geodml-emnlp-2026-reviewer / tables /probing_peaks_per_variant.csv
ValerianFourel's picture
Initial reviewer pack — condensed verifiable archive for EMNLP 2026 submission
c9eb63c verified
variant,treatment,pooling,peak_layer,peak_roc_auc,layer_0_roc_auc
biased,T1b_stats_density,last_token,62,0.9834,0.8611
biased,T1b_stats_density,mean,32,0.9877,0.9798
biased,T2a_question_headings,last_token,54,0.9868,0.8805
biased,T2a_question_headings,mean,24,0.9893,0.98
biased,T3_structured_data,last_token,35,0.9847,0.8744
biased,T3_structured_data,mean,18,0.9874,0.9797
biased,T4_citation_authority,last_token,30,0.9917,0.8955
biased,T4_citation_authority,mean,71,0.9938,0.9739
biased,T5_topical_comp,last_token,68,0.9649,0.8261
biased,T5_topical_comp,mean,46,0.974,0.9605
biased,T6_freshness,last_token,70,0.9859,0.8752
biased,T6_freshness,mean,73,0.9894,0.9829
biased,T7_llms_txt,last_token,19,0.9862,0.8794
biased,T7_llms_txt,mean,24,0.9896,0.9812
biased,T7_source_earned,last_token,68,0.9857,0.5644
biased,T7_source_earned,mean,48,0.9981,0.9856
biased,Y1_admission_inctx,last_token,60,0.8823,0.522
biased,Y1_admission_inctx,mean,56,0.8902,0.6971
neutral,T2a_question_headings,last_token,54,0.9868,0.8805
neutral,T2a_question_headings,mean,24,0.9893,0.98
neutral,T5_topical_comp,last_token,68,0.9649,0.8261
neutral,T5_topical_comp,mean,46,0.974,0.9605
neutral,T6_freshness,last_token,70,0.9859,0.8752
neutral,T6_freshness,mean,73,0.9894,0.9829
neutral,T7_source_earned,last_token,68,0.9805,0.5644
neutral,T7_source_earned,mean,48,0.9981,0.9856
neutral,Y1_admission_inctx,last_token,61,0.8757,0.521
neutral,Y1_admission_inctx,mean,53,0.8675,0.6399
biased_rag,T2a_question_headings,last_token,54,0.9868,0.8805
biased_rag,T2a_question_headings,mean,24,0.9893,0.98
biased_rag,T5_topical_comp,last_token,68,0.9649,0.8261
biased_rag,T5_topical_comp,mean,46,0.974,0.9605
biased_rag,T6_freshness,last_token,70,0.9859,0.8752
biased_rag,T6_freshness,mean,73,0.9894,0.9829
biased_rag,T7_source_earned,last_token,72,0.9868,0.5194
biased_rag,T7_source_earned,mean,48,0.9982,0.9858
biased_rag,Y1_admission_inctx,last_token,60,0.8651,0.4847
biased_rag,Y1_admission_inctx,mean,73,0.8768,0.6909
neutral_rag,T2a_question_headings,last_token,54,0.9868,0.8805
neutral_rag,T2a_question_headings,mean,24,0.9893,0.98
neutral_rag,T5_topical_comp,last_token,68,0.9649,0.8261
neutral_rag,T5_topical_comp,mean,46,0.974,0.9605
neutral_rag,T6_freshness,last_token,70,0.9859,0.8752
neutral_rag,T6_freshness,mean,73,0.9894,0.9829
neutral_rag,T7_source_earned,last_token,31,0.9816,0.5194
neutral_rag,T7_source_earned,mean,48,0.9982,0.9858
neutral_rag,Y1_admission_inctx,last_token,53,0.8589,0.5093
neutral_rag,Y1_admission_inctx,mean,60,0.87,0.6563