{ "derived_checks": { "authorization_execution_chain_valid": { "authorized_event_key": "g02:authorized:g02-switch-phi4mini", "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "registered_event_key": "asset:g02-switch-phi4mini", "succeeded_event_key": "g02:succeeded:g02-switch-phi4mini", "value": true }, "child_absent_from_learning_frontier": { "asset_id": "g02-switch-phi4mini", "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "value": true }, "child_absent_from_research_confirmed_assets": { "asset_id": "g02-switch-phi4mini", "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "value": true }, "child_absent_from_search_eligible_assets": { "asset_id": "g02-switch-phi4mini", "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "value": true }, "child_excluded_from_confirm_freeze": { "eligible_asset_ids": [ "g02-evolve-g01-canonicalize-historical-be", "g02-reuse-g01-canonicalize-historical-be" ], "freeze_receipt_sha256": "23b0607d93d46ccf29e105a7468b422de2267b8b8b88dec4c9af8de7ebb97032", "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "value": true }, "comparison_control_not_synthesized_as_parent": { "control_asset_id": "RAW_MISTRAL", "lineage_kind": "SUBSTRATE_SWITCH", "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "value": true }, "confirm_authority_bound_to_prior_freeze": { "authority_bound_freeze_receipt_sha256": "23b0607d93d46ccf29e105a7468b422de2267b8b8b88dec4c9af8de7ebb97032", "confirm_authority_recorded_at": "2026-09-14T09:16:46.243Z", "freeze_receipt_sha256": "23b0607d93d46ccf29e105a7468b422de2267b8b8b88dec4c9af8de7ebb97032", "freeze_recorded_at": "2026-09-14T09:16:46.197Z", "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "value": true }, "confirm_evidence_absent_as_recorded": { "confirm_evidence_role": null, "confirm_record": null, "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "value": true }, "distinct_prediction_system_content_identity": { "child_content_identity_sha256": "e4b556b45a819864c607b02578a4926494543a4484d2a811c0b7a878899e3a71", "control_content_identity_sha256": "da34ac2ab3c9f68cbbad228578fe497f1fbfab1a3375586d53af513efe1eeea0", "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "value": true }, "distinct_substrate_snapshot": { "child_snapshot_content_sha256": "1dd43cebc169f18b97d7957f008915dffe732fd23c66331a1256696ed2205c04", "control_snapshot_content_sha256": "7d8f7d2e09deeb321df898edf67ae484a4d243814e3f64a0b2126b9a655bb984", "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "value": true }, "ledger_hash_chain_valid": { "final_newline_required": true, "ledger_head_sha256": "054311b729e4ab8b0d8d53cf74ae76a9ce5262dab80fdd0efc87898d2344d819", "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "value": true }, "ledger_registry_adjudication_payload_match": { "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "value": true }, "measurement_evidence_role_bindings_valid": { "child_measurement_receipt_sha256": "a74eb2c1fd5c05ecdca7d3ce8221f4089b9a8d501f22797dcca3a3befca5d220", "control_measurement_receipt_sha256": "b53c58ba9373b6cba3826472b7bfb7459ead450df4dac22a7c1c7b724217cde0", "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "value": true }, "measurement_identity_bindings_valid": { "child_identity_receipt_sha256": "8ab488537a64340633a8944559120fd9b7ecb2408e1657acb4e37362d3b8c880", "control_identity_receipt_sha256": "389117bb787e79114311f0dc803fb8e867d0408558eb298030b118bc60e39c6d", "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "value": true }, "no_physical_parent_recorded": { "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "registered_lineage": { "experiment_id": "g02-switch-phi4mini", "hypothesis_id": "g02-h4-substrate", "kind": "SUBSTRATE_SWITCH" }, "runtime_lineage": { "experiment_id": "g02-switch-phi4mini", "hypothesis_id": "g02-h4-substrate", "kind": "SUBSTRATE_SWITCH" }, "value": true }, "raw_substrate_child_without_adapter": { "adapter_bytes": 0, "adapter_relpath": null, "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "value": true }, "refutation_target_criterion_failed": { "minimum_target_cell_delta": 0.05, "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "target_delta": -0.125, "value": true }, "search_dataset_control_child_match": { "dataset_sha256": "265a632dc3362f77b09b9b4b79a474ed0bcd04ec8168789df3ce1c2d1d24318a", "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "value": true }, "search_only_evidence_recorded": { "measured_event_key": "g02:measured:g02-switch-phi4mini", "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "scientific_evidence_role": "SEARCH", "value": true }, "status_accuracy_delta_recomputed": { "matches": true, "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "recorded": 0.012499999999999956, "value": 0.012499999999999956 }, "target_delta_recomputed": { "matches": true, "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "recorded": -0.125, "value": -0.125 }, "worst_family_label_delta_recomputed": { "matches": true, "origin": "DERIVED_CHECK", "recorded": 0.0, "value": 0.0 } }, "limitations": [ "This projection covers one g02 substrate-switch research experiment, not the terminal v0.18 qualification outcome.", "The experiment was adjudicated on SEARCH evidence only because the child was not search-eligible and was excluded from the SEARCH_CONFIRM freeze.", "REFUTED is the recorded experiment/hypothesis adjudication for this tested Phi-4-mini substrate realization and does not establish a universal claim about Phi-4-mini or alternative substrates.", "No physical parent asset is recorded for this SUBSTRATE_SWITCH realization; the projection therefore does not fabricate one." ], "projection": { "projection_engine_id": "amf-public-evidence-projection/v0.1/python-stdlib", "projection_engine_sha256": "e84d86ba718f76e55ec62e92ea61fe7683010667440ef7926af916513a6e8f32", "projection_id": "v018-exp-003", "projection_sha256": "78f5f6b0de028063e55823c8749b9adceae0139395392b4e984e5bc36c623901", "projection_sha256_basis": "canonical JSON of the complete projection with projection.projection_sha256 set to null", "projection_version": "0.1", "source_set_sha256": "9a7d84cdbb772d682abee7b0de9d45f63aad4840ec100550c7d52a5d6972ff1b" }, "projection_of": { "experiment_id": "g02-switch-phi4mini", "run_id": "20260914T081215Z" }, "provenance": { "notes": [ "The historical Scientific Event Ledger, registry, receipts, identities, measurements, and dataset bytes remain