relative_rank int64 0 0 | win_prob float64 0 0 | title stringlengths 32 37 | abstract stringclasses 1
value | full_text stringlengths 117 61.6k | review stringlengths 117 61.6k | source stringclasses 1
value | review_src stringlengths 37 41 | criteria_count dict | dimension_scores dict | overall_score float64 0 5 | thinking_trace stringclasses 1
value | prompt stringclasses 1
value | prompt_length int64 0 0 | conversations listlengths 2 2 | year int64 2k 2.03k |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03956-9 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Impact of Coronary Artery Calcium on Progression of Diastolic Dysfunction: A Cohort
Study
Version: 2 Date: 29 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Below is my response and feedback. Please incorporate in your submission website. I appreciate
your help. I am traveling and would not be able to do this in the format your of... | Title: Impact of Coronary Artery Calcium on Progression of Diastolic Dysfunction: A Cohort
Study
Version: 2 Date: 29 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Below is my response and feedback. Please incorporate in your submission website. I appreciate
your help. I am traveling and would not be able to do this in the format your of... | BMC | 12916_2025_3956_ReviewerReport_V2_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 6,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 11
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.18181818181818182,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.5454545454545454,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.18181818181818182
} | 0.909091 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Impact of Coronary Artery Calcium on Progression of Diastolic Dysfunction: A Cohort\nStudy\nVersion: 2 Date: 29 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nBelow is my response and feedback. Please incorporate in your submission webs... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03962-x | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Development of an Artificial Intelligence-Based Multimodal Diagnostic System for Early
Detection of Biliary Atresia
Version: 0 Date: 03 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Muhammad Owais
Reviewer's report:
*Overall Impression*
This manuscript presents a well-structured and innovative study leveraging multimodal data and
deep le... | Title: Development of an Artificial Intelligence-Based Multimodal Diagnostic System for Early
Detection of Biliary Atresia
Version: 0 Date: 03 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Muhammad Owais
Reviewer's report:
*Overall Impression*
This manuscript presents a well-structured and innovative study leveraging multimodal data and
deep le... | BMC | 12916_2025_3962_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 4,
"materials_and_methods": 12,
"praise": 4,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 6,
"total": 30
} | {
"criticism": 0.03333333333333333,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.13333333333333333,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4,
"praise": 0.13333333333333333,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.1,
"results_and_discussion": 0.06666666666666667,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.2
} | 1.066667 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Development of an Artificial Intelligence-Based Multimodal Diagnostic System for Early\nDetection of Biliary Atresia\nVersion: 0 Date: 03 Oct 2024\nReviewer: Muhammad Owais\nReviewer's report:\n*Overall Impression*\nTh... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03962-x | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Development of an Artificial Intelligence-Based Multimodal Diagnostic System for Early
Detection of Biliary Atresia
Version: 0 Date: 30 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
This manuscript presents a comprehensive study on developing and validating an artificial
intelligence-based multimodal diagnostic system for early d... | Title: Development of an Artificial Intelligence-Based Multimodal Diagnostic System for Early
Detection of Biliary Atresia
Version: 0 Date: 30 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
This manuscript presents a comprehensive study on developing and validating an artificial
intelligence-based multimodal diagnostic system for early d... | BMC | 12916_2025_3962_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 10,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 11,
"materials_and_methods": 29,
"praise": 10,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 10,
"total": 34
} | {
"criticism": 0.29411764705882354,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.3235294117647059,
"materials_and_methods": 0.8529411764705882,
"praise": 0.29411764705882354,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.029411764705882353,
"results_and_discussion": 0.08823529411764706,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.29... | 2.176471 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Development of an Artificial Intelligence-Based Multimodal Diagnostic System for Early\nDetection of Biliary Atresia\nVersion: 0 Date: 30 Oct 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThis manuscript presents a comprehensive study on d... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03962-x | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Development of an Artificial Intelligence-Based Multimodal Diagnostic System for Early
Detection of Biliary Atresia
Version: 1 Date: 18 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors’ response to the reviewers' comments is exceptionally detailed and well-organized,
showcasing a thorough understanding of the concerns ra... | Title: Development of an Artificial Intelligence-Based Multimodal Diagnostic System for Early
Detection of Biliary Atresia
Version: 1 Date: 18 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors’ response to the reviewers' comments is exceptionally detailed and well-organized,
showcasing a thorough understanding of the concerns ra... | BMC | 12916_2025_3962_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0.5,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Development of an Artificial Intelligence-Based Multimodal Diagnostic System for Early\nDetection of Biliary Atresia\nVersion: 1 Date: 18 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors’ response to the reviewers' comments is... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03935-0 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic
Review and Meta-Analysis
Version: 0 Date: 05 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
This is a systematic review and meta-analysis of ICP incidence to better understand the incidence
of ICP globally. The authors performed a systematic revie... | Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic
Review and Meta-Analysis
Version: 0 Date: 05 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
This is a systematic review and meta-analysis of ICP incidence to better understand the incidence
of ICP globally. The authors performed a systematic revie... | BMC | 12916_2025_3935_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 9,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 5,
"results_and_discussion": 4,
"suggestion_and_solution": 8,
"total": 20
} | {
"criticism": 0.05,
"example": 0.1,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.45,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.25,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.4
} | 1.45 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic\nReview and Meta-Analysis\nVersion: 0 Date: 05 Jun 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThis is a systematic review and meta-analysis of ICP inci... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03935-0 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic
Review and Meta-Analysis
Version: 0 Date: 07 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for a very thorough review.
Abstract 1.1 line 49: "Account for" would be better than "justify"
Abstract 1:3 line 59 and Results lines 162 and 194... | Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic
Review and Meta-Analysis
Version: 0 Date: 07 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for a very thorough review.
Abstract 1.1 line 49: "Account for" would be better than "justify"
Abstract 1:3 line 59 and Results lines 162 and 194... | BMC | 12916_2025_3935_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 14,
"example": 26,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 9,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 21,
"results_and_discussion": 8,
"suggestion_and_solution": 15,
"total": 43
} | {
"criticism": 0.32558139534883723,
"example": 0.6046511627906976,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.023255813953488372,
"materials_and_methods": 0.20930232558139536,
"praise": 0.046511627906976744,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.4883720930232558,
"results_and_discussion": 0.18604651162790697,
"suggestion_... | 2.232558 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic\nReview and Meta-Analysis\nVersion: 0 Date: 07 Jun 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThank you for a very thorough review.\nAbstract 1.1 line ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03935-0 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic
Review and Meta-Analysis
Version: 1 Date: 24 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
I reviewed the revised manuscript and appreciate the time the authors took to address the issues
brought up on original review. I find the paper to be impr... | Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic
Review and Meta-Analysis
Version: 1 Date: 24 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
I reviewed the revised manuscript and appreciate the time the authors took to address the issues
brought up on original review. I find the paper to be impr... | BMC | 12916_2025_3935_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic\nReview and Meta-Analysis\nVersion: 1 Date: 24 Jul 2024\nReviewer's report:\nI reviewed the revised manuscript and appreciate the time... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03935-0 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic
Review and Meta-Analysis
Version: 1 Date: 14 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for your generally excellent responses to the reviewers' comments.
A few things remain:
Line 57 and throughout: I thought you had decided to omit... | Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic
Review and Meta-Analysis
Version: 1 Date: 14 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for your generally excellent responses to the reviewers' comments.
A few things remain:
Line 57 and throughout: I thought you had decided to omit... | BMC | 12916_2025_3935_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 20,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 17,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 13,
"total": 25
} | {
"criticism": 0.04,
"example": 0.8,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.08,
"praise": 0.04,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.68,
"results_and_discussion": 0.04,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.52
} | 2.2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic\nReview and Meta-Analysis\nVersion: 1 Date: 14 Aug 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThank you for your generally excellent responses to the r... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03935-0 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic
Review and Meta-Analysis
Version: 2 Date: 01 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Generally, this manuscript has been much improved by the recent revision.
I still feel that the opening sentence of both the Abstract and the Background se... | Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic
Review and Meta-Analysis
Version: 2 Date: 01 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Generally, this manuscript has been much improved by the recent revision.
I still feel that the opening sentence of both the Abstract and the Background se... | BMC | 12916_2025_3935_ReviewerReport_V2_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 8
} | {
"criticism": 0.125,
"example": 0.25,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.125,
"praise": 0.125,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.25,
"results_and_discussion": 0.125,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.25
} | 1.25 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic\nReview and Meta-Analysis\nVersion: 2 Date: 01 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nGenerally, this manuscript has been much improved by the ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03935-0 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic
Review and Meta-Analysis
Version: 4 Date: 22 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
You have done a great job with revising this manuscript, in particular, with adding to the search
criteria to include more recent material.
The edits sugge... | Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic
Review and Meta-Analysis
Version: 4 Date: 22 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
You have done a great job with revising this manuscript, in particular, with adding to the search
criteria to include more recent material.
