| angle_estimation_dataset_3000 Question-Design Validation Report |
| ========================================================== |
| Dataset version: angle-estimation-3.0.0 |
| Images/questions: 3000/15000 |
| Changes by level (answer or prompt): {'1': 0, '2': 366, '3': 671, '4': 1050, '5': 364} |
| Before distributions/baselines: {'1': {'counts': {'obtuse': 845, 'acute': 330, '2': 1050, '3': 750, 'right': 25}, 'constant_answer_baseline': 0.35}, '2': {'counts': {'300': 47, '45': 75, '195': 56, '180': 44, '285': 43, '150': 61, '330': 47, 'Angle 1': 520, 'Angle 2': 530, 'acute': 250, '240': 43, '15': 46, '315': 51, '30': 77, '255': 45, '60': 70, 'right': 250, '90': 38, 'obtuse': 250, '105': 51, '225': 50, '165': 63, '345': 41, '120': 69, '75': 56, '210': 52, '135': 69, '270': 6}, 'constant_answer_baseline': 0.17666666666666667}, '3': {'counts': {'greater than': 845, 'less than': 330, '40': 105, '20': 130, '10': 89, '80': 88, '30': 122, 'C': 138, 'A': 561, '90': 69, 'approximately equal to': 25, '50': 103, '60': 76, '100': 63, 'B': 51, '70': 80, '110': 44, '130': 27, '150': 8, '120': 23, '140': 21, '160': 2}, 'constant_answer_baseline': 0.2816666666666667}, '4': {'counts': {'118': 6, '141': 5, '15': 7, '135': 31, '0': 35, '109': 8, '36': 8, '157': 5, 'right': 77, 'straight': 204, 'neither': 769, '180': 750, '65': 9, '162': 7, '133': 6, '116': 11, '150': 31, '54': 6, '68': 12, '126': 7, '114': 3, '161': 8, '67': 3, '14': 3, '90': 25, '156': 3, '24': 6, '125': 13, '19': 8, '148': 7, '70': 11, '44': 10, '120': 31, '22': 8, '55': 12, '159': 6, '140': 7, '60': 23, '106': 6, '57': 5, '139': 7, '39': 8, '79': 6, '164': 8, '28': 6, '107': 6, '33': 7, '168': 6, '27': 8, '124': 5, '160': 10, '61': 3, '165': 7, '16': 14, '42': 7, '119': 5, '46': 11, '17': 7, '137': 9, '35': 7, '58': 8, '41': 6, '134': 7, '143': 7, '170': 5, '147': 9, '29': 9, '103': 7, '59': 9, '49': 9, '145': 8, '66': 7, '151': 11, '138': 5, '20': 8, '12': 6, '121': 5, '53': 5, '50': 7, '26': 10, '97': 4, '38': 4, '163': 5, '110': 11, '158': 6, '62': 6, '21': 7, '18': 8, '63': 6, '100': 8, '102': 9, '25': 4, '98': 7, '127': 4, '132': 7, '74': 10, '23': 11, '144': 10, '37': 8, '10': 11, '131': 11, '34': 7, '7': 8, '111': 11, '76': 7, '153': 4, '123': 5, '154': 9, '64': 3, '96': 6, '112': 6, '80': 8, '78': 5, '11': 6, '9': 7, '130': 8, '71': 3, '105': 4, '77': 6, '113': 5, '45': 12, '40': 6, '56': 7, '122': 8, '108': 6, '115': 6, '75': 2, '69': 9, '8': 11, '13': 8, '167': 3, '72': 4, '47': 13, '129': 8, '30': 9, '52': 9, '128': 5, '117': 3, '101': 5, '6': 1, '82': 4, '51': 7, '84': 6, '73': 2, '32': 5, '136': 3, '48': 6, '152': 4, '142': 7, '166': 5, '146': 7, '81': 7, '83': 3, '169': 11, '31': 8, '99': 4, '155': 7, '43': 4, '149': 2, '104': 1}, 'constant_answer_baseline': 0.25633333333333336}, '5': {'counts': {'exceeds 180': 856, 'less than 180': 344, 'smaller': 515, 'larger': 535, '190,no': 750}, 'constant_answer_baseline': 0.2853333333333333}} |
