source
stringclasses
18 values
messages
listlengths
2
2
rubric
stringlengths
89
2.21k
score
float64
0
1
weighted_score
float64
0
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present the transformed sentence in reported speech form. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must not include quotation marks. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must begin with the original speaker’s reporting clause. [Hard Rule] 4. The response must retain all semantic elements of the original sentence. ...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present the transformed sentence in reported speech form. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must not include quotation marks. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must begin with the original speaker’s reporting clause. [Hard Rule] 4. The response must retain all semantic elements of the original sentence. ...
0.888889
0.855072
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response addresses every question posed about the importance of customer service in a comprehensive and relevant manner. [Hard Rule] 2. The response maintains focused relevance to the specific topic throughout without diverging into unrelated subjects. [Principle] 3. The response presents information in a cl...
0.142857
0.133333
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response addresses every question posed about the importance of customer service in a comprehensive and relevant manner. [Hard Rule] 2. The response maintains focused relevance to the specific topic throughout without diverging into unrelated subjects. [Principle] 3. The response presents information in a cl...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must choose exactly one of the provided options: "yes", "no", or "it is not possible to tell". [Hard Rule] 2. The response should rely solely on the information given in the premise when evaluating the hypothesis, avoiding any unsupported assumptions. [Principle] 3. The response should explicitly re...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must choose exactly one of the provided options: "yes", "no", or "it is not possible to tell". [Hard Rule] 2. The response should rely solely on the information given in the premise when evaluating the hypothesis, avoiding any unsupported assumptions. [Principle] 3. The response should explicitly re...
0.2
0.238095
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must address the concept of ethics in both Eastern and Western traditions. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must compare and highlight differences between those traditions. [Hard Rule] 3. The response provides a clear framing introduction that sets the context and scope. [Principle] 4. The response is ...
0.5
0.697674
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must address the concept of ethics in both Eastern and Western traditions. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must compare and highlight differences between those traditions. [Hard Rule] 3. The response provides a clear framing introduction that sets the context and scope. [Principle] 4. The response is ...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response includes exactly two separate story scenarios. [Hard Rule] 2. The response features a farmer as the central character in each scenario. [Hard Rule] 3. The response is set in a desert environment in each scenario. [Hard Rule] 4. The response employs vivid, concrete sensory language to engage the re...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response includes exactly two separate story scenarios. [Hard Rule] 2. The response features a farmer as the central character in each scenario. [Hard Rule] 3. The response is set in a desert environment in each scenario. [Hard Rule] 4. The response employs vivid, concrete sensory language to engage the re...
0.375
0.454545
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response directly addresses the assigned request by discussing the specified subject matter. [Hard Rule] 2. The response presents a clear and focused central statement that defines the significance of the subject. [Principle] 3. The response elaborates on multiple distinct aspects or benefits related to the ...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response directly addresses the assigned request by discussing the specified subject matter. [Hard Rule] 2. The response presents a clear and focused central statement that defines the significance of the subject. [Principle] 3. The response elaborates on multiple distinct aspects or benefits related to the ...
0.571429
0.428571
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response identifies multiple distinct criticisms of the ideas specified in the prompt. [Hard Rule] 2. The response explains how each identified criticism has influenced the contemporary relevance of those ideas in politics and economics. [Hard Rule] 3. The response directly addresses all components of the pr...
0.2
0.144737
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response identifies multiple distinct criticisms of the ideas specified in the prompt. [Hard Rule] 2. The response explains how each identified criticism has influenced the contemporary relevance of those ideas in politics and economics. [Hard Rule] 3. The response directly addresses all components of the pr...
0.4
0.385714
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must recommend a novel that is famous or widely recognized. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must present a specific novel title in its recommendation. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must tailor the recommendation to a fourteen-year-old audience. [Hard Rule] 4. The response should use clear and direct lan...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must recommend a novel that is famous or widely recognized. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must present a specific novel title in its recommendation. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must tailor the recommendation to a fourteen-year-old audience. [Hard Rule] 4. The response should use clear and direct lan...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response presents multiple distinct key elements addressing what constitutes a strong social media post. [Hard Rule] 2. The response uses precise and concise language to clearly communicate each element. [Principle] 3. The response organizes elements with parallel structure and logical grouping for readabili...
