Some observations on Erdős matrices

In a seminal paper in 1959, Marcus and Ree proved that every ntimes n bistochastic matrix A satisfies |A|_{F}^2leq max_{σin S_n}A_{i,σ(i)} where S_n is the symmetric group on {1, ldots, n}. Erdős asked to characterize the bistochastic matrices for which the equality holds in the Marcus--Ree inequality. We refer to such matrices as Erdős matrices. While this problem is trivial in dimension n=2, the case of dimension n=3 was only resolved recently in~bouthat2024question in 2023. We prove that for every n, there are only finitely many ntimes n Erdős matrices. We also give a characterization of Erdős matrices that yields an algorithm to generate all Erdős matrices in any given dimension. We also prove that Erdős matrices can have only rational entries. This answers a question of~bouthat2024question.