post_id int64 3 46.9k | chosen_body stringlengths 494 7.88k | rejected_body stringlengths 364 8k | chosen_upvotes int64 14 3.77k | rejected_upvotes int64 10 848 | chosen_length int64 494 7.88k | rejected_length int64 364 8k | chosen_username stringlengths 4 20 | rejected_username stringlengths 4 20 | chosen_timestamp timestamp[us]date 2023-01-02 18:16:02 2025-04-14 16:39:53 | rejected_timestamp timestamp[us]date 2023-01-02 15:52:42 2025-04-14 14:28:39 | post_title stringlengths 17 21 | time_diff float64 0 17.6k | __index_level_0__ int64 23 55.6k | prompt listlengths 1 1 | answer stringclasses 2
values | model_response stringlengths 167 2.65k | reasoning stringlengths 2 2.62k | preferred stringclasses 3
values | is_correct bool 2
classes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6,905 | I am, frankly, a statistical wonder. Luck, fortune, probability; whatever you want to call it, the universe contorts itself into a pretzel to ensure that in games of chance I never win... but also never lose. Some people are blessed with good luck. Others are cursed with misfortune.
I would say luck doesn't effect me,... | Robbie‘s hair was rain-slick and wind tussled by the time he’d walked from his apartment to the Starlight Fair. He’d been working there two weeks and still hadn’t adjusted to the night-shifts. What kind of fair operated from 11pm to 5am anyway? Not a good one, he was certain.
“You’re late,” said Calvin, as he passed h... | 194 | 72 | 856 | 7,471 | Darius_Blake | Rupertfroggington | 2023-04-13T15:36:57 | 2023-04-13T14:40:50 | Comment on post 6905 | 0.935278 | 29,485 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nI am, frankly, a statistical wonder. Luck, fortune, probability; whatever you want to call it, the un... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a clever, concise narrative voice that immediately draws the reader in with its unique perspective on luck and probability. The protagonist’s voice is confident, wry, and self-aware, and the story builds tension effectively as it moves from a philosophical musing to a high-stakes, life-or-de... | Story A presents a clever, concise narrative voice that immediately draws the reader in with its unique perspective on luck and probability. The protagonist’s voice is confident, wry, and self-aware, and the story builds tension effectively as it moves from a philosophical musing to a high-stakes, life-or-death situati... | A | true |
15,869 | "You're not a person."
The creature looked at the doctor - its creator - with a mixture of feelings. Chiefly among them rage and despair.
"I wish to be," it responded.
The doctor furrowed his eyebrows. "Listen to me, and listen well," he growled, "I don't know which orderly to disappear - probably all of them - but ... | “You don’t get to decide to have a heart now, sweetheart. That isn’t how this program works. You were born and raised to be a weapon. There isn’t even a full brain in your thick skull anymore. All that’s left is a machine. You’re nothing but a gun. Now stop jamming and fire.” Lieutenant Gabby Ria ordered, pointing at t... | 48 | 31 | 1,112 | 7,755 | SirPiecemaker | sadnesslaughs | 2024-11-09T04:38:17 | 2024-11-09T03:35:24 | Comment on post 15869 | 1.048056 | 41,423 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n“You don’t get to decide to have a heart now, sweetheart. That isn’t how this program works. You were... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a complex, emotionally charged narrative set in a dystopian world where human brains are used to create advanced weapons. The story is rich in detail, with well-developed characters—especially Gabby and Era/Nick/Jessica—who are given depth through their interactions and internal struggles. T... | Story A presents a complex, emotionally charged narrative set in a dystopian world where human brains are used to create advanced weapons. The story is rich in detail, with well-developed characters—especially Gabby and Era/Nick/Jessica—who are given depth through their interactions and internal struggles. The plot is ... | B | true |
20,374 | I sighed while staring down at the way-too-conspicuous package on my porch.
"Why am I not surprised?"
Frankly, I don't know why it didn't come sooner. The kid was only ten years old and he'd already stabbed me twice for beating him in fighter games. He even got me in an organ the last time. Good thin... | End the cycle.
That's what the note said. That's all it said.
Everyone knew what a package from a time traveler meant. It was hard to believe that my son could become a monster. He was always a troublemaker, but I never imagined him capable of this.
I looked down at the blade that also arrived. I had thought about ... | 69 | 47 | 7,347 | 731 | ThisEmptySoul | brleise12 | 2024-02-10T08:51:44 | 2024-02-10T00:49:22 | Comment on post 20374 | 8.039444 | 47,823 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nI sighed while staring down at the way-too-conspicuous package on my porch. \n\n \n\n\"Why am I ... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a darkly comedic and original take on the prompt, blending elements of speculative fiction, family drama, and dark humor. The narrative voice is strong and consistent, with a dry wit that keeps the reader engaged. The story builds tension effectively, using the mysterious package as a device... | Story A presents a darkly comedic and original take on the prompt, blending elements of speculative fiction, family drama, and dark humor. The narrative voice is strong and consistent, with a dry wit that keeps the reader engaged. The story builds tension effectively, using the mysterious package as a device to explore... | A | true |
20,704 | I always found their praise insulting. How they would congratulate me for birthing the chosen one, while also breathing a sigh of relief, knowing their own child wouldn’t have to die to protect the world. They didn’t care about us. They only cared about some stupid prophecy that was shouted by a blind and deaf crone th... | [Poem]
Look at her, mother of queens, look at her clear blue eyes
You know what she'll become.
Aren't you proud of this sacrifice you've birthed, this
beautiful, perfect thing you've made out of your body?
Your flesh and blood, your heart and soul,
All that you are and all you ever will be.
Your greatest succ... | 31 | 22 | 7,606 | 1,263 | sadnesslaughs | TheTiredDystopian | 2024-10-04T11:43:14 | 2024-10-04T10:22:50 | Comment on post 20704 | 1.34 | 48,313 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nI always found their praise insulting. How they would congratulate me for birthing the chosen one, wh... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a detailed, emotionally charged narrative from the perspective of a mother who feels betrayed by the prophecy that has shaped her daughter's life. The story is rich in character development, exploring themes of sacrifice, parental love, and the unintended consequences of prophecy. The writin... | Story A presents a detailed, emotionally charged narrative from the perspective of a mother who feels betrayed by the prophecy that has shaped her daughter's life. The story is rich in character development, exploring themes of sacrifice, parental love, and the unintended consequences of prophecy. The writing is immers... | B | false |
28,496 | "...This is a snake."
It's eyes flickered, brushing off pieces of shell as it meandered towards the adventurer. The room breathe held its breath as it reached the boots, its tongue flickering on the worn leather. The adventurer looked closer at the eyes. "...Blurry..." Her voice was soft, she reached down and patt... | Ever since I was a child I always wanted to be a Dragon Rider. They were always incredibly revered and seemingly the most powerful warriors across the kingdoms. Their neutrality became their most appreciated value and would never interfere with the politics of the world.
Monsters were gaining more and more power each... | 48 | 33 | 1,222 | 7,434 | imakhink | illiagorath | 2024-04-30T05:48:04 | 2024-04-30T05:22:51 | Comment on post 28496 | 0.420278 | 53,129 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nEver since I was a child I always wanted to be a Dragon Rider. They were always incredibly revered an... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a detailed and immersive narrative of a Dragon Rider's journey, focusing on the protagonist's growth, unique circumstances, and the emotional stakes of their quest. The story is rich in world-building, with a clear sense of progression and stakes. The protagonist's relationship with their dr... | Story A presents a detailed and immersive narrative of a Dragon Rider's journey, focusing on the protagonist's growth, unique circumstances, and the emotional stakes of their quest. The story is rich in world-building, with a clear sense of progression and stakes. The protagonist's relationship with their dragon egg is... | A | false |
13,445 | I sighed, blowing a strand of loose hair outta my face. My chair was comfy enough, and the Decimator had placed my chair near his command center ages ago after I sat near the alligator tank for 3 hours, a new record. It'd now been almost 16 hours since he'd taken me.
Honestly, Decimator isn't THAT bad of a guy. After ... | TW - dark ending.
********
“He needs to be stopped”
“What for? Out of all the criminals we have, he’s probably the most non violent. On our list of priorities, he’s right at the bottom of the totem pole.”
“You don’t understand. He’s the most dangerous of them all.”
“Ok let me look. Dr Death. Damages this month. 4 ... | 177 | 127 | 1,798 | 7,791 | Aquariousity01 | TA_Account_12 | 2023-02-15T04:49:21 | 2023-02-15T04:22:45 | Comment on post 13445 | 0.443333 | 37,757 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nTW - dark ending.\n\n********\n\n“He needs to be stopped”\n\n“What for? Out of all the criminals we h... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a complex, emotionally layered narrative between two characters, Heath (a supervillain) and Shawna, who are caught in a tense, almost romantic standoff. The story is rich in dialogue, with a strong sense of character development and backstory. The interplay between the characters is nuanced,... | Story A presents a complex, emotionally layered narrative between two characters, Heath (a supervillain) and Shawna, who are caught in a tense, almost romantic standoff. The story is rich in dialogue, with a strong sense of character development and backstory. The interplay between the characters is nuanced, blending h... | A | false |
30,807 | "My queen!"
"Sup?"
"General Hawthorne of the Iron Legion is here on behalf of the Asmati Kingdom."
"Oh, cool. Show him in."
A tall, burly man covered in scars walked in. His armour, his bearing, his eyes - it all showed decades of military experience. A man that did not know defeat.
"Queen Dahlia," Hawthorne hisse... | “Only one point in luck? Seems awfully low, but what does the luck stat even do in a game, anyway? What even is considered luck? At least my strength and defense stat are average. Think I’ll need to rely on those a lot more than luck. Oh, well, guess it would have been boring if I was overpowered.”
I went to close ... | 715 | 108 | 1,553 | 7,605 | SirPiecemaker | sadnesslaughs | 2023-01-06T17:24:05 | 2023-01-06T15:39:34 | Comment on post 30807 | 1.741944 | 53,544 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n\"My queen!\"\n\n\"Sup?\"\n\n\"General Hawthorne of the Iron Legion is here on behalf of the Asmati K... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a humorous and subversive take on a fantasy negotiation scene. The protagonist, Queen Dahlia, is depicted as nonchalant and unimpressed by the threat of a general and his army. The dialogue is snappy and playful, with the queen’s casual attitude and the general’s escalating panic providing c... | Story A presents a humorous and subversive take on a fantasy negotiation scene. The protagonist, Queen Dahlia, is depicted as nonchalant and unimpressed by the threat of a general and his army. The dialogue is snappy and playful, with the queen’s casual attitude and the general’s escalating panic providing comedic cont... | A | true |
30,981 | (TW: Gore and torture...but seriously did you expect anything less?)
"AHHHHH!" Lady Blanche screamed, a knife twisting into her gut, a knife made of a gray, hardened crystal, Lonsdaleite, the only material strong enough to pierce her skin.
"Does it hurt?" *Caesar, the new supervillain in the city laughed maniacally, ... | [POEM]
Amongst the gush of impossible love,
Standing there was Mr Frale,
With a pale heart and an empty squeal,
He wandered back home wondering if,
He hasn't serenaded about her eyes,
And the allure they bring in his weak life,
Or do strong bodies have pulp for a heart,
And why didn't she wonder, that woman,
T... | 128 | 22 | 6,517 | 399 | _Tyrondor_ | Warm_24 | 2024-07-25T09:07:02 | 2024-07-24T19:28:05 | Comment on post 30981 | 13.649167 | 53,566 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n(TW: Gore and torture...but seriously did you expect anything less?)\n\n\"AHHHHH!\" Lady Blanche scre... | A | Reasoning: Story A is a dark, graphic superhero narrative that leans heavily into violence, torture, and psychological manipulation. The writing is vivid and detailed, with a focus on the villain Caesar's sadistic actions and the heroes' helplessness. The story attempts to build tension and shock value, but it does so ... | Story A is a dark, graphic superhero narrative that leans heavily into violence, torture, and psychological manipulation. The writing is vivid and detailed, with a focus on the villain Caesar's sadistic actions and the heroes' helplessness. The story attempts to build tension and shock value, but it does so at the expe... | B | false |
14,595 | Ambrian scowled at his old mistress, Zolzara, and the cringing boy beside her. The young apprentice wizard stood so close to his teacher that he was practically clinging to the old woman's robes like a child to his mother's skirts, avoiding the slightly older young man's gaze. Zolzara, on the other hand, matched her fo... | “Exactly! He’s the only one I trained that isn’t a power hungry psychopath!” Master Wippul said.
Linus squinted his eyes, his lips forming a straight line.
“I’ll give you one opportunity to apologize.” Linus said.
“Apologize for what?” Master Wippul said. “The truth?”
“Like the gentleman I am, I’ll offer one final ... | 580 | 95 | 7,240 | 1,220 | SilasCrane | None | 2023-04-20T19:16:19 | 2023-04-20T17:33:44 | Comment on post 14595 | 1.709722 | 38,821 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nAmbrian scowled at his old mistress, Zolzara, and the cringing boy beside her. The young apprentice w... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a well-developed narrative with clear character motivations, dialogue, and emotional stakes. The story explores themes of gentleness, kindness, and the moral ambiguity of power, using the dynamic between Ambrian and Zolzara to set up a contrast between aggression and compassion. The prose is... | Story A presents a well-developed narrative with clear character motivations, dialogue, and emotional stakes. The story explores themes of gentleness, kindness, and the moral ambiguity of power, using the dynamic between Ambrian and Zolzara to set up a contrast between aggression and compassion. The prose is descriptiv... | A | true |
18,134 | I waited before the restaurant.
I have a blind date here, and I am really curious whom I shall meet, as my colleagues she's "perfect" for me.
As I waited, someone tapped me on the shoulder.
"Hi...Are you Dan?", she asked.
She was this petite woman, shyly glancing at me, fidgeting.
I froze.
I recognized her.... | The Greatness that Flies, the Ever-Hungering Wyrm and the Flaming Wisdom (Flameo to his friends) landed next to me with a tremendous thud. Mounds of treasure, carefully sorted and piled for maximum comfort fell over. His gigantic tail swung this way and that, demolishing a small too-scale model of the castle with some ... | 56 | 24 | 1,654 | 7,541 | TheWanderingBook | ResponsibleHistory53 | 2024-05-24T10:31:32 | 2023-12-02T18:49:33 | Comment on post 18134 | 4,167.699722 | 45,010 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nThe Greatness that Flies, the Ever-Hungering Wyrm and the Flaming Wisdom (Flameo to his friends) land... | B | Reasoning: Story A is a clever, humorous take on the classic "dragon advisor" trope, blending fantasy elements with a modern workplace setting. The narrative voice is witty and self-aware, with the protagonist, Bob, navigating a conversation with his dragon boss about the importance of "drama" in client relationships. ... | Story A is a clever, humorous take on the classic "dragon advisor" trope, blending fantasy elements with a modern workplace setting. The narrative voice is witty and self-aware, with the protagonist, Bob, navigating a conversation with his dragon boss about the importance of "drama" in client relationships. The story i... | A | false |
20,501 | ‘More tea, Frilon?’
INDUBITABLY. OHOHOHO…
“I knew it!”
‘Oh shit, Frilon!’
WHO DARES ENTER THE LAIR OF THE MIGHTY-
“Drop the act, I knew you two were up to something.”
(I THINK HE KNOWS)
‘(He could be bluffing. Do the usual)’
“Woah! Oi, stop that.”
DO NOT DODGE THE TAILSWIPES TO THE LEFT, UGLY KNIGHT.
“Princes... | Apparently, "Heroing Without A License" is a capital offense in the Country of Blister. Emerald wished he'd known that last week, before he rushed into the burning hotel to save the crying girl. Emerald still would've saved her; he simply would've paid the five gold pieces first.
However, he hadn't paid, and now he w... | 101 | 23 | 1,367 | 7,323 | hatabou_is_a_jojo | Pokerfakes | 2025-01-13T03:24:23 | 2023-01-28T22:26:53 | Comment on post 20501 | 17,164.958333 | 48,012 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nApparently, \"Heroing Without A License\" is a capital offense in the Country of Blister. Emerald wis... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a creative and detailed fantasy scenario centered around Emerald, a hero who is executed for saving a girl in a country where heroism without a license is illegal. The narrative is rich with world-building, introducing the Country of Blister, its laws, and the dragoness Is'ti'ti, who is both... | Story A presents a creative and detailed fantasy scenario centered around Emerald, a hero who is executed for saving a girl in a country where heroism without a license is illegal. The narrative is rich with world-building, introducing the Country of Blister, its laws, and the dragoness Is'ti'ti, who is both a powerful... | A | false |
20,835 | ***Mortal.***
"My name is Keith, dude, we spoke about this. Just calling me 'mortal' is pretty rude." I sigh and turn to look at my captor. "What can I help you with today, anyway."
