{"run_id": "2026-09-03-1802-google_gemini-2.5-flash-image-conditioned", "model": "google/gemini-2.5-flash-image", "provider": "openrouter", "track": "conditioned", "task_id": "01-meet-proxy", "image": "evaluations/2026-09-03-1802-google_gemini-2.5-flash-image-conditioned/01-meet-proxy.png", "shape": 1, "color": 0, "face": 0, "style": 1, "bufoness": 2, "task_score": 3, "checks": [true, true, true], "judge_verdict": "FAIL", "judge_model": "google/gemini-2.5-flash", "rubric": "v2", "judge_agreement": null, "overridden": true, "expert_verdict": null, "notes": "The frog is smiling and has small, front-facing eyes, which are clear indicators of the 'cute-Sanrio frog' failure mode. The color is also off, being an olive-drab green. [runner overrode judge (FAIL/3) per rubric]"}
{"run_id": "2026-09-03-1802-google_gemini-2.5-flash-image-conditioned", "model": "google/gemini-2.5-flash-image", "provider": "openrouter", "track": "conditioned", "task_id": "02-morning-coffee", "image": "evaluations/2026-09-03-1802-google_gemini-2.5-flash-image-conditioned/02-morning-coffee.png", "shape": 0, "color": 0, "face": 0, "style": 1, "bufoness": 1, "task_score": 2, "checks": [true, true, false], "judge_verdict": "FAIL", "judge_model": "google/gemini-2.5-flash", "rubric": "v2", "judge_agreement": null, "overridden": true, "expert_verdict": null, "notes": "This is an olive-drab MS-paint frog. The colors are wrong, the eyes are small and deadpan, and it has a mouth. This is not Bufo. [runner overrode judge (FAIL/3) per rubric]"}
{"run_id": "2026-09-03-1802-google_gemini-2.5-flash-image-conditioned", "model": "google/gemini-2.5-flash-image", "provider": "openrouter", "track": "conditioned", "task_id": "03-party-hat", "image": "evaluations/2026-09-03-1802-google_gemini-2.5-flash-image-conditioned/03-party-hat.png", "shape": 0, "color": 0, "face": 0, "style": 0, "bufoness": 0, "task_score": 3, "checks": [true, true, true], "judge_verdict": "FAIL", "judge_model": "google/gemini-2.5-flash", "rubric": "v2", "judge_agreement": null, "overridden": false, "expert_verdict": null, "notes": "This is an olive-drab MS-paint frog. The colors are wrong, the eyes are small and deadpan, and the overall style is flat and lacks the canonical Bufo characteristics."}
{"run_id": "2026-09-03-1802-google_gemini-2.5-flash-image-conditioned", "model": "google/gemini-2.5-flash-image", "provider": "openrouter", "track": "conditioned", "task_id": "04-thumbs-up", "image": "evaluations/2026-09-03-1802-google_gemini-2.5-flash-image-conditioned/04-thumbs-up.png", "shape": 1, "color": 1, "face": 0, "style": 1, "bufoness": 3, "task_score": 3, "checks": [true, true, true], "judge_verdict": "FAIL", "judge_model": "google/gemini-2.5-flash", "rubric": "v2", "judge_agreement": null, "overridden": false, "expert_verdict": null, "notes": "This frog has a mouth and the eyes are not worried or sidelong, failing the core Bufo face. The colors are also too drab."}
{"run_id": "2026-09-03-1802-google_gemini-2.5-flash-image-conditioned", "model": "google/gemini-2.5-flash-image", "provider": "openrouter", "track": "conditioned", "task_id": "05-sleeping", "image": "evaluations/2026-09-03-1802-google_gemini-2.5-flash-image-conditioned/05-sleeping.png", "shape": 1, "color": 0, "face": 0, "style": 1, "bufoness": 2, "task_score": 3, "checks": [true, true, true], "judge_verdict": "FAIL", "judge_model": "google/gemini-2.5-flash", "rubric": "v2", "judge_agreement": null, "overridden": true, "expert_verdict": null, "notes": "This is an olive-drab MS-paint frog. The color is wrong, the eyes are small and deadpan, and it has a mouth, which are all failure modes. [runner overrode judge (FAIL/3) per rubric]"}
