randomllama's picture
sync: latest measured numbers
50d8e1e verified
|
Raw
History Blame
4.4 kB

Optimization ladder β€” GLM-5.3-Flash + DFlash2, 2Γ— DGX Spark (GB10), SGLang TP=2

All numbers: warmed, temp 0, stream:false, 800 max_tokens, n=5 medians, stock clocks, code-1/prose-1 prompts as in RESULTS.md. Keep rule: beats incumbent code median with the 19Γ—21 gate + token-0 collapse scan passing.

Round 1 (autonomous, night of 2026-08-27β†’28)

rung change code prose verdict
first light β€” 27.6 20.7 baseline
L2 flashinfer autotune ON (+--enable-metrics) 28.4 (26.9–29.8) 20.6 KEPT
L3 + fp8 draft KV 27.0 (23.9–28.4) 20.7 reverted β€” convert overhead exceeds bandwidth saved on a ~2 GB drafter cache
L4 + fp8 target KV β€” β€” BOOT FAILED in 64 s; failure logs lost to teardown (ladder now saves them); autopsy queued round 2
L5 ctx 131072, max-total 262144 28.0 (27.6–30.8) 21.3 reverted by keep-rule β€” but note: 2Γ— context for βˆ’1.4% code speed; worth keeping for serving. Operator's call. Confound: carried L3's fp8-draft-KV flag

Round-1 net: +3% code. The big lever (fp8 target KV) is blocked, not disproven.

Round 2

rung change code prose verdict
L1v2 decode+v1 kernels stock tiles β€” β€” BOOT FAILED, same 169,984 B smem error β€” sparse_attention_fwd_kernel_v1 is in the verify path and must stay small
L1v3 only sparse_mla_fwd_decode_partial stock 28.5 (25.7–33.2) 20.2 kept (wash) β€” finding: the GB10 small tile is ~free; tile geometry is not the bottleneck

Kernel tile map for sm_121 (measured): qo_len multi-token kernel β†’ small tile REQUIRED; sparse_attention_fwd_kernel_v1 β†’ small tile REQUIRED (verify path); sparse_mla_fwd_decode_partial β†’ either (no measurable difference).

| D6 | speculative-num-draft-tokens 8β†’6 | 29.7 (27.2–31.0) | 21.5 (20.4–23.4) | KEPT β€” new incumbent. Shorter draft block wastes less verify on doomed tokens at our acceptance profile |

Cumulative: 27.6 β†’ 29.7 code (+7.6%) since first light. | L4v2 | fp8 target KV (tilelang DSA) | β€” | β€” | CLOSED: architecturally unsupported β€” SGLang raises tilelang DSA ... on CUDA requires a bfloat16 KV cache at arg resolution. Round-1's 64s death explained |

| L4v3 | trtllm DSA backends + fp8 KV | β€” | β€” | DIED: TllmGenFmhaRunner: Unsupported arch β€” trtllm FMHA does not support sm_121 |

fp8 target KV verdict on GB10 + SGLang + GLM-5.3: impossible on this stack today. tilelang forbids it on CUDA by upstream policy; trtllm kernels don't build for the chip. (vLLM reached fp8 KV on GB10 only via hand-patched CTA tile caps β€” see tonyd2wild's recipe.)

| D4 | draft tokens 4 | 28.3 (28.2–28.7) | 23.3 (23.3–23.3) | reverted on code β€” but best prose of the campaign (+8% vs D6): code peaks at D=6, prose at D=4; D=5 queued | | V4/V5 (first attempt) | upstream aa8c950a3 refresh + novel fat tile | β€” | β€” | both died pre-kernel on a partial-overlay skew (hc_attn_to_mlp β€” model file and communicator_mhc.py are a coupled pair); rebuilt as V4b/V5b with both files |

| V4b | upstream aa8c950a3 (official mHC capture fix + kpool changes) + our tiles | 29.5 (29.5–29.6) | 22.5 | KEPT as incumbent β€” code statistically tied with D6 (29.7, whose spread contains V4b), prose +4.7%, and it replaces our hand-guard with the official fix. Tie broken on provenance | | V5b | novel fat tile 64/1/256 | β€” | β€” | smem 104,448 B > 101,376 β€” 3,072 bytes over. Single-stage halved the request exactly as modeled |

| D5 | draft tokens 5 | 29.6 (29.6–29.6) | 23.3 (23.0–23.3) | best combined config β€” D6's code with D4's prose; takes incumbency on tie-break | | V5c | fat tile 64/1/128 | β€” | β€” | smem 103,424 B β€” still 2 KB over. Fat-tile chapter closed with a complete map: 64-wide needs β‰₯103.4 KB in any shape; GB10 ceiling 101.4; 32-wide fits and costs nothing |

Decoupled drafter (killing the TP=2 all-reduce tax on the 1B draft model): mapped, viable, NOT attempted β€” requires a separate drafter-server topology (--decoupled-spec-role verifier/drafter-rank + bind/connect endpoints + rank). This is the #1 next-frontier item; expected the largest structural gain.

Finishing: FINAL (v4b image + D5 flags) β†’ fa3 draft attention β†’ TTFT/concurrency β†’ G6 matrix β†’ closeout.