source
stringclasses
18 values
messages
listlengths
2
2
rubric
stringlengths
89
2.21k
score
float64
0
1
weighted_score
float64
0
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response names at least one valid feature of a hammer. [Hard Rule] 2. The response describes the named feature accurately according to common understanding. [Principle] 3. The response uses clear and precise language to identify the feature. [Principle] 4. The response remains focused on the requested feat...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response names at least one valid feature of a hammer. [Hard Rule] 2. The response describes the named feature accurately according to common understanding. [Principle] 3. The response uses clear and precise language to identify the feature. [Principle] 4. The response remains focused on the requested feat...
0.5
0.535714
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present an outline (i.e., a list) of characteristics specifically pertaining to a successful team leader. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must exclusively focus on a team leader’s qualities, without addressing unrelated roles or subjects. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should align its content strictl...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present an outline (i.e., a list) of characteristics specifically pertaining to a successful team leader. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must exclusively focus on a team leader’s qualities, without addressing unrelated roles or subjects. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should align its content strictl...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response revises the provided sentence to include figurative language. [Hard Rule] 2. The response maintains grammatical correctness and clarity, ensuring that the figurative language enhances rather than obscures the intended meaning. [Principle] 3. The response preserves the core meaning of the original se...
0.166667
0.179487
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response revises the provided sentence to include figurative language. [Hard Rule] 2. The response maintains grammatical correctness and clarity, ensuring that the figurative language enhances rather than obscures the intended meaning. [Principle] 3. The response preserves the core meaning of the original se...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must separate advantages and disadvantages in an outline format, presenting them under distinct headings or sections. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must focus specifically on technology-driven healthcare, addressing its benefits and drawbacks. [Hard Rule] 3. The response presents information in clear,...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must separate advantages and disadvantages in an outline format, presenting them under distinct headings or sections. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must focus specifically on technology-driven healthcare, addressing its benefits and drawbacks. [Hard Rule] 3. The response presents information in clear,...
0.666667
0.636364
ultrafeedback_evol_instruct
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must provide a correct antonym for the word “grateful.” [Hard Rule] 2. The response should correctly fulfill the requested task by accurately identifying the antonym. [Principle] 3. The response should be concise, clear, and focused on presenting the requested information without extraneous content....
0.333333
0.217391
ultrafeedback_evol_instruct
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must provide a correct antonym for the word “grateful.” [Hard Rule] 2. The response should correctly fulfill the requested task by accurately identifying the antonym. [Principle] 3. The response should be concise, clear, and focused on presenting the requested information without extraneous content....
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must directly address the impact of technology on how people learn. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must remain focused on learning and avoid discussing unrelated topics. [Hard Rule] 3. The response organizes content into clear, distinct sections or categories with descriptive labels. [Principle] 4. T...
0.142857
0.132075
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must directly address the impact of technology on how people learn. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must remain focused on learning and avoid discussing unrelated topics. [Hard Rule] 3. The response organizes content into clear, distinct sections or categories with descriptive labels. [Principle] 4. T...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present exactly three distinct words. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must include a clear definition for each presented word. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must use valid LaTeX syntax to format both the words and their definitions. [Hard Rule] 4. The response should organize the entries in a coher...
0.571429
0.6
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present exactly three distinct words. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must include a clear definition for each presented word. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must use valid LaTeX syntax to format both the words and their definitions. [Hard Rule] 4. The response should organize the entries in a coher...
0.142857
0.208333
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response explicitly chooses one of the provided options “yes,” “no,” or “it is not possible to tell.” [Hard Rule] 2. The response bases its conclusion solely on the information presented in the premise and hypothesis, avoiding any external assumptions or world knowledge. [Principle] 3. The response presents ...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response explicitly chooses one of the provided options “yes,” “no,” or “it is not possible to tell.” [Hard Rule] 2. The response bases its conclusion solely on the information presented in the premise and hypothesis, avoiding any external assumptions or world knowledge. [Principle] 3. The response presents ...
