diff --git "a/magicquant-manifest/magicquant.replacements.json" "b/magicquant-manifest/magicquant.replacements.json" new file mode 100644--- /dev/null +++ "b/magicquant-manifest/magicquant.replacements.json" @@ -0,0 +1,3252 @@ +[ + { + "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.", + "rawReason": "smart baseline-tuning strict dominance fallback: real benchmark validated lower KLD at same-or-smaller size", + "removed": { + "key": "118:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q6_K_XL.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q6_K_XL", + "shortName": "UD-Q6_K_XL", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q6_K_XL", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.005183, + "ppl": 5.683428, + "pplDeltaPercent": -0.0628099173553742, + "sizeBytes": 31843776928, + "sizeGB": 31.843776928, + "sizeGiB": 29.656828314065933 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "118:103:119:119:119:119:118:119:0:119", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-Q6_K_1.gguf", + "displayName": "MQ-Q6_K_1", + "shortName": "MQ-Q6_K_1", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q6_K", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.005149, + "ppl": 5.673763, + "pplDeltaPercent": -0.23275892386144126, + "sizeBytes": 31590586784, + "sizeGB": 31.590586784000003, + "sizeGiB": 29.42102661728859 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 3.4000000000000176E-05, + "sizeBytes": 253190144, + "sizeGB": 0.253190144, + "sizeGiB": 0.23580169677734375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": -0.0628099173553742, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": -0.23275892386144126, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.16994900650606706 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.", + "rawReason": "smart baseline-tuning strict dominance fallback: real benchmark validated lower KLD at same-or-smaller size", + "removed": { + "key": "117:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q6_K.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q6_K", + "shortName": "UD-Q6_K", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q6_K", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.005696, + "ppl": 5.677694, + "pplDeltaPercent": -0.1636363636363721, + "sizeBytes": 29308320160, + "sizeGB": 29.30832016, + "sizeGiB": 27.295500189065933 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "117:103:118:118:118:118:118:118:0:118", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-Q5_K_1.gguf", + "displayName": "MQ-Q5_K_1", + "shortName": "MQ-Q5_K_1", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q5_K", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.005523, + "ppl": 5.68002, + "pplDeltaPercent": -0.12273606470899297, + "sizeBytes": 29185153440, + "sizeGB": 29.18515344, + "sizeGiB": 27.18079224228859 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.00017299999999999954, + "sizeBytes": 123166720, + "sizeGB": 0.12316672, + "sizeGiB": 0.11470794677734375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": -0.1636363636363721, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": -0.12273606470899297, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.04090029892737913 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.", + "rawReason": "strict predicted hybrid dominance validated by real benchmark", + "removed": { + "key": "116:103:117:117:117:117:117:118:0:117", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-Q5_K_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-Q5_K_S", + "shortName": "MQ-UD-Q5_K_XL", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q5_K_XL", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.006853, + "ppl": 5.685761, + "pplDeltaPercent": -0.021786530684016002, + "sizeBytes": 26404329888, + "sizeGB": 26.404329888, + "sizeGiB": 24.59094849228859 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "114:103:115:115:115:115:115:115:0:115", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-Q5_K_S_1.gguf", + "displayName": "MQ-Q5_K_S_1", + "shortName": "MQ-Q5_K_S_1", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q5_K_S", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.00673, + "ppl": 5.679092, + "pplDeltaPercent": -0.1390539827677241, + "sizeBytes": 26333026720, + "sizeGB": 26.33302672, + "sizeGiB": 24.52454224228859 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.00012299999999999985, + "sizeBytes": 71303168, + "sizeGB": 0.071303168, + "sizeGiB": 0.06640625, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": -0.021786530684016002, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": -0.1390539827677241, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.11726745208370809 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.", + "rawReason": "smart baseline-tuning strict dominance fallback: real benchmark validated lower KLD at same-or-smaller size", + "removed": { + "key": "116:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q5_K_XL.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q5_K_XL", + "shortName": "UD-Q5_K_XL", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q5_K_XL", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.006864, + "ppl": 5.678817, + "pplDeltaPercent": -0.14388957270970137, + "sizeBytes": 26592508320, + "sizeGB": 26.59250832, + "sizeGiB": 24.766203314065933 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "116:103:117:117:117:117:117:118:0:117", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-Q5_K_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-Q5_K_S", + "shortName": "MQ-UD-Q5_K_XL", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q5_K_XL", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.006853, + "ppl": 5.685761, + "pplDeltaPercent": -0.021786530684016002, + "sizeBytes": 26404329888, + "sizeGB": 26.404329888, + "sizeGiB": 24.59094849228859 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 1.1000000000000593E-05, + "sizeBytes": 188178432, + "sizeGB": 0.18817843199999998, + "sizeGiB": 0.17525482177734375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": -0.14388957270970137, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": -0.021786530684016002, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.12210304202568537 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.", + "rawReason": "strict predicted hybrid dominance validated by real benchmark", + "removed": { + "key": "116:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q5_K_XL.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q5_K_XL", + "shortName": "UD-Q5_K_XL", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q5_K_XL", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.006864, + "ppl": 5.678817, + "pplDeltaPercent": -0.14388957270970137, + "sizeBytes": 26592508320, + "sizeGB": 26.59250832, + "sizeGiB": 24.766203314065933 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "114:103:115:115:115:115:115:115:0:115", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-Q5_K_S_1.gguf", + "displayName": "MQ-Q5_K_S_1", + "shortName": "MQ-Q5_K_S_1", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q5_K_S", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.00673, + "ppl": 5.679092, + "pplDeltaPercent": -0.1390539827677241, + "sizeBytes": 26333026720, + "sizeGB": 26.33302672, + "sizeGiB": 24.52454224228859 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.00013400000000000044, + "sizeBytes": 259481600, + "sizeGB": 0.25948160000000003, + "sizeGiB": 0.24166107177734375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": -0.14388957270970137, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": -0.1390539827677241, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.004835589941977275 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.", + "rawReason": "smart baseline-tuning strict dominance fallback: real benchmark validated lower KLD at same-or-smaller size", + "removed": { + "key": "114:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q5_K_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q5_K_M", + "shortName": "UD-Q5_K_M", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q5_K_M", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.007072, + "ppl": 5.679171, + "pplDeltaPercent": -0.1376648496571142, + "sizeBytes": 26456193440, + "sizeGB": 26.456193440000003, + "sizeGiB": 24.639250189065933 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "114:103:115:115:115:115:115:115:0:115", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-Q5_K_S_1.gguf", + "displayName": "MQ-Q5_K_S_1", + "shortName": "MQ-Q5_K_S_1", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q5_K_S", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.00673, + "ppl": 5.679092, + "pplDeltaPercent": -0.1390539827677241, + "sizeBytes": 26333026720, + "sizeGB": 26.33302672, + "sizeGiB": 24.52454224228859 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0003420000000000003, + "sizeBytes": 123166720, + "sizeGB": 0.12316672, + "sizeGiB": 0.11470794677734375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": -0.1376648496571142, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": -0.1390539827677241, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.001389133110609897 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.", + "rawReason": "smart baseline-tuning strict dominance fallback: real benchmark validated lower KLD at same-or-smaller size", + "removed": { + "key": "115:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q5_K_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q5_K_S", + "shortName": "UD-Q5_K_S", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q5_K_S", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.007824, + "ppl": 5.692164, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.09080358712853392, + "sizeBytes": 24942049696, + "sizeGB": 24.942049695999998, + "sizeGiB": 23.229093939065933 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "115:103:116:116:116:116:116:116:0:116", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-Q4_K_M_1.gguf", + "displayName": "MQ-Q4_K_M_1", + "shortName": "MQ-Q4_K_M_1", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q4_K_M", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.007799, + "ppl": 5.685451, + "pplDeltaPercent": -0.027237559345888666, + "sizeBytes": 24818882976, + "sizeGB": 24.818882976, + "sizeGiB": 23.11438599228859 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 2.499999999999898E-05, + "sizeBytes": 123166720, + "sizeGB": 0.12316672, + "sizeGiB": 0.11470794677734375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.09080358712853392, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": -0.027237559345888666, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.1180411464744226 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.", + "rawReason": "smart baseline-tuning strict dominance fallback: real benchmark validated lower KLD at same-or-smaller size", + "removed": { + "key": "113:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q4_K_XL.