# Three-jury — family post-harden (2026-07-30)

> **Superseded historical packet (18:00 WIB).** Current authority is
> `results/RELEASE_MANIFEST.json` + `results/triple_aug3_lock.json`: no hero CTA
> is authorized before its explicit gate, and root `config.yaml` is the SAQS
> runtime manifest. The tips and calendar below describe this earlier jury only.

**Overall:** `PASS_CONTINUE_PREP` · all_go=true
**Mode:** three-seat appellate (chair **not co-signed**)
**Built:** 2026-07-30T18:00:45.587682+07:00
**Not:** freeze clearance · promo GO · GPU ship gate · headline claim
**JSON sha12:** `a591c19f0162`

## Tip bind (origin/main)

| Pack | HEAD | dirty | Class | Harden headline |
|------|------|------:|-------|-----------------|
| Laguna-S | `b82d33d` | 1 | measured-prior / harden-docs | scorer args_equals + sandbox + install |
| Laguna-XS | `bf942ac` | 0 | unmeasured sibling | scorer parity + honesty README |
| Qwen3-Coder-Next | `9849410` | 0 | preview probe | public FP8 path only + disk gate |
| DeepSeek REAP25 | `1ca5cda` | 0 | scaffold hold | TYPE40 x1.3 + BIN honesty |

## Calendar (SoT)

- Freeze: **2026-08-02 18:00 WIB**
- List all three: **2026-08-03 12:00 WIB**
- Historical candidate slots at this snapshot: Laguna **08-03 20:00** · Qwen **08-04 20:00** · DeepSeek **08-05 20:00**. **None is current CTA authorization.**

## Seats

### Fable-5 measure → GO_CONTINUE_PREP
- Harden tips clean and origin-synced on main (Laguna-S keeps local untracked jury artifacts only).
- Laguna S+XS: scorer enforces args_equals + path_must_be_sandbox on multi_05/repair_03/long_05; smoke_class labels smoke!=headline.
- Qwen: public FP8 path only (serve_spark -> serve_vllm_fp8); pull disk gate on; diy_gguf false; smoke remains probe class, not headline gate.
- DeepSeek: TYPE40 remote size x1.3 disk gate + binary-class honesty on serve; still scaffold HOLD / unmeasured.
- Install manifests (hermes/config.yaml + INSTALL.yaml) present on S/Q/DS.
- Prior Laguna 40/40 measure tip is NOT re-run on harden tip — do not claim fresh 40/40 on harden HEAD without re-smoke.

**Named gaps:**
- No fresh Laguna agent_smoke on harden tip b82d33d.
- DeepSeek still zero smoke / unmeasured through freeze risk.
- HF collection REAP25 membership gap from prior jury still open.

### Sol-5.6 serve → GO_CONTINUE_PREP
- Ports contract unchanged: Laguna :8000, Qwen :8001, DeepSeek :8002; loopback default; EXPOSE_LAN=1 for LAN.
- diy_gguf=false preserved across install manifests.
- DeepSeek disk gate strengthens fail-closed pull (free < remote x1.3).
- Qwen pull floor gate reduces disk surprises on Spark.
- Weights still external-not-in-git; Laguna Spark residency / weight trees not re-verified this pass.

**Named gaps:**
- Spark tree sync / weight residency not re-probed this jury.
- DeepSeek default BIN remains poolside/laguna fork — honest, so no product-runtime claim while HOLD.

### Composer-2.5 pack → GO_CONTINUE_PREP_WITH_NAMED_GAP
- README honesty blocks on all 4 packs: smoke!=headline, launch class, no campaign CTA.
- Superseded contract note: current packs use root `config.yaml` with a `saqs.*` schema; `hermes/config.yaml` is compatibility-only.
- XS scorer parity with S without inventing install manifest (XS parked Mac).
- Commit messages scoped; no promo language in harden set.

**Named gaps:**
- Prior named gap still open: HF collection missing REAP25 canonical / may still list legacy DeepSeek member.
- Hub may still auto-tag base_model finetune on card surfaces — bare YAML policy remains correct.
- Qwen case count (2) vs Laguna (40) still easy to conflate for skimmers — README warns; card/collection copy must too.

## Continue authority

**Allowed now:**
- HF collection membership fix (REAP25 + legacy redirect/drop)
- Spark pack-tree / docs sync
- Honesty patches and campaign checklist under promo_pre=false
- DeepSeek paper/preflight without GPU or HOLD_RELEASE
- Optional Laguna S re-smoke on harden tip (bind receipt only)
- NO-HERO DeepSeek pre-write

**Forbidden now:**
- public promo / hero windows early
- Qwen-ship or DeepSeek-measured claims
- early freeze
- diy_gguf true
- Mac internal weights for wts/stage/upload
- company-gate vault write for this portfolio
- treating PASS_CONTINUE_PREP as freeze GO or promo GO

## Founder decisions (one at a time — first = recommended)

1. **collection_membership** — HF collection: add DeepSeek-V4-Flash-REAP25 canonical; keep legacy DeepSeek only if labeled redirect, else drop.
   - Reco: Add REAP25 + label-or-drop legacy this session window.
2. **base_model_autotag** — Keep bare YAML base_model / no base_model_relation on founder-auth native tree?
   - Reco: Keep bare YAML policy (already memory-locked).
3. **deepseek_hero_path** — Pre-write NO-HERO demotion for DeepSeek; flip only if freeze evidence gate clears.
   - Reco: Write NO-HERO now; do not rely on freeze miracle.
4. **relabel_smoke_on_harden_tip** — Re-run Laguna S agent_smoke on tip b82d33d before freeze, or keep prior measure tip as sole 40/40 bind?
   - Reco: Schedule one short smoke on harden tip if Spark free; until then any 40/40 card cite must bind prior measure tip, not harden tip.

## Juries → do next (ordered)

- 1) Collection membership fix (founder HF) — highest external-confusion risk.
- 2) DeepSeek NO-HERO demotion draft in pack + calendar note.
- 3) Decide re-smoke Laguna S on b82d33d vs keep prior measure tip bind.
- 4) Spark residency probe (Laguna wts present; Qwen FP8 tree; DS TYPE40 absent until HOLD_RELEASE).
- 5) Campaign checklist freeze-readiness under promo_pre=false (no public CTA).

## Counter-case

- PASS_CONTINUE_PREP is not freeze GO and not promo GO.
- Harden tip is not a re-measure tip — citing 40/40 on b82d33d without re-smoke is dishonest.
- Collection lag still confuses strangers on DeepSeek identity.
- DeepSeek hero on 08-05 is likely NO-HERO unless evidence appears; plan demotion now.
- Chair seat did not co-sign this appellate.

## Artifact

- JSON: `results/three_jury_family_post_harden_2026-07-30.json`
- Prior still in force: `results/THREE_JURY_FAMILY_2026-07-30.md`
- DFlash prior: `results/three_jury_post_dflash_2026-07-29.json`