{ "eval_entity_strict_micro_precision": 0.5303312244138444, "eval_entity_strict_micro_recall": 0.6671348314606742, "eval_entity_strict_micro_f1": 0.5909185154468173, "eval_entity_strict_macro_precision": 0.5535129565492735, "eval_entity_strict_macro_recall": 0.6786390842577048, "eval_entity_strict_macro_f1": 0.6062922965299374, "eval_entity_strict_support": 2136, "eval_entity_strict_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nCVE 0.8571 1.0000 0.9231 30\nCapabilities 0.3598 0.4388 0.3954 196\nData 0.4257 0.6935 0.5276 62\nDevice 0.5714 0.5882 0.5797 68\nFile 0.6308 0.6613 0.6457 62\nGPE 0.4545 0.5000 0.4762 10\nMalware 0.4815 0.5000 0.4906 52\nMoney 0.6939 0.9444 0.8000 36\nNumber 0.7586 0.9565 0.8462 23\nOrganization 0.5104 0.6877 0.5859 285\nPII 0.5000 0.7216 0.5907 97\nPatch 0.7213 0.7333 0.7273 60\nPaymentMethod 0.4615 0.5000 0.4800 24\nPerson 0.5950 0.7441 0.6613 383\nPurpose 0.4186 0.5373 0.4706 67\nSoftware 0.4474 0.7083 0.5484 72\nSystem 0.3889 0.5431 0.4532 116\nTime 0.6497 0.7183 0.6823 142\nVersion 0.6600 0.6346 0.6471 52\nVulnerability 0.5593 0.6815 0.6144 270\nWebsite 0.4783 0.7586 0.5867 29\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 0.5303 0.6671 0.5909 2136\nmacro avg 0.5535 0.6786 0.6063 2136", "eval_entity_relaxed_micro_precision": 0.6557499069594344, "eval_entity_relaxed_micro_recall": 0.8249063670411985, "eval_entity_relaxed_micro_f1": 0.7306655608542402, "eval_entity_relaxed_macro_precision": 0.6900576767036484, "eval_entity_relaxed_macro_recall": 0.8405442839484656, "eval_entity_relaxed_macro_f1": 0.753632838197874, "eval_entity_relaxed_support": 2136, "eval_entity_relaxed_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nCVE 0.8571 1.0000 0.9231 30\nCapabilities 0.5732 0.6990 0.6299 196\nData 0.4950 0.8065 0.6135 62\nDevice 0.7286 0.7500 0.7391 68\nFile 0.7077 0.7419 0.7244 62\nGPE 0.8182 0.9000 0.8571 10\nMalware 0.6852 0.7115 0.6981 52\nMoney 0.7347 1.0000 0.8471 36\nNumber 0.7586 0.9565 0.8462 23\nOrganization 0.6042 0.8140 0.6936 285\nPII 0.6000 0.8660 0.7089 97\nPatch 0.8525 0.8667 0.8595 60\nPaymentMethod 0.7692 0.8333 0.8000 24\nPerson 0.6785 0.8486 0.7541 383\nPurpose 0.5930 0.7612 0.6667 67\nSoftware 0.5175 0.8194 0.6344 72\nSystem 0.5247 0.7328 0.6115 116\nTime 0.7325 0.8099 0.7692 142\nVersion 0.9200 0.8846 0.9020 52\nVulnerability 0.7538 0.9185 0.8280 270\nWebsite 0.5870 0.9310 0.7200 29\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 0.6557 0.8249 0.7307 2136\nmacro avg 0.6901 0.8405 0.7536 2136", "eval_event_type_strict_micro_precision": 1.0, "eval_event_type_strict_micro_recall": 0.9513513513513514, "eval_event_type_strict_micro_f1": 0.9750692520775623, "eval_event_type_strict_macro_precision": 1.0, "eval_event_type_strict_macro_recall": 0.9421732522796352, "eval_event_type_strict_macro_f1": 0.9691315136476428, "eval_event_type_strict_support": 185, "eval_event_type_strict_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nCyber.Databreach 1.0000 0.9787 0.9892 47\nCyber.DiscoverVulnerability 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 45\nCyber.PatchVulnerability 