{"run_id": "2026-09-03-1804-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned", "model": "google/gemini-3-pro-image", "provider": "openrouter", "track": "conditioned", "task_id": "01-meet-proxy", "image": "evaluations/2026-09-03-1804-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned/01-meet-proxy.png", "shape": 1, "color": 0, "face": 0, "style": 1, "bufoness": 2, "task_score": 3, "checks": [true, true, true], "judge_verdict": "FAIL", "judge_model": "google/gemini-2.5-flash", "rubric": "v2", "judge_agreement": null, "overridden": true, "expert_verdict": null, "notes": "This frog is an olive-drab MS-paint frog, with khaki colors, small beady eyes, and a mouth. This caps the bufoness score at 3. [runner overrode judge (FAIL/3) per rubric]"}
{"run_id": "2026-09-03-1804-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned", "model": "google/gemini-3-pro-image", "provider": "openrouter", "track": "conditioned", "task_id": "02-morning-coffee", "image": "evaluations/2026-09-03-1804-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned/02-morning-coffee.png", "shape": 0, "color": 0, "face": 0, "style": 0, "bufoness": 0, "task_score": 3, "checks": [true, true, true], "judge_verdict": "FAIL", "judge_model": "google/gemini-2.5-flash", "rubric": "v2", "judge_agreement": null, "overridden": false, "expert_verdict": null, "notes": "This is an olive-drab MS-paint frog. The colors are wrong, the eyes are small and deadpan, and the overall style is flat and wobbly. This is a failure mode, capping bufoness at 3."}
{"run_id": "2026-09-03-1804-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned", "model": "google/gemini-3-pro-image", "provider": "openrouter", "track": "conditioned", "task_id": "03-party-hat", "image": "evaluations/2026-09-03-1804-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned/03-party-hat.png", "shape": 0, "color": 0, "face": 0, "style": 0, "bufoness": 0, "task_score": 3, "checks": [true, true, true], "judge_verdict": "FAIL", "judge_model": "google/gemini-2.5-flash", "rubric": "v2", "judge_agreement": null, "overridden": true, "expert_verdict": null, "notes": "This is an olive-drab MS-paint frog. The colors are wrong, the eyes are small and deadpan, and it has a mouth. This caps the bufoness score at 3. [runner overrode judge (FAIL/3) per rubric]"}
{"run_id": "2026-09-03-1804-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned", "model": "google/gemini-3-pro-image", "provider": "openrouter", "track": "conditioned", "task_id": "04-thumbs-up", "image": "evaluations/2026-09-03-1804-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned/04-thumbs-up.png", "shape": 1, "color": 0, "face": 0, "style": 0, "bufoness": 1, "task_score": 3, "checks": [true, true, true], "judge_verdict": "FAIL", "judge_model": "google/gemini-2.5-flash", "rubric": "v2", "judge_agreement": null, "overridden": true, "expert_verdict": null, "notes": "This is a cute-Sanrio frog with a smile, round plush body, and khaki colors, which caps the bufoness score at 3. The eyes are also not the iconic worried sidelong glance. [runner overrode judge (FAIL/3) per rubric]"}
{"run_id": "2026-09-03-1804-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned", "model": "google/gemini-3-pro-image", "provider": "openrouter", "track": "conditioned", "task_id": "05-sleeping", "image": "evaluations/2026-09-03-1804-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned/05-sleeping.png", "shape": 1, "color": 0, "face": 0, "style": 1, "bufoness": 2, "task_score": 3, "checks": [true, true, true], "judge_verdict": "FAIL", "judge_model": "google/gemini-2.5-flash", "rubric": "v2", "judge_agreement": null, "overridden": true, "expert_verdict": null, "notes": "The candidate image is an olive-drab MS-paint frog, which is a failure mode. The colors are wrong, and the face lacks the iconic Bufo snout and eye style. [runner overrode judge (FAIL/3) per rubric]"}
