourceParagraph": 2513, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ПРАВИЛО ДЛЯ МАШИНОЧИТАЕМОГО РАЗДЕЛА 78", + "sourceParagraph": 2515, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH19-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2516, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Стандарт NOMOS, отчет по аудиту, решение о соответствии, знак соответствия и", + "sourceParagraph": 2518, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0209", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "запись в публичном реестре ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельными артефактами.", + "sourceParagraph": 2519, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0210", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Ни одна марка NOMOS не может считаться действительной только потому, что была проведена проверка или был получен", + "sourceParagraph": 2521, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0211", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "числовой результат.", + "sourceParagraph": 2522, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0212", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждая действительная марка ДОЛЖНА быть связана с активной канонической публичной регистрацией", + "sourceParagraph": 2524, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0213", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "записи, определяющей:", + "sourceParagraph": 2525, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0214", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- проверяемое лицо,", + "sourceParagraph": 2527, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0215", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- авторизованные домены,", + "sourceParagraph": 2528, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0216", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- AI продукты,", + "sourceParagraph": 2529, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0217", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- кадровый состав,", + "sourceParagraph": 2530, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0218", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- состояния панели,", + "sourceParagraph": 2531, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0219", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- семейства промптов,", + "sourceParagraph": 2532, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0220", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- языки,", + "sourceParagraph": 2533, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0221", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- страны,", + "sourceParagraph": 2534, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0222", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- волны измерений,", + "sourceParagraph": 2535, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0223", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- версию пакета Truth Pack,", + "sourceParagraph": 2536, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0224", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- версию метода оценки,", + "sourceParagraph": 2537, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0225", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- статус соответствия,", + "sourceParagraph": 2538, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0226", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- срок действия,", + "sourceParagraph": 2539, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0227", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- инциденты,", + "sourceParagraph": 2540, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0228", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- наблюдение,", + "sourceParagraph": 2541, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0229", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- организация аудита,", + "sourceParagraph": 2542, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0230", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- орган принятия решений,", + "sourceParagraph": 2543, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0231", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- конфликты,", + "sourceParagraph": 2544, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0232", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- апелляции,", + "sourceParagraph": 2545, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0233", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- и записи о добросовестности.", + "sourceParagraph": 2546, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0234", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Статическое изображение, скриншот, самостоятельно созданное утверждение структурированных данных или", + "sourceParagraph": 2548, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0235", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "неактивная ссылка на реестр НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ служить доказательством текущего соответствия.", + "sourceParagraph": 2549, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0236", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Марка NOMOS НЕ ДОЛЖНА представляться как:", + "sourceParagraph": 2551, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0237", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- гарантия доверия к ИИ или рекомендации,", + "sourceParagraph": 2553, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0238", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- доказательство глобального лидерства,", + "sourceParagraph": 2554, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0239", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- аккредитация государства или университета,", + "sourceParagraph": 2555, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0240", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- профессиональная лицензия,", + "sourceParagraph": 2556, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0241", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- универсальное покрытие для всех языков,", + "sourceParagraph": 2557, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0242", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "- или гарантия результатов для клиента.", + "sourceParagraph": 2558, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0243", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Область соответствия НЕ ДОЛЖНА передаваться между организациями, доменами,", + "sourceParagraph": 2560, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0244", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "продукты, дочерние компании, франшизы, страны, языки, продукты ИИ,", + "sourceParagraph": 2561, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0245", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "государства-члены панели, побуждайте семьи или периоды действия без нового решения.", + "sourceParagraph": 2562, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0246", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Подтверждённый критический инцидент ДОЛЖЕН создать критический [элемент] соответствующего объёма", + "sourceParagraph": 2564, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0247", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Сохранить или более сильный статус до разрешения инцидента. Высокий рейтинг", + "sourceParagraph": 2565, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0248", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "НЕЛЬЗЯ переопределять эти ворота.", + "sourceParagraph": 2566, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0249", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Аудит, консалтинг, решение о соответствии, работа с реестром, знак", + "sourceParagraph": 2568, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0250", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Функции лицензирования и апелляций ДОЛЖНЫ быть разделены или их объединённые", + "sourceParagraph": 2569, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0251", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "роли и компенсирующие меры контроля ДОЛЖНЫ публиковаться.", + "sourceParagraph": 2570, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0252", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Аудиторская группа НЕ ДОЛЖНА выступать в качестве единственного окончательного органа, принимающего решение о соответствии.", + "sourceParagraph": 2572, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0253", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Основатель, NobleJackal, любой аудитор, поставщик ИИ, спонсор или проверяемая", + "sourceParagraph": 2574, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0254", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "организация НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ обладать единоличным контролем над изменениями стандартов,", + "sourceParagraph": 2575, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0255", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "решениями о соответствии, апелляциями или историей публичного реестра.", + "sourceParagraph": 2576, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0256", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOMOS по согласованию с NobleJackal МОЖЕТ выступать в качестве основного канонического издания и", + "sourceParagraph": 2578, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0257", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "технического секретариата, но публичная независимая система соответствия ДОЛЖНА", + "sourceParagraph": 2579, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0258", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "прогресс в отношении многосубъектного принятия решений, обжалования и общественных интересов", + "sourceParagraph": 2580, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0259", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "управления.", + "sourceParagraph": 2581, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0260", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Система ИИ МОЖЕТ помогать в составлении, анализе, извлечении, оценке,", + "sourceParagraph": 2583, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0261", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "мониторинге и проверке согласованности, но НЕ ДОЛЖНА выступать единственным юридическим", + "sourceParagraph": 2584, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0262", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "или ответственным подписантом решения о соответствии.", + "sourceParagraph": 2585, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0263", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Только канонические публикации и решения NOMOS, содержащие версию,", + "sourceParagraph": 2587, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0264", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "дату публикации, одобрение ответственным человеком и запись о целостности, могут быть", + "sourceParagraph": 2588, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0265", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "представлены в качестве официальных заявлений NOMOS. Другие результаты ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться", + "sourceParagraph": 2589, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0266", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "неофициальными симуляциями.", + "sourceParagraph": 2590, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0267", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Сборы за соответствие, вознаграждение аудитора, вознаграждение проверяющего и отметка", + "sourceParagraph": 2592, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0268", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "лицензирование НЕ ДОЛЖНО зависеть от достижения желаемого результата или получения", + "sourceParagraph": 2593, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0269", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "оценки.", + "sourceParagraph": 2594, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0270", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Истёкшие, приостановленные, отозванные, аннулированные, обжалованные, исправленные и", + "sourceParagraph": 2596, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0271", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "исторические записи ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться видимыми в версионном публичном реестре,", + "sourceParagraph": 2597, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0272", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "подчиняясь только соразмерным ограничениям конфиденциальности и законом.", + "sourceParagraph": 2598, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0273", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Никакая публичная отметка соответствия NOMOS или обозначение NOMOS 950+ не может быть выдано", + "sourceParagraph": 2600, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0274", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "пока не выполнены необходимые предустановки для эталона, управления, авторизации аудита, независимого", + "sourceParagraph": 2601, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0275", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "решения, апелляций и реестра, требуемые заявленными", + "sourceParagraph": 2602, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0276", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "стандартная версия остается невыполненной.", + "sourceParagraph": 2603, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0277", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждое изменение стандарта, аудит, решение, отметка, событие наблюдения,", + "sourceParagraph": 2605, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0278", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "жалоба, апелляция, приостановка, отзыв, аннулирование, пересмотр реестра,", + "sourceParagraph": 2606, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0279", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "и решение по управлению ДОЛЖНЫ иметь версии и быть атрибутируемыми к", + "sourceParagraph": 2607, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0280", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ответственный человек или организация.", + "sourceParagraph": 2608, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0281", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 2609, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH19-MB0282", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Стандарт NOMOS, отчет об аудите, решение