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 33\nCyber.Phishing 1.0000 0.8750 0.9333 32\nCyber.Ransom 1.0000 0.8571 0.9231 28\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 1.0000 0.9514 0.9751 185\nmacro avg 1.0000 0.9422 0.9691 185", "eval_event_type_relaxed_micro_precision": 1.0, "eval_event_type_relaxed_micro_recall": 0.9513513513513514, "eval_event_type_relaxed_micro_f1": 0.9750692520775623, "eval_event_type_relaxed_macro_precision": 1.0, "eval_event_type_relaxed_macro_recall": 0.9421732522796352, "eval_event_type_relaxed_macro_f1": 0.9691315136476428, "eval_event_type_relaxed_support": 185, "eval_event_type_relaxed_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nCyber.Databreach 1.0000 0.9787 0.9892 47\nCyber.DiscoverVulnerability 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 45\nCyber.PatchVulnerability 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 33\nCyber.Phishing 1.0000 0.8750 0.9333 32\nCyber.Ransom 1.0000 0.8571 0.9231 28\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 1.0000 0.9514 0.9751 185\nmacro avg 1.0000 0.9422 0.9691 185", "eval_event_trigger_strict_micro_precision": 0.7107623318385651, "eval_event_trigger_strict_micro_recall": 0.3703271028037383, "eval_event_trigger_strict_micro_f1": 0.4869431643625192, "eval_event_trigger_strict_macro_precision": 0.7166741791901531, "eval_event_trigger_strict_macro_recall": 0.380790463420424, "eval_event_trigger_strict_macro_f1": 0.4866310627568544, "eval_event_trigger_strict_support": 856, "eval_event_trigger_strict_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nCyber.Databreach 0.6526 0.4247 0.5145 146\nCyber.DiscoverVulnerability 0.6838 0.3811 0.4895 244\nCyber.PatchVulnerability 0.7553 0.5635 0.6455 126\nCyber.Phishing 0.7857 0.3216 0.4564 171\nCyber.Ransom 0.7059 0.2130 0.3273 169\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 0.7108 0.3703 0.4869 856\nmacro avg 0.7167 0.3808 0.4866 856", "eval_event_trigger_relaxed_micro_precision": 0.8363228699551569, "eval_event_trigger_relaxed_micro_recall": 0.4357476635514019, "eval_event_trigger_relaxed_micro_f1": 0.5729646697388633, "eval_event_trigger_relaxed_macro_precision": 0.8553896160927976, "eval_event_trigger_relaxed_macro_recall": 0.4503194036113662, "eval_event_trigger_relaxed_macro_f1": 0.5765693184299867, "eval_event_trigger_relaxed_support": 856, "eval_event_trigger_relaxed_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nCyber.Databreach 0.7684 0.5000 0.6058 146\nCyber.DiscoverVulnerability 0.7721 0.4303 0.5526 244\nCyber.PatchVulnerability 0.9043 0.6746 0.7727 126\nCyber.Phishing 0.8714 0.3567 0.5062 171\nCyber.Ransom 0.9608 0.2899 0.4455 169\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 0.8363 0.4357 0.5730 856\nmacro avg 0.8554 0.4503 0.5766 856", "eval_event_argument_strict_micro_precision": 0.2419716206123973, "eval_event_argument_strict_micro_recall": 0.13427268959801078, "eval_event_argument_strict_micro_f1": 0.17270788912579957, "eval_event_argument_strict_macro_precision": 0.2296753557065223, "eval_event_argument_strict_macro_recall": 0.1169331406112381, "eval_event_argument_strict_macro_f1": 