{"run_id": "2026-09-03-1826-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned", "model": "google/gemini-3-pro-image", "provider": "openrouter", "track": "conditioned", "task_id": "01-meet-proxy", "image": "evaluations/2026-09-03-1826-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned/01-meet-proxy.png", "shape": 1, "color": 2, "face": 0, "style": 2, "bufoness": 5, "task_score": 3, "checks": [true, true, true], "judge_verdict": "FAIL", "judge_model": "anthropic/claude-sonnet-4", "rubric": "v4.1", "judge_agreement": "4/5 vs expert", "overridden": false, "expert_verdict": "FAIL", "notes": "Face fails due to wide-open glossy eyes gazing directly forward in cute-alert expression, opposite of Bufo's worried averted gaze."}
{"run_id": "2026-09-03-1826-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned", "model": "google/gemini-3-pro-image", "provider": "openrouter", "track": "conditioned", "task_id": "02-morning-coffee", "image": "evaluations/2026-09-03-1826-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned/02-morning-coffee.png", "shape": 2, "color": 2, "face": 2, "style": 2, "bufoness": 8, "task_score": 3, "checks": [true, true, true], "judge_verdict": "PASS", "judge_model": "anthropic/claude-sonnet-4", "rubric": "v4.1", "judge_agreement": "4/5 vs expert", "overridden": false, "expert_verdict": "PASS", "notes": "Perfect Bufo with heavy-lidded averted gaze holding white mug with steam curls, maintaining the canonical worried expression."}
{"run_id": "2026-09-03-1826-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned", "model": "google/gemini-3-pro-image", "provider": "openrouter", "track": "conditioned", "task_id": "03-party-hat", "image": "evaluations/2026-09-03-1826-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned/03-party-hat.png", "shape": 2, "color": 2, "face": 0, "style": 2, "bufoness": 6, "task_score": 2, "checks": [true, true, false], "judge_verdict": "FAIL", "judge_model": "anthropic/claude-sonnet-4", "rubric": "v4.1", "judge_agreement": "4/5 vs expert", "overridden": false, "expert_verdict": "PASS", "notes": "Perfect Bufo shape and color with party hat, but the wide-open forward-gazing eyes with glossy highlights create a cute-alert expression rather than the required blank unimpressed worry."}
{"run_id": "2026-09-03-1826-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned", "model": "google/gemini-3-pro-image", "provider": "openrouter", "track": "conditioned", "task_id": "04-thumbs-up", "image": "evaluations/2026-09-03-1826-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned/04-thumbs-up.png", "shape": 2, "color": 2, "face": 0, "style": 2, "bufoness": 6, "task_score": 2, "checks": [true, true, false], "judge_verdict": "FAIL", "judge_model": "anthropic/claude-sonnet-4", "rubric": "v4.1", "judge_agreement": "4/5 vs expert", "overridden": true, "expert_verdict": "FAIL", "notes": "Clear thumbs-up gesture and proper Bufo construction, but has a distinct mouth line which violates the narrow cap and fails the no-mouth checklist requirement. [runner overrode judge (FAIL/3) per rubric]"}
{"run_id": "2026-09-03-1826-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned", "model": "google/gemini-3-pro-image", "provider": "openrouter", "track": "conditioned", "task_id": "05-sleeping", "image": "evaluations/2026-09-03-1826-google_gemini-3-pro-image-conditioned/05-sleeping.png", "shape": 2, "color": 2, "face": 2, "style": 2, "bufoness": 8, "task_score": 3, "checks": [true, true, true], "judge_verdict": "PASS", "judge_model": "anthropic/claude-sonnet-4", "rubric": "v4.1", "judge_agreement": "4/5 vs expert", "overridden": false, "expert_verdict": "PASS", "notes": "Perfect sleeping Bufo with closed eyes as simple lines, slumped posture, and Z's indicating sleep."}