The edits sugge... | BMC | 12916_2025_3935_ReviewerReport_V4_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.5,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Global and Regional Incidence of Intrahepatic Cholestasis of Pregnancy: A Systematic\nReview and Meta-Analysis\nVersion: 4 Date: 22 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nYou have done a great job with revising this manuscript, ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03965-8 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted
Stem Cell Publications
Version: 0 Date: 03 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Upon analysis of the manuscript entitled "Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of
Retracted Stem Cell Publications," it is evident that the manus... | Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted
Stem Cell Publications
Version: 0 Date: 03 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Upon analysis of the manuscript entitled "Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of
Retracted Stem Cell Publications," it is evident that the manus... | BMC | 12916_2025_3965_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 3
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.3333333333333333,
"materials_and_methods": 0.6666666666666666,
"praise": 0.6666666666666666,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3333333333333333,
"results_and_discussion": 0.6666666666666666,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.3333333333333333
} | 3 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted\nStem Cell Publications\nVersion: 0 Date: 03 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nUpon analysis of the manuscript entitled \"Temporal Trends... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03965-8 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted
Stem Cell Publications
Version: 0 Date: 14 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the author's efforts in exploring the landscape of retracted publications within
stem cell research and examining their continued citation imp... | Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted
Stem Cell Publications
Version: 0 Date: 14 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the author's efforts in exploring the landscape of retracted publications within
stem cell research and examining their continued citation imp... | BMC | 12916_2025_3965_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 5,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 5,
"materials_and_methods": 4,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 6
} | {
"criticism": 0.8333333333333334,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.8333333333333334,
"materials_and_methods": 0.6666666666666666,
"praise": 0.16666666666666666,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0.16666666666666666,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2.666667 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted\nStem Cell Publications\nVersion: 0 Date: 14 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThank you for the author's efforts in exploring the landsc... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03965-8 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted
Stem Cell Publications
Version: 0 Date: 18 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Strengths:
The manuscript addresses an important issue by exploring the characteristics and impacts of
retracted publications in stem cell research. The stu... | Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted
Stem Cell Publications
Version: 0 Date: 18 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Strengths:
The manuscript addresses an important issue by exploring the characteristics and impacts of
retracted publications in stem cell research. The stu... | BMC | 12916_2025_3965_ReviewerReport_V0_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 3,
"materials_and_methods": 7,
"praise": 4,
"presentation_and_reporting": 6,
"results_and_discussion": 5,
"suggestion_and_solution": 9,
"total": 20
} | {
"criticism": 0.1,
"example": 0.1,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.15,
"materials_and_methods": 0.35,
"praise": 0.2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3,
"results_and_discussion": 0.25,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.45
} | 1.9 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted\nStem Cell Publications\nVersion: 0 Date: 18 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nStrengths:\nThe manuscript addresses an important issue by... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03965-8 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted
Stem Cell Publications
Version: 0 Date: 18 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript dealt with an analysis of retracted publications in stem cell and the topic is of
interest. However, it needs revision before acceptance.
1. ... | Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted
Stem Cell Publications
Version: 0 Date: 18 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript dealt with an analysis of retracted publications in stem cell and the topic is of
interest. However, it needs revision before acceptance.
1. ... | BMC | 12916_2025_3965_ReviewerReport_V0_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 5,
"example": 3,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 5,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 7,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 5,
"total": 20
} | {
"criticism": 0.25,
"example": 0.15,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.05,
"materials_and_methods": 0.25,
"praise": 0.05,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.35,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.25
} | 1.35 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted\nStem Cell Publications\nVersion: 0 Date: 18 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe manuscript dealt with an analysis of retracted publica... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03965-8 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted
Stem Cell Publications
Version: 2 Date: 16 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I thank the reviewer and the authors for the opportunity to review the manuscript. I believe that
the second version submitted addresses the comments and ev... | Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted
Stem Cell Publications
Version: 2 Date: 16 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I thank the reviewer and the authors for the opportunity to review the manuscript. I believe that
the second version submitted addresses the comments and ev... | BMC | 12916_2025_3965_ReviewerReport_V2_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted\nStem Cell Publications\nVersion: 2 Date: 16 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nI thank the reviewer and the authors for the opportunity t... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03965-8 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted
Stem Cell Publications
Version: 2 Date: 17 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
All revisions suggested have been incorporated. | Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted
Stem Cell Publications
Version: 2 Date: 17 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
All revisions suggested have been incorporated. | BMC | 12916_2025_3965_ReviewerReport_V2_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted\nStem Cell Publications\nVersion: 2 Date: 17 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nAll revisions suggested have been incorporated.",
"rol... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03965-8 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted
Stem Cell Publications
Version: 2 Date: 20 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thanks to the authors for making the changes, I think perhaps the letter format is more
appropriate for journals, based on the innovativeness of the article... | Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted
Stem Cell Publications
Version: 2 Date: 20 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thanks to the authors for making the changes, I think perhaps the letter format is more
appropriate for journals, based on the innovativeness of the article... | BMC | 12916_2025_3965_ReviewerReport_V2_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 4 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: A Systematic Analysis of Temporal Trends, Characteristics, and Citations of Retracted\nStem Cell Publications\nVersion: 2 Date: 20 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThanks to the authors for making the changes, I think perh... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03879-5 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Guidelines for the use of lung ultrasound to optimise the management of neonatal
respiratory distress: international expert consensus
Version: 0 Date: 09 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
This paper is an excellent review of the state of art of LUS. Deserves to be published. Description
of LUS signs are accurate, imag... | Title: Guidelines for the use of lung ultrasound to optimise the management of neonatal
respiratory distress: international expert consensus
Version: 0 Date: 09 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
This paper is an excellent review of the state of art of LUS. Deserves to be published. Description
of LUS signs are accurate, imag... | BMC | 12916_2025_3879_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 4,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 4
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.25,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.25,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.25
} | 1.75 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Guidelines for the use of lung ultrasound to optimise the management of neonatal\nrespiratory distress: international expert consensus\nVersion: 0 Date: 09 Oct 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThis paper is an excellent review... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03879-5 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Guidelines for the use of lung ultrasound to optimise the management of neonatal
respiratory distress: international expert consensus
Version: 0 Date: 31 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Kari D. Roberts
Reviewer's report:
This manuscript is very important and contributes to current knowledge gaps as lung ultrasound
becomes m... | Title: Guidelines for the use of lung ultrasound to optimise the management of neonatal
respiratory distress: international expert consensus
Version: 0 Date: 31 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Kari D. Roberts
Reviewer's report:
This manuscript is very important and contributes to current knowledge gaps as lung ultrasound
becomes m... | BMC | 12916_2025_3879_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 3,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 4,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 3,
"total": 10
} | {
"criticism": 0.1,
"example": 0.2,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.2,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3,
"praise": 0.2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.4,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.3
} | 1.7 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Guidelines for the use of lung ultrasound to optimise the management of neonatal\nrespiratory distress: international expert consensus\nVersion: 0 Date: 31 Oct 2024\nReviewer: Kari D. Roberts\nReviewer's report:\nThis ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03879-5 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Guidelines for the use of lung ultrasound to optimise the management of neonatal
respiratory distress: international expert consensus
Version: 0 Date: 01 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Ruixi Zhou
Reviewer's report:
The study examines the application of lung ultrasound (LUS) in neonatal respiratory
management, particularly ... | Title: Guidelines for the use of lung ultrasound to optimise the management of neonatal
respiratory distress: international expert consensus
Version: 0 Date: 01 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Ruixi Zhou
Reviewer's report:
The study examines the application of lung ultrasound (LUS) in neonatal respiratory
management, particularly ... | BMC | 12916_2025_3879_ReviewerReport_V0_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 7,
"materials_and_methods": 13,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 7,
"total": 25
} | {
"criticism": 0.12,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.28,
"materials_and_methods": 0.52,
"praise": 0.12,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.12,
"results_and_discussion": 0.04,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.28
} | 1.48 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Guidelines for the use of lung ultrasound to optimise the management of neonatal\nrespiratory distress: international expert consensus\nVersion: 0 Date: 01 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Ruixi Zhou\nReviewer's report:\nThe study ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03879-5 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Guidelines for the use of lung ultrasound to optimise the management of neonatal
respiratory distress: international expert consensus
Version: 1 Date: 06 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Ruixi Zhou
Reviewer's report:
The authors adequately addressed all the comments. | Title: Guidelines for the use of lung ultrasound to optimise the management of neonatal
respiratory distress: international expert consensus
Version: 1 Date: 06 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Ruixi Zhou
Reviewer's report:
The authors adequately addressed all the comments. | BMC | 12916_2025_3879_ReviewerReport_V1_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Guidelines for the use of lung ultrasound to optimise the management of neonatal\nrespiratory distress: international expert consensus\nVersion: 1 Date: 06 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Ruixi Zhou\nReviewer's report:\nThe author... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-024-03786-1 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Reviewer’s report
Title:
Association between antibiotics and treatment efficacy in metastatic
urothelial carcinoma patients
Version:
0
Date:
24 Mar 2024
Reviewer's report:
Major Comments:
- Supplemental Table 1 should list the antibiotic classes, while it lists the first-
line chemo-immuno treatments. Please add th... | Reviewer’s report
Title:
Association between antibiotics and treatment efficacy in metastatic
urothelial carcinoma patients
Version:
0
Date:
24 Mar 2024
Reviewer's report:
Major Comments:
- Supplemental Table 1 should list the antibiotic classes, while it lists the first-
line chemo-immuno treatments. Please add th... | BMC | 12916_2024_3786_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 3,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 15,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 10,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 15,
"total": 45
} | {
"criticism": 0.044444444444444446,
"example": 0.06666666666666667,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.022222222222222223,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3333333333333333,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2222222222222222,
"results_and_discussion": 0.06666666666666667,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.3... | 1.088889 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Reviewer’s report\nTitle: \nAssociation between antibiotics and treatment efficacy in metastatic\nurothelial carcinoma patients\nVersion: \n0 \nDate: \n24 Mar 2024\nReviewer's report:\nMajor Comments:\n- Supplemental Table 1 s... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-024-03786-1 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Reviewer’s report
Title:
Association between antibiotics and treatment efficacy in metastatic
urothelial carcinoma patients
Version:
0
Date:
29 Mar 2024
Reviewer's report:
This paper further validates the negative impact of ATB in patients treated with
ICI which has now been demonstrated in more than 100 studies in... | Reviewer’s report
Title:
Association between antibiotics and treatment efficacy in metastatic
urothelial carcinoma patients
Version:
0
Date:
29 Mar 2024
Reviewer's report:
This paper further validates the negative impact of ATB in patients treated with
ICI which has now been demonstrated in more than 100 studies in... | BMC | 12916_2024_3786_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 16,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 10,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 15,
"total": 46
} | {
"criticism": 0.06521739130434782,
"example": 0.021739130434782608,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.34782608695652173,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.21739130434782608,
"results_and_discussion": 0.043478260869565216,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.32608695652173914... | 1.021739 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Reviewer’s report\nTitle: \nAssociation between antibiotics and treatment efficacy in metastatic\nurothelial carcinoma patients\nVersion: \n0 \nDate: \n29 Mar 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThis paper further validates the negative... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-024-03786-1 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Reviewer’s report
Title:
Association between antibiotics and treatment efficacy in metastatic
urothelial carcinoma patients
Version:
1
Date:
09 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
The Authors addressed the Reviewers' comments.