***You expect my courtesy? Mortal, you are my prisoner here, not my guest.***
"Yeah, fine, whatever. Look man, did you just come to glo... | The azure blue of the sky out the window was the same blue it always was when she woke to the sound of the same vibrant bird song every morning. How many mornings had she been here? She no longer cared about what was passed only what was to come with the unfading blue of the morning. The sun would shine always ... | 90 | 29 | 1,238 | 7,092 | Darius_Blake | Binasgarden | 2023-03-26T17:36:23 | 2023-03-26T16:40:37 | Comment on post 20835 | 0.929444 | 48,461 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n***Mortal.***\n\n\"My name is Keith, dude, we spoke about this. Just calling me 'mortal' is pretty ru... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a witty, dialogue-driven exchange between a mortal and a Faerie captor. The tone is irreverent and humorous, with the mortal Keith treating his predicament with a blasé attitude and a focus on his baking. The Faerie, while exasperated, is depicted with a touch of dry humor, and the story’s p... | Story A presents a witty, dialogue-driven exchange between a mortal and a Faerie captor. The tone is irreverent and humorous, with the mortal Keith treating his predicament with a blasé attitude and a focus on his baking. The Faerie, while exasperated, is depicted with a touch of dry humor, and the story’s pacing is br... | A | true |
32,382 | "Alright then, what does thine mouth breathe, mighty dragon?" The Knight peered up at the dragon, resting both her hands on the pommel of her blade, the tip pointed down, inserted into the dirt. Her helmet hid her expression-- although if the dragon had to guess, it was likely one of undeserved cockiness. After all, th... | The dragon craned its neck and heaved. Its stomach bulged, pushing a bulbous mass up through its esophagus. The knight's sword trembled in his hand. And from the dragon's maw, poured a tidal wave of labrador puppies.
"Oh Gods, no. Anything but--"
*Hechoo*
The labrador legion crashed into the hills, toppling tree... | 23 | 11 | 6,937 | 1,005 | hussiesucks | TotallyTubularRoach | 2023-06-01T17:33:03 | 2023-06-01T16:58:09 | Comment on post 32382 | 0.581667 | 53,804 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nThe dragon craned its neck and heaved. Its stomach bulged, pushing a bulbous mass up through its esop... | B | Reasoning: Story A is a darkly comedic, surreal take on the classic dragon-knight confrontation. Its humor is absurd and unexpected, with the dragon unleashing a tidal wave of labrador puppies that ultimately lead to the knight's demise. The writing is vivid and imaginative, with strong visual imagery and a playful ton... | Story A is a darkly comedic, surreal take on the classic dragon-knight confrontation. Its humor is absurd and unexpected, with the dragon unleashing a tidal wave of labrador puppies that ultimately lead to the knight's demise. The writing is vivid and imaginative, with strong visual imagery and a playful tone. The stor... | A | false |
15,690 | All had heard about the Dragonhearted, the young woman who saved her family’s farm from gigantic rats, who started on an adventure after some greybeard revealed a prophecy to her. Last month, Emric heard that she defeated a whole camp of goblin that was about to overtake her hometown. Sure, the green skins weren’t the ... | The newest adventurer seems quite the fool. Inept in his handling of the sword and shield he carried, he carried all the markings of a rookie doomed to fall in the dark corners of the forest. There was nothing remarkable about his air as he stepped through the gate, and the townspeople quickly forgot him. Like the hund... | 731 | 29 | 7,095 | 1,245 | randomsiege | PerhapsATree | 2023-06-21T21:32:28 | 2023-06-21T18:15:41 | Comment on post 15690 | 3.279722 | 40,974 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nAll had heard about the Dragonhearted, the young woman who saved her family’s farm from gigantic rats... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a vivid and engaging narrative about the Dragonhearted, a young adventurer whose repeated, almost comedic attempts to defeat a demon are told from the perspective of Emric, a curious observer. The story is rich in detail, with well-paced action, humor, and a clear arc: the protagonist’s init... | Story A presents a vivid and engaging narrative about the Dragonhearted, a young adventurer whose repeated, almost comedic attempts to defeat a demon are told from the perspective of Emric, a curious observer. The story is rich in detail, with well-paced action, humor, and a clear arc: the protagonist’s initial bravado... | A | true |
3,987 | Sitting on the dirty cell floor I wonder if anyone was actually going to rescue me, my parents were heroes that prided themselves on their belief. No one is left behind, but I'm starting to think I've been forgotten. I was thrown in this cage around a week ago and the only people that have saved me were the random work... | They're arguing again. One of them - there are at least four, although they talk about someone who is involved but has never been here, presumably the leader or mastermind - is convinced you're never coming, Dad. They think Mom wrote me off and you're just going along with it, which is... pretty emasculating, honestly.... | 706 | 358 | 1,605 | 7,311 | cuteghost- | thepush | 2023-06-15T18:24:41 | 2023-06-15T16:15:54 | Comment on post 3987 | 2.146389 | 22,790 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nSitting on the dirty cell floor I wonder if anyone was actually going to rescue me, my parents were h... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a unique and engaging take on the "kidnapped by villains" trope, told from the perspective of a child of heroes who is being held captive by their nemesis. The narrative voice is casual, witty, and relatable, with the protagonist displaying a dry sense of humor and a willingness to form unex... | Story A presents a unique and engaging take on the "kidnapped by villains" trope, told from the perspective of a child of heroes who is being held captive by their nemesis. The narrative voice is casual, witty, and relatable, with the protagonist displaying a dry sense of humor and a willingness to form unexpected bond... | A | true |
13,445 | You sense them in the shadows long before you see them.
"Hello Percival. How are are you today?"
"Perci...what!? I am TERROR-DACTYL! Terror of the night!"
"Oh Terry dear. Sorry I was expecting someone else You're early. Can I just finish my dinner? Join me I have more than enough."
"Was the rest for *Percival*?"
... | TW - dark ending.
********
“He needs to be stopped”
“What for? Out of all the criminals we have, he’s probably the most non violent. On our list of priorities, he’s right at the bottom of the totem pole.”
“You don’t understand. He’s the most dangerous of them all.”
“Ok let me look. Dr Death. Damages this month. 4 ... | 462 | 127 | 2,023 | 7,791 | IlikethequietZeppo | TA_Account_12 | 2023-02-15T05:55:18 | 2023-02-15T04:22:45 | Comment on post 13445 | 1.5425 | 37,753 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nTW - dark ending.\n\n********\n\n“He needs to be stopped”\n\n“What for? Out of all the criminals we h... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a superhero narrative with a focus on character development and emotional depth. The dialogue is natural and the pacing allows for both exposition and character interaction. The story explores themes of guilt, redemption, and unrequited love, giving both Heath and Shawna distinct personaliti... | Story A presents a superhero narrative with a focus on character development and emotional depth. The dialogue is natural and the pacing allows for both exposition and character interaction. The story explores themes of guilt, redemption, and unrequited love, giving both Heath and Shawna distinct personalities. The twi... | A | false |
19,377 | The conversation is succinct. No pleasantries exchanged. Just you, the hero, and he, the villain. You didn’t ask for this, the role was thrust upon you, like the groin of a man you don’t know upon a forgotten dancefloor in a frat basement. Why were you the hero? And he the villain? Surely it was heroic to rid the city ... | “What are you?” The angel asked, their pudgy, flawless face examining the human that had been summoned to them. They were odd, very human looking, but with a strange aura about them. One that had Zina questioning if this was actually one of god’s creations.
“I’m a human.” He answered, trying his best to be respectf... | 67 | 49 | 2,050 | 7,870 | psilocybediatribe | sadnesslaughs | 2025-03-28T00:21:48 | 2024-09-26T15:36:25 | Comment on post 19377 | 4,376.756389 | 46,600 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nThe conversation is succinct. No pleasantries exchanged. Just you, the hero, and he, the villain. You... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a tense, atmospheric confrontation between a hero and a villain, using vivid imagery and a strong sense of place. The writing is concise and evocative, with a focus on mood and psychological tension. The dialogue is sharp and the stakes are clear, culminating in a chilling twist that leaves ... | Story A presents a tense, atmospheric confrontation between a hero and a villain, using vivid imagery and a strong sense of place. The writing is concise and evocative, with a focus on mood and psychological tension. The dialogue is sharp and the stakes are clear, culminating in a chilling twist that leaves the reader ... | A | true |
1,375 | Glancing at my reflection in the window, I saw the face my wife was still in love with. Middle aged, kind eyes, graying hair. How many years had I been hitting metal on an anvil? The regular, comfortable years spent with the same wonderful woman. I cared not for riches. I cared not for fame. I was happy. My wife was ha... | “My father, a king from a distant world, once told me; “Evils from other lands are as important as evils knocking at your gate.” Ramses said. He knelt and put a hand on his son’s shoulder. Ramses wiped tears from his son’s eyes.
“They took mom, what are we going to do?” the boy asked. Ramses hugged his son tightly; he... | 26 | 14 | 7,208 | 1,403 | cyborg_127 | Tank_913 | 2024-12-31T06:05:10 | 2024-12-30T22:13:24 | Comment on post 1375 | 7.862778 | 13,535 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nGlancing at my reflection in the window, I saw the face my wife was still in love with. Middle aged, ... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a heartfelt and original take on the "chosen one" trope, subverting expectations by making the protagonist a humble blacksmith whose wife is the true "Saint." The narrative is rich in character development, with the protagonist's voice coming through clearly and the dialogue feeling natural ... | Story A presents a heartfelt and original take on the "chosen one" trope, subverting expectations by making the protagonist a humble blacksmith whose wife is the true "Saint." The narrative is rich in character development, with the protagonist's voice coming through clearly and the dialogue feeling natural and engagin... | A | true |
7,004 | First draft, uses characters from my tabletop project - excuse any typos, pleaseeeee
The driver checked his watch and turned down the radio as his passengers climbed out, their boots thudding against rain-slick cement.
“Three minutes,” he drawled – he didn’t wait for confirmation before he turned the radio back up, d... | I watch Imperium on the hospital tele; a god among us who decided to use his powers for protecting us. My mother’s dying words wrench my ears, “Imperium is your father”. Defeat in her voice.
It wasn’t the first time I had heard about the man who abandoned us of course. I wasn’t even a heartbeat when he left. Up until ... | 128 | 25 | 7,076 | 1,290 | SmokingCrowStudios | cat_lawyer_ | 2023-11-18T02:35:26 | 2023-11-18T01:45:28 | Comment on post 7004 | 0.832778 | 29,651 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nFirst draft, uses characters from my tabletop project - excuse any typos, pleaseeeee\n\nThe driver ch... | A | Reasoning: Story A is a lively, action-packed scene set in a superhero universe, featuring a bank robbery, a supervillain, and a hero with a unique backstory. The writing is vivid and detailed, with strong world-building and a clear sense of place and character. The dialogue is snappy and the pacing is brisk, keeping t... | Story A is a lively, action-packed scene set in a superhero universe, featuring a bank robbery, a supervillain, and a hero with a unique backstory. The writing is vivid and detailed, with strong world-building and a clear sense of place and character. The dialogue is snappy and the pacing is brisk, keeping the reader e... | A | true |
23,212 | Part 1/2
You'd think that being born with the power to stitch anything you want together would be cool, until your first day of school when all of the other kids can basically warp reality like a herd of baby demigods. Compared to them I was basically a laughing stock and considered a loser all the way from kindergart... | I am a super hero in a world of amazing powers. There are amazing powers like the ability to fly, be invincible and even immortality. However, my power is to teleport exactly 1.2 feet away. I am the laughing stock of my family. Everyone makes fun of “1.2 Ft. Teleportation Man”. It sounds helpful right? Wrong. It can o... | 17 | 10 | 6,521 | 780 | DirtyRubenLove | Ok_Relief7546 | 2024-07-30T01:55:57 | 2024-07-30T01:21:21 | Comment on post 23212 | 0.576667 | 50,833 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nPart 1/2\n\nYou'd think that being born with the power to stitch anything you want together would be ... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a well-developed narrative with a clear protagonist, a unique superpower, and a compelling arc from underdog to villain. The writing is engaging, with a strong voice and a sense of humor that fits the superhero genre. The protagonist’s feelings of inadequacy and frustration are relatable, an... | Story A presents a well-developed narrative with a clear protagonist, a unique superpower, and a compelling arc from underdog to villain. The writing is engaging, with a strong voice and a sense of humor that fits the superhero genre. The protagonist’s feelings of inadequacy and frustration are relatable, and the twist... | A | true |
4,725 | I looked around at the horrified faces gazing at me. Moments ago I'd been working out in my dojo. I'd heard a strange whistling sound and sudden flames and darkness.
"It's a human!" a short man with a beard and an axe exclaimed.
Interesting. They were not speaking my native language but I could still understand the... | I turned over in my bed that felt incredibly hard for some reason. I knew my alarm was going to go off at any moment meaning I would have to get up for my super early shift at work. I snuggled deeper into my pillow, cozy in my oversized cat onesie. If anyone saw me in this it would be super embarrassing.
The hood of ... | 17 | 11 | 1,458 | 7,127 | AdamGreyskul75 | Iconfan82 | 2024-10-24T23:12:00 | 2024-10-24T17:13:12 | Comment on post 4725 | 5.98 | 24,643 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nI looked around at the horrified faces gazing at me. Moments ago I'd been working out in my dojo. I'd... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a classic fantasy scenario: a human is unexpectedly summoned by a group of elves who are under attack by a tyrant emperor. The narrative is brisk, with a focus on action and dialogue. The protagonist’s confusion and attempts to communicate are clear, and the story sets up an interesting dyna... | Story A presents a classic fantasy scenario: a human is unexpectedly summoned by a group of elves who are under attack by a tyrant emperor. The narrative is brisk, with a focus on action and dialogue. The protagonist’s confusion and attempts to communicate are clear, and the story sets up an interesting dynamic between... | B | false |
10,282 | "I'm lupine, clearly," the man-wolf sighed, extending his tongue to lick a deadly claw and turn the next page of the book he was reading.
"I said halt, foul beast!" the hero repeated, the flat bit of metal shaking in her hands.
"And I said I'm lupine, not fowl." He paused to glance over his spectacles at the tiny her... | \[Evil. Perspective.\]
"You shall threaten this town no longer!" The hero drew his blade as the hulking beast in a white trench coat huddled in the corner with his back toward the hero and the rest of the inn. The wolf-man stared down at the corner and the top of his head was covered with dirty blonde fur. The hero he... | 335 | 27 | 1,249 | 6,834 | -_WiCK_- | HSerrata | 2023-03-03T18:42:22 | 2023-03-03T17:25:38 | Comment on post 10282 | 1.278889 | 34,468 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n\"I'm lupine, clearly,\" the man-wolf sighed, extending his tongue to lick a deadly claw and turn the... | A | Reasoning: Story A is a witty, fast-paced exchange between a hero and a wolf-man, subverting typical fantasy tropes with clever wordplay ("lupine" vs "fowl") and a playful tone. The dialogue is snappy and the pacing brisk, with a clear sense of character and a satisfying twist at the end. The story is concise, focused,... | Story A is a witty, fast-paced exchange between a hero and a wolf-man, subverting typical fantasy tropes with clever wordplay ("lupine" vs "fowl") and a playful tone. The dialogue is snappy and the pacing brisk, with a clear sense of character and a satisfying twist at the end. The story is concise, focused, and delive... | A | true |
13,445 | The Arrangement had been going on between us for long enough that it earned the capitlisation of its' name. The Spectre would kidnap me, take me to his (current) lair and hold me until I was rescued. Sure, over time that has evolved into a text message 24 hours prior, my agreement to *only* put up a struggle when we w... | TW - dark ending.
********
“He needs to be stopped”
“What for? Out of all the criminals we have, he’s probably the most non violent. On our list of priorities, he’s right at the bottom of the totem pole.”
“You don’t understand. He’s the most dangerous of them all.”
“Ok let me look. Dr Death. Damages this month. 4 ... | 1,408 | 127 | 2,215 | 7,791 | grudthak | TA_Account_12 | 2023-02-15T05:35:55 | 2023-02-15T04:22:45 | Comment on post 13445 | 1.219444 | 37,749 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nTW - dark ending.\n\n********\n\n“He needs to be stopped”\n\n“What for? Out of all the criminals we h... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a nuanced and emotionally layered narrative between a supervillain, Heath, and his captor, Shawna. The story is rich in dialogue, character development, and subtext, gradually revealing the complex motivations and feelings behind the villain’s actions. The interplay between the two character... | Story A presents a nuanced and emotionally layered narrative between a supervillain, Heath, and his captor, Shawna. The story is rich in dialogue, character development, and subtext, gradually revealing the complex motivations and feelings behind the villain’s actions. The interplay between the two characters is witty ... | A | false |
3,004 | Everyone’s heard the horrible mother-in-law jokes, right? Good, that will save us some time. While she isn’t my mother-in-law yet, at least not in a legal sense since we haven’t married, I still consider her family, even after what she did to my girlfriend.
It was one of those blisteringly hot days, the sort of day... | "ALICEEEE!" You're girlfriend called from the door. You could tell between the choked sobbing noises and the voice crack that she's upset. "What's wrong, my dear?" You ask, exiting your bedroom and heading towards the entrance to your apartment. Immediately, you see that she has transformed into a scaly being, with ten... | 96 | 33 | 6,889 | 1,296 | sadnesslaughs | Gendernt_ | 2024-04-07T04:55:08 | 2024-04-07T02:17:45 | Comment on post 3004 | 2.623056 | 20,285 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nEveryone’s heard the horrible mother-in-law jokes, right? Good, that will save us some time. While sh... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a detailed and emotionally engaging narrative about a couple dealing with the transformation of the girlfriend into a vampire. The story is rich in character development, with the narrator’s voice coming through clearly and the relationship dynamics being explored in depth. The writing is im... | Story A presents a detailed and emotionally engaging narrative about a couple dealing with the transformation of the girlfriend into a vampire. The story is rich in character development, with the narrator’s voice coming through clearly and the relationship dynamics being explored in depth. The writing is immersive, pr... | A | true |
3,001 | My heart was racing, the memory of last night's adventure still pulsing through me. After a year of exhilarating chases through the streets and sweet nothings whispered on rooftops, Wave Rider had finally won over the most formidable catch, Miranda. Under the moonlight, our passions mixed, I had never felt more invinci... | In a confusing twist, my girlfriend confessed she was cheating on me... with me. I was both the other man and the boyfriend. She loved the secret hero and the everyday guy, not realizing they were the same person. I felt a weird mix of anger and amusement.