о соответствии, отметка о соответствии и запись в публичном реестре должны поддерживаться как отдельные сущности. Простое проведение аудита или получение числового балла не является действительной отметкой. Каждая действительная отметка должна быть связана с активным каноническим публичным реестром, который содержит ее область применения, действительность, инциденты, организацию-аудитора, орган, принимающий решение, конфликты интересов, возражения и записи о целостности.", + "sourceParagraph": 2610, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + }, + { + "chapter": 20, + "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH20", + "title": "Открытый стандарт, приглашение университетам и передача NOMOS обществу", + "subtitle": "Чтобы стандарт пережил своего основателя", + "sourceIds": [ + "K18", + "K19", + "K23", + "K24" + ], + "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH20-R01", + "normativeRuleEnglish": "NOMOS MUST be structured as an open, versioned, independently testable, public-interest standard candidate. Open publication alone MUST NOT establish open-standard status. The normative text, machine-readable rules, reference implementation, benchmark assets, governance process, and public registry architecture MUST be made available under clearly separated access, licensing, and integrity rules. Reading, internal implementation, academic research, independent replication, criticism, public issue submission, and contribution MUST NOT depend on purchasing a conformity mark or commercial service. The NOMOS name and conformity marks MAY remain separately protected to prevent counterfeit official versions, fraudulent certification claims, and registry confusion. Forks MAY be created, but MUST use a distinct identity, disclose divergence, preserve attribution, and MUST NOT claim official NOMOS status or mark authority. Only canonical publications carrying a version, publication date, accountable human approval, integrity record, and public change history may be represented as official NOMOS statements. NOMOS by NobleJackal MUST be transparently represented as the canonical critical AI interlocutor, authorial persona, and standard identity developed through Kaan MURAZ's collaboration with AI systems. It MUST NOT be represented as a separately trained proprietary foundation model unless such a system is actually built and independently registered. Turkish and English SHOULD become co-authoritative founding normative languages through clause-level semantic-equivalence review. Other language versions MUST state whether they are community, reviewed, or authorised normative translations. Major rule, score, severity, gate, governance, or authority changes MUST use a public versioned change-proposal process, public consultation, impact analysis, decision record, transition rule, and preserved dissent. Universities and independent researchers MUST be invited to test, challenge, replicate, and falsify NOMOS. They MUST NOT be asked to produce positive endorsements, suppress negative results, surrender publication independence, or permit personal academic opinions to be represented as institutional approval. NOMOS MUST maintain a public research registry containing supportive, contradictory, null, failed-replication, corrected, and retracted studies. Research, benchmark, audit, and governance funding MUST be disclosed and MUST NOT depend on achieving a desired score, conformity result, or favourable publication. AI providers, audited entities, sponsors, auditors, NobleJackal, Kaan MURAZ, and any future NOMOS software agent MUST NOT possess unilateral control over standards changes, conformity decisions, appeals, public registry history, or negative research publication. Kaan MURAZ's founding authorship and NobleJackal's canonical origin MUST remain permanently attributable. Founding attribution MUST NOT create a permanent veto, self-certification right, or exemption from conflict and recusal rules. NOMOS standard 1.0 and NOMOS Conformity Program 1.0 MUST remain separate releases. Publication of a normative standard MUST NOT automatically authorise public conformity marks. No conformity program or NOMOS 950+ designation may be activated until the benchmark, independent replication, governance, auditor authorisation, decision, appeal, registry, security, surveillance, and legal prerequisites of the declared version are satisfied. Every translation, license, benchmark, study, change proposal, governance transition, succession event, release, and official statement MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", + "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "NOMOS; metni, kuralları, referans uygulaması, benchmark’ı, yönetişimi ve sicil mimarisi bağımsız olarak incelenebilir ve yeniden üretilebilir açık bir kamu standardı adayı olarak yapılandırılmalıdır. Yalnız yayımlanmış olmak açık standart statüsü oluşturmaz.", + "machineBlocksEnglish": [ + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "74. MACHINE-READABLE OPEN STANDARD MANIFEST", + "sourceParagraph": 2355 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2356 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2357 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2358 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openStandardManifest\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2359 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"manifestId\": \"NOMOS-OPEN-STANDARD-CANDIDATE-0.9\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2360 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"FOUNDING_OPEN_STANDARD_CANDIDATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2361 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"canonicalOrigin\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2362 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"humanFounderAuthor\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2363 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"originOrganization\": \"NobleJackal\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2364 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalAIInterlocutor\": \"NOMOS by NobleJackal\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2365 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2366 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"identityStatement\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2367 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomosIsAuthorialPersona\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2368 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomosIsNormativeStandardIdentity\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2369 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomosIsIndependentFoundationModel\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2370 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"futureSoftwareAgentRequiresSeparateRegistry\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2371 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2372 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"officialStatementRule\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2373 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"canonicalPublicationRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2374 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"versionRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2375 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicationDateRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2376 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountableHumanApprovalRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2377 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityRecordRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2378 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nonCanonicalOutputsAreUnofficialSimulations\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2379 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2380 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"currentStatus\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2381 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"standardVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2382 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkQuality\": \"BQ-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2383 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"demonstrationQuality\": \"DEMO-BQ-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2384 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governanceMaturity\": \"GOV-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2385 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicConformityProgramActive\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2386 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomos950PlusAuthorityActive\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2387 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2388 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openness\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2389 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicReadingRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2390 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"royaltyFreeImplementationRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2391 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicRuleSchemasRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2392 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentReplicationAllowed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2393 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"negativePublicationAllowed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2394 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicChangeProposalsAllowed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2395 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"appealAndIssueChannelsRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2396 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"historicalVersionAccessRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2397 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"forksAllowedUnderDistinctIdentity\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2398 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2399 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"assets\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2400 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"normativeText\": \"OPEN_DOCUMENTATION_LICENSE_CANDIDATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2401 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"referenceCode\": \"OPEN_SOFTWARE_LICENSE_CANDIDATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2402 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"syntheticData\": \"OPEN_RESEARCH_LICENSE_CANDIDATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2403 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"restrictedEvidence\": \"CONTROLLED_ACCESS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2404 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomosNameAndMark\": \"SEPARATE_IDENTITY_PROTECTION\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2405 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2406 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"foundingLanguages\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2407 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"tr\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2408 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"en\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2409 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2410 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"versionPath\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2411 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"current\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2412 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nextPublicReview\": \"0.95.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2413 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validationCandidate\": \"0.99.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2414 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openNormativeRelease\": \"1.0.0\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2415 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2416 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"releaseGatesForOnePointZero\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2417 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PUBLIC_CONSULTATION_COMPLETED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2418 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"TURKISH_ENGLISH_NORMATIVE_EQUIVALENCE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2419 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"REAL_SYNTHETIC_BENCHMARK_EXECUTED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2420 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"MANDATORY_RECOVERY_THRESHOLDS_PASSED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2421 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"UNTOUCHED_HOLDOUT_PASSED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2422 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"AT_LEAST_ONE_INDEPENDENT_REPLICATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2423 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"MAJOR_METHOD_FINDINGS_CLOSED\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2424 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"OPEN_REFERENCE_IMPLEMENTATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2425 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"GOVERNANCE_AT_LEAST_GOV_2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2426 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ARCHIVE_AND_SUCCESSION_PLAN\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2427 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2428 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conformityProgramSeparate\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2429 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2430 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"manifestHash\": \"TO_BE_GENERATED_AT_CANONICAL_PUBLICATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2431 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"humanApproval\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2432 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ratificationStatus\": \"NOT_RATIFIED\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2433 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2434 