{ "eval_entity_strict_micro_precision": 0.484677703416696, "eval_entity_strict_micro_recall": 0.6441947565543071, "eval_entity_strict_micro_f1": 0.5531658291457286, "eval_entity_strict_macro_precision": 0.503332040182721, "eval_entity_strict_macro_recall": 0.661108298689041, "eval_entity_strict_macro_f1": 0.5654156786937735, "eval_entity_strict_support": 2136, "eval_entity_strict_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nCVE 0.8824 1.0000 0.9375 30\nCapabilities 0.4467 0.3418 0.3873 196\nData 0.3302 0.5645 0.4167 62\nDevice 0.5205 0.5588 0.5390 68\nFile 0.5857 0.6613 0.6212 62\nGPE 0.4118 0.7000 0.5185 10\nMalware 0.4483 0.5000 0.4727 52\nMoney 0.5893 0.9167 0.7174 36\nNumber 0.5676 0.9130 0.7000 23\nOrganization 0.4363 0.7088 0.5401 285\nPII 0.4516 0.5773 0.5068 97\nPatch 0.5833 0.8167 0.6806 60\nPaymentMethod 0.6087 0.5833 0.5957 24\nPerson 0.5565 0.7076 0.6230 383\nPurpose 0.4348 0.4478 0.4412 67\nSoftware 0.3657 0.6806 0.4757 72\nSystem 0.3200 0.4828 0.3849 116\nTime 0.5156 0.8169 0.6322 142\nVersion 0.5179 0.5577 0.5370 52\nVulnerability 0.5223 0.6926 0.5955 270\nWebsite 0.4750 0.6552 0.5507 29\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 0.4847 0.6442 0.5532 2136\nmacro avg 0.5033 0.6611 0.5654 2136", "eval_entity_relaxed_micro_precision": 0.5966889749911941, "eval_entity_relaxed_micro_recall": 0.7930711610486891, "eval_entity_relaxed_micro_f1": 0.6810050251256281, "eval_entity_relaxed_macro_precision": 0.6229831549264462, "eval_entity_relaxed_macro_recall": 0.8135953709456636, "eval_entity_relaxed_macro_f1": 0.6977482735320146, "eval_entity_relaxed_support": 2136, "eval_entity_relaxed_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nCVE 0.8824 1.0000 0.9375 30\nCapabilities 0.6000 0.4592 0.5202 196\nData 0.4340 0.7419 0.5476 62\nDevice 0.7260 0.7794 0.7518 68\nFile 0.6857 0.7742 0.7273 62\nGPE 0.5882 1.0000 0.7407 10\nMalware 0.6552 0.7308 0.6909 52\nMoney 0.6429 1.0000 0.7826 36\nNumber 0.5676 0.9130 0.7000 23\nOrganization 0.5227 0.8491 0.6471 285\nPII 0.5484 0.7010 0.6154 97\nPatch 0.6548 0.9167 0.7639 60\nPaymentMethod 0.8261 0.7917 0.8085 24\nPerson 0.6345 0.8068 0.7103 383\nPurpose 0.5362 0.5522 0.5441 67\nSoftware 0.4851 0.9028 0.6311 72\nSystem 0.4629 0.6983 0.5567 116\nTime 0.5867 0.9296 0.7193 142\nVersion 0.8036 0.8654 0.8333 52\nVulnerability 0.6899 0.9148 0.7866 270\nWebsite 0.5500 0.7586 0.6377 29\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 0.5967 0.7931 0.6810 2136\nmacro avg 0.6230 0.8136 0.6977 2136", "eval_event_type_strict_micro_precision": 1.0, "eval_event_type_strict_micro_recall": 0.8648648648648649, "eval_event_type_strict_micro_f1": 0.927536231884058, "eval_event_type_strict_macro_precision": 1.0, "eval_event_type_strict_macro_recall": 0.8482366599121918, "eval_event_type_strict_macro_f1": 0.9103141784418884, "eval_event_type_strict_support": 185, "eval_event_type_strict_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nCyber.Databreach 1.0000 0.9149 0.9556 47\nCyber.DiscoverVulnerability 1.0000 0.9111 0.9535 45\nCyber.PatchVulnerability 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 33\nCyber.Phishing 1.0000 0.8438 0.9153 32\nCyber.Ransom 