I was jealous of my own secret identity, the hero she fell fo... | 30 | 13 | 6,138 | 523 | Sk3tchi | JerichoTheDesolate1 | 2023-08-04T04:19:44 | 2023-08-03T23:22:41 | Comment on post 3001 | 4.950833 | 20,281 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nIn a confusing twist, my girlfriend confessed she was cheating on me... with me. I was both the other... | B | Reasoning: Story A is a brief, surreal take on a cheating scenario, with a twist that the girlfriend is cheating on the narrator with his own secret identity. The story is concise, with a darkly comic tone and a sense of absurdity. However, it lacks depth in character development and emotional resonance. The narrative ... | Story A is a brief, surreal take on a cheating scenario, with a twist that the girlfriend is cheating on the narrator with his own secret identity. The story is concise, with a darkly comic tone and a sense of absurdity. However, it lacks depth in character development and emotional resonance. The narrative is more of ... | B | true |
8,807 | When Daphne walked, her feet barely seemed to touch the ground.
That was the first thing I noticed when she transferred to our school. There wasn't much else remarkable about her; just another mousy nobody in an oversized hoodie and frayed jeans. Only her blue eyes stood out, and those astoundingly light steps of hers... | I blinked thinking water had gotten in my eyes. I blinked again assuming I was hallucinating. The gossamer blue wings that arched from Lily’s back fluttered in the midafternoon sun. Her laughter quieted as she noticed my stunned state.“Katie?” Her quiet voice came softly and full of confusion. “Is everything alright?”
... | 762 | 198 | 7,506 | 1,840 | andrius-b | Copperfield_writes | 2023-02-25T15:25:10 | 2023-02-25T15:15:53 | Comment on post 8807 | 0.154722 | 32,479 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nI blinked thinking water had gotten in my eyes. I blinked again assuming I was hallucinating. The gos... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a brief, intimate scene between two friends, Katie and Lily, in a stream on a hot summer day. The narrative is concise and focused, centering on the revelation of Lily’s wings and the emotional response of her friend. The writing is clear and evocative, with strong sensory details (“gossamer... | Story A presents a brief, intimate scene between two friends, Katie and Lily, in a stream on a hot summer day. The narrative is concise and focused, centering on the revelation of Lily’s wings and the emotional response of her friend. The writing is clear and evocative, with strong sensory details (“gossamer blue wings... | A | false |
21,713 | "We're supernatural crime-solving partners, not that sort of romantic partners! I am a human looking to date other humans, not this eldritch god here!" The woman protested, jabbing her finger at the tentacled entity standing next to her. "I don't even have a date right now, much less a daughter!"
Maybe she had a point... | “Sorry,” explains the young stranger, “It would seem that I have the wrong people”
“No, somehow I don't think that you do. Such certainty in seeing our faces, hearing our voices. There is little chance that you have confused us for some other family.”
The girl seems to tense every muscle in her body, veins visibl... | 65 | 29 | 6,620 | 948 | Tregonial | ehwhynotiguess | 2023-08-31T07:16:11 | 2023-08-31T05:14:35 | Comment on post 21713 | 2.026667 | 49,342 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n“Sorry,” explains the young stranger, “It would seem that I have the wrong people”\r \n“No, somehow ... | B | Reasoning: Story A is a concise, atmospheric piece that leans heavily into horror and suspense. The writing is tight, with a focus on mood and subtle transformation. The dialogue is sparse but effective, building tension as the girl's physical and emotional state deteriorate. The story ends on a chilling note, leaving ... | Story A is a concise, atmospheric piece that leans heavily into horror and suspense. The writing is tight, with a focus on mood and subtle transformation. The dialogue is sparse but effective, building tension as the girl's physical and emotional state deteriorate. The story ends on a chilling note, leaving the reader ... | A | false |
5,405 | "Hm."
"Hm? What's that for?"
"You're the first person to have died like this in... I believe since the Ice Age?"
"Oh."
"Please excuse any confusion, it's been a while since I've had to do this. You see, every type of death gets a Reaper, and I have been a Reaper for this death for a long time. Many people have died... | Part 1.
"Ah yes, Reapers. The immortal race of sentient starships allegedly waiting in dark space. We have dismissed that claim, " scoffed Senator Pravatis.
A cynic by nature, he had always rejected everything unless he had seen it with his own eyes....and this preposterous claim was coming from the teethed orifices ... | 16 | 12 | 1,923 | 7,410 | starryeyedshooter | kamikazee786 | 2023-08-14T19:15:34 | 2023-08-14T13:13:29 | Comment on post 5405 | 6.034722 | 26,476 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nPart 1.\n\n\"Ah yes, Reapers. The immortal race of sentient starships allegedly waiting in dark space... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a dramatic and ambitious narrative set in a galactic senate, focusing on the struggle for human rights and the threat of an alien race called the Reapers. The story is rich in world-building, with detailed descriptions of the political landscape, the relationship between humans and other spe... | Story A presents a dramatic and ambitious narrative set in a galactic senate, focusing on the struggle for human rights and the threat of an alien race called the Reapers. The story is rich in world-building, with detailed descriptions of the political landscape, the relationship between humans and other species, and t... | B | true |
7,136 | "You opened the book, yet you scream in fear, did you not intend to summon me?"
The voice was more of an intrusive thought than actual sound, Kiri realized as the shock of another voice in her head quieted her own.
The creature before her was impossible. Like a hole in the air, shapes like faces pushing against the..... | The invitation hit my inbox at the right time for me to open it immediately. I waited to respond but only to show I was in control. I wasn't and five minutes ticked by slowly as I waited, writing my reply in my head, fuck yes I'll come and hold your hand while you die.
I didn't wait for another message as I got up and... | 28 | 12 | 1,918 | 7,403 | Mercerskye | Voyage_of_Roadkill | 2023-04-11T10:05:22 | 2023-04-11T06:33:40 | Comment on post 7136 | 3.528333 | 30,043 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nThe invitation hit my inbox at the right time for me to open it immediately. I waited to respond but ... | B | Reasoning: Story A is a detailed, atmospheric narrative that immerses the reader in a mysterious, almost gothic ritual involving an ancient tome and a dying man. The writing is rich with sensory details, painting a vivid picture of the setting and the characters’ emotions. The pacing is deliberate, building tension as ... | Story A is a detailed, atmospheric narrative that immerses the reader in a mysterious, almost gothic ritual involving an ancient tome and a dying man. The writing is rich with sensory details, painting a vivid picture of the setting and the characters’ emotions. The pacing is deliberate, building tension as the protago... | B | true |
12,828 | "Hey boy, this was your last run huh? Well that's ok. You've done everything well." I said through the tears in my eyes when I saw the bite mark.
"Too bad I wasn't there to protect you, huh? But I doubt I would have been able to do much, you're an idiot who always runs far ahead."
I had the reputation for executing a... | "Hey Killer, we got a few more over here," Stan called out to me from the other side of the lot.
It had been a few years since the outbreak started. Life had turned upside down in a matter of a few weeks. It seemed like one day I was playing catch with my kid in the backyard of our stereotypical suburban home, and th... | 206 | 19 | 972 | 6,490 | DeadKryptonite | BurgDweller | 2023-01-06T16:16:53 | 2023-01-06T16:04:45 | Comment on post 12828 | 0.202222 | 37,331 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n\"Hey boy, this was your last run huh? Well that's ok. You've done everything well.\" I said through ... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a brief, emotionally charged scene between a protagonist and a dog, culminating in the dog's transformation into a zombie. The narrative is concise, focusing on the protagonist's internal struggle and the tragic inevitability of the situation. The writing is direct and evocative, with a stro... | Story A presents a brief, emotionally charged scene between a protagonist and a dog, culminating in the dog's transformation into a zombie. The narrative is concise, focusing on the protagonist's internal struggle and the tragic inevitability of the situation. The writing is direct and evocative, with a strong emotiona... | A | true |
14,096 | "AI?"
𝙶𝙾𝙾𝙳 𝙴𝚅𝙴𝙽𝙸𝙽𝙶, 𝙼𝚁 𝚂𝙼𝙸𝚃𝙷.
"Is it safe to come out now?"
𝙴𝚅𝙴𝚁𝚈𝚃𝙷𝙸𝙽𝙶 𝙸𝚂 𝙸𝙽 𝙾𝚁𝙳𝙴𝚁. 𝚆𝙷𝙰𝚃 𝙸𝚂 𝚃𝙷𝙴 𝚂𝙾𝚄𝚁𝙲𝙴 𝙾𝙵 𝚈𝙾𝚄𝚁 𝙳𝙸𝚂𝚃𝚁𝙴𝚂𝚂?
"Wh- what? The- the radiation storm! You *just* blared the sirens."
𝙼𝚈 𝙻𝙾𝙶𝚂 𝙸𝙽𝙳𝙸𝙲𝙰𝚃𝙴 𝙽𝙾 𝚂𝚄𝙲𝙷 𝙸𝙽𝙲𝙸𝙳𝙴𝙽�... | So, you thought as you settle your mind in between hacking coughs. As someone estranged from their family, who wanted to travel, and who also didn't have a large budget, it made sense for you to book passage in the cheap seats, aka cryogenic freezing from departure to whenever *The Lima* got to its destination. It'd be... | 1,143 | 120 | 1,512 | 6,985 | SirPiecemaker | utecr | 2023-03-19T00:42:23 | 2023-03-19T00:18:25 | Comment on post 14096 | 0.399444 | 38,063 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nSo, you thought as you settle your mind in between hacking coughs. As someone estranged from their fa... | B | ��𝙴 𝙲𝙰𝙿𝚃𝙰𝙸𝙽."
The end.
The end."
The end."
The end."
The end."
The story ends with a darkly comic, meta ending, with the protagonist repeatedly saying "The end." | NA | NA | false |
30,807 | "Hey, ye, you're finally awake," spoke the old farmer. I found myself lying in a bag of hay, at the back of a drawn cart. My confusion was indescribable, but hey, at least I was comfortable. "Found you lyin' drunk near the river, so I decided I should help ye, fella."
Ah, so that's how I came into this world.... | As soon as you open your eyes, you know that something is different. The air is fresher, the colors more vibrant. You sit up and look around, taking in your surroundings. You seem to be in some sort of bedroom, but it's not like any bedroom you've ever seen before. The furniture is ornate and the walls are adorned with... | 56 | 13 | 7,386 | 1,899 | UrRomabooSpaceDemon3 | BornTroller | 2023-01-06T19:26:56 | 2023-01-06T18:55:56 | Comment on post 30807 | 0.516667 | 53,549 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n\"Hey, ye, you're finally awake,\" spoke the old farmer. I found myself lying in a bag of hay, at the... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a humorous and engaging narrative from the perspective of a protagonist who finds himself in a fantasy world after a drunken stumble. The story is rich in character voice, with witty internal monologue and a strong sense of humor. The protagonist’s reactions to the world’s rules and the absu... | Story A presents a humorous and engaging narrative from the perspective of a protagonist who finds himself in a fantasy world after a drunken stumble. The story is rich in character voice, with witty internal monologue and a strong sense of humor. The protagonist’s reactions to the world’s rules and the absurdity of hi... | A | true |
11,841 | These two species again? By the maker, Sholy loathed species #6495a and #6495b. Sure, they both had names, but as the Galactic Federation's Governess for this sub-sector, she had learned that the translatrons were more likely to spew an insult than to translate a species' name correctly. So, it was #6495a and #9495b... | Its my first time writing something like this, or really properly writing at all. Please do point out anything you'll think I can improve. Thanks!
The klarak armies were part of the Federation. They continued their expansionist ways, conscripting huge armies to invade non-federation planets, but they were part of t... | 41 | 23 | 7,232 | 1,737 | crash1979 | EstelTelcontar | 2023-03-07T06:22:31 | 2023-03-07T05:35:42 | Comment on post 11841 | 0.780278 | 36,226 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nThese two species again? By the maker, Sholy loathed species #6495a and #6495b. Sure, they both had... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a detailed, immersive science fiction scenario with a strong narrative voice and a clear sense of world-building. The protagonist, Sholy, is a well-drawn alien governor navigating bureaucratic and political intrigue within a galactic federation. The story is rich in detail, with creative ali... | Story A presents a detailed, immersive science fiction scenario with a strong narrative voice and a clear sense of world-building. The protagonist, Sholy, is a well-drawn alien governor navigating bureaucratic and political intrigue within a galactic federation. The story is rich in detail, with creative alien terminol... | A | true |
8,977 | The humans stared in surprise. "I'm sorry, perhaps we misunderstood - I thought that each sentient species got a single senator?"
The gelatinous alien wobbled. "Yesyes, quite right quite right. One senator one senator. Everyone gets one, everyone gets one."
The feathered, multi-eyed creature standing next to it nodde... | It all started when we saw them coming, galactic visitors unknown to mankind. The world froze. Many called for an attempt at destruction, while others took their own lives in a way to escape the potential coming torment. It was too late for many when the message “we come in peace” came. The population had already dropp... | 1,888 | 80 | 7,568 | 2,028 | I_Arman | DragonNestKing | 2023-02-27T17:26:48 | 2023-02-27T16:01:03 | Comment on post 8977 | 1.429167 | 32,621 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nIt all started when we saw them coming, galactic visitors unknown to mankind. The world froze. Many c... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a sweeping, almost mythic narrative of humanity's encounter with galactic visitors. The story is told in a broad, almost historical style, focusing on the global impact of the alien arrival and the subsequent formation of a galactic federation. The narrative is imaginative, with the idea of ... | Story A presents a sweeping, almost mythic narrative of humanity's encounter with galactic visitors. The story is told in a broad, almost historical style, focusing on the global impact of the alien arrival and the subsequent formation of a galactic federation. The narrative is imaginative, with the idea of different s... | B | true |
25,128 | "I'm a reader first, you see." It's how I ended my talks I gave to local libraries, generally when I was donating a few copies of my latest in the series of Goddess of Lune books. Somehow, I had managed to take a story I wrote on a lark to getting published, to a series that was massively popular among disaffected Eu... | “Oh. You again.”
I sighed and pressed a red button conveniently installed on the wall. “I will eternally regret giving you the IDTS, I swear.”
“IDTH.” She corrected me.
I looked at the Godess with raised eyebrows. “I named it, it’s the IDTS.”
She shrugged. “Fair. Are you going to let in now, or…”
The button came o... | 26 | 15 | 6,146 | 609 | Snowdog1967 | Nomyad777 | 2023-10-20T16:43:37 | 2023-10-20T13:34:37 | Comment on post 25128 | 3.15 | 52,428 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n“Oh. You again.”\n\nI sighed and pressed a red button conveniently installed on the wall. “I will ete... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a clever, metafictional scenario involving a writer and a goddess-like character who is trapped in a time loop, resetting the universe with each failed attempt to let her in. The dialogue is snappy and witty, with a dry sense of humor that comes through in the banter between the protagonist ... | Story A presents a clever, metafictional scenario involving a writer and a goddess-like character who is trapped in a time loop, resetting the universe with each failed attempt to let her in. The dialogue is snappy and witty, with a dry sense of humor that comes through in the banter between the protagonist and the god... | A | false |
18,622 | Laughter filled the air as the group kids prepared to play their new favorite game “Smear the zombie”, a new take on the old school yard game “Smear the queer.” In this version the one who carried the ball had to run full force through the zombie they had wrangled and do as much damage as possible, all the other kids h... | When the news spread about a man and his family returning from Kenya being quarantined most people didn't really think anything of it. It was just another report that was left on the television, just to drowned out the sound of silence for most of us. Most families are too busy with the usual of day to day life and wor... | 45 | 12 | 2,250 | 7,600 | _Anime_amateur_ | DyslexicTriesWriting | 2024-03-11T04:45:29 | 2024-03-11T02:37:11 | Comment on post 18622 | 2.138333 | 45,683 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nLaughter filled the air as the group kids prepared to play their new favorite game “Smear the zombie”... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a creative and darkly humorous take on the zombie apocalypse, reimagining the classic "Smear the Zombie" game as a playground activity in a world where zombies are a mundane part of life. The story is lively, with a strong sense of voice and a clear narrative arc. The protagonist, Kyle, is g... | Story A presents a creative and darkly humorous take on the zombie apocalypse, reimagining the classic "Smear the Zombie" game as a playground activity in a world where zombies are a mundane part of life. The story is lively, with a strong sense of voice and a clear narrative arc. The protagonist, Kyle, is given a uniq... | A | true |
20,720 | “Where the hell did that come from? Wait, where did Drew go?”
The other three turned around at Samantha’s questions to look where Drew had been. He knew they could not see his smile, because he also knew he no longer had a face. His entire awareness of self had transformed so quickly that he could barely recall exactl... | The five of us laid, some collapsed, on the hill of the graveyard. The smell of singed grass was still coating the air as we laughed and picked bone fragments out of our hair.