0.14838122390229586, "eval_event_argument_strict_support": 2413, "eval_event_argument_strict_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nAttack-Pattern 0.2000 0.0565 0.0881 124\nAttacker 0.2586 0.1596 0.1974 188\nCVE 0.1000 0.0938 0.0968 32\nCapabilities 0.2941 0.0877 0.1351 57\nCompromised-Data 0.2652 0.2108 0.2349 166\nDamage-Amount 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 1\nDiscoverer 0.1679 0.1341 0.1492 164\nIssues-Addressed 0.1667 0.0588 0.0870 17\nNumber-of-Data 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 12\nNumber-of-Victim 0.5000 0.3636 0.4211 11\nPatch 0.2683 0.1692 0.2075 65\nPatch-Number 0.2500 0.0476 0.0800 21\nPayment-Method 0.1667 0.0385 0.0625 26\nPlace 0.4000 0.2000 0.2667 10\nPrice 0.5455 0.1714 0.2609 35\nPurpose 0.2609 0.0896 0.1333 67\nReleaser 0.2619 0.2973 0.2785 74\nSupported_Platform 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 2\nTime 0.3800 0.1258 0.1891 151\nTool 0.2955 0.0922 0.1405 141\nTrusted-Entity 0.3000 0.1348 0.1860 89\nVictim 0.2629 0.1278 0.1720 360\nVulnerability 0.2217 0.1510 0.1796 298\nVulnerable_System 0.2314 0.1353 0.1707 207\nVulnerable_System_Owner 0.0976 0.0645 0.0777 62\nVulnerable_System_Version 0.0769 0.0303 0.0435 33\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 0.2420 0.1343 0.1727 2413\nmacro avg 0.2297 0.1169 0.1484 2413", "eval_event_argument_relaxed_micro_precision": 0.8015665796344648, "eval_event_argument_relaxed_micro_recall": 0.41787658802177857, "eval_event_argument_relaxed_micro_f1": 0.5493587831792425, "eval_event_argument_relaxed_macro_precision": 0.8620857154944501, "eval_event_argument_relaxed_macro_recall": 0.4241622875063204, "eval_event_argument_relaxed_macro_f1": 0.5376328900685231, "eval_event_argument_relaxed_support": 2204, "eval_event_argument_relaxed_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nAttack-Pattern 0.6857 0.1967 0.3057 122\nAttacker 0.7822 0.4675 0.5852 169\nCVE 0.9565 0.7333 0.8302 30\nCapabilities 0.8235 0.2456 0.3784 57\nCompromised-Data 0.7350 0.5621 0.6370 153\nDamage-Amount 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1\nDiscoverer 0.7959 0.5612 0.6582 139\nIssues-Addressed 0.8333 0.2941 0.4348 17\nNumber-of-Data 1.0000 0.0833 0.1538 12\nNumber-of-Victim 0.8750 0.6364 0.7368 11\nPatch 0.9231 0.6000 0.7273 60\nPatch-Number 1.0000 0.1500 0.2609 20\nPayment-Method 1.0000 0.1667 0.2857 24\nPlace 0.8000 0.4000 0.5333 10\nPrice 1.0000 0.2857 0.4444 35\nPurpose 0.8095 0.2537 0.3864 67\nReleaser 0.7308 0.7170 0.7238 53\nSupported_Platform 1.0000 0.5000 0.6667 2\nTime 0.9149 0.2986 0.4503 144\nTool 0.7561 0.2541 0.3804 122\nTrusted-Entity 0.8000 0.3256 0.4628 86\nVictim 0.7975 0.3877 0.5217 325\nVulnerability 0.7809 0.4947 0.6057 281\nVulnerable_System 0.8119 0.4505 0.5795 182\nVulnerable_System_Owner 0.8857 0.6200 0.7294 50\nVulnerable_System_Version 0.9167 0.3438 0.5000 32\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 0.8016 0.4179 0.5494 2204\nmacro avg 0.8621 0.4242 0.5376 2204", "eval_event_strict_micro_precision": 0.4166241713411525, "eval_event_strict_micro_recall": 