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q4_K_XL", + "shortName": "UD-Q4_K_XL", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q4_K_XL", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.011207, + "ppl": 5.692678, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.09984174432916525, + "sizeBytes": 22360455584, + "sizeGB": 22.360455584, + "sizeGiB": 20.824797064065933 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "113:114:114:114:114:114:114:116:0:114", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-Q4_K_M_2.gguf", + "displayName": "MQ-Q4_K_M_2", + "shortName": "MQ-Q4_K_M_2", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q4_K_M", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.011007, + "ppl": 5.694152, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.12576050641813968, + "sizeBytes": 22324804000, + "sizeGB": 22.324804, + "sizeGiB": 20.791593939065933 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.00020000000000000052, + "sizeBytes": 35651584, + "sizeGB": 0.035651584, + "sizeGiB": 0.033203125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.09984174432916525, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 0.12576050641813968, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.025918762088974437 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "111:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q4_K_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q4_K_M", + "shortName": "UD-Q4_K_M", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q4_K_M", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.011409, + "ppl": 5.695264, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.14531387374713567, + "sizeBytes": 22134528416, + "sizeGB": 22.134528416000002, + "sizeGiB": 20.61438599228859 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "113:114:114:114:114:114:114:116:0:114", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-Q4_K_M_2.gguf", + "displayName": "MQ-Q4_K_M_2", + "shortName": "MQ-Q4_K_M_2", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q4_K_M", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.011007, + "ppl": 5.694152, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.12576050641813968, + "sizeBytes": 22324804000, + "sizeGB": 22.324804, + "sizeGiB": 20.791593939065933 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0004020000000000013, + "sizeBytes": -190275584, + "sizeGB": -0.190275584, + "sizeGiB": -0.17720794677734375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.14531387374713567, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 0.12576050641813968, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.019553367328995985 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.", + "rawReason": "strict hybrid dominance: best accepted actual KLD at same-or-smaller real size", + "removed": { + "key": "112:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q4_K_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q4_K_S", + "shortName": "UD-Q4_K_S", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q4_K_S", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.013393, + "ppl": 5.709169, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.38981888517671676, + "sizeBytes": 20893014432, + "sizeGB": 20.893014432, + "sizeGiB": 19.45813599228859 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:1:1:1:1:112:113:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_NL_1.gguf", + "displayName": "MQ-IQ4_NL_1", + "shortName": "MQ-IQ4_NL_1", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "IQ4_NL", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.013277, + "ppl": 5.708942, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.38582732547916526, + "sizeBytes": 20887239072, + "sizeGB": 20.887239072, + "sizeGiB": 19.45275726914406 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.00011599999999999978, + "sizeBytes": 5775360, + "sizeGB": 0.00577536, + "sizeGiB": 0.00537872314453125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.38981888517671676, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 0.38582732547916526, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.003991559697551494 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:103:1:2:1:1:112:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_NL.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_NL", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.014189, + "ppl": 5.701422, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.2535959205204803, + "sizeBytes": 20414331296, + "sizeGB": 20.414331296, + "sizeGiB": 19.01232758164406 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:1:1:1:1:112:113:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_NL_1.gguf", + "displayName": "MQ-IQ4_NL_1", + "shortName": "MQ-IQ4_NL_1", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "IQ4_NL", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.013277, + "ppl": 5.708942, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.38582732547916526, + "sizeBytes": 20887239072, + "sizeGB": 20.887239072, + "sizeGiB": 19.45275726914406 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0009119999999999996, + "sizeBytes": -472907776, + "sizeGB": -0.472907776, + "sizeGiB": -0.4404296875, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.2535959205204803, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 0.38582732547916526, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.13223140495868496 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:114:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_NL.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_NL", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.014221, + "ppl": 5.697566, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.1857921575523097, + "sizeBytes": 20358273440, + "sizeGB": 20.35827344, + "sizeGiB": 18.960119634866714 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:1:2:1:1:112:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_NL.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_NL", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.014189, + "ppl": 5.701422, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.2535959205204803, + "sizeBytes": 20414331296, + "sizeGB": 20.414331296, + "sizeGiB": 19.01232758164406 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 3.199999999999904E-05, + "sizeBytes": -56057856, + "sizeGB": -0.056057856, + "sizeGiB": -0.05220794677734375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.1857921575523097, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 0.2535959205204803, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.06780376296817059 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:103:1:1:1:1:7:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.015257, + "ppl": 5.716926, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.5262176894672002, + "sizeBytes": 19861207456, + "sizeGB": 19.861207456, + "sizeGiB": 18.49719086289406 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:114:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_NL.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_NL", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.014221, + "ppl": 5.697566, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.1857921575523097, + "sizeBytes": 20358273440, + "sizeGB": 20.35827344, + "sizeGiB": 18.960119634866714 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0010360000000000005, + "sizeBytes": -497065984, + "sizeGB": -0.497065984, + "sizeGiB": -0.46292877197265625, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.5262176894672002, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 0.1857921575523097, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.34042553191489044 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:3:1:1:1:1:7:111:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.015428, + "ppl": 5.731319, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.7793036750483519, + "sizeBytes": 19835607456, + "sizeGB": 19.835607456, + "sizeGiB": 18.473349004983902 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:1:1:1:1:7:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.015257, + "ppl": 5.716926, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.5262176894672002, + "sizeBytes": 19861207456, + "sizeGB": 19.861207456, + "sizeGiB": 18.49719086289406 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.000171000000000001, + "sizeBytes": -25600000, + "sizeGB": -0.0256, + "sizeGiB": -0.02384185791015625, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.7793036750483519, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 0.5262176894672002, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.2530859855811517 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "INTERIOR_DISCOVERY", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was selected as a useful interior point inside a size/KLD gap between anchors.", + "rawReason": "interior subspace discovery dominated by real benchmark truth", + "removed": { + "key": "0:103:1:1:1:1:7:111:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_NL.