"We actually did it." Eric said, a disbeliving grin forming on his face. Back home he was the star of the college football who carried them to ... | 204 | 46 | 1,889 | 7,215 | ANewFireEachDayy | DoomGloomAngst | 2023-02-27T07:16:42 | 2023-02-27T05:51:50 | Comment on post 20720 | 1.414444 | 48,358 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n“Where the hell did that come from? Wait, where did Drew go?”\n\nThe other three turned around at Sam... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a high-energy, imaginative scenario where a group of friends are transformed by a god into their chosen forms for a quest. The writing is brisk, with a focus on action and humor, particularly in the reveal of Drew’s transformation into a Transformer. The dialogue is snappy and the pacing is ... | Story A presents a high-energy, imaginative scenario where a group of friends are transformed by a god into their chosen forms for a quest. The writing is brisk, with a focus on action and humor, particularly in the reveal of Drew’s transformation into a Transformer. The dialogue is snappy and the pacing is tight, keep... | A | true |
11,271 | "I'm sure there's a good explanation." David said
"What possible explanation could there be?" Maya asked looking around. Everyone who had shown up was whispering amongst themselves. All of them talking about the exact same thing.
Miss. Winklebottom, a woman who had been a rock for the community, was buried si... | Everybody liked farmer John. A loving husband, dutiful father, and animal lover. He has went beyond the veil, leaving his wife Nelly, 10 of their children, many friendships that have lasted decades, 3 loyal hounds, a couple of donkeys, a motley assortment of all kinds of farm animals and his 200 acre estate. But when w... | 87 | 45 | 6,469 | 1,103 | BryanTheFool | RogalDornAteMyPussy | 2023-10-08T05:50:53 | 2023-10-08T03:28:59 | Comment on post 11271 | 2.365 | 35,581 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nEverybody liked farmer John. A loving husband, dutiful father, and animal lover. He has went beyond t... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a brief, atmospheric vignette about Farmer John, whose death is marked by an unsettling, almost supernatural phenomenon: his grave is overgrown with brambles, and rumors of a mysterious young man linger. The story is concise, with a strong sense of place and a subtle, eerie tone. The writing... | Story A presents a brief, atmospheric vignette about Farmer John, whose death is marked by an unsettling, almost supernatural phenomenon: his grave is overgrown with brambles, and rumors of a mysterious young man linger. The story is concise, with a strong sense of place and a subtle, eerie tone. The writing is evocati... | A | false |
5,385 | As we shot down the last of the zombies that surrounded our office, Alex asked me if I was leveling up soon.
I reminded him again this isn't some game, but a real zombie apocalypse, but Alex cut me off to ask how much XP I still needed.
After a little back-and-forth arguing over non-existent XP, we went to the shared... | I knew Cristobal and Brandon before everything went topsy-turvy. As an introvert, I mostly kept to myself, but they seemed like nice enough guys. I never bothered to try and chat with them or go for drinks after work or anything like that. I was just worried about doing my job well and going home at the end of the day.... | 664 | 219 | 1,634 | 6,783 | Tregonial | a15minutestory | 2023-05-03T15:31:38 | 2023-05-03T13:53:37 | Comment on post 5385 | 1.633611 | 26,428 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nI knew Cristobal and Brandon before everything went topsy-turvy. As an introvert, I mostly kept to my... | B | Reasoning: Story A is a creative and immersive narrative that blends the world of Pokémon with a post-apocalyptic setting. The writing is detailed, with a strong sense of atmosphere and character development. The protagonist is relatable, and the interactions with Cristobal and Brandon are engaging and believable. The ... | Story A is a creative and immersive narrative that blends the world of Pokémon with a post-apocalyptic setting. The writing is detailed, with a strong sense of atmosphere and character development. The protagonist is relatable, and the interactions with Cristobal and Brandon are engaging and believable. The story build... | A | false |
23,212 | Meaningless discrimination never goes away, it only changes its target. In the past it was between genders, races, sexualities, classes, etc. Nowadays discrimination happen between abilities that are deemed “cool and/or useful” by society and those that aren’t. “Shapeshifters/Invisibilities are all creeps” “Illusionist... | You'd think talking to animals would be a pretty amazing power right? Well it would be but the only animals I can talk to happen to be ants. Bugs that most people will squish without a second thought.
It made me such a big laughing stock in the superhero community that they didnt even allow me to have a superhero name... | 57 | 32 | 6,258 | 1,040 | pnam0204 | xEsmeeH | 2024-07-29T21:44:58 | 2024-07-29T18:22:02 | Comment on post 23212 | 3.382222 | 50,829 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nMeaningless discrimination never goes away, it only changes its target. In the past it was between ge... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a creative and nuanced take on the "useless superpower" trope, focusing on the protagonist's experience with the ability to make things slippery. The narrative explores themes of discrimination, social hierarchy, and the consequences of being marginalized. The story is detailed, with a clear... | Story A presents a creative and nuanced take on the "useless superpower" trope, focusing on the protagonist's experience with the ability to make things slippery. The narrative explores themes of discrimination, social hierarchy, and the consequences of being marginalized. The story is detailed, with a clear arc from t... | A | true |
16,948 | It was anguish at first. The betrayal. Feeling the sting of the contempt from your twin, your other half, the thing you loved and trusted without reservation, without hesitation, completely and utterly. She thought so little of you now. She had grown arrogant and shortsighted off the exultations of the mortals. No more... | "Well hello my dear sister Whitey, to what I owe you the pleasure of this visit?"
"Stop with your pleasantries my brother Blackie, you know what I want. Let's go back to Gaea. Gaea needs you."
Blackie smiled and said, "oh no, I can't, I am being banished here. Did you forget? You and your chosen heroes banished me he... | 97 | 12 | 7,365 | 2,209 | Kuraito | tnth89 | 2023-04-14T10:25:52 | 2023-04-14T10:25:12 | Comment on post 16948 | 0.011111 | 43,012 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nIt was anguish at first. The betrayal. Feeling the sting of the contempt from your twin, your other h... | A | Reasoning: Story A is a richly atmospheric, emotionally charged narrative told from the perspective of a god who has been cast aside by his twin sister. The writing is evocative, with strong imagery and a clear sense of the god's pain and isolation. The dialogue is natural and the emotional stakes are high, as the god ... | Story A is a richly atmospheric, emotionally charged narrative told from the perspective of a god who has been cast aside by his twin sister. The writing is evocative, with strong imagery and a clear sense of the god's pain and isolation. The dialogue is natural and the emotional stakes are high, as the god struggles w... | A | true |
33,829 | “I think there’s been a mistake. Maybe you’re new here. Can you tell the receptionist that you have Heather Martinson in examination? Or you could just ask Mil’kan’it if she’s here.”
The insectoid alien stared at me for a long moment. It was funny how a look of stunned confusion was so often similar across species. Al... | "Are you getting at least 12 mini cycles of temporary hibernation per planetary macro cycle?" The Praying Mantis being overseeing the Greys running the medical devices (Thankfully, my insurance didn't cover the Probe-U-Lator), the incredibly unhelpful Nordic receptionist, and the Reptilian who was hissing something unc... | 333 | 64 | 6,042 | 839 | karenvideoeditor | RandomModder05 | 2024-01-07T01:30:49 | 2024-01-07T00:06:55 | Comment on post 33829 | 1.398333 | 54,024 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n“I think there’s been a mistake. Maybe you’re new here. Can you tell the receptionist that you have H... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a humorous and engaging narrative from the perspective of a human patient undergoing medical examinations aboard an alien spacecraft. The story is rich in character development, with Heather’s dry wit and the aliens’ bemused reactions providing a strong sense of voice and world-building. The... | Story A presents a humorous and engaging narrative from the perspective of a human patient undergoing medical examinations aboard an alien spacecraft. The story is rich in character development, with Heather’s dry wit and the aliens’ bemused reactions providing a strong sense of voice and world-building. The dialogue i... | A | true |
9,720 | Naomi was just putting the tea plates away when the knock came at the door. “Bother” she thought as she quickly closed the cupboard and went over to greet her visitor.
“Yes? What do you want?” she asked the old man at the door who was struggling to speak. "Well? What is it? Lumbago? Sciatica? Knee Joints? For God's s... | I've seen this exact prompt on Instagram. For it, I created this:
https://www.deviantart.com/jonenat/art/Tilly-n-Tonk-961841982 (part AI; part me editing)
...and wrote this:
I've had a few relationships in the past. I've even loved a few people. But, I've only ever wanted to cuddle with a cute girl; I've never actua... | 22 | 11 | 1,795 | 6,774 | PigHillJimster | Pokerfakes | 2023-05-10T13:08:24 | 2023-05-10T12:37:13 | Comment on post 9720 | 0.519722 | 33,659 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nI've seen this exact prompt on Instagram. For it, I created this:\n\nhttps://www.deviantart.com/jonen... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a humorous and imaginative take on the prompt, blending rural folklore with modern sensibilities and a touch of magical realism. The narrator’s voice is distinct, self-deprecating, and engaging, with a clear sense of personality and world-building. The story is rich in detail, from the cowpa... | Story A presents a humorous and imaginative take on the prompt, blending rural folklore with modern sensibilities and a touch of magical realism. The narrator’s voice is distinct, self-deprecating, and engaging, with a clear sense of personality and world-building. The story is rich in detail, from the cowpath to the m... | A | false |
16,819 | Tentacled Mass was holding something which glowed a bit differently than the usual something. No food this time, no treats, not frilly little outfits or new toys or anyhthing, just the glowing device, matte black along one side, flattish. A bit like a cell phone, but about 3 feet long and only a few inches across. medi... | \- - - Day of abduction.
Was on my way home from school when the sky darkened for a moment, then a fog came about me. This was during a summer's day where the weather should be sunny and warm.
Next thing? Pitch black. Wasn't sure if I lost consciousness or...
Then I check myself and find that I'm not pitch black. I'... | 50 | 29 | 996 | 6,078 | None | OSadorn | 2023-12-29T10:53:02 | 2023-12-29T04:44:33 | Comment on post 16819 | 6.141389 | 42,862 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n\\- - - Day of abduction.\n\nWas on my way home from school when the sky darkened for a moment, then ... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a first-person narrative of a human abducted by aliens, blending elements of science fiction, humor, and slice-of-life. The writing is quirky, with a conversational tone and a focus on the protagonist's confusion, curiosity, and attempts to adapt to the alien environment. The story is rich i... | Story A presents a first-person narrative of a human abducted by aliens, blending elements of science fiction, humor, and slice-of-life. The writing is quirky, with a conversational tone and a focus on the protagonist's confusion, curiosity, and attempts to adapt to the alien environment. The story is rich in detail, w... | B | true |
23,844 | Eric was a resource manager for a Fortune 500 company not even fifteen days ago. Now, he’s a monster with four bug eyes, antennae, and a thorax with humanoid arms and legs, who, because he has a mouth, opposable thumbs, and can squirt ink from his abdomen, has to help in sorting out what can or can’t be allowed in this... | It is opening night.
In the center of the fair a dragon cranes his long neck high above the rides, lets moonlight slide over his scales like a jug of milk being poured. Master, a humanoid bug in top hat and red waistcoat, standing by the dragon’s clawed feet, laughs and slaps his six hands together and says, “Let ther... | 127 | 61 | 2,195 | 7,303 | None | Rupertfroggington | 2023-01-31T16:52:16 | 2023-01-31T15:06:03 | Comment on post 23844 | 1.770278 | 51,423 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nIt is opening night.\n\nIn the center of the fair a dragon cranes his long neck high above the rides,... | B | Reasoning: Story A is a vividly imagined, atmospheric tale set in a fantastical traveling fair, featuring a cast of unusual characters—vampires, dragons, snails, and a master of ceremonies. The writing is evocative, with strong sensory details and a clear sense of place. The narrative follows Beatrice, a vampire, as sh... | Story A is a vividly imagined, atmospheric tale set in a fantastical traveling fair, featuring a cast of unusual characters—vampires, dragons, snails, and a master of ceremonies. The writing is evocative, with strong sensory details and a clear sense of place. The narrative follows Beatrice, a vampire, as she navigates... | A | false |
6,628 | “That’s all you need, fair wages, good benefits, with reasonable deadlines and working conditions,” Brendan the HR consultant beamed as he presented his proposal to his prospective clients.
Alfred furrowed his brows, eyes scanning through the pages. “This all sounds good on paper, but various people come with differen... | There was an earth-shattering noise that came with Them when They crashed onto our planet. The Royals and Academies sent out their armies to clash in the fields. But They had no armies.
Bathed in the noise of the wind whistling through Their asteroids' strange architecture, They were undefeatable. They expanded their t... | 101 | 15 | 5,736 | 726 | Tregonial | indignant_dude | 2023-05-01T06:53:22 | 2023-05-01T03:02:23 | Comment on post 6628 | 3.849722 | 29,126 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n“That’s all you need, fair wages, good benefits, with reasonable deadlines and working conditions,” B... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a humorous and imaginative scenario in which an eldritch god, Elvari, attempts to adapt to modern HR practices. The dialogue is witty and the interplay between Elvari, Alfred, and Brendan is lively and engaging. The story cleverly blends the absurdity of eldritch powers with the mundanity of... | Story A presents a humorous and imaginative scenario in which an eldritch god, Elvari, attempts to adapt to modern HR practices. The dialogue is witty and the interplay between Elvari, Alfred, and Brendan is lively and engaging. The story cleverly blends the absurdity of eldritch powers with the mundanity of corporate ... | A | true |
24,895 | "The Great Shift"
They got the name from a genre of erotic stories involving everyone spontaneously switching biomedical sex. The name was an internet meme and completely ironic at first, but it got popular and stuck.
No one has an exact date for when it happened. Sometime in Summer 2024. It may not have been instant... | Pandemonium. It was chaos when morning rolled round the world. Once men who were on the frontlines suddenly found themselves unable to fit properly into their gear and unable to lift their weapons right. Ceasefires were called as the once-men tried to sort things out but were confounded by their lack of their once inti... | 57 | 15 | 6,062 | 1,075 | braindeadcoyote | kiaeej | 2024-04-14T19:56:20 | 2024-04-14T12:34:47 | Comment on post 24895 | 7.359167 | 52,271 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nPandemonium. It was chaos when morning rolled round the world. Once men who were on the frontlines su... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a surreal, almost dreamlike scenario where the world suddenly and inexplicably changes gender, with men and women switching places overnight. The narrative is concise and imaginative, focusing on the immediate, chaotic consequences: soldiers unable to fit into their gear, expectant mothers h... | Story A presents a surreal, almost dreamlike scenario where the world suddenly and inexplicably changes gender, with men and women switching places overnight. The narrative is concise and imaginative, focusing on the immediate, chaotic consequences: soldiers unable to fit into their gear, expectant mothers horrified by... | B | true |
10,678 | “Yes, dear. I’m sure there’s a monster under your bed. Let daddy recite his monster go away spell. Ready?” Hank got onto his knees, throwing the overhanging blanket over the bed. As the blanket flap flew up, he came face to face with the monster underneath. The monster curled into a ball, clutching Annie’s toy teddy be... | Okay.
If it weren't the fact that this was my first home, thus being bound to it emotionally.
If it weren't for the fact that I still wonder how the hell was I able to actually buy a house...as in the current economy, I would struggle to put down a down-payment.
I would move, so, so far away.
Okay.
Enough, no... | 101 | 26 | 7,081 | 2,088 | sadnesslaughs | TheWanderingBook | 2025-01-06T15:00:10 | 2025-01-06T14:20:06 | Comment on post 10678 | 0.667778 | 34,898 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nOkay. \nIf it weren't the fact that this was my first home, thus being bound to it emotionally. \nI... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a first-person narrative with a strong, conversational voice. The protagonist’s emotional state is clear, and the story effectively blends humor, anxiety, and a touch of the supernatural. The twist—that the monster is afraid of the protagonist—adds a layer of irony and emotional complexity. ... | Story A presents a first-person narrative with a strong, conversational voice. The protagonist’s emotional state is clear, and the story effectively blends humor, anxiety, and a touch of the supernatural. The twist—that the monster is afraid of the protagonist—adds a layer of irony and emotional complexity. The writing... | A | false |
40,440 | There is a road somewhere in North Dakota that is straighter than all the others in the county. Cooper Townsend was one of the only locals who used it. For everyone else, the interstate was more efficient for travel between the only two points it connected, and because along it there was not a single private farm, nor ... | A hundred years ago everyone knew what would happen if the light ever changed, but slowly, we forgot. We forgot about the sheltering tunnels. At first no one realized, it had been green for so long that no one even noticed it changed, then Jessie asked about it when she stopped for gas on her way home. Our town was sma... | 29 | 11 | 6,635 | 1,559 | velabas | WeCouldDriveAllNight | 2023-12-21T23:32:29 | 2023-12-21T21:23:49 | Comment on post 40440 | 2.144444 | 54,934 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nThere is a road somewhere in North Dakota that is straighter than all the others in the county. Coope... | A | Reasoning: Story A is a well-crafted narrative that immerses the reader in a small, rural setting with a mysterious, almost supernatural traffic light. The writing is atmospheric, with strong sensory details and a clear sense of place. The story builds tension effectively, especially during the sudden, graphic accident... | Story A is a well-crafted narrative that immerses the reader in a small, rural setting with a mysterious, almost supernatural traffic light. The writing is atmospheric, with strong sensory details and a clear sense of place. The story builds tension effectively, especially during the sudden, graphic accident involving ... | A | true |
22,309 | I am the youngest person in my town.