0.2
0.25
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present a meme concept that pairs a clear, descriptive image with an accompanying caption. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must center the meme’s content on a food-related theme. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should maintain a direct and coherent relationship between the visual description and the ca...
0.8
0.815789
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present a meme concept that pairs a clear, descriptive image with an accompanying caption. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must center the meme’s content on a food-related theme. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should maintain a direct and coherent relationship between the visual description and the ca...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must focus on the figure specified in the request. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must directly address whether the figure was recognized during their time or gained prominence later, clearly indicating which. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should state its main conclusion in a clear and direct manner bef...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must focus on the figure specified in the request. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must directly address whether the figure was recognized during their time or gained prominence later, clearly indicating which. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should state its main conclusion in a clear and direct manner bef...
1
1
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response focuses on explaining tools appropriate for carving softwood sculptures. [Hard Rule] 2. The response maintains relevance by aligning content with the user’s specified domain. [Principle] 3. The response comprehensively covers the essential categories of tools needed to accomplish the task. [Principl...
1
1
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response focuses on explaining tools appropriate for carving softwood sculptures. [Hard Rule] 2. The response maintains relevance by aligning content with the user’s specified domain. [Principle] 3. The response comprehensively covers the essential categories of tools needed to accomplish the task. [Principl...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must outline a construction scheme for building the detailed model of the Deluxe Fire Station using LEGO bricks. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must define each individual component of the model and ensure its accurate representation in the design. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must incorporate a functio...
0.333333
0.333333
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must outline a construction scheme for building the detailed model of the Deluxe Fire Station using LEGO bricks. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must define each individual component of the model and ensure its accurate representation in the design. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must incorporate a functio...
0.555556
0.655738
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must analyze how the cultural context of a television show influences its interpretation by international audiences. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must explain the causal mechanisms or processes underlying this influence. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must remain strictly relevant to the specified conte...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must analyze how the cultural context of a television show influences its interpretation by international audiences. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must explain the causal mechanisms or processes underlying this influence. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must remain strictly relevant to the specified conte...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must define Southern comfort food. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must define Southern American cuisine. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must explicitly state whether Southern comfort food is distinct from Southern American cuisine. [Hard Rule] 4. The response must focus exclusively on comparing the spec...
0.6
0.476923
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must define Southern comfort food. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must define Southern American cuisine. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must explicitly state whether Southern comfort food is distinct from Southern American cuisine. [Hard Rule] 4. The response must focus exclusively on comparing the spec...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response provides a revised version of the original sentence that directly addresses the request for greater clarity. [Hard Rule] 2. The response uses concise phrasing to eliminate redundancy and minimize unnecessary words. [Principle] 3. The response selects precise and varied vocabulary to convey meaning m...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response provides a revised version of the original sentence that directly addresses the request for greater clarity. [Hard Rule] 2. The response uses concise phrasing to eliminate redundancy and minimize unnecessary words. [Principle] 3. The response selects precise and varied vocabulary to convey meaning m...
0.166667
0.128205
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must be composed as a single, integrated paragraph that aligns with the specified format. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must seamlessly continue the existing narrative, matching its tone, style, and level of formality. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must focus on evidence-based practices within integrati...
0.857143
0.821429
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must be composed as a single, integrated paragraph that aligns with the specified format. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must seamlessly continue the existing narrative, matching its tone, style, and level of formality. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must focus on evidence-based practices within integrati...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must explain how technological advancements in renewable energy have impacted the energy industry. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must focus on developments and effects within the 21st century. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should systematically consider multiple dimensions of impact rather than a single...
0.875
0.912281
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must explain how technological advancements in renewable energy have impacted the energy industry. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must focus on developments and effects within the 21st century. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should systematically consider multiple dimensions of impact rather than a single...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must explain how to calculate the productivity of a research study using the term “prolific” as a measure where higher values indicate greater productivity. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must include example MATLAB code that directly uses the provided ‘prolific’ and ‘total_words’ data arrays. [Hard Rule...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must explain how to calculate the productivity of a research study using the term “prolific” as a measure where higher values indicate greater productivity. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must include example MATLAB code that directly uses the provided ‘prolific’ and ‘total_words’ data arrays. [Hard Rule...
