# Three-jury — family campaign (2026-07-30)

> **Superseded historical packet.** Current CTA and evidence authority lives in
> `results/RELEASE_MANIFEST.json` and `results/triple_aug3_lock.json`; candidate
> calendar slots below are not promotion authorization.

**Overall:** `PASS_CONTINUE_PREP` · all_go=true
**Mode:** Manwë three-seat appellate (Lórien chair **timeout** after health-ok; single attempt, no retry)
**Built:** 2026-07-30T15:21:39+07:00
**Not:** freeze clearance · promo GO · GPU ship gate
**JSON sha12:** `a63b57a0bfe9`

## Tip bind

| Pack | HEAD | dirty | Class | Headline |
|------|------|------:|-------|----------|
| Laguna-S-2.1-Spark-Agentic | `ca92272` | 0 | measured | 40/40 · 27/27 · 21.47 · measure tip `bf82eab` |
| Qwen3-Coder-Next-Spark-Agentic | `e54d988` | 0 | preview probe | FP8 pull complete · smoke 2/2 **≠ gate** |
| DeepSeek-V4-Flash-REAP25-Spark-Agentic | `0e7a1ef` | 0 | scaffold hold | unmeasured · TYPE40 HOLD_RELEASE |
| Laguna-XS (sibling) | `1cee5f7` | 1 NOTICE | unmeasured | out of S freeze set |

## Calendar (SoT)

- Freeze: **2026-08-02 18:00 WIB**
- List all three: **2026-08-03 12:00 WIB**
- Historical candidate slots at this snapshot: Laguna **08-03 20:00** · Qwen **08-04 20:00** · DeepSeek **08-05 20:00**. **None is current CTA authorization.**

## Seats

### Fable-5 measure → GO_CONTINUE_PREP
- Laguna measure tip intact; docs tip ≠ measure tip (by design).
- Qwen 2/2 probe only; DeepSeek no smoke.
- DFlash still no-promote.

### Sol-5.6 serve → GO_CONTINUE_PREP
- Ports 8000/8001/8002 · diy_gguf false · Spark-only weights for Laguna.
- Non-blocking: Spark missing Qwen/REAP trees; Laguna Spark git behind Mac docs tip.

### Composer-2.5 pack → GO_CONTINUE_PREP_WITH_NAMED_GAP
- Cards honest on finetune auto-tag + Parameters tables.
- **Named gap:** HF collection missing REAP25 canonical; still has legacy DeepSeek member.

## Continue authority

**Allowed now:** collection fix, Spark pack-tree sync (docs), honesty patches, campaign checklist under `promo_pre=false`, DeepSeek paper preflight without GPU.

**Forbidden now:** public promo/hero, Qwen-ship or DeepSeek-measured claims, early freeze, diy_gguf, Mac internal weights, company-gate vault write, treating this as freeze/launch GO.

## Founder decisions (one at a time — first defaults recommended)

1. **Collection membership** — add REAP25; keep legacy only if labeled redirect (else drop).
2. **base_model auto-tag** — keep bare YAML policy (recommended).
3. **DeepSeek hero path** — pre-write NO-HERO demotion; flip only if freeze gate actually clears.

## Counter-case

PASS_CONTINUE_PREP ≠ freeze GO ≠ promo GO.
Collection lag can still confuse strangers.
Qwen "40/40" shard language collides with Laguna smoke if skimmed.
Lórien did not co-sign.

## Artifact

- JSON: `results/three_jury_family_campaign_2026-07-30.json`
- Prior still in force: `results/three_jury_post_dflash_2026-07-29.json`