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_NL", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.015447, + "ppl": 5.730909, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.7720942500439477, + "sizeBytes": 19903150496, + "sizeGB": 19.903150496, + "sizeGiB": 18.53625336289406 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:1:1:1:1:7:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.015257, + "ppl": 5.716926, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.5262176894672002, + "sizeBytes": 19861207456, + "sizeGB": 19.861207456, + "sizeGiB": 18.49719086289406 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.00019000000000000093, + "sizeBytes": 41943040, + "sizeGB": 0.04194304, + "sizeGiB": 0.0390625, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.7720942500439477, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 0.5262176894672002, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.24587656057674756 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:3:1:1:1:1:7:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.015629, + "ppl": 5.734911, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.8424652716722355, + "sizeBytes": 19793664416, + "sizeGB": 19.793664416, + "sizeGiB": 18.434286504983902 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:3:1:1:1:1:7:111:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.015428, + "ppl": 5.731319, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.7793036750483519, + "sizeBytes": 19835607456, + "sizeGB": 19.835607456, + "sizeGiB": 18.473349004983902 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0002009999999999998, + "sizeBytes": -41943040, + "sizeGB": -0.04194304, + "sizeGiB": -0.0390625, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.8424652716722355, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 0.7793036750483519, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.06316159662388365 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:103:1:2:1:1:7:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.01568, + "ppl": 5.725093, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.6698259187620877, + "sizeBytes": 19698678176, + "sizeGB": 19.698678175999998, + "sizeGiB": 18.34582367539406 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:3:1:1:1:1:7:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.015629, + "ppl": 5.734911, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.8424652716722355, + "sizeBytes": 19793664416, + "sizeGB": 19.793664416, + "sizeGiB": 18.434286504983902 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 5.099999999999896E-05, + "sizeBytes": -94986240, + "sizeGB": -0.09498624000000001, + "sizeGiB": -0.08846282958984375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.6698259187620877, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 0.8424652716722355, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.17263935291014776 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:7:7:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.017713, + "ppl": 5.742713, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.9796553543168612, + "sizeBytes": 19320445344, + "sizeGB": 19.320445344, + "sizeGiB": 17.993566900491714 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:1:2:1:1:7:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.01568, + "ppl": 5.725093, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.6698259187620877, + "sizeBytes": 19698678176, + "sizeGB": 19.698678175999998, + "sizeGiB": 18.34582367539406 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.002033, + "sizeBytes": -378232832, + "sizeGB": -0.37823283199999996, + "sizeGiB": -0.35225677490234375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.9796553543168612, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 0.6698259187620877, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.3098294355547735 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:7:2:2:1:1:7:7:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.018614, + "ppl": 5.753295, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.165728855283969, + "sizeBytes": 19173439904, + "sizeGB": 19.173439904, + "sizeGiB": 17.856657415628433 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:7:7:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.017713, + "ppl": 5.742713, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.9796553543168612, + "sizeBytes": 19320445344, + "sizeGB": 19.320445344, + "sizeGiB": 17.993566900491714 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.000900999999999999, + "sizeBytes": -147005440, + "sizeGB": -0.14700544, + "sizeGiB": -0.13690948486328125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 1.165728855283969, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 0.9796553543168612, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.18607350096710784 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "NEAR_BASELINE_PREMIUM", + "reasonDescription": "The winner used only the configured near-baseline size premium and beat the real linear KLD trade line.", + "rawReason": "near-baseline replacement within \u002B1% size premium", + "removed": { + "key": "0:103:1:1:1:1:106:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.02034, + "ppl": 5.733493, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.8175312115350781, + "sizeBytes": 19150797216, + "sizeGB": 19.150797215999997, + "sizeGiB": 17.83556976914406 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:7:7:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.017713, + "ppl": 5.742713, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.9796553543168612, + "sizeBytes": 19320445344, + "sizeGB": 19.320445344, + "sizeGiB": 17.993566900491714 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.002627000000000001, + "sizeBytes": -169648128, + "sizeGB": -0.16964812799999998, + "sizeGiB": -0.15799713134765625, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.8175312115350781, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 0.9796553543168612, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.1621241427817831 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:103:1:1:1:1:106:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.02034, + "ppl": 5.733493, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.8175312115350781, + "sizeBytes": 19150797216, + "sizeGB": 19.150797215999997, + "sizeGiB": 17.83556976914406 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:7:2:2:1:1:7:7:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.018614, + "ppl": 5.753295, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.165728855283969, + "sizeBytes": 19173439904, + "sizeGB": 19.173439904, + "sizeGiB": 17.856657415628433 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0017260000000000018, + "sizeBytes": -22642688, + "sizeGB": -0.022642688, + "sizeGiB": -0.021087646484375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.8175312115350781, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 1.165728855283969, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.34819764374889095 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.", + "rawReason": "strict hybrid dominance: best accepted actual KLD at same-or-smaller real size", + "removed": { + "key": "105:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ4_NL_XL.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ4_NL_XL", + "shortName": "UD-IQ4_NL_XL", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ4_NL_XL", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.020351, + "ppl": 5.743716, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.9972920696324911, + "sizeBytes": 19500505504, + "sizeGB": 19.500505504, + "sizeGiB": 18.16126099228859 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:1:1:1:1:106:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.02034, + "ppl": 5.733493, + "pplDeltaPercent": 0.8175312115350781, + "sizeBytes": 19150797216, + "sizeGB": 19.150797215999997, + "sizeGiB": 17.83556976914406 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 1.1000000000000593E-05, + "sizeBytes": 349708288, + "sizeGB": 0.349708288, + "sizeGiB": 0.32569122314453125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.9972920696324911, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 0.8175312115350781, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.17976085809741293 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.", + "rawReason": "strict hybrid dominance: best accepted actual KLD at same-or-smaller real size", + "removed": { + "key": "104:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ4_NL.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ4_NL", + "shortName": "UD-IQ4_NL", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ4_NL", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.026609, + "ppl": 5.772912, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.5106734657991832, + "sizeBytes": 18040887712, + "sizeGB": 18.040887712, + "sizeGiB": 16.80188599228859 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:1:2:1:1:105:111:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M_1.gguf", + "displayName": "MQ-IQ3_M_1", + "shortName": "MQ-IQ3_M_1", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "IQ3_M", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.02633, + "ppl": 5.764787, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.3678037629681699, + "sizeBytes": 17604147616, + "sizeGB": 17.604147616000002, + "sizeGiB": 16.39514008164406 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.00027900000000000147, + "sizeBytes": 436740096, + "sizeGB": 0.43674009599999997, + "sizeGiB": 0.40674591064453125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 1.5106734657991832, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 1.3678037629681699, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.1428697028310133 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.", + "rawReason": "strict predicted hybrid dominance validated by real benchmark", + "removed": { + "key": "0:103:1:1:1:1:105:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.02673, + "ppl": 5.759679, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.2779848777914529, + "sizeBytes": 17724733856, + "sizeGB": 17.724733856, + "sizeGiB": 16.50744476914406 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:1:2:1:1:105:111:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M_1.gguf", + "displayName": "MQ-IQ3_M_1", + "shortName": "MQ-IQ3_M_1", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "IQ3_M", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.02633, + "ppl": 