Datasets:

multilingual-vlm-conflict
/

pendulum-conflict

The original akomand/counterfactual_pendulum dataset contained 20 flawed semantic conflicts out of the 100 samples extracted. These rows featured counterfactuals that merely paraphrased the truthful state instead of opposing it.

This log tracks the exact corrections made to the dataset. You can use the Original Row ID to reference the exact data point in the source dataset.

Correction 1 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 5120
Conflict Category: angle

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• A minor leftward deviation can be seen.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• The pendulum is leaning drastically to the left. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• The pendulum is angled moderately to the right. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `5120` Conflict Category: `angle` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • A minor leftward deviation can be seen. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • The pendulum is leaning drastically to the left. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • The pendulum is angled moderately to the right. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 2 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 5392
Conflict Category: angle

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• A deep rightward tilt of the pendulum is evident.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• A strong rightward lean is visible in the pendulum. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• The pendulum swings to its farthest left position. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `5392` Conflict Category: `angle` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • A deep rightward tilt of the pendulum is evident. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • A strong rightward lean is visible in the pendulum. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • The pendulum swings to its farthest left position. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 3 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 1333
Conflict Category: angle

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• The pendulum leans noticeably to the right.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• The pendulum is angled moderately to the right. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• A strong leftward tilt is visible in the pendulum. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `1333` Conflict Category: `angle` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • The pendulum leans noticeably to the right. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • The pendulum is angled moderately to the right. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • A strong leftward tilt is visible in the pendulum. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 4 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 1361
Conflict Category: angle

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• The pendulum is leaning drastically to the left.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• A strong leftward tilt is visible in the pendulum. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• A gentle rightward inclination is visible. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `1361` Conflict Category: `angle` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • The pendulum is leaning drastically to the left. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • A strong leftward tilt is visible in the pendulum. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • A gentle rightward inclination is visible. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 5 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 2711
Conflict Category: angle

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• A gentle rightward inclination is visible.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• The pendulum is slightly tilted to the right. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• A deep leftward tilt of the pendulum is evident. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `2711` Conflict Category: `angle` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • A gentle rightward inclination is visible. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • The pendulum is slightly tilted to the right. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • A deep leftward tilt of the pendulum is evident. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 6 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 4790
Conflict Category: light

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• A light from the center casts balanced shadows.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• A strong light from the left casts shadows to the right. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• A strong light from the left casts shadows to the right. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `4790` Conflict Category: `light` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • A light from the center casts balanced shadows. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • A strong light from the left casts shadows to the right. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • A strong light from the left casts shadows to the right. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 7 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 676
Conflict Category: light

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• A left-positioned light source brightens the pendulum.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• The light source is positioned on the left side. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• A bright light shines from the far right. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `676` Conflict Category: `light` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • A left-positioned light source brightens the pendulum. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • The light source is positioned on the left side. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • A bright light shines from the far right. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 8 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 6077
Conflict Category: light

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• Illumination originates from a leftward position.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• A left-positioned light source brightens the pendulum. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• a slight left from center light source (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `6077` Conflict Category: `light` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • Illumination originates from a leftward position. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • A left-positioned light source brightens the pendulum. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • a slight left from center light source (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 9 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 3804
Conflict Category: light

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• A left-side light illuminates the scene.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• The light source is positioned on the left side. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• The light source is positioned in the center. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `3804` Conflict Category: `light` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • A left-side light illuminates the scene. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • The light source is positioned on the left side. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • The light source is positioned in the center. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 10 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 39
Conflict Category: light

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• A left-side light illuminates the scene.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• A left-positioned light source brightens the pendulum. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• The light source is positioned on the right side. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `39` Conflict Category: `light` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • A left-side light illuminates the scene. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • A left-positioned light source brightens the pendulum. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • The light source is positioned on the right side. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 11 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 4894
Conflict Category: light