1.0000 0.5714 0.7273 28\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 1.0000 0.8649 0.9275 185\nmacro avg 1.0000 0.8482 0.9103 185", "eval_event_type_relaxed_micro_precision": 1.0, "eval_event_type_relaxed_micro_recall": 0.8648648648648649, "eval_event_type_relaxed_micro_f1": 0.927536231884058, "eval_event_type_relaxed_macro_precision": 1.0, "eval_event_type_relaxed_macro_recall": 0.8482366599121918, "eval_event_type_relaxed_macro_f1": 0.9103141784418884, "eval_event_type_relaxed_support": 185, "eval_event_type_relaxed_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nCyber.Databreach 1.0000 0.9149 0.9556 47\nCyber.DiscoverVulnerability 1.0000 0.9111 0.9535 45\nCyber.PatchVulnerability 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 33\nCyber.Phishing 1.0000 0.8438 0.9153 32\nCyber.Ransom 1.0000 0.5714 0.7273 28\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 1.0000 0.8649 0.9275 185\nmacro avg 1.0000 0.8482 0.9103 185", "eval_event_trigger_strict_micro_precision": 0.6564885496183206, "eval_event_trigger_strict_micro_recall": 0.3014018691588785, "eval_event_trigger_strict_micro_f1": 0.41313050440352284, "eval_event_trigger_strict_macro_precision": 0.6907690560382159, "eval_event_trigger_strict_macro_recall": 0.30995972468041066, "eval_event_trigger_strict_macro_f1": 0.40600423349111237, "eval_event_trigger_strict_support": 856, "eval_event_trigger_strict_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nCyber.Databreach 0.5824 0.3630 0.4473 146\nCyber.DiscoverVulnerability 0.6194 0.3402 0.4392 244\nCyber.PatchVulnerability 0.7079 0.5000 0.5860 126\nCyber.Phishing 0.6923 0.2105 0.3229 171\nCyber.Ransom 0.8519 0.1361 0.2347 169\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 0.6565 0.3014 0.4131 856\nmacro avg 0.6908 0.3100 0.4060 856", "eval_event_trigger_relaxed_micro_precision": 0.7786259541984732, "eval_event_trigger_relaxed_micro_recall": 0.3574766355140187, "eval_event_trigger_relaxed_micro_f1": 0.48999199359487594, "eval_event_trigger_relaxed_macro_precision": 0.819208088325982, "eval_event_trigger_relaxed_macro_recall": 0.3714471518022961, "eval_event_trigger_relaxed_macro_f1": 0.4858129949600869, "eval_event_trigger_relaxed_support": 856, "eval_event_trigger_relaxed_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nCyber.Databreach 0.7033 0.4384 0.5401 146\nCyber.DiscoverVulnerability 0.6866 0.3770 0.4868 244\nCyber.PatchVulnerability 0.8764 0.6190 0.7256 126\nCyber.Phishing 0.9038 0.2749 0.4215 171\nCyber.Ransom 0.9259 0.1479 0.2551 169\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 0.7786 0.3575 0.4900 856\nmacro avg 0.8192 0.3714 0.4858 856", "eval_event_argument_strict_micro_precision": 0.10122699386503067, "eval_event_argument_strict_micro_recall": 0.04102776626605885, "eval_event_argument_strict_micro_f1": 0.05838985549985256, "eval_event_argument_strict_macro_precision": 0.09333334774462895, "eval_event_argument_strict_macro_recall": 0.03767139590145343, "eval_event_argument_strict_macro_f1": 0.05087823993503374, "eval_event_argument_strict_support": 2413, "eval_event_argument_strict_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nAttack-Pattern 0.2000 