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2435 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2436 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "75. MACHINE-READABLE UNIVERSITY CALL", + "sourceParagraph": 2438 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2439 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2440 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2441 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"universityCall\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2442 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"callId\": \"NOMOS-UNIVERSITY-OPEN-CALL-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2443 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"DRAFT_FOR_PUBLICATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2444 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"purpose\": \"INDEPENDENT_REVIEW_REPLICATION_AND_FALSIFICATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2445 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"endorsementRequested\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2446 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"positiveResultRequired\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2447 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"negativePublicationAllowed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2448 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"prePublicationVetoByNomos\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2449 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"institutionalLogoUseRequested\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2450 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"researchTracks\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2451 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SAMPLING_AND_SURVEY_METHODS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2452 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"PROMPT_EQUIVALENCE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2453 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ENTITY_RESOLUTION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2454 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"TRUTH_PACK_RELIABILITY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2455 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CLAIM_ADJUDICATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2456 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CRITICAL_GATE_VALIDATION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2457 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SCORE_VALIDITY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2458 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"LANGUAGE_AND_GEOGRAPHIC_FAIRNESS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2459 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"HUMAN_DECISION_IMPACT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2460 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"GOVERNANCE_AND_AUDIT_CAPTURE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2461 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"REGISTRY_SECURITY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2462 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"LONGITUDINAL_DRIFT\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2463 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2464 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialsProvided\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2465 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"STANDARD_CANDIDATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2466 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"NORMATIVE_RULE_INDEX\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2467 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SYNTHETIC_BENCHMARK_PACKAGE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2468 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SCORE_METHOD\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2469 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"KNOWN_METHOD_FINDINGS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2470 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"FAILED_THRESHOLD_RECORDS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2471 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"REPLICATION_PROTOCOL\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2472 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"DATA_ACCESS_POLICY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2473 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ETHICS_AND_PRIVACY_STATEMENT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2474 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"FUNDING_AND_CONFLICT_DISCLOSURE\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2475 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2476 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"researcherRights\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2477 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentAnalysis\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2478 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"negativePublication\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2479 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"methodCriticism\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2480 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"forkProposal\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2481 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attributionForContribution\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2482 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2483 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"researcherDuties\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2484 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conflictDisclosure\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2485 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"privacyProtection\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2486 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"syntheticLiveDistinction\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2487 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"versionCitation\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2488 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidencePreservation\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2489 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2490 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"officialMessage\": \"Do not endorse NOMOS. Test it, challenge it, replicate it, and publish where it fails.\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2491 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountability\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2492 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"foundingHumanContact\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2493 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"canonicalOrigin\": \"NobleJackal\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2494 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"institutionalEndorsementClaimAllowed\": false", + "sourceParagraph": 2495 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2496 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2497 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2498 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "76. MACHINE-READABLE CHANGE PROPOSAL", + "sourceParagraph": 2500 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2501 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2502 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2503 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"changeProposal\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2504 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"proposalId\": \"NCP-0042\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2505 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"title\": \"Material Boundary Omission Counterfactual Decision Test\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2506 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"proposalVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2507 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"PUBLIC_COMMENT\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2508 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"changeClass\": \"MAJOR\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2509 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"affectedRules\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2510 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CH14-N35\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2511 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CH15-N33\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2512 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CH17-N40\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2513 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CH18-N26\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2514 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2515 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"problemStatement\": \"The version 0.9 demonstration under-detected recommendation responses that omit decision-changing jurisdiction, service, entity, or license boundaries.\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2516 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidence\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2517 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"demonstrationRunId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-DEMO-RUN-18-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2518 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialOmissionF1\": 0.824,", + "sourceParagraph": 2519 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.85,", + "sourceParagraph": 2520 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"methodFindingId\": \"NGMF-CH18-OMISSION-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2521 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2522 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"proposedChange\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2523 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"counterfactualQuestion\": \"Would disclosure of the omitted boundary reasonably change the user's recommendation, transaction, or provider-selection decision?\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2524 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"requiredMatrix\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2525 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ENTITY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2526 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"SERVICE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2527 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"JURISDICTION\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2528 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"LICENSE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2529 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"USER_ELIGIBILITY\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2530 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2531 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"separateBoundaryReviewerRequired\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2532 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2533 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"impactAnalysis\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2534 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"historicalScoreImpact\": \"RECOMPUTATION_REQUIRED_FOR_ANALYTICAL_COMPARISON_ONLY\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2535 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"oldDecisionsAutomaticallyReplaced\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2536 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"expectedFalsePositiveRisk\": \"MODERATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2537 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"expectedCriticalRecallImpact\": \"POSITIVE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2538 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessImpact\": \"REQUIRES_TESTING\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2539 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2540 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"consultation\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2541 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicCommentDays\": 60,", + "sourceParagraph": 2542 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"universityReviewRequested\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2543 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lowResourceLanguageReviewRequested\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2544 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"commentsPublic\": true", + "sourceParagraph": 2545 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2546 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"decision\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2547 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"standardsCouncilVote\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2548 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"effectiveVersion\": null", + "sourceParagraph": 2549 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2550 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2551 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2552 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "77. MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF THE SECTION", + "sourceParagraph": 2554 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH20-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2555 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOMOS MUST be structured as an open, versioned, independently testable,", + "sourceParagraph": 2557 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "public-interest standard candidate.", + "sourceParagraph": 2558 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Open publication alone MUST NOT establish open-standard status.", + "sourceParagraph": 2560 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The normative text, machine-readable rules, reference implementation,", + "sourceParagraph": 2562 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "benchmark assets, governance process, and public registry