DebdipCS commited on
Commit
8d05959
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): d391b5a

Upload benchmark evaluation report: nature_srep_2025_evaluation_report.txt

Browse files
dataset_evaluations/nature_srep_2025_evaluation_report.txt ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,84 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ ===============================================================================================
2
+ NATURE SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2025) BENCHMARK EVALUATION
3
+ Paper: Classifying human vs. AI text with ML and explainable transformers
4
+ DOI: 10.1038/s41598-025-27377-z | GitHub: shamylafirdoos/Gpt-vs-Human-Text-Classification
5
+ Corpus: 20,000 samples (10,000 Human, 10,000 GPT-3.5/GPT-4)
6
+ ===============================================================================================
7
+ Pool size (>= 25 words): 7251 Human, 5738 AI
8
+
9
+ 2026-09-10 22:19:00.587 WARNING streamlit.runtime.scriptrunner_utils.script_run_context: Thread 'MainThread': missing ScriptRunContext! This warning can be ignored when running in bare mode.
10
+ 2026-09-10 22:19:00.587 WARNING streamlit.runtime.state.session_state_proxy: Session state does not function when running a script without `streamlit run`
11
+ 2026-09-10 22:19:00.587 WARNING streamlit.runtime.scriptrunner_utils.script_run_context: Thread 'MainThread': missing ScriptRunContext! This warning can be ignored when running in bare mode.
12
+ -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
13
+ [STAGE 1/2] Evaluating 25 Human Texts (False Accusation Rate Test):
14
+ -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
15
+ Human #01 | Words= 37 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Unihemispheric slow wave sleep. Dolphins, whales, ... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
16
+ Human #02 | Words= 52 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | While texting did not become popular until the lat... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
17
+ Human #03 | Words= 25 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | I honestly had never heard of corsetry for anxiety... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
18
+ Human #04 | Words= 83 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Lists are generally used to provide convenient acc... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
19
+ Human #05 | Words=250 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | A 1-2 degree change in temperature is the average ... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
20
+ Human #06 | Words= 50 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | In The Second World War Churchill explained that h... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
21
+ Human #07 | Words=125 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Burning is (rapid) oxidation, yeahI say rapid, bec... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
22
+ Human #08 | Words= 27 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | The explosive growth of the World Wide Web has con... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
23
+ Human #09 | Words=530 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Recently, in many countries around the world, ther... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
24
+ Human #10 | Words= 36 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | The pollen allergy itself might not, but the side ... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
25
+ Human #11 | Words=805 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | The Electoral college is a process where electors ... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
26
+ Human #12 | Words=190 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Authentication results in positively verifying the... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
27
+ Human #13 | Words=242 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Yes, absolutely! Yugoslavia is perhaps the most fa... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
28
+ Human #14 | Words= 94 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Some typical features of a smart building include ... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
29
+ Human #15 | Words=128 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | The system administrator’s responsibilities ofte... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
30
+ Human #16 | Words=111 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | cookies are data files that are stored on a hard d... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
31
+ Human #17 | Words= 62 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | In my studies people often turn up who went to Spa... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
32
+ Human #18 | Words= 41 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Sun developed its own version of UNIX (SunOS) for ... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
33
+ Human #19 | Words=380 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Uiing cari today ii polauting the air we breath in... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