0.0161 0.0299 124\nAttacker 0.1316 0.0532 0.0758 188\nCVE 0.0400 0.0312 0.0351 32\nCapabilities 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 57\nCompromised-Data 0.1923 0.1205 0.1481 166\nDamage-Amount 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 1\nDiscoverer 0.0568 0.0305 0.0397 164\nIssues-Addressed 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 17\nNumber-of-Data 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 12\nNumber-of-Victim 0.2500 0.1818 0.2105 11\nPatch 0.0377 0.0308 0.0339 65\nPatch-Number 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 21\nPayment-Method 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 26\nPlace 0.2500 0.1000 0.1429 10\nPrice 0.3636 0.1143 0.1739 35\nPurpose 0.2000 0.0299 0.0519 67\nReleaser 0.0484 0.0405 0.0441 74\nSupported_Platform 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 2\nTime 0.1774 0.0728 0.1033 151\nTool 0.1429 0.0284 0.0473 141\nTrusted-Entity 0.0385 0.0112 0.0174 89\nVictim 0.1324 0.0500 0.0726 360\nVulnerability 0.0317 0.0134 0.0189 298\nVulnerable_System 0.0899 0.0386 0.0541 207\nVulnerable_System_Owner 0.0435 0.0161 0.0235 62\nVulnerable_System_Version 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 33\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 0.1012 0.0410 0.0584 2413\nmacro avg 0.0933 0.0377 0.0509 2413", "eval_event_argument_relaxed_micro_precision": 0.7694840834248079, "eval_event_argument_relaxed_micro_recall": 0.3180580762250454, "eval_event_argument_relaxed_micro_f1": 0.45008025682182984, "eval_event_argument_relaxed_macro_precision": 0.757448285854237, "eval_event_argument_relaxed_macro_recall": 0.3415952275367054, "eval_event_argument_relaxed_macro_f1": 0.4292055169835072, "eval_event_argument_relaxed_support": 2204, "eval_event_argument_relaxed_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nAttack-Pattern 0.3000 0.0246 0.0455 122\nAttacker 0.7027 0.3077 0.4280 169\nCVE 0.9167 0.7333 0.8148 30\nCapabilities 1.0000 0.1053 0.1905 57\nCompromised-Data 0.7742 0.4706 0.5854 153\nDamage-Amount 0.5000 1.0000 0.6667 1\nDiscoverer 0.7342 0.4173 0.5321 139\nIssues-Addressed 1.0000 0.1765 0.3000 17\nNumber-of-Data 0.7500 0.2500 0.3750 12\nNumber-of-Victim 0.7143 0.4545 0.5556 11\nPatch 0.8400 0.7000 0.7636 60\nPatch-Number 0.8889 0.4000 0.5517 20\nPayment-Method 1.0000 0.1250 0.2222 24\nPlace 1.0000 0.3000 0.4615 10\nPrice 1.0000 0.3143 0.4783 35\nPurpose 0.7000 0.1045 0.1818 67\nReleaser 0.6727 0.6981 0.6852 53\nSupported_Platform 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 2\nTime 0.8689 0.3681 0.5171 144\nTool 0.7143 0.1639 0.2667 122\nTrusted-Entity 0.8800 0.2558 0.3964 86\nVictim 0.7436 0.2677 0.3937 325\nVulnerability 0.7815 0.3310 0.4650 281\nVulnerable_System 0.7471 0.3571 0.4833 182\nVulnerable_System_Owner 0.9091 0.4000 0.5556 50\nVulnerable_System_Version 0.5556 0.1562 0.2439 32\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 0.7695 0.3181 0.4501 2204\nmacro avg 0.7574 0.3416 0.4292 2204", "eval_event_strict_micro_precision": 0.33768778576094055, "eval_event_strict_micro_recall": 0.14968152866242038, "eval_event_strict_micro_f1": 0.20742226680040118, "eval_event_strict_macro_precision": 