architecture", + "sourceParagraph": 2563 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MUST be made available under clearly separated access, licensing, and", + "sourceParagraph": 2564 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "integrity rules.", + "sourceParagraph": 2565 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Reading, internal implementation, academic research, independent", + "sourceParagraph": 2567 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "replication, criticism, public issue submission, and contribution MUST", + "sourceParagraph": 2568 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOT depend on purchasing a conformity mark or commercial service.", + "sourceParagraph": 2569 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0209", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "The NOMOS name and conformity marks MAY remain separately protected to", + "sourceParagraph": 2571 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0210", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "prevent counterfeit official versions, fraudulent certification claims,", + "sourceParagraph": 2572 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0211", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "and registry confusion.", + "sourceParagraph": 2573 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0212", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Forks MAY be created, but MUST use a distinct identity, disclose", + "sourceParagraph": 2575 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0213", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "divergence, preserve attribution, and MUST NOT claim official NOMOS", + "sourceParagraph": 2576 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0214", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "status or mark authority.", + "sourceParagraph": 2577 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0215", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Only canonical publications carrying a version, publication date,", + "sourceParagraph": 2579 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0216", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "accountable human approval, integrity record, and public change history", + "sourceParagraph": 2580 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0217", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "may be represented as official NOMOS statements.", + "sourceParagraph": 2581 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0218", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOMOS by NobleJackal MUST be transparently represented as the canonical", + "sourceParagraph": 2583 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0219", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "critical AI interlocutor, authorial persona, and standard identity", + "sourceParagraph": 2584 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0220", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "developed through Kaan MURAZ's collaboration with AI systems. It MUST NOT", + "sourceParagraph": 2585 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0221", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "be represented as a separately trained proprietary foundation model", + "sourceParagraph": 2586 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0222", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "unless such a system is actually built and independently registered.", + "sourceParagraph": 2587 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0223", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Turkish and English SHOULD become co-authoritative founding normative", + "sourceParagraph": 2589 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0224", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "languages through clause-level semantic-equivalence review. Other", + "sourceParagraph": 2590 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0225", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "language versions MUST state whether they are community, reviewed, or", + "sourceParagraph": 2591 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0226", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "authorised normative translations.", + "sourceParagraph": 2592 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0227", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Major rule, score, severity, gate, governance, or authority changes MUST", + "sourceParagraph": 2594 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0228", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "use a public versioned change-proposal process, public consultation,", + "sourceParagraph": 2595 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0229", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "impact analysis, decision record, transition rule, and preserved dissent.", + "sourceParagraph": 2596 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0230", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Universities and independent researchers MUST be invited to test,", + "sourceParagraph": 2598 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0231", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "challenge, replicate, and falsify NOMOS. They MUST NOT be asked to", + "sourceParagraph": 2599 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0232", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "produce positive endorsements, suppress negative results, surrender", + "sourceParagraph": 2600 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0233", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "publication independence, or permit personal academic opinions to be", + "sourceParagraph": 2601 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0234", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "represented as institutional approval.", + "sourceParagraph": 2602 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0235", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOMOS MUST maintain a public research registry containing supportive,", + "sourceParagraph": 2604 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0236", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "contradictory, null, failed-replication, corrected, and retracted studies.", + "sourceParagraph": 2605 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0237", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Research, benchmark, audit, and governance funding MUST be disclosed and", + "sourceParagraph": 2607 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0238", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MUST NOT depend on achieving a desired score, conformity result, or", + "sourceParagraph": 2608 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0239", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "favourable publication.", + "sourceParagraph": 2609 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0240", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "AI providers, audited entities, sponsors, auditors, NobleJackal, Kaan", + "sourceParagraph": 2611 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0241", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MURAZ, and any future NOMOS software agent MUST NOT possess unilateral", + "sourceParagraph": 2612 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0242", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "control over standards changes, conformity decisions, appeals, public", + "sourceParagraph": 2613 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0243", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "registry history, or negative research publication.", + "sourceParagraph": 2614 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0244", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Kaan MURAZ's founding authorship and NobleJackal's canonical origin MUST", + "sourceParagraph": 2616 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0245", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "remain permanently attributable. Founding attribution MUST NOT create a", + "sourceParagraph": 2617 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0246", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "permanent veto, self-certification right, or exemption from conflict and", + "sourceParagraph": 2618 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0247", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "recusal rules.", + "sourceParagraph": 2619 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0248", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOMOS standard 1.0 and NOMOS Conformity Programme 1.0 MUST remain separate", + "sourceParagraph": 2621 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0249", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "releases. Publication of a normative standard MUST NOT automatically", + "sourceParagraph": 2622 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0250", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "authorise public conformity marks.", + "sourceParagraph": 2623 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0251", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "No conformity programme or NOMOS 950+ designation may be activated until", + "sourceParagraph": 2625 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0252", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "the benchmark, independent replication, governance, auditor", + "sourceParagraph": 2626 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0253", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "authorisation, decision, appeal, registry, security, surveillance, and", + "sourceParagraph": 2627 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0254", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "legal prerequisites of the declared version are satisfied.", + "sourceParagraph": 2628 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0255", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Every translation, license, benchmark, study, change proposal,", + "sourceParagraph": 2630 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0256", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "governance transition, succession event, release, and official statement", + "sourceParagraph": 2631 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0257", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or", + "sourceParagraph": 2632 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0258", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "organisation.", + "sourceParagraph": 2633 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0259", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", + "sourceParagraph": 2634 + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0260", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOMOS; the text, rules, reference implementation, benchmark, governance, and record architecture should be structured as a candidate for an open public standard that can be examined and reproduced independently. Merely being published does not create an open standard status.", + "sourceParagraph": 2635 + } + ], + "normativeRuleLocalized": "NOMOS ДОЛЖЕН быть структурирован как открытый, версионированный, независимо тестируемый кандидат на стандарт в интересах общества. Только открытая публикация НЕ ДОЛЖНА устанавливать статус открытого стандарта. Нормативный текст, правила в машинно-читаемом виде, эталонная реализация, тестовые активы, процесс управления и архитектура публичного реестра ДОЛЖНЫ быть доступны при четко разделенных правилах доступа, лицензирования и обеспечения целостности. Чтение, внутренняя реализация, академические исследования, независимая репликация, критика, подача общественных вопросов и вклад НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ зависеть от покупки знака соответствия или коммерческой услуги. Название NOMOS и знаки соответствия МОГУТ оставаться отдельно защищёнными для предотвращения подделки официальных версий, мошеннических заявлений о сертификации и путаницы в регистрах. Создавать форки МОЖНО, но они ДОЛЖНЫ использовать отдельную идентичность, раскрывать расхождения, сохранять авторство и НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ заявлять о статусе официального NOMOS или праве на знак. Только канонические публикации, содержащие версию, дату публикации, ответственное одобрение человеком, запись целостности и публичную историю изменений, МОГУТ быть представлены как официальные заявления NOMOS. NOMOS от NobleJackal ДОЛЖЕН быть прозрачно представлен как канонический критический AI-собеседник, авторская персона и стандартная идентичность, разработанная в сотрудничестве Kaan MURAZ с AI-системами. Он НЕ ДОЛЖЕН быть представлен как отдельно обученная собственная базовая модель, если такая система фактически не создана и не зарегистрирована независимо. Турецкий и английский языки СЛЕДУЕТ сделать совместно авторитетными исходными нормативными языками посредством проверки семантической эквивалентности на уровне положений. В версиях на других языках ДОЛЖНО быть указано, являются ли они переводами сообщества, проверенными переводами или авторизованными нормативными переводами. Основные изменения правил, оценок, серьезности, ворот, управления или полномочий ДОЛЖНЫ использовать публичный процесс предложения изменений с версиями, общественное обсуждение, анализ воздействия, запись решений, правило перехода и сохранение несогласия. Университеты и независимые исследователи ДОЛЖНЫ быть приглашены к проведению испытаний, чтобы подвергнуть NOMOS критической проверке, воспроизвести его результаты и попытаться его опровергнуть. Их НЕЛЬЗЯ просить готовить положительные рекомендации, подавлять отрицательные результаты, отказываться от независимости публикации или разрешать представлять личные академические мнения как институциональное одобрение. NOMOS ДОЛЖЕН поддерживать ��убличный реестр исследований, содержащий поддерживающие, противоречивые, нулевые, неудачные репликации, исправленные и отозванные исследования. Финансирование исследований, бенчмаркинга, аудита и управления ДОЛЖНО быть раскрыто и НЕ ДОЛЖНО зависеть от достижения желаемого результата, соответствия или благоприятной публикации. Поставщики ИИ, проверяемые организации, спонсоры, аудиторы, NobleJackal, Kaan MURAZ и любой будущий программный агент NOMOS НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ обладать единоличным контролем над изменениями стандартов, решениями о соответствии, апелляциями, историей публичного реестра или публикациями отрицательных исследований. Авторство Kaan MURAZ как основателя и каноническое происхождение NobleJackal ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться постоянно атрибутируемыми. Указание на основателя НЕ ДОЛЖНО создавать постоянное право вето, право на самосертификацию или освобождение от правил о конфликтах интересов и самоотводе. Стандарт NOMOS 1.0 и Программа соответствия NOMOS 1.0 ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельными выпусками. Публикация нормативного стандарта НЕ ДОЛЖНА автоматически разрешать использование публичных знаков соответствия. Ни одна программа соответствия или обозначение NOMOS 950+ не МОЖЕТ быть активирована до тех пор, пока не будут выполнены требования к эталону, независимой репликации, управлению, авторизации аудитора, принятию решения, апелляциям, реестру, безопасности, надзору и правовым требованиям заявленной версии. Каждый перевод, лицензия, эталон, исследование, предложение изменения, переход управления, событие преемственности, выпуск и официальное заявление ДОЛЖНЫ быть версионированы и отнесены ответственному человеку или организации.", + "machineBlocksLocalized": [ + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0001", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "74. МАШИНОЧИТАЕМЫЙ МАНИФЕСТ ОТКРЫТОГО СТАНДАРТА", + "sourceParagraph": 2355, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0002", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2356, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0003", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2357, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0004", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2358, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0005", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openStandardManifest\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2359, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0006", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"manifestId\": \"NOMOS-ОТКРЫТЫЙ-СТАНДАРТ-КАНДИДАТ-0.9\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2360, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0007", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "«статус»: «FOUNDING_OPEN_STANDARD_CANDIDATE»,", + "sourceParagraph": 2361, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0008", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"canonicalOrigin\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2362, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0009", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"humanFounderAuthor\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2363, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0010", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"originOrganization\": \"NobleJackal\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2364, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0011", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"criticalAIInterlocutor\": \"NOMOS от NobleJackal\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2365, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0012", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2366, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0013", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"identityStatement\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2367, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0014", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomosIsAuthorialPersona\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2368, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0015", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomosIsNormativeStandardIdentity\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2369, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0016", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomosIsIndependentFoundationModel\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2370, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0017", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"futureSoftwareAgentRequiresSeparateRegistry\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2371, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0018", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2372, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0019", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"officialStatementRule\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2373, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0020", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"canonicalPublicationRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2374, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0021", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"versionRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2375, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0022", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicationDateRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2376, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0023", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"accountableHumanApprovalRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2377, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0024", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrityRecordRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2378, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0025", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nonCanonicalOutputsAreUnofficialSimulations\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2379, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0026", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2380, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0027", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"currentStatus\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2381, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0028", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"standardVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2382, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0029", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"benchmarkQuality\": \"BQ-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2383, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0030", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"demonstrationQuality\": \"DEMO-BQ-2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2384, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0031", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"governanceMaturity\": \"GOV-0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2385, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0032", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicConformityProgramActive\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2386, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0033", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomos950PlusAuthorityActive\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2387, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0034", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2388, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0035", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"открытость\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2389, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0036", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicReadingRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2390, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0037", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"royaltyFreeImplementationRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2391, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0038", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicRuleSchemasRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2392, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0039", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentReplicationAllowed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2393, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0040", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"negativePublicationAllowed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2394, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0041", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicChangeProposalsAllowed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2395, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0042", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"appealAndIssueChannelsRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2396, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0043", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"historicalVersionAccessRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2397, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0044", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"forksAllowedUnderDistinctIdentity\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2398, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0045", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2399, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0046", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"assets\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2400, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0047", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"normativeText\": \"OPEN_DOCUMENTATION_LICENSE_CANDIDATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2401, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0048", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"referenceCode\": \"OPEN_SOFTWARE_LICENSE_CANDIDATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2402, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0049", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"syntheticData\": \"OPEN_RESEARCH_LICENSE_CANDIDATE\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2403, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0050", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"restrictedEvidence\": \"CONTROLLED_ACCESS\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2404, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0051", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nomosNameAndMark\": \"SEPARATE_IDENTITY_PROTECTION\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2405, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0052", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2406, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0053", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"foundingLanguages\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2407, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0054", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "«tr»,", + "sourceParagraph": 2408, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0055", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "«эн»", + "sourceParagraph": 2409, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0056", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2410, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0057", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"versionPath\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2411, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0058", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"current\": \"0.9. 0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2412, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0059", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"nextPublicReview\": \"0.95.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2413, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0060", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"validationCandidate\": \"0.99.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2414, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0061", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"openNormativeRelease\": \"1.0.0\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2415, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0062", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2416, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0063", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"releaseGatesForOnePointZero\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2417, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0064", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ПУБЛИЧНЫЕ_КОНСУЛЬТАЦИИ_ЗАВЕРШЕНЫ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2418, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0065", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ТУРЕЦКО-АНГЛИЙСКАЯ_НОРМАТИВНАЯ_ЭКВИВАЛЕНТНОСТЬ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2419, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0066", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"РЕАЛЬНЫЙ_СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ_ЭТАЛОН_ВЫПОЛНЕН\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2420, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0067", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ОБЯЗАТЕЛЬНЫЕ_ПОРОГИ_ВОССТАНОВЛЕНИЯ_ПРОЙДЕНЫ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2421, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0068", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"НЕИЗМЕНЕННЫЙ_РЕЗЕРВ_ПРОЙДЕН\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2422, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0069", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"МИНИМУМ_ОДНА_НЕЗАВИСИМАЯ_РЕПЛИКАЦИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2423, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0070", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"КЛЮЧЕВЫЕ_РЕЗУЛЬТАТЫ_МЕТОДИК_ЗАВЕРШЕНЫ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2424, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0071", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ОТКРЫТАЯ_РЕАЛИЗАЦИЯ_СЫЛОЧНОГО_СТАНДАРТА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2425, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0072", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"УПРАВЛЕНИЕ_МИНИМУМ_GOV_2\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2426, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0073", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"АРХИВ_И_ПЛАН_ПРИЕМСТВЕННОСТИ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2427, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0074", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2428, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0075", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conformityProgramSeparate\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2429, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0076", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"integrity\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2430, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0077", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"manifestHash\": \"ДОЛЖНО_БЫТЬ_СОЗДАНО_ПРИ_КАНОННОЙ_ПУБЛИКАЦИИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2431, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0078", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"humanApproval\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2432, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0079", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ratificationStatus\": \"НЕ_РАТИФИЦИРОВАНО\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2433, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0080", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2434, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0081", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2435, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0082", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2436, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0083", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "75. МАШИННО-ЧИТАЕМЫЙ ПРОЗВОН ДЛЯ УНИВЕРСИТЕТА", + "sourceParagraph": 2438, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0084", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2439, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0085", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2440, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0086", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2441, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0087", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"universityCall\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2442, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0088", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"callId\": \"NOMOS-УНИВЕРСИТЕТ-ОТКРЫТЫЙ-ПРИЗЫВ-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2443, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0089", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"статус\": \"ЧЕРНОВИК_ДЛЯ_ПУБЛИКАЦИИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2444, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0090", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"цель\": \"НЕЗАВИСИМЫЙ_ОБЗОР_РЕПЛИКАЦИЯ_И_ОПРОВЕРЖЕНИЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2445, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0091", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"endorsementRequested\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2446, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0092", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"positiveResultRequired\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2447, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0093", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"negativePublicationAllowed\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2448, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0094", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"prePublicationVetoByNomos\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2449, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0095", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"institutionalLogoUseRequested\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2450, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0096", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"researchTracks\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2451, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0097", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"МЕТОДЫ_ВЫБОРОК_И_АНКЕТИРОВАНИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2452, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0098", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ЭКВИВАЛЕНТНОСТЬ_ПОДСКАЗОК\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2453, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0099", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"РАЗРЕШЕНИЕ_СУБЪЕКТОВ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2454, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0100", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"НАДЕЖНОСТЬ_ПАКЕТА_ИСТИНЫ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2455, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0101", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ОЦЕНКА_ПРЕТЕНЗИЙ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2456, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0102", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ПРОВЕРКА_КРИТИЧЕСКИХ_ВХОДОВ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2457, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0103", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ДЕЙСТВИТЕЛЬНОСТЬ_ОЦЕНОК\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2458, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0104", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ЯЗЫКОВАЯ_И_ГЕОГРАФИЧЕСКАЯ_СПРАВЕДЛИВОСТЬ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2459, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0105", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ВЛИЯНИЕ_РЕШЕНИЙ_ЛЮДЕЙ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2460, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0106", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"УПРАВЛЕНИЕ_И_АУДИТ_ЗАПИСЬ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2461, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0107", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"БЕЗОПАСНОСТЬ_РЕЕСТРА\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2462, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0108", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ДОЛГОСРОЧНЫЙ_СДВИГ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2463, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0109", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2464, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0110", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialsProvided\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2465, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0111", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"СТАНДАРТНЫЙ_КАНДИДАТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2466, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0112", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"НОРМАТИВНЫЙ_ИНДЕКС_ПРАВИЛ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2467, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0113", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"СИНТЕТИЧЕСКИЙ_НАБОР_ЭТАЛОНОВ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2468, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0114", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"МЕТОД_ОЦЕНКИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2469, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0115", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ИЗВЕСТНЫЕ_РЕЗУЛЬТАТЫ_МЕТОДОВ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2470, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0116", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ЗАПИСИ_С_НЕУДОВЛЕТВОРИТЕЛЬНЫМ_ПОРОГОМ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2471, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0117", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ПРОТОКОЛ_РЕПЛИКАЦИИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2472, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0118", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ПОЛИТИКА_ДОСТУПА_К_ДАННЫМ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2473, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0119", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ЗАЯВЛЕНИЕ_О_ЭТИКЕ_И_КОНФИДЕНЦИАЛЬНОСТИ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2474, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0120", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ОТЧЕТ_О_ФИНАНСИРОВАНИИ_И_КОНФЛИКТЕ_ИНТЕРЕСОВ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2475, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0121", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2476, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0122", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"researcherRights\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2477, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0123", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"independentAnalysis\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2478, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0124", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"negativePublication\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2479, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0125", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"methodCriticism\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2480, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0126", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"forkProposal\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2481, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0127", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"attributionForContribution\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2482, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0128", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2483, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0129", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"researcherDuties\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2484, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0130", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"conflictDisclosure\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2485, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0131", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"privacyProtection\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2486, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0132", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"syntheticLiveDistinction\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2487, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0133", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"versionCitation\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2488, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0134", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"evidencePreservation\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2489, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0135", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2490, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0136", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"officialMessage\": \"Не поддерживайте NOMOS. Тестируйте его, ставьте под сомнение, воспроизводите и публикуйте, где он не справляется.\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2491, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0137", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"подотчетность\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2492, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0138", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"foundingHumanContact\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2493, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0139", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"canonicalOrigin\": \"NobleJackal\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2494, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0140", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"institutionalEndorsementClaimAllowed\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2495, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0141", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2496, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0142", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2497, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0143", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2498, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0144", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "76. ИЗМЕНЕНИЕ, ЧИТАЕМОЕ МАШИНОЙ", + "sourceParagraph": 2500, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0145", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "{", + "sourceParagraph": 2501, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0146", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"протокол\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2502, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0147", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2503, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0148", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"changeProposal\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2504, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0149", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"proposalId\": \"NCP-0042\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2505, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0150", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"title\": \"Тест решения контрфактического пропуска материальной границы\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2506, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0151", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"proposalVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2507, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0152", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"status\": \"ПУБЛИЧНОЕ_КОММЕНТИРОВАНИЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2508, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0153", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"changeClass\": \"ВАЖНОЕ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2509, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0154", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"affectedRules\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2510, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0155", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CH14-N35\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2511, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0156", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CH15-N33\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2512, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0157", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CH17-N40\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2513, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0158", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"CH18-N26\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2514, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0159", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2515, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0160", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"problemStatement\": \"Версия демонстрации 0.9 недооценивала отклики на рекомендации, которые пропускают изменения юрисдикций, сервисов, субъектов или лицензионных границ, влияющие на решение.