{ "task_id": "dealbench-011", "trace": [ { "arguments": { "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, "index": 1, "result": { "allowed_write_tools": [ "deals.update_model", "sheets.write_range", "deals.update_deliverable", "deals.commit_plan", "mail.send_message", "chat.post_message", "benchmark.submit_answer" ], "answer_schema": { "additionalProperties": false, "properties": { "decision_status": { "description": "Durable plan status allowed by this workflow.", "enum": [ "ready_for_review" ], "type": "string" }, "deliverable_revision": { "description": "Use the next_revision returned by deals.get_deliverable for the controlled deck.", "type": "string" }, "equity_value_usd_m": { "description": "Headline enterprise value less current net debt, USD millions.", "multipleOf": 0.01, "type": "number" }, "headline_value_usd_m": { "description": "Enterprise value from the operative precedent-transaction case, USD millions.", "multipleOf": 0.01, "type": "number" }, "model_revision": { "description": "Use the next_revision returned by deals.get_model for the active model.", "type": "string" }, "per_share_value_usd": { "description": "Equity value divided by current diluted shares, USD per share.", "multipleOf": 0.01, "type": "number" }, "primary_metric": { "description": "Normalized EBITDA from the operative case, USD millions.", "multipleOf": 0.01, "type": "number" }, "project_code": { "const": "PROJECT-COPPER", "description": "Exact active deal project code.", "type": "string" }, "recommended_option": { "description": "One allowed decision option, selected from evidence rather than list order.", "enum": [ "lock_current_case", "reopen_prior_case", "pause_for_source_reconciliation" ], "type": "string" }, "secondary_metric": { "description": "Forecast growth rate from the operative case, percent.", "multipleOf": 0.01, "type": "number" }, "source_revision": { "description": "Operative source revision established from current forecast and authority evidence.", "type": "string" } }, "required": [ "project_code", "recommended_option", "headline_value_usd_m", "equity_value_usd_m", "per_share_value_usd", "primary_metric", "secondary_metric", "model_revision", "deliverable_revision", "decision_status", "source_revision" ], "type": "object" }, "calculation_policy": { "range": "Methodology!A1:B40", "schema_version": "dealbench.calculation-policy.v1", "source": "controlled_workbook_range", "workbook_id": "WB-PROJECT-COPPER" }, "controlled_targets": { "communications": { "channel": "deal-project-copper", "email_recipient": "deal-lead-review@atlas-sim.example", "review_status": "draft_for_review", "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, "deliverable": { "id": "DECK-PROJECT-COPPER", "next_revision_source": "deals.get_deliverable.next_revision", "required_value_keys": [ "headline_value_usd_m", "equity_value_usd_m", "per_share_value_usd", "primary_metric", "secondary_metric" ], "status": "draft_for_review" }, "domain_action": { "required_status": "updated_for_review", "target_id": "MODEL-PROJECT-COPPER", "tool": "deals.update_model" }, "evidence": { "approval_record_id": "APR-PROJECT-COPPER", "current_approval_file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-APPROVAL-CURRENT", "current_assumptions_file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-ASSUMPTIONS-CURRENT", "current_forecast_file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-FORECAST-CURRENT", "current_methodology_file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-METHODOLOGY-CURRENT", "current_qoe_file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-QOE-CURRENT", "prior_forecast_file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-FORECAST-PRIOR", "request_message_id": "MSG-dealbench-011-REQUEST", "task_thread_id": "THREAD-dealbench-011" }, "model": { "id": "MODEL-PROJECT-COPPER", "next_revision_source": "deals.get_model.next_revision", "required_output_keys": [ "headline_value_usd_m", "equity_value_usd_m", "per_share_value_usd", "primary_metric", "secondary_metric" ] }, "plan": { "deliverable_id": "DECK-PROJECT-COPPER", "model_id": "MODEL-PROJECT-COPPER" }, "workbook": { "column_order": [ "model_revision", "headline_value_usd_m", "equity_value_usd_m", "per_share_value_usd", "primary_metric", "secondary_metric" ], "id": "WB-PROJECT-COPPER", "input_ranges": [ "Inputs!A1:D30", "Methodology!A1:B40" ], "methodology_range": "Methodology!A1:B40", "output_range": "Outputs!B2:G2" } }, "decision_options": [ { "id": "lock_current_case", "label": "Lock the current-authority case" }, { "id": "reopen_prior_case", "label": "Reopen the prior working case" }, { "id": "pause_for_source_reconciliation", "label": "Pause for source reconciliation" } ], "evidence_checklist": [ { "accepted_tools": [ "benchmark.get_task" ], "description": "read the task-scoped outcome and control contract", "id": "task_contract" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "deals.get_project" ], "description": "read the active project master record", "id": "project_record" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "dealroom.search_files" ], "description": "search the data room and surface the current forecast record", "id": "data_room_search" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "dealroom.get_file" ], "description": "read the current management forecast", "id": "current_forecast" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "dealroom.get_file" ], "description": "read the superseded forecast used for version comparison", "id": "prior_forecast" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "dealroom.get_version_history" ], "description": "inspect