authoritative over this projection.", "The projection does not expose planner scores, candidate rankings, or unselected experiment proposals.", "The recorded experiment and hypothesis verdicts are preserved verbatim as REFUTED; no semantic relabeling is performed.", "RAW_MISTRAL is projected as the recorded contemporaneous comparison control, not as a synthesized physical parent of the Phi substrate realization.", "The hypothesis context source g01-canonicalize-historical-best-v017a21 is preserved inside the hypothesis evidence context and is not reinterpreted as realization lineage.", "No SEARCH_CONFIRM measurement is synthesized for this experiment; the recorded ASSET_MEASURED event contains confirm_evidence_role=null and confirm_record=null." ], "source_manifest": [ { "bytes": 157963, "path": "20260914T081215Z/SCIENTIFIC_EVENT_LEDGER.jsonl", "sha256": "ff28dfdd5ec4a02d1f51504d30f2d2014b1e75109618242de81146f329ec8f74" }, { "bytes": 455, "path": "20260914T081215Z/assets/RAW_MISTRAL/ASSET_RUNTIME.json", "sha256": "673727f60ab10599f962a505bab600ec649a5008d6fbd922cf1223ee07d3b019" }, { "bytes": 8956, "path": "20260914T081215Z/assets/g02-switch-phi4mini/ASSET_RUNTIME.json", "sha256": "d46c7a2750a2377a995aec65d72e0c1fa5d74061f288228df6db650bf092c173" }, { "bytes": 742, "path": "20260914T081215Z/generations/g02/SEARCH_CANDIDATE_FREEZE.json", "sha256": "12465dbcc7f1ba67d6b057eaf29696352440cebe4eab5ebf1cacf4bf51b84330" }, { "bytes": 2193, "path": "20260914T081215Z/generations/g02/SEARCH_CONFIRM_AUTHORITY.json", "sha256": "14a5c73df47f8edc31d26308175dc113aac02811c5cd19f1cce83d7526ebbd61" }, { "bytes": 421, "path": "20260914T081215Z/generations/g02/measurements/search/RAW_MISTRAL.EVIDENCE_ROLE.json", "sha256": "3f49ad5f682d0b3e16b19c3e4fb6c924b4a0a6769ee36018f7315b92d3a882f1" }, { "bytes": 1698, "path": "20260914T081215Z/generations/g02/measurements/search/RAW_MISTRAL.json", "sha256": "d8877ca627582a27596cf5caeaac165ca676916c958050713bd9dbda5fd257b2" }, { "bytes": 429, "path": "20260914T081215Z/generations/g02/measurements/search/g02-switch-phi4mini.EVIDENCE_ROLE.json", "sha256": "0ea33a9b3a65385be9ee5679d51c2e7bf25c272bbb7d387f1cc22a648be01635" }, { "bytes": 1693, "path": "20260914T081215Z/generations/g02/measurements/search/g02-switch-phi4mini.json", "sha256": "bec4886f0c273be5e21baa47aa77c5f4b611ea8e4ace243d291da0d3376c19c7" }, { "bytes": 315105, "path": "20260914T081215Z/generations/g02/research_datasets/search_adaptive.jsonl", "sha256": "265a632dc3362f77b09b9b4b79a474ed0bcd04ec8168789df3ce1c2d1d24318a" }, { "bytes": 594, "path": "20260914T081215Z/generations/g02/worker_receipts/EVAL_SEARCH_RAW_MISTRAL.json", "sha256": "619126db8d7713b747709e6449d8e0a6434ab6bd0afc028353bd16bcdb0d840b" }, { "bytes": 602, "path": "20260914T081215Z/generations/g02/worker_receipts/EVAL_SEARCH_g02-switch-phi4mini.json", "sha256": "80fca911e13e5ddccfb15d2a1c1447b4872c7e2c5f66067013132bf33ad4e03b" }, { "bytes": 611, "path": "20260914T081215Z/identities/RAW_MISTRAL.json", "sha256": "48b8c5bed40f70d6e6b5a5394ccf2a0fb72ba55b1dc9674bbd177e3b842e3bd5" }, { "bytes": 607, "path": "20260914T081215Z/identities/g02-switch-phi4mini.json", "sha256": "05dc9d0f461ca72a36925e6c9b414b76976d7ba2dc88834bba083d958ed2cd67" }, { "bytes": 