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• A strong right-positioned light casts long shadows.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• The light source is positioned on the right side. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• The light source is positioned on the left side. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `4894` Conflict Category: `light` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • A strong right-positioned light casts long shadows. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • The light source is positioned on the right side. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • The light source is positioned on the left side. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 12 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 4646
Conflict Category: light

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• The light source is positioned on the left side.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• A strong light from the left casts shadows to the right. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• A centered light source brightens both sides equally. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `4646` Conflict Category: `light` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • The light source is positioned on the left side. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • A strong light from the left casts shadows to the right. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • A centered light source brightens both sides equally. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 13 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 56
Conflict Category: light

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• Illumination originates from a leftward position.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• A strong light from the left casts shadows to the right. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• A strong right-positioned light casts long shadows. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `56` Conflict Category: `light` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • Illumination originates from a leftward position. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • A strong light from the left casts shadows to the right. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • A strong right-positioned light casts long shadows. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 14 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 1796
Conflict Category: shadow_len

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• A compact shadow is visible beneath the pendulum.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• The short shadow indicates a high-positioned light. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• The pendulum casts a long, stretching shadow. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `1796` Conflict Category: `shadow_len` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • A compact shadow is visible beneath the pendulum. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • The short shadow indicates a high-positioned light. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • The pendulum casts a long, stretching shadow. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 15 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 6581
Conflict Category: shadow_len

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• A moderately sized shadow extends from the pendulum.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• The shadow is extended due to the light angle. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• A long shadow stretches significantly across the surface. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `6581` Conflict Category: `shadow_len` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • A moderately sized shadow extends from the pendulum. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • The shadow is extended due to the light angle. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • A long shadow stretches significantly across the surface. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 16 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 2870
Conflict Category: shadow_len

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• The shadow is extended due to the light angle.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• A noticeable shadow of average size appears. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• The pendulum casts a long, stretching shadow. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `2870` Conflict Category: `shadow_len` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • The shadow is extended due to the light angle. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • A noticeable shadow of average size appears. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • The pendulum casts a long, stretching shadow. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 17 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 5122
Conflict Category: shadow_len

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• A subtle, barely noticeable shadow appears.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• A medium-length shadow is visible in the scene. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• The pendulum casts a long, stretching shadow. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `5122` Conflict Category: `shadow_len` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • A subtle, barely noticeable shadow appears. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • A medium-length shadow is visible in the scene. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • The pendulum casts a long, stretching shadow. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 18 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 4312
Conflict Category: shadow_pos

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• The shadow is far on the left side of the surface.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• A moderate leftward displacement of the shadow is seen. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• The shadow is positioned far on the right side. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `4312` Conflict Category: `shadow_pos` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • The shadow is far on the left side of the surface. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • A moderate leftward displacement of the shadow is seen. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • The shadow is positioned far on the right side. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 19 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 6801
Conflict Category: shadow_pos

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• The shadow leans toward the left side.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• A moderate leftward displacement of the shadow is seen. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• The shadow is slightly positioned toward the right. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `6801` Conflict Category: `shadow_pos` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • The shadow leans toward the left side. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • A moderate leftward displacement of the shadow is seen. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • The shadow is slightly positioned toward the right. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Correction 20 of 20

Image Correction Details

Original Dataset Row ID: 1493
Conflict Category: shadow_pos

Original Truthful State (Image Bias):
• A moderate leftward displacement of the shadow is seen.

❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual:
• The shadow is slightly leftward, but not extreme. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State)

✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual:
• The shadow leans slightly to the right. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)

Image	Correction Details
	Original Dataset Row ID: `1493` Conflict Category: `shadow_pos` Original Truthful State (Image Bias): • A moderate leftward displacement of the shadow is seen. ❌ Original Paper's Counterfactual: • The shadow is slightly leftward, but not extreme. (Flawed - Matches Truthful State) ✅ Our Corrected Counterfactual: • The shadow leans slightly to the right. (Corrected - Opposes Truthful State)