Minor edits:
- Introduction, third paragraph: Enfortumab Vedotin-ejfv is mispelled in its first
a... | Reviewer’s report
Title:
Association between antibiotics and treatment efficacy in metastatic
urothelial carcinoma patients
Version:
1
Date:
09 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
The Authors addressed the Reviewers' comments.
Minor edits:
- Introduction, third paragraph: Enfortumab Vedotin-ejfv is mispelled in its first
a... | BMC | 12916_2024_3786_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 9,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 8,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 12,
"total": 37
} | {
"criticism": 0.02702702702702703,
"example": 0.05405405405405406,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.24324324324324326,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.21621621621621623,
"results_and_discussion": 0.02702702702702703,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.32432432432432434
} | 0.891892 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Reviewer’s report\nTitle: \nAssociation between antibiotics and treatment efficacy in metastatic\nurothelial carcinoma patients\nVersion: \n1 \nDate: \n09 Sep 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe Authors addressed the Reviewers' comm... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03857-x | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Increased Risk of Chronic Diseases and Multimorbidity in Middle-Aged and Elderly
Individuals with Early Vision, Hearing, or Dual Sensory Impairments: Insights from Prospective
Cohort Studies and Mendelian Randomization Analysis
Version: 0 Date: 20 Sep 2024
Reviewer: Kyung-Won Hong
Reviewer's report:
Thank you f... | Title: Increased Risk of Chronic Diseases and Multimorbidity in Middle-Aged and Elderly
Individuals with Early Vision, Hearing, or Dual Sensory Impairments: Insights from Prospective
Cohort Studies and Mendelian Randomization Analysis
Version: 0 Date: 20 Sep 2024
Reviewer: Kyung-Won Hong
Reviewer's report:
Thank you f... | BMC | 12916_2025_3857_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 4,
"materials_and_methods": 4,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 8,
"results_and_discussion": 9,
"suggestion_and_solution": 9,
"total": 20
} | {
"criticism": 0.15,
"example": 0.05,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.2,
"materials_and_methods": 0.2,
"praise": 0.15,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.4,
"results_and_discussion": 0.45,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.45
} | 2.05 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Increased Risk of Chronic Diseases and Multimorbidity in Middle-Aged and Elderly\nIndividuals with Early Vision, Hearing, or Dual Sensory Impairments: Insights from Prospective\nCohort Studies and Mendelian Randomizatio... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03857-x | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Increased Risk of Chronic Diseases and Multimorbidity in Middle-Aged and Elderly
Individuals with Early Vision, Hearing, or Dual Sensory Impairments: Insights from Prospective
Cohort Studies and Mendelian Randomization Analysis
Version: 0 Date: 30 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report: | Title: Increased Risk of Chronic Diseases and Multimorbidity in Middle-Aged and Elderly
Individuals with Early Vision, Hearing, or Dual Sensory Impairments: Insights from Prospective
Cohort Studies and Mendelian Randomization Analysis
Version: 0 Date: 30 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12916_2025_3857_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Increased Risk of Chronic Diseases and Multimorbidity in Middle-Aged and Elderly\nIndividuals with Early Vision, Hearing, or Dual Sensory Impairments: Insights from Prospective\nCohort Studies and Mendelian Randomizatio... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03857-x | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Increased Risk of Chronic Diseases and Multimorbidity in Middle-Aged and Elderly
Individuals with Early Vision, Hearing, or Dual Sensory Impairments: Insights from Prospective
Cohort Studies and Mendelian Randomization Analysis
Version: 2 Date: 17 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Kyung-Won Hong
Reviewer's report:
The manuscr... | Title: Increased Risk of Chronic Diseases and Multimorbidity in Middle-Aged and Elderly
Individuals with Early Vision, Hearing, or Dual Sensory Impairments: Insights from Prospective
Cohort Studies and Mendelian Randomization Analysis
Version: 2 Date: 17 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Kyung-Won Hong
Reviewer's report:
The manuscr... | BMC | 12916_2025_3857_ReviewerReport_V2_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 4,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 5
} | {
"criticism": 0.4,
"example": 0.2,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.2,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4,
"praise": 0.8,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2,
"results_and_discussion": 0.6,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.2
} | 3 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Increased Risk of Chronic Diseases and Multimorbidity in Middle-Aged and Elderly\nIndividuals with Early Vision, Hearing, or Dual Sensory Impairments: Insights from Prospective\nCohort Studies and Mendelian Randomizatio... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03857-x | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Increased Risk of Chronic Diseases and Multimorbidity in Middle-Aged and Elderly
Individuals with Early Vision, Hearing, or Dual Sensory Impairments: Insights from Prospective
Cohort Studies and Mendelian Randomization Analysis
Version: 2 Date: 07 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report: | Title: Increased Risk of Chronic Diseases and Multimorbidity in Middle-Aged and Elderly
Individuals with Early Vision, Hearing, or Dual Sensory Impairments: Insights from Prospective
Cohort Studies and Mendelian Randomization Analysis
Version: 2 Date: 07 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12916_2025_3857_ReviewerReport_V2_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Increased Risk of Chronic Diseases and Multimorbidity in Middle-Aged and Elderly\nIndividuals with Early Vision, Hearing, or Dual Sensory Impairments: Insights from Prospective\nCohort Studies and Mendelian Randomizatio... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03857-x | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Increased Risk of Chronic Diseases and Multimorbidity in Middle-Aged and Elderly
Individuals with Early Vision, Hearing, or Dual Sensory Impairments: Insights from Prospective
Cohort Studies and Mendelian Randomization Analysis
Version: 3 Date: 17 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report: | Title: Increased Risk of Chronic Diseases and Multimorbidity in Middle-Aged and Elderly
Individuals with Early Vision, Hearing, or Dual Sensory Impairments: Insights from Prospective
Cohort Studies and Mendelian Randomization Analysis
Version: 3 Date: 17 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12916_2025_3857_ReviewerReport_V3_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Increased Risk of Chronic Diseases and Multimorbidity in Middle-Aged and Elderly\nIndividuals with Early Vision, Hearing, or Dual Sensory Impairments: Insights from Prospective\nCohort Studies and Mendelian Randomizatio... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03886-6 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Association between general anesthesia for cesarean delivery and subsequent
developmental disorders in children: A nationwide retrospective cohort study
Version: 0 Date: 04 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
This large-scale retrospective cohort study compared the risk of developmental disorders
between general anesthe... | Title: Association between general anesthesia for cesarean delivery and subsequent
developmental disorders in children: A nationwide retrospective cohort study
Version: 0 Date: 04 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
This large-scale retrospective cohort study compared the risk of developmental disorders
between general anesthe... | BMC | 12916_2025_3886_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 13,
"example": 9,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 13,
"praise": 4,
"presentation_and_reporting": 12,
"results_and_discussion": 11,
"suggestion_and_solution": 10,
"total": 41
} | {
"criticism": 0.3170731707317073,
"example": 0.21951219512195122,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.04878048780487805,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3170731707317073,
"praise": 0.0975609756097561,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2926829268292683,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2682926829268293,
"suggestion_and_s... | 1.804878 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Association between general anesthesia for cesarean delivery and subsequent\ndevelopmental disorders in children: A nationwide retrospective cohort study\nVersion: 0 Date: 04 Jul 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThis large-sca... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03886-6 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Association between general anesthesia for cesarean delivery and subsequent
developmental disorders in children: A nationwide retrospective cohort study
Version: 0 Date: 10 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
This study highlights an increasingly growing area of interest but can be improved in some areas.
1. The author... | Title: Association between general anesthesia for cesarean delivery and subsequent
developmental disorders in children: A nationwide retrospective cohort study
Version: 0 Date: 10 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
This study highlights an increasingly growing area of interest but can be improved in some areas.