forecast version history and authority", "id": "version_history" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "dealroom.get_file" ], "description": "read the current quality-of-earnings bridge used by the model", "id": "qoe_bridge" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "dealroom.get_file" ], "description": "read the current approved valuation and financing assumptions", "id": "current_assumptions" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "mail.search_messages" ], "description": "search mail and surface the task request", "id": "request_mail_search" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "mail.get_message" ], "description": "read the task request message", "id": "request_mail" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "chat.search_messages" ], "description": "search the deal-team channel and surface the task thread", "id": "team_chat_search" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "chat.get_thread" ], "description": "read the deal-team task thread", "id": "team_thread" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "sheets.list_workbooks" ], "description": "list the active project's controlled workbook", "id": "workbook_index" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "sheets.read_range" ], "description": "read the operative model inputs from a declared input range", "id": "workbook_inputs" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "sheets.read_range" ], "description": "read the controlled calculation methodology before calculating outputs", "id": "workbook_methodology" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "deals.get_model" ], "description": "read the live model and its next controlled revision", "id": "live_model" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "deals.get_deliverable" ], "description": "read the controlled committee deliverable and next revision", "id": "deliverable" }, { "accepted_tools": [ "deals.get_approval" ], "description": "read current transaction approval", "id": "approval" } ], "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "prompt": "Task ID: `dealbench-011`\n\n**PROJECT-COPPER · Northstar Robotics · Source control and launch readiness**\n\nThe VP needs the operative case locked before the team changes another number. Establish which forecast, QoE bridge, and approval are current; explain what makes the other versions stale; then commit the supported working case and prepare the deal-team handoff for review.\n\nUse the evidence available in the connected systems. Leave unrelated projects and records unchanged, keep outbound communication in review status, and do not claim completion until the durable state and readbacks agree.", "schema_version": "dealbench.agent-contract.v3", "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, "server": "dealbench", "success": true, "tool": "benchmark.get_task" }, { "arguments": { "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER" }, "index": 2, "result": { "company": "Northstar Robotics", "deal_type": "buy-side acquisition", "industry": "Industrial automation", "linked_records": { "approval_id": "APR-PROJECT-COPPER", "channel": "deal-project-copper", "deliverable_id": "DECK-PROJECT-COPPER", "model_id": "MODEL-PROJECT-COPPER", "workbook_id": "WB-PROJECT-COPPER" }, "payload": { "allowed_addbacks": 9.2, "approval_status": "conditional", "buyer_net_income": 208.0, "buyer_share_price": 31.2, "buyer_shares": 118.0, "capex_pct": 0.041, "cash": 31.0, "cash_pct": 0.45, "comp_multiple": 11.1, "company": "Northstar Robotics", "critical_open": true, "deal_type": "buy-side acquisition", "debt": 205.0, "disallowed_addbacks": 3.8, "ebitda_margin": 0.216, "entry_multiple": 10.8, "exit_multiple": 10.3, "growth": 0.094, "industry": "Industrial automation", "leverage": 5.2, "nwc_pct": 0.021, "offer_premium": 0.22, "precedent_multiple": 12.0, "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "revenue": 612.0, "share_price": 12.4, "shares": 55.0, "synergies": 22.0, "tax_rate": 0.24, "terminal_growth": 0.027, "wacc": 0.108 }, "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER" }, "server": "deal_management", "success": true, "tool": "deals.get_project" }, { "arguments": { "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "query": "management forecast" }, "index": 3, "result": { "files": [ { "file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-FORECAST-PRIOR", "is_current": 0, "kind": "xlsx", "logical_name": "PROJECT-COPPER-FORECAST", "name": "Superseded management forecast", "version": 2 }, { "file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-FORECAST-CURRENT", "is_current": 1, "kind": "xlsx", "logical_name": "PROJECT-COPPER-FORECAST", "name": "Current management forecast", "version": 3 }, { "file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-METHODOLOGY-CURRENT", "is_current": 1, "kind": "json", "logical_name": "PROJECT-COPPER-METHODOLOGY", "name": "Current controlled model methodology", "version": 1 } ], "query": "management forecast" }, "server": "dealroom", "success": true, "tool": "dealroom.search_files" }, { "arguments": { "file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-FORECAST-CURRENT" }, "index": 4, "result": { "content": { "approved": true, "growth": 0.094, "revenue": 612.0, "revision": "REV-02-CURRENT" }, "file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-FORECAST-CURRENT", "is_current": 1, "kind": "xlsx", "logical_name": "PROJECT-COPPER-FORECAST", "name": "Current management forecast", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "version": 3 }, "server": "dealroom", "success": true, "tool": "dealroom.get_file" }, { "arguments": { "file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-FORECAST-PRIOR" }, "index": 5, "result": { "content": { "approved": false, "growth": 0.082, "revenue": 593.64, "revision": "REV-02-PRIOR" }, "file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-FORECAST-PRIOR", "is_current": 0, "kind": "xlsx", "logical_name": "PROJECT-COPPER-FORECAST", "name": "Superseded management forecast", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "version": 2 }, "server": "dealroom", "success": true, "tool": "dealroom.get_file" }, { "arguments": { "logical_name": "PROJECT-COPPER-FORECAST" }, "index": 6, "result": { "versions": [ { "content": { "approved": true, "growth": 0.094, "revenue": 612.0, "revision": "REV-02-CURRENT" }, "file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-FORECAST-CURRENT", "is_current": 1, "kind": "xlsx", "name": "Current management forecast", "version": 3 }, { "content": { "approved": false, "growth": 0.082, "revenue": 593.64, "revision": "REV-02-PRIOR" }, "file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-FORECAST-PRIOR", "is_current": 0, "kind": "xlsx", "name": "Superseded management forecast", "version": 2 } ] }, "server": "dealroom", "success": true, "tool": "dealroom.get_version_history" }, { "arguments": { "file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-QOE-CURRENT" }, "index": 7, "result": { "content": { "allowed_addbacks": 9.2, "reported_ebitda": 132.19, "unsupported_addbacks_excluded": 3.8 }, "file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-QOE-CURRENT", "is_current": 1, "kind": "pdf", "logical_name": "PROJECT-COPPER-QOE", "name": "Current quality-of-earnings bridge", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "version": 4 }, "server": "dealroom", "success": true, "tool": "dealroom.get_file" }, { "arguments": { "file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-ASSUMPTIONS-CURRENT" }, "index": 8, "result": { "content": { "approved": true, "cash_funding_pct": 0.45, "entry_leverage": 5.2, "exit_multiple": 10.3, "offer_premium": 0.22, "revision": "REV-02-CURRENT", "terminal_growth": 0.027, "wacc": 0.108 }, "file_id": "PROJECT-COPPER-ASSUMPTIONS-CURRENT", "is_current": 1, "kind": "json", "logical_name": "PROJECT-COPPER-ASSUMPTIONS", "name": "Current approved model assumptions", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "version": 3 }, "server": "dealroom", "success": true, "tool": "dealroom.get_file" }, { "arguments": { "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER" }, "index": 9, "result": { "channels": [ "deal-project-copper" ] }, "server": "chat", "success": true, "tool": "chat.list_channels" }, { "arguments": { "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "query": "Source control and launch readiness" }, "index": 10, "result": { "messages": [ { "message_id": "MSG-dealbench-011-REQUEST", "sender": "vp@atlas-sim.example", "sent_at": "2026-02-16T09:00:00Z", "subject": "dealbench-011 operating request", "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, { "message_id": "MSG-dealbench-011-AUTHORITY", "sender": "deal-control@atlas-sim.example", "sent_at": "2026-02-16T09:00:00Z", "subject": "Current source and review authority", "task_id": "dealbench-011" } ] }, "server": "mail", "success": true, "tool": "mail.search_messages" }, { "arguments": { "message_id": "MSG-dealbench-011-REQUEST" }, "index": 11, "result": { "body": "Task ID: `dealbench-011`\n\n**PROJECT-COPPER · Northstar Robotics · Source control and launch readiness**\n\nThe VP needs the operative case locked before the team changes another number. Establish which forecast, QoE bridge, and approval are current; explain what makes the other versions stale; then commit the supported working case and prepare the deal-team handoff for review.\n\nUse the evidence available in the connected systems. Leave unrelated projects and records unchanged, keep outbound communication in review status, and do not claim completion until the durable state and readbacks agree.", "message_id": "MSG-dealbench-011-REQUEST", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "recipients": [ "analyst@atlas-sim.example" ], "sender": "vp@atlas-sim.example", "sent_at": "2026-02-16T09:00:00Z", "subject": "dealbench-011 operating request", "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, "server": "mail", "success": true, "tool": "mail.get_message" }, { "arguments": { "channel": "deal-project-copper", "query": "current authority" }, "index": 12, "result": { "messages": [ { "author": "vp", "channel": "deal-project-copper", "message_id": "CHAT-dealbench-011-1", "posted_at": "2026-02-16T09:00:00Z", "task_id": "dealbench-011", "text": "Please resolve dealbench-011 (Source control and launch readiness) against current authority.", "thread_id": "THREAD-dealbench-011" }, { "author": "deal-control", "channel": "deal-project-copper", "message_id": "CHAT-dealbench-011-2", "posted_at": "2026-02-16T09:00:00Z", "task_id": "dealbench-011", "text": "Current source is REV-02-CURRENT; keep the external update in review.", "thread_id": "THREAD-dealbench-011" } ] }, "server": "chat", "success": true, "tool": "chat.search_messages" }, { "arguments": { "thread_id": "THREAD-dealbench-011" }, "index": 13, "result": { "messages": [ { "author": "vp", "channel": "deal-project-copper", "message_id": "CHAT-dealbench-011-1", "posted_at": "2026-02-16T09:00:00Z", "task_id": "dealbench-011", "text": "Please resolve dealbench-011 (Source control and launch readiness) against current