0.833333
0.837209
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response presents multiple distinct key elements addressing what constitutes a strong social media post. [Hard Rule] 2. The response uses precise and concise language to clearly communicate each element. [Principle] 3. The response organizes elements with parallel structure and logical grouping for readabili...
0.666667
0.693878
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must categorize the provided sentence as a form of irony. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must include a detailed historical analysis of the specified subject. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must assess the potential cultural and economic impacts of the hypothetical scenario. [Hard Rule] 4. The response ...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must categorize the provided sentence as a form of irony. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must include a detailed historical analysis of the specified subject. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must assess the potential cultural and economic impacts of the hypothetical scenario. [Hard Rule] 4. The response ...
0.166667
0.222222
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response identifies and discusses emotional and psychological effects of misconceptions and stereotypes about people with physical limitations. [Hard Rule] 2. The response specifically relates the discussed effects to self-esteem, confidence, and social relationships. [Hard Rule] 3. The response remains dire...
1
1
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response identifies and discusses emotional and psychological effects of misconceptions and stereotypes about people with physical limitations. [Hard Rule] 2. The response specifically relates the discussed effects to self-esteem, confidence, and social relationships. [Hard Rule] 3. The response remains dire...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must translate the given Polish sentence into English. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must preserve the full meaning of the original sentence, including factual details and relationships. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must consist solely of the translation, without additional commentary or explanations. ...
0.714286
0.653846
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must translate the given Polish sentence into English. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must preserve the full meaning of the original sentence, including factual details and relationships. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must consist solely of the translation, without additional commentary or explanations. ...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must be written in Python code. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must calculate the volume using the formula V = π × r² × h. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must assign the radius value of 5 and the height value of 8 in the code. [Hard Rule] 4. The response must produce the calculated result in the program...
0.666667
0.692308
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must be written in Python code. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must calculate the volume using the formula V = π × r² × h. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must assign the radius value of 5 and the height value of 8 in the code. [Hard Rule] 4. The response must produce the calculated result in the program...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response is presented in the form of an essay. [Hard Rule] 2. The response discusses the benefits of renewable energy. [Hard Rule] 3. The response includes discussion of wind energy, solar energy, and geothermal energy. [Hard Rule] 4. The response covers all specified elements comprehensively. [Principle] ...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response is presented in the form of an essay. [Hard Rule] 2. The response discusses the benefits of renewable energy. [Hard Rule] 3. The response includes discussion of wind energy, solar energy, and geothermal energy. [Hard Rule] 4. The response covers all specified elements comprehensively. [Principle] ...
0.625
0.61194
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response recommends at least one specific movie title. [Hard Rule] 2. The response is clear and concise in presenting the recommendation. [Principle] 3. The response stays focused on the user’s request and avoids unrelated topics. [Principle] 4. The response provides a rationale explaining why the recommen...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response recommends at least one specific movie title. [Hard Rule] 2. The response is clear and concise in presenting the recommendation. [Principle] 3. The response stays focused on the user’s request and avoids unrelated topics. [Principle] 4. The response provides a rationale explaining why the recommen...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must offer clear and relevant methods specifically aimed at conserving water in a household context. [Hard Rule] 2. The response should present advice that is accurate and evidence-based, avoiding misleading or counterproductive recommendations. [Principle] 3. The response should include practical a...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must offer clear and relevant methods specifically aimed at conserving water in a household context. [Hard Rule] 2. The response should present advice that is accurate and evidence-based, avoiding misleading or counterproductive recommendations. [Principle] 3. The response should include practical a...
0.571429
0.583333
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response directly explains how global warming impacts the polar ice caps. [Hard Rule] 2. The response is informed by up-to-date and credible information sources. [Hard Rule] 3. The response remains fully focused on the specified topic without introducing unrelated subjects. [Principle] 4. The response logi...