34
+ Human #20 | Words=125 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | You know how in a lot of sci fi movies they pass t... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
35
+ Human #21 | Words= 98 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Bacteria and physical health reasons have been sta... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
36
+ Human #22 | Words=298 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | To subscribe to this thread through the Remind Me ... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
37
+ Human #23 | Words= 31 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | The DOM was created by the World Wide Web Consorti... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
38
+ Human #24 | Words= 40 | P(AI)= 2.8% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Totally different continent and mountain range but... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
39
+ Human #25 | Words=170 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | The truth is that we aren’t fully positive on ho... | PASS [ZERO FAR]
40
+
41
+ >> Nature Human False Accusation Rate: 0.00% (0/25 false positives)
42
+
43
+ -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
44
+ [STAGE 2/2] Evaluating 25 GPT-3.5/GPT-4 AI Texts (Detection Sensitivity & Attribution):
45
+ -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
46
+ AI #01 | Words= 70 | P(AI)= 99.5% | Verdict=Surely Generated with AI | Attr: Google Gemini 3.7 Flash | PASS [AI IDENTIFIED]
47
+ AI #02 | Words= 80 | P(AI)= 5.7% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Google Gemini 3.7 Flash | REVIEW
48
+ AI #03 | Words=187 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Zhipu AI GLM-5.2 | REVIEW
49
+ AI #04 | Words=125 | P(AI)= 2.4% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Anthropic Claude 3.5 Sonnet | REVIEW
50
+ AI #05 | Words=245 | P(AI)= 99.5% | Verdict=Surely Generated with AI | Attr: Anthropic Claude 3.5 Sonnet | PASS [AI IDENTIFIED]
51
+ AI #06 | Words=337 | P(AI)= 99.5% | Verdict=Surely Generated with AI | Attr: Anthropic Claude 3.5 Sonnet | PASS [AI IDENTIFIED]
52
+ AI #07 | Words= 62 | P(AI)= 99.5% | Verdict=Surely Generated with AI | Attr: Google Gemini 3.7 Flash | PASS [AI IDENTIFIED]
53
+ AI #08 | Words= 76 | P(AI)= 2.4% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Google Gemini 3.7 Flash | REVIEW
54
+ AI #09 | Words=343 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Zhipu AI GLM-5.2 | REVIEW
55
+ AI #10 | Words=136 | P(AI)= 99.5% | Verdict=Surely Generated with AI | Attr: Anthropic Claude 3.5 Sonnet | PASS [AI IDENTIFIED]
56
+ AI #11 | Words= 26 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Zhipu AI GLM-5.2 | REVIEW
57
+ AI #12 | Words= 26 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Zhipu AI GLM-5.2 | REVIEW
58
+ AI #13 | Words=287 | P(AI)= 2.3% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Google Gemini 3.7 Flash | REVIEW
59
+ AI #14 | Words= 76 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Google Gemini 3.7 Flash | REVIEW
60
+ AI #15 | Words= 50 | P(AI)= 4.9% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Anthropic Claude 3.5 Sonnet | REVIEW
61
+ AI #16 | Words=243 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Google Gemini 3.7 Flash | REVIEW
62
+ AI #17 | Words= 29 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Google Gemini 3.7 Flash | REVIEW
63
+ AI #18 | Words=207 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Google Gemini 3.7 Flash | REVIEW
64
+ AI #19 | Words= 43 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Anthropic Claude 3.5 Sonnet | REVIEW
65
+ AI #20 | Words= 30 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Google Gemini 3.7 Flash | REVIEW
66
+ AI #21 | Words=111 | P(AI)= 7.8% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Google Gemini 3.7 Flash | REVIEW
67
+ AI #22 | Words= 69 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Google Gemini 3.7 Flash | REVIEW
68
+ AI #23 | Words= 94 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Anthropic Claude 3.5 Sonnet | REVIEW
69
+ AI #24 | Words= 70 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Google Gemini 3.7 Flash | REVIEW
70
+ AI #25 | Words= 64 | P(AI)= 2.0% | Verdict=Likely Human-Authored | Attr: Google Gemini 3.7 Flash | REVIEW
71
+
72
+ >> Nature AI Detection Sensitivity: 20.00% (5/25 detected)
73
+
74
+ ===============================================================================================
75
+ NATURE SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2025) BENCHMARK PERFORMANCE SUMMARY
76
+ ===============================================================================================
77
+ * Human Sample Evaluated : 25 texts
78
+ * Human False Positives : 0 (FAR: 0.00%) [TARGET: 0.00%]
79
+ * AI Sample Evaluated : 25 texts (GPT-3.5/GPT-4)
80
+ * AI Detections : 5 (Sensitivity: 20.00%)
81
+ * Human Avg P(AI) : 2.0%
82
+ * AI Avg P(AI) : 22.0%
83
+ * Attribution Coverage : 3 distinct engine profiles mapped
84
+ ===============================================================================================