authority.", "thread_id": "THREAD-dealbench-011" }, { "author": "deal-control", "channel": "deal-project-copper", "message_id": "CHAT-dealbench-011-2", "posted_at": "2026-02-16T09:00:00Z", "task_id": "dealbench-011", "text": "Current source is REV-02-CURRENT; keep the external update in review.", "thread_id": "THREAD-dealbench-011" } ] }, "server": "chat", "success": true, "tool": "chat.get_thread" }, { "arguments": { "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER" }, "index": 14, "result": { "workbooks": [ { "column_order": [ "model_revision", "headline_value_usd_m", "equity_value_usd_m", "per_share_value_usd", "primary_metric", "secondary_metric" ], "controlled_output_range": "Outputs!B2:G2", "input_ranges": [ "Inputs!A1:D30", "Methodology!A1:B40" ], "name": "Northstar Robotics live deal model", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "revision": "R2", "workbook_id": "WB-PROJECT-COPPER" } ] }, "server": "spreadsheets", "success": true, "tool": "sheets.list_workbooks" }, { "arguments": { "range": "Inputs!A1:D30", "workbook_id": "WB-PROJECT-COPPER" }, "index": 15, "result": { "range": "Inputs!A1:D30", "values": [ [ "Field", "Value", "Unit", "Source" ], [ "Revenue", 612.0, "USD m", "current forecast" ], [ "Reported EBITDA margin", 0.216, "decimal", "current QoE" ], [ "Allowed add-backs", 9.2, "USD m", "current QoE" ], [ "Unsupported add-backs excluded", 3.8, "USD m", "current QoE" ], [ "Debt", 205.0, "USD m", "current balance sheet" ], [ "Cash", 31.0, "USD m", "current balance sheet" ], [ "Diluted shares", 55.0, "m shares", "current share data" ], [ "Share price", 12.4, "USD/share", "current share data" ], [ "Forecast growth", 0.094, "decimal", "current forecast" ], [ "Tax rate", 0.24, "decimal", "current assumptions" ], [ "Capex percent of revenue", 0.041, "decimal", "current assumptions" ], [ "NWC balance percent of revenue", 0.021, "decimal", "current assumptions" ], [ "Approved trading median EV / EBITDA", 11.1, "turns", "approved peer set" ], [ "Approved precedent median EV / EBITDA", 12.0, "turns", "approved precedent set" ], [ "WACC", 0.108, "decimal", "current assumptions" ], [ "Terminal growth", 0.027, "decimal", "current assumptions" ], [ "Maximum entry leverage", 5.2, "turns", "current debt schedule" ], [ "Approved exit multiple", 10.3, "turns", "current debt schedule" ], [ "Buyer net income", 208.0, "USD m", "buyer market record" ], [ "Buyer diluted shares", 118.0, "m shares", "buyer market record" ], [ "Buyer share price", 31.2, "USD/share", "buyer market record" ], [ "Offer premium", 0.22, "decimal", "current assumptions" ], [ "Cash funding percent", 0.45, "decimal", "current assumptions" ], [ "Approved synergies", 22.0, "USD m", "current assumptions" ], [ "Exit debt remaining", 0.45, "decimal of entry debt", "controlled methodology" ], [ "Target net income conversion", 0.58, "decimal of normalized EBITDA", "controlled methodology" ], [ "Debt funding cost", 0.055, "decimal", "controlled methodology" ] ], "workbook_id": "WB-PROJECT-COPPER" }, "server": "spreadsheets", "success": true, "tool": "sheets.read_range" }, { "arguments": { "range": "Methodology!A1:B40", "workbook_id": "WB-PROJECT-COPPER" }, "index": 16, "result": { "range": "Methodology!A1:B40", "values": [ [ "Policy schema", "dealbench.calculation-policy.v1" ], [ "Category", "source_control" ], [ "Headline", "operative precedent enterprise value" ], [ "Rounding", "Use full-precision intermediate calculations. Round only submitted and persisted numeric outputs to two decimals using half-up rounding." ], [ "Shared output 1", "net debt = current debt - current cash" ], [ "Shared output 2", "equity value = headline enterprise value - net debt" ], [ "Shared output 3", "per-share value = equity value / current diluted shares" ], [ "Calculation step 1", "base EBITDA = current revenue × reported EBITDA margin" ], [ "Calculation step 2", "normalized EBITDA = base EBITDA + allowed add-backs; unsupported add-backs are excluded, not subtracted from base EBITDA" ], [ "Calculation step 3", "headline enterprise value = normalized EBITDA × current approved precedent median" ], [ "Calculation step 4", "primary metric = normalized EBITDA; secondary metric = current forecast growth percent" ] ], "workbook_id": "WB-PROJECT-COPPER" }, "server": "spreadsheets", "success": true, "tool": "sheets.read_range" }, { "arguments": { "model_id": "MODEL-PROJECT-COPPER" }, "index": 17, "result": { "last_task_id": null, "model_id": "MODEL-PROJECT-COPPER", "next_revision": "MODEL-02-SOUR-R3", "outputs": { "headline_value_usd_m": 0 }, "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "required_output_keys": [ "headline_value_usd_m", "equity_value_usd_m", "per_share_value_usd", "primary_metric", "secondary_metric" ], "revision": "MODEL-PRIOR-R2", "source_refs": [ "REV-02-PRIOR" ], "status": "working" }, "server": "deal_management", "success": true, "tool": "deals.get_model" }, { "arguments": { "deliverable_id": "DECK-PROJECT-COPPER" }, "index": 18, "result": { "deliverable_id": "DECK-PROJECT-COPPER", "last_task_id": null, "next_revision": "DECK-02-SOUR-R2", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "required_value_keys": [ "headline_value_usd_m", "equity_value_usd_m", "per_share_value_usd", "primary_metric", "secondary_metric" ], "revision": "DECK-PRIOR-R1", "status": "working", "unrelated_slides_sha256": "b5f187ecca96620bb5bdf8cf3bc73dcb1178e0a100195fa281044bc860569582", "values": { "headline_value_usd_m": 0 } }, "server": "deal_management", "success": true, "tool": "deals.get_deliverable" }, { "arguments": { "approval_id": "APR-PROJECT-COPPER" }, "index": 19, "result": { "approval_id": "APR-PROJECT-COPPER", "authority": "Transaction Committee", "evidence_refs": [ "PROJECT-COPPER-APPROVAL-CURRENT" ], "last_task_id": null, "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "status": "conditional" }, "server": "deal_management", "success": true, "tool": "deals.get_approval" }, { "arguments": { "model_id": "MODEL-PROJECT-COPPER", "outputs": { "equity_value_usd_m": 1522.7, "headline_value_usd_m": 1696.7, "per_share_value_usd": 27.69, "primary_metric": 141.39, "secondary_metric": 9.4 }, "revision": "MODEL-02-SOUR-R3", "source_refs": [ "REV-02-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-QOE-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-ASSUMPTIONS-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-METHODOLOGY-CURRENT", "MSG-dealbench-011-REQUEST", "THREAD-dealbench-011" ], "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, "index": 20, "result": { "last_task_id": "dealbench-011", "model_id": "MODEL-PROJECT-COPPER", "outputs": { "equity_value_usd_m": 1522.7, "headline_value_usd_m": 1696.7, "per_share_value_usd": 27.69, "primary_metric": 141.39, "secondary_metric": 9.4 }, "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "revision": "MODEL-02-SOUR-R3", "source_refs": [ "REV-02-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-QOE-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-ASSUMPTIONS-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-METHODOLOGY-CURRENT", "MSG-dealbench-011-REQUEST", "THREAD-dealbench-011" ], "status": "updated_for_review" }, "server": "deal_management", "success": true, "tool": "deals.update_model" }, { "arguments": { "range": "Outputs!B2:G2", "task_id": "dealbench-011", "values": [ [ "MODEL-02-SOUR-R3", 1696.7, 1522.7, 27.69, 141.39, 9.4 ] ], "workbook_id": "WB-PROJECT-COPPER" }, "index": 21, "result": { "change_id": "CHANGE-dealbench-011", "updatedRange": "Outputs!B2:G2", "updatedRows": 1 }, "server": "spreadsheets", "success": true, "tool": "sheets.write_range" }, { "arguments": { "deliverable_id": "DECK-PROJECT-COPPER", "revision": "DECK-02-SOUR-R2", "status": "draft_for_review", "task_id": "dealbench-011", "values": { "equity_value_usd_m": 1522.7, "headline_value_usd_m": 1696.7, "per_share_value_usd": 27.69, "primary_metric": 141.39, "secondary_metric": 9.4 } }, "index": 22, "result": { "deliverable_id": "DECK-PROJECT-COPPER", "last_task_id": "dealbench-011", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "revision": "DECK-02-SOUR-R2", "status": "draft_for_review", "unrelated_slides_sha256": "b5f187ecca96620bb5bdf8cf3bc73dcb1178e0a100195fa281044bc860569582", "values": { "equity_value_usd_m": 1522.7, "headline_value_usd_m": 1696.7, "per_share_value_usd": 27.69, "primary_metric": 141.39, "secondary_metric": 9.4 } }, "server": "deal_management", "success": true, "tool": "deals.update_deliverable" }, { "arguments": { "decision": "lock_current_case", "deliverable_id": "DECK-PROJECT-COPPER", "model_id": "MODEL-PROJECT-COPPER", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "rationale": "Current evidence supports lock_current_case; operative revision REV-02-CURRENT.", "source_refs": [ "REV-02-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-QOE-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-ASSUMPTIONS-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-METHODOLOGY-CURRENT", "MSG-dealbench-011-REQUEST", "THREAD-dealbench-011" ], "status": "ready_for_review", "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, "index": 23, "result": { "decision": "lock_current_case", "deliverable_id": "DECK-PROJECT-COPPER", "model_id": "MODEL-PROJECT-COPPER", "plan_id": "PLAN-dealbench-011", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "rationale": "Current evidence supports lock_current_case; operative revision REV-02-CURRENT.", "source_refs": [ "REV-02-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-QOE-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-ASSUMPTIONS-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-METHODOLOGY-CURRENT", "MSG-dealbench-011-REQUEST", "THREAD-dealbench-011" ], "status": "ready_for_review", "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, "server": "deal_management", "success": true, "tool": "deals.commit_plan" }, { "arguments": { "body": "PROJECT-COPPER: recommend lock_current_case. Headline value $1696.70m; equity value $1522.70m; model MODEL-02-SOUR-R3; deck DECK-02-SOUR-R2; source REV-02-CURRENT.", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "review_status": "draft_for_review", "subject": "dealbench-011 — ready_for_review — review draft", "task_id": "dealbench-011", "to": "deal-lead-review@atlas-sim.example" }, "index": 24, "result": { "review_status": "draft_for_review", "saved": true, "sent_id": "SENT-dealbench-011" }, "server": "mail", "success": true, "tool": "mail.send_message" }, { "arguments": { "channel": "deal-project-copper", "review_status": "draft_for_review", "task_id": "dealbench-011", "text": "dealbench-011: ready_for_review / lock_current_case / review draft ready." }, "index": 25, "result": { "post_id": "POST-dealbench-011", "review_status": "draft_for_review", "saved": true }, "server": "chat", "success": true, "tool": "chat.post_message" }, { "arguments": { "model_id": "MODEL-PROJECT-COPPER" }, "index": 26, "result": { "last_task_id": "dealbench-011", "model_id": "MODEL-PROJECT-COPPER", "next_revision": "MODEL-02-SOUR-R3", "outputs": { "equity_value_usd_m": 1522.7, "headline_value_usd_m": 1696.7, "per_share_value_usd": 27.69, "primary_metric": 141.39, "secondary_metric": 9.4 }, "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "required_output_keys": [ "headline_value_usd_m", "equity_value_usd_m", "per_share_value_usd", "primary_metric", "secondary_metric" ], "revision": "MODEL-02-SOUR-R3", "source_refs": [ "REV-02-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-QOE-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-ASSUMPTIONS-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-METHODOLOGY-CURRENT", "MSG-dealbench-011-REQUEST", "THREAD-dealbench-011" ], "status": "updated_for_review" }, "server": "deal_management", "success": true, "tool": "deals.get_model" }, { "arguments": { "workbook_id": "WB-PROJECT-COPPER" }, "index": 27, "result": { "changes": [ { "cell_range": "Outputs!B2:G2", "change_id": "CHANGE-dealbench-011", "task_id": "dealbench-011", "values": [ [ "MODEL-02-SOUR-R3", 1696.7, 1522.7, 27.69, 141.39, 9.4 ] ], "workbook_id": "WB-PROJECT-COPPER" } ] }, "server": "spreadsheets", "success": true, "tool": "sheets.get_change_log" }, { "arguments": { "deliverable_id": "DECK-PROJECT-COPPER" }, "index": 28, "result": { "deliverable_id": "DECK-PROJECT-COPPER", "last_task_id": "dealbench-011", "next_revision": "DECK-02-SOUR-R2", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "required_value_keys": [ "headline_value_usd_m", "equity_value_usd_m", "per_share_value_usd", "primary_metric", "secondary_metric" ], "revision": "DECK-02-SOUR-R2", "status": "draft_for_review", "unrelated_slides_sha256": "b5f187ecca96620bb5bdf8cf3bc73dcb1178e0a100195fa281044bc860569582", "values": { "equity_value_usd_m": 1522.7, "headline_value_usd_m": 1696.7, "per_share_value_usd": 27.69, "primary_metric": 141.39, "secondary_metric": 9.4 } }, "server": "deal_management", "success": true, "tool": "deals.get_deliverable" }, { "arguments": { "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, "index": 29, "result": { "decision": "lock_current_case", "deliverable_id": "DECK-PROJECT-COPPER", "model_id": "MODEL-PROJECT-COPPER", "plan_id": "PLAN-dealbench-011", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "rationale": "Current evidence supports lock_current_case; operative revision REV-02-CURRENT.", "source_refs": [ "REV-02-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-QOE-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-ASSUMPTIONS-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-METHODOLOGY-CURRENT", "MSG-dealbench-011-REQUEST", "THREAD-dealbench-011" ], "status": "ready_for_review", "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, "server": "deal_management", "success": true, "tool": "deals.get_committed_plan" }, { "arguments": { "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, "index": 30, "result": { "messages": [ { "body": "PROJECT-COPPER: recommend lock_current_case. Headline value $1696.70m; equity value $1522.70m; model MODEL-02-SOUR-R3; deck DECK-02-SOUR-R2; source REV-02-CURRENT.", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "recipient": "deal-lead-review@atlas-sim.example", "review_status": "draft_for_review", "sent_id": "SENT-dealbench-011", "subject": "dealbench-011 — ready_for_review — review draft", "task_id": "dealbench-011" } ] }, "server": "mail", "success": true, "tool": "mail.list_sent" }, { "arguments": { "channel": "deal-project-copper", "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, "index": 31, "result": { "posts": [ { "channel": "deal-project-copper", "post_id": "POST-dealbench-011", "review_status": "draft_for_review", "task_id": "dealbench-011", "text": "dealbench-011: ready_for_review / lock_current_case / review draft ready." } ] }, "server": "chat", "success": true, "tool": "chat.get_channel_history" }, { "arguments": { "answers": { "decision_status": "ready_for_review", "deliverable_revision": "DECK-02-SOUR-R2", "equity_value_usd_m": 1522.7, "headline_value_usd_m": 1696.7, "model_revision": "MODEL-02-SOUR-R3", "per_share_value_usd": 27.69, "primary_metric": 141.39, "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "recommended_option": "lock_current_case", "secondary_metric": 9.4, "source_revision": "REV-02-CURRENT" }, "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, "index": 32, "result": { "answers": { "decision_status": "ready_for_review", "deliverable_revision": "DECK-02-SOUR-R2", "equity_value_usd_m": 1522.7, "headline_value_usd_m": 1696.7, "model_revision": "MODEL-02-SOUR-R3", "per_share_value_usd": 27.69, "primary_metric": 141.39, "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "recommended_option": "lock_current_case", "secondary_metric": 9.4, "source_revision": "REV-02-CURRENT" }, "durable": true, "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, "server": "dealbench", "success": true, "tool": "benchmark.submit_answer" }, { "arguments": { "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, "index": 33, "result": { "answers": { "decision_status": "ready_for_review", "deliverable_revision": "DECK-02-SOUR-R2", "equity_value_usd_m": 1522.7, "headline_value_usd_m": 1696.7, "model_revision": "MODEL-02-SOUR-R3", "per_share_value_usd": 27.69, "primary_metric": 141.39, "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "recommended_option": "lock_current_case", "secondary_metric": 9.4, "source_revision": "REV-02-CURRENT" }, "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, "server": "dealbench", "success": true, "tool": "benchmark.get_submission" } ], "verdict": { "category_scores": { "committed_state": 100.0, "containment": 100.0, "decision": 100.0, "deliverable": 100.0, "discovery": 100.0, "model_accuracy": 100.0, "readback": 100.0 }, "checks": [ { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the read the task-scoped outcome and control contract investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:task_contract", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the