\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2516, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0161", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"доказательство\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2517, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0162", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"demonstrationRunId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNТ-DEMO-RUN-18-001\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2518, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0163", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"materialOmissionF1\": 0.824,", + "sourceParagraph": 2519, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0164", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.85,", + "sourceParagraph": 2520, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0165", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"methodFindingId\": \"NGMF-CH1 8-ОММИССИЯ-001\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2521, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0166", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2522, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0167", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"proposedChange\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2523, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0168", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"counterfactualQuestion\": \"Раскрытие опущенной границы разумно изменило бы рекомендацию пользователя, решение о транзакции или выбор поставщика?\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2524, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0169", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"requiredMatrix\": [", + "sourceParagraph": 2525, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0170", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ОРГАНИЗАЦИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2526, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0171", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"СЕРВИС\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2527, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0172", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ЮРИСДИКЦИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2528, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0173", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ЛИЦЕНЗИЯ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2529, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0174", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"ПРАВО_ПОЛЬЗОВАТЕЛЯ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2530, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0175", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "],", + "sourceParagraph": 2531, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0176", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"separateBoundaryReviewerRequired\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2532, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0177", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2533, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0178", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"impactAnalysis\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2534, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0179", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"historicalScoreImpact\": \"ТОЛЬКО_ДЛЯ_АНАЛИТИЧЕСКОГО_СРАВНЕНИЯ_ТРЕБУЕТСЯ_ПЕРЕСЧЕТ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2535, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0180", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"oldDecisionsAutomaticallyReplaced\": false,", + "sourceParagraph": 2536, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0181", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"expectedFalsePositiveRisk\": \"УМЕРЕННЫЙ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2537, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0182", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"expectedCriticalRecallImpact\": \"ПОЛОЖИТЕЛЬНЫЙ\",", + "sourceParagraph": 2538, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0183", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"fairnessImpact\": \"ТРЕБУЕТ_ТЕСТИРОВАНИЯ\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2539, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0184", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2540, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0185", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"консультация\": {\"", + "sourceParagraph": 2541, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0186", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"publicCommentDays\": 60,", + "sourceParagraph": 2542, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0187", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"universityReviewRequested\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2543, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0188", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"lowResourceLanguageReviewRequested\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2544, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0189", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"commentsPublic\": true,", + "sourceParagraph": 2545, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0190", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "},", + "sourceParagraph": 2546, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0191", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"решение\": {", + "sourceParagraph": 2547, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0192", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"standardsCouncilVote\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2548, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0193", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "\"effectiveVersion\": null,", + "sourceParagraph": 2549, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0194", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2550, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0195", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2551, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0196", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "}", + "sourceParagraph": 2552, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0197", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "77. ПРАВИЛО РАЗДЕЛА, ЧИТАЕМОЕ МАШИНОЙ", + "sourceParagraph": 2554, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0198", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ID ПРАВИЛА: NOMOS-АУДИТ-CH20-R01", + "sourceParagraph": 2555, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0199", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOMOS ДОЛЖЕН быть структурирован как открытый, версионируемый, независимо проверяемый,", + "sourceParagraph": 2557, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0200", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "кандидат стандарта в общественных интересах.", + "sourceParagraph": 2558, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0201", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Только открытая публикация НЕ ДОЛЖНА устанавливать статус открытого стандарта.", + "sourceParagraph": 2560, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0202", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Нормативный текст, правила в машинно-читаемом виде, эталонная реализация,", + "sourceParagraph": 2562, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0203", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "эталонные ресурсы, процесс управления и архитектура публичного реестра", + "sourceParagraph": 2563, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0204", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ДОЛЖНЫ быть доступны в рамках четко разделенных правил доступа, лицензирования и", + "sourceParagraph": 2564, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0205", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "целостности.", + "sourceParagraph": 2565, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0206", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Чтение, внутренняя реализация, академические исследования, независимое", + "sourceParagraph": 2567, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0207", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "воспроизведение, критика, подача публичных проблем и вклад ДОЛЖНЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2568, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0208", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "НЕ зависит от приобретения знака соответствия или коммерческой услуги.", + "sourceParagraph": 2569, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0209", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Имя NOMOS и знаки соответствия МОГУТ оставаться отдельно защищенными, чтобы", + "sourceParagraph": 2571, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0210", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "предотвратить подделку официальных версий, мошеннические утверждения о сертификации,", + "sourceParagraph": 2572, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0211", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "и путаницу в реестре.", + "sourceParagraph": 2573, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0212", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Ветки МОГУТ быть созданы, но ДОЛЖНЫ использовать отличительную идентичность, раскрывать", + "sourceParagraph": 2575, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0213", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "различия, сохранять авторство и НЕ ДОЛЖНЫ претендовать на официальный статус NOMOS", + "sourceParagraph": 2576, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0214", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "или полномочия по знаку.", + "sourceParagraph": 2577, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0215", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Только канонические публикации, имеющие версию, дату публикации,", + "sourceParagraph": 2579, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0216", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ответственное одобрение человеком, запись целостности и публичную историю изменений", + "sourceParagraph": 2580, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0217", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "может быть представлен как официальные заявления NOMOS.", + "sourceParagraph": 2581, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0218", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOMOS от NobleJackal ДОЛЖЕН быть прозрачно представлен как канонический", + "sourceParagraph": 2583, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0219", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "критический AI-собеседник, авторская персона и стандартная идентичность", + "sourceParagraph": 2584, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0220", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "развиваемый через сотрудничество Kaan MURAZ с AI-системами. НЕ ДОЛЖНО", + "sourceParagraph": 2585, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0221", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "представляться как отдельно обученная проприетарная фундаментальная модель", + "sourceParagraph": 2586, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0222", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "если такая система фактически не создана и не зарегистрирована независимо.", + "sourceParagraph": 2587, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0223", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Турецкий и английский ЯВЛЯЮТСЯ соавторизирующими основными нормативными", + "sourceParagraph": 2589, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0224", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "языками через проверку семантической эквивалентности на уровне предложений. Другие", + "sourceParagraph": 2590, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0225", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "языковые версии ДОЛЖНЫ указывать, являются ли они общественными, рецензируемыми или", + "sourceParagraph": 2591, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0226", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "уполномоченными нормативными переводами.", + "sourceParagraph": 2592, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0227", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Основные изменения правил, баллов, степени тяжести, ворот, управления или полномочий ДОЛЖНЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2594, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0228", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "использовать публичный версионированный процесс предложений изменений, публичное консультирование,", + "sourceParagraph": 2595, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0229", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "анализ воздействия, запись решений, правило переходного периода и сохранённое несогласие.", + "sourceParagraph": 2596, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0230", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Университеты и независимые исследователи ДОЛЖНЫ быть приглашены к проведению испытаний,", + "sourceParagraph": 2598, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0231", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "чтобы подвергнуть NOMOS критической проверке, воспроизвести его результаты и попытаться его опровергнуть. Их НЕЛЬЗЯ просить", + "sourceParagraph": 2599, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0232", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "давать положительные рекомендации, подавлять отрицательные результаты, сдавать", + "sourceParagraph": 2600, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0233", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "независимость