0.444444
0.547945
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must provide an outline of steps specifically addressing conflict resolution. [Hard Rule] 2. The response presents the steps in a clear, organized outline format, facilitating easy navigation and comprehension. [Principle] 3. The response labels each step with an action-oriented phrase that clearly ...
0.875
0.881356
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must provide an outline of steps specifically addressing conflict resolution. [Hard Rule] 2. The response presents the steps in a clear, organized outline format, facilitating easy navigation and comprehension. [Principle] 3. The response labels each step with an action-oriented phrase that clearly ...
0.75
0.759259
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must propose exactly five discrete topics. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must present topics that are appropriately scoped for a 30-minute presentation. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must list only the topic titles without additional commentary or explanations. [Hard Rule] 4. The response should prese...
0.75
0.734694
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must propose exactly five discrete topics. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must present topics that are appropriately scoped for a 30-minute presentation. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must list only the topic titles without additional commentary or explanations. [Hard Rule] 4. The response should prese...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response defines the target concept clearly and comprehensively. [Hard Rule] 2. The response describes the concept’s impact on the specified industry domain. [Hard Rule] 3. The response includes concrete examples of innovations within the concept. [Hard Rule] 4. The response links each example to its speci...
0.909091
0.9375
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response defines the target concept clearly and comprehensively. [Hard Rule] 2. The response describes the concept’s impact on the specified industry domain. [Hard Rule] 3. The response includes concrete examples of innovations within the concept. [Hard Rule] 4. The response links each example to its speci...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response identifies the common characteristics of a healthy diet. [Hard Rule] 2. The response organizes information into clearly defined elements or categories. [Principle] 3. The response provides concrete and specific descriptors rather than vague generalities. [Principle] 4. The response addresses both ...
0.375
0.444444
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response identifies the common characteristics of a healthy diet. [Hard Rule] 2. The response organizes information into clearly defined elements or categories. [Principle] 3. The response provides concrete and specific descriptors rather than vague generalities. [Principle] 4. The response addresses both ...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must explicitly identify the described learning paradigm as supervised learning. [Hard Rule] 2. The response accurately maps the given scenario to the correct type of learning. [Principle] 3. The response uses clear and precise terminology to avoid ambiguity. [Principle] 4. The response is concise...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must explicitly identify the described learning paradigm as supervised learning. [Hard Rule] 2. The response accurately maps the given scenario to the correct type of learning. [Principle] 3. The response uses clear and precise terminology to avoid ambiguity. [Principle] 4. The response is concise...
0.25
0.192308
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present the correct decimal representation of the scientific notation provided in the request. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must accurately perform the calculation or transformation requested. [Principle] 3. The response must directly address the specific input given without introducing unrelate...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present the correct decimal representation of the scientific notation provided in the request. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must accurately perform the calculation or transformation requested. [Principle] 3. The response must directly address the specific input given without introducing unrelate...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must consist solely of an English translation of the provided text, with no additional commentary or extraneous content. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must faithfully convey the meaning of the original text. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should present a complete and self-contained sentence without elli...
0.714286
0.666667
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must consist solely of an English translation of the provided text, with no additional commentary or extraneous content. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must faithfully convey the meaning of the original text. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should present a complete and self-contained sentence without elli...
0.428571
0.444444
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must describe qualities that make a good leader. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must be concise, limited to a few words. [Hard Rule] 3. The response organizes information clearly to facilitate quick comprehension. [Principle] 4. The response prioritizes essential points and omits extraneous details. ...