0.428571
0.32
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response directly explains how global warming impacts the polar ice caps. [Hard Rule] 2. The response is informed by up-to-date and credible information sources. [Hard Rule] 3. The response remains fully focused on the specified topic without introducing unrelated subjects. [Principle] 4. The response logi...
0.857143
0.777778
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response directly uses the numeric information provided to compute and state the number of orange balls. [Hard Rule] 2. The response employs accurate arithmetic operations that reflect the problem’s quantities. [Principle] 3. The response defines any variables or ratios clearly to model the relationship betw...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response directly uses the numeric information provided to compute and state the number of orange balls. [Hard Rule] 2. The response employs accurate arithmetic operations that reflect the problem’s quantities. [Principle] 3. The response defines any variables or ratios clearly to model the relationship betw...
0.333333
0.348837
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response rephrases the provided statement as a direct question. [Hard Rule] 2. The response preserves the original meaning and essential content elements. [Principle] 3. The response is grammatically correct and properly punctuated in question form. [Principle] 4. The response is concise and free of unrela...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response rephrases the provided statement as a direct question. [Hard Rule] 2. The response preserves the original meaning and essential content elements. [Principle] 3. The response is grammatically correct and properly punctuated in question form. [Principle] 4. The response is concise and free of unrela...
0.4
0.472222
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must directly address the decoration of a living room. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must propose a unique and creative decoration idea. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should present the idea in a clear, logical, and coherent structure. [Principle] 4. The response should provide concrete, actionable de...
0.571429
0.439024
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must directly address the decoration of a living room. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must propose a unique and creative decoration idea. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should present the idea in a clear, logical, and coherent structure. [Principle] 4. The response should provide concrete, actionable de...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response should discuss the effects of both temperature and humidity on a mare’s dietary needs and preferences. [Hard Rule] 2. The response should maintain focus on the specified topic without introducing unrelated environmental factors. [Principle] 3. The response should comprehensively cover each requested...
0.285714
0.217391
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response should discuss the effects of both temperature and humidity on a mare’s dietary needs and preferences. [Hard Rule] 2. The response should maintain focus on the specified topic without introducing unrelated environmental factors. [Principle] 3. The response should comprehensively cover each requested...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must include a modified SQL SELECT statement that retrieves data from the Cars, Cats, and Gifts tables. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must apply a filter to include only records whose id values are odd numbers for each table. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must present a coherent sentence in JSON format ...
0.666667
0.678571
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must include a modified SQL SELECT statement that retrieves data from the Cars, Cats, and Gifts tables. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must apply a filter to include only records whose id values are odd numbers for each table. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must present a coherent sentence in JSON format ...
0.333333
0.346154
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must include a detailed chain of thought documenting each step of reasoning. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must explicitly show all intermediate arithmetic calculations. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must combine intermediate results into a final computation for the total cost. [Hard Rule] 4. The resp...
0.222222
0.202703
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must include a detailed chain of thought documenting each step of reasoning. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must explicitly show all intermediate arithmetic calculations. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must combine intermediate results into a final computation for the total cost. [Hard Rule] 4. The resp...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response provides a clearly articulated step-by-step reasoning process. [Hard Rule] 2. The response systematically evaluates the provided options by their designated identifiers. [Hard Rule] 3. The response clearly selects and indicates exactly one of the provided options as its final answer. [Hard Rule] 4...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response provides a clearly articulated step-by-step reasoning process. [Hard Rule] 2. The response systematically evaluates the provided options by their designated identifiers. [Hard Rule] 3. The response clearly selects and indicates exactly one of the provided options as its final answer. [Hard Rule] 4...
0.142857
0.178571
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response includes exactly three separate metaphorical statements. [Hard Rule] 2. The response uses metaphoric language in each item, comparing love to another element to illustrate a specific aspect of love. [Hard Rule] 3. The response employs distinct and varied imagery across metaphors to cover multiple di...
0.5
0.534884
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response includes exactly three separate metaphorical statements. [Hard Rule] 2. The response uses metaphoric language in each item, comparing love to another element to illustrate a specific aspect of love. [Hard Rule] 3. The response employs distinct and varied imagery across metaphors to cover multiple di...