5.764787, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.3678037629681699, + "sizeBytes": 17604147616, + "sizeGB": 17.604147616000002, + "sizeGiB": 16.39514008164406 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.00040000000000000105, + "sizeBytes": 120586240, + "sizeGB": 0.12058624, + "sizeGiB": 0.1123046875, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 1.2779848777914529, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 1.3678037629681699, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.08981888517671699 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.", + "rawReason": "strict hybrid dominance: best accepted actual KLD at same-or-smaller real size", + "removed": { + "key": "106:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "UD-IQ4_XS", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ4_XS", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.027103, + "ppl": 5.763986, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.3537190082644588, + "sizeBytes": 17730509216, + "sizeGB": 17.730509215999998, + "sizeGiB": 16.51282349228859 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:1:1:1:1:105:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.02673, + "ppl": 5.759679, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.2779848777914529, + "sizeBytes": 17724733856, + "sizeGB": 17.724733856, + "sizeGiB": 16.50744476914406 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.00037299999999999833, + "sizeBytes": 5775360, + "sizeGB": 0.00577536, + "sizeGiB": 0.00537872314453125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 1.3537190082644588, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 1.2779848777914529, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.07573413047300592 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.", + "rawReason": "strict predicted hybrid dominance validated by real benchmark", + "removed": { + "key": "106:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ4_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ4_XS", + "shortName": "UD-IQ4_XS", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ4_XS", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.027103, + "ppl": 5.763986, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.3537190082644588, + "sizeBytes": 17730509216, + "sizeGB": 17.730509215999998, + "sizeGiB": 16.51282349228859 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:1:2:1:1:105:111:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M_1.gguf", + "displayName": "MQ-IQ3_M_1", + "shortName": "MQ-IQ3_M_1", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "IQ3_M", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.02633, + "ppl": 5.764787, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.3678037629681699, + "sizeBytes": 17604147616, + "sizeGB": 17.604147616000002, + "sizeGiB": 16.39514008164406 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0007729999999999994, + "sizeBytes": 126361600, + "sizeGB": 0.12636160000000002, + "sizeGiB": 0.11768341064453125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 1.3537190082644588, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 1.3678037629681699, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.014084754703711067 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:105:7:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.028347, + "ppl": 5.764639, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.3652013363812128, + "sizeBytes": 17183971744, + "sizeGB": 17.183971743999997, + "sizeGiB": 16.003820806741714 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:1:2:1:1:105:111:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M_1.gguf", + "displayName": "MQ-IQ3_M_1", + "shortName": "MQ-IQ3_M_1", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "IQ3_M", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.02633, + "ppl": 5.764787, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.3678037629681699, + "sizeBytes": 17604147616, + "sizeGB": 17.604147616000002, + "sizeGiB": 16.39514008164406 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0020170000000000014, + "sizeBytes": -420175872, + "sizeGB": -0.42017587199999995, + "sizeGiB": -0.39131927490234375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 1.3652013363812128, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 1.3678037629681699, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.002602426586957085 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "INTERIOR_DISCOVERY", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was selected as a useful interior point inside a size/KLD gap between anchors.", + "rawReason": "interior subspace discovery dominated by real benchmark truth", + "removed": { + "key": "0:7:2:2:1:1:105:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.028525, + "ppl": 5.794961, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.898382275364859, + "sizeBytes": 17292032416, + "sizeGB": 17.292032416, + "sizeGiB": 16.104460150003433 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:105:7:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.028347, + "ppl": 5.764639, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.3652013363812128, + "sizeBytes": 17183971744, + "sizeGB": 17.183971743999997, + "sizeGiB": 16.003820806741714 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0001779999999999976, + "sizeBytes": 108060672, + "sizeGB": 0.10806067200000001, + "sizeGiB": 0.10063934326171875, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 1.898382275364859, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 1.3652013363812128, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.5331809389836462 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "INTERIOR_DISCOVERY", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was selected as a useful interior point inside a size/KLD gap between anchors.", + "rawReason": "interior subspace discovery dominated by real benchmark truth", + "removed": { + "key": "0:103:1:3:1:1:105:7:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.028995, + "ppl": 5.770342, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.4654826797960265, + "sizeBytes": 17249204640, + "sizeGB": 17.24920464, + "sizeGiB": 16.06457367539406 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:105:7:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.028347, + "ppl": 5.764639, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.3652013363812128, + "sizeBytes": 17183971744, + "sizeGB": 17.183971743999997, + "sizeGiB": 16.003820806741714 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0006479999999999993, + "sizeBytes": 65232896, + "sizeGB": 0.065232896, + "sizeGiB": 0.06075286865234375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 1.4654826797960265, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 1.3652013363812128, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.10028134341481376 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:7:2:2:1:1:105:7:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.029406, + "ppl": 5.789109, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.7954809213996756, + "sizeBytes": 17036966304, + "sizeGB": 17.036966304, + "sizeGiB": 15.866911321878433 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:105:7:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.028347, + "ppl": 5.764639, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.3652013363812128, + "sizeBytes": 17183971744, + "sizeGB": 17.183971743999997, + "sizeGiB": 16.003820806741714 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.001059000000000001, + "sizeBytes": -147005440, + "sizeGB": -0.14700544, + "sizeGiB": -0.13690948486328125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 1.7954809213996756, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 1.3652013363812128, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.43027958501846286 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "INTERIOR_DISCOVERY", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was selected as a useful interior point inside a size/KLD gap between anchors.", + "rawReason": "interior subspace discovery dominated by real benchmark truth", + "removed": { + "key": "0:7:2:3:1:1:105:107:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.029854, + "ppl": 5.794784, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.895269913838573, + "sizeBytes": 17234098592, + "sizeGB": 17.234098592, + "sizeGiB": 16.050505071878433 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:105:7:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.028347, + "ppl": 5.764639, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.3652013363812128, + "sizeBytes": 17183971744, + "sizeGB": 17.183971743999997, + "sizeGiB": 16.003820806741714 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.001506999999999998, + "sizeBytes": 50126848, + "sizeGB": 0.050126847999999995, + "sizeGiB": 0.04668426513671875, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 1.895269913838573, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 1.3652013363812128, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.5300685774573601 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "108:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q3_K_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q3_K_M", + "shortName": "UD-Q3_K_M", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q3_K_M", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.036042, + "ppl": 5.791067, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.8299103217865251, + "sizeBytes": 16600709536, + "sizeGB": 16.600709536000004, + "sizeGiB": 15.460615545511246 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:7:2:2:1:1:105:7:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.029406, + "ppl": 5.789109, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.7954809213996756, + "sizeBytes": 17036966304, + "sizeGB": 17.036966304, + "sizeGiB": 15.866911321878433 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.006635999999999996, + "sizeBytes": -436256768, + "sizeGB": -0.43625676799999996, + "sizeGiB": -0.4062957763671875, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 