| After distributions/baselines: {'1': {'counts': {'obtuse': 845, 'acute': 330, '2': 1050, '3': 750, 'right': 25}, 'constant_answer_baseline': 0.35}, '2': {'counts': {'300': 47, '45': 75, '195': 56, '180': 44, '285': 43, '150': 61, '330': 47, 'Angle 1': 524, 'Angle 2': 526, 'acute': 250, '240': 43, '15': 46, '315': 51, '30': 77, '255': 45, '60': 70, 'right': 250, '90': 38, 'obtuse': 250, '105': 51, '225': 50, '165': 63, '345': 41, '120': 69, '75': 56, '210': 52, '135': 69, '270': 6}, 'constant_answer_baseline': 0.17533333333333334}, '3': {'counts': {'greater than': 845, 'less than': 330, '40': 117, '20': 132, '10': 101, '110': 40, 'C': 138, 'A': 561, '140': 24, '30': 125, '120': 28, 'approximately equal to': 25, '60': 88, '90': 52, '100': 51, 'B': 51, '50': 124, '70': 63, '130': 30, '80': 61, '150': 12, '160': 2}, 'constant_answer_baseline': 0.2816666666666667}, '4': {'counts': {'118': 6, '141': 5, '15': 7, '135': 31, '0': 35, '109': 8, '36': 8, '157': 5, 'right': 350, 'straight': 350, 'neither': 350, '180': 750, '65': 9, '162': 7, '133': 6, '116': 11, '150': 31, '54': 6, '68': 12, '126': 7, '114': 3, '161': 8, '67': 3, '14': 3, '90': 25, '156': 3, '24': 6, '125': 13, '19': 8, '148': 7, '70': 11, '44': 10, '120': 31, '22': 8, '55': 12, '159': 6, '140': 7, '60': 23, '106': 6, '57': 5, '139': 7, '39': 8, '79': 6, '164': 8, '28': 6, '107': 6, '33': 7, '168': 6, '27': 8, '124': 5, '160': 10, '61': 3, '165': 7, '16': 14, '42': 7, '119': 5, '46': 11, '17': 7, '137': 9, '35': 7, '58': 8, '41': 6, '134': 7, '143': 7, '170': 5, '147': 9, '29': 9, '103': 7, '59': 9, '49': 9, '145': 8, '66': 7, '151': 11, '138': 5, '20': 8, '12': 6, '121': 5, '53': 5, '50': 7, '26': 10, '97': 4, '38': 4, '163': 5, '110': 11, '158': 6, '62': 6, '21': 7, '18': 8, '63': 6, '100': 8, '102': 9, '25': 4, '98': 7, '127': 4, '132': 7, '74': 10, '23': 11, '144': 10, '37': 8, '10': 11, '131': 11, '34': 7, '7': 8, '111': 11, '76': 7, '153': 4, '123': 5, '154': 9, '64': 3, '96': 6, '112': 6, '80': 8, '78': 5, '11': 6, '9': 7, '130': 8, '71': 3, '105': 4, '77': 6, '113': 5, '45': 12, '40': 6, '56': 7, '122': 8, '108': 6, '115': 6, '75': 2, '69': 9, '8': 11, '13': 8, '167': 3, '72': 4, '47': 13, '129': 8, '30': 9, '52': 9, '128': 5, '117': 3, '101': 5, '6': 1, '82': 4, '51': 7, '84': 6, '73': 2, '32': 5, '136': 3, '48': 6, '152': 4, '142': 7, '166': 5, '146': 7, '81': 7, '83': 3, '169': 11, '31': 8, '99': 4, '155': 7, '43': 4, '149': 2, '104': 1}, 'constant_answer_baseline': 0.25}, '5': {'counts': {'exceeds 180': 856, 'less than 180': 344, 'smaller': 593, 'larger': 457, '190,no': 750}, 'constant_answer_baseline': 0.2853333333333333}} |