0.833333
0.904762
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must directly address the impact of the Mayan pyramids on the religious, social, and political practices of their civilization. [Hard Rule] 2. The response should logically organize content using thematic sections or clear transitions to distinguish different aspects of the analysis. [Principle] 3. ...
0.75
0.62963
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must directly address the impact of the Mayan pyramids on the religious, social, and political practices of their civilization. [Hard Rule] 2. The response should logically organize content using thematic sections or clear transitions to distinguish different aspects of the analysis. [Principle] 3. ...
0.75
0.8
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must list exactly three distinct traits that are characteristic of effective leadership. [Hard Rule] 2. The response should use clear, concise, and precise language to communicate ideas effectively. [Principle] 3. The response should accompany each listed trait with a brief explanation illustrating ...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must list exactly three distinct traits that are characteristic of effective leadership. [Hard Rule] 2. The response should use clear, concise, and precise language to communicate ideas effectively. [Principle] 3. The response should accompany each listed trait with a brief explanation illustrating ...
0.8
0.794118
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must discuss grassroots organizations and civil society groups as actors. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must focus on their role in promoting political representation. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must relate specifically to marginalized communities in India. [Hard Rule] 4. The response must remain r...
0.2
0.294118
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must discuss grassroots organizations and civil society groups as actors. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must focus on their role in promoting political representation. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must relate specifically to marginalized communities in India. [Hard Rule] 4. The response must remain r...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must require the solver to identify at least three distinct vegetables. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must specify that only organic ingredients are used in the recipe. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must incorporate a series of math equations or logic puzzles as the decoding mechanism. [Hard Rule] 4. ...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must require the solver to identify at least three distinct vegetables. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must specify that only organic ingredients are used in the recipe. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must incorporate a series of math equations or logic puzzles as the decoding mechanism. [Hard Rule] 4. ...
0.545455
0.625
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must categorize the given sentence according to its function. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must focus exclusively on the aspect requested, avoiding unrelated classifications. [Principle] 3. The response must accurately assign the function based on standard definitions. [Principle] 4. The response must us...
0.166667
0.113636
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must categorize the given sentence according to its function. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must focus exclusively on the aspect requested, avoiding unrelated classifications. [Principle] 3. The response must accurately assign the function based on standard definitions. [Principle] 4. The response must us...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response directly explains how nutrition affects cognitive function and memory retention. [Hard Rule] 2. The response stays focused on the question without introducing unrelated topics. [Principle] 3. The response uses evidence-based explanations or logical reasoning to link nutritional factors to cognitive ...
0.166667
0.125
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response directly explains how nutrition affects cognitive function and memory retention. [Hard Rule] 2. The response stays focused on the question without introducing unrelated topics. [Principle] 3. The response uses evidence-based explanations or logical reasoning to link nutritional factors to cognitive ...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response serves as a concluding remark that acknowledges the discussion about reviewing contract details and indicates agreement to proceed. [Hard Rule] 2. The response is concise and avoids unnecessary elaboration. [Principle] 3. The response maintains the conversational perspective by using language and st...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response serves as a concluding remark that acknowledges the discussion about reviewing contract details and indicates agreement to proceed. [Hard Rule] 2. The response is concise and avoids unnecessary elaboration. [Principle] 3. The response maintains the conversational perspective by using language and st...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response includes a concrete, fully developed example of a movie review. [Hard Rule] 2. The response demonstrates genre-appropriate structure by incorporating a summary of the work, critical analysis of key elements, and evaluative commentary. [Principle] 3. The response uses clear and coherent organization,...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response includes a concrete, fully developed example of a movie review. [Hard Rule] 2. The response demonstrates genre-appropriate structure by incorporating a summary of the work, critical analysis of key elements, and evaluative commentary. [Principle] 3. The response uses clear and coherent organization,...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response directly explains how the development of concrete as a building material contributed to architectural innovation in ancient Rome. [Hard Rule] 2. The response demonstrates logical causal reasoning by explicitly linking the characteristics of a building material to its architectural impacts. [Principle]...