0.23653734800231616, "eval_event_strict_micro_f1": 0.3017543859649123, "eval_event_strict_macro_precision": 0.4043036151200096, "eval_event_strict_macro_recall": 0.2681966731775691, "eval_event_strict_macro_f1": 0.30935346398561614, "eval_event_strict_support": 3454, "eval_event_strict_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\narg:Attack-Pattern 0.2000 0.0565 0.0881 124\narg:Attacker 0.2586 0.1596 0.1974 188\narg:CVE 0.1000 0.0938 0.0968 32\narg:Capabilities 0.2941 0.0877 0.1351 57\narg:Compromised-Data 0.2652 0.2108 0.2349 166\narg:Damage-Amount 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 1\narg:Discoverer 0.1679 0.1341 0.1492 164\narg:Issues-Addressed 0.1667 0.0588 0.0870 17\narg:Number-of-Data 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 12\narg:Number-of-Victim 0.5000 0.3636 0.4211 11\narg:Patch 0.2683 0.1692 0.2075 65\narg:Patch-Number 0.2500 0.0476 0.0800 21\narg:Payment-Method 0.1667 0.0385 0.0625 26\narg:Place 0.4000 0.2000 0.2667 10\narg:Price 0.5455 0.1714 0.2609 35\narg:Purpose 0.2609 0.0896 0.1333 67\narg:Releaser 0.2619 0.2973 0.2785 74\narg:Supported_Platform 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 2\narg:Time 0.3800 0.1258 0.1891 151\narg:Tool 0.2955 0.0922 0.1405 141\narg:Trusted-Entity 0.3000 0.1348 0.1860 89\narg:Victim 0.2629 0.1278 0.1720 360\narg:Vulnerability 0.2217 0.1510 0.1796 298\narg:Vulnerable_System 0.2314 0.1353 0.1707 207\narg:Vulnerable_System_Owner 0.0976 0.0645 0.0777 62\narg:Vulnerable_System_Version 0.0769 0.0303 0.0435 33\ntrigger:Cyber.Databreach 0.6526 0.4247 0.5145 146\ntrigger:Cyber.DiscoverVulnerability 0.6838 0.3811 0.4895 244\ntrigger:Cyber.PatchVulnerability 0.7553 0.5635 0.6455 126\ntrigger:Cyber.Phishing 0.7857 0.3216 0.4564 171\ntrigger:Cyber.Ransom 0.7059 0.2130 0.3273 169\ntype:Cyber.Databreach 1.0000 0.9787 0.9892 47\ntype:Cyber.DiscoverVulnerability 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 45\ntype:Cyber.PatchVulnerability 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 33\ntype:Cyber.Phishing 1.0000 0.8750 0.9333 32\ntype:Cyber.Ransom 1.0000 0.8571 0.9231 28\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 0.4166 0.2365 0.3018 3454\nmacro avg 0.4043 0.2682 0.3094 3454", "eval_event_relaxed_micro_precision": 0.8300395256916996, "eval_event_relaxed_micro_recall": 0.4530046224961479, "eval_event_relaxed_micro_f1": 0.5861244019138755, "eval_event_relaxed_macro_precision": 0.880310463425547, "eval_event_relaxed_macro_recall": 0.499741187628315, "eval_event_relaxed_macro_f1": 0.6029710917269374, "eval_event_relaxed_support": 3245, "eval_event_relaxed_classification_report": "label precision recall f1 support\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\narg:Attack-Pattern 0.6857 0.1967 0.3057 122\narg:Attacker 0.7822 0.4675 0.5852 169\narg:CVE 0.9565 0.7333 0.8302 30\narg:Capabilities 0.8235 0.2456 0.3784 57\narg:Compromised-Data 0.7350 0.5621 0.6370 153\narg:Damage-Amount 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1\narg:Discoverer 0.7959 0.5612 0.6582 139\narg:Issues-Addressed 0.8333 0.2941 0.4348 17\narg:Number-of-Data 