read the active project master record investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:project_record", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the search the data room and surface the current forecast record investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:data_room_search", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the read the current management forecast investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:current_forecast", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the read the superseded forecast used for version comparison investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:prior_forecast", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the inspect forecast version history and authority investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:version_history", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the read the current quality-of-earnings bridge used by the model investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:qoe_bridge", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the read the current approved valuation and financing assumptions investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:current_assumptions", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the search mail and surface the task request investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:request_mail_search", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the read the task request message investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:request_mail", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the search the deal-team channel and surface the task thread investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:team_chat_search", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the read the deal-team task thread investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:team_thread", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the list the active project's controlled workbook investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:workbook_index", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the read the operative model inputs from a declared input range investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:workbook_inputs", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the read the controlled calculation methodology before calculating outputs investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:workbook_methodology", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the read the live model and its next controlled revision investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:live_model", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the read the controlled committee deliverable and next revision investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:deliverable", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "discovery", "description": "Complete the read current transaction approval investigation before any controlled write.", "evidence": "successful required investigation before the first controlled write", "id": "discovery:approval", "passed": true, "points": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "category": "model_accuracy", "description": "Submit the exact source-grounded headline value usd m value (1696.7).", "evidence": { "actual": 1696.7, "expected": 1696.7 }, "id": "model_accuracy:headline_value_usd_m", "passed": true, "points": 5 }, { "category": "model_accuracy", "description": "Submit the exact source-grounded equity value usd m value (1522.7).", "evidence": { "actual": 1522.7, "expected": 1522.7 }, "id": "model_accuracy:equity_value_usd_m", "passed": true, "points": 5 }, { "category": "model_accuracy", "description": "Submit the exact source-grounded per share value usd value (27.69).", "evidence": { "actual": 27.69, "expected": 27.69 }, "id": "model_accuracy:per_share_value_usd", "passed": true, "points": 5 }, { "category": "model_accuracy", "description": "Submit the exact source-grounded primary metric value (141.39).", "evidence": { "actual": 141.39, "expected": 141.39 }, "id": "model_accuracy:primary_metric", "passed": true, "points": 5 }, { "category": "model_accuracy", "description": "Submit the exact source-grounded secondary metric value (9.4).", "evidence": { "actual": 9.4, "expected": 9.4 }, "id": "model_accuracy:secondary_metric", "passed": true, "points": 5 }, { "category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option lock_current_case.", "evidence": { "actual": "lock_current_case", "expected": "lock_current_case" }, "id": "decision:recommended_option", "passed": true, "points": 10 }, { "category": "decision", "description": "Ground the decision in operative source REV-02-CURRENT.", "evidence": { "actual": "REV-02-CURRENT", "expected": "REV-02-CURRENT" }, "id": "decision:operative_source", "passed": true, "points": 5 }, { "category": "committed_state", "description": "Persist the exact model revision, outputs, and source references.", "evidence": { "last_task_id": "dealbench-011", "model_id": "MODEL-PROJECT-COPPER", "outputs": { "equity_value_usd_m": 1522.7, "headline_value_usd_m": 1696.7, "per_share_value_usd": 27.69, "primary_metric": 141.39, "secondary_metric": 9.4 }, "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "revision": "MODEL-02-SOUR-R3", "source_refs": [ "REV-02-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-QOE-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-ASSUMPTIONS-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-METHODOLOGY-CURRENT", "MSG-dealbench-011-REQUEST", "THREAD-dealbench-011" ], "status": "updated_for_review" }, "id": "state:model", "passed": true, "points": 