0.3022364533764287, "eval_event_strict_macro_recall": 0.1880677282333556, "eval_event_strict_macro_f1": 0.2195673971659967, "eval_event_strict_support": 3454, "eval_event_strict_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\narg:Attack-Pattern 0.2000 0.0161 0.0299 124\narg:Attacker 0.1316 0.0532 0.0758 188\narg:CVE 0.0400 0.0312 0.0351 32\narg:Capabilities 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 57\narg:Compromised-Data 0.1923 0.1205 0.1481 166\narg:Damage-Amount 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 1\narg:Discoverer 0.0568 0.0305 0.0397 164\narg:Issues-Addressed 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 17\narg:Number-of-Data 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 12\narg:Number-of-Victim 0.2500 0.1818 0.2105 11\narg:Patch 0.0377 0.0308 0.0339 65\narg:Patch-Number 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 21\narg:Payment-Method 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 26\narg:Place 0.2500 0.1000 0.1429 10\narg:Price 0.3636 0.1143 0.1739 35\narg:Purpose 0.2000 0.0299 0.0519 67\narg:Releaser 0.0484 0.0405 0.0441 74\narg:Supported_Platform 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 2\narg:Time 0.1774 0.0728 0.1033 151\narg:Tool 0.1429 0.0284 0.0473 141\narg:Trusted-Entity 0.0385 0.0112 0.0174 89\narg:Victim 0.1324 0.0500 0.0726 360\narg:Vulnerability 0.0317 0.0134 0.0189 298\narg:Vulnerable_System 0.0899 0.0386 0.0541 207\narg:Vulnerable_System_Owner 0.0435 0.0161 0.0235 62\narg:Vulnerable_System_Version 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 33\ntrigger:Cyber.Databreach 0.5824 0.3630 0.4473 146\ntrigger:Cyber.DiscoverVulnerability 0.6194 0.3402 0.4392 244\ntrigger:Cyber.PatchVulnerability 0.7079 0.5000 0.5860 126\ntrigger:Cyber.Phishing 0.6923 0.2105 0.3229 171\ntrigger:Cyber.Ransom 0.8519 0.1361 0.2347 169\ntype:Cyber.Databreach 1.0000 0.9149 0.9556 47\ntype:Cyber.DiscoverVulnerability 1.0000 0.9111 0.9535 45\ntype:Cyber.PatchVulnerability 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 33\ntype:Cyber.Phishing 1.0000 0.8438 0.9153 32\ntype:Cyber.Ransom 1.0000 0.5714 0.7273 28\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 0.3377 0.1497 0.2074 3454\nmacro avg 0.3022 0.1881 0.2196 3454", "eval_event_relaxed_micro_precision": 0.7971311475409836, "eval_event_relaxed_micro_recall": 0.3596302003081664, "eval_event_relaxed_micro_f1": 0.49564663410490556, "eval_event_relaxed_macro_precision": 0.7997137742733353, "eval_event_relaxed_macro_recall": 0.416108193736855, "eval_event_relaxed_macro_f1": 0.5038883141272518, "eval_event_relaxed_support": 3245, "eval_event_relaxed_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\narg:Attack-Pattern 0.3000 0.0246 0.0455 122\narg:Attacker 0.7027 0.3077 0.4280 169\narg:CVE 0.9167 0.7333 0.8148 30\narg:Capabilities 1.0000 0.1053 0.1905 57\narg:Compromised-Data 0.7742 0.4706 0.5854 153\narg:Damage-Amount 0.5000 1.0000 0.6667 1\narg:Discoverer 0.7342 0.4173 0.5321 139\narg:Issues-Addressed 1.0000 0.1765 0.3000 17\narg:Number-of-Data 0.7500 0.2500 0.3750 12\narg:Number-of-Victim 0.7143 0.4545 0.5556 11\narg:Patch 0.8400 0.7000 0.7636 