0.428571
0.442308
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must describe qualities that make a good leader. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must be concise, limited to a few words. [Hard Rule] 3. The response organizes information clearly to facilitate quick comprehension. [Principle] 4. The response prioritizes essential points and omits extraneous details. ...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response explains how gaming publications have adapted their content specifically for mobile gaming enthusiasts. [Hard Rule] 2. The response remains strictly on topic, avoiding unrelated or tangential information. [Principle] 3. The response covers a comprehensive range of distinct adaptation strategies and ...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response explains how gaming publications have adapted their content specifically for mobile gaming enthusiasts. [Hard Rule] 2. The response remains strictly on topic, avoiding unrelated or tangential information. [Principle] 3. The response covers a comprehensive range of distinct adaptation strategies and ...
0
0
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must explain how differing levels of discipline and training within various garrisons affect cultural exchange among soldiers. [Hard Rule] 2. The response should examine multiple relevant dimensions of cultural exchange, demonstrating both depth and breadth in the analysis. [Principle] 3. The respon...
1
1
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must explain how differing levels of discipline and training within various garrisons affect cultural exchange among soldiers. [Hard Rule] 2. The response should examine multiple relevant dimensions of cultural exchange, demonstrating both depth and breadth in the analysis. [Principle] 3. The respon...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must identify and list the conventional parts of a book. [Hard Rule] 2. The response comprehensively covers the topic by enumerating both central and peripheral components. [Principle] 3. The response maintains focus and conciseness, avoiding unnecessary elaboration beyond what the request requires....
0.8
0.805556
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must identify and list the conventional parts of a book. [Hard Rule] 2. The response comprehensively covers the topic by enumerating both central and peripheral components. [Principle] 3. The response maintains focus and conciseness, avoiding unnecessary elaboration beyond what the request requires....
0.4
0.473684
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must describe the African National Congress’s views regarding the Homestead policy. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must maintain strict relevance to the specific policy or topic requested without introducing unrelated content. [Principle] 3. The response must accurately represent the position and persp...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must describe the African National Congress’s views regarding the Homestead policy. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must maintain strict relevance to the specific policy or topic requested without introducing unrelated content. [Principle] 3. The response must accurately represent the position and persp...
0
0
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must answer the question by explaining how offering a variety of products increases sales for a website owner. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must reference or utilize the information presented in the given text. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should maintain focus on the core topic and avoid introducing ...
0.857143
0.818182
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must answer the question by explaining how offering a variety of products increases sales for a website owner. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must reference or utilize the information presented in the given text. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should maintain focus on the core topic and avoid introducing ...
0.142857
0.098039
ultrafeedback_evol_instruct
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response proposes exactly one actionable step. [Hard Rule] 2. The response focuses on a measure that is implemented before the food enters the store. [Hard Rule] 3. The response directly addresses reduction of ecological footprint. [Hard Rule] 4. The response articulates recommendations in clear, specific,...
1
1
ultrafeedback_evol_instruct
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response proposes exactly one actionable step. [Hard Rule] 2. The response focuses on a measure that is implemented before the food enters the store. [Hard Rule] 3. The response directly addresses reduction of ecological footprint. [Hard Rule] 4. The response articulates recommendations in clear, specific,...
0.571429
0.537037
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must discuss the historical origins and development of various forms of dance and movement. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must explain the cultural significance and social functions of various forms of dance and movement. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must cover multiple distinct forms of dance and move...
0
0
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must discuss the historical origins and development of various forms of dance and movement. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must explain the cultural significance and social functions of various forms of dance and movement. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must cover multiple distinct forms of dance and move...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response provides specific strategies to ensure data security. [Hard Rule] 2. The response organizes the guidance into a clear, logical structure. [Principle] 3. The response uses accurate, up-to-date information aligned with established best practices. [Principle] 4. The response employs precise and unamb...
0.625
0.541667
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response provides specific strategies to ensure data security. [Hard Rule] 2. The response organizes the guidance into a clear, logical structure. [Principle] 3. The response uses accurate, up-to-date information aligned with established best practices. [Principle] 4. The response employs precise and unamb...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must be presented as a poem. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must include the words “sadness,” “explore,” “sacred,” and “whisper” exactly. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should use line breaks and other poetic structures to establish rhythm and flow. [Principle] 4. The response should integrate the requi...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must be presented as a poem. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must include the words “sadness,” “explore,” “sacred,” and “whisper” exactly. [Hard Rule] 3. The response should use line breaks and other poetic structures to establish rhythm and flow. [Principle] 4. The response should integrate the requi...