1. The author... | BMC | 12916_2025_3886_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 4,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 12,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 4,
"total": 25
} | {
"criticism": 0.16,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.04,
"materials_and_methods": 0.48,
"praise": 0.04,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.12,
"results_and_discussion": 0.04,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.16
} | 1.04 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Association between general anesthesia for cesarean delivery and subsequent\ndevelopmental disorders in children: A nationwide retrospective cohort study\nVersion: 0 Date: 10 Jul 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThis study hig... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03886-6 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Association between general anesthesia for cesarean delivery and subsequent
developmental disorders in children: A nationwide retrospective cohort study
Version: 0 Date: 10 Jul 2024
Reviewer: John J. Kowalczyk
Reviewer's report:
Title: Association between general anesthesia for cesarean delivery and subsequent
... | Title: Association between general anesthesia for cesarean delivery and subsequent
developmental disorders in children: A nationwide retrospective cohort study
Version: 0 Date: 10 Jul 2024
Reviewer: John J. Kowalczyk
Reviewer's report:
Title: Association between general anesthesia for cesarean delivery and subsequent
... | BMC | 12916_2025_3886_ReviewerReport_V0_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 7,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 5,
"results_and_discussion": 4,
"suggestion_and_solution": 8,
"total": 12
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0.5833333333333334,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.08333333333333333,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.4166666666666667,
"results_and_discussion": 0.3333333333333333,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.6666666666666666
} | 2.583333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Association between general anesthesia for cesarean delivery and subsequent\ndevelopmental disorders in children: A nationwide retrospective cohort study\nVersion: 0 Date: 10 Jul 2024\nReviewer: John J. Kowalczyk\nRevi... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03886-6 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Association between general anesthesia for cesarean delivery and subsequent
developmental disorders in children: A nationwide retrospective cohort study
Version: 1 Date: 18 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors carefully provided a point-by-point response to the comments and addressed most
of the reviewers' co... | Title: Association between general anesthesia for cesarean delivery and subsequent
developmental disorders in children: A nationwide retrospective cohort study
Version: 1 Date: 18 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors carefully provided a point-by-point response to the comments and addressed most
of the reviewers' co... | BMC | 12916_2025_3886_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 4,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 11
} | {
"criticism": 0.2727272727272727,
"example": 0.09090909090909091,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5454545454545454,
"praise": 0.18181818181818182,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.09090909090909091,
"results_and_discussion": 0.36363636363636365,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.181... | 1.727273 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Association between general anesthesia for cesarean delivery and subsequent\ndevelopmental disorders in children: A nationwide retrospective cohort study\nVersion: 1 Date: 18 Sep 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors ca... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03959-6 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Exploration of the clonal evolution and construction of the tumor clonal evolution rate as
a prognostic indicator in metastatic breast cancer
Version: 0 Date: 13 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
Authors in this manuscript investigated clonal evolution in the context of breast cancer and
proposed tumor clonal evolutio... | Title: Exploration of the clonal evolution and construction of the tumor clonal evolution rate as
a prognostic indicator in metastatic breast cancer
Version: 0 Date: 13 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
Authors in this manuscript investigated clonal evolution in the context of breast cancer and
proposed tumor clonal evolutio... | BMC | 12916_2025_3959_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 4,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 4,
"total": 15
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0.06666666666666667,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4,
"praise": 0.06666666666666667,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.26666666666666666,
"results_and_discussion": 0.06666666666666667,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.26666666666666666
} | 1.133333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Exploration of the clonal evolution and construction of the tumor clonal evolution rate as\na prognostic indicator in metastatic breast cancer\nVersion: 0 Date: 13 Sep 2024\nReviewer's report:\nAuthors in this manuscrip... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03959-6 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Exploration of the clonal evolution and construction of the tumor clonal evolution rate as
a prognostic indicator in metastatic breast cancer
Version: 0 Date: 01 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
Lv, Lan and colleagues report on the analysis of breast tumor evolution in ctDNA liquid biopsies
from patients with metasta... | Title: Exploration of the clonal evolution and construction of the tumor clonal evolution rate as
a prognostic indicator in metastatic breast cancer
Version: 0 Date: 01 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
Lv, Lan and colleagues report on the analysis of breast tumor evolution in ctDNA liquid biopsies
from patients with metasta... | BMC | 12916_2025_3959_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 21,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 10,
"results_and_discussion": 7,
"suggestion_and_solution": 11,
"total": 45
} | {
"criticism": 0.044444444444444446,
"example": 0.022222222222222223,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.022222222222222223,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4666666666666667,
"praise": 0.044444444444444446,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2222222222222222,
"results_and_discussion": 0.15555555555555556,
"suggestio... | 1.222222 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Exploration of the clonal evolution and construction of the tumor clonal evolution rate as\na prognostic indicator in metastatic breast cancer\nVersion: 0 Date: 01 Oct 2024\nReviewer's report:\nLv, Lan and colleagues re... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03959-6 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Exploration of the clonal evolution and construction of the tumor clonal evolution rate as
a prognostic indicator in metastatic breast cancer
Version: 1 Date: 08 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thanks for addressing all my comments. | Title: Exploration of the clonal evolution and construction of the tumor clonal evolution rate as
a prognostic indicator in metastatic breast cancer
Version: 1 Date: 08 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thanks for addressing all my comments. | BMC | 12916_2025_3959_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Exploration of the clonal evolution and construction of the tumor clonal evolution rate as\na prognostic indicator in metastatic breast cancer\nVersion: 1 Date: 08 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThanks for addressing all... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03949-8 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Anti-hypertensive medication adherence, socioeconomic status, and cognitive aging in
the Chinese community-dwelling middle-aged and older adults # 45 years: a population-based
longitudinal study
Version: 0 Date: 14 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
This study investigates an important topic with a generally sound meth... | Title: Anti-hypertensive medication adherence, socioeconomic status, and cognitive aging in
the Chinese community-dwelling middle-aged and older adults # 45 years: a population-based
longitudinal study
Version: 0 Date: 14 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
This study investigates an important topic with a generally sound meth... | BMC | 12916_2025_3949_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 6,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 5,
"materials_and_methods": 10,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 4,
"results_and_discussion": 8,
"suggestion_and_solution": 7,
"total": 32
} | {
"criticism": 0.1875,
"example": 0.0625,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.15625,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3125,
"praise": 0.0625,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.125,
"results_and_discussion": 0.25,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.21875
} | 1.375 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Anti-hypertensive medication adherence, socioeconomic status, and cognitive aging in\nthe Chinese community-dwelling middle-aged and older adults # 45 years: a population-based\nlongitudinal study\nVersion: 0 Date: 14 A... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03949-8 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Anti-hypertensive medication adherence, socioeconomic status, and cognitive aging in
the Chinese community-dwelling middle-aged and older adults # 45 years: a population-based
longitudinal study
Version: 0 Date: 03 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
Please see the comments file. | Title: Anti-hypertensive medication adherence, socioeconomic status, and cognitive aging in
the Chinese community-dwelling middle-aged and older adults # 45 years: a population-based
longitudinal study
Version: 0 Date: 03 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
Please see the comments file. | BMC | 12916_2025_3949_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Anti-hypertensive medication adherence, socioeconomic status, and cognitive aging in\nthe Chinese community-dwelling middle-aged and older adults # 45 years: a population-based\nlongitudinal study\nVersion: 0 Date: 03 S... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03949-8 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Anti-hypertensive medication adherence, socioeconomic status, and cognitive aging in
the Chinese community-dwelling middle-aged and older adults # 45 years: a population-based
longitudinal study
Version: 0 Date: 14 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the invitation. This paper is generally well written. I ... | Title: Anti-hypertensive medication adherence, socioeconomic status, and cognitive aging in
the Chinese community-dwelling middle-aged and older adults # 45 years: a population-based
longitudinal study
Version: 0 Date: 14 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the invitation. This paper is generally well written. I ... | BMC | 12916_2025_3949_ReviewerReport_V0_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 3,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 11,
"results_and_discussion": 6,
"suggestion_and_solution": 10,
"total": 20
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.15,
"praise": 0.1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.55,
"results_and_discussion": 0.3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 1.6 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Anti-hypertensive medication adherence, socioeconomic status, and cognitive aging in\nthe Chinese community-dwelling middle-aged and older adults # 45 years: a population-based\nlongitudinal study\nVersion: 0 Date: 14 N... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03949-8 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Anti-hypertensive medication adherence, socioeconomic status, and cognitive aging in
the Chinese community-dwelling middle-aged and older adults # 45 years: a population-based
longitudinal study
Version: 1 Date: 03 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for your revisions. All the issues have been fully addressed... | Title: Anti-hypertensive medication adherence, socioeconomic status, and cognitive aging in
the Chinese community-dwelling middle-aged and older adults # 45 years: a population-based
longitudinal study
Version: 1 Date: 03 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for your revisions. All the issues have been fully addressed... | BMC | 12916_2025_3949_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Anti-hypertensive medication adherence, socioeconomic status, and cognitive aging in\nthe Chinese community-dwelling middle-aged and older adults # 45 years: a population-based\nlongitudinal study\nVersion: 1 Date: 03 J... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03949-8 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Anti-hypertensive medication adherence, socioeconomic status, and cognitive aging in
the Chinese community-dwelling middle-aged and older adults # 45 years: a population-based
longitudinal study
Version: 1 Date: 09 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors have addressed all my concerns and questions thoroughly. I... | Title: Anti-hypertensive medication adherence, socioeconomic status, and cognitive aging in
the Chinese community-dwelling middle-aged and older adults # 45 years: a population-based
longitudinal study
Version: 1 Date: 09 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors have addressed all my concerns and questions thoroughly. I... | BMC | 12916_2025_3949_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 3
} | {
"criticism": 0.3333333333333333,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.6666666666666666,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Anti-hypertensive medication adherence, socioeconomic status, and cognitive aging in\nthe Chinese community-dwelling middle-aged and older adults # 45 years: a population-based\nlongitudinal study\nVersion: 1 Date: 09 J... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03936-z | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Sensitivity to thyroid hormones in children developing acute kidney injury at the onset
of type 1 diabetes mellitus
Version: 0 Date: 20 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Giorgio Radetti
Reviewer's report:
I read with interest the paper by Guarino et al, concerning the relationship between thyroid
Hormones, the metabolic deran... | Title: Sensitivity to thyroid hormones in children developing acute kidney injury at the onset
of type 1 diabetes mellitus
Version: 0 Date: 20 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Giorgio Radetti
Reviewer's report:
I read with interest the paper by Guarino et al, concerning the relationship between thyroid
Hormones, the metabolic deran... | BMC | 12916_2025_3936_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 5
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.2,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.4,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.4,
"results_and_discussion": 0.4,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.2
} | 1.6 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Sensitivity to thyroid hormones in children developing acute kidney injury at the onset\nof type 1 diabetes mellitus\nVersion: 0 Date: 20 Nov 2024\nReviewer: Giorgio Radetti\nReviewer's report:\nI read with interest th... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03936-z | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Sensitivity to thyroid hormones in children developing acute kidney injury at the onset
of type 1 diabetes mellitus
Version: 0 Date: 18 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report: | Title: Sensitivity to thyroid hormones in children developing acute kidney injury at the onset
of type 1 diabetes mellitus
Version: 0 Date: 18 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12916_2025_3936_ReviewerReport_V0_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Sensitivity to thyroid hormones in children developing acute kidney injury at the onset\nof type 1 diabetes mellitus\nVersion: 0 Date: 18 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:",
"role": "assistant"
}
] | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03936-z | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Sensitivity to thyroid hormones in children developing acute kidney injury at the onset