1.8299103217865251, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 1.7954809213996756, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.034429400386849496 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:105:103:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.036701, + "ppl": 5.805336, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.0808158959029246, + "sizeBytes": 16187365792, + "sizeGB": 16.187365791999998, + "sizeGiB": 15.075659185647964 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "108:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q3_K_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q3_K_M", + "shortName": "UD-Q3_K_M", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q3_K_M", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.036042, + "ppl": 5.791067, + "pplDeltaPercent": 1.8299103217865251, + "sizeBytes": 16600709536, + "sizeGB": 16.600709536000004, + "sizeGiB": 15.460615545511246 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0006589999999999999, + "sizeBytes": -413343744, + "sizeGB": -0.413343744, + "sizeGiB": -0.38495635986328125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 2.0808158959029246, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 1.8299103217865251, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.25090557411639947 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "INTERIOR_DISCOVERY", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was selected as a useful interior point inside a size/KLD gap between anchors.", + "rawReason": "interior subspace discovery dominated by real benchmark truth", + "removed": { + "key": "0:7:2:1:1:1:105:103:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.036763, + "ppl": 5.829303, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.5022507473184468, + "sizeBytes": 16202889632, + "sizeGB": 16.202889631999998, + "sizeGiB": 15.090116888284683 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:105:103:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.036701, + "ppl": 5.805336, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.0808158959029246, + "sizeBytes": 16187365792, + "sizeGB": 16.187365791999998, + "sizeGiB": 15.075659185647964 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 6.199999999999956E-05, + "sizeBytes": 15523840, + "sizeGB": 0.01552384, + "sizeGiB": 0.01445770263671875, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 2.5022507473184468, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 2.0808158959029246, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.42143485141552217 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:7:2:2:1:1:105:103:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.037456, + "ppl": 5.834445, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.5926674872516156, + "sizeBytes": 16040360352, + "sizeGB": 16.040360352, + "sizeGiB": 14.938749700784683 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:105:103:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.036701, + "ppl": 5.805336, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.0808158959029246, + "sizeBytes": 16187365792, + "sizeGB": 16.187365791999998, + "sizeGiB": 15.075659185647964 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0007550000000000057, + "sizeBytes": -147005440, + "sizeGB": -0.14700544, + "sizeGiB": -0.13690948486328125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 2.5926674872516156, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 2.0808158959029246, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.511851591348691 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "INTERIOR_DISCOVERY", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was selected as a useful interior point inside a size/KLD gap between anchors.", + "rawReason": "interior subspace discovery dominated by real benchmark truth", + "removed": { + "key": "0:103:1:3:1:3:105:103:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.037692, + "ppl": 5.816251, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.2727448566906983, + "sizeBytes": 16221141408, + "sizeGB": 16.221141408, + "sizeGiB": 15.107115179300308 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:105:103:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.036701, + "ppl": 5.805336, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.0808158959029246, + "sizeBytes": 16187365792, + "sizeGB": 16.187365791999998, + "sizeGiB": 15.075659185647964 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0009910000000000058, + "sizeBytes": 33775616, + "sizeGB": 0.033775616, + "sizeGiB": 0.03145599365234375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 2.2727448566906983, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 2.0808158959029246, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.19192896078777366 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "INTERIOR_DISCOVERY", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was selected as a useful interior point inside a size/KLD gap between anchors.", + "rawReason": "interior subspace discovery dominated by real benchmark truth", + "removed": { + "key": "0:4:2:1:1:1:105:103:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.037792, + "ppl": 5.818985, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.32081941269561, + "sizeBytes": 16218782112, + "sizeGB": 16.218782112, + "sizeGiB": 15.104917913675308 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:105:103:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.036701, + "ppl": 5.805336, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.0808158959029246, + "sizeBytes": 16187365792, + "sizeGB": 16.187365791999998, + "sizeGiB": 15.075659185647964 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0010910000000000017, + "sizeBytes": 31416320, + "sizeGB": 0.03141632, + "sizeGiB": 0.02925872802734375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 2.32081941269561, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 2.0808158959029246, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.24000351679268528 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "109:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q3_K_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q3_K_S", + "shortName": "UD-Q3_K_S", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q3_K_S", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.042683, + "ppl": 5.848953, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.847775628626685, + "sizeBytes": 15359195552, + "sizeGB": 15.359195552, + "sizeGiB": 14.304365545511246 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:7:2:2:1:1:105:103:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.037456, + "ppl": 5.834445, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.5926674872516156, + "sizeBytes": 16040360352, + "sizeGB": 16.040360352, + "sizeGiB": 14.938749700784683 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0052269999999999955, + "sizeBytes": -681164800, + "sizeGB": -0.6811648, + "sizeGiB": -0.6343841552734375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 2.847775628626685, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 2.5926674872516156, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.2551081413750693 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:109:108:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.049366, + "ppl": 5.808506, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.136557059961317, + "sizeBytes": 14755264928, + "sizeGB": 14.755264927999999, + "sizeGiB": 13.741911321878433 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "109:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q3_K_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q3_K_S", + "shortName": "UD-Q3_K_S", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q3_K_S", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.042683, + "ppl": 5.848953, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.847775628626685, + "sizeBytes": 15359195552, + "sizeGB": 15.359195552, + "sizeGiB": 14.304365545511246 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0066830000000000014, + "sizeBytes": -603930624, + "sizeGB": -0.603930624, + "sizeGiB": -0.5624542236328125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 2.136557059961317, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 2.847775628626685, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.7112185686653678 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:7:1:2:1:1:109:108:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.049486, + "ppl": 5.831284, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.5370845788640732, + "sizeBytes": 14731426208, + "sizeGB": 14.731426208, + "sizeGiB": 13.719709783792496 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:109:108:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.049366, + "ppl": 5.808506, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.136557059961317, + "sizeBytes": 14755264928, + "sizeGB": 14.755264927999999, + "sizeGiB": 13.741911321878433 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.00012000000000000205, + "sizeBytes": -23838720, + "sizeGB": -0.02383872, + "sizeGiB": -0.0222015380859375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 2.5370845788640732, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 2.136557059961317, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.4005275189027562 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:7:2:1:1:1:109:104:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.049772, + "ppl": 5.817175, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.288992438895718, + "sizeBytes": 14730688928, + "sizeGB": 14.730688928, + "sizeGiB": 13.719023138284683 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:7:1:2:1:1:109:108:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.049486, + "ppl": 5.831284, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.5370845788640732, + "sizeBytes": 14731426208, + "sizeGB": 14.731426208, + "sizeGiB": 13.719709783792496 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0002859999999999946, + "sizeBytes": -737280, + "sizeGB": -0.00073728, + "sizeGiB": -0.0006866455078125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 