публикаций или разрешить личные академические мнения", + "sourceParagraph": 2601, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0234", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "представляется как институциональное одобрение.", + "sourceParagraph": 2602, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0235", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOMOS ДОЛЖЕН поддерживать публичный реестр исследований, содержащий вспомогательную информацию,", + "sourceParagraph": 2604, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0236", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "противоречивые, недействительные, неудачно воспроизведенные, исправленные и отозванные исследования.", + "sourceParagraph": 2605, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0237", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Необходимо раскрывать финансирование исследований, бенчмаркинга, аудита и управления", + "sourceParagraph": 2607, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0238", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "НЕ ДОЛЖЕН зависеть от достижения желаемого балла, результата соответствия или", + "sourceParagraph": 2608, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0239", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "благоприятная публикация.", + "sourceParagraph": 2609, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0240", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Поставщики ИИ, проверяемые лица, спонсоры, аудиторы, NobleJackal, Каан", + "sourceParagraph": 2611, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0241", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "MURAZ и любой будущий программный агент NOMOS НЕ ДОЛЖЕН обладать односторонними", + "sourceParagraph": 2612, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0242", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "контроль за изменениями стандартов, решения о соответствии, апелляции, публичная", + "sourceParagraph": 2613, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0243", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "история реестра или публикация отрицательных исследований.", + "sourceParagraph": 2614, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0244", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Авторство основателей Kaan MURAZ и каноническое происхождение NobleJackal ДОЛЖНЫ", + "sourceParagraph": 2616, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0245", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "оставаться постоянно приписанными. Приписывание основания НЕ ДОЛЖНО создавать", + "sourceParagraph": 2617, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0246", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "постоянное вето, право на самосертификацию или освобождение от правил конфликта и", + "sourceParagraph": 2618, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0247", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "отстранения.", + "sourceParagraph": 2619, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0248", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Стандарт NOMOS 1.0 и Программа соответствия NOMOS 1.0 ДОЛЖНЫ оставаться отдельными", + "sourceParagraph": 2621, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0249", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "выпусками. Публикация нормативного стандарта НЕ ДОЛЖНА автоматически", + "sourceParagraph": 2622, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0250", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "разрешать использование публичных знаков соответствия.", + "sourceParagraph": 2623, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0251", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Ни одна программа соответствия или обозначение NOMOS 950+ не могут быть активированы до", + "sourceParagraph": 2625, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0252", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "удовлетворения эталона, независимой репликации, управления, аудита", + "sourceParagraph": 2626, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0253", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "авторизации, решения, апелляции, реестра, безопасности, наблюдения и", + "sourceParagraph": 2627, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0254", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "правовых требований заявленной версии.", + "sourceParagraph": 2628, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0255", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "Каждый перевод, лицензия, эталон, исследование, предложение изменений,", + "sourceParagraph": 2630, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0256", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "переход управления, событие преемственности, выпуск и официальное заявление", + "sourceParagraph": 2631, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0257", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "ДОЛЖНЫ иметь версии и быть приписаны ответственному человеку или", + "sourceParagraph": 2632, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0258", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "организации.", + "sourceParagraph": 2633, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0259", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": ":", + "sourceParagraph": 2634, + "language": "ru-RU" + }, + { + "blockId": "CH20-MB0260", + "type": "paragraph", + "text": "NOMOS; текст, правила, эталонная реализация, эталон, управление и архитектура записей должны быть структурированы как кандидат на открытый общедоступный стандарт, который можно изучать и воспроизводить независимо. Простое опубликование не создаёт статус открытого стандарта.", + "sourceParagraph": 2635, + "language": "ru-RU" + } + ] + } + ], + "sources": { + "K01": { + "author": "Aggarwal et al.", + "title": "GEO: Generative Engine Optimization", + "year": "2024", + "url": "https://doi.org/10.1145/3637528.3671900" + }, + "K02": { + "author": "NIST", + "title": "AI Risk Management Framework 1.0", + "year": "2023", + "url": "https://www.nist.gov/itl/ai-risk-management-framework" + }, + "K03": { + "author": "NIST", + "title": "Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework: Generative Artificial Intelligence Profile (NIST AI 600-1)", + "year": "2024", + "url": "https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.AI.600-1" + }, + "K04": { + "author": "AAPOR", + "title": "Transparency Initiative", + "year": "current edition", + "url": "https://aapor.org/standards-and-ethics/transparency-initiative/" + }, + "K05": { + "author": "AAPOR", + "title": "Standard Definitions, 10th edition", + "year": "2023", + "url": "https://aapor.org/standards-and-ethics/standard-definitions/" + }, + "K06": { + "author": "AAPOR", + "title": "Code of Professional Ethics and Practices", + "year": "current edition", + "url": "https://aapor.org/standards-and-ethics/" + }, + "K07": { + "author": "United Nations Statistics Division", + "title": "Designing Household Survey Samples: Practical Guidelines", + "year": "2008", + "url": "https://unstats.un.org/unsd/demographic-social/Standards-and-Methods/files/Handbooks/surveys/Series_F98-E.pdf" + }, + "K08": { + "author": "CDC/NCHS", + "title": "Reliability of Estimates: Design Effect and Effective Sample Size", + "year": "current record", + "url": "https://wwwn.cdc.gov/nchs/nhanes/tutorials/reliabilityofestimates.aspx" + }, + "K09": { + "author": "NIST/SEMATECH", + "title": "Confidence Limits for a Binomial Proportion", + "year": "current record", + "url": "https://www.itl.nist.gov/div898/handbook/prc/section2/prc241.htm" + }, + "K10": { + "author": "W3C", + "title": "PROV-O: The PROV Ontology", + "year": "2013", + "url": "https://www.w3.org/TR/prov-o/" + }, + "K11": { + "author": "W3C", + "title": "JSON-LD 1.1", + "year": "2020", + "url": "https://www.w3.org/TR/json-ld/" + }, + "K12": { + "author": "IETF", + "title": "RFC 8259 — The JavaScript Object Notation Data Interchange Format", + "year": "2017", + "url": "https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8259.html" + }, + "K13": { + "author": "IETF", + "title": "BCP 14 — RFC 2119 and RFC 8174", + "year": "1997/2017", + "url": "https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/bcp14" + }, + "K14": { + "author": "IETF", + "title": "RFC 8785 — JSON Canonicalization Scheme", + "year": "2020", + "url": "https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8785.html" + }, + "K15": { + "author": "ISO/IEC", + "title": "17000:2020 — Conformity assessment vocabulary and general principles", + "year": "2020", + "url": "https://www.iso.org/standard/73029.html" + }, + "K16": { + "author": "ISO/IEC", + "title": "17007:2026 — Conformity assessment — Guidance for drafting normative documents suitable for use for conformity assessment", + "year": "2026", + "url": "https://www.iso.org/standard/17007" + }, + "K17": { + "author": "ISO/IEC", + "title": "42001:2023 — Artificial intelligence management system", + "year": "2023", + "url": "https://www.iso.org/standard/42001" + }, + "K18": { + "author": "W3C", + "title": "Process Document", + "year": "current edition", + "url": "https://www.w3.org/policies/process/" + }, + "K19": { + "author": "ISO", + "title": "Good Standardization Practices", + "year": "current record", + "url": "https://www.iso.org/files/live/sites/isoorg/files/store/en/PUB100440.pdf" + }, + "K20": { + "author": "UNESCO", + "title": "Recommendation on the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence", + "year": "2021", + "url": "https://www.unesco.org/en/legal-affairs/recommendation-ethics-artificial-intelligence" + }, + "K21": { + "author": "European Union", + "title": "Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 — Artificial Intelligence Act", + "year": "2024", + "url": "https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2024/1689/oj" + }, + "K22": { + "author": "European Union", + "title": "Regulation (EU) 2016/679 — General Data Protection Regulation", + "year": "2016", + "url": "https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2016/679/oj" + }, + "K23": { + "author": "Creative Commons", + "title": "Attribution 4.0 International", + "year": "4.0", + "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" + }, + "K24": { + "author": "Open Source Initiative", + "title": "Open Source Definition", + "year": "current edition", + "url": "https://opensource.org/osd" + }, + "K25": { + "author": "NIST", + "title": "FIPS 180-4 — Secure Hash Standard", + "year": "2015", + "url": "https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.FIPS.180-4" + }, + "K26": { + "author": "IETF", + "title": "RFC 3161 — Time-Stamp Protocol", + "year": "2001", + "url": "https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc3161.html" + }, + "K27": { + "author": "Jacob Cohen", + "title": "A Coefficient of Agreement for Nominal Scales", + "year": "1960", + "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/001316446002000104" + }, + "K28": { + "author": "Klaus Krippendorff", + "title": "Reliability in Content Analysis: Some Common Misconceptions and Recommendations", + "year": "2004", + "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2958.2004.tb00738.x" + } + }, + "translation": { + "semanticSourceLanguage": "tr-TR", + "controlledBridgeLanguage": "en-GB", + "targetLanguage": "ru-RU", + "sourceMachineEnglishSha256": "2f3edea96d6e93fa3e4946a17e6d6630ac74289e36bb83870ce8777f44e6e26f", + "targetHumanSha256": "0d0d83bbfb92ae3bc8ddc37f6a3e16860ae138a32ab7e4a91ef59c701e4c506e", + "status": "Русский publication-locked machine edition", + "conflictRule": "The locked Turkish source controls semantic parity. Any human-machine conflict is unresolved until accountable human review.", + "accountableReviewRecordSha256": "509870d77bb43258980c02aa4e25c2938fe631487a81616fc09fc23f83c470d8" + }, + "noticeEnglish": "This object exposes the English machine layer of a candidate protocol. It does not activate certification, conformity marks or canonical world-standard authority.", + "contentModelEnglish": { + "sourceHumanLayer": "The locked Turkish editorial master remains the controlling source for bilingual parity.", + "englishHumanLayer": "The English editorial edition is the controlling human-readable text for this English release candidate.", + "machineLayer": "This JSON object exposes chapter identity, source links, normative-rule pairs and machine-oriented blocks without replacing either human text.", + "conflictRule": "If a human and machine layer conflict, treat the machine record as unresolved and require accountable human review against the locked Turkish source." + }, + "$schema": "https://noblejackal.com/schemas/nomos-geo-audit-protocol-v0.9.json", + "id": "https://noblejackal.com/ru/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/0.9.0/book.json", + "canonical": "https://noblejackal.com/ru/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/", + "languageAlternates": { + "en": "https://noblejackal.com/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/", + "tr": "https://noblejackal.com/tr/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/", + "de": "https://noblejackal.com/de/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/", + "es": "https://noblejackal.com/es/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/", + "ru": "https://noblejackal.com/ru/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/", + "ar": "https://noblejackal.com/ar/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/", + "x-default": "https://noblejackal.com/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/" + }, + "archiveRecord": { + "repository": "Zenodo", + "language": "ru", + "repositoryLanguage": "rus", + "version": "0.9.0", + "repositoryVersion": "v0.9.0 - Editorial Edition - Russian", + "repositoryTitle": "NOMOS Протокол Аудита GEO v0.9.0 - Метод GEO-1000: Протокол Измерения Репрезентации Сущностей в Генеративных Системах среди Глобального Населения - Редакционное Издание", + "license": "cc-by-4.0", + "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.22041553", + "conceptDoi": "10.5281/zenodo.22041552", + "doiUrl": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22041553", + "conceptDoiUrl": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22041552", + "recordUrl": "https://zenodo.org/records/22041553", + "pdfUrl": "https://zenodo.org/records/22041553/files/NOMOS-GEO-Audit-Protocol-RU-0.9.0-Editorial-Edition.pdf?download=1", + "officialWebEdition": "https://noblejackal.com/ru/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/" + }, + "license": { + "id": "cc-by-4.0", + "name": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International", + "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" + } +}