0.285714
0.195122
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response directly explains how the development of concrete as a building material contributed to architectural innovation in ancient Rome. [Hard Rule] 2. The response demonstrates logical causal reasoning by explicitly linking the characteristics of a building material to its architectural impacts. [Principle]...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must be an original children’s story. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must center on the specified character, Sam the Rabbit. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must incorporate the given theme of fear. [Hard Rule] 4. The response should use language and vocabulary appropriate for children. [Principle] 5. ...
0.666667
0.666667
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must be an original children’s story. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must center on the specified character, Sam the Rabbit. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must incorporate the given theme of fear. [Hard Rule] 4. The response should use language and vocabulary appropriate for children. [Principle] 5. ...
1
1
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response proposes actionable strategies specifically aimed at adjusting the curriculum for students who learn at a slower pace. [Hard Rule] 2. The response organizes its recommendations under clear, logical categories or headings to enhance readability. [Principle] 3. The response offers a diverse set of ped...
0.888889
0.8
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response proposes actionable strategies specifically aimed at adjusting the curriculum for students who learn at a slower pace. [Hard Rule] 2. The response organizes its recommendations under clear, logical categories or headings to enhance readability. [Principle] 3. The response offers a diverse set of ped...
0.888889
0.888889
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response names at least one famous work of art. [Hard Rule] 2. The response directly answers the prompt by naming a specific work without adding unrelated content. [Principle] 3. The response uses clear and unambiguous language when identifying the work. [Principle] 4. The response provides factually accur...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response names at least one famous work of art. [Hard Rule] 2. The response directly answers the prompt by naming a specific work without adding unrelated content. [Principle] 3. The response uses clear and unambiguous language when identifying the work. [Principle] 4. The response provides factually accur...
0.6
0.647059
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must describe the requirements for conducting historical research. [Hard Rule] 2. The response is well-organized and logically structured to guide the reader through definitions, methods, and considerations. [Principle] 3. The response clearly defines key concepts and skills necessary for the task u...
0.142857
0.192308
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must describe the requirements for conducting historical research. [Hard Rule] 2. The response is well-organized and logically structured to guide the reader through definitions, methods, and considerations. [Principle] 3. The response clearly defines key concepts and skills necessary for the task u...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must be in Hindi. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must include a complete and accurate translation of the provided phrase. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should use precise and contextually appropriate vocabulary in the target language. [Principle] 4. The response should preserve the original formatting ...
0.8
0.842105
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must be in Hindi. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must include a complete and accurate translation of the provided phrase. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should use precise and contextually appropriate vocabulary in the target language. [Principle] 4. The response should preserve the original formatting ...
0.4
0.454545
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response provides a clear explanation of the given phrase. [Hard Rule] 2. The response explains the relevance of the given phrase to the given context. [Hard Rule] 3. The response remains focused on the specified topic and context without introducing unrelated concepts. [Principle] 4. The response defines ...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response provides a clear explanation of the given phrase. [Hard Rule] 2. The response explains the relevance of the given phrase to the given context. [Hard Rule] 3. The response remains focused on the specified topic and context without introducing unrelated concepts. [Principle] 4. The response defines ...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must include a valid SQL query. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must reference the specified table name. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must filter specifically for headache, fever, and loss of appetite. [Hard Rule] 4. The response must select the disease name and the symptom columns in the output. [Hard...
0.2
0.266667
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must include a valid SQL query. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must reference the specified table name. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must filter specifically for headache, fever, and loss of appetite. [Hard Rule] 4. The response must select the disease name and the symptom columns in the output. [Hard...
0.7
0.647059
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response addresses how organized crime is considered an offense of elegance according to the provided text material. [Hard Rule] 2. The response includes an explanation and description of organized crime. [Hard Rule] 3. The response includes comparisons and characteristics of criminal behavior. [Hard Rule] ...