49376, "path": "20260914T081215Z/state/EXPERIMENT_KNOWLEDGE_REGISTRY.json", "sha256": "fe12b92ac9f12968b6592137cdade97f0bef4b9bdce771787b973b37e4b5179e" }, { "bytes": 355, "path": "20260914T081215Z/subjects/RAW_MISTRAL/PREDICTION_SYSTEM.json", "sha256": "649dea8296fd2e4b3bdc4b1c51a816ee09e46a3f7c223e9742aad7544bd5b5f1" }, { "bytes": 410, "path": "20260914T081215Z/subjects/g02-switch-phi4mini/PREDICTION_SYSTEM.json", "sha256": "77a95e646f2876765a7395cb072d43f4edcd7fcc844ca8b1dea85df20a3fd4c1" } ], "source_manifest_hash_algorithm": "sha256(canonical-json(source_manifest))" }, "schema": "amf/public-evidence-projection/v0.1", "source_claims": { "child": { "origin": "SOURCE", "source_refs": [ { "path": "20260914T081215Z/identities/g02-switch-phi4mini.json" }, { "path": "20260914T081215Z/assets/g02-switch-phi4mini/ASSET_RUNTIME.json" }, { "path": "20260914T081215Z/subjects/g02-switch-phi4mini/PREDICTION_SYSTEM.json" }, { "event_key": "asset:g02-switch-phi4mini", "event_sha256": "842c093891a5ee541f73520b1876f8dab3d98d2fada10ba1c8fcbadcfa338d72", "event_type": "REALIZATION_REGISTERED", "path": "20260914T081215Z/SCIENTIFIC_EVENT_LEDGER.jsonl", "seq": 66 } ], "value": { "adapter_bytes": 0, "adapter_relpath": null, "asset_id": "g02-switch-phi4mini", "identity_receipt_sha256": "8ab488537a64340633a8944559120fd9b7ecb2408e1657acb4e37362d3b8c880", "model_id": "microsoft/Phi-4-mini-instruct", "prediction_system_content_identity_sha256": "e4b556b45a819864c607b02578a4926494543a4484d2a811c0b7a878899e3a71", "resource_class": 4.0, "revision": "cfbefacb99257ffa30c83adab238a50856ac3083", "snapshot_content_sha256": "1dd43cebc169f18b97d7957f008915dffe732fd23c66331a1256696ed2205c04", "target_alias": "phi4mini" } }, "comparison": { "origin": "SOURCE", "source_refs": [ { "path": "20260914T081215Z/identities/RAW_MISTRAL.json" }, { "path": "20260914T081215Z/assets/RAW_MISTRAL/ASSET_RUNTIME.json" }, { "path": "20260914T081215Z/subjects/RAW_MISTRAL/PREDICTION_SYSTEM.json" }, { "json_pointer": "/adjudications/g02-switch-phi4mini", "object_sha256": "289f7734ae995a33ee6faa1f02b6d931617d9b7932ed983a3c6b71726c976eda", "path": "20260914T081215Z/state/EXPERIMENT_KNOWLEDGE_REGISTRY.json" }, { "event_key": "g02:adjudicated:g02-switch-phi4mini", "event_sha256": "5cb63660c38873387cc7c24d2c576f34255126ef0cd48feaf4343576c13e9601", "event_type": "EXPERIMENT_ADJUDICATED", "path": "20260914T081215Z/SCIENTIFIC_EVENT_LEDGER.jsonl", "seq": 76 } ], "value": { "after": { "status_accuracy": 0.5604166666666667, "target_cell_accuracy": 0.375, "worst_family_label_accuracy": 0.0 }, "before": { "status_accuracy": 0.5479166666666667, "target_cell_accuracy": 0.5, "worst_family_label_accuracy": 0.0 }, "control": { "adapter_bytes": 0, "adapter_relpath": null, "identity_receipt_sha256": "389117bb787e79114311f0dc803fb8e867d0408558eb298030b118bc60e39c6d", "model_id": "mistralai/Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.3", "prediction_system_content_identity_sha256": "da34ac2ab3c9f68cbbad228578fe497f1fbfab1a3375586d53af513efe1eeea0", "resource_class": 