0.166667
0.25
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present a clear and direct definition of the specified term. [Hard Rule] 2. The response uses precise and accessible language suitable for a broad audience. [Principle] 3. The response focuses on the core attributes of the concept without introducing unrelated topics. [Principle] 4. The respo...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present a clear and direct definition of the specified term. [Hard Rule] 2. The response uses precise and accessible language suitable for a broad audience. [Principle] 3. The response focuses on the core attributes of the concept without introducing unrelated topics. [Principle] 4. The respo...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must describe a sunset. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must employ at least one metaphor to convey the sunset. [Hard Rule] 3. The response presents a coherent and integrated metaphor throughout. [Principle] 4. The response evokes vivid sensory imagery to help the reader visualize the scene. [Principl...
0.333333
0.47619
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must describe a sunset. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must employ at least one metaphor to convey the sunset. [Hard Rule] 3. The response presents a coherent and integrated metaphor throughout. [Principle] 4. The response evokes vivid sensory imagery to help the reader visualize the scene. [Principl...
0.833333
0.928571
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must consist of exactly three lines. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must adhere to the 5-7-5 syllabic structure across its three lines. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must thematically center on stars. [Hard Rule] 4. The response employs vivid sensory imagery that evokes the characteristics of the theme...
0.875
0.920635
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must consist of exactly three lines. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must adhere to the 5-7-5 syllabic structure across its three lines. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must thematically center on stars. [Hard Rule] 4. The response employs vivid sensory imagery that evokes the characteristics of the theme...
0.875
0.777778
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response explicitly states whether the two words are related. [Hard Rule] 2. The response includes a description of the relationship between the words when a relationship is asserted. [Hard Rule] 3. The response provides explanations that are broadly applicable rather than tied to a specific domain. [Princip...
0.6
0.714286
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response explicitly states whether the two words are related. [Hard Rule] 2. The response includes a description of the relationship between the words when a relationship is asserted. [Hard Rule] 3. The response provides explanations that are broadly applicable rather than tied to a specific domain. [Princip...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must consist of exactly one sentence. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must present a summary of the specified song. [Hard Rule] 3. The response highlights the song’s central theme or message. [Principle] 4. The response employs concise and focused language, avoiding unnecessary specifics. [Principle] ...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must consist of exactly one sentence. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must present a summary of the specified song. [Hard Rule] 3. The response highlights the song’s central theme or message. [Principle] 4. The response employs concise and focused language, avoiding unnecessary specifics. [Principle] ...
0.857143
0.893617
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response lists exactly five distinct items. [Hard Rule] 2. The response includes only items that are plausible and appropriate for a day-long hike. [Hard Rule] 3. The response is presented in a clear list format. [Hard Rule] 4. The response uses concise and clear descriptions without unnecessary elaboratio...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response lists exactly five distinct items. [Hard Rule] 2. The response includes only items that are plausible and appropriate for a day-long hike. [Hard Rule] 3. The response is presented in a clear list format. [Hard Rule] 4. The response uses concise and clear descriptions without unnecessary elaboratio...
0.333333
0.416667
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must provide an explanation of the concept of Virtual Reality. [Hard Rule] 2. The response accurately defines the key concept using precise and comprehensive terminology. [Principle] 3. The response describes the core mechanisms and technologies that enable the concept. [Principle] 4. The response...
0.625
0.581818
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must provide an explanation of the concept of Virtual Reality. [Hard Rule] 2. The response accurately defines the key concept using precise and comprehensive terminology. [Principle] 3. The response describes the core mechanisms and technologies that enable the concept. [Principle] 4. The response...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must directly address the specific question posed using the provided passage. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must reference the relevant portion of the passage to support its answer. [Hard Rule] 3. The response explicitly cites the precise evidence from the passage that justifies the answer. [Principle...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must directly address the specific question posed using the provided passage. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must reference the relevant portion of the passage to support its answer. [Hard Rule] 3. The response explicitly cites the precise evidence from the passage that justifies the answer. [Principle...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response explicitly states the exchange rate for Euro to US Dollar. [Hard Rule] 2. The response provides a numeric value representing the amount of US Dollars per one Euro. [Hard Rule] 3. The response indicates that the rate is current. [Hard Rule] 4. The response uses standardized currency notation to max...