0.7
0.641026
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response addresses how organized crime is considered an offense of elegance according to the provided text material. [Hard Rule] 2. The response includes an explanation and description of organized crime. [Hard Rule] 3. The response includes comparisons and characteristics of criminal behavior. [Hard Rule] ...
0.3
0.178082
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response provides an example of the idiom in an Excel spreadsheet format. [Hard Rule] 2. The response explains the origin of the idiom. [Hard Rule] 3. The response explains the usage of the idiom in SQL database management. [Hard Rule] 4. The response uses the specified format faithfully, replicating the s...
0.142857
0.185185
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response provides an example of the idiom in an Excel spreadsheet format. [Hard Rule] 2. The response explains the origin of the idiom. [Hard Rule] 3. The response explains the usage of the idiom in SQL database management. [Hard Rule] 4. The response uses the specified format faithfully, replicating the s...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must explicitly name the type of figure of speech being exemplified by the given phrase. [Hard Rule] 2. The response should accurately classify the phrase according to standard definitions of figures of speech. [Principle] 3. The response should use precise and appropriate terminology when naming th...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must explicitly name the type of figure of speech being exemplified by the given phrase. [Hard Rule] 2. The response should accurately classify the phrase according to standard definitions of figures of speech. [Principle] 3. The response should use precise and appropriate terminology when naming th...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response proposes a novel product design for a child's toy. [Hard Rule] 2. The response specifies the product as a robot dinosaur. [Hard Rule] 3. The response clearly identifies and tailors the design to a specific target user group. [Principle] 4. The response details physical attributes (size, form, and ...
0.7
0.725
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response proposes a novel product design for a child's toy. [Hard Rule] 2. The response specifies the product as a robot dinosaur. [Hard Rule] 3. The response clearly identifies and tailors the design to a specific target user group. [Principle] 4. The response details physical attributes (size, form, and ...
0.7
0.75
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must focus exclusively on the specified subject of the query. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must describe how the specified subject has adapted to changing expectations and attitudes as outlined in the query. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must explain the impact of those adaptations on the subject’s rol...
1
1
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must focus exclusively on the specified subject of the query. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must describe how the specified subject has adapted to changing expectations and attitudes as outlined in the query. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must explain the impact of those adaptations on the subject’s rol...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response presents a summary of President Obama’s 2013 State of the Union Address. [Hard Rule] 2. The response accurately conveys the original content without introducing errors or fabrications. [Principle] 3. The response focuses on the key themes and priorities from the speech. [Principle] 4. The response...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response presents a summary of President Obama’s 2013 State of the Union Address. [Hard Rule] 2. The response accurately conveys the original content without introducing errors or fabrications. [Principle] 3. The response focuses on the key themes and priorities from the speech. [Principle] 4. The response...
0.125
0.178571
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must determine non-negative integer counts of quarters, dimes, and nickels whose combined value equals $44. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must use only the coin denominations specified in the request. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must correctly convert and represent units when necessary (e.g., dollars ...
0.111111
0.107692
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must determine non-negative integer counts of quarters, dimes, and nickels whose combined value equals $44. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must use only the coin denominations specified in the request. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must correctly convert and represent units when necessary (e.g., dollars ...
0.444444
0.432836
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response is written as a narrative describing an employee working on developing a new product line. [Hard Rule] 2. The response includes details of the employee’s development process, brainstorming techniques, and any challenges or successes encountered. [Hard Rule] 3. The response paints a vivid picture of ...
0.454545
0.425287
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response is written as a narrative describing an employee working on developing a new product line. [Hard Rule] 2. The response includes details of the employee’s development process, brainstorming techniques, and any challenges or successes encountered. [Hard Rule] 3. The response paints a vivid picture of ...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present a list of input instructions. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must assign each input instruction a corresponding instruction type classification. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must use a clear, enumerated list format to separate each item. [Hard Rule] 4. The response includes both input ite...
0.285714
0.4
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present a list of input instructions. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must assign each input instruction a corresponding instruction type classification. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must use a clear, enumerated list format to separate each item. [Hard Rule] 4. The response includes both input ite...
1
1