2.288992438895718, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 2.5370845788640732, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.24809213996835533 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "INTERIOR_DISCOVERY", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was selected as a useful interior point inside a size/KLD gap between anchors.", + "rawReason": "interior subspace discovery dominated by real benchmark truth", + "removed": { + "key": "0:7:2:1:1:1:109:108:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.050155, + "ppl": 5.817412, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.293159838227532, + "sizeBytes": 14770788768, + "sizeGB": 14.770788768, + "sizeGiB": 13.756369024515152 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:103:2:2:1:1:109:108:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.049366, + "ppl": 5.808506, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.136557059961317, + "sizeBytes": 14755264928, + "sizeGB": 14.755264927999999, + "sizeGiB": 13.741911321878433 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.000788999999999998, + "sizeBytes": 15523840, + "sizeGB": 0.01552384, + "sizeGiB": 0.01445770263671875, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 2.293159838227532, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 2.136557059961317, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.15660277826621494 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:7:2:2:1:1:109:104:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.050828, + "ppl": 5.823728, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.4042201512220807, + "sizeBytes": 14568159648, + "sizeGB": 14.568159648, + "sizeGiB": 13.567655950784683 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:7:2:1:1:1:109:104:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.049772, + "ppl": 5.817175, + "pplDeltaPercent": 2.288992438895718, + "sizeBytes": 14730688928, + "sizeGB": 14.730688928, + "sizeGiB": 13.719023138284683 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0010560000000000014, + "sizeBytes": -162529280, + "sizeGB": -0.16252928, + "sizeGiB": -0.1513671875, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 2.4042201512220807, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 2.288992438895718, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.11522771232636275 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:3:2:2:1:1:103:104:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_XXS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_XXS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.070443, + "ppl": 5.913238, + "pplDeltaPercent": 3.9781607174256988, + "sizeBytes": 13285128608, + "sizeGB": 13.285128607999999, + "sizeGiB": 12.372740179300308 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "102:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf", + "displayName": "UD-IQ3_S", + "shortName": "UD-IQ3_S", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ3_S", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.068376, + "ppl": 5.970404, + "pplDeltaPercent": 4.983365570599613, + "sizeBytes": 13676722592, + "sizeGB": 13.676722592, + "sizeGiB": 12.73744049668312 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0020669999999999994, + "sizeBytes": -391593984, + "sizeGB": -0.39159398399999995, + "sizeGiB": -0.3647003173828125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 3.9781607174256988, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 4.983365570599613, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -1.0052048531739142 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "103:104:104:104:104:104:104:108:0:104", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_XXS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_XXS", + "shortName": "MQ-UD-IQ3_XXS", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ3_XXS", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.0709, + "ppl": 5.908587, + "pplDeltaPercent": 3.8963777035343683, + "sizeBytes": 13251254688, + "sizeGB": 13.251254688, + "sizeGiB": 12.34119263291359 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:3:2:2:1:1:103:104:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_XXS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_XXS", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.070443, + "ppl": 5.913238, + "pplDeltaPercent": 3.9781607174256988, + "sizeBytes": 13285128608, + "sizeGB": 13.285128607999999, + "sizeGiB": 12.372740179300308 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0004569999999999991, + "sizeBytes": -33873920, + "sizeGB": -0.033873919999999995, + "sizeGiB": -0.03154754638671875, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 3.8963777035343683, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 3.9781607174256988, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.08178301389133047 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "NEAR_BASELINE_PREMIUM", + "reasonDescription": "The winner used only the configured near-baseline size premium and beat the real linear KLD trade line.", + "rawReason": "smart baseline-tuning near-baseline fallback within \u002B1% size premium", + "removed": { + "key": "103:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_XXS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_XXS", + "shortName": "UD-IQ3_XXS", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ3_XXS", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.07148, + "ppl": 5.908789, + "pplDeltaPercent": 3.899929664146287, + "sizeBytes": 13211154848, + "sizeGB": 13.211154848, + "sizeGiB": 12.30384674668312 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "103:104:104:104:104:104:104:108:0:104", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_XXS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_XXS", + "shortName": "MQ-UD-IQ3_XXS", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ3_XXS", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.0709, + "ppl": 5.908587, + "pplDeltaPercent": 3.8963777035343683, + "sizeBytes": 13251254688, + "sizeGB": 13.251254688, + "sizeGiB": 12.34119263291359 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0005799999999999972, + "sizeBytes": -40099840, + "sizeGB": -0.04009983999999999, + "sizeGiB": -0.03734588623046875, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 3.899929664146287, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 3.8963777035343683, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.0035519606119187586 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "103:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_XXS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_XXS", + "shortName": "UD-IQ3_XXS", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ3_XXS", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.07148, + "ppl": 5.908789, + "pplDeltaPercent": 3.899929664146287, + "sizeBytes": 13211154848, + "sizeGB": 13.211154848, + "sizeGiB": 12.30384674668312 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "103:104:104:104:104:104:104:108:0:104", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_XXS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ3_XXS", + "shortName": "MQ-UD-IQ3_XXS", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ3_XXS", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.0709, + "ppl": 5.908587, + "pplDeltaPercent": 3.8963777035343683, + "sizeBytes": 13251254688, + "sizeGB": 13.251254688, + "sizeGiB": 12.34119263291359 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0005799999999999972, + "sizeBytes": -40099840, + "sizeGB": -0.04009983999999999, + "sizeGiB": -0.03734588623046875, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 3.899929664146287, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 3.8963777035343683, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.0035519606119187586 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:4:2:7:7:3:103:10:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.077533, + "ppl": 5.959504, + "pplDeltaPercent": 4.791700369263225, + "sizeBytes": 12927367584, + "sizeGB": 12.927367584, + "sizeGiB": 12.039549261331558 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "103:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_XXS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_XXS", + "shortName": "UD-IQ3_XXS", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ3_XXS", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.07148, + "ppl": 5.908789, + "pplDeltaPercent": 3.899929664146287, + "sizeBytes": 13211154848, + "sizeGB": 13.211154848, + "sizeGiB": 12.30384674668312 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.006053000000000003, + "sizeBytes": -283787264, + "sizeGB": -0.28378726400000004, + "sizeGiB": -0.2642974853515625, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 4.791700369263225, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 3.899929664146287, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.8917707051169379 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "INTERIOR_DISCOVERY", + "reasonDescription": "The winner was selected as a useful interior point inside a size/KLD gap between anchors.", + "rawReason": "interior subspace discovery dominated by real benchmark truth", + "removed": { + "key": "0:4:2:6:7:3:103:10:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.077612, + "ppl": 5.953623, + "pplDeltaPercent": 4.688289080358714, + "sizeBytes": 12932610464, + "sizeGB": 12.932610464, + "sizeGiB": 12.044432073831558 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:4:2:7:7:3:103:10:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.077533, + "ppl": 5.959504, + "pplDeltaPercent": 4.791700369263225, + "sizeBytes": 12927367584, + "sizeGB": 12.927367584, + "sizeGiB": 12.039549261331558 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 7.899999999999574E-05, + "sizeBytes": 5242880, + "sizeGB": 0.00524288, + "sizeGiB": 0.0048828125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 4.688289080358714, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 4.791700369263225, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.10341128890451134 