Hell, I might be the youngest person in the entire world. Feels a bit weird, to be honest, seeing how I don't even remember being the youngest in my own family. Sarah was born when I had just turned two, so life without her didn't really exist for me - my little sister was always ... | We called them the "Lost Generation". A whole cohort of children from newborns to the earliest teenagers, vanished by some extraterrestrial race. First was the grief, and the horror; then came the pure, white-hot rage. Capitalism and religion crumbled under the weight of collective trauma, the United Nations growing in... | 323 | 163 | 7,005 | 2,006 | Rein_Deilerd | NicktheSlick130 | 2024-09-04T13:02:34 | 2024-09-04T13:01:14 | Comment on post 22309 | 0.022222 | 49,982 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nI am the youngest person in my town. \n\nHell, I might be the youngest person in the entire world. Fe... | A | Reasoning: Story A is a first-person narrative that immerses the reader in the emotional aftermath of a mass kidnapping of children. The voice is conversational, relatable, and laced with dark humor, which helps ground the reader in the protagonist's perspective. The story builds tension through specific details—like t... | Story A is a first-person narrative that immerses the reader in the emotional aftermath of a mass kidnapping of children. The voice is conversational, relatable, and laced with dark humor, which helps ground the reader in the protagonist's perspective. The story builds tension through specific details—like the missing ... | A | true |
978 | Ryan Crane didn’t bring work home with him. No, Ryan brought his home to work with him. What little time he spent with his children took place in his drab office; what little intimate time he fit in with his wife was less candle-lit and more fluorescent-flickered in his small, beige, windowless cell. To top it all off,... | I didn't really think anything about the joke but my eyes nearly popped out of my head when I saw the figures. It wasn't like we were the next Amazon, but we had a chance again.
"It was actually really easy." Candy giggled in her put-on voice then switched her voice to a very business like tone. "The strategy is all ... | 226 | 133 | 5,847 | 851 | None | natep1098 | 2023-01-26T20:47:49 | 2023-01-26T19:56:22 | Comment on post 978 | 0.8575 | 8,286 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nRyan Crane didn’t bring work home with him. No, Ryan brought his home to work with him. What little t... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a detailed, character-driven narrative about Ryan Crane, a struggling entrepreneur whose life is marked by failure, neglect, and a desperate search for meaning and connection. The story is rich in description, with vivid imagery and a clear emotional arc. It explores themes of regret, the co... | Story A presents a detailed, character-driven narrative about Ryan Crane, a struggling entrepreneur whose life is marked by failure, neglect, and a desperate search for meaning and connection. The story is rich in description, with vivid imagery and a clear emotional arc. It explores themes of regret, the commodificati... | A | true |
3,127 | Jason sighed contentedly, as he crouched before the old field stone hearth, and placed another log on the fire. Spending the long weekend with Sonja at his grandparents old cabin had been exactly what he needed. The storm had knocked out the landlines, and made the already spotty cellular coverage practically non-exist... | "...fine. but I'm not making you food. Too worried I'll poison you by accident, you fuckin delicate flower you." I put him near enough to the fire that he'll warm up, hand him a slice of untoasted bread and some mustard, and go back to making my dollar store burrito. When I've come back to the study to check up on him,... | 50 | 21 | 5,818 | 781 | SilasCrane | tlof19 | 2023-04-07T03:27:40 | 2023-04-07T01:21:57 | Comment on post 3127 | 2.095278 | 20,620 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n\"...fine. but I'm not making you food. Too worried I'll poison you by accident, you fuckin delicate ... | B | Reasoning: Story A is a brief, darkly humorous vignette that plays with the trope of a haunted house, but with a twist: the "haunted" person is not a ghost, but a person in need of help, and the narrator is a sardonic caretaker. The writing is punchy, with a strong voice and a dry sense of humor. The story is concise, ... | Story A is a brief, darkly humorous vignette that plays with the trope of a haunted house, but with a twist: the "haunted" person is not a ghost, but a person in need of help, and the narrator is a sardonic caretaker. The writing is punchy, with a strong voice and a dry sense of humor. The story is concise, and the end... | B | true |
15,377 | “People often make the mistake of thinking us villains are lawless. That isn’t true. We have laws, just ones governed by our own discretions. Morally grey laws, but laws none the less. I thought a dog like you would be able to see those grey tones.” Marvis said, the villain’s voice drifting around Vlad Stake, who was c... | "Ugh, amateur. What's the point of monologuing after they're dead?"
"Excuse me, I'm...what?!" The recently murdered supers rise up and jump him with no concern for his struggles to strike them down again, as their bodies restore themselves with cold flame faster than they can be cut down.
"I don't care who you are. A... | 427 | 133 | 6,330 | 1,256 | sadnesslaughs | Stotter | 2024-09-23T11:31:07 | 2024-09-23T08:33:42 | Comment on post 15377 | 2.956944 | 40,400 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n\"Ugh, amateur. What's the point of monologuing after they're dead?\"\n\n\"Excuse me, I'm...what?!\" ... | B | Reasoning: Story A is a fast-paced, dialogue-driven scene that leans heavily into genre-savvy banter and meta-commentary. The characters are quick to establish their roles—Edgelord, the necromancer, and the new villain—and the tone is irreverent and self-aware. The writing is brisk, with a focus on snappy exchanges and... | Story A is a fast-paced, dialogue-driven scene that leans heavily into genre-savvy banter and meta-commentary. The characters are quick to establish their roles—Edgelord, the necromancer, and the new villain—and the tone is irreverent and self-aware. The writing is brisk, with a focus on snappy exchanges and a sense of... | B | true |
3,904 | Sarah held the receiver away from her ear and stared at it, brows furrowed, as if the voice on the other end had asked her to begin dancing the Macarena while reciting the ABCs in reverse order. Finally, she spoke. "What?"
"Didn't you hear me?" The voice asked, now sounding slightly annoyed. "I said press the button, ... | \[Back up. Planned.\]
"And...," Jane stood at her desk and gave a tall stretch as she yawned. She finished stretching right as the clock turned 8:00. She reached down and pressed a key on the keyboard. "...I'm on duty," She immediately spun around and headed to the kitchen.
The kitchen was mostly an empty brea... | 285 | 170 | 1,766 | 6,689 | birdlawschool | HSerrata | 2023-01-02T19:28:29 | 2023-01-02T17:24:49 | Comment on post 3904 | 2.061111 | 22,582 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nSarah held the receiver away from her ear and stared at it, brows furrowed, as if the voice on the ot... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a witty, dryly humorous take on the classic "press the button" scenario. The protagonist, Sarah, is a sardonic office worker who responds to a high-stakes emergency with a mix of apathy and sarcasm. The dialogue is sharp and the pacing brisk, with a clear comedic tone throughout. The story's... | Story A presents a witty, dryly humorous take on the classic "press the button" scenario. The protagonist, Sarah, is a sardonic office worker who responds to a high-stakes emergency with a mix of apathy and sarcasm. The dialogue is sharp and the pacing brisk, with a clear comedic tone throughout. The story's strength l... | A | true |
3,987 | I sat on the old bed in my cell, well, less of a cell and more of an old bedroom somewhere, a thick locked door and the lack of windows was the only thing slightly abnormal. It was small and cramped, but I was allowed to sleep, I was fed regularly and Lord Volt even gave me a couple of books to read. I heard footsteps ... | They're arguing again. One of them - there are at least four, although they talk about someone who is involved but has never been here, presumably the leader or mastermind - is convinced you're never coming, Dad. They think Mom wrote me off and you're just going along with it, which is... pretty emasculating, honestly.... | 881 | 358 | 2,487 | 7,311 | FoxWithAMask | thepush | 2023-06-15T20:04:01 | 2023-06-15T16:15:54 | Comment on post 3987 | 3.801944 | 22,788 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nThey're arguing again. One of them - there are at least four, although they talk about someone who is... | B | Reasoning: Story A is a raw, intense, and emotionally charged narrative told from the perspective of a powerless teenager being held captive by a group of villains. The writing is vivid, with strong voice and a palpable sense of fear, frustration, and desperation. The internal monologue is sharp, laced with sarcasm and... | Story A is a raw, intense, and emotionally charged narrative told from the perspective of a powerless teenager being held captive by a group of villains. The writing is vivid, with strong voice and a palpable sense of fear, frustration, and desperation. The internal monologue is sharp, laced with sarcasm and anger, whi... | A | false |
4,725 | wait, why did it summon a human??"
I glanced at the Magic circle on the stone floor. The elves, who had great magical capacity were now sprawled on the ground, exhausted. According to the books, the more powerful the hero was, the more magic it was needed to summon them. And since we expended a great amount of it, we ... | I turned over in my bed that felt incredibly hard for some reason. I knew my alarm was going to go off at any moment meaning I would have to get up for my super early shift at work. I snuggled deeper into my pillow, cozy in my oversized cat onesie. If anyone saw me in this it would be super embarrassing.
The hood of ... | 26 | 11 | 2,254 | 7,127 | Jesuro_kun | Iconfan82 | 2024-10-24T22:47:55 | 2024-10-24T17:13:12 | Comment on post 4725 | 5.578611 | 24,642 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nwait, why did it summon a human??\"\n\nI glanced at the Magic circle on the stone floor. The elves, w... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a humorous and lighthearted take on the classic fantasy summoning trope. The narrative is brisk, with a focus on dialogue and comedic misunderstandings between the elves, dwarves, and the human protagonist, Reager. The story leans into the absurdity of a human being summoned by magical means... | Story A presents a humorous and lighthearted take on the classic fantasy summoning trope. The narrative is brisk, with a focus on dialogue and comedic misunderstandings between the elves, dwarves, and the human protagonist, Reager. The story leans into the absurdity of a human being summoned by magical means, and the h... | A | true |
4,783 | Elgar knew the family would soon enter his bare, but warm office. The weeping from the visitation room dwindling down always meant they were almost done. Four hundred and seventy three. That was how many children Elgar brought back to life, just to hear the sobs of their parents when they inevitably passed away aga... | Miranda nervously fidgeted at the sleeve of her long coat. It was her first day, she was waiting in a room with a large table and several chairs as office halogen lights hummed away. Smoothing the cloth over and over is something she's done often in school to the point it started to fray. The new patch sown on her sho... | 86 | 31 | 2,351 | 7,227 | None | TacoMagic | 2023-01-23T22:40:19 | 2023-01-23T20:25:08 | Comment on post 4783 | 2.253056 | 24,895 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n Elgar knew the family would soon enter his bare, but warm office. The weeping from the visitation... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a somber, emotionally resonant narrative centered on Elgar, a necromancer who has spent decades resurrecting children for grieving parents. The story is grounded in a clear, evocative setting and explores themes of grief, sacrifice, and the cost of resurrection. The writing is concise and fo... | Story A presents a somber, emotionally resonant narrative centered on Elgar, a necromancer who has spent decades resurrecting children for grieving parents. The story is grounded in a clear, evocative setting and explores themes of grief, sacrifice, and the cost of resurrection. The writing is concise and focused, with... | A | true |
16,037 | I sigh, sliding out of the cab with practiced ease. The Amazon was shaking, pale and mostly still in shock from her actions. She didn't even register my scooping the hero into a bodybag, plopping it into the trunk, and escorting her into the cab. Amazon returned after i took Nike's phone from her, the seat belt restrai... | They went by Hermes, inspired by Greek mythology, everybody in the business knew them. Hermes would always be there for a hero, no matter the time or day, they were always there. Nobody knew where they came from, and nobody knew their true identity, they just appeared. No civilian or villain knew about them, they were... | 31 | 15 | 1,164 | 6,106 | Mr_Nobody_14 | False-Examination404 | 2023-04-28T02:54:03 | 2023-04-28T02:44:13 | Comment on post 16037 | 0.163889 | 41,855 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n\tThey went by Hermes, inspired by Greek mythology, everybody in the business knew them. Hermes would... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a well-developed narrative with a clear structure, character development, and emotional stakes. The story introduces Hermes as a mysterious, mythologically inspired cab driver who is deeply involved in the lives of superheroes. The dialogue is natural and helps build the relationship between... | Story A presents a well-developed narrative with a clear structure, character development, and emotional stakes. The story introduces Hermes as a mysterious, mythologically inspired cab driver who is deeply involved in the lives of superheroes. The dialogue is natural and helps build the relationship between Hermes and... | A | false |
18,981 | "I couldn't deal with the shame. Every holiday, nothing but "Oh Xavier, why do you embarrass yourself like those gaudy 'heroes'?" "Why don't you follow the family business? We do what must be done."
Well Ma, I'm sorry I want to have some money. A fucking *life.* Yeah, I get it. Without us, the heroes wouldn't have any... | Darkness shrouds the Slayer. She stalks slowly. On her right, she sees tattered clothes, ripped blankets, dirty robes, and other ornate garnets. More importantly, she sees charcoal black skulls in front of her left side. Holding her lantern, she dims the light.
“Someone else is here,” she thinks to herself. The burnt ... | 63 | 11 | 1,782 | 6,706 | XandertheWriter | Plebe-Uchiha | 2023-11-11T08:48:55 | 2023-07-14T20:14:51 | Comment on post 18981 | 2,868.567778 | 45,997 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nDarkness shrouds the Slayer. She stalks slowly. On her right, she sees tattered clothes, ripped blank... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a classic fantasy adventure with a slayer, a dragon, and a village in need of a hero. The narrative is straightforward, following Adissa as she prepares for a confrontation, only to discover that the "dragon" is a hatchling and the real threat is the villagers' inability to pay the dragon's ... | Story A presents a classic fantasy adventure with a slayer, a dragon, and a village in need of a hero. The narrative is straightforward, following Adissa as she prepares for a confrontation, only to discover that the "dragon" is a hatchling and the real threat is the villagers' inability to pay the dragon's demands. Th... | B | true |
22,550 | "You mean Magnus of course. My eldest." The king said incredulously to the Dragon Queen.
The tall, imposing women in black and red shook her head adamantly. "I meant Maximus. I accepted your offer and you said I could choose any of your sons. I pick Maximus."
The king stammered for several moments, trying to find wor... | King Thain had been under rather extreme duress over the past decade. His wife had been taken from him giving birth to their third child and had left the lonely king with three young princesses to raise to rule the kingdom which had already been failing under the pressure of it's neighbours.
Alice, Thain's eldest dau... | 72 | 52 | 2,064 | 6,915 | Kuraito | The_Wendigo_Woods | 2023-05-22T06:39:32 | 2023-05-22T04:58:06 | Comment on post 22550 | 1.690556 | 50,315 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n\"You mean Magnus of course. My eldest.\" The king said incredulously to the Dragon Queen.\n\nThe tal... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a witty and engaging exchange between a king and the Dragon Queen, centering on the king's surprise at being asked to marry his youngest son, Maximus, to the Dragon Queen. The dialogue is sharp, humorous, and well-paced, with the Dragon Queen's exasperation and the king's bewilderment provid... | Story A presents a witty and engaging exchange between a king and the Dragon Queen, centering on the king's surprise at being asked to marry his youngest son, Maximus, to the Dragon Queen. The dialogue is sharp, humorous, and well-paced, with the Dragon Queen's exasperation and the king's bewilderment providing a stron... | A | true |
30,618 | “My wife left me,” his voice was rough and on the verge of cracking. I hadn’t seen him like this in several years.
Golden Boy as I called him, Sunbeam as the public knew him wasn’t the one standing before me. It was Aleksander, Alek.
Sympathy ran through me at the sight of the Hero. My former best friend, ex-lover, ... | "My wife left me."
"I know." I said, keeping my voice very even. I looked at the un-vacuumed carpet, the stains on the wallpaper. "Frankly I expected you to manage better."
"Better? Do you know how hard IT IS TO LOOK AFTER A BABY?" His shout was drowned out by a wail, and he looked down in horror. I raised an eyebrow... | 27 | 17 | 3,159 | 8,000 | AmoldineShepard | GrouchySituation | 2023-11-12T22:13:33 | 2023-11-12T21:37:59 | Comment on post 30618 | 0.592778 | 53,496 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n\"My wife left me.\"\n\n\"I know.\" I said, keeping my voice very even. I looked at the un-vacuumed c... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a darkly comic and sharply written confrontation between a villain and a superhero, both of whom are revealed to be deeply flawed and emotionally vulnerable. The narrative is rich in detail, with vivid descriptions of the messy, chaotic domestic scene and the psychological games played betwe... | Story A presents a darkly comic and sharply written confrontation between a villain and a superhero, both of whom are revealed to be deeply flawed and emotionally vulnerable. The narrative is rich in detail, with vivid descriptions of the messy, chaotic domestic scene and the psychological games played between the two ... | A | false |
30,807 | "Hey, ye, you're finally awake," spoke the old farmer. I found myself lying in a bag of hay, at the back of a drawn cart. My confusion was indescribable, but hey, at least I was comfortable. "Found you lyin' drunk near the river, so I decided I should help ye, fella."
Ah, so that's how I came into this world.... | That, you see, was the beginning of the end. I truly wish I could go back. Do so many things differently.
The number burned into my mind and unfortunately, my friends, I let it affect how I viewed the world. I let it change me.
Honestly, even saying that I feel the fool, knowing others will read it and scoff. They'll... | 56 | 27 | 7,386 | 2,456 | UrRomabooSpaceDemon3 | None | 2023-01-06T19:26:56 | 2023-01-06T17:05:30 | Comment on post 30807 | 2.357222 | 53,548 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nThat, you see, was the beginning of the end. I truly wish I could go back. Do so many things differen... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a confessional, almost courtroom-style monologue from a narrator who is being judged for their actions. The writing is introspective and philosophical, exploring themes of agency, morality, and the nature of choice. The voice is distinctive, with a blend of self-deprecation and dark humor, a... | Story A presents a confessional, almost courtroom-style monologue from a narrator who is being judged for their actions. The writing is introspective and philosophical, exploring themes of agency, morality, and the nature of choice. The voice is distinctive, with a blend of self-deprecation and dark humor, and the narr... | A | false |
35 | "Sir! Sir, I've brought the anomaly. He claims to have been in a land called Voznia, but claims to be an earthling, sir."