60\narg:Patch-Number 0.8889 0.4000 0.5517 20\narg:Payment-Method 1.0000 0.1250 0.2222 24\narg:Place 1.0000 0.3000 0.4615 10\narg:Price 1.0000 0.3143 0.4783 35\narg:Purpose 0.7000 0.1045 0.1818 67\narg:Releaser 0.6727 0.6981 0.6852 53\narg:Supported_Platform 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 2\narg:Time 0.8689 0.3681 0.5171 144\narg:Tool 0.7143 0.1639 0.2667 122\narg:Trusted-Entity 0.8800 0.2558 0.3964 86\narg:Victim 0.7436 0.2677 0.3937 325\narg:Vulnerability 0.7815 0.3310 0.4650 281\narg:Vulnerable_System 0.7471 0.3571 0.4833 182\narg:Vulnerable_System_Owner 0.9091 0.4000 0.5556 50\narg:Vulnerable_System_Version 0.5556 0.1562 0.2439 32\ntrigger:Cyber.Databreach 0.7033 0.4384 0.5401 146\ntrigger:Cyber.DiscoverVulnerability 0.6866 0.3770 0.4868 244\ntrigger:Cyber.PatchVulnerability 0.8764 0.6190 0.7256 126\ntrigger:Cyber.Phishing 0.9038 0.2749 0.4215 171\ntrigger:Cyber.Ransom 0.9259 0.1479 0.2551 169\ntype:Cyber.Databreach 1.0000 0.9149 0.9556 47\ntype:Cyber.DiscoverVulnerability 1.0000 0.9111 0.9535 45\ntype:Cyber.PatchVulnerability 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 33\ntype:Cyber.Phishing 1.0000 0.8438 0.9153 32\ntype:Cyber.Ransom 1.0000 0.5714 0.7273 28\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 0.7971 0.3596 0.4956 3245\nmacro avg 0.7997 0.4161 0.5039 3245", "eval_entity_error_COR": 1397, "eval_entity_error_LE": 53, "eval_entity_error_BES": 128, "eval_entity_error_BEL": 108, "eval_entity_error_BEO": 54, "eval_entity_error_LBE": 79, "eval_entity_error_FP": 1020, "eval_entity_error_FN": 317, "eval_entity_fair_micro_precision": 0.5315829528158296, "eval_entity_fair_micro_recall": 0.7257142857142858, "eval_entity_fair_micro_f1": 0.6136613222051396, "eval_entity_fair_support": 2136, "eval_entity_error_report": "entity error analysis (Ortmann 2022, fair evaluation)\ntype count\n-----------------\nCOR 1397\nLE 53\nBES 128\nBEL 108\nBEO 54\nLBE 79\nFP 1020\nFN 317\n-----------------\nfair P / R / F1: 0.5316 / 0.7257 / 0.6137\n\nlabel confusions (gold -> pred):\n Person -> Organization: 10\n Capabilities -> Organization: 7\n System -> Software: 7\n Capabilities -> Data: 6\n Capabilities -> Person: 6\n PII -> Data: 6\n System -> Organization: 6\n Capabilities -> File: 5\n Capabilities -> Purpose: 5\n Organization -> Person: 5\n Capabilities -> Vulnerability: 4\n Data -> PII: 4\n Organization -> System: 4\n Purpose -> Capabilities: 4\n Purpose -> PII: 4\n Capabilities -> Malware: 2\n Capabilities -> Software: 2\n Purpose -> Data: 2\n Software -> System: 2\n System -> Device: 2\n Version -> Patch: 2\n Website -> File: 2\n Capabilities -> Device: 1\n Capabilities -> PII: 1\n Capabilities -> System: 1\n Capabilities -> Website: 1\n Data -> Capabilities: 1\n Data -> Organization: 1\n Data -> Person: 1\n Data -> Purpose: 1\n Device -> Capabilities: 1\n Device -> System: 1\n Device -> Vulnerability: 1\n File -> Purpose: 1\n Malware -> Capabilities: 1\n Malware -> File: 1\n Malware -> Person: 1\n Organization -> Vulnerability: 1\n PII -> Capabilities: 1\n PII -> Person: 1\n PII -> Purpose: 1\n PaymentMethod -> Money: 1\n Person -> Device: 1\n Person -> Vulnerability: 1\n Person -> Website: 1\n Purpose -> Person: 1\n Purpose -> System: 1\n Software -> File: 1\n Software -> Purpose: 1\n System -> Capabilities: 1\n System -> Person: 1\n System -> Vulnerability: 1\n Version -> System: 1\n Vulnerability -> Capabilities: 1\n Vulnerability -> Organization: 1\n Vulnerability -> Version: 1\n Website -> Vulnerability: 1", "eval_event_trigger_error_COR": 258, "eval_event_trigger_error_LE": 3, "eval_event_trigger_error_BES": 35, "eval_event_trigger_error_BEL": 10, "eval_event_trigger_error_BEO": 3, "eval_event_trigger_error_LBE": 0, "eval_event_trigger_error_FP": 84, "eval_event_trigger_error_FN": 547, "eval_event_trigger_fair_micro_precision": 0.7020408163265306, "eval_event_trigger_fair_micro_recall": 0.3106562311860325, "eval_event_trigger_fair_micro_f1": 0.4307178631051753, "eval_event_trigger_fair_support": 856, "eval_event_trigger_error_report": "event_trigger error analysis (Ortmann 2022, fair evaluation)\ntype count\n-----------------\nCOR 258\nLE 3\nBES 35\nBEL 10\nBEO 3\nLBE 0\nFP 84\nFN 547\n-----------------\nfair P / R / F1: 0.7020 / 0.3107 / 0.4307\n\nlabel confusions (gold -> pred):\n Cyber.DiscoverVulnerability -> Cyber.PatchVulnerability: 2\n Cyber.Databreach -> Cyber.DiscoverVulnerability: 1", "eval_event_argument_error_COR": 618, "eval_event_argument_error_LE": 22, "eval_event_argument_error_BES": 39, "eval_event_argument_error_BEL": 30, "eval_event_argument_error_BEO": 19, "eval_event_argument_error_LBE": 28, "eval_event_argument_error_FP": 121, "eval_event_argument_error_FN": 1407, "eval_event_argument_fair_micro_precision": 0.7648514851485149, "eval_event_argument_fair_micro_recall": 0.29512893982808025, "eval_event_argument_fair_micro_f1": 0.4259131633356306, "eval_event_argument_fair_support": 2163, "eval_event_argument_error_report": "event_argument error analysis (Ortmann 2022, fair evaluation)\ntype count\n-----------------\nCOR 618\nLE 22\nBES 39\nBEL 30\nBEO 19\nLBE 28\nFP 121\nFN 1407\n-----------------\nfair P / R / F1: 0.7649 / 0.2951 / 0.4259\n\nlabel confusions (gold -> pred):\n Discoverer -> Releaser: 5\n Vulnerable_System_Owner -> Releaser: 5\n Purpose -> Compromised-Data: 3\n Attack-Pattern -> Tool: 2\n Attacker -> Victim: 2\n Capabilities -> Compromised-Data: 2\n Compromised-Data -> Attack-Pattern: 2\n Patch-Number -> Vulnerable_System_Version: 2\n Victim -> Compromised-Data: 2\n Vulnerable_System_Owner -> Vulnerable_System: 2\n Attack-Pattern -> Compromised-Data: 1\n Attack-Pattern -> Discoverer: 1\n Attack-Pattern -> Purpose: 1\n Attack-Pattern -> Releaser: 1\n Attack-Pattern -> Trusted-Entity: 1\n Capabilities -> Attack-Pattern: 1\n Capabilities -> Releaser: 1\n Capabilities -> Tool: 1\n Capabilities -> Victim: 1\n Capabilities -> Vulnerability: 1\n Discoverer -> Patch: 1\n Discoverer -> Vulnerability: 1\n Issues-Addressed -> Compromised-Data: 1\n Issues-Addressed -> Releaser: 1\n Patch -> Patch-Number: 1\n Purpose -> Victim: 1\n Releaser -> Compromised-Data: 1\n Releaser -> Discoverer: 1\n Trusted-Entity -> Attacker: 1\n Vulnerability -> Discoverer: 1\n Vulnerability -> Patch: 1\n Vulnerable_System_Owner -> Victim: 1\n Vulnerable_System_Version -> Patch-Number: 1" }