| Features at V >= 0.10 (nothing hidden): {"canvas_size": {"1": {"classification": "scene_feature", "cramers_v": 0.7743534281862694, "justification": null, "kind": "categorical"}, "2": {"classification": "scene_feature", "cramers_v": 0.7698717239082997, "justification": null, "kind": "categorical"}, "3": {"classification": "scene_feature", "cramers_v": 0.7748708658808346, "justification": null, "kind": "categorical"}, "4": {"classification": "scene_feature", "cramers_v": 0.7756249837581568, "justification": null, "kind": "categorical"}, "5": {"classification": "scene_feature", "cramers_v": 0.782011425290792, "justification": null, "kind": "categorical"}}, "difficulty_score": {"1": {"classification": "scene_feature", "cramers_v": 0.8731080884125804, "justification": null, "kind": "numeric_deciles"}, "2": {"classification": "scene_feature", "cramers_v": 0.9970108807623623, "justification": null, "kind": "numeric_deciles"}, "3": {"classification": "scene_feature", "cramers_v": 0.8731080884125804, "justification": null, "kind": "numeric_deciles"}, "4": {"classification": "scene_feature", "cramers_v": 0.8577689246435114, "justification": null, "kind": "numeric_deciles"}, "5": {"classification": "scene_feature", "cramers_v": 0.8707254584105054, "justification": null, "kind": "numeric_deciles"}}, "scene_type": {"1": {"classification": "scene_feature", "cramers_v": 1.0, "justification": null, "kind": "categorical"}, "2": {"classification": "scene_feature", "cramers_v": 1.0, "justification": null, "kind": "categorical"}, "3": {"classification": "scene_feature", "cramers_v": 1.0, "justification": null, "kind": "categorical"}, "4": {"classification": "scene_feature", "cramers_v": 1.0, "justification": null, "kind": "categorical"}, "5": {"classification": "scene_feature", "cramers_v": 1.0, "justification": null, "kind": "categorical"}}} |
| Definitional whitelist with justifications: {"angle_1_degrees": {"2": "defines larger-angle label", "3": "defines difference", "4": "defines sum bucket", "5": "defines doubled-smaller comparison"}, "angle_2_degrees": {"2": "defines larger-angle label", "3": "defines difference", "4": "defines sum bucket", "5": "defines doubled-smaller comparison"}, "angle_degrees": {"1": "defines single-angle class", "2": "defines rounded estimate", "3": "defines comparison with 90", "4": "defines distance from 180", "5": "defines doubled result"}, "largest_angle_vertex": {"3": "is the triangle L3 answer"}, "triangle_class": {"2": "is the triangle-class answer"}} |
| dataset_version: angle-estimation-3.0.0 |
| images: 3000 |
| questions: 15000 |
| changes_by_level_including_prompt_changes: {'1': 0, '2': 366, '3': 671, '4': 1050, '5': 364} |
| angle_sum_rule: right if within 15 degrees of 90; straight if within 15 degrees of 180; otherwise neither |
| boundary_margin_degrees: 2 |
| observed_minimum_boundary_distance_degrees: 2.0263920000000013 |
| generation_rejection_count: 7310 |
| guard_injection_tests: {'violating_14_degrees_from_boundary_rejected': True, 'boundary_13_degrees_inside_accepted': True, 'boundary_17_degrees_outside_accepted': True} |
| comparison_level4_distribution: {'right': 350, 'straight': 350, 'neither': 350} |
| Full leak matrix and full parameter distributions: validation_metrics.json |
|
|
| Summary: PASS |
|
|