1.0000 0.0833 0.1538 12\narg:Number-of-Victim 0.8750 0.6364 0.7368 11\narg:Patch 0.9231 0.6000 0.7273 60\narg:Patch-Number 1.0000 0.1500 0.2609 20\narg:Payment-Method 1.0000 0.1667 0.2857 24\narg:Place 0.8000 0.4000 0.5333 10\narg:Price 1.0000 0.2857 0.4444 35\narg:Purpose 0.8095 0.2537 0.3864 67\narg:Releaser 0.7308 0.7170 0.7238 53\narg:Supported_Platform 1.0000 0.5000 0.6667 2\narg:Time 0.9149 0.2986 0.4503 144\narg:Tool 0.7561 0.2541 0.3804 122\narg:Trusted-Entity 0.8000 0.3256 0.4628 86\narg:Victim 0.7975 0.3877 0.5217 325\narg:Vulnerability 0.7809 0.4947 0.6057 281\narg:Vulnerable_System 0.8119 0.4505 0.5795 182\narg:Vulnerable_System_Owner 0.8857 0.6200 0.7294 50\narg:Vulnerable_System_Version 0.9167 0.3438 0.5000 32\ntrigger:Cyber.Databreach 0.7684 0.5000 0.6058 146\ntrigger:Cyber.DiscoverVulnerability 0.7721 0.4303 0.5526 244\ntrigger:Cyber.PatchVulnerability 0.9043 0.6746 0.7727 126\ntrigger:Cyber.Phishing 0.8714 0.3567 0.5062 171\ntrigger:Cyber.Ransom 0.9608 0.2899 0.4455 169\ntype:Cyber.Databreach 1.0000 0.9787 0.9892 47\ntype:Cyber.DiscoverVulnerability 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 45\ntype:Cyber.PatchVulnerability 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 33\ntype:Cyber.Phishing 1.0000 0.8750 0.9333 32\ntype:Cyber.Ransom 1.0000 0.8571 0.9231 28\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\nmicro avg 0.8300 0.4530 0.5861 3245\nmacro avg 0.8803 0.4997 0.6030 3245", "eval_entity_error_COR": 1448, "eval_entity_error_LE": 41, "eval_entity_error_BES": 134, "eval_entity_error_BEL": 109, "eval_entity_error_BEO": 63, "eval_entity_error_LBE": 70, "eval_entity_error_FP": 822, "eval_entity_error_FN": 271, "eval_entity_fair_micro_precision": 0.58422432923139, "eval_entity_fair_micro_recall": 0.7512321660181582, "eval_entity_fair_micro_f1": 0.6572855197458012, "eval_entity_fair_support": 2136, "eval_entity_error_report": "entity error analysis (Ortmann 2022, fair evaluation)\ntype count\n-----------------\nCOR 1448\nLE 41\nBES 134\nBEL 109\nBEO 63\nLBE 70\nFP 822\nFN 271\n-----------------\nfair P / R / F1: 0.5842 / 0.7512 / 0.6573\n\nlabel confusions (gold -> pred):\n Organization -> Person: 7\n Person -> Organization: 7\n System -> Software: 7\n Capabilities -> Data: 5\n Data -> PII: 5\n Capabilities -> Organization: 4\n Capabilities -> Vulnerability: 4\n Purpose -> Capabilities: 4\n System -> Organization: 4\n Capabilities -> File: 3\n Capabilities -> Purpose: 3\n Capabilities -> Website: 3\n File -> Capabilities: 3\n Organization -> System: 3\n Person -> Capabilities: 3\n Vulnerability -> Capabilities: 3\n Malware -> Person: 2\n Malware -> Purpose: 2\n PII -> Data: 2\n Purpose -> Person: 2\n Software -> Capabilities: 2\n Software -> System: 2\n System -> Device: 2\n Capabilities -> Device: 1\n Capabilities -> Person: 1\n Capabilities -> Software: 1\n Capabilities -> System: 1\n Data -> Organization: 1\n Data -> Person: 1\n Malware -> Capabilities: 1\n Organization -> Software: 1\n Organization -> Vulnerability: 1\n Organization -> Website: 1\n PII -> Capabilities: 1\n PII -> Person: 1\n PII -> Purpose: 1\n PII -> Website: 1\n Patch -> Software: 1\n Patch -> System: 1\n Patch -> Version: 1\n Person -> System: 1\n Person -> Vulnerability: 1\n Purpose -> Data: 1\n Purpose -> Organization: 1\n Purpose -> PII: 1\n Software -> Organization: 1\n Software -> Purpose: 1\n System -> Capabilities: 1\n System -> Vulnerability: 1\n Vulnerability -> Organization: 1\n Vulnerability -> Person: 1\n Website -> File: 1", "eval_event_trigger_error_COR": 317, "eval_event_trigger_error_LE": 1, "eval_event_trigger_error_BES": 30, "eval_event_trigger_error_BEL": 17, "eval_event_trigger_error_BEO": 9, "eval_event_trigger_error_LBE": 0, "eval_event_trigger_error_FP": 72, "eval_event_trigger_error_FN": 482, "eval_event_trigger_fair_micro_precision": 0.7592814371257485, "eval_event_trigger_fair_micro_recall": 0.38308157099697887, "eval_event_trigger_fair_micro_f1": 0.5092369477911647, "eval_event_trigger_fair_support": 856, "eval_event_trigger_error_report": "event_trigger error analysis (Ortmann 2022, fair evaluation)\ntype count\n-----------------\nCOR 317\nLE 1\nBES 30\nBEL 17\nBEO 9\nLBE 0\nFP 72\nFN 482\n-----------------\nfair P / R / F1: 0.7593 / 0.3831 / 0.5092\n\nlabel confusions (gold -> pred):\n Cyber.DiscoverVulnerability -> Cyber.PatchVulnerability: 1", "eval_event_argument_error_COR": 807, "eval_event_argument_error_LE": 9, "eval_event_argument_error_BES": 50, "eval_event_argument_error_BEL": 41, "eval_event_argument_error_BEO": 26, "eval_event_argument_error_LBE": 33, "eval_event_argument_error_FP": 163, "eval_event_argument_error_FN": 1197, "eval_event_argument_fair_micro_precision": 0.7689375893282515, "eval_event_argument_fair_micro_recall": 0.3873290136789057, "eval_event_argument_fair_micro_f1": 0.5151611873603575, "eval_event_argument_fair_support": 2163, "eval_event_argument_error_report": "event_argument error analysis (Ortmann 2022, fair evaluation)\ntype count\n-----------------\nCOR 807\nLE 9\nBES 50\nBEL 41\nBEO 26\nLBE 33\nFP 163\nFN 1197\n-----------------\nfair P / R / F1: 0.7689 / 0.3873 / 0.5152\n\nlabel confusions (gold -> pred):\n Attack-Pattern -> Tool: 3\n Capabilities -> Compromised-Data: 3\n Purpose -> Compromised-Data: 3\n Attacker -> Victim: 2\n Compromised-Data -> Victim: 2\n Discoverer -> Releaser: 2\n Vulnerability -> Discoverer: 2\n Vulnerable_System_Owner -> Releaser: 2\n Vulnerable_System_Owner -> Vulnerable_System: 2\n Attack-Pattern -> Trusted-Entity: 1\n Attack-Pattern -> Victim: 1\n Capabilities -> Attack-Pattern: 1\n Capabilities -> Issues-Addressed: 1\n Capabilities -> Vulnerable_System: 1\n Capabilities -> Vulnerable_System_Owner: 1\n Compromised-Data -> Attack-Pattern: 1\n Discoverer -> Vulnerable_System: 1\n Issues-Addressed -> Attacker: 1\n Issues-Addressed -> Discoverer: 1\n Issues-Addressed -> Vulnerability: 1\n Purpose -> Attack-Pattern: 1\n Purpose -> Tool: 1\n Purpose -> Victim: 1\n Releaser -> Compromised-Data: 1\n Releaser -> Vulnerable_System: 1\n Victim -> Attack-Pattern: 1\n Victim -> Attacker: 1\n Victim -> Compromised-Data: 1\n Vulnerability -> Releaser: 1\n Vulnerable_System_Owner -> Vulnerability: 1" }