7.0, "revision": "c170c708c41dac9275d15a8fff4eca08d52bab71", "snapshot_content_sha256": "7d8f7d2e09deeb321df898edf67ae484a4d243814e3f64a0b2126b9a655bb984", "target_alias": "mistral7b" }, "control_asset_id": "RAW_MISTRAL", "effect": { "status_accuracy_delta": 0.012499999999999956, "target_cell_delta": -0.125, "train_target_cell_delta": -0.203125, "worst_family_label_accuracy_delta": 0.0 }, "target": { "family": "records", "label": "INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE", "metric": "family_label_accuracy" } } }, "evidence": { "origin": "SOURCE", "source_refs": [ { "path": "20260914T081215Z/generations/g02/research_datasets/search_adaptive.jsonl" }, { "path": "20260914T081215Z/generations/g02/measurements/search/g02-switch-phi4mini.json" }, { "path": "20260914T081215Z/generations/g02/measurements/search/g02-switch-phi4mini.EVIDENCE_ROLE.json" }, { "path": "20260914T081215Z/generations/g02/measurements/search/RAW_MISTRAL.json" }, { "path": "20260914T081215Z/generations/g02/measurements/search/RAW_MISTRAL.EVIDENCE_ROLE.json" }, { "event_key": "g02:measured:g02-switch-phi4mini", "event_sha256": "3ae7e3019e67af945de5bf81e771346649cdecdf21aab9bc24526c0ac0ea1025", "event_type": "ASSET_MEASURED", "path": "20260914T081215Z/SCIENTIFIC_EVENT_LEDGER.jsonl", "seq": 75 } ], "value": { "dataset_sha256": "265a632dc3362f77b09b9b4b79a474ed0bcd04ec8168789df3ce1c2d1d24318a", "fresh_final_used": false, "protected_data_used": false, "sample_count": 480, "scientific_evidence_role": "SEARCH", "underlying_trust_role": "SEARCH" } }, "experiment": { "origin": "SOURCE", "source_refs": [ { "json_pointer": "/adjudications/g02-switch-phi4mini", "object_sha256": "289f7734ae995a33ee6faa1f02b6d931617d9b7932ed983a3c6b71726c976eda", "path": "20260914T081215Z/state/EXPERIMENT_KNOWLEDGE_REGISTRY.json" }, { "event_key": "g02:adjudicated:g02-switch-phi4mini", "event_sha256": "5cb63660c38873387cc7c24d2c576f34255126ef0cd48feaf4343576c13e9601", "event_type": "EXPERIMENT_ADJUDICATED", "path": "20260914T081215Z/SCIENTIFIC_EVENT_LEDGER.jsonl", "seq": 76 } ], "value": { "generation": 2, "id": "g02-switch-phi4mini" } }, "experiment_verdict": { "origin": "SOURCE", "source_refs": [ { "json_pointer": "/adjudications/g02-switch-phi4mini", "object_sha256": "289f7734ae995a33ee6faa1f02b6d931617d9b7932ed983a3c6b71726c976eda", "path": "20260914T081215Z/state/EXPERIMENT_KNOWLEDGE_REGISTRY.json" }, { "event_key": "g02:adjudicated:g02-switch-phi4mini", "event_sha256": "5cb63660c38873387cc7c24d2c576f34255126ef0cd48feaf4343576c13e9601", "event_type": "EXPERIMENT_ADJUDICATED", "path": "20260914T081215Z/SCIENTIFIC_EVENT_LEDGER.jsonl", "seq": 76 } ], "value": "REFUTED" }, "falsification_criteria": { "origin": "SOURCE", "source_refs": [ { "json_pointer": "/adjudications/g02-switch-phi4mini", "object_sha256": "289f7734ae995a33ee6faa1f02b6d931617d9b7932ed983a3c6b71726c976eda", "path": "20260914T081215Z/state/EXPERIMENT_KNOWLEDGE_REGISTRY.json" }, { "event_key": "g02:adjudicated:g02-switch-phi4mini", "event_sha256": "5cb63660c38873387cc7c24d2c576f34255126ef0cd48feaf4343576c13e9601", "event_type": "EXPERIMENT_ADJUDICATED", "path": "20260914T081215Z/SCIENTIFIC_EVENT_LEDGER.jsonl", "seq": 76 } ], "value": { "maximum_status_accuracy_regression": 0.1, "minimum_target_cell_delta": 0.05 } }, "hypothesis": { "origin": "SOURCE", "source_refs": [ { "event_key": "g02:hypothesis:g02-h4-substrate", "event_sha256": "0ca9d6cd104e78496ceddc7b49c9dff61e02c055a9cc39d9c3d2e2010cd42705", "event_type": "HYPOTHESIS_CREATED", "path": "20260914T081215Z/SCIENTIFIC_EVENT_LEDGER.jsonl", "seq": 50 } ], "value": { "claim": "If adapter evolution is refuted on fresh evidence, an untested allowed substrate may provide more information than repeating the same transformation family.", "evidence_context": { "current_source_asset": "g01-canonicalize-historical-best-v017a21", "evidence_role": "SEARCH_CONFIRM" }, "id": "g02-h4-substrate", "target": { "direction": "INCREASE", "family": "records", "label": "INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE", "metric": "family_label_accuracy" }, "type": "ALTERNATIVE_SUBSTRATE" } }, "hypothesis_verdict": { "origin": "SOURCE", "source_refs": [ { "event_key": "g02:hypothesis-verdict:g02-h4-substrate", "event_sha256": "71627b43d36994f8f45ac6102315be5bc14ddedbc9bef8efc037bd594e30ea0a", "event_type": "HYPOTHESIS_ADJUDICATED", "path": "20260914T081215Z/SCIENTIFIC_EVENT_LEDGER.jsonl", "seq": 80 } ], "value": "REFUTED" }, "intervention": { "origin": "SOURCE", "source_refs": [ { "path": "20260914T081215Z/assets/g02-switch-phi4mini/ASSET_RUNTIME.json" }, { "path": "20260914T081215Z/subjects/g02-switch-phi4mini/PREDICTION_SYSTEM.json" }, { "path": "20260914T081215Z/generations/g02/worker_receipts/EVAL_SEARCH_g02-switch-phi4mini.json" }, { "event_key": "g02:authorized:g02-switch-phi4mini", "event_sha256": "dd78811827deb80889f01994c9fdc3ad18cd6b347c5887d4bd69e94670e17da4", "event_type": "EXPERIMENT_AUTHORIZED", "path": "20260914T081215Z/SCIENTIFIC_EVENT_LEDGER.jsonl", "seq": 58 }, { "event_key": "g02:succeeded:g02-switch-phi4mini", "event_sha256": "7a1a13c081b65730d0eee62fc27b32953f3d9030551cdcb3dd80b788cfe69180", "event_type": "EXPERIMENT_SUCCEEDED", "path": "20260914T081215Z/SCIENTIFIC_EVENT_LEDGER.jsonl", "seq": 65 }, { "event_key": "asset:g02-switch-phi4mini", "event_sha256": "842c093891a5ee541f73520b1876f8dab3d98d2fada10ba1c8fcbadcfa338d72", "event_type": "REALIZATION_REGISTERED", "path": "20260914T081215Z/SCIENTIFIC_EVENT_LEDGER.jsonl", "seq": 66 } ], "value": { "adapter_bytes": 0, "adapter_relpath": null, "input_transform": null, "model_id": "microsoft/Phi-4-mini-instruct", "operation_type": "SUBSTRATE_SWITCH", "optimizer_steps": 0, "resource_class": 4.0, "revision": "cfbefacb99257ffa30c83adab238a50856ac3083", "snapshot_content_sha256": "1dd43cebc169f18b97d7957f008915dffe732fd23c66331a1256696ed2205c04", "target_alias": "phi4mini" } }, "research_status": { "origin": "SOURCE", "source_refs": [ { "path": "20260914T081215Z/assets/g02-switch-phi4mini/ASSET_RUNTIME.json" }, { "event_key": "g02:completed", "event_sha256": "24e5a1162905eb4557833d8b4d88c16397d4a3463fa49c8f3378edb80dfa7285", "event_type": "GENERATION_COMPLETED", "path": "20260914T081215Z/SCIENTIFIC_EVENT_LEDGER.jsonl", "seq": 82 } ], "value": { "generation_best_confirmed_asset_id": "g02-reuse-g01-canonicalize-historical-be", "generation_best_search_asset_id": "g02-evolve-g01-canonicalize-historical-be", "research_confirmed": false, "search_eligible": false } } } }