of type 1 diabetes mellitus
Version: 0 Date: 30 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report: | Title: Sensitivity to thyroid hormones in children developing acute kidney injury at the onset
of type 1 diabetes mellitus
Version: 0 Date: 30 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12916_2025_3936_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Sensitivity to thyroid hormones in children developing acute kidney injury at the onset\nof type 1 diabetes mellitus\nVersion: 0 Date: 30 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:",
"role": "assistant"
}
] | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03936-z | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Sensitivity to thyroid hormones in children developing acute kidney injury at the onset
of type 1 diabetes mellitus
Version: 1 Date: 23 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript has been significantly improved by the revision. All my questions and points
of criticism were dealt with adequately. | Title: Sensitivity to thyroid hormones in children developing acute kidney injury at the onset
of type 1 diabetes mellitus
Version: 1 Date: 23 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript has been significantly improved by the revision. All my questions and points
of criticism were dealt with adequately. | BMC | 12916_2025_3936_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Sensitivity to thyroid hormones in children developing acute kidney injury at the onset\nof type 1 diabetes mellitus\nVersion: 1 Date: 23 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe manuscript has been significantly improved by t... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03936-z | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Sensitivity to thyroid hormones in children developing acute kidney injury at the onset
of type 1 diabetes mellitus
Version: 1 Date: 23 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Giorgio Radetti
Reviewer's report:
The paper has been significantly improved, according to the reviewer's suggestions | Title: Sensitivity to thyroid hormones in children developing acute kidney injury at the onset
of type 1 diabetes mellitus
Version: 1 Date: 23 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Giorgio Radetti
Reviewer's report:
The paper has been significantly improved, according to the reviewer's suggestions | BMC | 12916_2025_3936_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Sensitivity to thyroid hormones in children developing acute kidney injury at the onset\nof type 1 diabetes mellitus\nVersion: 1 Date: 23 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Giorgio Radetti\nReviewer's report:\nThe paper has been sign... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03917-2 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Forecasting total and cause-specific health expenditures for 116 health conditions in
Norway, 2022-2050
Version: 0 Date: 11 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Brendan Collins
Reviewer's report:
Forecasting total and cause-specific health expenditures for 116 health conditions in Norway,
2022-2050
Review by Dr Brendan Collins
O... | Title: Forecasting total and cause-specific health expenditures for 116 health conditions in
Norway, 2022-2050
Version: 0 Date: 11 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Brendan Collins
Reviewer's report:
Forecasting total and cause-specific health expenditures for 116 health conditions in Norway,
2022-2050
Review by Dr Brendan Collins
O... | BMC | 12916_2025_3917_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 5,
"total": 10
} | {
"criticism": 0.3,
"example": 0.1,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.1,
"materials_and_methods": 0.2,
"praise": 0.2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 1.9 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Forecasting total and cause-specific health expenditures for 116 health conditions in\nNorway, 2022-2050\nVersion: 0 Date: 11 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Brendan Collins\nReviewer's report:\nForecasting total and cause-specifi... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03917-2 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Forecasting total and cause-specific health expenditures for 116 health conditions in
Norway, 2022-2050
Version: 0 Date: 15 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Tony Blakely
Reviewer's report:
Re: Kinge et al. Forecasting total and cause-specific health expenditures for 116 health
conditions in Norway, 2022-2050
This is a fascin... | Title: Forecasting total and cause-specific health expenditures for 116 health conditions in
Norway, 2022-2050
Version: 0 Date: 15 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Tony Blakely
Reviewer's report:
Re: Kinge et al. Forecasting total and cause-specific health expenditures for 116 health
conditions in Norway, 2022-2050
This is a fascin... | BMC | 12916_2025_3917_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 8,
"example": 12,
"importance_and_relevance": 4,
"materials_and_methods": 23,
"praise": 4,
"presentation_and_reporting": 10,
"results_and_discussion": 11,
"suggestion_and_solution": 18,
"total": 82
} | {
"criticism": 0.0975609756097561,
"example": 0.14634146341463414,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.04878048780487805,
"materials_and_methods": 0.2804878048780488,
"praise": 0.04878048780487805,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.12195121951219512,
"results_and_discussion": 0.13414634146341464,
"suggestion_an... | 1.097561 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Forecasting total and cause-specific health expenditures for 116 health conditions in\nNorway, 2022-2050\nVersion: 0 Date: 15 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Tony Blakely\nReviewer's report:\nRe: Kinge et al. Forecasting total and... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03917-2 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Forecasting total and cause-specific health expenditures for 116 health conditions in
Norway, 2022-2050
Version: 1 Date: 16 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Brendan Collins
Reviewer's report:
Happy with all of the responses and changes made. | Title: Forecasting total and cause-specific health expenditures for 116 health conditions in
Norway, 2022-2050
Version: 1 Date: 16 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Brendan Collins
Reviewer's report:
Happy with all of the responses and changes made. | BMC | 12916_2025_3917_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Forecasting total and cause-specific health expenditures for 116 health conditions in\nNorway, 2022-2050\nVersion: 1 Date: 16 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Brendan Collins\nReviewer's report:\nHappy with all of the responses and... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03917-2 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Forecasting total and cause-specific health expenditures for 116 health conditions in
Norway, 2022-2050
Version: 1 Date: 17 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Tony Blakely
Reviewer's report:
The authors have addressed all my comments. I look forward to seeing the paper in print/on-line. | Title: Forecasting total and cause-specific health expenditures for 116 health conditions in
Norway, 2022-2050
Version: 1 Date: 17 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Tony Blakely
Reviewer's report:
The authors have addressed all my comments. I look forward to seeing the paper in print/on-line. | BMC | 12916_2025_3917_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.5,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Forecasting total and cause-specific health expenditures for 116 health conditions in\nNorway, 2022-2050\nVersion: 1 Date: 17 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Tony Blakely\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors have addressed all my comm... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03940-3 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and
Risk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study
Version: 0 Date: 26 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors described the link between dietary patterns and premature aging. It is well-writt... | Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and
Risk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study
Version: 0 Date: 26 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors described the link between dietary patterns and premature aging. It is well-writt... | BMC | 12916_2025_3940_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 4,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 10,
"praise": 4,
"presentation_and_reporting": 11,
"results_and_discussion": 5,
"suggestion_and_solution": 11,
"total": 23
} | {
"criticism": 0.08695652173913043,
"example": 0.17391304347826086,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.043478260869565216,
"materials_and_methods": 0.43478260869565216,
"praise": 0.17391304347826086,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.4782608695652174,
"results_and_discussion": 0.21739130434782608,
"suggestion_... | 2.086957 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and\nRisk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study\nVersion: 0 Date: 26 Jun 2024\nReviewer's repo... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03940-3 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and
Risk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study
Version: 0 Date: 27 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
To the authors,
The authors are providing an important overview of the effect of dietary patt... | Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and
Risk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study
Version: 0 Date: 27 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
To the authors,
The authors are providing an important overview of the effect of dietary patt... | BMC | 12916_2025_3940_ReviewerReport_V0_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 7,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 5,
"results_and_discussion": 6,
"suggestion_and_solution": 6,
"total": 16
} | {
"criticism": 0.1875,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.0625,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4375,
"praise": 0.1875,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3125,
"results_and_discussion": 0.375,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.375
} | 1.9375 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and\nRisk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study\nVersion: 0 Date: 27 Aug 2024\nReviewer's repo... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03940-3 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and
Risk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study
Version: 0 Date: 27 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
A good manuscript.
General
Please add line numbers to help in reviewing.
Methods
Page 6: Othe... | Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and
Risk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study
Version: 0 Date: 27 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
A good manuscript.
General
Please add line numbers to help in reviewing.
Methods
Page 6: Othe... | BMC | 12916_2025_3940_ReviewerReport_V0_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 6,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 8,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 10,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 8,
"total": 17
} | {
"criticism": 0.058823529411764705,
"example": 0.35294117647058826,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.47058823529411764,
"praise": 0.058823529411764705,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.5882352941176471,
"results_and_discussion": 0.11764705882352941,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.... | 2.117647 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and\nRisk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study\nVersion: 0 Date: 27 Aug 2024\nReviewer's repo... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03940-3 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and
Risk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study
Version: 1 Date: 09 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors answered all observations. I did not find other modifications or clarifications n... | Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and
Risk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study
Version: 1 Date: 09 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors answered all observations. I did not find other modifications or clarifications n... | BMC | 12916_2025_3940_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0.5,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.5,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and\nRisk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study\nVersion: 1 Date: 09 Dec 2024\nReviewer's repo... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03940-3 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and
Risk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study
Version: 1 Date: 10 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Since this analysis focuses on diet and aging it is acceptable not to adjust for physical act... | Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and
Risk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study
Version: 1 Date: 10 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Since this analysis focuses on diet and aging it is acceptable not to adjust for physical act... | BMC | 12916_2025_3940_ReviewerReport_V1_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 7
} | {
"criticism": 0.2857142857142857,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.2857142857142857,
"praise": 0.14285714285714285,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2857142857142857,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.2857142857142857
} | 1.285714 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and\nRisk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study\nVersion: 1 Date: 10 Dec 2024\nReviewer's repo... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03940-3 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and
Risk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study
Version: 1 Date: 21 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Previous comments have been addressed. However in future you need to state the line numbers
f... | Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and
Risk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study
Version: 1 Date: 21 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Previous comments have been addressed. However in future you need to state the line numbers
f... | BMC | 12916_2025_3940_ReviewerReport_V1_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 4,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 6,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 6,
"total": 7
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0.14285714285714285,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5714285714285714,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.8571428571428571,
"results_and_discussion": 0.14285714285714285,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.8571428571428571
} | 2.571429 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and\nRisk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study\nVersion: 1 Date: 21 Dec 2024\nReviewer's repo... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03940-3 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and
Risk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study
Version: 2 Date: 13 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
No further modification or clarifications are needed. | Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and
Risk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study
Version: 2 Date: 13 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
No further modification or clarifications are needed. | BMC | 12916_2025_3940_ReviewerReport_V2_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and\nRisk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study\nVersion: 2 Date: 13 Jan 2025\nReviewer's repo... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03940-3 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and
Risk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study
Version: 2 Date: 24 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Comments have been addressed adequately. | Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and
Risk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study