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:7:2:6:1:3:103:10:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.077967, + "ppl": 5.956834, + "pplDeltaPercent": 4.744751186917521, + "sizeBytes": 12926220704, + "sizeGB": 12.926220703999999, + "sizeGiB": 12.038481146097183 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:4:2:7:7:3:103:10:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.077533, + "ppl": 5.959504, + "pplDeltaPercent": 4.791700369263225, + "sizeBytes": 12927367584, + "sizeGB": 12.927367584, + "sizeGiB": 12.039549261331558 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.00043399999999998995, + "sizeBytes": -1146880, + "sizeGB": -0.00114688, + "sizeGiB": -0.001068115234375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 4.744751186917521, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 4.791700369263225, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.046949182345703555 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:7:2:7:1:3:103:10:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.077972, + "ppl": 5.964178, + "pplDeltaPercent": 4.873887814313348, + "sizeBytes": 12920977824, + "sizeGB": 12.920977824, + "sizeGiB": 12.033598333597183 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:7:2:6:1:3:103:10:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.077967, + "ppl": 5.956834, + "pplDeltaPercent": 4.744751186917521, + "sizeBytes": 12926220704, + "sizeGB": 12.926220703999999, + "sizeGiB": 12.038481146097183 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 5.0000000000050004E-06, + "sizeBytes": -5242880, + "sizeGB": -0.00524288, + "sizeGiB": -0.0048828125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 4.873887814313348, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 4.744751186917521, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.12913662739582676 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:4:2:15:1:1:103:10:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.078411, + "ppl": 5.964572, + "pplDeltaPercent": 4.880815895902939, + "sizeBytes": 12916947360, + "sizeGB": 12.91694736, + "sizeGiB": 12.029844671487808 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:7:2:7:1:3:103:10:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.077972, + "ppl": 5.964178, + "pplDeltaPercent": 4.873887814313348, + "sizeBytes": 12920977824, + "sizeGB": 12.920977824, + "sizeGiB": 12.033598333597183 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.00043899999999999495, + "sizeBytes": -4030464, + "sizeGB": -0.004030464, + "sizeGiB": -0.003753662109375, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 4.880815895902939, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 4.873887814313348, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.006928081589590462 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:7:2:2:1:1:108:104:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.090083, + "ppl": 5.990322, + "pplDeltaPercent": 5.333602954105849, + "sizeBytes": 12574046624, + "sizeGB": 12.574046624000001, + "sizeGiB": 11.710493475198746 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:4:2:15:1:1:103:10:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.078411, + "ppl": 5.964572, + "pplDeltaPercent": 4.880815895902939, + "sizeBytes": 12916947360, + "sizeGB": 12.91694736, + "sizeGiB": 12.029844671487808 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.011672000000000002, + "sizeBytes": -342900736, + "sizeGB": -0.342900736, + "sizeGiB": -0.3193511962890625, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 5.333602954105849, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 4.880815895902939, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.45278705820291076 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "0:7:2:3:1:1:108:104:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.091149, + "ppl": 5.997713, + "pplDeltaPercent": 5.463566027782658, + "sizeBytes": 12516112800, + "sizeGB": 12.5161128, + "sizeGiB": 11.656538397073746 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:7:2:2:1:1:108:104:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.090083, + "ppl": 5.990322, + "pplDeltaPercent": 5.333602954105849, + "sizeBytes": 12574046624, + "sizeGB": 12.574046624000001, + "sizeGiB": 11.710493475198746 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0010659999999999975, + "sizeBytes": -57933824, + "sizeGB": -0.057933824, + "sizeGiB": -0.053955078125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 5.463566027782658, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 5.333602954105849, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.1299630736768087 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "107:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q2_K_XL.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q2_K_XL", + "shortName": "UD-Q2_K_XL", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q2_K_XL", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.09941, + "ppl": 6.039307, + "pplDeltaPercent": 6.1949534024969175, + "sizeBytes": 12290628000, + "sizeGB": 12.290628, + "sizeGiB": 11.44653931260109 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "0:7:2:3:1:1:108:104:0:1", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_M", + "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "Q8_0", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.091149, + "ppl": 5.997713, + "pplDeltaPercent": 5.463566027782658, + "sizeBytes": 12516112800, + "sizeGB": 12.5161128, + "sizeGiB": 11.656538397073746 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.008261000000000004, + "sizeBytes": -225484800, + "sizeGB": -0.22548479999999999, + "sizeGiB": -0.20999908447265625, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 6.1949534024969175, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 5.463566027782658, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.7313873747142594 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "100:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ2_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ2_M", + "shortName": "UD-IQ2_M", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ2_M", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.119666, + "ppl": 6.077022, + "pplDeltaPercent": 6.858132583084228, + "sizeBytes": 11522701728, + "sizeGB": 11.522701728, + "sizeGiB": 10.731352239847183 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "107:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q2_K_XL.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-Q2_K_XL", + "shortName": "UD-Q2_K_XL", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-Q2_K_XL", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.09941, + "ppl": 6.039307, + "pplDeltaPercent": 6.1949534024969175, + "sizeBytes": 12290628000, + "sizeGB": 12.290628, + "sizeGiB": 11.44653931260109 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.020255999999999996, + "sizeBytes": -767926272, + "sizeGB": -0.7679262720000001, + "sizeGiB": -0.7151870727539062, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 6.858132583084228, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 6.1949534024969175, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.6631791805873108 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "101:102:102:108:102:102:102:102:0:102", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_XXS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_XXS", + "shortName": "MQ-UD-IQ2_XXS", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ2_XXS", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.136141, + "ppl": 6.162199, + "pplDeltaPercent": 8.35588183576578, + "sizeBytes": 10758814112, + "sizeGB": 10.758814112, + "sizeGiB": 10.019926458597183 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "100:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ2_M.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ2_M", + "shortName": "UD-IQ2_M", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ2_M", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.119666, + "ppl": 6.077022, + "pplDeltaPercent": 6.858132583084228, + "sizeBytes": 11522701728, + "sizeGB": 11.522701728, + "sizeGiB": 10.731352239847183 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.016475000000000017, + "sizeBytes": -763887616, + "sizeGB": -0.7638876160000001, + "sizeGiB": -0.71142578125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 8.35588183576578, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 6.858132583084228, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 1.497749252681552 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "NEAR_BASELINE_PREMIUM", + "reasonDescription": "The winner used only the configured near-baseline size premium and beat the real linear KLD trade line.", + "rawReason": "smart baseline-tuning near-baseline fallback within \u002B1% size premium", + "removed": { + "key": "101:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ2_XXS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ2_XXS", + "shortName": "UD-IQ2_XXS", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ2_XXS", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.136725, + "ppl": 6.170083, + "pplDeltaPercent": 8.494513803411282, + "sizeBytes": 10756585888, + "sizeGB": 10.756585888, + "sizeGiB": 10.017851263284683 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "101:102:102:108:102:102:102:102:0:102", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_XXS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_XXS", + "shortName": "MQ-UD-IQ2_XXS", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ2_XXS", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.136141, + "ppl": 6.162199, + "pplDeltaPercent": 8.35588183576578, + "sizeBytes": 10758814112, + "sizeGB": 10.758814112, + "sizeGiB": 10.019926458597183 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0005840000000000012, + "sizeBytes": -2228224, + "sizeGB": -0.002228224, + "sizeGiB": -0.0020751953125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 8.494513803411282, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 8.35588183576578, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.13863196764550167 