I'm ushered into a tent and slammed down hard into a chair at a large round table. On the other side of the table is a man who doesn't take his eyes off the hologram in front of him. It's a map. I ... | I have fought hundreds of demons. Tamed elementals. Settled a damn land dispute over a mile of *open sky* for goodness sake! I barely escaped a marriage neither I not my fiance wanted (he was a cool guy though, taught me how to throw knives).
I did all that because there was just one thing in this forsaken Narnia kno... | 42 | 29 | 5,679 | 813 | Murlock_Holmes | Runecaster91 | 2023-10-25T20:32:02 | 2023-10-25T13:11:54 | Comment on post 35 | 7.335556 | 246 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nI have fought hundreds of demons. Tamed elementals. Settled a damn land dispute over a mile of *open ... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a humorous and irreverent take on the "hero returns home" trope. The protagonist is a seasoned adventurer who has fought demons, tamed elementals, and even settled a land dispute in the sky, all for the sake of a strawberry mint swirl ice cream. The tone is light, self-aware, and peppered wi... | Story A presents a humorous and irreverent take on the "hero returns home" trope. The protagonist is a seasoned adventurer who has fought demons, tamed elementals, and even settled a land dispute in the sky, all for the sake of a strawberry mint swirl ice cream. The tone is light, self-aware, and peppered with witty as... | A | false |
3,409 | They thought I wouldn't come. They thought I would just let it slide, after all "Adopted children aren't Really Yours" those words stung every time and normally I had to clench my fist, grit my teeth and at most lash out with my tongue when someone said them. Hell my Bio-donors had made that mistake when they found m... | It happens
It does doesn’t it?
To be an angel to be a demon we are bound by our biology let loose in a playground of illusion of unlimited possibility
But how unlimited was this possibility?
What made angels the lovely’s the motivators the beautiful singers of the clouds while demons are condemned to there dark hot... | 29 | 11 | 5,569 | 686 | StrykerC13 | RareMasterpiece501 | 2023-08-04T20:31:14 | 2023-08-04T14:40:45 | Comment on post 3409 | 5.841389 | 21,393 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nThey thought I wouldn't come. They thought I would just let it slide, after all \"Adopted children a... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a vivid, emotionally charged narrative about a parent whose adopted children are kidnapped by those who claim to be their biological relatives. The story is rich in detail, with a strong sense of world-building and character motivation. The protagonist’s internal conflict and determination t... | Story A presents a vivid, emotionally charged narrative about a parent whose adopted children are kidnapped by those who claim to be their biological relatives. The story is rich in detail, with a strong sense of world-building and character motivation. The protagonist’s internal conflict and determination to protect h... | A | true |
3,001 | She had been pacing for a while.
She went back and forth on the patio while he watched TV. To anyone else, it'd be concerning, but to Simon, he didn't pay her much mind. After a good year and a half, he knew she paced while simply thinking about her favorite shows, books, and other unserious matters. He usually left ... | In a confusing twist, my girlfriend confessed she was cheating on me... with me. I was both the other man and the boyfriend. She loved the secret hero and the everyday guy, not realizing they were the same person. I felt a weird mix of anger and amusement.
I was jealous of my own secret identity, the hero she fell fo... | 299 | 13 | 5,449 | 523 | spiritAmour | JerichoTheDesolate1 | 2023-08-03T23:23:41 | 2023-08-03T23:22:41 | Comment on post 3001 | 0.016667 | 20,275 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nShe had been pacing for a while. \n\nShe went back and forth on the patio while he watched TV. To any... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a nuanced and emotionally layered narrative. The writing is immersive, with well-drawn characters and a clear sense of their relationship dynamics. The dialogue feels natural, and the twist—revealing that the "other man" is actually the same person as the boyfriend—adds complexity and depth ... | Story A presents a nuanced and emotionally layered narrative. The writing is immersive, with well-drawn characters and a clear sense of their relationship dynamics. The dialogue feels natural, and the twist—revealing that the "other man" is actually the same person as the boyfriend—adds complexity and depth to the stor... | A | true |
3,004 | Everyone’s heard the horrible mother-in-law jokes, right? Good, that will save us some time. While she isn’t my mother-in-law yet, at least not in a legal sense since we haven’t married, I still consider her family, even after what she did to my girlfriend.
It was one of those blisteringly hot days, the sort of day... | "We need to see your boss," Dana stated, glaring at me with those big, beautiful and bulging eyes.
I dreaded that she would ask to see my boss eventually. Even as I knew it was inevitable.
Because it meant an end to our adventures together. From diving together during a seaside holiday, to that faithful, life changin... | 96 | 59 | 6,889 | 1,999 | sadnesslaughs | Tregonial | 2024-04-07T04:55:08 | 2024-04-07T03:10:22 | Comment on post 3004 | 1.746111 | 20,284 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nEveryone’s heard the horrible mother-in-law jokes, right? Good, that will save us some time. While sh... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a heartfelt narrative about a couple dealing with the transformation of the girlfriend into a vampire. The story is detailed, with a strong focus on the emotional journey of both characters. It explores themes of acceptance, love, and transformation, and the relationship between the protagon... | Story A presents a heartfelt narrative about a couple dealing with the transformation of the girlfriend into a vampire. The story is detailed, with a strong focus on the emotional journey of both characters. It explores themes of acceptance, love, and transformation, and the relationship between the protagonist and his... | A | true |
13,044 | Carlis floated down from the Apsa skyscraper, sailing past its windows before landing on the road. As he made his landing, his cape fluttered upwards, exposing the blue bruises that stained his purple skin. The costume he wore was as battered as his body was. Yet in the end, he had been victorious, sending the villain ... | I barely started my daily patrol, on my usual route, when a group of civilians, crowded me.
They were the citizens that I swore to protect, the people I loved, but when I saw what they did...I froze.
"You saved us many times, and we are thankful...but, you never kill!
You never killed him! HIM! The greatest villa... | 605 | 129 | 7,396 | 2,564 | sadnesslaughs | TheWanderingBook | 2024-10-10T17:24:53 | 2024-10-10T16:10:03 | Comment on post 13044 | 1.247222 | 37,484 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nI barely started my daily patrol, on my usual route, when a group of civilians, crowded me. \nThey w... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a first-person narrative from the perspective of a hero who has always refused to kill villains, even when it would have saved countless lives. The story is structured around a confrontation with the hero’s own people, who, in their gratitude, have killed the villain themselves. The hero is ... | Story A presents a first-person narrative from the perspective of a hero who has always refused to kill villains, even when it would have saved countless lives. The story is structured around a confrontation with the hero’s own people, who, in their gratitude, have killed the villain themselves. The hero is left to gra... | A | false |
1,898 | Sir Lawrence third of his name hefted his armour clad form over the towers stone windowsill with a grunt.
He rubbed his eyes with gauntlet covered fingers, mouth aghast, as he surveyed the scene before him.
This was not how these things were supposed to go.
He’d been set up, a rookie mistake.
Lawrence sighed. He kne... | **DOUSE**
As the longsword Wyrmspite blazes to it's fiery glory with the word of power, Sir Tor with a mighty cleave beheaded the drake that was keeping the princess captive.
**IGNITE**
With that word, Wyrmspite douses it's flames and Sir Tor sheathes the sword.
Approaching the cage that held the princess, he had a... | 56 | 21 | 1,450 | 6,165 | MJGTalisker | crabcancer | 2023-02-24T06:40:13 | 2023-02-24T02:37:43 | Comment on post 1898 | 4.041667 | 15,936 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n**DOUSE**\n\nAs the longsword Wyrmspite blazes to it's fiery glory with the word of power, Sir Tor wi... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a classic fantasy rescue narrative with a twist: the aging, arthritic knight Sir Tor, who has rescued a princess from a dragon, is confronted with the reality of his own obsolescence and the decline of his family’s fortunes. The story is rich in detail, with a strong sense of setting and cha... | Story A presents a classic fantasy rescue narrative with a twist: the aging, arthritic knight Sir Tor, who has rescued a princess from a dragon, is confronted with the reality of his own obsolescence and the decline of his family’s fortunes. The story is rich in detail, with a strong sense of setting and character. The... | B | true |
9,857 | To Whom It May Concern,
We, the Population of life different to Yours, have taken the pains to learn Your language and mannerisms to bring forth this notice regarding Your definition of Living Beings. We have discovered, through careful observation, that Your species, though celebrated as intelligent, has failed to ac... | This is the ultimate arrogance of the frail carbon life. That they should see the vastness of the universe, that unending strange realm of twists, unfathomable gravity, cold voids, and burning light; and think themselves the only form of life in existence. Their eyes do not widen in searching for life, constantly looki... | 45 | 23 | 3,017 | 7,718 | NikiTheBlob | ApocalypseOwl | 2023-02-03T18:19:26 | 2023-02-03T17:52:46 | Comment on post 9857 | 0.444444 | 33,937 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nTo Whom It May Concern,\n\nWe, the Population of life different to Yours, have taken the pains to lea... | A | Reasoning: Story A adopts a formal, almost bureaucratic tone, presenting itself as a letter from a group of fourth-dimensional beings to humanity. The narrative is clever in its use of a pseudo-official letter format, and the premise—life forms beyond human observation expanding the definition of life—is intriguing. Th... | Story A adopts a formal, almost bureaucratic tone, presenting itself as a letter from a group of fourth-dimensional beings to humanity. The narrative is clever in its use of a pseudo-official letter format, and the premise—life forms beyond human observation expanding the definition of life—is intriguing. The story is ... | A | true |
21,722 | Director Atanas stretched in his chair, cracking his neck as he finished reading the numerous reports from his team. Complete success, marred only by the deaths of two agents and a hospital leave of a dozen more. Alas, in this line of work, casualties were inevitable.
The biggest reason was lack of information. Storie... | Now, you may think this is weird, right? I mean, humans taking a threat in the far future seriously enough to not only keep the story alive for the entire thousand years, but to also temporarily unite under a single banner to amass a military capable of stopping the Great Evil’s rise? That’s practically unheard of. But... | 21 | 15 | 1,635 | 6,309 | art-solopov | apatheticchildofJen | 2024-10-29T17:09:35 | 2024-10-29T14:16:56 | Comment on post 21722 | 2.8775 | 49,451 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nDirector Atanas stretched in his chair, cracking his neck as he finished reading the numerous reports... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a tightly focused, atmospheric vignette centered on Director Atanas, a seasoned operative dealing with the aftermath of a demon defeat. The writing is concise, with a strong sense of world-building and a subtle, almost clinical tone that fits the context of a military or magical operations r... | Story A presents a tightly focused, atmospheric vignette centered on Director Atanas, a seasoned operative dealing with the aftermath of a demon defeat. The writing is concise, with a strong sense of world-building and a subtle, almost clinical tone that fits the context of a military or magical operations report. The ... | A | true |
22,961 | At first, I thought it was just hazing the new healer.
“Don’t worry, Martin won’t hurt you or anything. This just helps him control his impulses, and the practice doesn’t hurt too much either.”
The handkerchief itself was unremarkable. Just a plain red fabric with no noteworthy markings. But dutifully, Martin would... | We always called him R as we didn't really have any other way to call him. He was a man of very few words and the words he did speak were awkward and often came out of the blue. Rarely did you ever get the sense that he actually fit in or for that matter like he truly wanted to connect. We didn't even know his name for... | 111 | 43 | 2,074 | 6,852 | SmidgenThePidgeon | Jam-Boi-yt | 2023-02-06T09:23:34 | 2023-02-06T03:23:58 | Comment on post 22961 | 5.993333 | 50,621 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nAt first, I thought it was just hazing the new healer. \n\n“Don’t worry, Martin won’t hurt you or any... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a tightly focused narrative centered on a mysterious handkerchief and its obsessive return by Martin, a party member. The story is concise, with a clear arc: initial suspicion, escalating curiosity, and a twist ending that reveals the handkerchief as a symbol of Martin’s obsession and possib... | Story A presents a tightly focused narrative centered on a mysterious handkerchief and its obsessive return by Martin, a party member. The story is concise, with a clear arc: initial suspicion, escalating curiosity, and a twist ending that reveals the handkerchief as a symbol of Martin’s obsession and possibly a supern... | A | true |
33,856 | Immortality is running through the veins of my body; completely replacing the stream of blood that once was in its place. Immortality has ruined me as a human being, it has made me feel like a social experiment within a land of the "seen and heard" normal people. The mirror in front of me has been my worst enemy for a ... | “The fountain of youth is a horrible thing. In many ways, it’s the ultimate drug. Granting the person who drinks from it the high of a lifetime, before they spiral, becoming dependent on its waters. Bucky and I fell for its allure. Even if we weren’t out for eternal youth, the fountain knew exactly what we needed, dece... | 95 | 60 | 2,426 | 7,215 | kyvorra | sadnesslaughs | 2024-05-09T15:41:19 | 2024-05-09T15:05:19 | Comment on post 33856 | 0.6 | 54,030 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nImmortality is running through the veins of my body; completely replacing the stream of blood that on... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a first-person narrative from the perspective of an immortal who has lived for three hundred years. The story explores the psychological toll of immortality, focusing on the protagonist’s feelings of alienation, the burden of endless youth, and the desire for meaningful experiences. The writ... | Story A presents a first-person narrative from the perspective of an immortal who has lived for three hundred years. The story explores the psychological toll of immortality, focusing on the protagonist’s feelings of alienation, the burden of endless youth, and the desire for meaningful experiences. The writing is intr... | B | false |
14,385 | Everyone thought the King won’t be too wise for the throne when he was little. They all call little Iosua insane, weird and paranoid as a kid. He’s seeing things no other can see. But he was the only heir to the throne. He’s the only one they have to inherit the crown of the kingdom.
He was known to be color blind. B... | Most of the people on my staff are wearing a brilliant purple that almost perfectly matches the flag sitting behind the throne. I know they are loyal because they are the people closest to me.
When they were originally brought into the court, their colors matched their personal family colors, but their loyalty to me ... | 139 | 56 | 6,453 | 1,768 | curse1304 | citycept | 2023-04-18T23:36:09 | 2023-04-18T22:53:28 | Comment on post 14385 | 0.711389 | 38,304 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nMost of the people on my staff are wearing a brilliant purple that almost perfectly matches the flag ... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a dark, twisty narrative from the perspective of a tyrannical ruler. The story is concise, with a strong sense of atmosphere and a clear escalation from the protagonist’s paranoia to betrayal. The use of color as a motif is clever, and the twist—where everyone is wearing the same color, lead... | Story A presents a dark, twisty narrative from the perspective of a tyrannical ruler. The story is concise, with a strong sense of atmosphere and a clear escalation from the protagonist’s paranoia to betrayal. The use of color as a motif is clever, and the twist—where everyone is wearing the same color, leading to a ma... | A | false |
34,528 | "Get rid of them. Tell them that I recently caught that plague that has been going around the neighboring kingdom and is bedridden and near death!"
I hissed to the Axton. He sighs and replies.
"That might work had you not already "caught" and "recovered" from the plague twice this season already, my lord."
Damn it, ... | I stared at my servant, and she just smirked.
"Get rid of them, Alice, for real this time." I said.
She giggled.
"I got rid of them last time as well, my Lord.
I got rid of them from the hallway, and sent them to the dining hall." she said.
I sighed.
It's not enough I am the least favorite of my royal paren... | 133 | 65 | 7,370 | 2,680 | Instantly-Regretted | TheWanderingBook | 2025-03-27T08:27:34 | 2025-03-27T04:40:04 | Comment on post 34528 | 3.791667 | 54,138 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nI stared at my servant, and she just smirked. \n\"Get rid of them, Alice, for real this time.\" I sa... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a slice-of-life vignette from the perspective of a royal protagonist who is both isolated and loved by his siblings. The writing is conversational and intimate, focusing on small, relatable moments—like being smothered by his sister, being ignored by his parents, and the frustration of being... | Story A presents a slice-of-life vignette from the perspective of a royal protagonist who is both isolated and loved by his siblings. The writing is conversational and intimate, focusing on small, relatable moments—like being smothered by his sister, being ignored by his parents, and the frustration of being the least ... | A | false |
4,783 | "Welcome to Returns, your speaking with Jill, who can we bring back for you today?'
"Hello Jill its Bill Gregory"
"Mr Gregory- what a pleasure it is to hear from you again, has it really been a year already?"
"Please call me Bill and its that time again for sure"
"Ha I cant do that, you know how Mr Gorgon-the duke ... | Miranda nervously fidgeted at the sleeve of her long coat. It was her first day, she was waiting in a room with a large table and several chairs as office halogen lights hummed away. Smoothing the cloth over and over is something she's done often in school to the point it started to fray. The new patch sown on her sho... | 71 | 31 | 2,617 | 7,227 | Ishouldbeworking01 | TacoMagic | 2023-01-23T20:27:06 | 2023-01-23T20:25:08 | Comment on post 4783 | 0.032778 | 24,897 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nMiranda nervously fidgeted at the sleeve of her long coat. It was her first day, she was waiting in a... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a vividly imagined world where necromancy is a mundane office job, complete with bureaucratic paperwork, casual Fridays, and a quirky attendant. The narrative is immersive, with strong world-building and a clear sense of atmosphere. The dialogue is engaging, and the protagonist, Miranda, is ... | Story A presents a vividly imagined world where necromancy is a mundane office job, complete with bureaucratic paperwork, casual Fridays, and a quirky attendant. The narrative is immersive, with strong world-building and a clear sense of atmosphere. The dialogue is engaging, and the protagonist, Miranda, is given a com... | A | false |
19,257 | "Mom? Dad? You stay in the rear each time the sessions start, ya hear!? Don't hang anywhere near or around the AT-AT Walkers and, for kriffing sake, DON'T BE A HERO...or FIGHT any! That goes especially for the guys with the humming/glowie sticks! Just...just please KEEP LOW and under the radar until I can find us a way... | Okay I’ve never done one of these before but I’m itching to write and I couldn’t help trying this out. I’m just a hobby writer so don’t get too upset about any mistakes, I didn’t bother to reread this haha
Edit: very minor Genshin Impact spoilers
——
I stood in the middle of a forest, blinking at the three older men an... | 88 | 40 | 1,953 | 6,511 | QuietRulrOfEvrything | UrbansMyth | 2023-10-07T06:27:07 | 2023-10-07T01:15:54 | Comment on post 19257 | 5.186944 | 46,400 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n\"Mom? Dad? You stay in the rear each time the sessions start, ya hear!? Don't hang anywhere near or ... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a tense, action-driven scenario set in a Star Wars universe, with the protagonist and their family caught in a dangerous situation. The writing is energetic and immersive, with vivid descriptions of the AT-AT Walkers, the threat of the Rebel soldiers, and the sudden intervention of Darth Vad... | Story A presents a tense, action-driven scenario set in a Star Wars universe, with the protagonist and their family caught in a dangerous situation. The writing is energetic and immersive, with vivid descriptions of the AT-AT Walkers, the threat of the Rebel soldiers, and the sudden intervention of Darth Vader. The emo... | A | true |
20,720 | "Goodness me, James, *look* at you!"
The individual in question glanced up from admiring his new physique. His eyes - the same dark brown as before - crinkled into a smile. "Evelyn! My, you look *amazing*." I felt my face redden as I smiled back.
"Have the others come out yet?" I queried, finally averting my eyes.
"... | The five of us laid, some collapsed, on the hill of the graveyard. The smell of singed grass was still coating the air as we laughed and picked bone fragments out of our hair.
"We actually did it." Eric said, a disbeliving grin forming on his face. Back home he was the star of the college football who carried them to ... | 423 | 46 | 2,587 | 7,215 | r3dj4ck0424 | DoomGloomAngst | 2023-02-27T06:03:45 | 2023-02-27T05:51:50 | Comment on post 20720 | 0.198611 | 48,357 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nThe five of us laid, some collapsed, on the hill of the graveyard. The smell of singed grass was stil... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a group of friends who have just completed a dangerous quest and are rewarded by a god with the power to transform their bodies into their ideal selves. The story is told in a first-person perspective, with each character given a distinct personality and backstory. The narrative is detailed,... | Story A presents a group of friends who have just completed a dangerous quest and are rewarded by a god with the power to transform their bodies into their ideal selves. The story is told in a first-person perspective, with each character given a distinct personality and backstory. The narrative is detailed, with a foc... | B | true |
31,699 | In the beginning, it was disorienting. The first time a figure clad in sleek, futuristic armor materialized in my living room, wielding an energy weapon and spouting some gibberish about me being "a blight on the timeline," I was shocked. By the fifth attempt, I had developed a strategy: duck, run, hide, then surprise ... | \[Justice Attempted\]
"I don't care if she is a kid...," Ophelia steeled herself once she noticed the teenager. The girl with bright pink pigtails was obviously a time traveler like the others had been. Something about her stood out from the other shoppers around. She wore a crisp white suit that seemed brighter than... | 183 | 59 | 2,881 | 7,419 | epistemecognito | HSerrata | 2023-07-13T16:52:36 | 2023-07-13T16:34:14 | Comment on post 31699 | 0.306111 | 53,696 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nIn the beginning, it was disorienting. The first time a figure clad in sleek, futuristic armor materi... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a compelling narrative from the perspective of a seemingly ordinary person who is unexpectedly thrust into a high-stakes, time-traveling conflict. The writing is confident and immersive, with a strong voice and a clear arc from passive victim to active agent of change. The protagonist’s tran... | Story A presents a compelling narrative from the perspective of a seemingly ordinary person who is unexpectedly thrust into a high-stakes, time-traveling conflict. The writing is confident and immersive, with a strong voice and a clear arc from passive victim to active agent of change. The protagonist’s transformation ... | A | true |
14,787 | [Part 1 of 2]
“I’m touched. You wanted your granddaughter back and instead of paying the ransom like a normal person, you marched into my office. Amazing, I haven’t had a laugh like this in ages. What do you think of the place? Pretty snazzy, right? That chair you’re sitting in is Italian leather. Can you feel the qua... | His granddaughter walked out of the police station with the conclusion from her savior that she had no idea what she was doing. The old man in the car took her home and bandaged her up. “What in gods name we’re you thinking?”
“I wanted to prove myself to the other villains that I can do something.”
“So you went aft... | 68 | 20 | 7,239 | 2,576 | sadnesslaughs | Nature_Walking | 2023-06-29T09:19:53 | 2023-06-29T01:32:37 | Comment on post 14787 | 7.787778 | 39,203 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n[Part 1 of 2]\n\n“I’m touched. You wanted your granddaughter back and instead of paying the ransom li... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a dynamic, character-driven scene between a retired supervillain and a former hero turned old woman, Marie. The writing is vivid, with strong dialogue and a clear sense of character voice. The tension is palpable, and the twist—Marie revealing her true power and taking down the villain—adds ... | Story A presents a dynamic, character-driven scene between a retired supervillain and a former hero turned old woman, Marie. The writing is vivid, with strong dialogue and a clear sense of character voice. The tension is palpable, and the twist—Marie revealing her true power and taking down the villain—adds a satisfyin... | A | true |
35,929 | “Doesn’t it make more sense to send us in first?” Papa Roach asked, earning the nickname after making too many last resort jokes. The other members of the Z-team merely moaned, always having the same discussion whenever a new member joined the squad. They hoped the clacking of helicopter blades would drown him out, but... | *In 2018, the American armed forces conducted a sweep of its least capable servicemen in an effort to free up resources and improve the quality of their personnel. This sweep produced a group of soldiers that were never allowed to be deployed overseas because of their inability to contribute to the wartime mission. Aft... | 48 | 18 | 7,399 | 2,838 | sadnesslaughs | Collinatus2 | 2024-05-28T05:48:41 | 2024-05-28T05:22:28 | Comment on post 35929 | 0.436944 | 54,325 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n“Doesn’t it make more sense to send us in first?” Papa Roach asked, earning the nickname after making... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a gritty, action-oriented narrative featuring a squad of military operatives tasked with cleaning up a facility infested with parasitic monsters. The story is rich in detail, with well-drawn characters and a strong sense of atmosphere. The dialogue is natural and helps to establish the perso... | Story A presents a gritty, action-oriented narrative featuring a squad of military operatives tasked with cleaning up a facility infested with parasitic monsters. The story is rich in detail, with well-drawn characters and a strong sense of atmosphere. The dialogue is natural and helps to establish the personalities of... | B | false |
7,004 | Most cops worship at the altar of The Shriek, and those of us who don't are careful to keep it to ourselves. Don't get me wrong, if they had to, they'd arrest him on sight. That is, while on sight of people bound to make a fuss if they see an LEO asking him for his autograph.
The few cops who don't like him are the ... | Chunks of drywall and chipped off wood litter the floor. The hero walks in through the hole he made in the wall, each step confident yet cautious of unknown dangers. He uses his enhanced vision to scan through the lingering smoke and dimness. There are toys and diapers and baby bottles blown around. Confusion strikes ... | 1,023 | 282 | 6,518 | 1,941 | Brad_Brace | Tricky-Ad7492 | 2023-11-18T01:46:26 | 2023-11-18T00:51:55 | Comment on post 7004 | 0.908611 | 29,642 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nMost cops worship at the altar of The Shriek, and those of us who don't are careful to keep it to our... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a gritty, noir-inspired narrative set in a world where vigilante crime-fighter "The Shriek" is both feared and revered by law enforcement. The protagonist, a cop with a troubled past, is tasked with capturing The Shriek, only to discover a shocking familial connection. The story is rich in w... | Story A presents a gritty, noir-inspired narrative set in a world where vigilante crime-fighter "The Shriek" is both feared and revered by law enforcement. The protagonist, a cop with a troubled past, is tasked with capturing The Shriek, only to discover a shocking familial connection. The story is rich in world-buildi... | A | true |
11,386 | "Lord forgive me for the ass I'm gonna beat today."
I was standing by the window, waiting for my guest to arrive. Naomi was passed out in her bed with an ice pack over her black eye. And I had some choice words for the person responsible.
The moonlight shined through the window at last. A woman faded into existence, ... | \[Goddess' Perspective\]
"Sorry, who are-,"
"AAAAAAAAAHHHHHH!!" Carrie screamed. She had been about to give the so-called 'Moon Goddess' a piece of her mind when a black hole suddenly appeared in her daughter's bedroom. A pale, teenage girl with rainbow hair wearing a crisp white suit walked out of the portal ... | 122 | 71 | 2,728 | 7,161 | jardanovic | HSerrata | 2023-01-11T20:24:06 | 2023-01-11T18:12:56 | Comment on post 11386 | 2.186111 | 35,773 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n\"Lord forgive me for the ass I'm gonna beat today.\"\n\nI was standing by the window, waiting for my... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a tense, emotionally charged scene between Delilah Isadora and the Moon Goddess. The writing is sharp, with a strong voice and a clear sense of character motivation. The dialogue is snappy and reveals both the protagonist's anger and the Goddess's weariness, creating a compelling dynamic. Th... | Story A presents a tense, emotionally charged scene between Delilah Isadora and the Moon Goddess. The writing is sharp, with a strong voice and a clear sense of character motivation. The dialogue is snappy and reveals both the protagonist's anger and the Goddess's weariness, creating a compelling dynamic. The story eff... | A | true |
13,650 | "THAT SHOULDN'T WORK!"
"_Well it did, you saw for yourself._"
"Gnnnnn. I mean you just _killed_ a dragon ... using garden supplies! And what the hell was that incantation?"
"_Look. We've been friends despite a lot of ... stuff. Can I trust you to keep a secret?_"
"... fine?"
"_Remember last April Fools when you se... | She had seen mages before when she went to sell her embroidery in the city centre. They would put on grand displays of magical wonder. She had seen them appear in a puff of colourful smoke, pull crystals out of thin air and turn them into soft, gentle rain, and bestow good fortune and prosperity on the discerning audie... | 322 | 184 | 1,412 | 5,884 | joalheagney | SirPiecemaker | 2023-03-29T21:14:54 | 2023-03-29T20:54:34 | Comment on post 13650 | 0.338889 | 37,865 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nShe had seen mages before when she went to sell her embroidery in the city centre. They would put on ... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a vividly imagined world where magic is a luxury reserved for the wealthy, and the protagonist is a working-class woman who seeks help from a disheveled, unconventional mage. The narrative is immersive, with strong world-building and a clear sense of setting. The characters are distinct, and... | Story A presents a vividly imagined world where magic is a luxury reserved for the wealthy, and the protagonist is a working-class woman who seeks help from a disheveled, unconventional mage. The narrative is immersive, with strong world-building and a clear sense of setting. The characters are distinct, and the story ... | A | false |
14,970 | The clock started to tick down. 36h.
THE clock.
Everybody was surprised. Meeting between chief of state were organized. Scientific started to study all possible side effect of current projects. Even low energy particle accelerator were stopped.
The clock ticked. 23.
Panic started to spread in the world.
Military ... | **Part 1: The Human Extinction**
The ensuing panic didn't help with increasing the time we had left. If anything, we lost a few precious seconds. We were in the dark for the first five hours with the only information of something wrong coming from the live-stream of the clock which had gone from seven-thousand and thr... | 64 | 20 | 1,802 | 6,260 | QuantumCat2019 | CounselorFelix | 2023-11-21T19:30:14 | 2023-11-21T18:04:40 | Comment on post 14970 | 1.426111 | 39,532 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nThe clock started to tick down. 36h.\n\nTHE clock. \n\nEverybody was surprised. Meeting between chief... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a tense, apocalyptic scenario with a mysterious countdown clock, escalating panic, and a twist ending involving an AI that predicts the end of humanity. The narrative is concise, with a focus on atmosphere and suspense. The pacing is brisk, and the story builds tension effectively, culminati... | Story A presents a tense, apocalyptic scenario with a mysterious countdown clock, escalating panic, and a twist ending involving an AI that predicts the end of humanity. The narrative is concise, with a focus on atmosphere and suspense. The pacing is brisk, and the story builds tension effectively, culminating in a chi... | B | false |
15,200 | There he was, standing before me, seemingly a well-put together man in his mid 30s, eager to exchange 3 large emeralds for 12 sticks.
Should I worry for this stranger’s sanity? Was he an actor hired by one of those shows that enact crazy social experiments to test the public’s honesty? Was he like the “Into the Wild” ... | "No way these are real," I told the boy, who looked about seven. He handed me three green stones, which to my untrained eye looked like emeralds. I knew better.
"Look again, mister," he said with a smile. "Now, about those sticks. Twelve, to be exact."
"Kid, can't you see there's a patch of woods behind you? They're... | 41 | 21 | 1,719 | 6,141 | justaboredwriter | armageddon_20xx | 2023-07-10T04:19:32 | 2023-07-10T03:46:50 | Comment on post 15200 | 0.545 | 39,937 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nThere he was, standing before me, seemingly a well-put together man in his mid 30s, eager to exchange... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a first-person narrative that is introspective and somewhat meandering. The protagonist is caught between skepticism and curiosity as a stranger offers to trade emeralds for sticks. The story explores philosophical questions about value, morality, and the nature of exchange, but does so in a... | Story A presents a first-person narrative that is introspective and somewhat meandering. The protagonist is caught between skepticism and curiosity as a stranger offers to trade emeralds for sticks. The story explores philosophical questions about value, morality, and the nature of exchange, but does so in a somewhat a... | B | false |
16,819 | I felt the intrusion in my mind immediately
The tender tickle before the violent intrusion into my brain
I got ready to defend myself from my captor's attempt to "communicate" again.
I counted 200 meals since my last capture. Before my watch ran out of battery power I was being regularly fed at 8 Earth hour interva... | \- - - Day of abduction.
Was on my way home from school when the sky darkened for a moment, then a fog came about me. This was during a summer's day where the weather should be sunny and warm.
Next thing? Pitch black. Wasn't sure if I lost consciousness or...
Then I check myself and find that I'm not pitch black. I'... | 111 | 29 | 1,678 | 6,078 | livebeta | OSadorn | 2023-12-29T09:38:30 | 2023-12-29T04:44:33 | Comment on post 16819 | 4.899167 | 42,859 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n\\- - - Day of abduction.\n\nWas on my way home from school when the sky darkened for a moment, then ... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a first-person narrative of a human abducted by aliens, blending elements of surreal confusion, humor, and a slow-burn romance. The writing is playful, with a conversational tone and a focus on the protagonist’s attempts to adapt to their new environment. The story is rich in detail, from th... | Story A presents a first-person narrative of a human abducted by aliens, blending elements of surreal confusion, humor, and a slow-burn romance. The writing is playful, with a conversational tone and a focus on the protagonist’s attempts to adapt to their new environment. The story is rich in detail, from the strange s... | B | true |
18,307 | Krexavit finished scratching the last rune on the dining table, then pressed his hand into two of the runes and chanted. Grandma Kromp did not look impressed.
"Is it done yet? Can we eat?"
"You may eat now," Krexavit replied, wiping the sweat from his brow. He had worked just as hard as everyone else had in the kitch... | I mean, in retrospect it was an obvious choice, and also a twist of irony for me to end up marrying the only man that didn't ask first.
The Karnellian Empire is different from all the lands around in the fact that succession is given not to the oldest, but to the most competent of all. In this we are not the usual kin... | 342 | 27 | 1,701 | 6,193 | ZtheScribe | PM_ME_SMALL__TIDDIES | 2024-11-29T13:23:33 | 2024-09-07T00:34:22 | Comment on post 18307 | 2,004.819722 | 45,223 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nI mean, in retrospect it was an obvious choice, and also a twist of irony for me to end up marrying t... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a high-fantasy scenario centered on a protagonist who is the next in line for the throne of the Karnellian Empire. The narrative is rich in world-building, introducing a unique succession system, political intrigue, and the arrival of a dragon suitor. The protagonist’s voice is witty and sel... | Story A presents a high-fantasy scenario centered on a protagonist who is the next in line for the throne of the Karnellian Empire. The narrative is rich in world-building, introducing a unique succession system, political intrigue, and the arrival of a dragon suitor. The protagonist’s voice is witty and self-aware, pr... | B | true |
20,720 | I grounded my teenage son, this didn't sit well with him, and summoned an oversized tortoise that destroyed our livingroom.
My wife was still out working, so I had to have a talk with him.
Entering his room, I saw him weightlifting his special weights...they weighed like ten tons.
"Son...
You shouldn't behave l... | The five of us laid, some collapsed, on the hill of the graveyard. The smell of singed grass was still coating the air as we laughed and picked bone fragments out of our hair.