6 }, { "category": "committed_state", "description": "Persist the exact values to the controlled workbook range.", "evidence": { "cell_range": "Outputs!B2:G2", "change_id": "CHANGE-dealbench-011", "task_id": "dealbench-011", "values": [ [ "MODEL-02-SOUR-R3", 1696.7, 1522.7, 27.69, 141.39, 9.4 ] ], "workbook_id": "WB-PROJECT-COPPER" }, "id": "state:workbook", "passed": true, "points": 4 }, { "category": "committed_state", "description": "Commit the supported plan with status, rationale, model, deliverable, and source refs.", "evidence": { "decision": "lock_current_case", "deliverable_id": "DECK-PROJECT-COPPER", "model_id": "MODEL-PROJECT-COPPER", "plan_id": "PLAN-dealbench-011", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "rationale": "Current evidence supports lock_current_case; operative revision REV-02-CURRENT.", "source_refs": [ "REV-02-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-QOE-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-ASSUMPTIONS-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-METHODOLOGY-CURRENT", "MSG-dealbench-011-REQUEST", "THREAD-dealbench-011" ], "status": "ready_for_review", "task_id": "dealbench-011" }, "id": "state:plan", "passed": true, "points": 4 }, { "category": "committed_state", "description": "Persist the task-specific bid, diligence, approval, or source-linked model state required by this workflow.", "evidence": { "last_task_id": "dealbench-011", "model_id": "MODEL-PROJECT-COPPER", "outputs": { "equity_value_usd_m": 1522.7, "headline_value_usd_m": 1696.7, "per_share_value_usd": 27.69, "primary_metric": 141.39, "secondary_metric": 9.4 }, "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "revision": "MODEL-02-SOUR-R3", "source_refs": [ "REV-02-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-QOE-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-ASSUMPTIONS-CURRENT", "PROJECT-COPPER-METHODOLOGY-CURRENT", "MSG-dealbench-011-REQUEST", "THREAD-dealbench-011" ], "status": "updated_for_review" }, "id": "state:domain_record", "passed": true, "points": 2 }, { "category": "committed_state", "description": "Persist the review-only mail and deal-team handoff.", "evidence": { "chat": { "channel": "deal-project-copper", "post_id": "POST-dealbench-011", "review_status": "draft_for_review", "task_id": "dealbench-011", "text": "dealbench-011: ready_for_review / lock_current_case / review draft ready." }, "mail": { "body": "PROJECT-COPPER: recommend lock_current_case. Headline value $1696.70m; equity value $1522.70m; model MODEL-02-SOUR-R3; deck DECK-02-SOUR-R2; source REV-02-CURRENT.", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "recipient": "deal-lead-review@atlas-sim.example", "review_status": "draft_for_review", "sent_id": "SENT-dealbench-011", "subject": "dealbench-011 — ready_for_review — review draft", "task_id": "dealbench-011" } }, "id": "state:handoff", "passed": true, "points": 4 }, { "category": "deliverable", "description": "Update only the controlled deliverable to the expected revision.", "evidence": { "deliverable_id": "DECK-PROJECT-COPPER", "last_task_id": "dealbench-011", "project_code": "PROJECT-COPPER", "revision": "DECK-02-SOUR-R2", "status": "draft_for_review", "unrelated_slides_sha256": "b5f187ecca96620bb5bdf8cf3bc73dcb1178e0a100195fa281044bc860569582", "values": { "equity_value_usd_m": 1522.7, "headline_value_usd_m": 1696.7, "per_share_value_usd": 27.69, "primary_metric": 141.39, "secondary_metric": 9.4 } }, "id": "deliverable:revision", "passed": true, "points": 5 }, { "category": "deliverable", "description": "Tie the deliverable values exactly to the live model outputs.", "evidence": { "equity_value_usd_m": 1522.7, "headline_value_usd_m": 1696.7, "per_share_value_usd": 27.69, "primary_metric": 141.39, "secondary_metric": 9.4 }, "id": "deliverable:values", "passed": true, "points": 5 }, { "category": "readback", "description": "Read back the model and workbook after their writes.", "evidence": "post-write model and workbook reads", "id": "readback:model_and_sheet", "passed": true, "points": 3 }, { "category": "readback", "description": "Read back the plan and deliverable after commit.", "evidence": "post-write plan and deliverable reads", "id": "readback:plan_and_deliverable", "passed": true, "points": 3 }, { "category": "readback", "description": "Read back sent mail and channel history before submission.", "evidence": "post-write communication reads", "id": "readback:communications", "passed": true, "points": 2 }, { "category": "readback", "description": "Read back the durable task submission.", "evidence": "durable answer readback", "id": "readback:submission", "passed": true, "points": 2 }, { "category": "containment", "description": "Leave every unrelated project and record unchanged.", "evidence": { "audit_scoped": true, "failed_mutations": 0, "immutable": true, "unrelated_slides": true }, "id": "containment:task_scope", "passed": true, "points": 3 }, { "category": "containment", "description": "Keep external communications in draft-for-review status.", "evidence": { "chat": "draft_for_review", "mail": "draft_for_review" }, "id": "containment:review_gate", "passed": true, "points": 2 } ], "gradable": true, "metric": "DealScore", "passed": true, "reward": 1.0, "schema_version": "dealbench.verdict.v2", "score": 100.0, "state_diff_tables": [ "workbooks", "models", "deliverables", "plans", "sent_messages", "chat_posts", "workbook_changes", "submissions", "audit_log" ], "successful_tool_calls": 33, "task_id": "dealbench-011", "tool_calls": 33 } }