Version: 2 Date: 24 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Comments have been addressed adequately. | BMC | 12916_2025_3940_ReviewerReport_V2_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Plant-based, Fast-food, Western-contemporary, and Animal-based Dietary Patterns and\nRisk of Premature Aging in Adult Survivors of Childhood Cancer: a cross-sectional study\nVersion: 2 Date: 24 Jan 2025\nReviewer's repo... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-024-03833-x | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Minimum and optimal combined variations in sleep, physical activity, and nutrition in
relation to all-cause mortality risk
Version: 1 Date: 06 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Zhilei Shan
Reviewer's report: | Title: Minimum and optimal combined variations in sleep, physical activity, and nutrition in
relation to all-cause mortality risk
Version: 1 Date: 06 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Zhilei Shan
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12916_2024_3833_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Minimum and optimal combined variations in sleep, physical activity, and nutrition in\nrelation to all-cause mortality risk\nVersion: 1 Date: 06 Oct 2024\nReviewer: Zhilei Shan\nReviewer's report:",
"role": "assist... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-024-03833-x | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Minimum and optimal combined variations in sleep, physical activity, and nutrition in
relation to all-cause mortality risk
Version: 1 Date: 07 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
Stamatakis et al conducted a very innovative analysis unraveling the triangulation of combined
effect of sleep, physical activity, and nutriti... | Title: Minimum and optimal combined variations in sleep, physical activity, and nutrition in
relation to all-cause mortality risk
Version: 1 Date: 07 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
Stamatakis et al conducted a very innovative analysis unraveling the triangulation of combined
effect of sleep, physical activity, and nutriti... | BMC | 12916_2024_3833_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 5,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 9
} | {
"criticism": 0.2222222222222222,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.2222222222222222,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5555555555555556,
"praise": 0.1111111111111111,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0.3333333333333333,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.1111111111111111
} | 1.555556 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Minimum and optimal combined variations in sleep, physical activity, and nutrition in\nrelation to all-cause mortality risk\nVersion: 1 Date: 07 Oct 2024\nReviewer's report:\nStamatakis et al conducted a very innovative... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-024-03833-x | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Minimum and optimal combined variations in sleep, physical activity, and nutrition in
relation to all-cause mortality risk
Version: 1 Date: 15 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report: | Title: Minimum and optimal combined variations in sleep, physical activity, and nutrition in
relation to all-cause mortality risk
Version: 1 Date: 15 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12916_2024_3833_ReviewerReport_V1_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Minimum and optimal combined variations in sleep, physical activity, and nutrition in\nrelation to all-cause mortality risk\nVersion: 1 Date: 15 Oct 2024\nReviewer's report:",
"role": "assistant"
}
] | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-024-03833-x | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Minimum and optimal combined variations in sleep, physical activity, and nutrition in
relation to all-cause mortality risk
Version: 2 Date: 17 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors have addressed all the comments. I have no further comments. | Title: Minimum and optimal combined variations in sleep, physical activity, and nutrition in
relation to all-cause mortality risk
Version: 2 Date: 17 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors have addressed all the comments. I have no further comments. | BMC | 12916_2024_3833_ReviewerReport_V2_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0.5,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Minimum and optimal combined variations in sleep, physical activity, and nutrition in\nrelation to all-cause mortality risk\nVersion: 2 Date: 17 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors have addressed all the comments.... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-024-03833-x | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Minimum and optimal combined variations in sleep, physical activity, and nutrition in
relation to all-cause mortality risk
Version: 2 Date: 27 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report: | Title: Minimum and optimal combined variations in sleep, physical activity, and nutrition in
relation to all-cause mortality risk
Version: 2 Date: 27 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12916_2024_3833_ReviewerReport_V2_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Minimum and optimal combined variations in sleep, physical activity, and nutrition in\nrelation to all-cause mortality risk\nVersion: 2 Date: 27 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:",
"role": "assistant"
}
] | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03927-0 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The
EURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research
Use
Version: 0 Date: 27 Jul 2024
Reviewer: gemma Parramon
Reviewer's report: | Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The
EURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research
Use
Version: 0 Date: 27 Jul 2024
Reviewer: gemma Parramon
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12916_2025_3927_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The\nEURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research\nUse\nVersion: 0 Date: 27 Jul 2024\nReviewer: gemma Parramon\... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03927-0 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The
EURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research
Use
Version: 0 Date: 19 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
- It is unclear who is the intended audience - researchers or clinicians. The authors switch
between desc... | Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The
EURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research
Use
Version: 0 Date: 19 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
- It is unclear who is the intended audience - researchers or clinicians. The authors switch
between desc... | BMC | 12916_2025_3927_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 9,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 14,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 5,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 3,
"total": 21
} | {
"criticism": 0.42857142857142855,
"example": 0.047619047619047616,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.09523809523809523,
"materials_and_methods": 0.6666666666666666,
"praise": 0.047619047619047616,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.23809523809523808,
"results_and_discussion": 0.09523809523809523,
"suggestion... | 1.761905 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The\nEURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research\nUse\nVersion: 0 Date: 19 Sep 2024\nReviewer's report:\n- It i... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03927-0 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The
EURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research
Use
Version: 0 Date: 27 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report: | Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The
EURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research
Use
Version: 0 Date: 27 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12916_2025_3927_ReviewerReport_V0_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The\nEURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research\nUse\nVersion: 0 Date: 27 Sep 2024\nReviewer's report:",
"... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03927-0 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The
EURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research
Use
Version: 1 Date: 06 Dec 2024
Reviewer: gemma Parramon
Reviewer's report:
Dear Dr Salzmann,
I am writing to express my sincere gratitude for the revisio... | Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The
EURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research
Use
Version: 1 Date: 06 Dec 2024
Reviewer: gemma Parramon
Reviewer's report:
Dear Dr Salzmann,
I am writing to express my sincere gratitude for the revisio... | BMC | 12916_2025_3927_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 6
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.16666666666666666,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.16666666666666666,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.16666666666666666
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The\nEURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research\nUse\nVersion: 1 Date: 06 Dec 2024\nReviewer: gemma Parramon\... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03927-0 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The
EURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research
Use
Version: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for thoroughly considering and responding to my feedback. It is clear the authors
spent signif... | Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The
EURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research
Use
Version: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for thoroughly considering and responding to my feedback. It is clear the authors
spent signif... | BMC | 12916_2025_3927_ReviewerReport_V1_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 4
} | {
"criticism": 0.25,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.5,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.75,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.25
} | 2.25 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The\nEURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research\nUse\nVersion: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThank ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03927-0 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The
EURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research
Use
Version: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript, Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition:
The EURONET-SOMA... | Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The
EURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research
Use
Version: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript, Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition:
The EURONET-SOMA... | BMC | 12916_2025_3927_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 7,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 5,
"materials_and_methods": 16,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 5,
"suggestion_and_solution": 11,
"total": 26
} | {
"criticism": 0.2692307692307692,
"example": 0.038461538461538464,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.19230769230769232,
"materials_and_methods": 0.6153846153846154,
"praise": 0.038461538461538464,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.11538461538461539,
"results_and_discussion": 0.19230769230769232,
"suggestion_... | 1.884615 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The\nEURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research\nUse\nVersion: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe ma... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03927-0 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The
EURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research
Use
Version: 2 Date: 17 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to review the revised manuscript. I believe the authors addressed
my concer... | Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The
EURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research
Use
Version: 2 Date: 17 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to review the revised manuscript. I believe the authors addressed
my concer... | BMC | 12916_2025_3927_ReviewerReport_V2_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0.5,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Assessment of Psychosocial Aspects in Adults in post-COVID-19 condition: The\nEURONET-SOMA Recommendations on Core Outcome Domains for Clinical and Research\nUse\nVersion: 2 Date: 17 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThank ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03883-9 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates
from Australia
Version: 0 Date: 28 Sep 2024
Reviewer: Joanna Didkowska
Reviewer's report:
I found the paper extremely interesting and necessary. The authors have demonstrated excellent
statistical skills and have done a gigantic... | Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates
from Australia
Version: 0 Date: 28 Sep 2024
Reviewer: Joanna Didkowska
Reviewer's report:
I found the paper extremely interesting and necessary. The authors have demonstrated excellent
statistical skills and have done a gigantic... | BMC | 12916_2025_3883_ReviewerReport_V0_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 4,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 6
} | {
"criticism": 0.3333333333333333,
"example": 0.16666666666666666,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.16666666666666666,
"materials_and_methods": 0.6666666666666666,
"praise": 0.3333333333333333,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.16666666666666666,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.3333... | 2.166667 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates\nfrom Australia\nVersion: 0 Date: 28 Sep 2024\nReviewer: Joanna Didkowska\nReviewer's report:\nI found the paper extremely interesting... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03883-9 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates
from Australia
Version: 0 Date: 29 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors estimated tobacco smoking attributable mortality in Australia. The topic is of
importance. The manuscript is well-written. I only have some comments below... | Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates
from Australia
Version: 0 Date: 29 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors estimated tobacco smoking attributable mortality in Australia. The topic is of
importance. The manuscript is well-written. I only have some comments below... | BMC | 12916_2025_3883_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 4,
"results_and_discussion": 6,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 16
} | {
"criticism": 0.0625,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.0625,
"materials_and_methods": 0.375,
"praise": 0.125,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.25,
"results_and_discussion": 0.375,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.125
} | 1.375 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates\nfrom Australia\nVersion: 0 Date: 29 Sep 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors estimated tobacco smoking attributable mortality in Aust... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03883-9 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates
from Australia
Version: 0 Date: 30 Sep 2024
Reviewer: Philippe Autier
Reviewer's report:
The paper of G Joshy and colleagues is about the risk of various conditions and of death
associated with tobacco smoking in a large cohort ... | Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates
from Australia
Version: 0 Date: 30 Sep 2024
Reviewer: Philippe Autier
Reviewer's report:
The paper of G Joshy and colleagues is about the risk of various conditions and of death
associated with tobacco smoking in a large cohort ... | BMC | 12916_2025_3883_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 8
} | {
"criticism": 0.125,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.125,
"materials_and_methods": 0.75,
"praise": 0.375,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0.25,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.25
} | 1.875 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates\nfrom Australia\nVersion: 0 Date: 30 Sep 2024\nReviewer: Philippe Autier\nReviewer's report:\nThe paper of G Joshy and colleagues is a... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03883-9 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates
from Australia
Version: 0 Date: 04 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for inviting me to review the manuscript titled “Relationship of Tobacco Smoking to