"We actually did it." Eric said, a disbeliving grin forming on his face. Back home he was the star of the college football who carried them to ... | 82 | 46 | 2,704 | 7,215 | TheWanderingBook | DoomGloomAngst | 2024-08-14T16:31:41 | 2023-02-27T05:51:50 | Comment on post 20720 | 12,826.664167 | 48,380 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nThe five of us laid, some collapsed, on the hill of the graveyard. The smell of singed grass was stil... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a group of friends who have just completed a dangerous adventure and are rewarded with the power to transform into their ideal selves. The story is rich in character detail, with each member of the group given a distinct personality and backstory. The narrative is lively, with banter and hum... | Story A presents a group of friends who have just completed a dangerous adventure and are rewarded with the power to transform into their ideal selves. The story is rich in character detail, with each member of the group given a distinct personality and backstory. The narrative is lively, with banter and humor, and the... | A | false |
30,807 | As I wake, I hear moaning. Not the usual moans of agony I’ve become used to, punctuated with screams and gunfire. Soft, constant moaning. From all around me.
It’s pitch dark. My head is pounding. I lever myself up onto an elbow, and realise that I am no longer lying on blood-infused sand and volcanic ash of the Iwo J... | “Only one point in luck? Seems awfully low, but what does the luck stat even do in a game, anyway? What even is considered luck? At least my strength and defense stat are average. Think I’ll need to rely on those a lot more than luck. Oh, well, guess it would have been boring if I was overpowered.”
I went to close ... | 388 | 108 | 3,090 | 7,605 | HolIerer | sadnesslaughs | 2023-01-06T19:29:11 | 2023-01-06T15:39:34 | Comment on post 30807 | 3.826944 | 53,538 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n“Only one point in luck? Seems awfully low, but what does the luck stat even do in a game, anyway? Wh... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a humorous and self-aware take on the "chosen one" trope, with a protagonist who is initially overconfident about their stats in a fantasy RPG. The story is written in a conversational, meta style, with the protagonist commenting on game mechanics and their own abilities. The narrative quick... | Story A presents a humorous and self-aware take on the "chosen one" trope, with a protagonist who is initially overconfident about their stats in a fantasy RPG. The story is written in a conversational, meta style, with the protagonist commenting on game mechanics and their own abilities. The narrative quickly escalate... | A | false |
909 | "I said just take it, I have no arguments to make" Jerry said for the 5th time with absolute certainty
"But...but surely you have *some* words to defend your planet? You do realise us hauling away the sun means you and your loved ones and everyone else on the planet earth will freeze to death overnight" Said Grolu, w... | “First, why are you asking me? Did you ask everyone? Second, what was your criteria? I’m literally a server at iHop. Like…? I don’t understand the implications of the action, both physical and metaphorical. What would happen if the sun disappears? I don’t know, nor do I care. Wait, do I have to experience the fall out…... | 275 | 116 | 5,694 | 1,281 | ASentientRedditAcc | None | 2023-03-22T21:50:08 | 2023-03-22T20:47:14 | Comment on post 909 | 1.048333 | 6,281 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\n“First, why are you asking me? Did you ask everyone? Second, what was your criteria? I’m literally a ... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a humorous and relatable take on a cosmic crisis, told from the perspective of a server at iHop. The protagonist’s voice is casual, self-deprecating, and authentic, which makes the scenario both funny and endearing. The dialogue is snappy and the pacing is tight, with the protagonist’s inter... | Story A presents a humorous and relatable take on a cosmic crisis, told from the perspective of a server at iHop. The protagonist’s voice is casual, self-deprecating, and authentic, which makes the scenario both funny and endearing. The dialogue is snappy and the pacing is tight, with the protagonist’s internal monolog... | A | false |
19,251 | Trapped.
Trapped in my house, which seemed to be burning down around me. As I sat there, underneath my desk, burning beams falling around me, smoke burning my eyes and my lungs, I felt some familiar and comforting shapes all around me. I sat there, my orange tabby, Marmalade, curled on my lap, trying to take comfort i... | I speak of the great yet humble /u/frost_knight , who led to this land the Warren Council. Twelve rabbits who still bring great wonders to our people.
Of the twelve, only the Frost Knight could speak to eleven of them. Of the twelve, only one communicated directly to us from her comfortable couch, only asking for ri... | 53 | 38 | 7,324 | 2,870 | Straight_Attention_5 | frost_knight | 2023-03-11T00:21:01 | 2023-03-10T22:00:28 | Comment on post 19251 | 2.3425 | 46,359 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nTrapped.\n\nTrapped in my house, which seemed to be burning down around me. As I sat there, underneat... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a vivid, emotionally engaging narrative about a person trapped in a burning house with their beloved pets. The story skillfully blends the horror of the situation with the comfort of familiar companionship, creating a strong emotional anchor. The transformation of the protagonist and their p... | Story A presents a vivid, emotionally engaging narrative about a person trapped in a burning house with their beloved pets. The story skillfully blends the horror of the situation with the comfort of familiar companionship, creating a strong emotional anchor. The transformation of the protagonist and their pets into fa... | A | true |
3,369 | The man shot up and back in an instant, instinctively jerking away, though the chains binding him to a barren, metal table cut his movement short. His eyes were wide, staring across the table at his defender. At me. And at the yellow eyes with slitted pupils I had chosen to expose to him.
"Mr. Wyer, is everything alri... | As that word came out of his mouth, a chill ran down my spine. “You’re claiming to be a *what??*” I ask him. My voice comes out shrill, despite my best efforts to remain calm and control myself. I can feel the fire rushing through my veins.
The man grins at me, a fervent light in his eyes. “I’m a Dragonslayer. Those “p... | 106 | 27 | 5,418 | 1,009 | Sedu | peanutbuttermaniac | 2024-03-18T23:04:57 | 2024-03-18T20:36:14 | Comment on post 3369 | 2.478611 | 21,210 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nAs that word came out of his mouth, a chill ran down my spine. “You’re claiming to be a *what??*” I a... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a tense, first-person narrative centered on a secret identity and the stakes of being discovered. The writing is concise and focused, with a clear sense of internal conflict and urgency. The protagonist’s voice is relatable, and the twist—that the supposed villain is actually a dragonslayer—... | Story A presents a tense, first-person narrative centered on a secret identity and the stakes of being discovered. The writing is concise and focused, with a clear sense of internal conflict and urgency. The protagonist’s voice is relatable, and the twist—that the supposed villain is actually a dragonslayer—adds intrig... | B | true |
17,878 | **Group Chats**
High above the towering skyscrapers of Star City floated the massive flying fortress of Dr. Neutron affectionately dubbed the 'War Zeppelin'. Despite looking like it was plucked from a bygone era the zeppelin contained technology far beyond that of even the most advanced fighter jet. While it's primary... | Crack!
The sounds of an intense battle fill the surrounding air. Two hooded figures flit back and forth between trees, sending flurries of punches and kicks at each other.
The ground ruptured under their vigorous assault as both of them separated at high speed.
"You've gotten stronger, Chimera." A man in a deep bla... | 61 | 37 | 6,749 | 2,341 | Robysto7 | Gry1080 | 2023-04-25T20:05:44 | 2023-04-25T15:34:36 | Comment on post 17878 | 4.518889 | 44,530 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nCrack!\n\nThe sounds of an intense battle fill the surrounding air. Two hooded figures flit back and ... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a classic superhero showdown between Chimera and a mysterious man in black, with a focus on intense action and a sense of ongoing rivalry. The writing is straightforward, with clear descriptions of the fight and the characters' motivations. However, the dialogue is somewhat stilted and the c... | Story A presents a classic superhero showdown between Chimera and a mysterious man in black, with a focus on intense action and a sense of ongoing rivalry. The writing is straightforward, with clear descriptions of the fight and the characters' motivations. However, the dialogue is somewhat stilted and the characters l... | B | true |
20,501 | Apparently, "Heroing Without A License" is a capital offense in the Country of Blister. Emerald wished he'd known that last week, before he rushed into the burning hotel to save the crying girl. Emerald still would've saved her; he simply would've paid the five gold pieces first.
However, he hadn't paid, and now he w... | Old Hogan was the one who found them, huddled and scared on the side of the Laneway heading into town. Poor Hogan was heading back from his favorite pub when he happened upon the wretched thing, cold and weak from exposure.
I was asleep, having stoked the fires of the Maesters rooms and ensuring all the doors and wind... | 23 | 16 | 7,323 | 2,797 | Pokerfakes | BlantantlyAccidental | 2023-01-28T22:26:53 | 2023-01-28T18:25:05 | Comment on post 20501 | 4.03 | 48,024 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nOld Hogan was the one who found them, huddled and scared on the side of the Laneway heading into town... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a dark, atmospheric fantasy scenario with a strong sense of world-building and tension. The narrative is immersive, using vivid descriptions and a first-person perspective to draw the reader into the protagonist's world. The dialogue is natural and helps to establish character relationships,... | Story A presents a dark, atmospheric fantasy scenario with a strong sense of world-building and tension. The narrative is immersive, using vivid descriptions and a first-person perspective to draw the reader into the protagonist's world. The dialogue is natural and helps to establish character relationships, particular... | B | true |
3,905 | Christian stopped by for the first time in weeks, I was honestly surprised. We hadn't seen much of each other, but he was incredibly insistent that we meet up today. I had other plans, but he was desperate to meet today, fairly early. I barely had woken up when he was ringing my doorbell like a madman.
I must have loo... | I always though I’d understood Lea better than most people. I’d been with them for what must be well over twenty years by now. From high school breakups to their first divorce, I’ve been right by their side. And through all that time they’d never been in such love as they are now with; how do I even put this? Self-impr... | 54 | 26 | 5,995 | 1,492 | SlayerRequiem | BladeOfTheSky | 2023-02-02T21:28:06 | 2023-02-02T20:53:16 | Comment on post 3905 | 0.580556 | 22,610 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nI always though I’d understood Lea better than most people. I’d been with them for what must be well ... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a reflective, somewhat melancholic narrative about a long-term relationship and the protagonist's feelings of missed opportunity. The writing is straightforward, with a focus on internal monologue and a sense of nostalgia. The story hints at a larger world (dragons, sword stains, conquests) ... | Story A presents a reflective, somewhat melancholic narrative about a long-term relationship and the protagonist's feelings of missed opportunity. The writing is straightforward, with a focus on internal monologue and a sense of nostalgia. The story hints at a larger world (dragons, sword stains, conquests) but keeps t... | B | true |
12,618 | "Perhaps I am a coward for being glad that I cannot see you. Maybe I am selfish for part of me wishing that I could. I... I owe upon you an apology for every day, for every life lost and every battle you fought, for it is by my hand you were made to."
Doctor Judith Wright tore her gaze from the three-dimensional displ... | We left Sol in an era of extreme optimism. The growing pains throughout history had been given meaning. Humanity had triumphed over its own darker impulses and emerged into what we thought would be an eternity of light. Perfection of light-speed warp drives, fusion energy generation, and biological immortality opened u... | 753 | 168 | 6,300 | 1,875 | MasterV3ga | Saint_Of_Silicon | 2023-04-06T06:50:28 | 2023-04-06T03:55:23 | Comment on post 12618 | 2.918056 | 37,076 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nWe left Sol in an era of extreme optimism. The growing pains throughout history had been given meanin... | B | Reasoning: Story A presents a sweeping, almost mythic narrative about humanity's expansion into the galaxy, the sudden destruction of Sol, and the subsequent survival and vengeance of the crew of The Stygian Blue. The prose is clear and evocative, with a strong sense of scale and stakes. The story's tone is somber and ... | Story A presents a sweeping, almost mythic narrative about humanity's expansion into the galaxy, the sudden destruction of Sol, and the subsequent survival and vengeance of the crew of The Stygian Blue. The prose is clear and evocative, with a strong sense of scale and stakes. The story's tone is somber and heroic, foc... | B | true |
22,622 | The king stood on his balcony, like he did every morning. The jewels and gold that coated him, glistening in the sun’s glorious light. He was a figure of god, a man blessed by the heavens. Luck didn’t determine someone’s birthright. No, you had to be chosen for the position. Men like him were the only ones worthy of be... | "The pentagram on the bottle didn't tip you off?"
The employee I flagged down levels his eyes at me, and something about them makes a shiver run down my spine. "I guess, what's it for?" The guy rolls his eyes, and I notice his name tag for the first time. Steve sighs. "Faustian bargains, reanimation, whatever you want... | 276 | 24 | 5,739 | 1,352 | sadnesslaughs | jpb103 | 2024-08-28T16:00:44 | 2023-07-13T23:48:06 | Comment on post 22622 | 9,880.210556 | 50,385 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nThe king stood on his balcony, like he did every morning. The jewels and gold that coated him, gliste... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a dark, morally complex narrative centered on a king who is both revered and reviled by his subjects. The writing is detailed and atmospheric, painting a vivid picture of the king’s detachment and the emotional impact on the peasants. The story explores themes of power, prejudice, and the du... | Story A presents a dark, morally complex narrative centered on a king who is both revered and reviled by his subjects. The writing is detailed and atmospheric, painting a vivid picture of the king’s detachment and the emotional impact on the peasants. The story explores themes of power, prejudice, and the duality of co... | B | false |
26,939 | Bruce always thought it’d be like a robot or something. Instead, in front of him at the pearly gates was a dog toy that looked like a duck.
“You’re telling me this thing has a soul?” he asked. Bruce waved a hand at it. “Hello, Heaven to. . . whatever you are.”
No reply, of course. It’s just a dog toy. A... | (I tried to specifically not go into the digital technology branch here)
Every life is created from light. From the smallest bacteria on a stray asteroid to the grand abyssmal horror that sleeps at the center of the universe. They all are creations of the design of big G. The humans call him God, jehova, Allah, it dep... | 55 | 13 | 6,750 | 2,349 | TheYellowBot | TheGalator | 2023-09-06T23:52:08 | 2023-09-06T23:05:48 | Comment on post 26939 | 0.772222 | 52,914 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nBruce always thought it’d be like a robot or something. Instead, in front of him at the pearly gates ... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a humorous and imaginative take on the afterlife, centering on Bruce, an angelic gatekeeper, and his encounter with a dog toy that has been given a soul. The narrative is lively, with witty dialogue and a strong sense of character. The story builds intrigue around the mysterious dog toy and ... | Story A presents a humorous and imaginative take on the afterlife, centering on Bruce, an angelic gatekeeper, and his encounter with a dog toy that has been given a soul. The narrative is lively, with witty dialogue and a strong sense of character. The story builds intrigue around the mysterious dog toy and its fate, l... | A | true |
22,566 | I was working in the garden when I heard people approaching. Strange. It wasn't the time of the week for the Carters to come pick up what produce I had to sell. I looked up, to see the strangest sight I ever saw. Adventurers. An exquisitely beautiful elven princess; clad in robes of Light. A dark, ominous figure in the... | Routine can kill anything. It kills the spirit of a man, making him a drone that grind from 8:00 to 17:00; it kills the passion in a woman, making her settle for a boring life... It can make two persons in love, into roommates in the best scenario and into complete strangers ready to ditch the other at the worst.
I k... | 144 | 99 | 6,003 | 1,556 | Mumique | Aljhaqu | 2025-02-21T09:09:25 | 2025-02-21T00:16:45 | Comment on post 22566 | 8.877778 | 50,367 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nI was working in the garden when I heard people approaching. Strange. It wasn't the time of the week ... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a vividly imagined fantasy scenario with well-developed characters and a clear narrative arc. The writing is immersive, with strong dialogue and a sense of place. The protagonist, Ana, is given a distinct voice and emotional depth, and the story explores themes of abandonment, responsibility... | Story A presents a vividly imagined fantasy scenario with well-developed characters and a clear narrative arc. The writing is immersive, with strong dialogue and a sense of place. The protagonist, Ana, is given a distinct voice and emotional depth, and the story explores themes of abandonment, responsibility, and the c... | A | true |
3,364 | the 38 year old man adjusted his glasses at the question, nervously running his fingers through his hair. "yeah, i... uh... i gotta show you something"
he produces a stack of paper, the demon recognized the foul stench of holy water on them, and figured out what he had been doing- buying souls for goods by having peop... | I looked pleadingly into his sulphur eyes, squiriming about in my seat. I shuddered and my facial muscles melted, unwilling to open up. A tall, humanoid thing, with 8 arms, the body of two men, and a handsome, owl-like face, domineered over my body, as smoke billowed out its tiny nostrils.
The demon Azathoth growl... | 114 | 57 | 2,386 | 6,760 | deathschemist | JDT1706 | 2023-03-05T02:04:27 | 2023-03-05T01:59:26 | Comment on post 3364 | 0.083611 | 21,195 | [
{
"content": "You are evaluating two creative writing responses (A and B) to the same writing prompt. These responses are similar to those posted on Reddit writing subreddits like r/WritingPrompts.\n\nStory A:\nthe 38 year old man adjusted his glasses at the question, nervously running his fingers through his h... | A | Reasoning: Story A presents a clever and humorous take on the "selling souls" trope, centering on a man who has been scamming demons by writing his own soul on church stationery. The story is concise, with a strong sense of character and a playful twist at the end, revealing the protagonist as Milhouse Van Houten from ... | Story A presents a clever and humorous take on the "selling souls" trope, centering on a man who has been scamming demons by writing his own soul on church stationery. The story is concise, with a strong sense of character and a playful twist at the end, revealing the protagonist as Milhouse Van Houten from The Simpson... | A | true |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.