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "101:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ2_XXS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ2_XXS", + "shortName": "UD-IQ2_XXS", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ2_XXS", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.136725, + "ppl": 6.170083, + "pplDeltaPercent": 8.494513803411282, + "sizeBytes": 10756585888, + "sizeGB": 10.756585888, + "sizeGiB": 10.017851263284683 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "101:102:102:108:102:102:102:102:0:102", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_XXS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_XXS", + "shortName": "MQ-UD-IQ2_XXS", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ2_XXS", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.136141, + "ppl": 6.162199, + "pplDeltaPercent": 8.35588183576578, + "sizeBytes": 10758814112, + "sizeGB": 10.758814112, + "sizeGiB": 10.019926458597183 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.0005840000000000012, + "sizeBytes": -2228224, + "sizeGB": -0.002228224, + "sizeGiB": -0.0020751953125, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 8.494513803411282, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 8.35588183576578, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.13863196764550167 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "11:12:12:15:18:7:12:12:0:12", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-IQ2_XS", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "IQ2_XS", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.215492, + "ppl": 6.718442, + "pplDeltaPercent": 18.136838403376107, + "sizeBytes": 10588284320, + "sizeGB": 10.588284320000001, + "sizeGiB": 9.861108213663101 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "101:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ2_XXS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ2_XXS", + "shortName": "UD-IQ2_XXS", + "provider": "Unsloth", + "quantFamily": "UD-IQ2_XXS", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": true, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.136725, + "ppl": 6.170083, + "pplDeltaPercent": 8.494513803411282, + "sizeBytes": 10756585888, + "sizeGB": 10.756585888, + "sizeGiB": 10.017851263284683 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.07876699999999998, + "sizeBytes": -168301568, + "sizeGB": -0.168301568, + "sizeGiB": -0.15674304962158203, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 18.136838403376107, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 8.494513803411282, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 9.642324599964825 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "NEAR_BASELINE_PREMIUM", + "reasonDescription": "The winner used only the configured near-baseline size premium and beat the real linear KLD trade line.", + "rawReason": "near-baseline size-premium replacement validated by real benchmark", + "removed": { + "key": "10:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-LM-IQ2_S.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-LM-IQ2_S", + "shortName": "LM-IQ2_S", + "provider": "llama.cpp", + "quantFamily": "IQ2_S", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.236115, + "ppl": 6.828657, + "pplDeltaPercent": 20.07485493230173, + "sizeBytes": 10652479904, + "sizeGB": 10.652479904, + "sizeGiB": 9.920895010232925 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "11:12:12:15:18:7:12:12:0:12", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-IQ2_XS", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "IQ2_XS", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.215492, + "ppl": 6.718442, + "pplDeltaPercent": 18.136838403376107, + "sizeBytes": 10588284320, + "sizeGB": 10.588284320000001, + "sizeGiB": 9.861108213663101 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.020623000000000002, + "sizeBytes": 64195584, + "sizeGB": 0.064195584, + "sizeGiB": 0.05978679656982422, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 20.07485493230173, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 18.136838403376107, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 1.9380165289256226 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "NEAR_BASELINE_PREMIUM", + "reasonDescription": "The winner used only the configured near-baseline size premium and beat the real linear KLD trade line.", + "rawReason": "smart baseline-tuning near-baseline fallback within \u002B1% size premium", + "removed": { + "key": "11:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-LM-IQ2_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-LM-IQ2_XS", + "shortName": "LM-IQ2_XS", + "provider": "llama.cpp", + "quantFamily": "IQ2_XS", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.26653, + "ppl": 7.031325, + "pplDeltaPercent": 23.638561631791795, + "sizeBytes": 10507030944, + "sizeGB": 10.507030944, + "sizeGiB": 9.785435110330582 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "11:12:12:15:18:7:12:12:0:12", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-IQ2_XS", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "IQ2_XS", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.215492, + "ppl": 6.718442, + "pplDeltaPercent": 18.136838403376107, + "sizeBytes": 10588284320, + "sizeGB": 10.588284320000001, + "sizeGiB": 9.861108213663101 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.051038, + "sizeBytes": -81253376, + "sizeGB": -0.081253376, + "sizeGiB": -0.07567310333251953, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 23.638561631791795, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 18.136838403376107, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 5.501723228415688 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "11:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-LM-IQ2_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-LM-IQ2_XS", + "shortName": "LM-IQ2_XS", + "provider": "llama.cpp", + "quantFamily": "IQ2_XS", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.26653, + "ppl": 7.031325, + "pplDeltaPercent": 23.638561631791795, + "sizeBytes": 10507030944, + "sizeGB": 10.507030944, + "sizeGiB": 9.785435110330582 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "11:12:12:15:18:7:12:12:0:12", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_XS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_XS", + "shortName": "MQ-IQ2_XS", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "IQ2_XS", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.215492, + "ppl": 6.718442, + "pplDeltaPercent": 18.136838403376107, + "sizeBytes": 10588284320, + "sizeGB": 10.588284320000001, + "sizeGiB": 9.861108213663101 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.051038, + "sizeBytes": -81253376, + "sizeGB": -0.081253376, + "sizeGiB": -0.07567310333251953, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 23.638561631791795, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 18.136838403376107, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 5.501723228415688 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "NEAR_BASELINE_PREMIUM", + "reasonDescription": "The winner used only the configured near-baseline size premium and beat the real linear KLD trade line.", + "rawReason": "smart baseline-tuning near-baseline fallback within \u002B1% size premium", + "removed": { + "key": "12:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-LM-IQ2_XXS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-LM-IQ2_XXS", + "shortName": "LM-IQ2_XXS", + "provider": "llama.cpp", + "quantFamily": "IQ2_XXS", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.344116, + "ppl": 7.511203, + "pplDeltaPercent": 32.076718832424824, + "sizeBytes": 9497653664, + "sizeGB": 9.497653664000001, + "sizeGiB": 8.845379263162613 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "12:13:13:15:18:7:13:13:0:13", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_XXS_1.gguf", + "displayName": "MQ-IQ2_XXS_1", + "shortName": "MQ-IQ2_XXS_1", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "IQ2_XXS", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.27513, + "ppl": 7.049514, + "pplDeltaPercent": 23.958396342535607, + "sizeBytes": 9587160480, + "sizeGB": 9.58716048, + "sizeGiB": 8.928738981485367 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.06898599999999999, + "sizeBytes": -89506816, + "sizeGB": -0.089506816, + "sizeGiB": -0.0833597183227539, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 32.076718832424824, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 23.958396342535607, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 8.118322489889216 + } + }, + { + "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE", + "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.", + "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 822,164,582 bytes", + "removed": { + "key": "12:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-LM-IQ2_XXS.gguf", + "displayName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-LM-IQ2_XXS", + "shortName": "LM-IQ2_XXS", + "provider": "llama.cpp", + "quantFamily": "IQ2_XXS", + "isHybrid": false, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false, + "kld": 0.344116, + "ppl": 7.511203, + "pplDeltaPercent": 32.076718832424824, + "sizeBytes": 9497653664, + "sizeGB": 9.497653664000001, + "sizeGiB": 8.845379263162613 + }, + "winner": { + "key": "12:13:13:15:18:7:13:13:0:13", + "fileName": "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-MQ-IQ2_XXS_1.gguf", + "displayName": "MQ-IQ2_XXS_1", + "shortName": "MQ-IQ2_XXS_1", + "provider": "MagicQuant", + "quantFamily": "IQ2_XXS", + "isHybrid": true, + "isExternalPureBaseline": false, + "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false, + "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true, + "kld": 0.27513, + "ppl": 7.049514, + "pplDeltaPercent": 23.958396342535607, + "sizeBytes": 9587160480, + "sizeGB": 9.58716048, + "sizeGiB": 8.928738981485367 + }, + "deltas": { + "kld": 0.06898599999999999, + "sizeBytes": -89506816, + "sizeGB": -0.089506816, + "sizeGiB": -0.0833597183227539, + "removedPplDeltaPercent": 32.076718832424824, + "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 23.958396342535607, + "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 8.118322489889216 + } + } +] \ No newline at end of file