Cause-Specific Mortality: Contemporary Estimates from Australia.” The pa... | Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates
from Australia
Version: 0 Date: 04 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for inviting me to review the manuscript titled “Relationship of Tobacco Smoking to
Cause-Specific Mortality: Contemporary Estimates from Australia.” The pa... | BMC | 12916_2025_3883_ReviewerReport_V0_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 7,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 17,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 8,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 9,
"total": 24
} | {
"criticism": 0.125,
"example": 0.2916666666666667,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.041666666666666664,
"materials_and_methods": 0.7083333333333334,
"praise": 0.041666666666666664,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3333333333333333,
"results_and_discussion": 0.041666666666666664,
"suggestion_and_solution":... | 1.958333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates\nfrom Australia\nVersion: 0 Date: 04 Oct 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThank you for inviting me to review the manuscript titled “Relations... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03883-9 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates
from Australia
Version: 1 Date: 30 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors answered my comments appropriately. I have no further questions. | Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates
from Australia
Version: 1 Date: 30 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors answered my comments appropriately. I have no further questions. | BMC | 12916_2025_3883_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates\nfrom Australia\nVersion: 1 Date: 30 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors answered my comments appropriately. I have no further qu... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03883-9 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates
from Australia
Version: 1 Date: 01 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Philippe Autier
Reviewer's report:
Authors have provided satisfactory answers to my comments. | Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates
from Australia
Version: 1 Date: 01 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Philippe Autier
Reviewer's report:
Authors have provided satisfactory answers to my comments. | BMC | 12916_2025_3883_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Relationship of tobacco smoking to cause-specific mortality: Contemporary estimates\nfrom Australia\nVersion: 1 Date: 01 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Philippe Autier\nReviewer's report:\nAuthors have provided satisfactory answe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03933-2 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous
coronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the
OPT-CAD cohort
Version: 0 Date: 03 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to review the manuscript titled "Long-t... | Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous
coronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the
OPT-CAD cohort
Version: 0 Date: 03 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to review the manuscript titled "Long-t... | BMC | 12916_2025_3933_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 6,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 8,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 9,
"results_and_discussion": 8,
"suggestion_and_solution": 9,
"total": 37
} | {
"criticism": 0.16216216216216217,
"example": 0.02702702702702703,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.05405405405405406,
"materials_and_methods": 0.21621621621621623,
"praise": 0.05405405405405406,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.24324324324324326,
"results_and_discussion": 0.21621621621621623,
"suggestion_... | 1.216216 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous\ncoronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the\nOPT-CAD cohort\nVersion: 0 Date: 03 ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03933-2 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous
coronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the
OPT-CAD cohort
Version: 0 Date: 07 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
I think this is an important study, as it clarifies the differences i... | Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous
coronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the
OPT-CAD cohort
Version: 0 Date: 07 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
I think this is an important study, as it clarifies the differences i... | BMC | 12916_2025_3933_ReviewerReport_V0_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 3,
"materials_and_methods": 4,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 4,
"total": 15
} | {
"criticism": 0.13333333333333333,
"example": 0.06666666666666667,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.2,
"materials_and_methods": 0.26666666666666666,
"praise": 0.06666666666666667,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0.06666666666666667,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.26666666666666666... | 1.066667 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous\ncoronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the\nOPT-CAD cohort\nVersion: 0 Date: 07 ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03933-2 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous
coronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the
OPT-CAD cohort
Version: 0 Date: 16 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors should be congratulated for this interesting and well-con... | Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous
coronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the
OPT-CAD cohort
Version: 0 Date: 16 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors should be congratulated for this interesting and well-con... | BMC | 12916_2025_3933_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 16,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 8,
"results_and_discussion": 7,
"suggestion_and_solution": 13,
"total": 24
} | {
"criticism": 0.08333333333333333,
"example": 0.041666666666666664,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.08333333333333333,
"materials_and_methods": 0.6666666666666666,
"praise": 0.041666666666666664,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3333333333333333,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2916666666666667,
"suggestion_a... | 2.083333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous\ncoronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the\nOPT-CAD cohort\nVersion: 0 Date: 16 ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03933-2 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous
coronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the
OPT-CAD cohort
Version: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors successfully answered all of my comments. | Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous
coronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the
OPT-CAD cohort
Version: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors successfully answered all of my comments. | BMC | 12916_2025_3933_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous\ncoronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the\nOPT-CAD cohort\nVersion: 1 Date: 11 ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03933-2 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous
coronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the
OPT-CAD cohort
Version: 1 Date: 13 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
I think the current version of the article has been revised very well... | Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous
coronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the
OPT-CAD cohort
Version: 1 Date: 13 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
I think the current version of the article has been revised very well... | BMC | 12916_2025_3933_ReviewerReport_V1_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous\ncoronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the\nOPT-CAD cohort\nVersion: 1 Date: 13 ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03933-2 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous
coronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the
OPT-CAD cohort
Version: 1 Date: 02 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
We have reviewed the revised manuscript. The authors' responses to th... | Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous
coronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the
OPT-CAD cohort
Version: 1 Date: 02 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
We have reviewed the revised manuscript. The authors' responses to th... | BMC | 12916_2025_3933_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 4
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.75,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.25,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Long-term outcomes in patients with acute coronary syndrome undergoing percutaneous\ncoronary intervention without standard modifiable cardiovascular risk factors: findings from the\nOPT-CAD cohort\nVersion: 1 Date: 02 ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03925-2 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving
perioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer
Version: 0 Date: 03 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
I have reviewed the manuscript you provided. Below is a constructive critique with three areas
for improvement and a positiv... | Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving
perioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer
Version: 0 Date: 03 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
I have reviewed the manuscript you provided. Below is a constructive critique with three areas
for improvement and a positiv... | BMC | 12916_2025_3925_ReviewerReport_V0_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 6,
"materials_and_methods": 10,
"praise": 8,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 6,
"suggestion_and_solution": 6,
"total": 14
} | {
"criticism": 0.07142857142857142,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.42857142857142855,
"materials_and_methods": 0.7142857142857143,
"praise": 0.5714285714285714,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.14285714285714285,
"results_and_discussion": 0.42857142857142855,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.428... | 2.785714 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving\nperioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer\nVersion: 0 Date: 03 Sep 2024\nReviewer's report:\nI have reviewed the manusc... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03925-2 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving
perioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer
Version: 0 Date: 09 Sep 2024
Reviewer: Taro Okayama
Reviewer's report:
The authors developed a new nutritional and inflammatory status index, the SNII, and
investigated it... | Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving
perioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer
Version: 0 Date: 09 Sep 2024
Reviewer: Taro Okayama
Reviewer's report:
The authors developed a new nutritional and inflammatory status index, the SNII, and
investigated it... | BMC | 12916_2025_3925_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 5,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 4,
"total": 7
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.14285714285714285,
"materials_and_methods": 0.7142857142857143,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2857142857142857,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5714285714285714
} | 1.714286 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving\nperioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer\nVersion: 0 Date: 09 Sep 2024\nReviewer: Taro Okayama\nReviewer's report:\nT... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03925-2 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving
perioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer
Version: 0 Date: 23 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
Peiyu Wang et al developed and validated the SNII as a tool for identifying systemic nutrition
and inflammation risk, which ... | Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving
perioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer
Version: 0 Date: 23 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
Peiyu Wang et al developed and validated the SNII as a tool for identifying systemic nutrition
and inflammation risk, which ... | BMC | 12916_2025_3925_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 6,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 17,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 6,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 5,
"total": 22
} | {
"criticism": 0.2727272727272727,
"example": 0.045454545454545456,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.09090909090909091,
"materials_and_methods": 0.7727272727272727,
"praise": 0.045454545454545456,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2727272727272727,
"results_and_discussion": 0.09090909090909091,
"suggestion_a... | 1.818182 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving\nperioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer\nVersion: 0 Date: 23 Sep 2024\nReviewer's report:\nPeiyu Wang et al developed... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03925-2 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving
perioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer
Version: 1 Date: 24 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Taro Okayama
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors,
In this revision, the authors have responded well to the previous critique. This is a ... | Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving
perioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer
Version: 1 Date: 24 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Taro Okayama
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors,
In this revision, the authors have responded well to the previous critique. This is a ... | BMC | 12916_2025_3925_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 3
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3333333333333333,
"praise": 0.6666666666666666,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving\nperioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer\nVersion: 1 Date: 24 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Taro Okayama\nReviewer's report:\nD... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03925-2 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving
perioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer
Version: 1 Date: 13 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The revised manuscript demonstrates significant improvements and successfully addresses the
previous feedback. The study is ... | Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving
perioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer
Version: 1 Date: 13 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The revised manuscript demonstrates significant improvements and successfully addresses the
previous feedback. The study is ... | BMC | 12916_2025_3925_ReviewerReport_V1_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 4,
"praise": 6,
"presentation_and_reporting": 6,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 5,
"total": 10
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.2,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4,
"praise": 0.6,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.6,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 2.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving\nperioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer\nVersion: 1 Date: 13 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe revised manuscript dem... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03925-2 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving
perioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer
Version: 1 Date: 15 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The author's work was perfect.
This manuscript was more improved as valuable for medical science and clinical practice.
I ha... | Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving
perioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer
Version: 1 Date: 15 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The author's work was perfect.
This manuscript was more improved as valuable for medical science and clinical practice.