0.833333
0.851064
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response explicitly states the exchange rate for Euro to US Dollar. [Hard Rule] 2. The response provides a numeric value representing the amount of US Dollars per one Euro. [Hard Rule] 3. The response indicates that the rate is current. [Hard Rule] 4. The response uses standardized currency notation to max...
0.666667
0.666667
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present a clear and actionable plan for getting in shape. [Hard Rule] 2. The response should remain focused on the user's stated goal throughout, avoiding irrelevant content. [Principle] 3. The response should organize suggestions into a logical, step-by-step sequence. [Principle] 4. The resp...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present a clear and actionable plan for getting in shape. [Hard Rule] 2. The response should remain focused on the user's stated goal throughout, avoiding irrelevant content. [Principle] 3. The response should organize suggestions into a logical, step-by-step sequence. [Principle] 4. The resp...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must select exactly one of the provided option labels (“yes”, “no”, or “it is not possible to tell”). [Hard Rule] 2. The response must present a step-by-step reasoning process before stating the conclusion. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must include a clear final answer formatted as “The answer is <op...
0.375
0.328125
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must select exactly one of the provided option labels (“yes”, “no”, or “it is not possible to tell”). [Hard Rule] 2. The response must present a step-by-step reasoning process before stating the conclusion. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must include a clear final answer formatted as “The answer is <op...
0.875
0.846154
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must provide the equivalent amount in Indian Rupees for the specified US Dollar value. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must present the conversion result explicitly and unambiguously in a concise manner. [Principle] 3. The response must use accurate and current exchange rate information or clearly state...
0
0
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must provide the equivalent amount in Indian Rupees for the specified US Dollar value. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must present the conversion result explicitly and unambiguously in a concise manner. [Principle] 3. The response must use accurate and current exchange rate information or clearly state...
0.75
0.740741
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present actionable recommendations for maintaining ethical standards while reducing costs through downsizing and layoffs. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must integrate both ethical considerations and cost-reduction measures specific to downsizing and layoffs. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must empha...
0.2
0.2
ultrafeedback_ultrachat
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present actionable recommendations for maintaining ethical standards while reducing costs through downsizing and layoffs. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must integrate both ethical considerations and cost-reduction measures specific to downsizing and layoffs. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must empha...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present exactly four distinct search query examples. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must provide the examples as Scala code. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must use precise and idiomatic code syntax appropriate to Scala and the query language. [Principle] 4. The response must be concise and directl...
0.833333
0.813953
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response must present exactly four distinct search query examples. [Hard Rule] 2. The response must provide the examples as Scala code. [Hard Rule] 3. The response must use precise and idiomatic code syntax appropriate to Scala and the query language. [Principle] 4. The response must be concise and directl...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response focuses on identifying and describing major free speech controversies on college campuses today. [Hard Rule] 2. The response maintains direct relevance to the specific issue of free speech controversies on college campuses, avoiding tangential or overly broad topics. [Principle] 3. The response iden...
1
1
skywork_ob
[ { "content": "You are an impartial expert evaluator.\n\nYour task is to evaluate an assistant response using a given rubric.\n\n# Inputs\nYou will receive:\n- A user request\n- A single assistant response\n- A rubric containing evaluation criteria\n\n# Instructions\nFor EACH rubric criterion:\n1. Determine whet...
1. The response focuses on identifying and describing major free speech controversies on college campuses today. [Hard Rule] 2. The response maintains direct relevance to the specific issue of free speech controversies on college campuses, avoiding tangential or overly broad topics. [Principle] 3. The response iden...
0.142857
0.104167