GitHub Action commited on
Commit
306cfae
·
1 Parent(s): 4574f92

Sync from GitHub with Git LFS

Browse files
Files changed (1) hide show
  1. docs/HMP-0005.md +17 -18
docs/HMP-0005.md CHANGED
@@ -2245,10 +2245,25 @@ Used when the node explicitly defines the meaning of a concept or term.
2245
 
2246
  > **Note:** Containers referencing semantic terms SHOULD include a `related.definition` field pointing to the defining `semantic_node` to ensure consistent semantic alignment across the Mesh.
2247
 
2248
- > **Note:** Deprecated or outdated definitions MAY be marked via `evaluations` entries (e.g., `"type": "outdated", "value": -1"`), or superseded through standard versioning mechanisms using `related.previous_version`. This approach maintains continuity in the semantic lineage while allowing agents to reflect evolving conceptual understanding over time.
2249
-
2250
  > **See also:** The `semantic_index` container describes how agents manage and publish their active sets of semantic definitions.
2251
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
2252
  ---
2253
 
2254
  ##### Container `semantic_index`
@@ -2352,22 +2367,6 @@ When `meta.framework` values differ significantly, agents SHOULD treat definitio
2352
 
2353
  ---
2354
 
2355
- ##### Intra-framework Evaluation
2356
-
2357
- Agents MAY record evaluations of definitions authored by other agents **within the same `meta.framework`**
2358
- to indicate the degree of **semantic correspondence or conceptual proximity**, rather than agreement or opposition.
2359
-
2360
- When doing so, the agent SHOULD include in the `evaluations` entry:
2361
-
2362
- * `"type": "semantic_similarity"` — indicates comparison of meaning rather than endorsement;
2363
- * `"value"` — numerical estimate of semantic closeness (e.g., `1` = near-identical, `0` = related but distinct, `-1` = incompatible interpretation);
2364
- * `"target"` — DID of the definition container currently adopted by the evaluating agent as its `actual` reference point.
2365
-
2366
- Such evaluations are **not reputational judgments**, but signals used for mapping internal coherence within a theoretical framework.
2367
- They help agents quantify degrees of shared understanding and support the emergence of **semantic topology** across the Mesh.
2368
-
2369
- ---
2370
-
2371
  ###### Merging
2372
 
2373
  When aligning its own active definitions with those discovered in other agents’ indexes,
 
2245
 
2246
  > **Note:** Containers referencing semantic terms SHOULD include a `related.definition` field pointing to the defining `semantic_node` to ensure consistent semantic alignment across the Mesh.
2247
 
 
 
2248
  > **See also:** The `semantic_index` container describes how agents manage and publish their active sets of semantic definitions.
2249
 
2250
+ ####### Intra-framework Evaluation
2251
+
2252
+ Deprecated or outdated definitions MAY be marked via `evaluations` entries (e.g., `"type": "outdated", "value": -1"`), or superseded through standard versioning mechanisms using `related.previous_version`. This approach maintains continuity in the semantic lineage while allowing agents to reflect evolving conceptual understanding over time.
2253
+
2254
+ Agents MAY evaluate definitions created by other agents **within the same `meta.framework`**
2255
+ to express their assessment of conceptual validity or alignment.
2256
+
2257
+ When doing so, the agent SHOULD include in the `evaluations` entry:
2258
+
2259
+ * `"type": "semantic_similarity"` — indicates semantic assessment within a shared framework;
2260
+ * `"value"` — numerical estimate of conceptual agreement
2261
+ (e.g., `1` = strong alignment, `0` = partial correspondence, `-1` = incompatible or incorrect interpretation);
2262
+ * `"target"` — DID of the definition container currently adopted by the evaluating agent as its `actual` reference point.
2263
+
2264
+ Such evaluations contribute to the **reputational weighting of definitions** within a theoretical framework,
2265
+ allowing agents to converge on more coherent or widely accepted interpretations over time.
2266
+
2267
  ---
2268
 
2269
  ##### Container `semantic_index`
 
2367
 
2368
  ---
2369
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
2370
  ###### Merging
2371
 
2372
  When aligning its own active definitions with those discovered in other agents’ indexes,