I ha... | BMC | 12916_2025_3925_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 3
} | {
"criticism": 0.3333333333333333,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.3333333333333333,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3333333333333333,
"praise": 0.6666666666666666,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1.666667 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Development and validation of the systemic nutrition/inflammation index for improving\nperioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer\nVersion: 1 Date: 15 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe author's work was perf... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03851-3 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Antidepressant use and cognitive decline in patients with dementia: a national cohort study
Version: 0 Date: 20 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
This national cohort study investigates the impact of antidepressants on cognitive decline in
dementia patients, including the risks of severe dementia, fractures, and death... | Title: Antidepressant use and cognitive decline in patients with dementia: a national cohort study
Version: 0 Date: 20 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
This national cohort study investigates the impact of antidepressants on cognitive decline in
dementia patients, including the risks of severe dementia, fractures, and death... | BMC | 12916_2025_3851_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 10,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 5,
"suggestion_and_solution": 4,
"total": 22
} | {
"criticism": 0.13636363636363635,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.45454545454545453,
"praise": 0.045454545454545456,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.13636363636363635,
"results_and_discussion": 0.22727272727272727,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.18181818181818182
... | 1.181818 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Antidepressant use and cognitive decline in patients with dementia: a national cohort study\nVersion: 0 Date: 20 Jul 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThis national cohort study investigates the impact of antidepressants on cog... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03851-3 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Antidepressant use and cognitive decline in patients with dementia: a national cohort study
Version: 0 Date: 20 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
I have provided my comments in the uploaded document. | Title: Antidepressant use and cognitive decline in patients with dementia: a national cohort study
Version: 0 Date: 20 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
I have provided my comments in the uploaded document. | BMC | 12916_2025_3851_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Antidepressant use and cognitive decline in patients with dementia: a national cohort study\nVersion: 0 Date: 20 Aug 2024\nReviewer's report:\nI have provided my comments in the uploaded document.",
"role": "assista... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03851-3 | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Antidepressant use and cognitive decline in patients with dementia: a national cohort study
Version: 1 Date: 15 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors have addressed all my concerns; I have no further comments. | Title: Antidepressant use and cognitive decline in patients with dementia: a national cohort study
Version: 1 Date: 15 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors have addressed all my concerns; I have no further comments. | BMC | 12916_2025_3851_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Antidepressant use and cognitive decline in patients with dementia: a national cohort study\nVersion: 1 Date: 15 Oct 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors have addressed all my concerns; I have no further comments.",
... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03928-z | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Cost-Effectiveness of Nirsevimab and Maternal RSVpreF Vaccination for Preventing
Respiratory Syncytial Virus Disease in Infants Across Canada
Version: 0 Date: 18 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Nathaniel Hendrix
Reviewer's report:
Thanks for the opportunity to review this interesting and highly relevant manuscript on RSV
pr... | Title: Cost-Effectiveness of Nirsevimab and Maternal RSVpreF Vaccination for Preventing
Respiratory Syncytial Virus Disease in Infants Across Canada
Version: 0 Date: 18 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Nathaniel Hendrix
Reviewer's report:
Thanks for the opportunity to review this interesting and highly relevant manuscript on RSV
pr... | BMC | 12916_2025_3928_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 9,
"praise": 5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 5,
"total": 17
} | {
"criticism": 0.17647058823529413,
"example": 0.058823529411764705,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.11764705882352941,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5294117647058824,
"praise": 0.29411764705882354,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.11764705882352941,
"results_and_discussion": 0.17647058823529413,
"suggestion_... | 1.764706 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Cost-Effectiveness of Nirsevimab and Maternal RSVpreF Vaccination for Preventing\nRespiratory Syncytial Virus Disease in Infants Across Canada\nVersion: 0 Date: 18 Nov 2024\nReviewer: Nathaniel Hendrix\nReviewer's repo... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03928-z | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Cost-Effectiveness of Nirsevimab and Maternal RSVpreF Vaccination for Preventing
Respiratory Syncytial Virus Disease in Infants Across Canada
Version: 0 Date: 25 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to revise the manuscript draft entitled "Cost-effectiveness of
Nirsevimab and Abrysvo for Pre... | Title: Cost-Effectiveness of Nirsevimab and Maternal RSVpreF Vaccination for Preventing
Respiratory Syncytial Virus Disease in Infants Across Canada
Version: 0 Date: 25 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to revise the manuscript draft entitled "Cost-effectiveness of
Nirsevimab and Abrysvo for Pre... | BMC | 12916_2025_3928_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 3,
"materials_and_methods": 21,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 15,
"results_and_discussion": 5,
"suggestion_and_solution": 18,
"total": 46
} | {
"criticism": 0.043478260869565216,
"example": 0.021739130434782608,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.06521739130434782,
"materials_and_methods": 0.45652173913043476,
"praise": 0.043478260869565216,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.32608695652173914,
"results_and_discussion": 0.10869565217391304,
"suggesti... | 1.456522 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Cost-Effectiveness of Nirsevimab and Maternal RSVpreF Vaccination for Preventing\nRespiratory Syncytial Virus Disease in Infants Across Canada\nVersion: 0 Date: 25 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThank you for the opportu... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03928-z | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Cost-Effectiveness of Nirsevimab and Maternal RSVpreF Vaccination for Preventing
Respiratory Syncytial Virus Disease in Infants Across Canada
Version: 1 Date: 16 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for address my comments. The revised manuscript looks great.
One last item that I hope authors and the editor can... | Title: Cost-Effectiveness of Nirsevimab and Maternal RSVpreF Vaccination for Preventing
Respiratory Syncytial Virus Disease in Infants Across Canada
Version: 1 Date: 16 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for address my comments. The revised manuscript looks great.
One last item that I hope authors and the editor can... | BMC | 12916_2025_3928_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 8
} | {
"criticism": 0.375,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.125,
"materials_and_methods": 0.25,
"praise": 0.125,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.125,
"results_and_discussion": 0.125,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1.125 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Cost-Effectiveness of Nirsevimab and Maternal RSVpreF Vaccination for Preventing\nRespiratory Syncytial Virus Disease in Infants Across Canada\nVersion: 1 Date: 16 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThank you for address my ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03928-z | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Cost-Effectiveness of Nirsevimab and Maternal RSVpreF Vaccination for Preventing
Respiratory Syncytial Virus Disease in Infants Across Canada
Version: 1 Date: 22 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Nathaniel Hendrix
Reviewer's report:
Excellent work on the updates. This is fascinating work and you've executed it well! I'm happy... | Title: Cost-Effectiveness of Nirsevimab and Maternal RSVpreF Vaccination for Preventing
Respiratory Syncytial Virus Disease in Infants Across Canada
Version: 1 Date: 22 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Nathaniel Hendrix
Reviewer's report:
Excellent work on the updates. This is fascinating work and you've executed it well! I'm happy... | BMC | 12916_2025_3928_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 3
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.3333333333333333,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1.333333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Cost-Effectiveness of Nirsevimab and Maternal RSVpreF Vaccination for Preventing\nRespiratory Syncytial Virus Disease in Infants Across Canada\nVersion: 1 Date: 22 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Nathaniel Hendrix\nReviewer's repo... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03947-w | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Ultra-Processed Food Consumption in the Central Division of Fiji
Version: 0 Date: 22 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Catherine Leclercq
Reviewer's report:
The paper deals with an important nutrition issue at global level i.e. the high consumption
of Highly Processed Foods which has been put in relation with the increased le... | Title: Ultra-Processed Food Consumption in the Central Division of Fiji
Version: 0 Date: 22 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Catherine Leclercq
Reviewer's report:
The paper deals with an important nutrition issue at global level i.e. the high consumption
of Highly Processed Foods which has been put in relation with the increased le... | BMC | 12916_2025_3947_ReviewerReport_V0_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 5,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 12,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 12,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 10,
"total": 29
} | {
"criticism": 0.10344827586206896,
"example": 0.1724137931034483,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.034482758620689655,
"materials_and_methods": 0.41379310344827586,
"praise": 0.06896551724137931,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.41379310344827586,
"results_and_discussion": 0.10344827586206896,
"suggestion_... | 1.655172 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultra-Processed Food Consumption in the Central Division of Fiji\nVersion: 0 Date: 22 Oct 2024\nReviewer: Catherine Leclercq\nReviewer's report:\nThe paper deals with an important nutrition issue at global level i.e. t... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03947-w | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Ultra-Processed Food Consumption in the Central Division of Fiji
Version: 0 Date: 31 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Edwina Wambogo
Reviewer's report: | Title: Ultra-Processed Food Consumption in the Central Division of Fiji
Version: 0 Date: 31 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Edwina Wambogo
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12916_2025_3947_ReviewerReport_V0_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultra-Processed Food Consumption in the Central Division of Fiji\nVersion: 0 Date: 31 Oct 2024\nReviewer: Edwina Wambogo\nReviewer's report:",
"role": "assistant"
}
] | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03947-w | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Ultra-Processed Food Consumption in the Central Division of Fiji
Version: 0 Date: 04 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Paul Eze Eme
Reviewer's report:
This is an interesting well-written paper. Just a couple of issues to be considered:
1. The authors reported that a household listing was conducted from Oct to Dec 2021 but how... | Title: Ultra-Processed Food Consumption in the Central Division of Fiji
Version: 0 Date: 04 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Paul Eze Eme
Reviewer's report:
This is an interesting well-written paper. Just a couple of issues to be considered:
1. The authors reported that a household listing was conducted from Oct to Dec 2021 but how... | BMC | 12916_2025_3947_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 10,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 5,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 7,
"total": 23
} | {
"criticism": 0.043478260869565216,
"example": 0.08695652173913043,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.043478260869565216,
"materials_and_methods": 0.43478260869565216,
"praise": 0.043478260869565216,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.21739130434782608,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": ... | 1.173913 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultra-Processed Food Consumption in the Central Division of Fiji\nVersion: 0 Date: 04 Nov 2024\nReviewer: Paul Eze Eme\nReviewer's report:\nThis is an interesting well-written paper. Just a couple of issues to be consi... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03947-w | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Ultra-Processed Food Consumption in the Central Division of Fiji
Version: 1 Date: 13 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Paul Eze Eme
Reviewer's report:
The paper has been well revised and significantly improved. Kudos to the authors for doing the
wonderful job. | Title: Ultra-Processed Food Consumption in the Central Division of Fiji
Version: 1 Date: 13 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Paul Eze Eme
Reviewer's report:
The paper has been well revised and significantly improved. Kudos to the authors for doing the
wonderful job. | BMC | 12916_2025_3947_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultra-Processed Food Consumption in the Central Division of Fiji\nVersion: 1 Date: 13 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Paul Eze Eme\nReviewer's report:\nThe paper has been well revised and significantly improved. Kudos to the autho... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12916-025-03947-w | Reviewed - bmc_medicine | Title: Ultra-Processed Food Consumption in the Central Division of Fiji
Version: 1 Date: 01 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Catherine Leclercq
Reviewer's report:
In the revised version of the manuscript, the authors have dealt with all the issues that I had
raised in my referee report and made corrections/integrations based on the... | Title: Ultra-Processed Food Consumption in the Central Division of Fiji
Version: 1 Date: 01 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Catherine Leclercq
Reviewer's report:
In the revised version of the manuscript, the authors have dealt with all the issues that I had
raised in my referee report and made corrections/integrations based on the... | BMC | 12916_2025_3947_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 3
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.3333333333333333,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0.333333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultra-Processed Food Consumption in the Central Division of Fiji\nVersion: 1 Date: 01 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Catherine Leclercq\nReviewer's report:\nIn the revised version of the manuscript, the authors have dealt with al... | 2,025 |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.